Oreoluwa Aiyegbusi

PHIL145- Philosophy Through Film

10 Clues to Unlocking "Mulholland Dr."

Statement of the Issue

"Mulholland Dr." is a complex and ambiguous film by director David Lynch, which has been the subject of
much interpretation and analysis since its release in 2001. One issue that arises in attempting to unlock the
film's meaning is the challenge of understanding its nonlinear narrative structure, which features dreamlike
sequences and multiple plot threads that may or may not be connected. The film"10 Clues to Unlocking
'Mulholland Dr.'" aims to provide a roadmap for viewers to navigate the film's labyrinthine plot and themes.
The issue at hand is how to make sense of the film's various clues and symbols, which may be interpreted in
multiple ways, and to arrive at a coherent understanding of the story's underlying meaning. The article offers
ten key clues to consider, each of which provides a piece of the puzzle in deciphering the film's enigmatic
narrative. Mulholland Drive is all about the “Hollywood Dream” that is sold to aspiring actors and filmmakers.
But on a deeper lever, the film is about the pressure we feel to live a life that is not our own.

Explanation of 10 Clues to Unlocking "Mulholland Dr."

The article "10 Clues to Unlocking 'Mulholland Dr.'" does not explicitly delve into philosophical arguments,
but it touches upon several themes and ideas that have philosophical implications.

One philosophical argument that can be inferred from the article is the idea that reality is subjective and can
be shaped by individual perception and experience. The film's nonlinear narrative and dreamlike sequences
suggest that the story is not meant to be interpreted literally, but rather as a representation of the
characters' inner thoughts, desires, and fears. This idea is in line with the philosophy of phenomenology,
which posits that reality is a product of our consciousness and that our perception of the world is subjective.

Another philosophical theme in the article is the notion of identity and the self. The film's main character,
Betty/Diane, is shown to be struggling with her own sense of identity and self-worth, which is reflected in the
fractured narrative structure of the film. This theme touches upon questions of personal identity, the nature
of the self, and the role of memory in shaping our sense of self.

Additionally, the article discusses the idea of duality and the presence of opposing forces within the film's
narrative. This theme is reminiscent of the ancient philosophy of yin and yang, which posits that opposing
forces can coexist and complement each other. The article suggests that the film's contrasting elements, such
as light and darkness, reality and illusion, and love and betrayal, are all part of a larger whole and contribute
to the film's overall meaning.

Overall, while the article does not offer explicit philosophical arguments, it touches upon several themes and
ideas that have philosophical implications and can be interpreted through a philosophical lens.
Philosophical Content of 10 Clues to Unlocking “Mulholland Dr.”

The film "Mulholland Dr." contains several philosophical themes and ideas, which the article "10 Clues to
Unlocking 'Mulholland Dr.'" attempts to uncover and explain. Some of the philosophical content of the film
includes:

Reality and Perception: The film explores the idea that reality is subjective and can be shaped by individual
perception and experience. The article suggests that the film's nonlinear narrative and dreamlike sequences
represent the characters' inner thoughts, desires, and fears, rather than a straightforward depiction of
events.

Identity and the Self: The film's main character, Betty/Diane, is shown to be struggling with her own sense of
identity and self-worth. The article suggests that this theme touches upon questions of personal identity, the
nature of the self, and the role of memory in shaping our sense of self.

Dualism and Duality: The film presents contrasting elements, such as light and darkness, reality and illusion,
and love and betrayal. The article suggests that these opposing forces contribute to the film's overall
meaning and can be interpreted through the lens of the philosophy of yin and yang.

Existentialism: The film presents a sense of existential crisis and dread, particularly in the character of Diane,
who is shown to be grappling with feelings of guilt, shame, and despair. The article suggests that this theme
touches upon the existentialist idea that life is inherently meaningless, and that individuals must create their
own meaning and purpose.

The Nature of Art: The film's themes of illusion, reality, and perception touch upon questions about the
nature of art and its relationship to truth. The article suggests that the film challenges the viewer's
perception of what is real and what is not, and that it invites a deeper contemplation of the role of art in
shaping our understanding of the world.

Overall, the philosophical content of "Mulholland Dr." is complex and multifaceted, and the film invites
multiple interpretations and readings. The article "10 Clues to Unlocking 'Mulholland Dr.'" attempts to
provide a framework for understanding the film's philosophical themes and ideas, but ultimately, it is up to
the viewer to engage with the film's content and draw their own conclusions.

Philosophical Analysis of 10 Clues to Unlocking "Mulholland Dr."

The film "Mulholland Dr." contains several philosophical themes and ideas that invite interpretation and
contemplation. In this response, I will explain the philosophical content of the film, as explored in the
article "10 Clues to Unlocking 'Mulholland Dr.'" in greater detail.

One key philosophical theme in "Mulholland Dr." is the idea of reality and perception. The film explores
the idea that reality is subjective and can be shaped by individual perception and experience.

The article "10 Clues to Unlocking 'Mulholland Dr.'" suggests that the film's nonlinear narrative and
dreamlike sequences represent the characters' inner thoughts, desires, and fears, rather than a
straightforward depiction of events. This suggests that the film is not concerned with pre senting an
objective reality, but rather with exploring the subjective experiences of the characters. The film also
presents the idea that perception can be distorted or manipulated. This can be seen in the way that the
film presents both the idealized, glamorous version of Hollywood and the corrupt, seedy underbelly of
the entertainment industry. The article suggests that this contrast highlights the way in which
perception can be manipulated to create an illusion of reality. The film's use of dualism and duality also
contributes to its exploration of reality and perception. The contrasting elements of light and dark,
reality and illusion, and love and betrayal work together to create a multifaceted, ambiguous portrayal
of reality. Furthermore, the film suggests that memory plays a significant role in shaping our perception
of reality. The character of Diane is shown to be grappling with her own memories and how they shape
her understanding of the world. This touches upon questions of personal identity and t he role of
memory in shaping our sense of self. Overall, the film's exploration of reality and perception contributes
to its philosophical content by highlighting the subjective nature of reality and the role that perception
and memory play in shaping our understanding of the world. The film invites the viewer to question
their own perceptions and to consider the ways in which their experiences and memories shape their
understanding of reality.

Another key philosophical theme in "Mulholland Dr." is the idea of dualism and duality. The film
presents several opposing forces, such as light and darkness, reality and illusion, and love and betrayal,
which contribute to the film's overall meaning and can be interpreted through the lens of the
philosophy of yin and yang. Dualism is a philosophical idea that suggests that reality can be divided into
two opposing forces or principles. In the case of "Mulholland Dr.," this can be seen in the way that the
film presents contrasting elements, such as the bright, sunny landscapes of Hollywood and the dark,
shadowy world of Diane's apartment. The film also presents the idea of a dual identity, with Betty and
Diane representing opposite sides of the same person. Duality is another related philosophical concept
that suggests that opposing forces can coexist and complement each other. In "Mulholland Dr.," this can
be seen in the way that the film presents seemingly contradictory elements that work together to create
a coherent whole. For example, the film presents both the glamorous, idealized version of Hollywood
and the seedy, corrupt underbelly of the entertainment industry. The article "10 Clues to Unlocking
'Mulholland Dr.'" suggests that the film's use of dualism and duality contributes to the film's overall
meaning by highlighting the complexity and ambiguity of the world. The film presents a multifaceted,
contradictory portrayal of Hollywood and the human psyche, which suggests that reality is not a simple
binary of good and evil, but rather a complex interplay of opposing forces. Furthermore, the film's use of
dualism and duality also touches upon the idea of balance and harmony. The philosophy of yin and yang
suggests that opposing forces can coexist and complement each other to create a harmonious whole. In
the case of "Mulholland Dr.," the film suggests that the contrasting elements of light and dark, reality
and illusion, and love and betrayal work together to create a unified, meaningful whole. Overall, the
film's use of dualism and duality contributes to its philosophical content by highlighting the complexity
and ambiguity of reality, and by suggesting that opposing forces can coexist and complement each other
to create a harmonious whole.

The third philosophical theme I will be discussing in “Mulholland Dr. “is existentialism. Existentialism is a
philosophical movement that emphasizes individual freedom and choice, the inherent meaninglessness
of life, and the importance of creating one's own meaning and purpose. The film explores existential
themes through the character of Diane, who is shown to be struggling with feelings of guilt, shame, and
despair. The article "10 Clues to Unlocking 'Mulholland Dr.'" suggests that this narrative structure serves
to convey Diane's internal state of mind, rather than a straightforward depiction of events. Diane is
shown to be grappling with the consequences of her choices and actions, and the film suggests that she
is unable to find a way out of her despair. One of the central ideas of existentialism is the concept of
authenticity, which refers to the idea that individuals must live in accordance with their own values and
beliefs, rather than conforming to societal norms and expectations. The film suggests that Diane is
unable to live an authentic life, as she is constantly struggling to reconcile her desires with the demands
of others. For example, Diane's relationship with Camilla, who is shown to be a successful actress and
the object of Diane's affection, is fraught with power imbalances and unfulfilled desires. Diane's inability
to express her feelings for Camilla leads to feelings of guilt and shame, which ultimately contribute to
her existential crisis. Another important aspect of existentialism is the idea that life is inherently
meaningless, and that individuals must create their own meaning and purpose. The film suggests that
Diane is unable to find a sense of meaning in her life, as she is consumed by feelings of regret and
despair. The film's surreal imagery and dreamlike sequences serve to underscore the absurdity and
meaninglessness of Diane's existence. Overall, the film's existential themes suggest that individuals must
confront the inherent meaninglessness of life and create their own meaning and purpose. Diane's story
serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of living an inauthentic life and the consequences of failing
to create one's own sense of meaning and purpose.

Finally, the film includes an exploration of the nature of art and its relationship to truth. The film
challenges the viewer's perception of what is real and what is not, and it invites a deeper contemplation
of the role of art in shaping our understanding of the world. Throughout the film, there are several
instances where characters are shown to be engaging in acts of deception or illusion-making, such as the
use of prosthetics to create a false appearance, or the creation of a theatrical performance that blurs
the line between reality and fantasy. These instances of illusion raise questions about the nature of art
and its relationship to truth. Is art a reflection of reality, or is it something that creates its own reality? Is
there such a thing as objective truth, or is truth always subject to interpretation and manipulation? The
film also raises questions about the power of art to shape our perception of reality. The character of
Betty, for example, is shown to be influenced by the Hollywood glamour and mythology that surrounds
her, which shapes her understanding of the world and her place in it. The film suggests that art has the
power to create its own reality, and that this reality can be just as convincing and influential as the world
we perceive with our senses. Overall, the film's exploration of the nature of art invites the viewer to
question their assumptions about reality and truth, and to consider the ways in which art shapes our
understanding of the world. The film suggests that art has the power to create and manipulate illusions,
and that these illusions can have a profound impact on our perception of reality. By challenging our
understanding of truth and illusion, the film encourages us to engage in a deeper contemplation of the
nature of art and its relationship to our perception of the world.

Works Cited

Ebert, Roger. "10 Clues to Unlocking 'Mulholland Dr.'" RogerEbert.com, Ebert Digital LLC, 28 Oct. 2001,
https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/great-movie-mulholland-dr-2001.

Lynch, David, “10 Clues to Unlocking “Mulholland Dr.”, davidlynch.com, 2001

http://www.davidlynch.com/mulholland-drive.html.

Nordine, Michael. "10 Clues to Unlocking 'Mulholland Dr.'" IndieWire, 22 Sept. 2017,
https://www.indiewire.com/2017/09/mulholland-drive-explained-david-lynch-clues-1201871907/.
Word Count

2,239