Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Community Centred Conservation (C3)
Community Centred Conservation (C3)
C3-Comores 2007 C3-Comores is a collaborative initiative between Community Centred Conservation (C3), a nonprofit company registered in England no. 5606924 and Comorian partner organizations. The Year of the Turtle activities described in this report have been supported by the IOSEA Marine Turtle Memorandum of Understanding. Suggested citation: C3-Comores (2007) TURTLE INFORMATION CENTRE AND AWARENESS-RAISING CAMPAIGN, MOHLI, COMOROS. A report submitted to the UNEP/IOSEA Marine Turtle MoU Secretariat.12pp
IOSEA www.ioseaturtles.org
Moroni 2007
AIDE
ADSEI
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This report is the culmination of the advice, cooperation, hard work and expertise of many people. In particular, acknowledgments are due to the following for their contributions: COMMUNITY CENTRED CONSERVATION (C3) Director: Patricia Davis International Programme Manager: Chris Poonian C3-Comores Programme Manager: Rozenn Le Scao C3-Comores Programme Coordinator: Melissa Hauzer Interns: Charles Beaufrere, Sarah Freed, Ariana Arcenas, Kileken Ole Moi-Yoi, Bjorn Alfthan, Joanne Nice and Audrey Clark MOHLI MARINE PARK Curator : Kamardine Boinali Ecoguards, particularly Hamada Issoufi and Cheikh Moussa Management Committee, particularly Abdou Malida and Nassur Ahamada ADSEI, particularly Matarafi Hamadi FADEVICHO / HUPPE, particularly Nema Madi, Loufti Madi, Ahmed Abla, Ahmed Dahalane, Mouzidalifa Issouf, Aboubacar Ahmed Kaldi, Omar Nafdi and Bachiroudine Issa THE MINISTRY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ENVIRONMENT, MOHLI, particularly Abdou Tchake, Minister for the Environment and Toiouilou Madi Bam Dou, Director General for Tourism THE MINISTRY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ENVIRONMENT, COMOROS, particularly Sitti Kassim, Minister for the Environment; Said Mohammed Ali Said, Secretary General and Fatouma Abdallah, Adjoint Director, INRAPE AIDE, particularly Zaharani Moindjie and Said Ahamada, Secretary General All other volunteers and students, particularly Ben Said Omar, Mouzdaaoi Baussawi and Bounouenche Moussa
CONTENTS
1. INTRODUCTION 2. OBJECTIVES 3. ACTIVITIES 3.1 Day of the Turtle 3.2 Schools drawing competition 3.3 Hoani Conservation Centre 3.4 Activities evaluation 4. FINANCIAL REPORT 4.1 Financial statement 4.2 Financial evaluation 5. APPENDICES 1 3 4 4 5 8 10 11 11 11 12
C3-Comores
1. INTRODUCTION
Mohli Island in the Comoros (Figure 1) is one of the key nesting sites for green turtles in the Western Indian Ocean. Hawksbill turtles also nest here and leatherbacks are occasionally sighted. Green turtles nest throughout the year, with a peak during the Austral Winter. However, poaching of nesting females has become a serious problem in recent years.
The creation of Mohli Marine Park (PMM) in 2001 reduced the threat of turtle poaching, however, owing to a lack of funds in recent years, the Park has been unable to continue turtle surveillance, and poaching is again an increasing threat. Mortimer (2002)1 has identified the following priorities for turtle conservation in the Comoros: 1. Support efforts of village associations and local communities to protect turtles on Mohli 2. Develop income generating activities and employment related to the presence of marine turtles, particularly through eco-tourism. 3. Put in place a mechanism for long-term financing of marine turtle conservation in Comoros. 4. Involve local communities in monitoring activities on Mohli. 5. Conduct public awareness programmes on Mohli, Anjouan, & Grand Comore to minimize poaching by their residents at Mohli. Fortunately, some villages have already established effective community surveillance programmes, and many others have expressed a strong interest in forming environmental associations to protect their sea turtles. The village of Itsamia had been the target of much of the previous turtle conservation work on Mohli and the community has initiated turtle ecotourism activities. This IOSEA project aimed to motivate and fully implicate all of the communities of Mohli in the conservation of their sea turtles. Following discussions with Kamardine Boinali (PMM Curator) and the PMM ecoguards, it was decided specifically that this project must reach those villages on Mohli where poaching was most prevalent.
1 Mortimer (2002) A STRATEGY TO CONSERVE AND MANAGE THE SEA TURTLE RESOURCES OF THE WESTERN INDIAN OCEAN REGION. A report produced for IUCN, WWF, and The Ocean Conservancy. 46pp
Page 1 of 12
C3-Comores
Page 2 of 12
C3-Comores
2. OBJECTIVES
To support the Association for the Socioeconomic Development of Itsamia (ADSEI) through a contribution to the organizational costs of the Day of the Turtle 2006 in collaboration with CEDTM/Kelonia Reunion. To organize a turtle drawing competition to raise public awareness in five villages of Mohli, focussing on those most affected by poaching. To create a conservation centre on Mohli in order to promote the conservation of sea turtles to tourists and Mohlians; to provide a headquarters for turtle conservation activities and to act as a point of sale for artisanal goods and souvenirs to generate income for local communities.
Page 3 of 12
C3-Comores
3. ACTIVITIES
3.1 DAY OF THE TURTLE Since 1999, May 28th has been celebrated on Mohli as the official Day of the Turtle. Held in Itsamia, the day has been a resounding success for the promotion of environmental awareness of sea turtles on Mohli. In 2006 this day marked the starting point of activities to celebrate IOSEA Year of the Turtle.
Speeches about turtle conservation were made by the Curator of Mohli Marine Park (PMM), the Minister for the Environment, Minister for Tourism, Francois Beudard of CEDTM/Kelonia and the Patricia Davis of C3. People came from all over the island to participate in a huge range of activities to suit all ages. Some of the most popular activities included tug of war, dancing, singing, poetry and dictation competitions and the tam tam de boeuf, the Comorian equivalent of the running of the bulls!
Page 4 of 12
C3-Comores
C3 helped to organize the weekend in collaboration with PMM and Association for the Socioeconomic Development of Itsamia (ADSEI). The event was a great success, with an estimated 400 participants. Everybody learned a great deal about sea turtle ecology and conservation. Prizes for competition winners and IOSEA t-shirts were distributed at the end of the weekend. The event was filmed by a team from CEDTM/Kelonia, the turtle research group from Reunion Island. Most participants received goody bags with snacks and drinks to keep them happy and full of energy throughout.
3.2 SCHOOLS DRAWING COMPETITION In celebration of IOSEA Year of the Turtle 2006, C3 and Mohli Marine Park (PMM) initiated a programme to inform students of the life history, ecology and conservation issues of Mohlis sea turtles and encourage their involvement in their protection. The programme took place at schools in five villages, from 16 June to 11 July (full details in Table 1). The villages were identified by the PMM Curator, Kamardine Boinali, as those most heavily affected by turtle poaching. A total of 313 students attended the five presentations, 151 girls and 162 boys between the ages of 7 and 23. C3 was assisted by PMM ecoguards Hamada Issoufi, Cheikh Moussa (Bush) and community volunteers.
Page 5 of 12
Dictation competition
C3-Comores
In addition to educating students about the turtles that were nesting nightly on Mohlis beaches at the time, a drawing contest was held in each village. The ecoguards held the attention of classrooms full of up to 81 children with their animated and heartfelt presentations. At Hamavouna, the team was unfortunate enough to discover a disemboweled turtle on the beach, so it was decided to bring the children outside to witness firsthand the destructive actions of turtle poachers. The children participated eagerly in the drawing competition, and many of them added thoughtful captions to their drawings.
Page 6 of 12
C3-Comores
BOYS 19 33 36 36 38
GIRLS 24 26 27 31 43
ECOGUARD Hamada Yssoufi Cheikh Moussa Cheikh Moussa Cheikh Moussa Cheikh Moussa
WINNER Dega Hamada Andarcia Ali Abacar Yssouf Soimadou Halasse Youssouf Madi
PMM Curator Kamardine Boinali judged the competition, taking into account the age of the competitor and the pertinence of the message included with the drawing. First, second and third prize winners from each village were awarded a certificate (see Appendices) and one winner from each village was taken on an exciting overnight field trip to Itsamia All the winners were lucky enough to observe both nesting females and juvenile turtles emerging. PMM ecoguard and turtle expert Matarafi Hamadi provided the children with further information and a full commentary on the turtle nesting process. The drawings selected were used to create a poster and T-shirt promoting turtle conservation, which has been distributed throughout Mohli and the Comoros (see Appendices).
Page 7 of 12
C3-Comores
3.3 HOANI CONSERVATION CENTRE Mohlis potential for ecotourism is undoubtedly its greatest asset, and is one of the most frequentlyproposed means for economic development on the island. Mohlis natural environment is unique, the island hosts coral reefs, tropical forests and charismatic endangered species such as dugongs and sea turtles. However, capacity for ecotourism on the island is low, there is little interpretative material about turtles available to tourists and few local people have received the necessary training in tourism services. A building exists in Itsamia, known as the House of the Turtle, however, its awareness materials are now aging, and there are no brochures or information for tourists to take away with them.
The village of Hoani, on the northwest coast of the island was identified by C3-Comores as a priority site for turtle conservation activities, since it lies outside of the boundaries of Mohli Marine Park (PMM), despite the fact that the villages beaches provide an important nesting site for green turtles. As a result of the villages concerns at increased levels of turtle poaching in the area, C3 and FADEVICHO (the village association of Hoani) created a Conservation Centre. A disused building was renovated to create a headquarters for turtle conservation activities in northwest Mohli.
Page 8 of 12
C3-Comores
Work on the Conservation Centre started in June 2006, and it was completed in December. The Centre is located on a turtle nesting beach close to Hoani, and comprises two rooms. The first room has been designed to accommodate anti-poaching community ecoguard teams (trained by C3) during night patrols and for tourists who wish to view nesting turtles. The second room has been designed to inform tourists and villagers about conservation issues on Mohli. The room displays informative brochures about turtles, as well as information boards on the environment, history and culture of Hoani village and the surrounding region (see Appendices).
The Centre will act as a point of sale for handicrafts, postcards and T-shirts, revenue from which will be channeled back into conservation initiatives in the village. The postcards, T-shirts and brochures
Page 9 of 12
C3-Comores
(displayed in Appendices), were also distributed to other village associations throughout Mohli and the House of Ecotourism. Two murals have been painted on the centre by Audrey Clarke (C3) and artists from Hoani. The specific designs for the paintings were chosen by FADEVICHO to portray the environment of Mohli and the species that live within it. A menu and programme of activities for ecotourists was also compiled following discussion between C3 and FADEVICHO. By enhancing the experience of tourists, additional funds will be raised for turtle conservation activities through purchase of souvenirs and increased international awareness.
FADEVICHO is very pleased with the progress initiated by the presence of the Centre and later sent a letter of thanks to C3 and its donor agencies (see Appendices). The Centre is already generating motivation for turtle monitoring activities villagers out on patrol were successful in arresting several poachers in the months of August and September 2006. The resounding success of this collaboration was formalized in 2006 when C3 and FADEVICHO signed a Memorandum of Understanding to work together to conserve the important marine ecosystems of northwest Mohli. 3.4 ACTIVITIES EVALUATION Through cooperation between C3, Mohli Marine Park (PMM) and the communities of Mohli, this project achieved all of its objectives. However, problems of rivalry between small village communities led to some complications. For example: Itsamia had always been the target of external intervention in turtle conservation on Mohli, and some members of the community were disgruntled to see other villages receiving benefits for the first time. This problem was compounded since Itsamia had been the sole target for another, unsuccessful IOSEA proposal. However, by ensuring that the choice of locations for the drawing competition and Conservation Centre were based on objective assessment, the impact of the project was in fact maximized. The activities from this project were presented at the International Society for Reef Studies Conference in Bremen, October 2006, Reef Conservation UK Annual Meeting in December 2006, International Sea Turtle Society Symposium in February 2007 and at workshops held on Mohli and Grande Comore in April and June 2007 (see Appendices for presentations). It was suggested by the PMM Management Committee that, in the future, the success of the Day of the Turtle should be spread throughout Mohli; with a different village hosting the event each year to ensure a sense of ownership for all Mohelians. All collaborating parties have agreed that the initiation of community conservation efforts for turtles in the northwest region of Mohli is an unanticipated and extremely positive result to emerge from this project.
Page 10 of 12
C3-Comores
4. FINANCIAL REPORT
4.1 FINANCIAL STATEMENT Day of the Turtle Refreshments Photocopying Minibus rental Competition prizes Sound equipment Schools drawing competition Crayons Paper Posters T shirts Transport (including winners' trip and distribution of prizes) Hoani Conservation Centre Furniture and materials Renovation of centre (including mural and information boards) Transport General Final workshop (refreshments and travel) Brochures Postcards Bank transfer charges Total expenses 100 173 236 24 $533 $3000 455 139 85 $679 11 31 138 443 174 $797 $528 38 108 235 81 $991
I certify that the above financial statement is a true representation of expenses incurred during activities carried out by C3 for the project described in this report. Patricia Z. R. Davis, Director, C3 18th June 2007 4.2 FINANCIAL EVALUATION This project ran closely to its predicted budget. The only discrepancies arose from the request by PMM and ADSEI to use $1000 to contribute to the Day of the Turtle celebration. This money was taken from the budget allocated to the opening ceremony of the Conservation Centre, which worked well, since FADEVICHO was happy to arrange and finance the opening ceremony themselves. Overall, however, this project is a good example of international cooperation to achieve outstanding results and excellent value for money.
Page 11 of 12
C3-Comores
5. APPENDICES
5.1 LETTER OF THANKS FROM HOANI 5.2 DRAWING COMPETITION CERTIFICATE 5.3 T-SHIRT AND POSTER DESIGN 5.4 HOANI ENVIRONMENTAL INFORMATION POSTER 5.5 HOANI CULTURAL INFORMATION POSTER 5.6 IOSEA POSTCARD 5.7 TURTLE INFORMATION BROCHURE 5.8 ISRS POSTER PRESENTATION 5.9 RCUK POSTER PRESENTATION 5.10 ISTS ORAL PRESENTATIONS 5.11 IOSEA YEAR OF THE TURTLE FACTSHEET
Page 12 of 12
M. Kamardine Boinali
Nous risquons de perdre nos voisines les tortues. On peut les protger en adoptant une quelques rgles simples de conduite: Ne pas dranger lanimal durant la ponte (ni lampe, ni contact tactile avec lanimal). Les nids non plus ne doivent pas tre drangs. Lors du processus de nidification, les tortues utilisent beaucoup dnergie . Tout stress ajout cet effort peut la faire retourner leau ou pire, interrompre la nidification. Protgeons galement les herbiers marins (source de nourriture pour la tortue verte) des sdiments boueux (rsultat de la dforestation) et des pandages dordures mnagres. Gardons les plages propres, prservons la fort, surveillons les littoraux et sensibilisons notre entourage la protection de lenvironnement.
Les tortues de mer occupent les ocans depuis 100 millions dannes. Les tortues passent la plus grande partie de leur vie dans leau et se rendent terre pour pondre lors de la nidification. Les tortues respirent de lair, mais leur corps de forme hydrodynamique est adapt la vie marine.
Pour plus de renseignements sur les tortues de mer contactez:
Les tortues sont inscrites sur la Convention du commerce international des espces menaces dextinction (CITES) et sont strictement protges par le gouvernement Comorien.
info@c-3.org.uk
IOSEA: www.ioseaturtles.org
www.c-3.org.uk
Les tortues de mer Mohli Lle de Mohli , connue pour ses tortues est la seconde le de lOcan Indien la plus frquentes par les tortues vertes. Il ny a que douze sites au monde comptant les mmes populations de tortues vertes. Les tortues que lon trouve Mohli sont la tortue verte (Chelonia mydas) et la tortue imbrique
Le cycle de vie dune tortue Elle commence la nuit ou la femelle rampe sur la plage pour pondre. Celle-ci creuse une chambre avec ses pattes postrieures et y dpose ses ufs. Cette tortue reviendra crer d'autres nids des intervalles de 8 15 jours et jusqu' un maximum de 14 fois selon lespce. Lincubation dure entre 45 et 70 jours. Aprs l'closion, les bbs grimpent le long de la paroi du nid. Leur instinct les dirige vers la partie la plus brillante de lhorizon qui est la mer sur laquelle se reflte la lumire de lune. Emports par les vagues, les bbs tortues mangeront ensuite des invertbrs jusqu atteindre 20 ou 30cm (en 2 ans environ). Ces annes sont libelles comme les annes perdues car peu dinformation existent sur les premires tapes de la vie dune tortue. Les juvniles rejoindront les adultes et festoieront au sein des herbiers et barrires de corail, ils sont alors assez grands pour viter les prdateurs.
(Eretmochelys imbricata).
La tortue verte La tortue verte est la plus grande des deux espces de tortues ctoyant lle de Mohli. Son poids moyen est de 175kg et sa longueur de 110 cm. Leur priode de reproduction se situe entre 15 et 30 ans. Les tortues de mer ne pondent pas tous les ans. Les tortues vertes pondent en moyenne 120 ufs et ce plusieurs fois dans lanne de reproduction. Aux Comores, les tortues vertes utilisent les plages de ponte durant la majeure partie de lanne, avec une frquentation plus accrue durant le mois de juillet. La tortue imbrique La tortue imbrique est plutt omnivore, mangeant les herbiers marins, les ponges, les crustacs et autres invertbrs. Son poids moyen est 60kg et sa longueur 82cm. Elle pond en moyenne 160 ufs. Aux Comores les tortues imbriques pondent plutt entre dcembre et mars.
Protgeons la tortue Les tortues sont menaces dans le monde entier et Mohli est lun des sites importants pour la ponte des tortues. Il est donc ncessaire de les protger. Les tortues sont trs sensibles aux activits humaines (destruction de son habitat, braconnage...) et ne peuvent se reproduire qu partir d' une population minimale de 30 spcimens. Les populations les plus rduites ont beaucoup de difficult se reconstituer. A Mohli, les problmes frquents de braconnage de viande et ufs de tortues, la perturbation des tortues lors de la ponte et la destruction des herbiers crent des menaces pour ces espces en voie de disparition.
C3-COMORES 2006
TRAINING, EDUCATION & RESEARCH FOR SEA TURTLE CONSERVATION IN THE COMOROS
AIDE
Summary of activities
(1) Training (2) Education and Awareness (3) Research
-Community ecoguards and ecoguides -Law-enforcement workshop -Schools drawing competition -Junior ecoguards -Village events -Turtle Conservation Centre - Quarterly beach monitoring - Turtle meat survey
Junior ecoguards
-Group of Mohelian teenagers united to protect their natural environment -Awareness-raising events -Turtle sketch -Training with adult ecoguards -Assisted with C3s research -Excellent role models for their peers -Fun and income generation for activities -To be initiated in 5 other villages in 2007
Village events
-Day of the Turtle 2006, Itsamia -Organized annually -Competitions, dancing, celebration -Free visit to turtle nesting beach
-Awareness raising presentations from Marine Park ecoguards -Promotion of turtles and dugongs as flagship species -Excellent response from all communities
-Turtle database for the northwest Moimbasa region -Improved facilities planned for 2007
-Provides simple information for local communities -Further training still required for effective monitoring programme
Future projects
Turtle meat survey expanded to Grande Comore and Anjouan Awareness-raising work on Grande Comore and Anjouan Formalization of a turtle protected area in the north west of Moheli and reinforcement of justice system
-Expand survey to Grande Comore and Anjouan -Research alternative sources of meat in 2007 hedgehogs?
MARAHABA
Questions?
www.c-3.org.uk
COMMUNITY-MANAGED SEA TURTLE MONITORING AND PROTECTION ON MOHLI, UNION OF THE COMOROS
Chris Poonian, Cheikh Moussa & Hamada Issoufi
AIDE
Village of Hoani
Priorities
(1) Community involvement (2) Sustainability (3) Governmental support
95%
Awareness raising
-Schools awareness and drawing competition
Sustainability
-Ecotourism: Menus, activities, souvenirs -Share of fine from poaching convictions -Is ecotourism cost-effective? -Are other sustainable livelihoods a more viable option?
Governmental support
Decentralisation of Comorian government still causing difficulties Proposed MoU between villages in Northwest region of Mohli Reinforcement of legal system
Future priorities
Further training and logistical support Improved publicity for tourism facilities Inter-village connections
MARAHABA
MARAHABA
Questions?
www.c-3.org.uk