Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2173-2184 020649 PDF
2173-2184 020649 PDF
2173-2184 020649 PDF
net/publication/320190676
CITATIONS READS
3 912
3 authors:
Jesus T. Ponce-Palafox
Universidad Autónoma de Nayarit
205 PUBLICATIONS 1,761 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Jesus T. Ponce-Palafox on 29 August 2020.
Abstract
Differences of meristics, morphometrics characters and length-weight relationship were
used to estimate the variability of wild and cultivated populations of the eastern river
prawn, M. nipponense in the populations in Iranian Basin of the Caspian Sea. Three
samples were collected from the northern and southern parts of the Caspian Sea in Iran.
Ten measurements which made for each individual were size-standardized by
allometric methods and principal component, and the resulting measurements were
analyzed by cluster analysis and discriminant analysis (DA). The results of cluster
analysis and DA indicated that the samples were clustered into two groups: the first
group included the Caspian Sea sample; the second included the Anzali Lagoon and the
third was Aquaculture farm sample. DA tests showed that morphometric, meristic and
length-weight relationship differences among the two groups were significant. At least
two morphologically populations of this species in the Iranian Basin of the Caspian Sea
were determined. This study also suggested that external morphological traits in M.
nipponense are variable and change markedly when exposed to different environmental
conditions regardless of their geographic origin and that extensive variation was present
among the populations studied.
waters (Bânârescu, 1990; Udekem- al., 2013; Chen et al., 2015a) and in
D’Acoz, 1999). This species is widely China on the genetic variation of wild
distributed in waters of China, Japan, and cultured organisms (Ge et al.,
Korea, Vietnam and Myanmar (Yu and 2011). However, knowledge of the
Miyake, 1972; Ma et al., 2012) whilst it genetic variability for the domestic
has been introduced to Singapore, populations were cultured with different
Philippines, Uzbekistan, Iraq and Iran models is limited. Many differences
from the southern and south-eastern were found in genetic content and
parts of the Caspian Sea (De Grave and morphometric of oriental river prawn
Ghane, 2006). Due to overfishing for populations in estuarine and freshwater
food, the wild stocks of M. nipponense in Japan and Taiwan (Liu et al., 2007).
are endangered (Feng and Li, 2008). In However, there is very limited
addition, the species is cultivated in a information on the structure of
wide range of systems to the extreme in populations and morphometric
the cooling reservoirs of several characteristic in Iran, where it was
thermal power stations in Russia, recorded since 1998 (De Grave and
Belarus and Moldova (Alekhnovich and Ghane, 2006). The aim of this study
Kulesh, 2001). In general, it has been was to assess to the morphometric,
established wild populations of this meristic characters and length-weight
species in basins, reservoirs and relationship variations in wild and
estuarine lagoon systems, offsite domestic populations of the eastern
original distribution. river prawn, M. nipponense in the
The species has high aquaculture populations of Iranian Basin of the
potential, as it can withstand in low Caspian Sea (Anzali Lagoon, southern
winter temperatures and can grow in Caspian Sea and aquaculture farms).
freshwater (Kwon and Uno, 1969). Due
to the M. nipponense habitat Material and methods
fragmentation and its high adaptability, Sample collection
the species seems to be useful for the Samples of M. nipponense were
study of shaping patterns concomitant collected from wild and domestic
to varying ecological conditions. In populations in three regions of Iran:
general, it has been found that the Anzali Lagoon (AL; 37 29´20.70”N;
genetic diversity populations of M. 49 19´44.30”E), Caspian Sea (CS;
nipponense grown in farms decease 37 27´52.72”N; 49 43´2.64”E) and
with generations (Ge et al., 2011). Aquaculture Farms (AF;
Iranian Journal of Fisheries Sciences 19(4) 2020 2175
mesh dip nets. The sex was identified the measurements were taken on the
and individuals were separated right leg. All measurements were made
accordingly. All samples were using a Vernier caliper (±0.05 mm).
measured in fresh conditions and Specimens with missing or regenerating
molted individuals with soft limbs were excluded. In the present
exoskeleton were excluded from study, the carapace length (CL) was
analysis. The freshwater prawns were used as a reference dimension because
identified to species according to Cai it was the easiest, fastest and most
and Ng (2002). reliable.
Morphometric relationships
Six hundred specimens were collected
at each site. In total, 1,800 specimens
have been analyzed using 11
Table 2: Morphometric, meristic and weight parameters of male, female and offspring specimens
Macrobrachium nipponense in sampling site by sex. X = mean±S.E; R = range; CV =
coefficient of variation; M = male; F = female; OF = offspring; CS = Caspian Sea; AL =
Anzali Lagoon; AF = Aquaculture Farm.
Downloaded from jifro.ir at 16:56 +0430 on Saturday August 29th 2020
2178 Tizkar et al., Study of some morphometric, meristic characters and length-weight relationship in…
Table 3: Relationships among carapace length (CL), total length (TL), and body wet weight (BW)
of Macrobrachium nipponense in Caspian Sea, Anzali Lagoon and Aquaculture Farms in
Downloaded from jifro.ir at 16:56 +0430 on Saturday August 29th 2020
Iran. M, male; F, female; TL, total length; CL, carapace length; BW, body weight; r 2,
correlation determination; n, no. of prawn.
Parameter TL=a+b(CL) BW=a(TL)b BW=a(CL)b
M F M F M F
Caspian Sea
a 0.0016 7.7078 0.00005 0.00005 11.217 0.0002
b 2.1127a 2.0942b 2.53b 2.9558b 1.9013b 2.9458b
2
r 0.9611 0.6753 89 0.8131 0.9652 0.8122
n 200 370 230 370 200 370
Anzali Lagoon
a 4.352 2.4907 0.000003 0.00001 0.00009 0.00005
b 2.0723a 2.4514a 3.2327a 2.9827b 3.0231a 3.2886a
2
r 0.981 0.954 0.9661 0.9655 0.9414 0.9223
n 340 370 340 375 340 367
Aquaculture farms
a 6.3139 4.2534 0.000006 0.000006 0.0001 0.0002
b 2.0187a 2.1519b 3.093a 3.0001a 2.984a 2.8129b
2
r 0.935 0.9399 0.9396 0.9332 0.933 0.9186
n 378 303 378 316 369 303
subgroups. The first subgroup included weight measurements were included in,
BW and the second CW mainly, and the analysis increased to 92.2%.
second group included TL and CL Therefore, the stepwise discriminant
mainly, at least two clusters were analysis retained ten variables that most
identified among the ten variables. discriminate the different populations.
When included only the morphometric These characters of primary importance
and meristic variables in the cluster in distinguishing between the three
analysis (Fig. 1a), similar result was populations where total weight (=0.36;
found that when the weight variables F=174; p<0.001), total length (=0.79;
are included (Fig. 1b). F=157.58; p<0.001) and carapace
length (=0.95; F=32.54; p<0.001). The
most well-defined populations were
from aquaculture farm and Caspian Sea
with classified individual percentage of
100.0% and 89.01% respectively,
followed by Anzali Lagoon (26.72%).
The number of misclassified individuals
from Anzali Lagoon assigned
aquaculture farm (85) was higher than
Caspian Sea. The confusion matrix
Figure 1: Dendrogram for characters for
Macrobrachium nipponense data set. a). indicated that 73.28% of population
Morphometric and meristic variables, and from Anzali Lagoon has morphometric
b). All variables.
characters similar with aquaculture
The stepwise discriminant analysis was farm population. This resulted in an
in two forms. First, single overall rate of correct classification of
morphometric and meristic variables, 92.2%. This analysis revealed that the
and second, the variables related to Linkage distances between the different
body weight. In the first case the groups were significant at 0.1%. The
analysis showed that the classification cross-validation procedures show that
of organisms in different environments 2,436 of 1,465 prawns (60.14%) were
was defined by the morphometric and correctly classified in their respective
meristic variables in canonical factor I group. The best proportion
and canonical factor II respectively and classification (100%) was obtained in
in the second case it was defined by aquaculture farm populations. A higher
proportion (58.46%) of misclassified
2180 Tizkar et al., Study of some morphometric, meristic characters and length-weight relationship in…
Figure 2: Plot of 95% confidence ellipses around sample from individuals (CS,
AF, AL) and group means of first two canonical scores, a).
Morphometric and meristic variables, and b). All variables.
Mirabdullaev, I.M. and Niyazov, hardwickii in the East China Sea and
D.S., 2005. Alien decapods Taiwan strait inferred by
(Crustacea) in Uzbekistan. Abstracts morphometric variation. Fisheries
of the II International Symposium Science, 70, 758-764.
Invasion of alien species in Holarctic Udekem-D’Acoz, C.D., 1999.
(BOROK-2), Borok, Russia, Inventaire et distribution des
September 27- October 1, 113-114. crustacés décapodes de l’Atlantique
Reist, J., 1985. An empirical evaluation nord-Oriental, de la Méditerranée et
of several univariate methods that des eaux continetales adjacentes au
adjust for size variation in nord de 25°N. Muséum national
morphometric data, Canadian d'Histoire naturelle, Paris.
Journal of Zoology, 63, 1429-1439. Patrimoines Naturels, 40, 1-383.
Salman, S.D., Page, T.J., Naser, M.D. Waldman, J.R., Grossfield, J. and
and Yasser, A.G., 2006. The Wrigin, I., 1988. Review of stock
Invasion of Macrobrachium discrimination techniques for striped
nipponense (De Haan 1849) bass. North American Journal of
(Caridae, Palaemonidae) into the Fisheries Management, 8, 410-425.
SouthernIraqi Marshes. Aquatic Wong, J.T.Y. and McAndrew, B.J.,
Invasions, 1, 109-115. 1994. Allozyme variation in riverine
Shen, H., Zhou, X., Bai, A., Ren, X. and lacustrine populations of
and Zhang, Y., 2013. Ecdysone Macrobrachium nipponense (De
receptor gene from the freshwater Haan). Aquaculture and Fisheries
prawn Macrobrachium nipponense: Management, 25, 393-400.
Identification of different splice Yu, H.P. and Miyake, S., 1972. Five
variants and sexually dimorphic species of the genus Macrobrachium
expression, fluctuation of expression (Crustacea, Decapoda,
in the molt cycle and effect of Palaemonidae) from Taiwan. Ohmu,
eyestalk ablation. General and 3, 45-55.
Comparative Endocrinology, 193, Zhao, X.Q., Ni, J., Chen, L.Q. and
86-94. Gu, Z.M., 2006. Analysis of
Soulé, M. and Couzin-Roudy, J., morphological variations among four
1982. Allometric variation. 2. populations of Macrobrachium
Developmental instability of extreme nipponense. Journal of Fishery
phenotypes. The American Sciences of China, 13(2), 224-229.
Naturalist 120, 765-786.