Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CE 370 Reinforced Concrete-I: Shear in RC Beams
CE 370 Reinforced Concrete-I: Shear in RC Beams
CE 370
REINFORCED CONCRETE-I
Prof. A. Charif
Shear in RC Beams
Shear in Beams
• Transverse loads on
beams cause
bending moment M
and shear force V
• Shear force V is the
first derivative of
the moment M
dM
V
dx
Shear in Beams
• Bending moment causes normal stresses with compression
resisted by concrete and tension by longitudinal steel bars
• Bending design delivers required longitudinal steel
• Shear force causes shear stress and shear design is performed
independently
principal stresses
2
f f
f p v2
2 2
2v
tan2
f
SBC / ACI :
V
v
bw d
Average
shear stress
must not
exceed
certain limit
7
Flexural-shear Failure
(Flexure-shear cracks)
• For flexure-shear cracks to occur, the moment must be larger
than the cracking moment and the shear must be rather large.
• The cracks run at angles of about 450 with the beam axis and
often start at the top of the flexural cracks.
10
11
12
13
14
• Nowadays,
stirrups are
often vertical
15
Bent up bars
16
17
18
19
Benefits of Stirrups
Stirrups carry shear across the crack directly
Promote aggregate interlock
Confine the core of the concrete in the beam thereby
increasing strength and ductility
Confine the longitudinal bars and prevent concrete
cover from splitting off the beam
Hold the pieces of concrete on either side of the
crack together and prevent the crack from
propagating into the compression region
20
CE 370
REINFORCED CONCRETE-I
Prof. A. Charif
Vn Vc Vs
Vc : Concrete shear strength
Vs : Stirrups shear strength
Av f y d
Vertical stirrups: Vs ns Av f y
s
Inclined stirrups: Vs Av f y sin cos
d
s
Av : Stirrup cross - section area
25
Av f y d
Vs
s
26
29
30
31
Ln
d Ln/2
35
v
4
The minimum shear steel area requirement, expressed in terms of
spacing s, can thus be transformed to another spacing requirement:
f ' 1b s
M inimum shear steel area Av ,min M ax c , w
16 3 f y
16.0 Av f y
M aximum steel spacing smax2
M in , 3.0
f' bw
c
38
Vu Shear design
Insufficient section and spacing
5Vc
Case (a)
s1max Case (b)
2 d
Vu 3Vc : smax M in 2 , 600 mm (a)
1
3Vc
V 3V : s1 M in d , 300 mm (b)
u c max
4
16.0 Av f y
2
smax Min , 3.0
f' bw
c
Av f y d
Yes
3
smax
V u Vc ? Vu
Vc
No
s Min s1max , smax
2
s Min s1max , smax
2 3
, smax
41
42
44
45
Solution 1
The ultimate load is :
wu = 1.4 x 27.0 + 1.7 x 17.5 = 37.8 + 29.75 = 67.55 kN/m
Factored live load is : wLu = 1.7 x 17.5 = 29.75 kN/m
Ultimate shear force at support and mid-span as well as value at the
critical section (at a distance d from the support) are:
Ln 9.6
Vu 0 wu 67.55 324.24 kN
2 2
L 9.6
VuL / 2 wLu n 29.75 35.7 kN
8 8
Vud Vu 0
2d
Vu 0 VuL/ 2
Ln
2 0.54
Vud 324.24 324.24 35.7 291.78 kN
9.6
46
Solution 1 – Cont.
Vu0 Vud 0.5Vc 50.62 kN
0.5Vc VuL/2 Vu 0 324.24 kN
VuL / 2 35.7 kN
0.54m Ln/2 = 4.8 m Vud 291.78 kN
Vud is used for design
Concrete nominal shear strength is :
f c' 25
Vc bw d 300 540 135000 N 135.0 kN
6 6
Section adequacy check :
5Vc 5 0.75 135 506.25 kN Vu Vud 291.78 kN Section OK
Stirrup requiremen t : 0.5Vc 50.625 kN Vud Stirrups are required
n d s 3 10 2
2
Solution 1 – Cont.
Maximum geometry spacing : Vud 291.78 3Vc 303.75 kN
s1max Min 0.5d , 600 mm 270.0 mm Case (a)
16.0 Av f y
M inimum steel spacing : smax2
M in , 3.0
f' bw
c
16.0 235.6 420
smax
2
M in , 3.0 989.5 mm
25 300
Av f y d
3
Required stirrup spacing : s max
Vud
Vc
235.6 420 540
s max
3
210.3 mm
291.78
135.0 1000
0.75 48
Solution 1 – Cont.
M aximum spacing requiremen t summary :
Geometry maximum spacing : s 1max 270.0 mm
2
M inimum steel spacing : s max 989.5 mm
3
Required stirrup spacing : s max 210.3 mm
Adoptedspacing : s M in s 1max , s max
2 3
, s max s 210 mm
We use a 200 mm spacing
• A stirrup is assumed to resist shear over a distance
extending s/2 on each side of the stirrup
• The first stirrup must thus be located at a distance s/2 from
the support face
• First stirrup at 100 mm, then constant 200 mm spacing
Question 1: We used 3 legs. What happens if we use 2 or 4 legs?
49
Solution 1 – Cont.
Geometry maximum spacing is unchanged : s1max 270.0 mm (a)
Stirrup Requirement
and Spacing Variation
• When shear force is reduced, we can not only change
(increase) stirrup spacing, but we may be able to stop
stirrups completely when they are no longer required
• Remember : Stirrups are required in beams in all
zones where:
Vu 0.5Vc
Stirrup Requirement
and Spacing Variation
Stirrups are no longer required when : Vu 0.5Vc
Distance x0 over which stirrups are required is obtained using
similar triangles :
x0
Ln Vu 0 0.5Vc Vu0
x0 0.5Vc VuL/2
2 Vu 0 VuL / 2 Ln/2
54
Spacing Variation
57
58
59
Solution 2
• The ultimate load, shear force values and concrete shear strength
are the same as before.
0.5Vc 50.62 kN
Vu0 V
ud Vu 0 324.24 kN
0.5Vc VuL/2 VuL / 2 35.7 kN
Vud 291.78 kN
0.54m Ln/2 = 4.8 m
f c'
Vc bw d 135.0 kN
6
Section adequacy check :
5Vc 5 0.75 135 506.25 kN Vu Vud 291.78 kN Section OK
Vc
Stirrup requiremen t : 50.62 kN Vud Stirrups are required
2
61
Solution 2 – Cont.
• Distance x0 beyond which stirrups are not required is :
Ln Vu 0 0.5Vc 9.6 324.24 0.5 0.75 135
x0 4.552 m 4552 mm
2 Vu 0 VuL / 2 2 324.24 35.7
62
Solution 2 – Cont.
n d s
2
100
Start with two legs : n = 2 Av 2 157.08 mm2
4 4
16.0 Av f y
M inimum steel spacing : smax 2
M in , 3.0
f' bw
c
16.0 157.08 420
smax
2
M in , 3.0 659.7 mm
25 300
63
Solution 2 – Cont.
M aximum spacing requiremen t summary :
Geometry maximum spacing : s1max 270.0 mm
2
M inimum steel spacing : smax 659.7 mm
3
Required stirrup spacing : smax 140.2 mm
Adoptedspacing : s M in s1max , smax
2 3
, smax
s 140 mm (controlled by smax
3
)
We usually select spacing values as multiples of 50 mm
We use a 100 mm spacing
64
Solution 2 – Cont.
Spacing Variation
Spacing may be increased provided it does not exceed any of the two
limits s 1max , s max
2
65
Solution 2 – Cont.
Spacing Variation
The total number of stirrups with first spacing is :
s1 x 1 746 1
Ls1 x2 n1s1 x2 n1 2 7.96 n1 8
2 s1 2 100 2
The first stirrup is at a distance s1/2 = 50 mm. Seven more
stirrups are needed to cover this distance x2 (= 746 mm)
The remaining distance for spacing s2 is :
s1 100
R2 Lst Ls1 Ls1 n1s1
8 100 750 mm
2 2
R2 Lst Ls1 4552 750 3802 mm
The approximate number of stirrups with spacing s2 is :
R2 3802
n2 25.3
s2 150 66
Solution 2 – Cont.
Spacing Variation
R2 3802
n2 25.3
s2 150
This large number allows for further spacing variation (which is
still possible).
We chose a new (third) value of 250 mm (which corresponds in
fact to geometry maximum spacing) : s3 = 250 mm
The corresponding shear force value and its location are :
Solution 2 – Cont.
Spacing Variation
Vu 3 208.13 kN x3 1932 mm
x* 1182
n2 2 7.88 n2 8
s2 150
Ls 2 n2 s2 8 150 1200 mm
Solution 2- Summary
Stirrups required over a distance Lst = 4552 mm (less than half-span)
Use of two-leg 10 mm stirrups as follows:
1. Eight stirrups with spacing s1 = 100 mm. First stirrup located at
s1/2 = 50 mm, and then seven stirrups with spacing s1 = 100 mm
(Ls1 = 50 + 7 x 100 = 750 mm)
2. Eight stirrups with spacing s2 = 150 mm (Ls2 = 8 x 150 = 1200 mm
and Ls1 + Ls2 = 1950 mm)
3. Eleven stirrups with spacing s3 = 250 mm (Ls3 = 2750 mm , and
Ls1 + Ls2 + Ls3 = 4700 mm)
69
Solution 2 - Summary
Figure produced by
RC-TOOL software
implementing all
previous theory
Same results with
shear force diagrams
Solution 3
• The final spacing value controlled by the required spacing limit
(89.7 mm) is small and less than the minimum limit of 100 mm.
• To increase the required spacing, we must increase the number of
legs (or the stirrup diameter)
• We keep using the same 8-mm stirrup diameter and increase the
number of legs to three. The maximum geometry spacing remains
unchanged but the other two will increase:
n d s
2
64
s 1max 270.0 mm Av 3 48 150.8 mm 2
4 4
16.0 Av f y 16 150.8
2
s max M in , 3.0 M in , 3.0 420 633.3 mm
f' bw 25 300
c
A f d 150.8 420 540
134.6 mm
3 v y
s max
Vud 291 .78
Vc 135.0 1000
0.75
72
Solution 3 – Cont.
73
Solution 3 – Cont.
Spacing Variation
Spacing may be increased provided it does not exceed any of
the two limits s 1max , s max
2
74
Solution 3 – Cont.
Spacing Variation
The total number of stirrups with first spacing is :
s1 x 1 865 1
Ls1 x2 n1 s1 x2 n1 2 9.15 n1 10
2 s1 2 100 2
Ls1 50 9 100 950 mm
R2 3602
n2 24.01
s2 150
75
Solution 3 – Cont.
Spacing Variation
R2 3602
n2 24.01
s2 150
This large number allows for further spacing variation.
We chose a new (third) value of 250 mm (which corresponds in
fact to geometry maximum spacing) : s3 = 250 mm
The corresponding shear force value and its location are :
Av f y d 150.8 420 540
0.75135
1
Vu 3 Vc 203.85 kN
s3 250 1000
L V V 9.6 324.24 203.85
x3 n u 0 u 3 2.003 m 2003 mm
2 Vu 0 VuL / 2 2 324.24 35.7
76
Solution 3 – Cont.
Spacing Variation
Vu 3 203.85 kN x3 2003 mm
Solution 3 - Summary
Stirrups required over a distance Lst = 4552 mm (less than half-span)
Use of three-leg 8 mm stirrups as follows:
1. Ten stirrups with spacing s1 = 100 mm and the first stirrup is at
s1/2 = 50 mm, (Ls1 = 50 + 9 x 100 = 950 mm)
2. Eight stirrups with s2 = 150 mm (Ls2 = 8 x 150 = 1200 mm and
Ls1 + Ls2 = 2150 mm)
3. Ten stirrups with s3 = 250 mm (Ls3 = 10 x 250 = 2500 mm and
Ls1 + Ls2 + Ls3 = 4650 mm)
78
79
80
81
85
86
Solution 4
The ultimate load is :
wu = 1.4 x 40.0 + 1.7 x 20.0 = 56.0 + 34.0 = 90.0 kN/m
Factored live load is : wLu = 1.7 x 20.0 = 34.0 kN/m
Ultimate shear force at support and mid-span as well as value at
distance d are:
Ln 9.6
Vu 0 wu 90.0 432.0 kN
2 2
L 9.6
VuL / 2 wLu n 34.0 40.8 kN
8 8
Vud Vu 0
2d
Vu 0 VuL/ 2
Ln
2 0.54
Vud 432.0 432.0 40.8 387.99 kN
9.6
87
Solution 4
Vu0
Vud 0.5Vc 50.62 kN
3Vc 303.75 kN
3Vc
Vu 0 432.0 kN
0.5Vc VuL/2 VuL / 2 40.8 kN
0.54m Vud 387.99 kN
Ln/2 = 4.8 m
Vud is used for design
f c' 25
Concrete shear : Vc bw d 300 540 135000 N 135.0 kN
6 6
Section adequacy check :
5Vc 5 0.75 135 506.25 kN Vu Vud 387.99 kN Section OK
Vc
Stirrup requiremen t : 50.62 kN Vud Stirrups are required
2
88
Solution 4 – Cont.
Distance x0 over which stirrups are required is :
n d s
2
100
Start with two legs : n = 2 Av 2 157.08 mm2
4 4
16.0 Av f y
M inimum steel spacing : smax 2
M in , 3.0
f' bw
c
16.0 157.08 420
smax
2
M in , 3.0 659.7 mm
25 300
89
Solution 4 – Cont.
Solution 4 – Cont.
91
Solution 4 – Cont.
Final spacing is controlled by themaximum geometry limit s1max
It cannot therefore be changed. However s1max in this problem,
is controlled by case (b) because of a high shear force.
For reduced shear values (less than 3Vc 303.75 k N ),
s1max will become controlled by case (a) and its value doubled.
Distance beyond which s1max will be doubled :
Ln Vu 0 3Vc 9.6 432.0 3 0.75 135
xh 1.574 m 1574 mm
2 Vu 0 VuL / 2 2 432.0 40.8
Number of stirrups required to cover this distance with 100 mm spacing :
s1 x 1 1574 1
n1s1 xh n1 h 16.24 n1 17
2 s1 2 100 2
s1
Ls1 (n1 1) s1 50 16 100 1650 mm
2 92
Solution 4 – Cont.
Ls1 50 16 100 1650 mm
Beyond this distance (second part of the half - span),
the geometry maximum spacing is doubled :
s1max M in 0.5d , 600 mm 270.0 mm
The shear force at this location is :
2 1650
Vs1 Vu 0 s1 Vu 0 VuL / 2 432.0 432.0 40.8 297.525 kN
2L
Ln 9600
We can now design new stirrup spacing for this shear force value.
The spacings are : s1max 270.0 mm smax
2
989.6 mm (unchanged )
Av f y d 235.62 420 540
3
smax 204.20 mm
Vud
Vc 297.525
135.0 1000
0.75
We adopt a 200 mm spacing in the second part.
93
Solution 4 – Cont.
Spacing Variation
Remaining stirrup distance R2 Lst Ls1 4679 1650 3029 mm
Required number of stirrups with second spacing :
R 3029
n2 2 15.15 Further spacing increase is possible
s2 200
We choose a third spacing s3 250 mm
Corresponding shear force is :
A f d 235.62 420 1
Vu 3 Vc v y 0.75135 540 261.57 kN
s3 250 1000
The location of this shear force value is :
Ln Vu 0 Vu 3 9.6 432.0 261.57
x3 2.091 m 2091mm
2 Vu 0 VuL / 2 2 432.0 40.8
94
Solution 4 – Cont.
Spacing Variation
Vu 3 261.57 kN x3 2091mm
Solution 4 - Summary
96
RC-TOOL output
97
98
Problem 5
• A simply supported beam is subjected to
uniform loading composed of dead load
(including self weight) of 60.0 kN/m and
live load of 90.0 kN/m.
d 550
• Span length and section data are shown 625
99
Solution 5
The ultimate load is :
wu = 1.4 x 60.0 + 1.7 x 90.0 = 237.0 kN/m
Factored live load is : wLu = 1.7 x 90.0 = 153.0 kN/m
Ultimate shear force at support and mid-span as well as value at
distance d are:
Ln 4.2
Vu 0 wu 237.0 497.7 kN
2 2
L 4.2
VuL / 2 wLu n 153.0 80.325 kN
8 8
Vud Vu 0
2d
Vu 0 VuL/ 2
Ln
2 0.55
Vud 497.7 497.7 80.325 388.4 kN
4.2
100
Solution 5 – Cont.
Vu0 Vud
0.5Vc 70.6 kN VuL/2
Vu 0 497.7 kN VuL / 2 80.325 kN 0.5Vc
f c' 30
Concrete shear : Vc bw d 375 550 188279 N 188.3 kN
6 6
Section adequacy check :
5Vc 5 0.75 188.3 706.125 kN Vu Vud 388.4 kN Section OK
Stirrup requiremen t : 0.5Vc 70.6 kN Vud Stirrups are required
Vc
VuL / 2 80.325 Stirrups required over full half - span
2
101
Solution 5 – Cont.
Ln Vu 0 0.5Vc 4.2 497.7 0.5 0.75 188.3
x0 2.149 m 2149 mm
2 Vu 0 VuL / 2 2 497.7 80.325
L L
Lst Min x0 , n n 2100 mm
2 2
Maximum geometry spacing : Vud 388.4 3Vc 564.9 kN
s1max Min 0.5d , 600 mm 275.0 mm Case (a)
n d s
2
100
Start with two legs : n = 2 Av 2 157.08 mm2
4 4
16.0 Av f y
M inimum steel spacing : smax 2
M in , 3.0
f' bw
c
16.0 157.08 420
smax
2
M in , 3.0 513.9 mm
30 375 102
Solution 5 – Cont.
Av f y d 157.08 420 550
3
Required stirrup spacing : smax 110.1 mm
Vud
Vc 388.4
188.3 1000
0.75
103
Solution 5 – Cont.
Spacing Variation
Spacing may be increased provided it does not exceed any of
the two limits s 1max and s max
2
104
Solution 5 – Cont.
Spacing Variation
The total number of stirrups with first spacing is :
x2 1 881 1
n1 9.31 n1 10
s1 2 100 2
s1 100
Ls1 n1s1 10 150 950 mm
2 2
Solution 5 – Cont.
Spacing Variation
R2 1150
n2 7.67
s2 150
106
Solution 5a - Summary
Stirrups required over a distance Lst = 2100 mm (Half-span)
Use of two-leg 10 mm stirrups as follows:
1. Ten stirrups with spacing s1 = 100 mm. First stirrup located at
s1/2 = 50 mm (Ls1 = 950 mm)
2. Eight stirrups with spacing s2 = 150 mm (Ls2 = 1200 mm and
Ls1 + Ls2 = 2150 mm)
3. The extra 50 mm can be easily corrected by many ways, such as
adding one more stirrup at a spacing s1 :
4. Eleven stirrups with spacing s1 = 100 mm. First stirrup located
at s1/2 = 50 mm (Ls1 = 1050 mm)
5. Seven stirrups with spacing s2 = 150 mm (Ls2 = 1050 mm and
Ls1 + Ls2 = 2100 mm)
Total of 18 stirrups in half-span and 35 in the beam.
107
RC-TOOL Solution 5b
More Spacing Variation
R2 1150
n2 7.67
s2 150
108
RC-TOOL Solution 5b
Spacing Variation
Vu 3 250.08 kN x3 1246 mm
The exact distance used by stirrups with spacing s2 and their
number are:
s1 100
x2* x3 n1s1 1246 10 100 296 mm
2 2
x2* 296
n2 1.97 n2 2 Ls 2 2 150 300 mm
s2 150
RC-TOOL Solution 5b
Spacing Variation
110
111
RC-TOOL Solution
Total of 15 stirrups
in half-span and
30 in beam
(five less than in
solution 1)
112