The document provides a comparison of themes, techniques, and symbols between the novels 1984 by George Orwell and Persepolis by Marjane Satrapi. For 1984, key themes explored include totalitarian government, mass surveillance, violence, war, lack of freedom, and betrayal. Satrapi's Persepolis examines lack of freedom/repression under Islamic rule in Iran, war between Iran and Iraq, immigration, modernity, family, and betrayal. Both utilize techniques like irony, metaphor, juxtaposition, imagery, tone, foreshadowing, personification, symbolism, and allusion to convey their messages.
The document provides a comparison of themes, techniques, and symbols between the novels 1984 by George Orwell and Persepolis by Marjane Satrapi. For 1984, key themes explored include totalitarian government, mass surveillance, violence, war, lack of freedom, and betrayal. Satrapi's Persepolis examines lack of freedom/repression under Islamic rule in Iran, war between Iran and Iraq, immigration, modernity, family, and betrayal. Both utilize techniques like irony, metaphor, juxtaposition, imagery, tone, foreshadowing, personification, symbolism, and allusion to convey their messages.
The document provides a comparison of themes, techniques, and symbols between the novels 1984 by George Orwell and Persepolis by Marjane Satrapi. For 1984, key themes explored include totalitarian government, mass surveillance, violence, war, lack of freedom, and betrayal. Satrapi's Persepolis examines lack of freedom/repression under Islamic rule in Iran, war between Iran and Iraq, immigration, modernity, family, and betrayal. Both utilize techniques like irony, metaphor, juxtaposition, imagery, tone, foreshadowing, personification, symbolism, and allusion to convey their messages.
portraying about __, government freedom/repression example : totalitarian Big Brother Forced to wear veils and government leads to loss -Mass surveillance have bears, no freedom of humanity) Telescreens, constantly of speech… watched and listened -War to Iran vs Iraq -Violence -Religion Bombing Islam, talked to god Vaporization when she was little, Public executions pushes the plot forward Two minute hate -Immigration -Lack of Immigrated to Austria to freedom/repression run away from war, Telescreens, constantly explores he experience watched and listened as an immigrant to -Modernity Newspeak She tries to imitate Thought Police European people’s -war manners Eurasia vs Oceania -Family -love/lust She loves family and Winston and Julia they love her, strong -Betrayal connection Winston and big -Betrayal brother Anush betrayed the O’brien and Winston country - -Totalitarian Governement Islamic Regime -Mass surveillance The women that stopped her because of her Michael Jackson sweater, and the neighbours -Violence Bombing Fire in movie theater
Techniques Irony: “War is peace. Hyperbole: authors use
Freedom is slavery. hyperbole to create Ignorance is emphasis. in her comic strength.”Orwell uses strip Satrapi uses it to show how exaggeration to help manipulation and distinguish and control can restrict emphasis characteristics one’s freedom and more easily example : privacy. Its purpose of “and so I was lost, this slogan was to push without any bearings ” the population of she exaggerates the Oceania to have death of her uncle as if it contradictory was the end of the thoughts, having a world. This shows the name in the book 1984 reader that Anoosh was “doublethink”. very important to her Metaphor: Orwell Juxtaposition : Satrapi used metaphor and use juxtaposition to simile to create a dark imply disparities and grim atmosphere between age, gender , in the book. He class and to depict compared some different perspectives elements from the and/or gazes on the atmosphere to other issue of the veil in this dark things making comic strip we often see that grim atmosphere eastern and western used to portray the ideals juxtaposed to one harm of totalitarian another example : “ government. “He was Deep down I was very a lonely ghost uttering religious but as a family a truth that nobody we were very modern would ever hear.”It is and avant garde ” “rule used to show how the number six : Everybody narrator compares the should have a car. Rule words of a ghost to the number seven: all maids writings in the diary of should eat at the tables Winston and “In this with the others “ her game that we’re family owns a Cadillac playing, we can’t win.” and has a maid who Here Winston had doesn’t eat with them. given up all hope to Imagery:satrapi’s whole overcome the party’s novel is based off of control by saying life in imagery, since it is a Oceania is an graphic novel; however , unwinnable game. there is specific text that Allusion: the book of can cause a reader to 1984 alludes to nazi imagine what is Germany led by Adolf happening with or Hitler, and Russian without an actual image communism with examples : “Ma’am, my Stalin. For example, mother’s dead, my the concept of big stepmother is really brother watching over cruel and if I don’t go the people of Oceania home right away,she’ll strongly resembles kill me… she’ll burn me Hitler’s rulership. with clothes iron…. Orwell uses Allusion to She’ll make my father connect his work to put me in an orphanage actual events without ” “after marching and stating them, such as throwing stones all day, stalinism. He also by evening they had references Germany aches all over, even in led by Hitler once their heads ” again in chapter to, Tone: Marjane Satrapi when speaking of the uses different types of “child spies”, who are tones throughout her sent to make sure no comic to captivate the one is betraying big reader’s attention and brother. and to make want to Foreshadowing: know more examples: George Orwell uses “BBC said there were foreshadowing to 400 victims…the people show the reader or the knew it was the shah’s audience the fault” This quote creates dangerous things that a serious tone which will happen to the captivates readers and protagonist in the makes them want to future. In chapter 4 in read more.satrapi book 2, “Of all the creates a humorous tone horrors in the world- a when the widow of the rat!” It was to create dead man cries out , claustrophobic “The king is a environment and killer!”when he actually foreshadowed with died of cancer. what they will torture Irony: Satrapi uses this him with. So his device to show the biggest fear. “Traitor contrast between reality and Thought criminal” and how reality seems. it's when the two Mostly referring to the children are shouting effect the regime had on to Winstone, it the people. For example, foreshadows that he during Marji’s visit to her will be a traitor. aunt, her uncle says Personification: “If the “the stress I get from party could thrust it’s every gunshot I hear is hand into the past and much worse for me than say that this or that the cigarettes”. He says even never happened, this to his wife as a that surely was more response to her asking terrifying than mere him to quit smoking torture or death”. before he dies from it. Personnification is He ended up passing used in 1984 to give away due to the fear of a human characteristics bombing that happened to the government, in his neighborhood, and and big brother, not from the cigarettes, showing how truly cold which caused him two and cruel they could heart attacks. Through be, and the control this ironic situation the and power that they author aims to show had over all the that the islamic regime civilian’s lives. even negatively affected Symbolism: people’s health, “Telescreens, thought antagonizing it. police, glass Allusion: Multiple paperweight and the allusions are made. red coral”. Most of Allusions about historical these symbols are events are made to give used to show the context and show that ideology, propaganda, those events that we the dangers behind probably only saw on tv totalitarianism and affected her personally. censorship. The Page 14 and 15 depict telescreens are the “rex cinema fire”: symbolized as mass “the shah said that a surveillance and group of religious propaganda, Thought fanatics perpetrated the police is the thought massacre. But the control on the people knew that it was population and the shah's fault!!”. These censorship and as last panels give context to is symbolized as the why the shah was later true desire winstone overthrown had to find the real Symbolism: Symbols in history. Also when the the novel are used to police came to his show the repression of place to arrest him and the regime as well as the the glass paperweights characters (mainly marji) got broken by it, it opposition to the symbolizes that all his repression. “At around desire will be forever the same time as she lost. The red coral was had this realization, a symbol of love Marjane smokes her first between the two. cigarette as “my act of rebellion against my mother’s dictatorship." Since she was a child she knew she could not do much against the government of her country so she focused her rebellion against her well intentioned parents. Nonetheless the act of smoking the cigarette is an action against all the repression in her life. Color scheme: The color scheme is black and white to illustrate the opposing themes that are discussed in the novel (oppression vs freedom; violence vs peace; modernism vs traditionalism). For exemple on the first panel, on the third page, the black and white is used to symbolize the theme of freedom vs restraint. The veil Marjane is wearing is colored in black, this is to show that she is restrain by having to wear the veil by force. She is wearing a white dress under the veil; the white symbolizes freedom. Her veil hiding the upper part of her dress shows that it is obstructing on her ability to be fully free.
Context -Author was in the -Author experienced - Marjane lived in the
army in India when it totalitarian government islamic regime was a British colony -experienced life as an -He lived during the -at the time, USSR was immigrant existence of a a totalitarian like -went through being a totalitarian nation girl in an oppressive government -He was against government They were both violence - is muslim against that type of regime -Experience -autobiography so homelessness and author went through poverty everything that - he witnessed war happened in the novel -his wife died - is not religious Setting -Oceania, in 1984, -Iran (after the islamic Time is similar to during a period where revolution) and Austria both it is ruled by a in the late 1970s The places are totalitarian different government that went The type of by the name of Big government is similar Brother Genre Dystopian Fiction Autobiographical graphic novel Global Issues -Mass surveillance -repression leading to making people scared violence of being themselves -struggles when living as -repression leading to an immigrant violence - -fake news in the media - Characterization Winstone Smith: Marjane Satrapi: Protagonist protagonist Julia Anoosh O’brien: antagonist Marji’s parents Big Brother Shah (before regime): Emmanuel Goldstein antagonist The Parsons Islamic regime: Syme antagonist Mr. Charrington Iranian government: antagonist