Fang - A History of Mass Communication Six Information Revolutions PP Xv-Xxiii

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

What Are

Information
Revolutions?

Year by year more people are saying more present in every generation. Venturesome
over more channels on more topics to a souls have risked personal freedom, sav-
bigger total audience. The Internet is ex- ings, reputation, even life and limb to cre-
ploding. The talk in cable television is of ate and distribute information. In the
500 channels. Videotape stores sell used present generation, when technology has
tapes to clear their crowded shelves. Desk- merged the computer and other connective
top publishing pours out newsletters, self- media like cable and satellite with end-user
published books, magazines, and multi- media like books and television, opportuni-
media presentations, with no end in sight. ties have arisen that find their closest com-
New computer software arrives every day. parison in the fifteenth century, when
In free industrial nations, bookstores and printing began in Europe and the old limits
magazine stands are jammed with product. crumbled.
Libraries hardly know what to do with all
their books. It has been true for decades
that anyone can own a book. Now, in indus- Defining an Information
trial societies, almost anyone can own a Revolution
movie. Meanwhile, more movies are being The wish to remember something by writ-
shot than ever. And desktop video is bring- ing it down led over the course of millennia
ing a budget version of Hollywood to Main to the start of the first information revolu-
Street. Meanwhile, home computers ex- tion. It and the revolutions that followed
pand information use in ways only recently would shape humankind more than any
undreamed. wars or any kings ever did or could. With a
Even if it were nothing else, our Infor- few scratches, our inventive ancestors set
mation Age is the latest in a series of social in motion the never ending story of re-
revolutions that define and span recorded corded information, the communication
history. A desire to produce communica- and storage of knowledge outside the brain.
tion as well as to consume it has been Here broke history's long dawn.
XV
xvi A HISTORY OF MASS COMMUNICATION

What would constitute an information Social revolutions—those that perma-


revolution? The word revolution implies a nently affect the lives of most inhabi-
sudden and often violent change, but revo- tants—do not emanate from royal edicts.
lutions can be more subtle, evolving over They grow from disturbed soil, an open-
decades, even centuries.1 In the general ness to change, at least at some societal
parlance, revolution is an overwrought de- levels. Media join the turbulence, fastening
scription of any societal developments. means to purpose. The tools of communi-
The word long ago became a cliche. Con- cation become weapons in some hands,
sider it here in the sense of profound while in others they serve to extend hu-
changes involving new means of commu- mankind's knowledge and the richness of
nication that permanently affect entire so- intelligent life.
cieties, changes that have shaken political The social turbulence that provides the
structures and influenced economic devel- necessary basis for an information revolu-
opment, communal activity, and personal tion leads to independence of thought and
behavior. Unlike so many of our wars and the capacity for growth. Graham Greene
switching of rulers, information revolu- played a bit fast and loose with history, but
tions create changes, intended or not, that made at least a discussable point in The
stick. The new media of information be- Third Man, when his amoral character
come part of the changing society. Harry Lime said, "In Italy for 30 years
It appears evident that for an information under the Borgias they had warfare, terror,
revolution to succeed, media that will pro- murder, and bloodshed, but they produced
vide new means for communication must Michaelangelo, Leonardo da Vinci, and the
be disseminated within societies already un- Renaissance. In Switzerland they had
dergoing change. Communication technolo- brotherly love. They had 500 years of de-
giesby themselves are not enough. The media mocracy and peace. And what did they
both aid and are aided by whatever has produce? The cuckoo clock."
shaken the existing order, for those who One or more new communication tech-
seek change will reach out to grasp what- nologies arriving in the midst of social
ever means become available to gain sup- change can lead to an information revolu-
port for their opinions. This is not a new tion that adds to the turmoil and, more
idea. A Chinese of the T'ang dynasty (7th to importantly, leaves permanent marks on
10th centuries A.D.) wrote, "When customs the society. Indeed, the world is in the
change, writing changes."2 As those opinions midst of an information revolution now, a
spread, so does awareness of the media period identified with capital letters as the
themselves. From awareness comes use by Information Age, a product of the informa-
other hands. The interwoven cause and tion revolution of the second half of the
effect relationship between social change twentieth century. Yet, the second half of
and media development has continued the fifteenth century, following Guten-
since the beginnings of recorded history. berg's invention of printing, deserves as
The argument may be stated this way: if you much as our own half century to be called
build a better mousetrap, the world will not the Information Age. A strong claim as the
beat a path to your door unless the world Information Age could also be made for
can be shown that there are mice to be the second half of the nineteenth century,
caught. That has been the story of the tools following the inventions of photography
of communication, the "better mousetraps." and the telegraph, a half century that gave
They have affected much in our lives, but birth to the phonograph, telephone, type-
inventions by themselves do not change writer, motion pictures, and radio, plus
society. When people want change enough significant changes in printing and early
to take action, an invention helps. In the experiments in television and in recording
industrial nations throughout the century tape technology. Each of these communi-
that we are now completing, change has cation technologies was born in the midst
been constant and constantly desired. of the Industrial Revolution, a time of ten-
WHAT ARE INFORMATION REVOLUTIONS xvii

sion across all layers of contemporaneous with the convergence of advances in paper
society. production and printing press methods,
Of course, changes in communication and the invention of the telegraph, which
occurred during quieter periods as well, but changed the way information was con-
those identified here took a role in creating veyed. For the first time, newspapers and
a qualitative difference in society. The magazines reached out to the common
change has always led toward an equalizing man with news about events near and far,
of the status of members of society, the and packaged goods for sale. Photography
road toward democracy. That there has spoke to his heart. Public schools and pub-
never in human history been true equality lic libraries dotted the countryside and the
should not detract from an appreciation of growing cities. For the masses, literacy
genuine improvement in human affairs. came within reach.
The fourth information revolution, the
Six Information Entertainment Revolution, started in
Revolutions Europe and America toward the end of the
This book identifies six periods in Western nineteenth century with such technologies
history that fit the description of an infor- as stored sound, affordable cameras, and
mation revolution. The periods range in motion photography. Stories were printed
time from the eighth century B.C. to the and sold cheaply. Like the pots and pans
near future. coming off the assembly lines of the Indus-
The first of the six information revolu- trial Revolution, entertainment could now
tions may be characterized as the Writing be infinitely replicated and canned. In the
Revolution. It began primarily in Greece coming decades, it would be seen in the
about the eighth century B.C., with the nickelodeons and heard on the radio. The
convergence of the phonetic alphabet, an whole world would come to love the enter-
import from Phoenicia to the east, and pa- tainment products. At the start of the En-
pyrus, an import from Egypt to the south. tertainment Revolution, no one could have
With writing used to store knowledge, the imagined the number of hours that we
human mind would no longer be con- would spend entangled with this love.
strained by the limits of memory. Knowl- The fifth information revolution, the
edge would be boundless. creation of the Communication Toolshed
The second information revolution, the Home, evolved during the middle of the
Printing Revolution, began in Europe in the twentieth century, transforming the home
second half of the fifteenth century, with into the central location for receiving infor-
the convergence of paper, an import origi- mation and entertainment, thanks to the
nally from China, but proximately from the telephone, broadcasting, recording, im-
Arab and Moorish cultures, and a printing provements in print technologies, and
system that the German goldsmith Johan- cheap, universal mail services. The cen-
nes Gutenberg assembled, perhaps from a tury has, of course, been a period of unre-
variety of sources. With printing, informa- lieved political, cultural, and psychological
tion spread through many layers of society. turmoil and shifting. That the media of
Printing lent itself to massive political, re- communication have become inseparable
ligious, economic, educational, and per- from our lives is a matter that has been
sonal alterations. We have called these written about in countless worried articles,
changes the Reformation, the Renaissance, books, and research papers.
humanism, mercantilism, and the end of The sixth information revolution, the
feudalism. Printing marked the start of the Information Highway, is now being con-
modern world. structed out of the convergence of com-
The third information revolution, the puter, broadcasting, satellite, and visual
Mass Media Revolution, began in western technologies. Communication is shaking
Europe and the eastern United States dur- off transportation for work, study, and
ing the middle of the nineteenth century, play. Yet, if the information-elite can live
xviii A HISTORY OF MASS COMMUNICATION

anywhere, doubt arises about the future of more specialization of knowledge than
our cities, which grew with the centripetal previously existed. They also led to an
demands of the Industrial Revolution cou- overloading of information and to an in-
pled with sharp population increases. crease in misinformation.
If economies depend upon information, • As each information revolution has run
what does the future hold for vast areas of its course, which was based on the
the globe that are not fully plugged into the widening availability of the tools of com
information streams? What will happen to munication, content broadened. More
our interdependent world of instant com- producers sent a greater amount of infor
munication and weapons of mass destruc- mation on a greater variety of subjects
tion if these areas continue to respond with over more channels to more and more
economic stagnation, environmental de- receivers.
struction, and overpopulation? Can we af- • The spread of media production, emanat
ford to let the Information Highway bypass ing from a multiplicity of independent
any communities? thought, led to increases in what post
The pace of information revolution is modernism identifies as decentering and
speeding up. The second revolution ar- fragmentation, with a widening of the
rived 1,700 years after the first crested. The expression of points of view, frames of
last four, each quite distinct, have over- reference, experiences, and histories.
lapped during the last two centuries.3 Although by definition postmodernism
followed modernism, elements of a dis
Shared Characteristics tinctive pattern have been a charac
Each information revolution appears to teristic of every information revolution.
share certain characteristics with the others: • Each new communication technology
has displaced some other means of com
• Each is based upon the invention of more munication or behavior that had been
than one tool of communication, such as satisfactory until the new technology be
papyrus and the phonetic alphabet, paper came available. When something was
and printing, or television and satellites. gained, something of value may have
Their convergences have had powerful been lost.
effects. • All tools of communication have had one
• Each took place where change of a differ or more hardware components and at
ent sort was stirring the society and least one software component; that is,
where a social structure existed that en physical tools and methods or systems.
abled change to occur, such as those in As the tools reached more hands, both
modern Western democracies. hardware and software became more
• The tools of communication gave social complex, but they became simpler to
and political changes added dynamism manage. Their unit costs dropped and
and were themselves given a forward they were also likely to shrink and to
thrust by those other changes, a symbi transmit data faster.
otic relationship of cause and effect.4 • The need for physical transportation to
• Information revolutions tended toward send information has been reduced as
some leveling of conditions for those who communication replaced transportation
participated in them. Their results tended of messages.
to be egalitarian. They pointed toward a • The tools of communication have been
greater degree of democratization or diffused, or distributed, across most of
sharing of influence than previously ex the societies into which they were intro
isted. Where the use of the tools has been duced, or at least that portion of each
limited, both in ancient times and now, society that gave—or gives—direction to
human beings have been less free. the whole of that society; in short, the
• The changes wrought by these disper tools were in the hands of each society's
sions led toward a greater sharing and movers and shakers. In fully open de-
WHAT ARE INFORMATION REVOLUTIONS xix

mocracies, many of the tools are avail- cation and group activity. In extreme
able to those who want them. cases, a social dysfunction has resulted. •
• Changes in communication encountered Unlike political revolutions, the dates of
opposition from those who, for political social revolutions, including information
or financial reasons, disliked the changes revolutions, do not lend themselves to
taking place. Reaction was inevitable pinpointing. All the information revolu-
from those who must surrender a share tions had more or less identifiable begin-
of influence and power. They responded nings. None has truly ended.
both by using the media themselves and
by trying to control their use by others.
However, given enough time media
The Power of Information
availability has continued to spread. Communication media intrude into our
• New literacies have arisen to accommo lives more than most of us realize. They
date the new communication technolo influence our daily activities. We cannot
gies, from the phonetic alphabet of the ignore them or abandon them. When we
first information revolution to the com use them judiciously, we harness their
puter codes of the latest. With each new strength.
language has come a new class of experts At a national level they have assisted in
fully aware of the advantage emanating overthrowing governments. The tools have
from the hoarding of their knowledge. worked quite efficiently in the hands of
• As to the belief that the average citizen those who would sell us every known form
lies increasingly helpless under the heel of government from democracy to fascism,
of political and economic tyrants who communism to theocracy. From Tom
dominate the media and suppress free Paine's Common Sense pamphlets to Mao's
dom of thought, history tells the opposite little red books and the Ayatollah Khome-
story. The dissemination of the tools of ini's audiotapes, media have been used as
mass communication has increased the tools of revolution. Lenin's smuggled writ-
potential for social protest, and to that ings promoted the Bolshevik revolution
extent it has made humankind more free, and the underground samizdat of writers
not less. Their limitation has the opposite living under communism promoted its
result. end.
• Tools of communication were influenced Electronic tools have now joined the
by marketing considerations. Within the printed tools to bring added breadth to
boundaries of available technology and revolutionary fervor. Our age has also wit-
scientific possibility, communication nessed successful media use by those who
tools ultimately have become what their have no apparent ideology, no political
users wanted. agenda other than to grow rich or influen-
• The technology has changed markedly, tial.
but not people's tastes or interests. The Even if control of information does not
old wine is poured into the new bottles. always include responsibility, it does bring
• Use of communication media, their ef influence by journalists and other writers
fects multiplied by their convergence, for the popular media, whom Witold
led inevitably to the separation of their Rybczynski calls the "ragmen of informa-
users. Herein lies a dilemma. The tools tion."
have given us communication without
transportation, yet we still possess a hu While secondhand experience still depends,
man need for face-to-face contact. to a certain extent, on personal contact-
• Heavy personal use of the tools of com rumor and hearsay—the greatest single
source of most people's secondhand experi-
munication has been accompanied by ence is neither education nor conversation,
less social activity. The more time spent but the media: newspapers, magazines, film,
with mass communication, the less time radio, and television. Nowhere is the
has remained for face-to-face communi- influence of these ragmen of information
XX A HISTORY OF MASS COMMUNICATION

felt more than on the public perception of these individual toolsheds that the Infor-
technology.6 mation Highway will have its offramps.
The information will be cheaper, ena-
Highway and Village bling larger segments of the population to
ride on the Highway and dwell in commu-
Much consideration will be given in this nication toolsheds. At the turn of the cen-
book to what is called the Information tury, the cost of renting a telephone for a
Highway. To abuse an overworked meta- month represented about two weeks wages
phor, let us note that highways have direc- for an average workman. The first com-
tions, and their travelers have points of mercial television sets sold for half the cost
departure and destinations. As the tele- of a new car. Just a few decades ago the
phone companies, cable companies, and thought of self-publishing anything except
broadcasting companies pour the cement, via mimeograph was almost out of the
there are strong indications that this new question for middle-class Americans. To-
highway is not coming from the public day, even making a movie is not beyond a
library or the news office despite the pub- middle-class purse.
licity releases, as much as it is coming from
the cinema, the shopping mall, and the
video arcade. What we, the audience, want Sorting Media from Content
is oftentimes the stuff of dreams. Why do we believe what we believe? What
And where is this information highway are the sources of our opinions and atti-
going? It is not heading toward the "global tudes? Although the answers to such broad
village." Marshall McLuhan was correct in questions are complex, it is obvious that
foreseeing the technological possibility of a almost everything we know about present
"global village" in which most of human- events beyond our limited horizons comes
kind could share information.7 However, from media. In this we are different from
his metaphor of a village, where folks nor- ancestors who learned most of what they
mally communicate by talking face to face, knew through direct experience. If not
presumes that radio and television are re- from such current events media as newspa-
turning us to an oral culture; for example, pers, radio, and television, our information
"...the electric implosion now brings oral has come from books, the storehouses of
and tribal ear-culture to the literate West."8 human memory. At times our information
Yet, broadcasting although it strikes the is mediated through other people who de-
ear, has not returned us to an oral culture, rive their information from communica-
which is based upon a two-way, limited tions media and may distort it in the
scale of information on a human dimen- process.
sion. Instead, one-way radio and television, It is a highly arguable point, but in rela-
plus their content of recordings and motion tive terms of societal good, what we are
pictures, are oral versions of the limitless watching, the content, may not matter as
quantity of information that identifies a much as the way we shape our lives around
written culture that no single human being media. The medium, Marshall McLuhan
can, absorb in its totality. told us, is the message. The effects of con-
A further reality has been that only on tent are quite independent of the effects of
rare occasions, such as a lunar walk, the using the medium carrying it. For example,
Olympic Games, or the Gulf War, do we the effects on a child of watching violent
venture together into the shared space of a cartoons and junkfood commercials on a
global village. Mostly, we prefer to retreat Saturday morning are quite distinct from
into our homes, where we now spend so the effects of spending the entire Saturday
much of our time with so many communi- morning watching television, no matter
cation media that our homes can be what is on.
thought of as communication toolsheds, It has been argued that the problem with
which is another focus of this book. It is to television, a justifiable focus of irritation, is
WHAT ARE INFORMATION REVOLUTIONS xxi

that society, especially producers and edu- Shaping and Being Shaped
cators, has not fully marshaled its re- As we spend time with the tools of commu-
sources to use the television medium nication, we spend less time with one an-
wisely, or in fact to consider this medium other. Fewer Americans attend town or
the way we regard the medium of books as school meetings. Voter turnout has de-
existing for more than financial gain. Yet, clined. At the same time, distrust of govern-
a visit to the paperback racks of any drug- ment has grown. Memberships in the PTA,
store will remind us that books are not the League of Women Voters, and labor
always used as means of acquiring knowl- unions is down, while social distrust is up.
edge. It is useful to distinguish content Fewer volunteers turn out for the Boy
from the carriers of content, media. Scouts, Red Cross, Lions Club, Shriners, and
Jaycees.9 The nation has drifted from De-
Tocqueville's observation in the early nine-
Replacing Transportation teenth century that Americans liked to
Through recorded time, most communica- form civic associations. In organizations
tion depended upon transportation. Infor- whose membership has increased, like the
mation was bound by human limitations, Sierra Club, the National Organization of
the sound of a voice, the time it took a pair Women, and the American Association of
of feet, or a horse, or a ship to reach a Retired Persons, people do not normally
destination. Communication technology attend meetings.
changed that. Human limitations fell away. McLuhan observed that not only the me-
The promise of the Internet and the rest dia are shaped. As the technology is shape4
of the Information Highway is even more for and by its users, the technology shapes
replacement of transportation. Shopping the users. It shapes our lives and our views.
by electronic catalog, working and learning When enough people adopt a new means
at home via computer modem and facsimile, of communication so that people change
video teleconferencing in place of business the way they go about their daily activities,
travel, acquiring specialized education, the society itself is altered.
and receiving computer-assisted diagnostic
medical care are all reporting success. ... in operational and practical fact, the me-
If significant parts of one's work, mar- dium is the message. This is merely to say
keting, education, entertainment, and that the personal and social consequences of
well-being can be accomplished without any medium—that is, of any extension of
leaving home, will more people choose to ourselves—result from the new scale that is
live in the countryside instead of in cities introduced into our affairs by each extension
of ourselves, or by any new technology. ...
or suburbs? Will they choose San Francisco the "message" of any medium or tech-
and commute electronically to Omaha in- nology is the change of scale or pace or pat-
stead of living in Omaha? Such a pattern tern that it introduces into human affairs.10
could lead to a further decline in cities.
Population transfers resulting from For example, the ways that we use a com-
technology are not new. The Industrial puter changed because the technology
Revolution shoveled people out of the changed. Because it is more efficient than
countryside into cities. The post-World War it used to be to work on an airplane or even
II shift of middle-class families from the in a taxi weaving through traffic, people
city to the suburbs, a move encouraged by now work who once relaxed while traveling
the technologies of cars and highways, al- by reading a magazine article about some-
tered American life. A new population shift thing unrelated to their work, or staring out
based on the emerging communication of a window and thinking, or chatting with
technologies promises to shake up life as a seatmate. Now the traveler works. We
much as these earlier mass movements changed the media and then the media
did. changed us.
xxii A HISTORY OF MASS COMMUNICATION

Difficult Beginnings of the technology to that end. Before the


Many tools of communication began with turn of the century, Bell's telephone com-
quite limited ownership. For the centuries pany, formed soon after the telephone's
when books were hand produced by monks invention in 1876, had become AT&T. By
and booksellers, most people lived out their 1920, a web of telephone wires provided
lives not knowing that such a thing as a long distance service for much of the coun-
book existed, let alone ever seeing a book. try, and conducting business by telephone
For a half century after its invention, the had become a norm of American business.
still camera was a complicated piece of Some common tools of communication
equipment for the serious hobbyist and the may have begun their public existence as
professional. Even though ordinary people novelties beyond most people's under-
aspired to own photographs they did not standing of how they could possibly have
think of owning a camera. The videotape any meaning to daily life, yet as they were
recorder and the video camera were not diffused into society, the public found that
initially designed for untrained hands. Sci- meaning. Public feedback led to further
entists alone worked with the first comput- refinement, which in turn led to new uses
ers. In 1943 IBM chairman Thomas Watson by yet more people. Photography, for in-
said, "I think there is a world market for stance, had value for almost no one except
maybe five computers." hobbyists until a steady stream of improve-
Some familiar means of personal com- ments led first to a demand for family pic-
munication began as tools of government tures and later to a rush to own simple
and business, but achieved success in per- cameras that required only the push of a
sonal use. The world's postal systems, a real button. Market driven, photography flowed
communication technology, belong to this into art and journalism. It spread to printed
category. In the last quarter of the nineteenth media and, in motion pictures, photogra-
century, the typewriter, the telephone, the phy spawned a new medium of arguably
phonograph, and the radio all saw the first greater impact than its own.
light of day as aids to the world of com- As the quality of communication tools
merce. In the twentieth century, audiotape, improved and their advantages became
videotape, and the computer evolved with known, they spread throughout their po-
no idea that millions of ordinary people tential market. Their costs dropped in the
would take them into their homes. Those pattern of the so-called "calculator syn-
familiar business and government tools, the drome" that has affected the entire elec-
fax machine and the copier, are in the proc- tronics industry. Engineers also improved
ess of joining them in the home. designs to make the equipment easier to
Not all technologies showed immediate operate. The "buttons" went inside. Video
promise. The telegraph and the computer cameras and decks, once limited mostly to
went through periods of government sup- television stations and industries, meta-
port and little public acceptance. In time, morphosed into camcorders, a hot selling
they altered our world. item for the home. As a result, for a growing
New technologies found acceptance number of families, spoken words and pic-
when their superiority over existing tech- tures have replaced words written on paper.
nologies for specific uses was recognized, A letter to a distant loved one is sent in the
but diffusion required an infrastructure that form of a video. In high schools, the video
extended far beyond an invention, bringing yearbook joins the familiar bound version.
together elements of business, finance, en-
gineering, and government regulation.
Businesses and individuals adopted the tele- Life Is Different
phone because it offered an attractive alter- The success of the means of communica-
native to communication by mail and tion in becoming almost transparent to the
telegraph. Then structures grew in support user has the unintended effect of leading
WHAT ARE INFORMATION REVOLUTIONS xxiii

us to overlook their individual and collec- Recent telephone technologies like cel-
tive impact on the society. lular phones and facsimile machines have
For example, consider the percentage of affected some occupations, such as selling
our lives devoted to watching a television real estate and the lunch trade of some city
screen. The set is on in the average Ameri- restaurants. In the late 1980s and the early
can home for more than seven hours a day. 1990s, cellular and fax were hot items in
Our general sense that life is different than news stories and full page ads, so they got
it was only a few short years ago—more a lot of attention, but telephone answering
comfortable or more dangerous, more un- machines, based on a simple technology,
der our control or more beyond it—may fail never were exciting. Yet, when we arrive
to lead us thoughtfully to consider that at home each evening, because of its time-
among the reasons that we regard life as shifting advantage the answering machine
different is the time we spend looking at may be our first stop after opening the front
phosphor dots. It is just a step from regard- door. It liberated us from the need to be
ing life as different to regarding life as physically near the telephone if we awaited
strange. That may raise some concerns and an important call. It will remain an impor-
unease that can affect our attitudes about tant tool of communication until the tele-
the world around us. Heavy television us- phone itself shrinks to a cellphone that is
ers, for instance, tend on the whole to be as convenient to carry as a wallet, and we
more fearful persons than non-users. As a are always "at home."
result of our concerns, we may hesitate to
go out at night, we may buy a deadbolt lock
or a large dog, and we may vote for a law- It is the communication tools themselves
and-order candidate for mayor, all without and their effect upon the societies into
the attendant recognition that our which they were introduced that compose
attitudes can be traced to one of the tools these chapters, the communication tools
of communication in the toolsheds that we that we all pick up as comfortably as a
call our homes. Saturday sweater.

Political Tools and Weapons


Russian television carried the horrors from The power of the tools of mass commu-
Chechnya, of hungry dogs circling the nication first to shake and then to shape
corpses in Grozny. For decades such national policy was evident on the streets
scenes, neither photographed nor transmit- of American cities during the Vietnam War.
ted, did not disturb the Kremlin's rigid con- It became clearer in the Soviet Union just
trol. No longer. Russia and the rest of the a few years ago.
world are far different places now that tele-
vision cameras see, videotape records, sat- ...while it once appeared that the new media
ellites transmit, and television sets in living would enhance the power of governments
rooms show. Even if the Kremlin had the (as, for example, Orwell argued in 1984),
power it once had to block broadcasts on their effect recently has been the opposite:
Russian media, CNN would beam the sig- breaking state monopolies of information,
nals from the border of Finland to Vladivos- permeating national boundaries, allowing
peoples to hear and see how others do things
tok. Jamming a satellite TV signal is differently. It has also made richer and
considerably more difficult than jamming poorer countries more aware of the gap
radio. With 24-hour-a-day financial transac- between them than was possible a half
tions and the penetration by global news century ago, and stimulated legal and illegal
agencies, we live in what is becoming a migration.11
borderless world.

You might also like