Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Markets Be Identified, Their Magnitudes Estimated, and The Existing and Poten
Markets Be Identified, Their Magnitudes Estimated, and The Existing and Poten
Markets Be Identified, Their Magnitudes Estimated, and The Existing and Poten
1-4 MANUFACTURING
The definition of manufacturing as the making of goods and articles reveals little
about the complexity of the problem. A more specific definition is given by
CAM-I (Computer Aided Manufacturing International, Arlington, TX): "A
series of interrelated activities and operations involving design, materials selec-
tion, planning, production, quality assurance, management, and marketing of
discrete consumer and durable goods." This recognizes that, from the simple
beginnings when an artisan provided all the necessary mental and physical input,
manufacturing has grown to become a system with many components that
interact in a dynamic manner.
FIGURE 1-7
Manufacturing entails a large variety of activities, many of which have become specialities on
their own. More properly, manufacturing is regarded as a system with interdependent activi-
ties. Interaction can be strengthened by the use of the computer, leading to computer-
integrated manufacturing (CIM).
acceptable way. This often calls for ease of disassembly or separation by some
mechanical or chemical means.
f Most importantly, all the above criteria must be satisfied while also
ensuring ease of manufacture. This requires not only close cooperation between
industrial, mechanical, and electrical designers and manufacturing specialists, but
also demands that all designers should be aware of the manufacturing conse-
quences of their decisions. Seemingly minor changes may often present (or
remove) enormous manufacturing problems, thus affecting the cost, quality, and
reliability of the product.
g An important consideration is the number of units to be produced, in one
production run (batch size) and over the projected life of the product, because
this will enter into process choice.
h The performance of products can often be ensured only by product
research and development activities. These activities are essential when a company
desires to secure a competitive position by introducing new products or impro-
ving established product lines.
A comprehensive treatment of the many facets of design is given by Dieter.*
3 Once a product is designed, production drawings (or computer data bases)
are prepared of the assembly and of all parts other than standardized, mass-pro-
duced components. Decisions can then be made on what parts should be bought
from outside suppliers and what parts should be produced in-house. A bill of
materials is prepared which, in many ways, is central to the manufacturing
process.
4 For components produced in-house, process design is carried out: The best
process is selected and process parameters are chosen to optimize the quality and
properties of the finished product. Dies are designed, tooling is chosen, and, if the
tool must follow a prescribed path, this path is selected and programmed.
Fixtures are designed to hold the workpiece in the correct position in relation to
the machine tool or to hold several workpieces in the correct position relative to
each other. Jigs perform a similar function but also incorporate guides for the
tool. Activities in this group are often described in the narrower sense as
manufacturing engineering. For components produced by a vendor, these func-
tions are usually performed by the vendor, ideally in cooperation with the
purchaser. Again, process design is not an isolated activity. For example, it must
facilitate inspection for quality control.
5 The choice of the appropriate manufacturing technique and its optimiza-
tion are important functions. A strong competitive position also requires that
new processes be developed and old ones improved through process research and
development. New processes often make it possible to develop new products, thus
further increasing competitiveness. Process development on the production scale
can be very expensive. Therefore, the fundamentals of processes are often
explored in the laboratory. Models of a process can be used to explore the
* Engineering Design: A Materials and Processing Approach. McGraw-Hill. New York, 1983.
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION TO MANUFACTURING 15
functions:
1 All phases of product design can take place on a computer, with the design
displayed on a VDT (video-display terminal), most often a CRT (cathode-ray
tube). With the aid of geometric modeling and analysis, the designer can explore a
number of options and analyze them with the aid of software packages (including
those for finite-element analysis, FEM). Design can be optimized in a much
shorter time, rapid design changes become possible, and changing consumer
demands can be satisfied. Both assemblies and parts can be designed with
assurance that they will properly fit together. A library of standard components
can be built up. The bill of material is also generated and, if required, drawings
can be prepared by driving a pen under the commands of the computer. Thus,
activities indicated in blocks 2 and 3 of Fig. 1-7 are performed in what has
become known as CAD (computer-aided design).
2 Computers can be used for programming the machine-tool motions neces-
sary for generating the geometric shape of the part. Beginning with the 1950s,
information contained in drawings could be transformed into digital form for the
numerical control (NC) of machines. When the part geometry is created by CAD,
the data base already exists and can be directly employed in NC. Exchange of the
graphic data base between various systems is still a problem but standard formats
are being developed.* Beginning with the 1970s, the computer has been used also
for process optimization and control, materials management, material movement
(including transfer lines, robots, etc.), scheduling, monitoring, etc. This entire
field is now generally called CAM (computer-aided manufacturing)', it encom-
passes blocks 4, 5, 6, and 7 in Fig. 1-7.
3 The benefits of CAD and CAM can be fully realized only if an effective
interface is established between them, creating what is usually referred to as
CAD/CAM. Information flow in both directions ensures that parts and assem-
blies will be designed with the capabilities and limitations of materials and
manufacturing processes in mind. Superior products can be created and
tremendous competitive advantages attained. A company that uses integrated
CAD/CAM can develop new products more rapidly and at a lower cost, thus
increasing its market share at a time when product life cycles are declining and
efforts required to develop new products are increasing; it can be more respon-
sive to customer requests both in providing quotations and in accommodating
special needs; it can reduce the effort spent on design and process changes by
ensuring that such changes are entered in the common data base and are thus
immediately recognized at all stages of design and production. An important
benefit is that the introduction of CAD/CAM forces a review and improvement
of existing design and manufacturing practices and production planning.
4 The critical tasks of inventory management are also facilitated by the
computer. Material requirements planning (MRP) is based on the master produc-
*For example, IGES, "Initial Graphics Exchange Specification," American National Standards
Institute ANSI Y14.26M.
18 INTRODUCTION T O M A N U F A C T U R I N G PROCESSES
tion schedule, the bill of materials, and inventory records relating to raw
materials, purchased components, parts to be delivered, in-process materials and
parts, finished products, and tools and maintenance supplies. With this informa-
tion as the input, MRP manages the inventories with due regard to the timing of
material requirements. In detail, it provides notices for releasing orders, schedul-
ing and rescheduling, cancellation, inventory status, performance reports, devia-
tions from schedules, etc. A good MRP system results in reduced lead times,
minimum inventory, faster response to customer requests, and increased produc-
tivity. A further development is manufacturing resource planning (also called
MRP-II or closed-loop MRP) which integrates a complete manufacturing control
system. Production planning, master scheduling, capacity requirements planning,
and functions necessary for executing the production plan (including vendor
schedules and dispatch lists) are incorporated, and provisions are made for
continuous updating.
5 The management aspects of manufacturing lend themselves to computeriza-
tion even without CAM, and are often regarded as elements of a management
information system (MIS). More recently, MIS is taken to stand for manufacturing
information system.
6 Most recently, manufacturing has come to be treated as a single system
comprising hardware and software (as in Fig. 1-7) in which the complex interac-
tions are followed with the aid of the computer. In such computer-integrated
manufacturing (CIM) all actions take place with reference to a common data
base. Data base management is a complex but not insurmountable task. Draw-
ings serve only to visualize the geometry of parts; no changes are allowed to be
made on them. If changes in design, process, scheduling, bill of materials, quality
standard, etc. are to be made, they are made in the data base; thus they reflect
throughout the organization. The data base is continuously updated by most
recent information on production, sales, etc. For many industries, total CIM is
still in the future, but beginnings have been made.
One of the major remaining tasks is modeling of the manufacturing process.
Many of the most successful processes are largely based on experience and
intuition, and formalization of knowledge in a form useful for computer control
will take considerable time. A significant development is the modeling of the
entire manufacturing process by the IDEF methodology. It was developed by
SofTech, Inc. (Waltham, MA) under the sponsorship of the U.S. Air Force in the
Integrated Computer Aided Manufacturing (ICAM) program. IDEF stands for
ICAM Definition System, and incorporates a model of the manufacturing system
in a hierarchical form, using a graphical representation in which the manufactur-
ing functions are shown (together with the inputs, mechanisms, controls, and
outputs) by the gradual expansion of diagrams into lower level diagrams. An
exposition of the approach is given by Harrington in Understanding the Manufac-
turing Process.
In the forseeable future, much of manufacturing will still be conducted under
human control, and it is important to recognize that linking a process to a
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION TO MANUFACTURING 19
Data input
,Workpiece
Digital (part program)
readout
Toolpost
eft)/ Controller
/ Dial
WUL wm • f / M
Cross slide 1
Ballscrew
A"
Drive
(a)
Data input Main
MCU Input data and
(part program) motor
constraint
parameters for
Tool Adaptive adaptive control
changer control unit
Controller (MCU)
Vibration, force,
etc., transducer
W / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / / A W777W/.
\
i
Position tmm/mm w/m//<
transducer
(c) (c0
FIGURE 1-8
All manufacturing processes must be controlled. The example is for cutting on a lathe, under
(a) manual, (b) open-loop, (c) closed-loop, and (d) adaptive control. Adaptive control takes
actions in a manner a highly skilled machinist would.
(speed, feed, support of the part or tool) until the undesirable condition disap-
pears. The operator will also compensate for tool wear, change the tool when
needed, and will make sure that the machine tool is not overloaded.
A control system will take over several or all of the functions of the operator.
2 In open-loop control an action is taken without verifying the results of this
action. Actuators may be mechanical (cam, lever, linkage), electromechanical (dc
or ac motor, stepping motor), or hydraulic or pneumatic (motor or cylinder). For
example, the cross slide of the lathe may be moved by a cam, stepping motor, or
hydraulic cylinder to a predetermined position. The setting will be repeated for
each part, but it still takes an operator or setup person to confirm that the part is
within tolerance and, if not, to reset the cam, mechanical stop, microswitch, or
change the program instruction (Fig. 1-86).
3 In closed-loop control, sensors provide feedback to the system. In the
simplest case, a high-resolution position transducer is added to confirm that the
intended position of the cross slide has indeed been reached (Fig. l-8c). The
signal from the transducer is processed by a comparator that compares it with the
control signal and then issues an error signal to correct the position. In other
applications, the control would maintain a speed or other parameter at a set level
(as mentioned, the oldest example of closed-loop control is a purely mechanical
device, the centrifugal governor invented by Watt in 1788 for maintaining a
preset speed on a steam engine, irrespective of the load imposed on it). A simple
closed-loop control system is ignorant of possible secondary inputs to the system
and will go on producing parts even with a worn or broken tool or under
conditions of chatter.
4 Adaptive control is the highest level of control which, in its fullest develop-
ment, can replace the operator entirely. Sensors are used to provide feedback of
secondary inputs (in the case of the lathe, in-process measuring devices check the
diameter of the part, load cells measure forces, vibration transducers give signals
characteristic of the existing cutting conditions, etc.). The feedback signal is then
processed so that the control unit can take appropriate corrective action (Fig.
1-8d). Obviously, the corrective action will accomplish its intended purpose only
if the effect of process variables on the finished part are known. Interrelations
between process variables can be extremely complex, and full adaptive control
can be successful only if a sufficiently quantitative model of the process can be
formulated. Even if a simple model is used, the constraints of the process or
system (maximum force, speed, etc.) must be obeyed (adaptive control with
constraints, ACC). A more complex model allows optimization (adaptive control
with optimization, ACO), for example, for maximum production rate.
5 The power of the computer can be used to endow the control with some
measure of artificial intelligence (AI). As the name implies, the control program is
designed to solve a problem the way humans solve it; it is capable of some
reasoning, can learn from experience, and, ultimately, can do some self-program-
ming. Alternatively or additionally, elements of expert programs may be incor-
porated in the control system.
22 INTRODUCTION T O M A N U F A C T U R I N G PROCESSES
Automation The word automatic is derived from the Greek and means
self-moving or self-thinking. The word automation was coined to indicate a form
of manufacturing in which production, movement, and inspection are performed
or controlled by self-operating machines without human intervention. In general,
one may distinguish between several levels of automation. Here we will make a
distinction between:
1 Mechanization. This means that something is done or operated by machin-
ery and not by hand. Feedback is not provided; thus, one deals with open-loop
control. An example would be the use of a cam to move the cross slide in Fig.
2 Automation. This will imply closed-loop control and, in its advanced form,
adaptive control. Automation utilizes programmable devices, the flexibility of
which can be quite different:
a Hard automation refers to methods of control that require considerable
effort to reprogram for different parts or operations. For example, a limit switch
could be manually reset if a cylinder of different diameter had to be machined.
b Soft or flexible automation implies ease of reprogramming, usually simply
by changing the software.
An important aspect of automation in manufacturing is automation of material
movement. We shall come back to this topic in Sec. 11-1; however, we have to
give here some brief definitions: Manipulators are mechanical devices for the
movement of materials, tools, and parts, and robots are programmable manipula-
tors.
CAD data
base Blueprint Blueprint
_ Stock
Plant control, etc.
computer
Manaqement
information
Work Part-
monitoring program
Reporting schedule
Minicomputer
NC machine tool
(a) (6)
FIGURE 1-10
M a n y N C m a c h i n e s , w i t h s t r u c t u r e s s i m i l a r t o t h o s e s h o w n in Fig. 1 - 8 , a r e n o w c o n t r o l l e d b y
( a ) a d e d i c a t e d m i c r o c o m p u t e r ( C N C ) o r ( b ) by a h i e r a r c h y of c o m p u t e r s ( D N C ) .
introduced by the tape reader since the tape is read only once; it also reduces
overhead relative to NC.
3 In direct numerical control (DNC) several machine tools are connected to
one larger, central computer which stores all programs and issues the NC
commands to all machines (Fig. 1-10b). No machine tool must ever wait for an
instruction; therefore, there are often satellite control computers interposed
between the central computer and smaller groups of NC units, and the central
computer is used only to store, download, edit, and monitor programs, and to
provide supervisory and management functions. Such hierarchical control breaks
down even very complex tasks into manageable elements. The task of real-time
computation and sensory processing is allocated to the first-level computers. The
NC units may be of the conventional hard-wired type, with the tape reader
replaced by a direct communication line to the central computer (behind-the-
tape-reader systems), or specialized units which, like CNC units, use a minicom-
puter as the MCU. Obviously, the latter allow much greater flexibility.
CHAPTER 1: I N T R O D U C T I O N TO M A N U F A C T U R I N G 2 5
*A. Conan Doyle, Adventure of the Fire Orange Pips. Crown Publishers, New York, 1976.