Arts Therapies in Educational Settings An Intercultural Encounter

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 7

The Arts in Psychotherapy 28 (2001) 109 –115

Arts therapies in educational settings:


an intercultural encounter
Hilda Wengrower, M.A., DTRI*
Hebrew Univ. & Ministry of Education, P.O.B. 10491, 91104, Jerusalem, Israel

Introduction ship between the therapists and educators; and prac-


tically–focusing on the strategies and tactics involved
The effectiveness and necessity of therapy in a in a successful partnership of this kind.
school setting is no longer contested between school In this article I approach the issue by defining the
psychologists and counselors (Prout & Brown, 1999; aforementioned partnership as an intercultural en-
Kazdin & Johnson, 1994). A number of analyses of counter, with education and therapy seen as distinct
school-based psychotherapies have all concluded that cultures who share certain perspectives about human
the therapies are productive (Brantley, Brantley & beings and the world, but which differ from one
Baer-Barkley, 1996; Prout & DeMartino, 1986; Ka- another. The principles of these two cultures are
zdin & Johnson, 1994; Prout & Prout, 1998; Shecht- presented, and proposals are made for bridging the
man, 1993). Despite this, there is still very little gaps between them. I also bring forth studies sup-
written about the use of arts therapies in educational porting therapeutic work in schools and suggest strat-
settings, and there are those who remain skeptical egies and tactics useful to both educators and thera-
about its viability. Therapists who work in schools
pists.
occasionally feel that they are expected to intervene
as teachers of art, rather than therapists. They feel
that the unique nature of their professional identity
Culture
goes unrecognized. They are occasionally confronted
by teachers and school principals who balk at re-
Over the past three decades, the term “culture”
quests for “unusual” work arrangements, such as
has taken on a very broad meaning, going way be-
class observations and regroupings, that are not al-
yond classic anthropological definitions. Today, the
ways compatible with the class-organization. These
term refers to a system of meanings shared by a
teachers and principals do not view child observation
as part of the therapeutic workload. group of people by virtue of their affiliation and
My twenty years of working as a movement ther- identification with groups that are defined by ethnic
apist, clinical supervisor, and educational counselor association, age, sexual identity, sexual preference,
in educational institutions have led me to believe that and so forth (Kincheloe & Steinberg, 1997). These
both therapists and schools could only benefit from a affiliations and identifications constitute a culture in a
reconceptualization regarding the integration of one double sense, in that the aforementioned groups not
with the other. only produce an internal culture, they are constructed
This needs to be done on two levels: conceptual- within— or by—a culture as well. This perspective
ly–arriving at a general understanding of the partner- enables us to apply the term “culture” to a profession
itself, and not merely to the organizations in which
the professionals work, as has been the case in the
* E-mail address: mshilda@mscc.huji.ac.il (H. Wen- past (Frost, 1985). In their article, Lefley and Ped-
grower). ersen (1986) also concluded that particular jobs and

0197-4556/01/$ – see front matter © 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 1 9 7 - 4 5 5 6 ( 0 0 ) 0 0 0 9 1 - 5
110 H. Wengrower / The Arts in Psychotherapy 28 (2001) 109 –115

professions could be said to constitute their own societies or that of the culture of people living in
culture. the mountainous regions of South America.
Geertz (1973) defined culture as a structure of the
Technical information: Each unique culture pro-
meanings of life within a particular community,
vides modes of behavior and tools for problem
wherein people use these meanings to create their
solving.
identity, while also establishing their identity from
and within these particular meanings. Culture fosters Normative information: Culture creates and trans-
identity, common characteristics and language, and mits values, norms, aims, and restrictions.
enables the development of interaction. Using this
Prospective information: It consists of the view of
definition, a profession can be understood as a cul-
the future: the dreams, expectations, utopias, and
ture. Furthermore, if we look at the sociological dis-
ideals that people create grow out of culture, but
course on professions, the idea of culture is perceived
can also be used to expand it (see also Leledakis,
as a defining element. Payne’s “characteristics ap-
1995).
proach,” (Payne, 1996) for example, makes the claim
that a central component of a profession is its unique Presented below is a brief portrayal of the culture
culture, a feature of which is the claim to a specific of therapy, and the culture of school-based education,
and unique field of knowledge, and the claim of according to Ariño (1997). Although both these cul-
authority in that field. tures have shared elements, I would like to focus on
The establishment of a professional culture pro- the differences, as they are a cause of the difficulties
motes the type of communication found at interna- met in the intercultural encounter (see Table 1).
tional conferences. Here one can find people from
diverse geographic locations who are able to com- Arts therapies as culture
municate with each other using technical jargon, and
who share similar areas of interest, dilemmas, and In the culture of therapy, the person and the world
professional literature– be they mathematicians, phy- are rife with conflicts and internal contradictions.
sicians, or mental health practitioners. Importance is attached to introspection and anxieties.
In this article, the profession of arts therapies and Therapists see their role as accepting the child as he
that of school-based education are defined as differ- is, with all his distress and uniqueness, while at the
ent cultures. Much has been said and written about same time attempting to accompany him in his pro-
how the central formulizations of psychotherapy and cess of change. Occasionally, emphasis is placed on
arts therapies and their basic conceptualizations are the difficulties and on the deficiencies, rather than on
essentially the products of Western culture; more has the existing strengths and adaptive compensations
been written about their foundation upon a particular that the child is capable of creating for him.
outlook and its attendant norms (on this position According to this ontological view, the therapeu-
within arts therapies see Dokter, 1995; Lewis, 1997). tic task is accomplished by a bond and a process, the
According to the definitions provided by Geertz results of which can sometimes be measured better
(1973) and Ariño (1997), culture enables the estab- qualitatively rather than through quantitative indices.
lishment of an identity, an outlook, and strategic Each and every session is different, not only between
means and tactics for thought and action. Following patients but also during the course of the treatment of
these criteria, it can be posited that a profession is a single individual. Significance is attributed to pri-
thus a culture in and of itself. Abraham (1993) also vacy, respect for the process, and the patient’s per-
brings sources for the idea of a professional culture, sonal time, and as a result, the need to provide free-
which influences all the people who fulfill profes- dom of expression and a secluded location. Another
sional roles. She adds that the organizations in which aspect is that the planning is comprehensive and
such roles are performed, carefully maintain that cul- focuses on defining objectives and less on specific
ture. session designing. Even in short-term therapy, the
Ariño (1997) states that each particular culture patient and the process are allowed to lead them-
provides four different types of information, of a selves, although to a lesser degree. To better under-
comprehensive as well as pragmatic nature: stand what happened, much thought is invested in
reviewing the sessions, going over the interaction that
World outlook and descriptive information: It was generated, and the emotional involvement of
says how the world is, what there is and what both patient and therapist. In long-term treatment, the
there is not, it depicts human beings and reality. therapist appears to be passive, and is rarely, if ever,
For example, Zen Buddhist culture fosters a pic- the initiator, and intervenes only in the wake of the
ture of man and the world that is very different patient’s actions.
from that fostered by Western, postindustrialist In order to analyze the session and create a certain
H. Wengrower / The Arts in Psychotherapy 28 (2001) 109 –115 111

Table 1
Emphasis on general and relative differences-comparison and contrast

Emphasis in the therapy culture Emphasis in the education culture

The individual or the group The class or the school


Uniqueness, difference Common aspects of the age level, universalism
The child as a complex entity, with opposing motives, The pupil as a learning entity, who must respect norms
internal conflicts and be consistent (ego functions, reality principle)
The therapist accepts; the child expresses his inner world The teacher teaches, makes demands, gives exams;
the pupil is tested, competes for achievement
Deals with uncertainty Definitions and clear concepts
Therapist thinks after the session, processing Teacher works on course and lesson planning
Process, results are evaluated qualitatively Measurable results
Thinking, introspection Action, pragmatism
The interpersonal relationship between therapist-child is a The importance of the teacher-pupil relationship is in
“tool” used for the entire population of clients reverse proportion to the age of the pupils
(transference-countertransference)
Thinking about what was done and what took place at the Thinking about what was done and what took place on
unconscious level the conscious level

distance from the powerful emotions that the thera- the issue of whether the state schools actually imple-
pist also experiences during the encounter, he/she ment these values.
needs to take a break between clients in quiet and This concept, and not only the number of people
solitude. Clinical supervision is also an important served by the institution, directs the school towards
aspect of the therapist’s professional endeavor, being the universal and collective, and the demand that
used to examine the interpersonal and the technical each individual in the school community meet gen-
aspects of the therapy. eral, common standards. The ideal of the right to
The work of therapists in a school is made harder education for all as a criterion outweighs the concept
by the difficulty in maintaining the basic components of the individual and the different. Furthermore, the
of a clinical setting and climate, such as arranging state school is the institution used as the central tool
appointment times, discretion (with regard to both in forming a national identity among those societies
other pupils and the school faculty), and a special, who have placed this objective high on their list of
intimate atmosphere. All of these are affected by priorities, from that early period through today. The
changes imposed by the school calendar, which is full desire for a national identity has, up until the 1980s,
of special events shared by all members of this com- been responsible for the emphasis on unification and
munity, as well as holidays, trips, and so forth. Some- similarity between students.
times, because of their frequency, such events can The class serves as the basic (and, one could
damage the continuity of treatment. Random meet- almost say, the natural) unit of the school, to such an
ings in the corridor or schoolyard, between the ther- extent that it often becomes an important aspect of
apist and her young clients, can undermine the fan- the child’s identity; a child is often asked what grade
tasies of exclusivity that children often create and he’s in rather than how old he is. Even in a school
long for. where there is a clear declaration of concern for the
individual, the weight of the organizational structure
The culture of school-based education and this basic unit is most important. Therefore, arts
therapists are often asked to respect this structure
The school, as a public-governmental institution, when they are faced with the task of creating groups.
is motivated by principles which may differ and even This can have a detrimental effect on the child’s
conflict with those of therapy. One of the reasons for ability to move beyond the fixed role he fills within
this lies in the development of mass education at the the class and threaten his privacy and willingness to
end of the 18th and the beginning of the 19th centu- experiment with new roles and experiences.
ries (Stone, 1976). State-run schools were institutions Another characteristic of the culture of school-
resulting from a liberal ideology. The values of the based education, aside from the exceptions and some-
Revolution of 1789, which bore the standards of times despite them, is the sense that everyone is
equality and universality among people and disre- under constant evaluation. “Practitioners spend large
garded the differences between them, influenced the amounts of time designing lessons. . . setting up and
development of schools for all. We will not discuss enforcing classroom rules, preparing and administer-
112 H. Wengrower / The Arts in Psychotherapy 28 (2001) 109 –115

ing examinations, reporting absences. . . Students. . . land surveyor who has just arrived, informing him
spend inordinate amounts of time. . . taking tests. . . ” that he must not forget that he is there at their request.
(Zehm & Kottler, 1993, pp. 17–18). All these activ- They tell him he is an outsider and a stranger; that he
ities have the goal of measuring and comparing in- has no identity as far as they are concerned; that he is
dividuals or groups with the class/grade level, com- ignorant of their community and must beware.
pete with the standards of excellence in other schools, Another obstacle of the intercultural encounter is
and so forth. At the end of a session with the arts the lack of effort made to understand or communicate
therapist, the transition from one culture to the other with the stranger, and the way that differences be-
can be confusing for the child. tween him and the community involve the use of a
Sometimes the difficulty in carrying out therapy local language and excessive reference to names and
in the school framework stems from the essential events with which the outsider is unfamiliar. Grin-
difference between the objectives of the school and berg and Grinberg (1989, pp. 81– 86) claim that the
the therapy. The former involves inculcating subject characteristics attributed to the “intruder” (given that
matter, skills, and values, and achieving measurable there are those who experience him as such) reinforce
results. Considerations of economy and cost effec- feelings of jealousy and competition, and there is a
tiveness are an integral part of the thinking that chance that a cycle will be created wherein the new
guides the administrations in charge of the system’s person reacts with hostility, or by not initiating contact.
best interests. Therapy is viewed as “depart[ing] or Bion (1970) notes three possibilities concerning
detract[ing] from the primary educational mission” encounters between the established group and the
(Kazdin & Johnson, 1994, p. 240). newcomer/s:
The complexity, however, does not stop here. The
differences that arise are not only cultural or even A very forceful entrance by the newcomer will
organizational, but are also emotional, and not exacerbate feelings of danger to the group.
merely because of the intercultural component. We The group might stop developing because of its
shall deal with this aspect further on. suspicions.
All those involved will be flexible, thus enabling
The intercultural encounter interaction and allowing for a process of change
and mutual acceptance.
The school is the stronghold of the culture of
Based on the constructivist paradigm in social
education. The creative arts therapist, or any mental
sciences, it is feasible to see these possibilities as
health practitioner, who comes to work there, is like
a stranger entering a foreign land and constitutes a reciprocal interpretations or narratives with which the
minority. As in any case with an encounter between agents involved build their reality, rather than as
a minority and a majority stemming from different immutable facts. In other words, these are the inter-
cultures, difficulties arise. Psychoanalytical literature pretations by which anyone can construct his expe-
has dealt with this subject, as has social psychology. rience and understanding of the situation (Clarke,
For more than a decade now we have been witnessing 1997; Guba & Lincoln, 1994; Polkinghorne, 1991).
the great attention given to the encounter with the It is possible that while reading the above there
‘other’. are therapists who have already found here an echo of
Concerning the arrival of a newcomer to a com- their own experiences. Situations such as the admin-
munity, Grinberg and Grinberg (1989) analyzed Kaf- istrator not being able to find a suitable room to work
ka’s The Castle as a story symbolic of the suspicious in (“making room for her” in every sense of the
reception a community gives to a professional who word), or not finding an appropriate setting satisfac-
has been invited to come and work there. They base tory to both the school and the creative arts therapist,
their interpretation, among others, on Bion (1970), are fairly common. Sometimes it is not only the
who analyzed the dynamics that develop within a school, as the host group, which hides behind its own
group or an institution when faced with a new idea or specific language, but the therapist as well may, in
the representative of such an idea. The studies made reporting on her/his work, use technical jargon mean-
by Bion (1970), followed by Grinberg and Grinberg ingless to her/his listeners. It is possible that the
(1989), seem to be appropriate for the intercultural therapist is caught in her/his own terminology and
encounter in general, as well as the specific encounter unable to realize integration and change for her/him-
under discussion here. Bion (1970) notes that the self. Occasionally, therapists seem unable to recog-
presence of a stranger in a community or group can nize or appreciate the teachers’ efforts and work.
change its structure, thereby generating a subcon- There is no doubt that the need for change and flex-
scious feeling that the existing cultural identity is ibility is vital to both sides, and would benefit their
being threatened. In The Castle, the locals berate the mutual encounter.
H. Wengrower / The Arts in Psychotherapy 28 (2001) 109 –115 113

Other difficulties arise because of the ongoing wherein preventive interventions of various degrees
nature of relationships among members of the school can be carried out. In any event, there exists a belief
community. Occasionally there is covert/unconscious that there are a larger number of children and youth
jealousy and competition among different sections of who require therapy and are not receiving it, mainly
the staff. Classroom teachers and their pupils spend a because many of them are not even identified as such
long time working together and a close relationship is by their families or their school (Brown & Prout,
forged between them in which transference plays no 1989).
less a part than in the case of therapy. To leave this Let us briefly recall the terms used for different
term within the clinical setting, we can use the degrees of prevention as stated by Caplan (1964) and
slightly forgotten term coined by Sullivan (1954)– as they apply to education:
parataxic distortion. It refers to a broader application
Primary prevention–improving the psychological
of the transference phenomenon, wherein a person
powers and abilities of pupils who show no visi-
transfers the intensity of his feelings and the dynamic
ble signs of distress.
of a significant relationship from the past or from
other areas of his life. An example of parataxic dis- Secondary prevention–the identification and as-
tortion are the strong feelings that a classroom sessment of problems in order to reduce the like-
teacher can encourage/develop with regard to some lihood that these will inflict permanent damage.
of her pupils, almost as if they were her/his own
children. This renders it difficult for the teacher to Tertiary prevention–recognized therapeutic inter-
accept the possibility that another faculty member ventions with the population whose problems are
can establish a close relationship or achieve some explicit, with the objective of preventing escala-
sort of “success” with them. In these situations the tion of the situation while maintaining those func-
teacher-therapist relationship becomes deficient, and tions that are not damaged.
‘incidents’ resulting from unconscious conflicts Schools should undertake all three types of pre-
(parapraxis) result. Another reason for hostility stems vention, but they rely mainly on the last two. Often,
from the image the teacher may have of the thera- families of children who require tertiary prevention
pist’s work as privileged compared to the demands of are not cooperative for a variety of reasons, and as a
teaching an entire class. result do not take their children to treatment or men-
There are many ways in which these conflicts may tal health centers. In these cases, the education sys-
affect the common enterprise. For example: forget- tem becomes the only place where this need is met.
ting to provide important information regarding the Kazdin and Johnson (1994, p. 239) state that the
child being treated, not informing the therapist of advances in therapy “raise prospects and possibilities
sessions which need to be canceled because of a class directly relevant to interventions in the schools.”
event, and not taking into account the opinion of the They also consider that schools offer good opportu-
therapist when evaluating or making decisions about nities for observation, diagnosis, and intervention.
the child. This is not to say that therapists are immune Many aspects of a child’s development and adjust-
to such strong feelings, but training and clinical su- ment are apparent in the school setting: their interac-
pervision lessen the risk that such emotions will tion with their peers, academic functioning, and so-
block the channels of communication and coopera- cial behavior. Academic dysfunction has been found
tion. Let us remember the different emphasis on to correlate with subsequent psychiatric problems
thought and action within the two cultures. and vice versa.
Finally, during certain stages of the therapy, as In light of this, and to paraphrase Goldstein, Freud
part of the transference process, the child builds an and Solnit (1973), ‘in the best interests of the child’,
ideal image of the therapist, which increases the it would seem that both cultures must engage in some
chances of a split between good and bad ‘objects’ not kind of dialogue and achieve a mutually accepting
only with regard to parent-therapist, but teacher-ther- flexibility.
apist as well. Without working through this develop-
mental and transient phenomenon, tension and com-
petition between these adults could ensue or even Creative arts therapies as preventive
escalate. interventions in education

The need for an encounter between the culture of Creative arts therapies in educational settings can
education and the culture of therapy make the following contributions: Expression
through art is an activity that has social value and is
Despite all the difficulties cited, the school plays socially acceptable. Therefore, therapy based on such
an important role as the provider of a framework activity is less stigmatizing. It allows the integration
114 H. Wengrower / The Arts in Psychotherapy 28 (2001) 109 –115

of the child’s unimpaired aspects while he/she is the effectiveness of short-term verbal treatment
undergoing therapy. Thus, he/she may work on his among high school pupils that was conducted within
weaknesses and ways of coping with them, while at the school.
the same time uncovering his/her strengths. This has It would be beneficial to design working models
a positive effect on self-image. For example, a child that are adaptable to the educational culture, thereby
during a group session in movement therapy ex- emphasizing the artistic side of the therapy. While the
pressed the wish: “If only they would come from the surveys and meta-analysis conducted by Prout and
television to film us.” This was how he voiced the DeMartino (1986), Brown and Prout (1989), Prout,
feeling that he and his friends were artists, involved Alexander, Fletcher, Memis and Miller (1993), Prout
in something good and worthy of publicizing. Or as and Prout (1998), and Prout and Brown (1999), sug-
one child said to me: “I have discovered how creative gest that school psychologists and counselors are
I can be.” often constrained to implement Rogerian, behavioral,
Therapy through expression and creativity em- cognitive, and systemic therapies, creative arts ther-
ploys one’s entire personality, employing emotional, apists are able to apply psychodynamic approaches,
cognitive, and motorical skills; it therefore meets the providing of course that there is an adequate, not
multidimensional needs of special education pupils, purely clinical, setting. If there is a need to facilitate
such as children with learning disabilities, mental regression in therapy, this can be done using the
impairments, and/or emotional and behavioral prob- language and disciplines of art. The structuring of the
lems. sessions, whether they are in individual or group
settings, is also an important point and one which
therapists working in educational settings have to
Towards a more viable encounter re-examine, taking into account that the child/client
has to return to an environment that addresses his ego
In terms of the educational system, we suggest strengths as a student. Therapists could contribute
holding a discussion about and an examination of the their skills for differential diagnosis, family interven-
desire to accept innovations and new ideas, to change tions, parent-child groups, and so forth.
and be changed, in order to insure a fruitful collab- An arts therapist entering into the school, could
oration on behalf of our mutual clients–the pupils. It introduce and explain her profession to the school
seems that the best way to clarify these issues is faculty through lectures and workshops, presenta-
through “intercultural dialogue” so that the points tions of case studies, workshops to consolidate or
and concepts discussed in this article are raised as enrich the staff, and so on. For both therapists and
part of this agenda. The schools would have to ex- educators, the goal is to establish common concep-
plore the possibility of providing psychological as tualizations and understandings.
well as physical space for the incorporation of arts
therapies, providing rooms and materials, sharing in-
formation and decisions, and so on. The participation Summary
of therapists in staff meetings would result in a
deeper understanding of the child on the part of both This article endeavored to describe the work of
educational and therapeutic professionals. arts therapists in schools as an encounter between
It is suggested that creative arts therapists bear in two cultures, the culture of school-education and the
mind the following: after the home and family, culture of therapy. The term culture was employed
school is the most important place in the life of a using an encompassing meaning, which includes dif-
child, who spends an enormous amount of time there ferent levels: (a) ideas describing the nature of the
during his twelve years of education. In light of this human subject and the world; (b) values, norms,
fact, it appears that presenting the objectives of ther- goals, and restrictions; (c) modes of behavior and
apy as a service offered to the child so that he can problem solving procedures; and (d) expectations,
fulfill, enjoy, and maximize his role and identity as a utopias, and ideals of a society.
pupil, is an effective operative definition. There are The entrance of an arts therapist into a school is
already reports of interventions of this type, such as understood in terms of an intercultural encounter–the
psychodynamic intervention in kindergartens, whose coming of a foreigner to a community. Therefore
objective is to rechannel the child’s drive behavior as potential conflicts that may arise in such an encounter
play, learning, and work behavior (Brown & Prout, are mentioned, and some steps suggested that may
1989). Treatment that focuses on short-term therapy help in dealing with them. Since both cultures dis-
is a good alternative for many children who require cussed here are focused on the welfare and develop-
therapeutic attention (Dasberg, Itzigsohn & Sheffler, ment of the child/pupil, it seems important that their
1989). Lavoritano and Segal (1992) have reported on representatives–teachers and therapists–work to-
H. Wengrower / The Arts in Psychotherapy 28 (2001) 109 –115 115

gether to forge a dialogue that will promote their joint Kazdin, A., & Johnson, B. (1994). Advances in psychother-
objectives. apy for children and adolescents: Interrelations to ad-
justment, development and intervention. Journal of
School Psychology, 32, 217–246.
References Kincheloe, J., & Steinberg, S. (1997). Changing multicul-
turalism. Buckingham: Open University Press.
Abraham, A. (1993). La personalidad de los docentes. In Lavoritano, J. E., & Segal, P. B. (1992). Evaluating the
Juidı́as Barroso & Loscertates Abril (Eds.), El rol do- efficacy of short term counseling on adolescents in a
cente. Un enfoque psicosocial. Sevilla: Muñoz, Moya y school setting. Adolescence, 27, 535–543.
Montraveta. Lefley, H. P., & Pedersen, P. B. (1986). Cross-cultural
Ariño, A. (1997). Sociologı́a de la cultura. Barcelona: Ariel. training for mental health professionals. Springfield,
Bion, W. (1970). Attention and interpretation. London: Ta- Ill.: Charles Thomas Publishers.
vistock. Leledakis, K. (1995). Society and psyche. Social theory and
Brantley, L. S., Brantley, P. S., & Baer-Barkley, K. (1996). the unconscious dimension of the social. Oxford: Berg
Transforming acting-out behavior: a group counseling Publishers.
program for inner-city elementary school pupils. Ele- Lewis, P. (1997). Multiculturalism and Globalism in the
mentary School Guidance and Counseling, 31, 93–105. Arts in Psychotherapy. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 24,
Brown, D. T., & Prout, H. (1989). Counseling and psycho- 123–127.
therapy with children and adolescents. Theory and Payne, M. (1996). What is professional social work? Bir-
practice for school and clinic settings. Vermont: Bran- mingham: Venture press.
don. Polkinghorne, D. (1991). Narrative and Self-Concept. Jour-
Caplan, G. (1964). Principles of preventive psychiatry. New nal of Narrative and Life History, 1 (2–3) 135–153.
York: Basic Books. Prout, H., & Brown, D. (1999). Counseling and psychother-
Clarke, B. H. (1997). Hermeneutics and the “Relational” apy with children and adolescents. Theory and practice
turn: Schafer, Ricouer, Gadamer and the nature of psy- for school and clinic settings. New York: Wiley & Sons.
choanalytic subjectivity. Psychoanalysis and Contem- Prout, H., Alexander, S., Fletcher, C., Memis, J., & Miller,
porary Thought, 20, 3– 68. D. (1993). Counseling and psychotherapy services pro-
Dasberg, H., Itzigsohn, J., & Sheffler, G. (1989). Short-term vided by school psychologists: an analysis of patterns in
psychotherapy. Jerusalem: Magnes Press. practice. Journal of School Psychology, 31, 309 –316.
Dokter, D. (1995). One for all? Research into transcultural Prout, H., & DeMartino, R. (1986). A meta-analysis of
arts therapies’ issues. In Conference Proceedings of 3rd school-based studies of psychotherapy. Journal of
European Arts Therapies Conference, (10 –15). Univer- School Psychology, 24, 285–292.
sity of Hertfordshire-Hatfield. Prout, S., & Prout, H. (1998). A meta-analysis of school-
Frost, P. J. (1985). Organizational culture. London: Sage. based studies of counseling and psychotherapy: an up-
Geertz, C. (1973). The interpretation of cultures. Selected date. Journal of School Psychology, 36, 121–136.
essays. New York: Basic Books. Shechtman, Z. (1993). Group psychotherapy for the en-
Goldstein, J., Freud, A., & Solnit, A. (1973). Beyond the hancement of intimate friendship and self-esteem. Jour-
best interests of the child. London: Burnett Books. nal of Social and Personal Relationships, 19, 483– 494.
Grinberg, L., & Grinberg, R. (1989). Psychoanalytic per- Stone, L. (1976). Schooling and society. Studies in the
spectives on migration and exile. New Haven: Yale history of education. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Univer-
University Press. sity Press.
Guba, E., & Lincoln, Y. (1994). Competing paradigms in Sullivan, H. S. (1954). The psychiatric interview. New
qualitative research. In N. Denzin & Y. Lincoln, Hand- York: W. W. Norton.
book of Qualitative Research (pp. 105–116). California: Zehm, S., & Kottler, J. (1993). On being a teacher. Cali-
Sage. fornia: Corwin Press.

You might also like