Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 6 - Project Management and Development
Chapter 6 - Project Management and Development
INTRODUCTION
What is a Project?
Before we can go into the principle of project management, let us differentiate a program from a
project.
Following the mission of the UST NSTP CWTS LTS, our programs aim to inculcate the values of
patriotism, nationalism, Thomasian ideals and advance the involvement of the youth in public and
civic affairs while keeping in mind the end goal of empowerment. We derive our programs from
the nine (9) Social Transformation Program areas of the University, namely:
Equitable and
Inclusive
Education
Cybercrime and
Children's Rights Classroom Social Media
Lakbay Turo
Workshop Construction Responsibility
Seminar
Figure 1. NSTP CWTS | LTS Program and its projects. Illustrated in the chart is the program for Equitable and
Inclusive Education where several projects like Lakbay Turo, Children’s Workshop, etc are cited.
In the figure above, the program area Equitable and Inclusive Education has several projects under
its umbrella, Lakbay-Turo, Children’s Rights Workshop, Classroom Construction and Cybercrime,
and Social Media Responsibility Seminar to name a few.
For Michael F. Hanford, the Chief Methodologist of SUMMIT Ascendant Methodologies, project
management is concerned with the dynamic allocation, utilization, and direction of resources
1
BusinessDictionary.com
A program manager, or supervisor, in your NSTP Course, is the person you recognize as your NSTP
Facilitator, while the team leader within your group is the project manager. The Facilitator heads
the overall program and communicates with the project manager so that (s)he can be updated with
the current situation of each project.
A project manager requires an array of skill sets and balance to achieve efficient and effective
project management. Some of these skills may be more innate and instinctual to some and not
others, however, it does not mean that they cannot be learned and developed. These skill sets are
categorized into two: Hard Skills which are tangible and often known as technical skills. These are
easier to define, observe, measure and teach. Soft skills are intangible and focused on interpersonal
or people skills which are harder to quantify or measure and more difficult to teach.
SCENARIO A.
Imagine you and your friends are eager to help a small town in Pampanga through your Sustainable
gardening project. After weeks of planning, buying the materials and seedlings need., You and your
friends drove to the area. However, once you got there, you discovered that the soil in the
community is not conducive for planting and that there is no source of water to sustain the plants.
You have wasted resources, time and effort because of the faux pas.
SCENARIO B.
After evaluating the result of a health assessment, Group A discovered that there are a lot of
children who are malnourished in the community, so they proposed to have a feeding program in
the area. During the evaluation, they discovered several causes of it: a) most of the children’s
religion does not allow them to eat the types of food they’ve served; b) some of the children don’t
eat the food that was served and brings it at home for the rest of the family to consume c) there
are times that they had to cancel because the community coordinator they have talked to has an
important event to attend, and d) they went over budget since they have to buy ingredients and
condiments from time to time along the way because they failed to bring them during the actual
event.
These scenarios could have been prevented if proper project management was utilized.
Figure 4. According to PMI's PMBOK (Project Management Body of Knowledge Guide, project management
have five (5) phases.
This is where you gather data regarding a general area description and demographic
profile (Requirement Elicitation).
You can even identify and describe the condition of the community based on their
economic, education, environmental, health, political and social situation. You can
use the P.E.S.T.L.E. framework.
In community development, we need a collaborative and participatory approach since the project
would affect the stakeholders (particularly the members of the community). In a kick-off meeting,
the skills of being a facilitator, animator, and enabler of a project manager are important.
As a project manager, by understanding which type of thinkers are in your group, you would be able
to get insights on how to best utilize their skills and how to approach the project. Although
individuals might fit more than one criterion as a thinker, knowing which trait shows more
dominance could help you in selecting the roles of each member.
Creating a profile is similar to setting up a profile in an online social network such as Twitter or
Facebook. It is a set of data that helps identify the characteristics and features of a community. It
also attempts to describe the community, highlights area that needs to be developed, reveals
possibilities, and helps place a benchmark for your project.2 The forms like resumes, “Learner’s
Profile” or other survey forms can also be valuable tools for assessment.
In their book, In Key Concepts in Social Research, Payne and Payne (2004) identified three types of
profiling:
2
Fundamentals of project management By James P. Lewis
3
"Existing materials developed without the researcher's influence" (Salmon) like, but not limited to, published literature,
documents and reports, databses.
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
Internal Current
focus status
OPPORTUNITIES THREATS
External
Future
focus
OPPORTUNITIES THREATS
There are community profiles that you could access from the SIMBAHAYAN office from previous
projects which could be helpful, and LTS “Learner’s Profile” can give you an idea of the recipients of
the Lakbay Turo projects.
Who are the people you need to manage closely, keep satisfied, keep informed and monitor?
What is their level of authority and the impact they hold in the project?
How will they be affected by the project?
What engagement strategies can be used to gain positive influence and reduce negative
ones?
How do the stakeholders define an ‘ideal’ situation? “If a man knows not to which port he
sails, no wind is favorable.”
As the quote (left) indicates, if you don’t know what
you what to achieve, there would be no ideal ― Seneca the Younger
approach to your task.
Setting the objectives is a critical part of the project, and as discussed in the previous chapter, we
will use the SMART (Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant and Time-bound) framework to
establish our targets.
When defining the project, here are some questions that you need to consider and answer:
This is where you establish the name of the project, background of the beneficiaries (whether the
community, organization or particular target group), and the purpose of the said project.
The project scope refers to all the works that must be done in order to make the project outcome
possible. It is the ‘what’ of the project and the objective is the ‘why’ of the project.
Time Example:
Scope
If the project's scope gets bigger, yet the budget
remains the same, it can lead to reduced quality and
schedule extension. Likewise, if the project scope is
lessened, the time you would spend with it would
diminish as well as the spending.
Cost Quality Similarly, if you have time constraints, you have to
either trade-off the quality of the project output or the
scope.
It is often a misconception that there is no need to state what is out-of-scope (limitations) - since
isn’t it obvious - it is not stated in the scope and by definition is “out-of-scope”. However, more often
than not, some stakeholders would expect deliverables that cannot be handled by the other
constraint of the project.
As was discussed earlier, there are several types of thinkers in a group. It is now the task of the
project manager to set the tone of the project by directing, motivating and managing the team
through the phases of project management.
Since the team is composed of members with different types of thought process, there is a high
possibility that the working environment is not often conducive for project process. Know the
prevailing climate in your group (Young, 2013) - Is it stormy and riddled with conflicts? Cold and
non-responsive? – if this is the case, your group might spend most of your time trying to resolve
conflicts than focusing on the project implementation.
As project managers, it is not sufficient that you are good at handling scope, time, cost and quality.
In order to get a higher probability of success, you also need to have skills in people management.
The project manager helps influence this climate by setting a collaborative and consultative
environment (Young, 2013; Barker and Cole, 2009)
To define the stakeholder, we must systematically gather and analyze information to determine
whose interest, expectations and influence should be taken into account throughout the project.
Through a dialogue with the initial stakeholder – usually with the Community Development
Coordinator (CDC) and the Partner Community Coordinators of SIMBAHAYAN – we will be able to
expand the list and eventually identify all the potential stakeholders of the project.
Stakeholders can both be internal and external. Aside from identifying their interests, it is also
important to identify their power.
A summary of possible associated risk with the project can help manage expectations for
stakeholders at the start of the project management. Since this is just the initiation stage, we can
identify the risk through one of the following:
What are the major risk that can influence the project outcome?
Top 10 risk
General risk assessment, similar to that done during the DRRM
During the initiation stage, there might be a thing or two that cannot be easily resolved during the
Kick-off meeting but needs to be addressed since it would significantly impact the project. These
unresolved issues need to be noted as to be discussed further in the subsequent phases of the
project. In documenting these unresolved issues, you need to state the issue, why it was not
resolved and what needs to be addressed.
Since it can be challenging to estimate the time and budget involved in a project, using the term
“preferred” places into consideration the suggestion of the stakeholder when it comes to the project
schedule and resources. The common practice is to use phrases such as ‘between’ or plus/minus
to express target value rather than an absolute figure. It helps lessen misinterpretation and
misunderstanding.
Now that we have defined and dug up the bases for the project, the next step in the initiation is to
get approval to proceed with the project. This is usually done during a kick-off meeting with the
stakeholders.
So how do you prepare? By setting and formulating a well-laid plan for your project.
In the planning phase, all the required key points defined during the initiating phase is refined,
established, revisited and documented to come up with the best possible plan at the end.
The result of the planning phase is a project management plan. The plan contains an established
baseline of all the key points relating to the project; this is progressively updated during
implementing phase as it is the blueprint or roadmap of the project. It is often used to point you
from where you are to where you are going.
A well-defined plan can be an excellent health checklist as you monitor and control your progress
in your work.
During initiating phase, we have defined the scope of the project and know that it is vital in setting
the expectation of the stakeholders, as well as managing task. Scope is related to time, cost and
quality - the triple constraint, also known as project trade-offs. This is often set with the objective in
mind.
Example:
If the scope of you project increases but your project cost remains the same, then there will be a
trade-off or. (1) The timeframe can be extended – assuming that there will be no additional cost
with the extra time (2) Quality can be compromised
Extra time
Reduced Quality
Constraints are restrictions or limitation that may affect the performance of the project. They are
critical.
You have to be specific with your goal; don’t be vague or too wordy. Your group should also be able
to measure or rate the target that you want to achieve. Be sure that the plan is attainable – we don’t
want to set a very high expectation, or a fictitious idea. When you are setting up a plan, make sure
that there is a leeway for mistakes, and that it is amenable to changes. Be relevant. Your plan is
practical, and it is not just an idea but something that can be made possible. Being realistic or
relevant means, you have to consider the resources at hand, the skills of the group and the scope
is represented. And lastly, the plan should be time-bound. Ensure that the project can be completed
with reasonable timeframe, especially since you have only a semester or two to implement the said
project.
Here is an example of such objectives, point out which one followed the SMART guideline better:
Sample 2: Illustrate how to add two to three-digit numbers to the grade school children of
Maragondon within 2-3 weeks.
If your answer is Sample 2, then you have a grasp of what being SMART means. The second
objective is specific (what to teach, who should be taught and how long). But you also have to
remember that being SMART is not enough. As a Thomasian, you also have to ensure that the
Thomasian core values are integrated with your objectives. Think of it this way, your objective
should be affecting the following aspects:
b. HEART (affective) – this affects the emotions and expressions of an individual (Compassion)
Sample 1:
Sample 2:
If you will notice some of the objectives stated before might not indicate a timeline. This is usually
because each group of objectives usually start with these statements:
“At the end of this (the activity/date/time), the (target/beneficiaries) are expected to:”
Take a look at the start of this chapter where the objectives are stated. You will notice similar
statements. The same is true for the textbooks you read, online courses you take or even other
modules. Any activity usually has an objective even if it is as simple as just to have fun.
To help you further in setting up a goal for your project, you can refer to Bloom’s Taxonomy.
In this table, specific keywords are provided to describe and identify which appropriate objective
you can use for the task you intend to accomplish. Bloom's Taxonomy provides an approach to
establish measurable goals and objectives.
Around September 2015, United Nations adopted the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development,
which includes a set of 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). These are a new, universal set
of goals, targets and indicators that UN member states will be expected to use to frame their
agendas and political policies over the next 15 years.
For the group or organization to determine whether they are on the right path and the strategies
they are using are correct or not, the objectives are assessed against the dedicated metrics with
the help of KPI (Key Performance Indicator) - this key 'indicates' the factors that contribute to the
success of the organization and KRA (Key Results Area), significant areas requiring exceptional
performance to survive and maintain a competitive position.
Identifying these Keys in the Planning Phase would be useful, help the group measure and keep
track of the progress of their project.
B. PROJECT APPROACH
There are several approaches to project management that the group can employ when they
implement their projects. Since there is no such thing as a ‘one-size-fits-all’, your group needs to
see what approach would fit your project goals, targets and needs.
Click this link to know seven (7) of the most used methodologies in the industry.
Moreover, since we are working with the community, we must not forget to incorporate the
principles of Community Development and Organizing with the methods used for project
management.
C. PROJECT SCHEDULE
One of the most important deliverables in project management is a WBS (Work Breakdown
Structure). It should be a compulsory component of every project. It is a deliverable-oriented
hierarchal breakdown of the work to be executed by the team to accomplish the objectives and
create the required deliverables.
In filling out the WBS, Therese Linton (2014), author of Project Management Essential, mentioned
that deliverables are nouns and activities are verbs, and only nouns should appear in a WBS. The
4
In Business Dictionary online, a workstream is “The progressive completion of tasks completed by different
groups within a company which are required to finish a single project.” (16 Mar 2020)
(1) Deliverables – as mentioned earlier, deliverables are often stated in a form of a noun, these are
physical outputs that the project must produce to meet the objective.
(2) Activities – steps that need to be implemented and always related to the deliverables, if not, it
would only be deemed as wasted effort.
(3) Task – a step under activities, and are often found in long term project or large-scale
deliverables.
In setting up a schedule management plan, there two things you can check first before actually
creating one from scratch: (1) is there already a high-quality project out there that is similar to
yours? You can adapt their scheduling for your project (2) Have you already implemented similar
projects before? You can use and modify it to fit your current needs.
To avoid pitfalls of an overly detailed schedule plan, Linton (2014), shared three rules:
No activity smaller than a day. A day is the smallest time unit, if it can be done in less than a day, it
might not be worth specifying in the schedule anymore or there might be other interrelated tasks
to it.
If the activity is less than an hour, set it up as milestone (an activity or event that is important and
has zero duration), example: signing of MOU (memorandum of understanding)
No activity longer than a week. If it is longer, break it down. The longer the duration, the harder it is
to monitor or recover from should there be any setback.
D. PROJECT BUDGET
When you are planning for cost management, remember that it is one of the triple constraints and
that any change in it can affect the two other factors.
Things that needs to be discussed as you plan for the cost management
Asset – something that the entity acquired or purchased: something physical such as cash,
machinery, land, and building to name a few
Depreciation –the possible conversion value of the asset might change over the course of
the project management
Operational Expense – recurring cost that are related to the day-to-day activities in the
project, for example, travel expenses
In setting the budget, you should also consider where the spending will take place. Will the
materials be cheaper if bought near the area? More often than not, if the material is
bought near the community instead of the near UST, it’s less expensive, and you can save on
the transportation cost. There are also instances, wherein the owner of the establishment gives
discounts if they learn that it will be for their community’s benefit.
Quality as one of the triple constraint to the project scope, is more often than not easily sacrificed.
In the planning phase, you must list down the quality standards that are relevant to the project,
deliverables, and process. Identify which is an acceptable level of quality. Ideally, it would contain
the quality assurance and quality control techniques and activities linked to each deliverable.
Quality assurance – activities like reviews, process checklist and audits that are built into the
process used to create a product
Quality Control – inspection and testing. Activities done after the completion of the deliverable. It is
used to verify if the requirements are met and correct.
Make sure that you also state what the group should do if the quality was not met. You can also
revisit your objectives to find out what quality is expected for that particular activity or deliverable.
Creating the plan should not be solely shouldered by the leader of the group. The members who are
involved in the project should also give their input and help plan the project; otherwise, the members
might be clueless on what they have to do and feel no sense of commitment to the project. This
usually ends up with the project leader doing most of the task and the members being clueless on
what is going to happen.
Establishing a clear outline of work assignment and task description, conflict resolution process,
analyzing workload, setting timeframe of deliverables, encouraging feedback, and conducting
regular meetings for communication, updates and consultation can reduce conflicts in a team.
Usually in big projects RASCI (introduced in the 1990s) chart is used to delegate accountability for
major deliverables. RASCI stands for:
H.RIRISK MANAGEMENT
Uncertain circumstance and events may occur during project management phases, affecting the
project either negatively or positively. Once you have defined and predicted risk, it lowers the
probability of one occurring. Defining the risk allows the team to formulate countermeasures to
address it once it appears.
It is the acquisition of resources. The procurement can happen in any project management phase
and often involves a contract or essential documents between the seller and buyer.
2. Is procurement required
In implementing a plan, it would be best if the guidelines are set or given to the group beforehand
so that they will follow these as they complete the activities. This is where all the management
plans come into play.
Before the pandemic, NSTP CWTS | LTS adheres to the following policies which are discussed
during the orientations. These guidelines are as follows:
(Some of the contents are taken from All Student Leaders: Community Development
Forum, Orientation Materials; UST-OCD)
Currently, due to pandemic constraints, NSTP CWTS LTS does not conduct face-to-face fieldwork
and instead conducts project implementation (alternative fieldwork) online.
You
You also have to keep in mind that the main purpo
purpos se of your pro
project is to ensure that you empower
the community with knowledge dge, attitude and skilkills that will help them proprogres
gress and enrich their
lives
ves. Community interact
raction is encourage
raged; it should be a collaborat
boratiive ac
activity.
It is common that during the implementing phase, changes can occur – this would require re-
planning and adjusting the baselines based on what happens in the field to accommodate
situations. So when this situation arises, the immediate question is not “who’s responsible?” but
“what needs to be done to fix the problem?”. As a manager, do not look for sacrificial lambs, the
responsibility falls on you, so it is essential that you keep calm and concentrate on looking for the
best possible solution. This is where risk management and change management comes into action.
Do a risk assessment:
Is it internal or external?
Transfer – shifting, someone else will take responsibility and manage. It requires an
agreement between the team who is executing and the team who will take
responsibility to manage the risk.
Mitigate – reduce the impact, the earlier it is detected, the lesser the impact
That is why meetings during implementation is important, but to many, there is nothing more
aggravating than getting locked up in endless, pointless meetings that takes your time away from
doing ‘real work’. Therefore, it is pivotal that you make sure that each meeting is productive.
To plan or review
To make a decision
To do constructive work
If a meeting does not have at least one of these, you should reconsider if a meeting is really
essential. A meeting without clear, specific objectives and supporting agenda is inexcusable and
would most like fail.
1-2-3 of meeting
This is where your proposed plan will be helpful – you can use it as a basis for your monitoring. It
will also aid you in making sure that your objectives and the program’s goal are achieved.
It is like looking down on a blue print from time to time to ensure that the building is according to
plan – an architect or engineer would adjust some measurements if the environment or resources
are lacking. In sailing, you need to check from time to time the condition of your boat, environment
and the crew, to ensure safe journey. Your documentations will be helpful as well during this phase.
With monitoring, you can pinpoint milestones to be celebrated and issues that needs to be
addressed, validating if you need to adjust.
A project evaluation is used to also identify whether a particular project should be continued or
cancelled. It will lead back to the objectives cited at the onset of the project.
The last activity in the project closure is a Post Implementation Review (PIR). It represents the
formal closure of the project. The purpose of the said activity:
In developing a project, you should be able to identify the problems, needs or concerns of the
community you aim to serve. From the findings of your profiling or assessments, you will start
formulating possible solutions or response for the concerns pointed out.
These projects must be SMART. Everyone in the team must give inputs and contribute in the
planning of the project. Plans will be executed, monitored and evaluated to check the effectiveness
and efficiency of its implementation, whether it could be sustained, modified or cancelled.
Through Planning, you will become aware of real-life situations in different communities. You will
experience a change within yourselves and soon, your studies, researches and whatever resources
you have will be eagerly used to find ways to improve the lives of the people in the community. This
becomes apparent when you do volunteer work and give off your time, effort and talent for the
betterment of the community.
Remember that it is the people and their commitments to action that make a Project come alive
and make it work. A desirable outcome of all these is the contribution that you can give to the
community and that is empowerment. The community slowly realizes that it has the power, the
skills and the confidence to take care of itself and be self-sufficient, because you have planned out
a program or project with and for them.
Naturally it would be wishful thinking to assume that this can happen overnight but YOU, as learners
are reassured when you realize that you have helped in planting the seeds of empowerment.
SOURCES
WEBSITES:
http://www.cio.ca.gov/Government/IT_Policy/pdf/PM1.3_Overview_What_is_a_Proje ct.pdf
http://www.barnardos.org.uk/communityprofiling.pdf
http://www.census.gov.ph/
http://www.bulacan.gov.ph/map/topography.php
http://www.teachthought.com/
https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/topics
Phillips, P. P., &, C. A. (2008). Data collection: Planning for and collecting all types of
data. San Francisco: Pfeiffer.
Smith, A.& Frank, F. (1999). The Community Development handbook: A tool to build
community capacity. Hull, Quebec: Employment Programs Learning and Development
Unit, Human Resources Development Canada.