Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CT Storage Corrosion - October 2002 - 3011055 - 01
CT Storage Corrosion - October 2002 - 3011055 - 01
User Manual
October 2002
This information is CONFIDENTIAL and must not be copied in whole or in any part, and should be
filed accordingly by the addressee. It must not be shown to or discussed with anyone outside the
SCHLUMBERGER organization.
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 2 of 28
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 3 of 28
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 4 of 28
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 5 of 28
1 Introduction
Corrosion of coiled tubing (CT) pipe is one of the main reasons for taking the CT pipe
out of service. Coiled tubing strings are often retired prematurely when corrosion
problems are evident or anticipated, leading to a less than optimum usage of assets.
Additionally, corrosion-related pipe failures sometimes occur during coiled tubing
operations (see Figure 1). These failures are costly and have a significant impact on
the safety and reliability of coiled tubing operations. Pipe corrosion cannot be
completely eliminated due to the nature of CT operations and pipe materials used, but
it can be reduced to an acceptable level.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 6 of 28
Example:
This example provides only a rough estimate of the system cost and benefits, based
on the average, company-wide usage of CT strings. Each CT district can determine
the cost and benefits of the system more accurately, based on the actual usage of CT
strings at the district.
Current CT Conditions:
• In a CT district, 5 CT strings were retired (taken out of service) during the last
12 months. Out of these 5 strings, 3 strings were retired due to pipe storage
corrosion problems (for instance, pipe leak, pitting, suspected corrosion
damage, etc.) and the rest were retired for other reasons.
• The average maximum used CoilLife for the 3 strings retired due to storage
corrosion problems was 60% [for example: (50% + 70% + 60%)/3 = 60%].
Thus, for the 3 strings retired due to storage corrosion, the average lost CT life
is 40% per CT string.
• For all 5 strings retired during the last 12 months, the average pipe life lost due
to storage corrosion is 3/5 x 40% = 24% per CT string. It is necessary to
calculate the average lost CT life for all strings because the recommended
corrosion mitigation system needs to be applied to all CT strings.
Cost of the System:
• In this example, the cost of the recommended corrosion prevention system per
single application (per CT job/operation) is based on the purchase price of new
CT string. For an average CT string (80 kpsi grade material, 0.125-inch wall
thickness), the cost of the system per CT job/operation, excluding the
application time and effort, is about 0.4% of the purchase price of new CT
string. For thicker tubing walls and higher strength (more expensive) CT
materials this percentage is lower - around 0.3%. For thinner tubing walls and
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 7 of 28
lower strength (less expensive) CT materials the system price per CT job is
about 0.5% of the CT string purchase price. The effects of tubing length and
outside diameter on the system cost per application are approximately the
same as the effects they have on the cost of new pipe.
• Assuming that an average CT string is used on 30 jobs/operations during its
lifetime, the average cost of the proposed system per string lifetime is about
12% of the purchase price of new CT string (0.4% x 30).
Benefits of the System:
• In this example, the system cost is significantly lower than the cost associated
with the 24% pipe life loss due to storage corrosion. Assuming that the entire
24% pipe life loss due to corrosion can be prevented with the proposed system,
the benefit of pipe cost savings is about 12% of the new CT string price.
• The additional cost of pipe corrosion problems or failures can be lost revenue,
as well as the cost of downtime, pipe fishing, logistics, damage to the client, lost
client confidence, weakened Schlumberger image, etc. This additional cost
also can be reduced with the proposed system and should be considered when
estimating the total cost and benefits of the proposed storage corrosion
mitigation system.
Caution:
Keep in mind that in cases when significant pipe corrosion can occur during the job,
such as when a CT string is used extensively for acid treatments or in severe H2S or
CO2 environments, the proposed storage corrosion mitigation system may not ensure
the full 100% of string service life as predicted by the CoilLIFE software.
The following are some of the main reasons to use the recommended CT storage
corrosion mitigation system:
• Improved safety and reliability of CT operation (reduced number of pipe failures)
• Increased profit (extended pipe life)
• Improved image and client confidence, leading to increased usage of CT assets
• Reduced downtime
• Reduced environmental damage
• Reduced well contamination
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 8 of 28
The following are possible reasons not to use the recommended CT storage corrosion
mitigation system:
• There are no significant pipe corrosion problems or corrosion-related pipe failures
in the district, so the cost of the system would exceed the benefits it provides
• It takes extra time to implement and there is not enough client understanding or
support
This section describes how corrosion damage can occur during CT operations. A
more detailed technical description of CT corrosion mechanisms is presented in the
subsequent section.
3.1.1 General
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 9 of 28
The presence of more than one type of fluid or physical factor can increase the overall
effect of corrosion. An example is the presence of dissolved oxygen in brines, which
increases the overall metal loss. Other factors that can affect CT corrosion are the pH,
temperature and pressure of the fluid that comes in contact with the tubing. A low pH
(pH < 7) accelerates corrosion. In general, higher temperature will lead to accelerated
corrosion as will higher pressure in the case of CO2 and H2S corrosion. In the case of
atmospheric corrosion, higher humidity and dew point will lead to more corrosion
damage. In addition to the environmental factors noted above, the condition of the
coiled tubing itself can affect its susceptibility to corrosion. Three factors to consider
are discussed below.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 10 of 28
Tubing scratches and other surface defects are often caused by the injector head
blocks, the stripper, or drag in the well. The tubing that has scratches or other defects
on its surface is more susceptible to pitting corrosion attack than undamaged tubing.
Butt welds are far more susceptible to corrosion than the rest of the tubing due to the
heat-affected zone created during the butt welding process and the impossibility of
applying any rectifying heat treatment afterwards. Butt welds must be continuously
inspected. In general, butt-welded strings should not be used for regular acid work.
Best practice is to cut out tubing and re-weld it after an inspection shows any
developing corrosion.
There are various forms of corrosive attacks on metal surfaces. However, only a few
types of corrosion attacks occur during CT storage periods. The different forms of
corrosion typically experienced in coiled tubing during storage are discussed in the
following sections.
Uniform corrosion occurs when the corrosion attack proceeds uniformly and the loss of
material is even (see Figure 2). The tubing becomes thinner. This is often
experienced in CT service when the treating systems are well inhibited and the
corrosion rates are reduced to their minimum.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 11 of 28
Pitting is an “autocatalytic process,” that is, once a pit has started, it accelerates its
own growth. Pits can be isolated or so close together that they give the impression of
a rough surface. It is difficult to detect pitting on the inside of the CT string since pits
can reliably be detected only by visual inspection or microscopic analysis. Pitting
causes only a very small weight loss, meaning tubing string weight is an unreliable
indicator. Some new magnetic-flux inspection methods for the inside of the CT tubing
have been proposed, but often fail to detect pits as well. Because it is difficult to
detect and can result in destruction of an entire string of tubing due to a few tiny holes,
pitting is one of the most critical types of corrosion to address with the procedures in
this document.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 12 of 28
and rapid metal dissolution is taking place within the pit while oxygen reduction occurs
on adjacent surfaces near the pit. The rapid dissolution of the metal inside the pit
produces an excess of positive charges (M+) in this area resulting in the migration
(attraction) of the negatively charged ions (Cl-) to maintain electrical neutrality within the
pit. This high concentration of both ions encourages the hydrolysis reaction (M+Cl- +
H2O = MOH + H+Cl-) and as a consequence of this hydrolysis, the concentration of H+
rises inside the pit. Both Cl- and H+ ions stimulate the further dissolution of metal. This
is why pitting is self-perpetuating. Since the solubility of oxygen is virtually zero in the
concentrated solution within the pit, no oxygen reduction occurs inside it.
Solution
Metal
Cl-
M+
A pit is started because for some reason the rate of metal dissolution is momentarily
high at one particular spot. Chloride ions migrate to this spot, stimulate more metal
dissolution, and a pit begins. A particular spot can be susceptible to pit initiation due
to a scratch, local defect, random variation in metallurgy, or in the concentration of the
electrolyte. In fact, newborn pits are very unstable and many do not develop
significantly. Within a colony of pits, some are very small and never reach the
autocatalytic phase.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 13 of 28
Crevice corrosion is a type of localized corrosion that occurs in crevices or areas that
are shielded from fluid flow (see Figure 5). The process of crevice corrosion is
identical to the growth of a pit. Some examples of an environment where crevice
corrosion can occur are:
• At the metal contact points between tubing wraps on the reel (Figure 5);
• At the contact point between the tarp and the tubing, when the tarp that is used to
cover the reel touches the tubing;
• In CT logging strings, at contact points between the cable and the inside surface
of tubing if moisture is left inside the tubing.
Crevice corrosion attack is associated with small, stagnant volumes of corrosive fluid
caused by geometry traps, flanges, etc. Contact between metal and non-metallic
surfaces can also cause crevice corrosion as in the case of gasket. The corrosion
takes place in the area where the metal and gasket are in contact.
Initially, the oxygen reduction reaction takes place, but later the oxygen within the
crevice is depleted and oxygen reduction stops. After the oxygen is depleted within
the crevice, the dissolution of metal continues. This creates an excess of positive
charges within the crevice, and forces chloride ions to migrate into the crevice. The
large concentration of chloride ions creates a situation identical to that at the bottom of
a pit, corrosion is accelerated, and pH in the crevice drops to as low as 2 or 3. Like
the process of pitting, the increased corrosion in the crevice increases oxygen
reduction on adjacent areas. This cathodically protects the neighboring external
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 14 of 28
surfaces. As a result, the stagnant areas in the crevice are corroded while the
exposed external areas suffer no attack.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 15 of 28
T-sub installed below. The stripper rubber will also help to clean dirt or fluid off the
CT pipe surface.
2. Apply the OD corrosion inhibitor - Use the OD inhibitor applicator to apply
external CT corrosion inhibitor A265 to the OD surface of the tubing.
3. Cover the reel - Keep the reel away from rain and other corrosive elements (for
example, cover the reel). If the inhibitor was applied during rainy conditions or if it
rained before the reel was covered, it is recommended that the OD inhibitor
application be repeated as soon as possible.
The above summaries and Figure 6 give a brief overview of the requirements to
protect the internal and external surfaces of a coiled tubing string from storage
corrosion. The following sections give more detailed information on procedures to
effectively implement each step.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 16 of 28
COVER CT
(use tarp or other
cover)
INHIBIT
(pump ID inhibitor
between pigs)
PLUG CT ENDS
(seal CT ends to isolate
ID surface)
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 17 of 28
NOTE
Follow all safety standards for pressure pumping, CT operations, nitrogen pumping,
chemicals handling and disposal, etc. when using the proposed system. Any waste
resulting from spills or otherwise contaminated product should be treated as
industrial waste and disposed of in accordance with applicable state or federal
regulations.
Only the specified inhibitors should be used, because other inhibitors may provide
less protection from (or even cause) pitting corrosion.
In cases when significant pipe corrosion can occur during the job, such as when a
CT string is used extensively for acid treatments or in severe H 2S or CO2
environments, or when there is significant pre-existing pipe corrosion damage, this
storage corrosion mitigation system may not ensure the full 100% of string service
life as predicted by the CoilLIFE software.
Fresh water should be used to flush the tubing. However, if this is not possible,
seawater or 2 wt% KCl brine can be used. If nitrogen is not available on location to
displace the contents of the tubing immediately after the job, apply the full protection
procedure described above as soon as possible after returning to the base.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 18 of 28
any oxide or deposit that is present, and the oxide or deposits will prevent the inhibitor
from effectively reaching the metal surface. Cleaning procedures for the inside surface
of coiled tubing can be chemical or mechanical.
NOTE
Typically, no rust will be present internally following acid treatments. The acid itself
acts as an effective cleaning agent.
A dilute acid solution (5% HCl) can be used to chemically clean the ID of the string.
This acid bath can be limited to a few barrels only. Like any other acid pumped, this
acid has to be inhibited. Following chemical cleaning with acid, the neutralization step
must be carried out, just as if an acid job had been performed.
One mechanical cleaning option, if the tubing ID is known to have some rust, is the
Hippo Turbine ID cleaner from Hamdeen. This cleaner is superior to wipe darts and
foam plugs for mechanically cleaning the internal walls. Following treatment with the
Hippo Turbine, a dilute acid chemical cleaning as described in the previous section
could still be undertaken. The Hippo Turbine is illustrated in Figure 7.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 19 of 28
Pump a volume of fresh water equal to about one half to one full string volume to flush
the string. Fresh water should be used to displace the tubing content and flush the
tubing. However, if this is not possible, seawater or 2% KCl can be used.
There are three types of neutralizing agents which can be used to neutralize acids
either during the acid operation, as an after-acid flush, or by pumping during the flow-
back phase. All these neutralizers work by raising the pH of the fluid in the tubing and
thereby reducing the potential for corrosion. Depending on the alkaline substance
used, these neutralizing baths have different ability to raise pH. As a guideline, sodium
bicarbonate (baking soda, J464) has a pH of 8.5, sodium carbonate (soda ash, M3)
has a pH of 10.5, and sodium hydroxide (caustic soda, M2) has a pH of 14 and is
more hazardous to handle.
The base fluid can be fresh water or 2 wt% KCl brine. Obviously, if pumping the
neutralizer downhole, the use of KCl water is preferred to avoid any formation damage
if some product is lost to the formation. From the strictly corrosion prevention
standpoint, fresh water is the best base fluid for the neutralizer. Using a neutralizer that
has a pH of about 9 to 11 is the best practice. The pH of the neutralizing solution can
be adjusted by the amount and type of neutralizer used. To increase the pH, add more
neutralizer to the water or use a more powerful product such as sodium hydroxide,
Na(OH).
CAUTION
Sodium hydroxide (M2) is more dangerous to handle and also generates more heat
(via an exothermic reaction) as the acid is consumed by the alkali.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 20 of 28
The pH of the neutralizing fluid should not be too high. As the CT string is left exposed
to the environment it will attract and react with acids in the atmosphere in an attempt to
neutralize (especially in an industrial area). This process can load the metal surface
with ions and increase corrosion. So, as mentioned before, the recommendation is to
leave the entire metal surface neutral, with a pH as close to 7 as possible.
The inhibitor to be used for ID protection is internal CT corrosion inhibitor A266. The
ID inhibitor is mixed with water, and for subfreezing temperatures propylene glycol is
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 21 of 28
added to the solution. The total amount of ID inhibition solution to be pumped can be
determined by:
where CT OD is the outside diameter of coiled tubing. When propylene glycol is used,
it should be first mixed with water and then the ID inhibitor should be added to the
solution. The volume fraction of each component in the total ID inhibition solution is
given in Table 2. The inhibition solution should be mixed thoroughly before placing into
the tubing. Because increasing the fraction of propylene glycol in the total inhibitor
solution will result in gradually reducing the effectiveness of ID inhibitor, propylene
glycol should be used only when absolutely necessary and as specified in Table 2.
When the ambient temperature is below -13ºF (-25ºC), no internal corrosion inhibition
should be applied to coiled tubing. However, if following such a CT job without ID
inhibition the ambient temperature during CT storage rises above 14ºF (-10ºC), the ID
inhibition should be applied to coiled tubing when this temperature increase occurs.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 22 of 28
Pump ID
ID Inhibitor Tank inhibitor inside
CT
Pump
Hose
NOTE
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 23 of 28
There is no need to displace water or other fluids, such as brines or neutralizer, left in
the tubing form previous treatments before applying ID inhibition, unless the ID
surface needs to be cleaned.
For use in wired strings (CTL), do not cut a groove on the pig body to clear the cable.
The pig will deform enough to pass by the cable.
The entire OD surface needs to be covered with the OD inhibitor all the way around
and along the CT pipe. For this purpose, the applicator shown in Figure 11 should be
used. The applicator connects to the CT depth encoder mounted on the levelwind.
The OD inhibitor applicator is supplied with or without a tank and fittings from Hydra
Rig (see the Appendix for ordering information). The inhibitor is pushed from the tank
through the oiler by compressed air supplied from the CT unit. Dripping of the product
may still occur with this model, but this can be controlled by a drip pan.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 24 of 28
Protection from rain should be provided after the inhibitor film has been applied to
avoid it washing away. If the inhibitor was applied in rainy conditions or if it rained
before a proper cover was provided for the reel, the inhibitor was most likely washed
away. In this case, re-application is the best practice.
Issues with A265 usage/registration in Norway have made it difficult to use. Therefore,
it is recommended that A266 be used for both ID and OD corrosion protection which
does not require PR in Norway as it is not classified as hazardous.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 25 of 28
A266 will provide same level of corrosion protection as A265 when used for OD
application when used concurrently with a reel cover.
NOTE
The valve at the inhibitor tank needs to be adjusted manually to regulate the
inhibitor flow and achieve a full OD coverage with the inhibitor. The amount of
inhibitor that needs to be supplied to the CT pipe through the oiler will increase with
increased CT size (OD) and speed.
To avoid using the ID inhibitor for OD protection or the OD inhibitor for ID protection,
it is recommended that the OD and ID inhibitor application tanks have the same
labels (or other permanent codes) as the corresponding inhibitor containers that are
used to fill the application tanks.
For medium- to long-term storage, the OD of the pipe may need to be re-coated.
The tubing should be spooled off and a new inhibitor coat applied.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 26 of 28
NOTE
Do not allow the reel cover to come in direct contact with the CT string , because it
may trap moisture and generate crevice corrosion at the contact points.
During extended storage, verify status every couple of months and reapply the OD
inhibition if necessary.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 27 of 28
External and internal CT corrosion inhibitors, A265 and A266 respectively, should be
ordered through Schlumberger like any other Schlumberger chemical products.
RX3 foam pigs from Pipeline Pigging Products, Inc. should be used with the ID
inhibition procedures. Contact information:
Order RX3 pigs according to Table 3 below based on the tubing outside diameter and
specified wall thickness. For tapered CT strings, the minimum specified wall thickness
along the entire CT string should be used. The values in Table 3 are based on the
requirement that the pig diameter should be about 2% larger than the maximum
internal diameter of the tubing. Because the pigs cannot be manufactured to an exact
diameter, pig diameter ranges are specified.
RX3 pigs are made of polyurethane foam and their properties can degrade over
extended storage periods or if exposed to sunlight. The polyurethane foam hardens
with time, rendering the pigs less flexible and possibly reducing their effectiveness. To
avoid the deterioration of pigs, store the pigs in a closed opaque container at the room
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL
SYSTEM TO PROTECT COILED TUBING STRINGS FROM October 2002
STORAGE CORROSION
Page 28 of 28
temperature. It is recommended that RX3 pigs be used within six months from the
time of their manufacture.
0.109 0.80 – 0.85 1.05 – 1.15 1.3 – 1.4 1.55 – 1.65 1.8 – 1.9 - - -
0.125 - 1.0 – 1.1 1.25 – 1.35 1.5 – 1.6 1.75 – 1.85 2.15 – 2.25 - -
0.134 - 1.0 – 1.1 1.25 – 1.35 1.5 – 1.6 1.75 – 1.85 2.15 – 2.25 2.4 – 2.5 -
0.145 - 1.0 – 1.1 1.25 – 1.35 1.5 – 1.6 1.75 – 1.85 2.1 – 2.2 2.35 – 2.45 -
0.156 - 0.95 – 1.05 1.2 – 1.3 1.45 – 1.55 1.7 – 1.8 2.1 – 2.2 2.35 – 2.45 2.6 – 2.7
0.175 - 0.9 – 1.0 1.15 – 1.25 1.4 – 1.5 1.65 – 1.75 2.05 – 2.15 2.3 – 2.4 2.55 – 2.65
0.190 - - 1.15 – 1.25 1.4 – 1.5 1.65 – 1.75 2.0 – 2.1 2.25 – 2.35 2.5 – 2.6
0.204 - - - 1.35 – 1.45 1.6 – 1.7 2.0 – 2.1 2.25 – 2.35 2.5 – 2.6
NOTE: The pig length is automatically specified by the manufacturer and it ranges approximately from 2 times pig
diameter to 3 times pig diameter.
SCHLUMBERGER CONFIDENTIAL