Masika Kketaneal

21/21
a eesnenilalhersa

Anauwen
taedueien
he view Ratalkerien ia aenitualy immdral
Haa seeeived llepperlin The recent
Lehloasphheal Ltenaluure 2hie easay wi
Asgue lalalsnlieniaaenitualy inmenal
epeplpeaailly in rare easeo, and that tian
VKesamemeralealegeny ae kiling an
ianoleneadulThurman heing Vhisesasy will
nellesplene thetasuialny centain kand
Caae audk ae alerlitn befone inplantalion on
Lalentien when the lle oa worran io
hneatened ly a pregnaxay tn alerlion afen

Pre oheitera and antzabortioniata

The leginning of hia argumeny ke eyplaina
the typieäl arguniena fen prs-ekoilen and
anialontioniao touveven, he ahouse that lotR
aideasheuw weakntaa and ane hand
utalenlieniataaeem te helieve thatz
Otuth.efHeisoee yailally Centaina te
ewicse
ELample ie ie preaenlzrem Uhemonenl
lceneeplicn n Ulalseuaeo leck ke balieat
Uiaeluaea poooeaaa eharaeleriaieaueh ao
ageietecede Thatio heth neeesaary and
auloierilen bheing kuman
CHeatalliohing any theae laimaia
a ienlleakew kavabenlien ia menally
a emusder
Pre-oheioersoeem tlelieve that
ke tauth rfituaetacko tHe
ejialence
fealureo
eLoay fen menlal
ampl euaea ane nelpenacna or Hal
elusta ahe nelnaldenal agenla on Thaleluaea
Asenelaelial leinga
eatalliahing ary eTheae aime is
aunientleskeuw TKat an alonlion ia nota
whenadulklings.

NRatawneng with kLling?

i ia wnongy o
Ve develep ân allownb o whg
kLue we Lan alaakhem UKe aaawnyplktn
Tlatk:ling uaerulalizea The tnewhe kille,
utlia eiplanatien deeanelesplain why ilio
wneng le kilLkermlakeprimany reaatn
eDng iawrtng ia elauae ibinala rte
The gneaealpiaaille leaaea en he viet%
Lwokiathe Leoa o allthe ezpenientes,
anlrlie prcjeoaanderjeymenta whcek
stuld cersuise have cernaliluled The vieima
alne pnocnalle TKentam killed,tam
depnived ewkaltnow value and.wkatA
weuld. cerme le values and Thia ia wkabmakeo
kng wneng hiauudimenlany keeny he
wrergneaa killing ia evaluated by
Leatalliohingwhioknalarak prepenlg
ullimalel eplaina ke wnongneas ohe
kLling given Uiall ie wreng Hene ia no
shernalunalprspenly ialprovidea beuen
a

esplanaten, Then
klng ia wnong he looo o
tevictmafulure ia wkalmakea killy
ntng Andlpeeple wtKAAAL en eaneer whe
kneus They are dying helieve Rat dging isa
veny had hing fon hem. he view tiatkling
iowrengwkertakes away he value of a
Reaena fulune ia inlonpailLle witk KEview
Ratk:ng snly leingawhe ae liolegilall
Rarman Kaagnealmeralweni.
|Claim e leos t treio fulire
he lim lat tle lesa ef enea fuliune ia he
wrengrnakingealune oenea eing kLled
entalatlepeooiliLiy Tialaeme animala de
have hesamerighule life ae kuman lbeinga
e-auah additional oaclontwiLU le offerd in
Thia eaeay
he olaim Clat the leaa o tneia fulaune io
whalmakea k;lling wnery doeo not entail that
AQee euhanaaia iewnong Peraona whe ane
aeverelyand ineurally il wke face a future
pain and deapai and whowisk todwill
iethaveauenedalese i ey ane
eled hEHeony o The irengneaa of klling
defendedix Uhho
whengneaa e
eaday atceuwrtafor he
kiLling insanta and young
Leh:ldnen diseetly, ndskaree etrenglho of.
helaanCulgolie and penacrhooa alloiunla
wéakresses tf both h e
whle aetidng
Phuanywnenymaky e a e o a kLlig ia
The losaTe The vicimo he value of ilo
alune Vhie neana hal abenlien ia prina
 Lanieaenieualy merally wneng hia
angurment doeanetnel en thëinvalid
inenenoe Tatlecauaéiiiawreng to k0
pseene ili alaeuwnerg Te klLpeteniak
penatnaheangumenbprsleeda
independeny c henetion epenaen e
eeeaialperon trany eguialenti hia ani
aserienAngmertcan be llminated and
deesey enmpaing illeKe besl angmenb
Thewnengneas Thewartlen infliaten of
ain en aninala Hio anguneniaaaurmea ti
Vke iniioien ef pain Casoeo ouening wkcok
makea tleiniotion ofpainen aimale wreng
lngumenoehant
Re angumenlfen he wrengnesa o Ke
wanlen in ton epain on animala okareo a
e alsudlanalëalunee wiTK THe angwment
en heaerisua ina. awognt0a
alueriiern. Betkangunnento losk fon the
ekaraetrialia on The Cenaequenee o The
wwrg.aclen whick makeothe aetbn
wntrighis angwmentfon The wrsngnesa of
alstnliern in ema oa anuelurally aimla
angumerten The wnongneaa of Thi warton
 inctione eain ta asirnalaauaceda only
tHe aeletnegaadinganimala iothecoriedt
Lacdeui hanth acesunb iaawed benauae
THereianeseastn fer aadepling Thsa olaim
Kata angunmenin Uhe wnegnaa.o
initingpain ei animalo'eoo on d olaim
tHatia dermorotrally faloe heretore, the
aeratveanalsaiesheuld be acepled. ke
walue eauluneiketuo anwmenbaha
That alerlien io pima faeie wrong, ut kal
eculd leualaiedenly y Kemoallmpelling
eastrohehelere, áhentione wll le rare
indeed uwnleoa iey oLlur atearly in
egan
aeiduat
CHatafeliua i notyet defonitely an

Zhe valueefafuluelikeroura allountdoea

rethave teealomplete aelewnif the
wsergrtaae kling. keaoenTto
aeale a eny prëawmplhtn Uat Ke eiLLig a
aenicualywreng
Maengneaa e alerlitn ie a Conaequente
w é arunta e TKe wrengneaa of klling
esiat enetaaedn theaet thatipéople válue
theeyperientetf leving and wiak fer t t
alsengl4deaise le-Cenlinuele live he deaise
acune Tleetila.ey kLling ia a nival
aeu The ethile e blg Thatweula
pacvideUe baaiansejealkng ie an
aenliern peailienHedeaineactounlmal
aceideaneLaaay Cendikon fen THe
wnengeee e killing.ne pretilem will te
deaine ao0eio tRatue regard l aa
akitualywneng le klpenseona whe have
Ltle deaineteeve, ne deaise e live, tn a
deaine nettelive hevabuerepa-hwrane
utune aeLeuninendero alandandmonaliy
elligllein Theae taea e deoine
a 0 u n i e medifieaae iav i doea nobprovride
a neaeaoany cidien ler The wrongneaa td
elinga i eCempatle with THefuliune-tke

ulne deaisea kave nunalferte, Ren one

edn al an aniralerlien etka even d Ke
alsaernee eavalue oafulunelikeoua
aLleun tewever, iajuais2alion iano
neanly aa adeguate asThe value o a huma
alane jualigealisnke diatetliiualisn
a0eu.e/ Hewrengneoa e blling oeemaja
aintellig:lle as the value ef a fuine-lke
eute a00eun, uldoea netjal an anti
anerien paailien2he diacenanuahen aLLeun
nusaseere the value o e esperience that
1ay he dialenlinued and ke value e a
lneclike ture aotuni usairefen tothe
aue TRe eatlenafulane esperientea anad
prcieola 4lac 2keaynmelny fadea wken we
gedne en te tone penied.tf Tke value ef the
etperience el, whiLK Ka nsnal
enaeguen0ka Tepalterafulure ia
intolenalle we wantr aconto make t
w.erngte k:Ltlepatient
hediseminuatien alleunto the value tf a
human ualase ia eirae and oän be dioeanded
uit tfedalentinuatien aeteuntef whcck tio
apaal
disiling TReatspeefle value ofa fliune
argumnl
atennative gereral aceounta o the
w.engneoa blling ane ether nadeguate on
wnaualeaalin getng around the ant
alsenlisn Coraegueneee oe value of a
utne-likeroure angwient adiffehert
 aategy inveleea. limling The atape of he
value autune anguwrteni hia aenyptte
Li e azalontier angumerfailo beeause
aeearnligsiiee etuaafilurne can be
alualletetventdoea ntaeem lobe
valualle titat hmemenit allenpled
a4silde
Teeleyia elaima
Soedey olaimo thatetusea.lask the
Ctrleatualeapaetto deoine to continue t
Live and enelone abenlicn Cannotbe
enieuelprina falie wrengoeley agued
Tialindieidualaekave aprima faeieright t
whal They deaise, lllThie angwnenlfaila.ne
mightdepend 2erlegia basie elain thata
e aanetapprkhera corlenued le ao a
ene y anguing Thala etua ia lTenally
inajealleeoarng alboubon Taking an inlenea«t
aenneltlirgEack member e a a y
laimaaeema open lo oljecliorna, belau
peraese whe-have leen indoelinalea, dnugged,
errenderedenperarily wnleralioua may be
enallintapalleo/ Canig aloulaonethin
THaliein thein
 inteneei
PaulBaoaenia angumen
Paulaaaen haaangued UKalan embngo canne
ea viotnlecauee itlaakaaeniente He
olaima Tatplarlaand he penmanenly
wnecnaditua are alive, luii cannet le
iolamaZKe pacllem will kia angumenbia
attletkplanta and The penmanenuy
ntnalitua laskwkatBaaaen calla
ercapea" on "afulune life like euna. Hence,
Chey casuetle vtetmabasotn'a defenae okio
esampleo de nelauepenthia own view againa
the tReaie e thia eaaay Baoaenia view aema
plauaille besauae pahadignnatia caseaof
nagining acmetne aa a vietim involve
empathz whch seguireamentation of the
vielas Baaaena argumerthaturietingalisn
Agneaenpalhy ia aulieetto
aulhon
Lurenkaplea Tn ejanyple, i an

Aegandea kio wenk aa unworiy o aurwival,

empathy4 witk The villin eonleinig The lrsa io
leanl impeooillelBaoaena Weais iata
pereei Can be viomigead even iuey ane
inoapalle e meniatien ioaulgeot t
ecunlenesanyples lesauae He laaieinluilion
alisendena Baaaena vieu plauoillejo
tiaaing in e aullcnia lase

Cenelueien_
his eaa4y anguea Kat the cerreetetho o
Tewnengnead oy kling Can e estended
Latal le and saedteskew thalany abenlhen
tnal inpenniaoilile Houweven, he etkila
ekLlingin hia eoaay deea notentail that
Cenlaaneplitn io alas aeritrualy imonal
Candidateoera aulieciof kanm by
Cnsaneelen fallixte feir 0ategoniea aome
4pen ame ivu a apenm and an ovrwmn
Togelke and aeme cvwm andaome4penm
aepanalelg.Onemigh allenypTloavvid The
eneilene e l e loaa e afulune-lkeroura
Angumenby inaialing iauConlhaleplion
digaiveabeth theopenm and uie euw
lkeoura
eparaiely efa valualle fuiure
Heuwesen Tia allennalive doeonotyield a

aetnalouliecief hasm hia eaaay anguea

Tkalabolken io wntng becauae lelinaes
paalsa aprepernly Kalmakea kllig an