Professional Documents
Culture Documents
402 - FSV - Suggested Solutions - 2020 May
402 - FSV - Suggested Solutions - 2020 May
Disclaimer Notice
The copyright of this Suggested Solutions is reserved by the Institute of Certified Management
Accountants of Sri Lanka (CMA Sri Lanka) and Suggested Solutions neither in whole nor in part may
be reproduced without the prior written approval from the Institute. The purpose of the suggested
solutions is to provide only a guidance and not to be constructed as complete answers
PART - I
Agree,
• As a sole proprietor Mr. X would be facing the challenges/difficulties in accessing/obtaining
capital.
• For a sole proprietor capital will be limited to the sources such as, owner's own funds,
retained earnings, sale of assets, borrowing from relatives and friends, loans from
commercial banks and developments banks, leasing companies, trade credit and business
credit card facilities etc.
• By registering the business as a private limited company Mr. X will be able to access many
sources of capital such as, selling a part of itself in the form of shares to investors, obtain
loans from banks, raise private equity from angel investors and venture capitalists,
crowdfunding, subsidies and grants from Government etc.
1.2. List six types of bonds, Merchant Buying can issue once converted into a private limited
company.
• Mortgage bonds
• Debentures
• Convertible bonds
• Indexed or purchasing power bonds
• Zero-coupon bonds
• Junk bonds
• Floating-rate bonds
1.3. Mr. X was advised by a friend that a private limited company can issue preferred stock
instead of long term borrowings. Compare merits and demerits of preferred stock and
long-term borrowing as a source of funds.
1.4. Issuing a bond is a low cost source of funds. However, bond rating is the main
determinant of applicable interest rate for the bond issue. Explain briefly what determine
bond rating of a bond issue.
• Credit worthiness – Lesser the likelihood to default on outstanding debt (having a high level
of creditworthiness), higher the credit rating
• Earnings stability and future performance – A company whose earnings are stable over time
and have a good financial standing may get a higher credit rating
• Coverage ratios – Higher the coverage ratio, easier to make interest payments on its debt,
and thus to get a higher credit rating
• The relative amount of debt in the company’s capital structure – Higher the financial
leverage, higher the financial risk on residual owners, and thus may not get a higher credit
rating
• The degree of subordination – Subordinated bonds have relatively lower credit ratings
(B)
1.5. Calculate value of a share
Year 0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Dividend/share 10.00 11.00 12.10 13.31 14.64 16.10 16.58
Continuing Value 165.80 16.58
CV =
(13% - 3%)
Total CF 11.00 12.10 13.31 14.64 181.90
PV at 13% 9.73 9.48 9.22 8.98 98.73
Value/share Rs. 136.14
(C)
1.7. Compare financial risk of Alpha and Beta
Alpha Beta
Total current liabilities 54,560,000 50.91% 162,000,000 21.83%
Long-term debt 100,000 0.09% 350,000,000 47.17%
Other long-term liabilities 500,000 0.47% 30,000,000 4.04%
Total long-term Liabilities 600,000 0.56% 380,000,000 51.21%
Shareholder’s equity 52,000,000 48.53% 200,000,000 26.95%
Total liabilities and equity 107,160,000 100.00% 742,000,000 100.00%
Earnings before interest and tax 12,000,000 100% 90,000,000 100%
Interest expenses 4,000,000 33% 50,000,000 56%
Profit before Tax 8,000,000 67% 40,000,000 44%
Income Tax 2,000,000 17% 10,000,000 11%
Net Profit 6,000,000 50% 30,000,000 33%
• Financial risk refers to the additional variability of earnings per share and the increased
probability of insolvency that arises when a firm uses fixed cost sources of funds, such as debt
and preferred stock in its capital structure. Use of financial leverage increases the financial risk
of a firm.
• In this scenario, both companies are in the same industry, in the same tax bracket and neither
of them is a financial organization.
• Beta has been able to generate a larger EBIT compared to Alpha, which is approximately 7.5
times the EBIT of Alpha.
• As per the financial structure above, Alpha has not employed much long-term financing
(0.56%) compared to Beta (51.21%).
• On the other hand, 50.91% and 21.83% of assets in Alpha and Beta respectively are financed
from current liabilities.
• As a result, Total Liabilities/ Equity ratio of Alpha is 1.06, whereas that of Beta is 2.71. It is
almost 2.5 times of that of Alpha’s Total Liabilities/ Equity ratio.
• With higher financial leverage, financial risk of Beta is higher than that of Alpha. Beta’s EPS is
negatively affected from this.
• Although financial leverage arising from debt component is low in Alpha, its accounts payables
is almost 90% of its total liabilities. In addition, there is a Rs.4 Million interest expense for
Alpha which accounts for 1/3 of EBIT and can have an adverse effect of the EPS of Alpha.
• This interest expense of Rs. 4 million is incomparable with its long-term liabilities of
Rs.600,000/-. Therefore, this expense could be related to accounts payables and other current
liabilities.
1.8. Can Alpha benchmark capital structure of Beta? Justify your answer.
• Beta has employed a debt burden of 51.21% in its financial structure. With its current
liabilities, the total liabilities accounts to be 73.05% of total assets.
• When compared with the financial structure of Alpha whose total liabilities account for
51.47% of total assets, financial leverage and financial risk of Beta is higher than that of
Alpha.
• By considering NI/EBIT, it is observed that Alpha has been able to manage its expenses than
Beta, except for the interest cost.
• Since Alpha’s long-term liabilities are very low and current liabilities are very high, Alpha
can obtain long-term debt and settle current liabilities to an acceptable level.
• Alpha can increase leverage to restructure its total liabilities however not up to the level of
Beta.
• Therefore, Alpha should not benchmark Beta.
1.9. Suggest how Alpha can enhance Return on Equity (ROE) by restructuring the capital
structure of Alpha.
(D)
1.10. Company A acquired Company B by paying Rs. 25 million cash which was invested in
money market account generating 10% return. Calculate immediate post-merger
EPS.
1.11. If one share of A for two shares of B was offered instead of cash, calculate immediate
post-merger EPS
13,500,000
Immediate post-merger EPS =
1,200,000
Immediate post-merger EPS = Rs. 11. 25
PART - II
(A)
2.1 Discuss the similarities of two approaches, the Product life cycle approach and the
Boston Consulting Group’s (BCG) matrix which are used to analyze current status of a
product..
• The basic product life cycle model shows how sales change as a company develops over time,
whereas, BCG matrix provides a framework for analyzing products according to market
share and market growth rate.
• The similarities of two approaches are as follows;
– The question mark represents the launch stage.
– Growth is the star.
– The maturity stage is used as a cash cow.
– Low-growth, low-marker share dog is described as the declining stage.
• Providing financial information and advice for internal and external users -
This involves preparing statutory financial accounts and providing management
information for decision making, planning and control.
2.3 Discuss briefly main financial decisions taken by a financial manager of a company.
(B)
2.4 Comment, if the applicable yield is 12%, should this bond be traded at a discount or
premium?
Since 12% p.a. yield is greater than the annual coupon rate of 10%, the bond should trade at a
discount.
2.5 Advise, if the bond is trading in the market for Rs. 1100 and applicable yield rate is 8%
, whether you recommend to purchase this bond?
1 - (1 + 8%)-5 1,000
Value0 = 100 × ( )+ = Rs.1,079.85
8% (1 + 8%)5
Since the market price of the bond (Rs. 1,100) is greater than the value (Rs. 1,079.85), it is
overpriced. Therefore, it is not recommended to buy the bond.
2.6 Discuss whether you agree with the statement “A short-term bond has lower
reinvestment risk and interest rate risk”.? Justify your answer.
• The risk to which investors are exposed due to changing interest rates is called the interest
rate risk. The interest rate required on a bond is influenced by the length of time to maturity.
• A short-term bond has less interest rate risk as compared to a long-term bond.
• Reinvestment rate risk is the risk that income will decline when the funds received from
maturing a short-term bond are reinvested.
• On the other hand, this is the possibility that a bond holder/investor will not be able to
reinvest cash flows (e.g. coupon payments) at a rate comparable to their current rate of
return.
• Therefore, a short-term bond exposes the investor to more reinvestment risk.
D0 5
ks = = = 12.50%
P 40
D0 5
ke = = = 13.89%
P(1 - F) 40(1 - 10%)
Dps 4
kps = = = 7.41%
P(1 - F) 60(1 - 10%)
**Alternative answer
Cost of the project = (ke × We ) + (kps × Wps ) + (kd (1 - t) × Wd )
Capital Component Proportion (W) Cost (AT) Cost (AT) × W
(B)
3.3 Calculate Degree of financial leverage, Degree of operating leverage, and Degree of
combined leverage.
% change in EPS
DCL = = DFL × DOL = 3.13
% change in Sales
• When sales increases by 33.33%, variable operating costs also increases by the same
percentage, however fixed variable costs remain same.
• Therefore, EBIT increases by a greater percentage (57.14%) resulting a DOL of 1.7142. This
implies that when sales changes by 1%, EBIT changes by 1.7142%.
• Although sales increases by 33.33%, interest cost and preference dividends do not change.
Tax rate is also the same (25%).
• Therefore, EPS increases by a greater percentage (104.33%) resulting a DFL of 1.826. This
implies that when EBIT changes by 1%, EPS changes by 1.826%.
• The combined result is a DOL of 3.13. This implies that when sales changes by 1%, EPS
changes by 3.13%.
3.5 If capital structure consists 30% debt amounting Rs 3 million, and cost of equity is 12%,
calculate market value of the firm assuming all available income distribute as dividend.
(Assume company operates at Rs 6 million sales level)
3.6 If the company payout all debt in capital structure, what would be the market value of
the firm if Modigliani and Mille theory holds true. (Assume company operates at Rs. 6
million sales level)
Rs.
Present earnings 200,000
Fair return on net tangible assets (1,000,000 × 15%) (150,000)
Super Profits 50,000
Goodwill (50,000 × 3) 150,000
Value of ABC (1,000,000 + 150,000) 1,150,000
4.2 Calculate value of XYZ using Accounting Rate of Return (ARR) method assuming, the
post-acquisition earnings of XYZ after considering synergetic effect is expected to be
Rs. 2.5 million and the expected yield after tax is at 15%.
4.3 Compute synergy of merger using your answer for questions 4.1 and 4.2 above if XYZ
Ltd has no intangible assets.
Rs.
Post-acquisition value of XYZ 16,666,666.67
Value of XYZ (13,000,000.00)
Value of ABC (1,150,000.00)
Synergy 2,516,666.67
A merger is a combination of two or more companies in which one or more companies cease to
exist legally and the surviving company continues in operation under its original name An
acquisition is the terminology used to describe a business combination. When two companies
combine generally the acquiring company pays for the acquired business and the acquired
company’s assets and liabilities are transferred to the acquiring company.
4.5 Describe two defensive tactics you can use to mitigate this situation, if a large company
has made a hostile takeover bid over Paragon Ltd.
Pre-emptive defenses;
These are generally instituted through the Articles of Association or the Memorandum of
Association of a company/before a company is "in play".
Reactive defenses;
These are defenses which a takeover target can institute during an acquisition/after the company
is "in play".
4.6 Identify pre-emptive defensive tactics could have used by Paragon Ltd to discourage
any takeover attempt.
(A)
5.1 Explain briefly the Transaction exposure? Giving an example from the above scenario.
• Transaction exposure is the risk involved in possible exchange losses or gains on existing
foreign currency-denominated transactions.
• In other words, it is the sensitivity of the value of foreign currency denominated transactions
to exchange rate fluctuations.
• This may result in varying levels of LKR paid by the company for other raw materials imported
from USA.
• In addition, it may result in varying levels of export income in LKR (after converting USD
received to LKR).
E.g. Current exchange rate of USD 1 = LKR 181 may change over time.
If LKR depreciates from LKR 181/USD to LKR 185/USD, there will be;
- An adverse impact on the value of USD denominated imports
- A favourable impact on the value of USD denominated exports
5.2 Recommend a best suitable derivative to hedge the foreign exchange rate risk of
Malsha International? Justify your answer.
5.3 Advise whether you recommend to Malsha International to enter into a forward
contract to mitigate risk of foreign exchange income with appropriate justification , if
a bank has agreed to forward contract to buy USD at Rs 185 after one year and inflation
rates in Sri Lanka and USA expected to be 5% and 7% respectively.
• The relationship between expected spot rates and inflation can be drawn through
Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) as follows.
Future value of quote currency
Forward Exchange Rate = Spot Price × ( )
Future value of base currency
(1+rq )n
Forward Exchange Rate = S ×
(1+rb )n
(1+5%)1
Forward Exchange Rate = 181 ×
(1+7%)1
Forward Exchange Rate = LKR 177.62/USD
• To accommodate the differences in the inflation rates between the two countries, USD
should be depreciated by 1.87%. [(1.05/1.07)-1].
• However, the forward rate of USD exhibits an appreciation by 2.21% [(185 – 181)/181].
• Malsha International is exposed to a net inflow of USD 60,000 per month (100,000 –
40,000), i.e. it is a net exporter.
• Therefore, it is beneficial for Malsha International to go for the forward hedge with A Bank
at LKR 185/USD as it would increase the net inflow in terms of LKR.
Net Inflow without Forward = USD 60,000 × 177.62 = LKR 10,657,200
Net Inflow with Forward = USD 60,000 × 185 = LKR 11,100,000
(B)
5.4 Calculate Net Present Value (NPV) of the project using “Foreign currency approach”.
LKR 25,000,000
Initial investment (INR) = = INR 9,842,519.69
2.54
Year 0 1 2 3
Since the NPV of the project converted to LKR is positive, it is recommended to undertake this
project.
5.6 Explain economic exposure with an example from the above scenario.
• Economic exposure is the change in the value of foreign operations due to unanticipated
fluctuations in the economic conditions.
• In other words, it is the sensitivity of the firm’s cash flows to exchange rate movements.
• If INR depreciates against LKR (or LKR appreciates against INR) in the future, this would
represent an economic exposure for the SL company. As a result, NPV from the project in
India for the SL company will be adversely affected.