Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Theory of Dump Flood
The Theory of Dump Flood
The Theory of Dump Flood
b
6200 North· Central Expressway NUMBER 3733
Dallas, Texas 75206
© Copyright 1972
American Institute of Mining, Metallurgical, and Petroleum Engineers, Inc.
This paper was prepared for the SPE-European Spring Meeting 1972 of the Society of Petroleum
Engineers of AIME, held in Amsterdam; The Netherlands, May 1~18, 1972. Permission to copy is
restricted to an abstract of not more than 300 words. Illustrations :inay not be copied; The abstract
should contain conspicuous acknowledgment of where and by whom the paper is presented. Publication ·
elsewhere after publication in the JOURNAL OF PETROLEUM TECHNOLOGY or the SOCIETY OF
PETROLEUM ENGINEERS JOURNAL is usually granted upon request to the Editor of the appropriate
journal provided agreement to give proper credit is made.
Discussion of this paper is invited. Three copies of any discussion should be sent to the
· Society of Petroleum Engineers, P. 0. Box 228, The Hague, The Netherlands. Such discussion may be
presented at the above meeting and, with the paper, may be considered for publication in one of the
two-SPE magazines. · ·
There. has been a problem in monitoring the rate The methods available for obtaining water for
at which. the wells transfer water from a high injection purposes are numerous and the .econo-
pressure potential zon~·to a low pressure mics associated with the injection project
potenti~"'.. -::.-u-;;:. .'!:'~,:...~ is due to the fact that usually dictate which source should be used.
there are two zones open ·to the well bore which The source. of water used is dependent usually
cannot be readily monitored independently; on the quality and quantity of water available.
For instance, the sea or rivers may be used,·
The theory of dumpflooding has been developed when availa~le, but treatment costs are often
and due. to the complexity of solving the resul- very high. Subterranean water is. often of
tant second order differential equations, a better quality but quantity ~nd/or accessi-
computel;' program has been written and presented bility usually involve large capital expen-
to assist analysts in monitoring the dumping ditures for wells and pumps.
rates.
This paper deals with probably the cheapest and
A technique has also been developed which per- most effective method of injecting water into
·mits monitoring of the actual fluid injection an oil reservoir, that is, dumpflooding.
rate, within an acceptable accuracy~ and also
SPE 3733
..:rm dumpflooding refers to the process of of rate per unit time would give the cumulative
. ~.Lowing a water-bearing reservoir of high injection to that point in time.
pressure potential to feed into ari oil reservoir
of lower pressure potential by placing the two In the case where one zone is infinite and the
zones in communication through a casing string other is finite a: (ji:Herent set of equations
(Figure 1). The water source zone can be above will apply which would be a simplific;ation of
or below the oil reservoir, as long as there is the above equation. (See Appendix I, Cases
sufficient pressure potential to effect the III and IV).
water transfer. (The equations associated with
dumpflooding apply equal~y well to. both cases. The Signifi'cance of Pipe Friction
Appendix I) .
systems and water treating facilities. 3. With two zones open within one well, the
servicing of either zone becomes more com-
2. 'The operating costs of maintaining a con- plicated, hence more expensive. Certainly
ventional waterflood exceed the dumpflood the equipment to handle any conceivable
oper~ting costs by all those costs assoc- workover is available.
iated with equipment maintenance. The only
operating costs associated with dumpflooding 4. If sand or other particles were to be
which would not be necessary with a conven- deposited from the upper zone to a lower
tional system would be the periodic down- zone then circulating the hole clean would
hole rate monitoring and fluid level be a problem.
measurements. ·. .
pondingly; a fact which..must be ·recorded. The for oil field practical purpos.es. The technique,
suggested method of control would be· as follows: however, does require wee.kly to bi-weekly fluid·
level measurements .and. periodic rate deter-
·The starting point, A, on the dumpflood chart has minations using production.logging techniques.
been established in ·the. above discussion
(Figure 2). It is now necessary. to measure the · Acknowledgments
fluid level at one- to two ..week intervals and·
note any change. If the fluid levels are rising. The author.wishes to express hts appreciation to
then it would appear, from the graph, tl).at the the Oasis Oil Company of Libya, Inc., for the
injected zone is becoming damaged: Follow a line opportunity to write this paper for the First
Annual ·Meeting .of the European S.P.E. to be held
Conclusions
•
The· author concluded from his investigat,ion of
dumpflooding that the actual fluid transfer rate
can be. monitored, within an acceptable accuracy
SPE- 3733
5
Nomenclature Appendix I
API symbol~ are used whenever possible. CASE I - Both Source and Injected Zones of
Infinite Size
Symbol Description Units
The simplest case of dumpflooding is where an
I Injectivity Index BWPD/psi infinite source of water is dumping into an oil
J Productivity Index BWPD/psi zone also of infinite capacity. If the produc-
tivity of the water souce zone is J, BWPD/psi
N Original Oil in Place MMSTB and the injectivity of oil zone is I~ BWPD/psi,
q = -R1 (p. - p~ 0 e
) -Et
+ q o Bo (1 - . e -Et ) (27) f 1 (q w(')) is
. the derivative of. the function.
~
w 1 ~w ...
The convergence to the r~ot is quadratic or
linear if the multiplicity of the root to be
where
determined is equal to one or greater than one
Again .taking equation (25), Appendix I and respectively and if f(q ) can be differentiated
continuously at least t~ice in the range in
putting both zones of infinite capacity, that
which the iteration moves. T_olerance limits
is : N = N = ro the equation reduces to basic
equation (~) Appendix I. must be set to minimize the number of iteration
steps required.
R=.!.+l
I J
q.
~w
= (p. -p. )/(R+Tq?·79)
1w ~o ~w
This is a non-linear equation in q which can which governs the initial conditions. Since
be solved readily using Newton's i~erat~on this equation is non-linear it must be solved
technique. The technique is to refine an using the same techniques as above. (For
initial guess q {'- ) of a root of the general details see Case· I, Appendix II).
non-linear equa~~5~ 0 f(q ) = 0. This takes the
form of : w CASE III - Elaborated to Include Pipe Friction
differ~ntiate f-'(qw) 0.79Tq- 0 · 21 (43) Again in the last two equations the rate can be
w
calculated by iterating the expression
let f 1 (Q ) = -t/(N c f(q )) (44)
.-w. wtw w
(58)
differentiate f 1'1 (qw) =
differentiate f 12 (qw) =
1.79
R q + Tqw = (p.1W - p.10 )· = Ap (59)
w ·
(47) •
Using the last two equations the rate can be Let f (q ) Rq + Tqw1. 79 -~p '(60)
w w
calculated.by iterating the expression :
This can be solved to give the actual flow rate. The rate may be obtained by iterating the
expression :
CASE IV - Elaborated to Include Pipe Friction
(62)
The equations to find the actual flow rate,
q ("+l) at any time, t, for a system which has
a~ Inf1nite·source zone and a finite injected Thi's equation must be used in Cases II, III and
zone are as follows : IV to solve for q. which is the rate at initial
1W
. -'Et -Et conditions .
q
W
= q.·.1w·e + q .(1- e
· ·o
) (49)
Appendix II I
., . I '
SPE 3733 9
CARD 2 - Name Card (one :eer job) CARD 6 - Zone Basic Data
(Do not use if both zones are infinite)
Card Description Format
Column Card Description Format
Column
1- 2 Any number between 1-99 I2
3-14 Name of Field 3A4 1- 8 Aquifer size, MMRB F8.2
15-18 Concession Number A4 9-16 Reservoir size, MMSTB F8.2
19-30 Date 3A4 17-24 Total effective compressibility F8.2
31-38 User's Name 2A4 aquifer, psi-1 10-6
25-32 Total effective_~ompressibility F8.2
(J)
""0
rn
w
-.J
w
w
(f)
·~
F6=(cV~l.l*~V*X**{FV-2.l TF! IC~3l51, 'il, 50
C?~- T * ( I '!*C 1> AN 1 *c 2 I I I ~N* c l *~ ~ l *C 2 *F <; I "l IC J>~ 1
r:g=-1=7*CI')ICS 50 nn31 J'~l, ICD3
r: 4= X-~ ~ c **I=- 7- * P~' A'-1 *C J. -~q l •- F );:::<1= 7) I ( .!\ \i*C 1 o>c AI'H
C?) * IF ( I CD 4- l I 6? , 6? , 6 "l
"lr•--=·F=l.-F7*F~*r*t.'F'*( ~1-P*A~l*::ll I (.'\\J*Cl *ANl·:C(?) A> OE'il(l,?41 A~,A~l,C1 ,C2,T[,P,'1STEPS
r;r· T,.l '1? -r;r1 Tn 65
·') 1 T:ll =X. ~~ !(14~1
nx-=o. ~K2=1
(fii_L TTCP 61)~ nn240K K1 =l, KK2
I~( rrq l"r~ ,t...•/6,-::)s IF I I Cn 4- 21 2 0 2 , ? 0 2 , h 0 4
l') r,n T1 {ql-,,·17) ,IFP 6•)4 IF( KKI -1 I ?On, ?00,201
01-, l,-.iOJTr(3,1,5J ~0\1 T~ \
(~("\ fl ~q Gn rn ?02
1' ··J>:· r r r. 1 ,_, 1~6 1 201 T~T?*lKKl-11
r l T ) l c- ~1? !FIR! ll-9999. 1100,101,100
-. ! (1 .~ r.: f 1<. ,!{ 1 ) =X
!J. T c Fn> THF FJ~ST GJESS US~ THF ~'1 FR!CTir~ CA5F
'1f-t~ ('l\JT J'·II!F 1~ 1 •FPir~l.t~rK.l 1
T [' I I ( ') ,, - ~ l q .__. ' (; {, 1 '~ r,(l T'1 102
'· I 1 T VC"'·I --='). , r 1 o FP I c~ 1 • I~ I I I+ 1. I A I K, 1 I
(-<; -.-:: \~ S T '- :) ) 102 x~P>/PFP rc
1'),() Wl<l=l,!-'1-Cl J::l.:-PI=P JC*X+-';V*X**J:V-P3
TV" I .,. . T vr: I + ( L> ~ Tr-1 Kr< 1 ) + k· '\, f c ( K'<. l + l ) ) *T / ·}:;,l. r; ~EOF=DFPJC+FV*~V*X**(FV-1. I
TV·-1[ I_=T\/'11../ 1 ·ll:l. Gfl T'1 01
' ) .I rr I, T j '!I Jl f 'l x~"'*'"'*f-Tf(•r• rc•A~*Cl 11 /PF~Jc
'l. I •< • ·;- l :: ·-:, '-'·!< \ "·: ( " 'l- 1 • l .- 'c._, I r. I=~=C'I ~o Tr +GV>:•X1:*( FV-1. I
" r "', ~ 1 ::- x F~~rFV--l.I*SV*X"*IFV-2.1
'1 ( K , 1t) :::- Y. /f'l ( '( , J) F7=-T I ( A'J*C l *F5 I
--; ' T ,. ' { '"'-: 1 , --. ) ~ , 7' n~ 1 ... ( .-,) , T ·':I '• FO:-F7«F61F~
' ( :,; ' 1• ) -= '\ f < ' 4 ) .. ( "· ~l1 ,~: :' -'c p ) + Tv ll - D ~- r 1_ l I ( .-\ "· 1 ::r r ) l F4=X-G -:~*E**F 7
T ', I n~RF=1.-~~*F7*FP*E~*F7
'\ ( "' ' ::.. ) :::: ·'l. I --: . I_ ) t ~-- :> r;n T!l G?
· 1 •· • w ) :-or; \f-'o y ~' "r: V gq x~P~*c**I-TI(PFRIC*ANl*CZI I IPFRJC•P*(1.-E*O{-TI(PFPIC*A~10C21 II
'- I ·< , 1 r~ l :: I l ~ - :J::. F I \ It f k' , ~ l ) :'~X r~:Pl=R rr+~V*X.::!·*( FV~l. I
L '~'. ! ·; 1.': '\n.,~-r-·xl'1:\Tff"l H·~f FV-1. I*GV*X**l FV-2. I
r ·1 r i '~ l 1 1 :-; 1 • 1 s I J , r r: ')'; F7~-Tif~~1*C~*F~I
12 SPE 3733
14 1 !j , h(K,");"?.+ioi<R-?llST-Id!K,'>I+A!K,~I lt~r:
~(K 0 7);~(K,,,)
G~.,T'l 1 S 3
1 51 AI~ , ~ l ='ll +WI(R- P<JS T- hI K , 5 I I FG
A(K,7J;"~tWKi-HUST-IAIK,'il+.IK,q))/FG
r,r r1 1" ~
1 C)~ AI~.~~-~2+WK~-~UST-IIIK,5l+Gl~X**FVl/FG
-~I K, 71~n ?+WO-P!JST-1 AI K,Sl+~l K,R I l/FG
151 IFI A!K,Al I 70, 70,71
7~ A(K,9l~hiK,~l*FG
·'1/~TTI=f~,.:>q} T 15
•4Q JT<( '3,1101 P
!:i ~ W~TT'( "'\, '1}
·.>Jf<!Tr:"(',lQt (~ll\~~(12),{2-=10,131
'-IPtp:( ~. 20)
•.JC ITr:( ~. 71 t
1'·1 '1f'''1J;l, Jf;~1
TF( ~{ T }- c.·~gr:;. t lC'"-'+,1 f"'l:J ,104
1"·:; ··J~tTF{",~t~n1 (A.(J,l?),T?=1,1n}
(;~~ F"l ? ~
1 11 ~ ··/PIT r ( ~, :'::') ~ ( I l , f \ ( J, I 2 l , I~ =1 ,! '1 l
(0"1 T T ~!1/f:
Tr"ll= TC lll +T
TF f J C!) 11 ~ '? 1 "J. 1 • .' ,:., 3, -:11
l~ ~ ff11l=:'l
-mrrr( l.• .,~ 1
-~,_ r.f"'l~.~rr:HJr
r;f") rn /~ :"'
1q r: !\ll ;.: X:T T
'hln
SPE 3733 13
.;
u
;
'"
.r
LC
"'
u
0
>L
,_.
~ "' u".,,.
L'
"
'" ..
<> 4
.
~
0 *
;: G
'"* "z 7
u
> -j;.
u ,_ ~
u
> < "
**w 7
~'
l>
'·' q
> u
,- <
I l
,, ~
r >
I
-
lL ..... ('>J ,... - f'' -);. l"
- "'
'·' ::::
"- .:: ~ ! ~
•
r;> .._
I U
! ~· ~
• I LJ_,
•.
__.
~
. I
> -
'-- -l< ,._
1"': II ')<' II > - ~ :1 >' "u '
LL 0
« T**
·~-> ~·
--lf- * "*-
-..J<u -· -!"r-l< " *
-*~
if < ~v~
•xo
"'uu "'0 ~
('; .--< ~
,... ...~
v
v-
OXL
~~~
•x~
~;~ .~
LC *kLC
:~~
QL
~! :;~ '"" ~ ~~
1-
-'
,, ~•l'U -l~t!'~•trL.u *t"•~ll.:.JL
UJ
DL'
>-- . -
C
..-
r- • n
,..._ r" L
rr + +
.. XL:
> *
• . " - -r~ ....._ i<
U u_ -t~ -1~
l"'f
*'-!:L':J'Lll
>
1 "
*
¥ u_
.....
-r.-
....-• ......_
*
...~ ,..
>~}c._·
t,•·- -1;. ...._
u ~~
~
.;_c
..._
lr
_
'.C
f--1---
1 1
r--- ( " ' " - -
z c .. .. r-z::r c. .;~-· + •7-.cu.~~ + •?...C~J u + •7-.ou u ·--->---~
X • ,....., ,...., - := 0:: L.. U -:- L_ __. <1 ll. i~ I ..J L' ,....,· <.1 L -l~ <j~
1-
:::> :c
"< ..-• II
-
r- U - C
P""'<
- .:-" 1-- ....._ 'X
L
- ,__ >.1-- T
n !'
r-
C'
I -
> ....._
~:- ,..,-
r-- 1- ........
• =r -.. I - -:~ ....--
D. > ....._ r- •:· .--
I .J" L· ..- <• I.. -l<
• rr ~ • - .Y. r'
''! > -lf I'-- r •- ,.....,
i
• ..-
•
C
~'
><
-
)< •
~ _1 -
C
._ ::-
V• 1 r - v·, t..r; :-
L. l.J.
;;--
0 o-· c. Y. ..:t l' <f ...t ~X~ :..1. II~ ~ ll U. U II r t..L U. 1- U 11-ff" f' 1-- C' a ,_.,.... ;:, r .. l•"
L> u
ll PtY ~ '-l"llU'IJO F:<. I C T! (1"1 1U"'P DELTA FLO II I"JG FLJ 10 LEVELS FQ. ICT!0-4 ~fll HEAJ HTE LOSS
PI II "tb..TE BHP 8HP T J8 f~G CAS I~G L JSS PREssw~:: )!.II'-.!:; TO
II o I PSI /8PI""J ~\ojPQ PSI PS IG "~GV,FEET PSI PS IG F'l I CTIO"'
25. 5. o .. :?41)'54 54JS. 101'1 t. Z791 .. 62'4. !JlCJ. 2.91 o.) 12.1
o. J
"·
25.
10.
15.
'l. 14 OR2
a. 1076R
~233.
12'J 75.
923.
80'5.
2623.
2'505.
9R5o
1255.
973.
1235.
7. 5!'1
12.26 o. J
53.~
113. 8
". 20. 0.09116 142 S4,. 713. 2:413. 14!14. 143!'1. 16.52 o.o
o. J
181.2
"·
25.
25.
30.
o.OB127
O. 074S9
HOJ3.
174':>9.
64a.
580.
l34J.
228'J •
1631.
17':Jb.
tsqa ..
1729.
20.29
2.3.60 o.J
2*9.~
315. 9
2'5. 35. a. o1ooo lf:15H. 531. 22 31. 1879. 1B3!J. 2b.5J o.J 379.6
25. 40. o. 0664q 1CJ557. 489. 2:189. 1974. 1927. 29.0!J o.o 437.1
25. 45. 0.06376 20394. 453 .. 2153. 20'54. 2004. 31.32 O.J 491.2
25. so. 0.061'58 .?Ill.,. 42.2. 2122. 2124. 2171. 33.33 o.J 541.3
5). 5. 0.220513 513q5. 1179. zan. 398. 392. 3. +O o.J 15.4
so. 10. 0.12093 11752. 1075. 277S • bB. !Jl7. 9.96 o.o 82.4
so. 15. o. 08786 14799. 987. 2687. 832:. 804. 11.64 o.o 2:00.8
50. 20. 0.1)7140 18210. 91'). 2!J10. 10:>2. l!J1. 2:5.57 o. J 358.1
so. 25. J. 06158 21 1l!J. 845. 2545. 114-9. 1(195. 33.33 o.) 5 +I. 3
so. 30. O. C5 50~ 23017. 787. 2487. 1276. 1211. 4-0.73 o.J 7H.7
so. 35. o. 0'5042 257139. 7"37. 21t37. 1388. 1311. 47.M o.J 9+5 .. .,
"·
50.
40.
45.
50.
0.04f:.96
o. 04427
0.04213
27693.
2B73.
318!J s.
b92.
-'J5 3.
617.
2392.
2353.
2317.
1486.
15 74.
16'51.
1399.
1476.
1545.
54.16
60.18
65.77
O.J
01.>
O.J
ll53.t,.
1359. It
15S t. 0
5J.
17
14 SPE 3733
J SER JASISJIL
F 1 "'l f) SPf DATE
"" 18 lH2
ll BYA '-iOLLANO FC!.ICTIO"l ')U~P DELTA Fl 1ft I~G FLJIO LEw'ELS FR ICTIOII .tELL HEAiJ :UTE LOSS
P! !I
!!
.. ----
p! PSI /BPD
RATE
~"'PO
9HP
PSI
BHP
PS IG
TUB I'IG CASI~G
"'G\I,FEET
L JSS
PSI
PRES SUR=
PS IG
JW'I'iG f.O
FRICTIO,.,
500.
'iOO.
..
10.
1').20225
0.1021 ~
o. 061377
20"i~.
13 30.
41 ::!.
133.
2112.
1!333.
2[11.
2816.
2171.
2~15.
o. 52
0.24
o.o
o.o
2 ••
2. 3
'500.
50~).
'50').
15.
20.
25.
'). 05205
a. 04203
65S.
zq2.
124.
"·
15.
5.
1744.
1715.
170'5.
3022.
30"19.
3lll.
3022.
3J89.
3111.
o.or
0.02
O.OJ
o.o
o.o
o. J
1. 0
o.'
0.1
500. 30. (). 03535 52. 2. 1702. 3111 .. 311~. o.oJ o. J o.o
sao. 35. J.03058 21. I. 1701. 3121. 312i. Q.O') o. J o.o
50'1. 40. 0.02700 o. o. l70J. 3122. 3122. 0.0') o.o o.o
'iOO. 45. '1. 02422 4. o. 170J. 3123. 31 ~3. o. 00 o. 0 o.o
5011. 50. o.cz.no I. o. 170'). 3123. 3123. o.oo o. J o. 0
60'). 5. o. 201 qz 205 9. 41 z. 2112. 2172. 2111. o. 52 o.o 2 ••
600. 1(). o.1nl84 1 3Z'5. 1lZ. un2. 2817. 2916. 0.23 o. J 2. 3
60'). 15. ').1')6343 648. 4'3. 1743. 302 3.- 3023. 0.07 o. J 1.0
600. 20. 0.0'5172 296. \4. 1714. 3090. 3090. o.oz o.o o. 3
60'}.
6(').
25.
30.
a. 04169
o. 03501 ,,.
120.
'·
2.
1705.
1702.
3ll2.
3119.
3112.
3119.
o.oo
o. 00
o.o
o. J
0.1
o. 0
600. 35. 0.03024 20. I. 1701. 31n. 31 zz. o.oo o.o o.o
600. 40. 1).02667 a. o. 1700. 3122. 3"122. o.oJ o. J o.o
600. 45. o. 02389 3. o. 170:). 3123. 31Z l. o.oo Q.J o.o
6(!!). 50. J.02167 I. J. 170). 312 3. ~123. o.oo o., o. 0
18
l I BY .a '-11lLA'IlD F':I.ICTION 'JU"'P DELTA FLJ" t"'r; FL J In L E.J El S FPICTEl~ ~jELl HEA) ~ ~ TE L1JS s.
PI II
II PI
-~----
PSI/13PO
~.HE
ll~PO
'"p
PSI
""p
PS IG
TU ~ [~G CASI"'S
"''GY,FEET
LJSS
PSI
PRES SUR:
PS IG
l.oll "'G T1
FRICTION
~
N
...J
"'
...J
~
N <t
0
z
::>
0
...J "'a:
(.)
(.)
IL. ::>
0 0
a:
C> 0 "'z
0
Vl
a: N a:
<t
::E
!X ~ ~
z
0
...J "'
~
3: ~
en 0
0
z ~ z
<t
I
u
w
H ""
::>
1-
<t
::>
1-
<t
::E w 0 0
N
0:: 1- 1-
(!)
::> E- <t <t
!:2 :J
.. E-
z u. -0 >
..
:J ..
-0~
>
0 "0- C> ~
0
"0 u; Vl
a.. a..
0
...J
u. ~ "' a:"'::>
a:
a.. 0
::>
::E ...J
Vl
Vl
Vl
Vl
::>
0
rx: -. "-
0
a:
<t
"'"' "'a:a..
a..
~
a..
::>
.. ..
0
a..
;o
a..
16 SPE 3733
'' I.
\ I
./"--- / 17
./
I .,~·<_I I 1/ ! I ./
I /
I / ,,,I./
..:'"X'·. ...
"'-
./
I I ·l'l I /
\ / II /
. ./-1-hf-!/--+---+IL/-+!-+!7· '+.(--+'io;-.l'~v'_'.l---l----t-+-1--+-+-+-+--+--l---l-----1-~
13oo f-HHH-+-:+'--+--+--+++-+',.,_:'".+---+f--
\ /l i /! . y
~.ooo 10,000 zo.ooo 2.!i,Ooo JO,OOO 55,90()
'FLUID TRAN.SF'ER RA'TE, 8WP'D.