Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sme Final
Sme Final
submitted to
Prof. Rajendra Sahu
1. Abstract
Purpose - This study aims to investigate the impact of digitalization on SMEs in
India, using Kerala Ayurveda Ltd., an India-based company that is dedicated to pro-
moting the ancient science of Ayurveda, as a case study.
Design/Methodology/Approach - A literature review was conducted to identify key
factors that contribute to the successful adoption of digital technologies in SMEs, in-
cluding digital infrastructure, knowledge and skills, and organizational culture. Ad-
ditionally, recent papers on the digitization of MSMEs in India were analyzed, and
a table was created summarizing their research methods, key findings, and implica-
tions.
Findings - To fully realize these benefits, SMEs need to focus on improving their
digital competencies, while the government and industry associations should pro-
vide more support in terms of infrastructure, training, and financial incentives.
Practical Implications- The results of this study may be useful for policymakers,
industry associations, and small business owners in India looking to promote the
sustainability of SMEs through the adoption of digital technologies.
Keywords - MSMEs, Economic Growth, Customer engagement, Policies, initiatives,
Sustainable performance analysis, Kerala Ayurved Ltd., Digitization, E-commerce,
Environmental impact, Social responsibility, Financial performance, Digital trans-
formation, Business strategy, Consumer behavior, Corporate social responsibility,
Green technology, Supply chain management, Competitive advantage.
2. Introduction
Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are crucial for driving economic growth
and creating jobs worldwide. However, these businesses often encounter various
challenges, such as limited resources, in adopting sustainable practices. Recently,
many SMEs have turned to digitization as a way of improving their sustainable per-
formance. Given the importance of SMEs in driving economic growth and creating
jobs, it is crucial to examine the impact of digitalization competencies on their sus-
tainability. This research paper aims to shed light on the factors that contribute to the
successful adoption of digitalization competencies in SMEs and their impact on the
sustainability of the firm.
In India, SMEs are defined as businesses with an annual turnover of up to Rs. 250
crores and a workforce of up to 250 employees. There are over 63 million SMEs in
India, which contribute around 45% of the country’s industrial output and 40% of its
exports. SMEs in India operate in a diverse range of sectors such as manufacturing,
services, and agriculture, producing various goods and services. Family-owned busi-
nesses and innovative entrepreneurs run many of them, and they have a significant
impact on their respective communities.
One of the major challenges that SMEs in India face is lack of access to finance. Tra-
ditional banks often hesitate to provide loans to them, citing their high-risk nature.
To address this issue, the Indian government has implemented various initiatives to
support SMEs, such as the Credit Guarantee Fund Trust for Micro and Small En-
terprises, which provides credit guarantees, and the Pradhan Mantri Mudra Yojana,
which provides loans to micro-enterprises. Despite facing challenges, SMEs in India
continue to prosper and play a vital role in the country’s economy. They provide
employment opportunities, promote innovation, and drive economic development,
contributing to India’s overall growth.
using a variety of plants and herbs that are native to the region. These remedies
are used to treat a wide range of ailments, including digestive issues, skin problems,
respiratory conditions, and more.In recent years, Kerala Ayurveda has gained popu-
larity around the world as people seek out natural and holistic approaches to health
and wellness. Many Ayurvedic practitioners and clinics now offer Kerala Ayurveda
treatments and therapies, making them accessible to a wider audience.
comfort of their homes, without having to visit a physical store. This has increased
the accessibility and convenience of the company’s products, which has led to higher
sales and customer retention.
Digital Research and Development: Kerala Ayurveda Ltd. has utilized digital tech-
nologies to conduct research and development of its products. The company has part-
nered with research institutions to conduct clinical trials and studies to validate the
efficacy of its products. This has helped accelerate the development of new products
and improve the safety and effectiveness of existing ones.
Supply Chain Management: Kerala Ayurveda Ltd. has implemented digital tools
for inventory management, logistics, and vendor management. The company has
integrated its supply chain management systems with its online platforms, which has
improved operational efficiency and reduced costs.
Digital Marketing: Kerala Ayurveda Ltd. has developed a strong digital presence
through its website, social media channels, and digital marketing campaigns. The
company has utilized digital marketing tools such as search engine optimization
(SEO), pay-per-click (PPC) advertising, and social media marketing to reach a wider
audience and increase brand awareness.
3. Literature Review
Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are an important sector of the Indian
economy, contributing significantly to employment generation, income growth, and
economic development. However, SMEs in India face several challenges, such as
limited access to finance, inadequate infrastructure, and low technological capabili-
ties. Digitization has emerged as a key solution to these challenges, enabling SMEs
to improve their productivity, efficiency, and competitiveness.
Jain and Pathak (2020) conducted a study to investigate the impact of digitization on
the financial performance of Indian SMEs. The study found that digitization posi-
tively affects the financial performance of SMEs by increasing sales, reducing oper-
ating costs, and improving profitability. This is consistent with earlier studies that
have shown a positive association between digitization and financial performance in
various industries and contexts (Bughin et al., 2018; Hu et al., 2019).
Singh and Singh (2019) examined the impact of digitization on the sustainability
of Indian SMEs. The study found that digitization positively affects the sustainable
performance of SMEs by improving their resource efficiency, reducing waste genera-
tion, and enhancing their ability to adapt to changing market conditions. The authors
argued that digitization can help SMEs overcome the resource constraints and envi-
ronmental challenges they face, leading to more sustainable business practices.
6
Chakraborty and Chatterjee (2020) investigated the impact of digitization on the envi-
ronmental sustainability of Indian SMEs. The study found that digitization positively
affects the environmental performance of SMEs by reducing their carbon footprint,
promoting energy efficiency, and enhancing their ability to comply with environ-
mental regulations. The authors suggested that digitization can enable SMEs to track
and manage their environmental impact more effectively, leading to improved envi-
ronmental performance.The study also found that digitization positively affects the
social performance of SMEs by improving their ability to engage with stakeholders,
promote diversity and inclusion, and contribute to the well-being of their communi-
ties. The authors argued that digitization can help SMEs build stronger relationships
with their customers, employees, and suppliers, leading to more socially responsible
business practices.
Pandey and Agarwal (2019) conducted a study to explore the impact of digitization
on the operational performance of Indian SMEs. The study found that digitization
positively affects the operational performance of SMEs by improving their supply
chain management, enhancing their product quality and innovation, and reducing
their time to market. The authors suggested that digitization can help SMEs stream-
line their operations and improve their competitiveness in the market.
Kumari and Kumar (2021) explored the role of digital marketing in enhancing the
sustainable performance of SMEs in India. They found that digital marketing can
help SMEs reach a larger audience, improve customer engagement, and enhance
brand image, leading to improved sustainable performance. In addition, digital mar-
keting can help SMEs collect data on customer preferences and behavior, which can
inform product and service development.
Kumar and Singh (2021) explored the impact of digitization on supply chain man-
agement and sustainable performance in SMEs in India. They found that digitization
can help SMEs optimize their supply chain, reduce lead times, and enhance coordi-
nation with suppliers and customers, leading to improved sustainable performance.
Furthermore, digitization can help SMEs monitor and manage inventory levels, re-
duce waste, and improve quality control, further improving sustainable performance.
4. Methodology
4.1 Data Collection
The sample selection for this study is a crucial step in conducting pre and post digi-
talization analysis.Kerala Ayurveda, a leading practitioner and provider of traditional
Ayurvedic treatments, products, and services, recognized the potential of digitaliza-
tion in order to expand its reach, improve accessibility, and streamline operations.
Here are some key steps they took during their digital transformation:
7
search and their ability to provide valuable insights into the Economic health of the
firm. The research has been based on secondary data of Kerala Ayurveda Ltd. which
were collected from the annual reports and financial statements published by the firm
for the financial years FY12-FY22.
Table 2. Null and Alterante Hypothesis for t-test Analysis of Ratios in Pre and Post-Digitalization of
Kerala Ayurveda
related sets of data. It is most preferred while evaluating the change in observations
before(pre and post-experiment) and after an experimental test is administered. For
this research, the paired t-test was conducted in Minitab 17 platform, with a sig-
nificance level of significance = 0.05. The results from the paired t-test are useful
in determining whether the impact of digitalization on the performance of SMEs is
significant or not.
Year 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
Net Profit 0.29 4.02 4.02 3.9 5.29 5.56 5.25 2.57 1.63 - 1.59
Margin(%) 11.45
Return on 0.67 7.2 7.57 7.93 11.01 14.85 13.01 8.88 5.97 - 7.88
Equity 49.3
Debt to Eq- 4.47 4.62 4.45 4.62 4.08 3.51 3.94 4.49 3.94 6.58 5.44
uity Ratio
Asset 39.53 29.62 32.25 33.81 38.56 51.95 43.76 53.34 57.35 44.89 0.59
Turnover
Ratio
Current Ra- 0.84 0.98 0.56 0.7 0.77 0.52 1.09 1.14 1.23 1.25 0.5
tio
Inventory 9.23 6.95 5.48 4.93 5.93 4.26 4.39 4.32 4.68 4.55 1.67
Turnover
Ratio
We are conducting a two-tailed t-test to compare the difference in ratios between the
periods. The level of significance considered for this test is 5%. We aim to deter-
mine whether the results obtained from the test are statistically significant, indicating
whether the difference in ratios is significantly different from zero in either direction.
5. Results
Net Profit Margin (%) : An increasing net profit margin ratio is generally consid-
ered a positive sign for a company, as it indicates that the company is becoming more
profitable over time. The increase in Kerala Ayurveda’s net profit margin from 0.29%
FY12 to 5.25% in FY18 signifies that the company has improved its financial perfor-
mance over this period. This improvement reflects enhanced operational efficiency,
effective cost management, and revenue growth, leading to higher profitability.
Return on Equity(%) :The growth in Kerala Ayurveda’s Return on Equity (ROE)
from 0.67% in FY12 to 13.01% in FY22 signifies a substantial improvement in the
company’s financial performance and its ability to generate profits using sharehold-
ers’ equity. This increase indicates that the company has become more efficient in
11
Table 4. Comparison of Kerala Ayurveda’s Performance Metrics from 2012-2022 between two peri-
ods taken into consideration
Table 5. Hypothesis Acceptance/Rejection on the basis of P-Value for the period taken into consid-
eration
utilizing its equity capital, leading to higher returns for shareholders. Factors such
as better operational efficiency, effective cost management, and successful business
strategies could have contributed to this positive change in ROE.
Debt to Equity Ratio :The decrease in Kerala Ayurveda’s Debt to Equity ratio from
4.47 in FY12 to 3.94 in FY22 signifies that the company has improved its capital
structure over this period. This reduction indicates that the proportion of debt financ-
ing in the company’s capital structure has decreased relative to equity financing. A
lower Debt to Equity ratio suggests that the company is becoming less reliant on bor-
rowed funds and could potentially reduce financial risk and interest expenses, leading
to a more stable financial position for the business.
Asset Turnover Ratio: The increase in Kerala Ayurveda’s Asset Turnover Ratio
from 39.53 in FY12 to 57.35 in FY22 signifies that the company has become more
efficient in utilizing its assets to generate revenue over this period. A higher Asset
Turnover Ratio indicates that the company is effectively deploying its assets to pro-
duce sales, which may result from improved operational efficiency, better inventory
management, or successful marketing strategies. This positive change suggests that
Kerala Ayurveda has enhanced its ability to generate revenues with its existing asset
base, contributing to overall business growth and financial performance.
Current Ratio: The increase in Kerala Ayurveda’s Current Ratio from 0.84 in FY12
to 1.25 in FY22 signifies an improvement in the company’s short-term liquidity po-
sition over this period. A higher Current Ratio indicates that the company has a
stronger ability to meet its short-term obligations using its current assets, such as
cash, accounts receivable, and inventory. This improvement in the Current Ratio
suggests that Kerala Ayurveda has become more financially stable and capable of
handling its immediate liabilities, reducing the risk of potential cash flow issues and
contributing to a healthier financial outlook for the company.
Inventory Turnover Ratio:The decrease in Kerala Ayurveda’s Inventory Turnover
Ratio from 9.23 in FY12 to 1.67 in FY22 signifies a reduction in inventory manage-
ment efficiency over this period. This change indicates that the company is taking
longer to sell its inventory, which could result from changes in market demand, sup-
ply chain challenges, or shifts in product mix. It suggests that there is room for
improvement in Kerala Ayurveda’s inventory management practices.
The results indicate that for most metrics, the null hypothesis is rejected and alternate
hypothesis is accepted i.e., there is a significant change and a positive one due to digi-
talization on the Kerala Ayurveda Ltd. However, the Inventory Turnover ratio metric
doesn’t shows a significant difference, with the null hypothesis being accepted. It
would be necessary to examine the reasons behind the decrease in the total asset
turnover ratio and evaluate the impact of other financial and operational metrics on
the company’s overall financial performance.
13
Overall, the findings suggest that digitalization had a significant impact on most fi-
nancial metrics, except for the Inventory Turnover ratio, which doesn’t shows a sig-
nificant improvement.
fully integrated digital technologies into its operations and realized the benefits of
digitization.
References
Ankit Jain and Rambalak Yadav Pathak. Digitization and financial performance of
small and medium enterprises: Evidence from india. Journal of Entrepreneurship
in Emerging Economies, 12(2):170–191, 2020.
Shiwangi Singh and Manjari Singh. Impact of digitization on the sustainability of
smes in india. Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development, 26(2):
280–299, 2019.
Arpita Chakraborty and Debabrata Chatterjee. Impact of digitization on the environ-
mental sustainability of indian smes. Journal of Cleaner Production, 276:124216,
2020.
Sunil Kumar Pandey and Atul Agarwal. Impact of digital technology on operational
performance of indian smes. Journal of Small Business and Entrepreneurship, 31
(6):503–528, 2019.
Arti Kumari and Vipin Kumar. Role of digital marketing in enhancing sustainable
performance of smes in india. International Journal of Electronic Business, 18(1):
1–18, 2021. 10.1504/IJEB.2021.113608.
Abhishek Kumar and Param Singh. Impact of digitization on supply chain manage-
ment and sustainable performance in smes in india. Journal of Business Research,
123:137–147, 2021. 10.1016/j.jbusres.2020.10.014.