Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 3

1

Case study – Africa’s natural implicated in cyanide spills and human


rights violations.
resources: the example of
Ghana Ghana remains a very poor country.
Although the numbers living in poverty
Ghana is a resource-rich economy, but have diminished to just under a third of
the government faces challenges of the population, progress in poverty
sustainable and inclusive growth. reduction has been disappointingly
slow in rural areas (IMF, 2009). Ghana
Ghana has long been blessed with gold ranks a lowly 152 out of 182 countries
reserves, valuable and relatively easy to in the UN’s human development index
mine in comparison with the metal (UNDP, 2009). With gold prices now
found in other gold-rich African rising, the Ghanaian parliament voted
countries, such as South Africa. And to raise the royalties from 3% to 5% in
Ghana has been fortunate: although 2010. However, the companies have
mines in other countries have become resisted stoutly. They argued that their
dangerous or unproductive, it agreements were sacrosanct, incapable
registered a 10% increase in production of being overridden by new law (Burgis,
in 2008. The price of gold surged 2010). They also said that future
following the financial crisis of 2008, as investments which are being planned
investors sought safe havens. Ghana’s would be jeopardized if the
mining companies have benefited, and government altered their terms.
so has the country, but the government Ghana’s government is well aware that
is now looking at whether the country its reputation with foreign investors
is getting a fair return. President John could be dented if it imposed more
Atta Mills was elected in 2008, marking onerous terms, and the country
the second peaceful transfer of power depends on gold for 40% of its exports.
in the country, an example that stands But it is also aware that environmental
out in Africa’s turbulent political scene. damage, particularly from cyanide
The new government is now looking at spills, have been an issue for
how best to exploit further gains for communities, leaving the perception
the country while continuing to that mining companies take the profits
encourage foreign investors. with minimal accountability to
communities. In a report of 2009, the
Ghana introduced incentives to attract IMF found Ghana to have ‘weak
foreign mining companies to invest in institutional capacities for
1986. environmental management’ (IMF,
Mining companies have invested $6.7 2009).
billion in the country since 1994. Seven
companies altogether made $2.1 billion The government’s resolve is facing
in revenues, $146 million of which another challenge in that oil discoveries
(about 7%) went to the Ghanaian state, off its coast in 2007 look set to usher in
mainly through royalties and taxes. an oil boom. The Jubilee field is
Mining multinationals, Newmont of the forecast to pump 120,000 barrels of oil
US and South Africa’s AngloGold per day from 2010 onwards. Oil
Ashanti, have led the investment in earnings could eclipse those of gold and
Ghana’s goldmines, but both have been cocoa, its other primary natural
2

resource. The government is firm that and development expertise needed


the oil investments must take into over the long term? How can the
account benefits to all sectors of the benefits for Ghana as a country be
economy. The world’s large oil maximized? Ghana’s president said,
companies have eyed the prospects in ‘We must make sure oil and gas
Ghana, which look inviting in become a blessing. We must get
comparison to the resource nationalism competent people to manage the
evident in countries such as Russia and resources, to account for the resources
Venezuela. Tullow Oil of the UK, which and we must use them to build a
acquired three exploration licences stronger economy and invest in our
from the government, has been people (Wallis, 2009). Ghana’s
successful in its oil explorations in a president remained reluctant to allow
number of offshore sites. It has worked the deal with ExxonMobil to go
with other specialist foreign companies through. In August, 2010, the
in the field, including Kosmos Energy of agreement Kosmos had signed with
Texas. ExxonMobil came forward in late ExxonMobil was ended.
2009, agreeing to buy the stake held by
Kosmos in Ghana’s oil fields. However, Sources: Burgis, T. (2009) ‘Gold-diggers
Ghana’s government initially blocked boost production to help meet world
the bid by ExxonMobil, and was said to demand’, Financial Times, 4 December;
favour a deal with CNOOC, the Chinese Hoyos, C. (2009) ‘Ghana moves to block
state-owned oil company. Exxon bid for stake in Jubilee field’,
Financial Times, 13 October; Burgis, T.
US President Barack Obama, on a visit (2010) ‘Mining money fails to usher in
to Ghana in 2009, praised the country golden era for Ghana’, Financial Times,
for its governance, but warned that the 23 March; Wallis, W. (2009) ‘Finds put
oil issue could detract from its success Ghanaians on a roller coaster of
(Hoyos, 2009). Ghana’s oil seemed to expectations’, Financial Times, 4
be a prize dangling between an December; The Economist (2010)
established superpower and an aspiring ‘Carats and sticks’, 3 April; IMF (2009)
one: the strategic interests of both Ghana: Poverty Reduction Strategy
were at stake. Ghana’s government had Report (Washington, D.C.: IMF); UN
many factors to consider. Which (2009) Human Development Index, as
potential investors had the technology www.undp.org

2016 update:
Production of oil in the Jubilee field total of $3 billion in 2012, displacing
started to come on stream in 2011. cocoa as the country’s second-most
Tullow Oil has enjoyed success in valuable export (Ghana is the world’s
exploiting the Jubilee oil field, and has second-biggest producer of cocoa.)
embarked on developing other oil Ghana’s president, John Atta Mills, died
fields. One of these developments, tragically in July, 2012, just months
known as TEN, involves the co- before elections were due to take
operation of Kosmos, Tullow and place. The vice president, John Dramani
Anadarko Petroleum Corporation of the Mahama, took over as president, and
US. Exports of oil from Ghana reached a then won the presidential election that
3

was held in December, 2012. His win poverty in rural areas and in the north
was a narrow one, and was contested of the country. The economic growth
by the opposition candidate, through generated by the extractive industries
demands for recounts and recourse to have benefited urban areas, but this
the courts. After months of uncertainty, prosperity has not spread to the very
Mr Mahama was eventually confirmed poor rural areas where subsistence
as the legitimate winner. On his farming is prevalent. Economic growth
election, Mr Mahama committed has also brought growing income
himself to tackling Ghana’s extreme inequality. Ghana is no longer classified
poverty. To a significant extent, Ghana as a country with low human
can claim success in poverty reduction: development. In 2015, it was classified
the country met the MDG of reducing in the category of medium human
extreme poverty by half by 2015. development, but remained a lowly 140
However, there are big discrepancies out of 188 countries overall ranked in
across the country, with persistent the UN’s human development index.

Questions for discussion:


• Why are natural resources in Ghana, as in other African countries, considered a
curse as well as a blessing?
• What is the role of foreign oil companies in exploiting Africa’s resources, and
how is it changing?
• If you are an executive in a foreign oil company operating in Ghana, what
would you do to mitigate the accusations of resource exploitation?
• What advice would you give to Ghana’s government in deciding which foreign
investors to welcome and on what terms?

You might also like