Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Derivations On The Young-Laplace Eqs
Derivations On The Young-Laplace Eqs
Derivations On The Young-Laplace Eqs
23-30, 2021
Original article
Keywords: Abstract:
Young-Laplace The classical Young-Laplace equation relates capillary pressure to surface tension and the
space curves principal radii of curvature of the interface between two immiscible fluids. In this paper
principle radii the required properties of space curves and smooth surfaces are described by differential
linear algebra geometry and linear algebra. The equilibrium condition is formulated by a force balance
and minimization of surface energy.
Cited as:
Siqveland, L. M., Skjæveland, S. M.
Derivations of the Young-Laplace
equation. Capillarity, 2021, 4(2): 23-30,
doi: 10.46690/capi.2021.02.01
∗ Corresponding author.
E-mail address: leiv.magne@siqveland.no (L.M. Siqveland); s-skj@ux.uis.no (S.M. Skjæveland).
2.1 Definitions
Arc length If f(t) is differentiable with continuous deriva- 2.2 Curvature of a normal section
tive in the interval [a, b], then the arc length L is defined Again, let r = f(u, v) a surface S and r = f(u(t), v(t)) a
by: space curve C on S. From the definitions, we have Kh = dt/ds.
Z b Multiplying by n gives
L =
ḟ(t)dt
a dt
n = K cos θ
where the dot denotes Rdifferentiation with respect to t. If ds
t ∈ [a, b] and we set s = at ḟ(t)dt, we get the arc differential
where θ is the angle between the principal normal to C and
ds = |ḟ(t)|dt = ±|dr|. Then s is a continuous function of t that the surface normal at the chosen point P (Fig. 1).
increases from 0 to L when t increases from a to b. Instead of Since n · t = 0, we get by differentiation
t, we can use s as a parameter to represent the curve. By this
arc length form, many formulas are especially simple, e.g., dt dn
n + t=0
|r 0 | = |dr/ds| = 1. ds ds
Tangent to a curve The vector t = dr/ds = r 0 is defined and thereby
as the tangent vector of the space curve r = f(t). Since |t| = 1,
t is a unity vector along the tangent of the curve. 1 dn 1 dn · dr
K=− t=−
Curvature The curvature K of a curve is defined by cos θ ds cos θ ds2
K = |dt/ds| = |d 2 r/ds2 | = |r 00 |, or simply K = |f 00 (s)|, the From the definition of n, we have ru n = 0, rv n = 0.
curve being on the arc length form. Differentiating with respect to u and v, we get
Radius of curvature The radius of curvature R of a space
curve C is defined by R = 1/K. ru nu + ruu n = 0, rv nu + ruv n = 0,
Principal normal to a curve The principal normal h of ru nv + ruv n = 0, rv nv + rvv n = 0.
a curve is defined by h = r 00 /|r 00 | = r 00 /K. Since r 02 = 1 it
follows that r 0 · r 00 = 0, and hence h is normal to t (and the Since
curve).
Normal of a surface The surface normal n to a surface dn = nu du + nv dv, dr = ru du + rv dv
at a point is defined by n = ru × rv /|ru × rv |. Here ru and rv
we have
denotes partial derivatives of r with respect to u and v, cf. Eq.
(2). The total differential dr is given by
dn · dr = ru nu du2 + (ru nv + rv nu )du dv + rv nv dv2
dr = ru du + rv dv = −(ruu n du2 + 2ruv n du dv + rvv n dv2 )
and for the space curve on the surface, u = u(t) and v = v(t). and we get
From the definition of t, dr is along t, and it is easily seen
that dr · n = 0. That is, n is normal to all curves on the surface 1 L du2 + 2M du dv + N dv2
K= (4)
drawn through the selected point. cos θ E du2 + 2F du dv + G dv2
Normal plane and normal section A plane through the when
normal to a surface, i.e., the normal is lying in the plane, is
called a normal plane. The cut between a normal plane and
the surface is a curve on the surface and is called a normal ds2 = dr2 = (ru du + rv dv)2
section. = r2u du2 + 2ru rv dudv + r2v dv2
Siqveland, L.M. and Skjæveland, S.M. Capillarity, 2021, 2(2): 23-30 25
Solving this equation we have to find the square root of dr1 = ru du1 + rv dv1 , dr2 = ru du2 + rv dv2
(EG − F 2 )(EN − GL)2 i.e., the principal curvature sections are orthogonal. (One can
ϕ(M1 ) = ≥0 easily show that this is the case also for FN − GM = 0).
EG
26 Siqveland, L.M. and Skjæveland, S.M. Capillarity, 2021, 2(2): 23-30
dr φ
t= = t1 cos α + t2 sin α
ds
dn dn dn
= cos α + sin α
ds ds1 ds2
N
and by scalar multiplying these two expressions,
Fig. 3. Equilibrium of a nonspherical cap.
dn
−K =t
ds
dn dn dn By summation, we the get
=t1 · cos2 α + t1 + t2 sin α cos α
ds1 ds2 ds1
dn K + K⊥ = K1 + K2 (10)
+ t2 · sin2 α
ds2 that is, the sum of the curvatures of two orthogonal normal
2 2 dn dn sections is constant, equal to the sum of the curvatures of the
= − K1 cos α − K2 sin α + t1 + t2 sin α cos α principal sections.
ds2 ds1
Since n · t1 = n · t2 = 0, we get 3. The Young-Laplace equation
dn t1 dn t2 The Young-Laplace equation may be derived either by
t1 +n = 0, t2 +n =0
ds2 ds2 ds1 ds1 minimization of energy or by summing all forces to zero. We
will do both here although the concept of force in connection
The curves C1 and C2 are embedded in two orthogonal
with surface tension may be somewhat obscure. The force
planes, t1 · t2 = 0, and t1 is independent of s2 . Therefore
approach follows the derivation of Defay and Prigogine (1966)
dt1 /ds2 = 0 and likewise dt2 /ds1 = 0, and we get Euler’s
and the energy approach is taken from the book by Landau and
result
Lifshitz (1987). In both cases it is assumed that the interface is
without thickness and that the interfacial tension is constant.
K = K1 cos2 α + K2 sin2 α (9)
Let us now choose another normal section at an angle 3.1 Force balance
α + π/2 with ds1 and denote the corresponding arc differ- Consider a point P on the surface as shown in Fig. 3, and
ential by ds⊥ since it is at an angle π/2 with ds. For the draw a curve at a constant distance ρ from P. This curve forms
corresponding curvature K⊥ we get from Eq. (9) the boundary of a cap for which we shall find the equilibrium
condition as ρ tends to zero.
π π Through P we draw the two principal curvature sections
K⊥ = K1 cos2 α + + K2 sin2 α +
2 2 AB and CD on the surface. Their radii of curvature at P are
2 2
= K1 sin α + K2 cos α R1 and R2 . At the point A, an element δ l of the boundary line
Siqveland, L.M. and Skjæveland, S.M. Capillarity, 2021, 2(2): 23-30 27
ρ
σ δ l sin φ ' σ φ δ l = σ δl
R2
since φ by assumption is small. Y
If we consider four elements δ l of the periphery at A, B, X
C, and D, they will contribute with a force
1 1
y
2ρσ δ l +
R1 R2
x
Since this expression by Euler’s theorem, Eq. (10), is
independent of the choice of AB and CD, it can be integrated Fig. 4. Surface in space.
around the circumference. Since four orthogonal elements are
considered, the integration is made over one quarter of a
revolution to give for ds2 ). Hence the surface element d f = ds1 ds2 becomes,
after displacement,
1 1
πρ 2 σ +
R1 R2
δζ δζ ∼ δζ δζ
The force on the surface element caused by the pressure ds1 1 + ds2 1 + ds ds
= 1 2 1 + +
R1 R2 R1 R2
difference over the surface is given by (p1 − p2 )πρ 2 , and
equating the last two expressions, the Young-Laplace equation
follows. i.e., it changes by δ ζ d f (1/R1 + 1/R2 ). Hence we see that the
total change in area of the surface of separation is
3.2 Minimum energy
1 1
Z
Let the surface of separation undergo an infinitesimal δf = δζ + df (12)
displacement. At each point of the undisplaced surface we R1 R2
draw the normal. The length of the segment of the normal
lying between the points where it intersects the displaced and Substituting these expressions in Eq. (11) and equating to zero,
undisplaced surfaces is denoted by δ ζ . Then a volume element we obtain the equilibrium condition in the form
between the two sufaces is δ ζ d f , where d f is a surface
element. Let p1 and p2 be the pressures in the two media, Z
1 1
and let δ ζ be positive if the displacement of the surface is δ ζ (p1 − p2 ) − σ + df =0
R1 R2
towards medium 2 (say). Then the work necessary to bring
about the change in volume is This condition must hold for every infinitesimal displace-
Z ment of the surface, i.e., for all δ ζ . Hence the expression in
(−p1 + p2 )δ ζ d f braces must be identically equal to zero and Young-Laplace’s
equation follows.
The total work δW in displacing the surface is obtained
by adding to this the work connected with the change in area 4. Space curves by linear algebra
of the surface. This part of the work is proportional to the We assume the space surface defined by z = f (x, y) to be
change δ f in area of the surface, and is σ δ f , where σ is the smooth as shown in Fig. 4 (Shifrin, 2013). A Taylor expansion
surface tension. Thus the total work is around a point (a, b) gives an approximation to the surface
Z around (a, b),
δW = − (p1 − p2 )δ ζ d f + σ δ f (11)
A new coordinate system (XY Z) is now introduced with By comparing Eq. (17) and Eq. (19) we find
origin in (a, b) and the (XY ) plane defined as the tangent plane
to the surface at (a, b). This gives αξ 2 ξ2
Z= =
2 2Rα
∂ f (0, 0) ∂ f (0, 0)
f (0, 0) = 0, = 0, =0 (14) and
∂X ∂Y
Since the surface is smooth, the order of differentiation is 1
Rα = (20)
arbitrary, and the crossterms may be added to render α
The curvature κ of a space curve at a point is defined in
Z = f (X,Y ) Section 2 as the inverse of the radius of curvature at the point.
The curvature of the parabola Z = g(ξ , 0) is therefore
1 ∂ 2 f (0, 0) 2 ∂ 2 f (0, 0) 2 ∂ 2 f (0, 0)
≈ X + Y +2 XY 1
2! ∂ X2 ∂Y 2 ∂ X∂Y κ =α =
1 Rα
fXX X 2 + fYY Y 2 + 2 fXY XY
=
2 Considering instead the (Zη)-plane (ξ = 0), the curvature
This may be reformulated as the matrix product of the parabola Z = g(0, η) is given by
1
κ =β =
1 fXX fXY X Rβ
f (X,Y ) ≈ X Y (15)
2 fXY fYY Y
A arbitrary plane normal to the tangent plane at the point
The 2 × 2 matrix in Eq. (15) formed by the partial deriva- (a, b), see Section 2, will cut the tangent plane (ξ η) along a
tives of f is symmetrical, the matrix can be diagonalized with straight line l : ξ = Kη where K is a constant (Fig. 5).
orthogonal eigenvectors (Howard, 1984), and the surface may The distance λ between the point (a, b) and a point (ξ , η)
be approximated by the matrix product on l may then be expressed by
1 α 0 λ 2 = ξ 2 + η 2 = K2η 2 + η 2 = K2 + 1 η 2
ξ (21)
f (X,Y ) ≈ g(ξ , η) = ξ η
2 0 β η
(16) Solved with respect to η 2 we get
1 1
= αξ 2 + β η 2
2 2 λ2
η2 = (22)
Here ξ and η are the coordinates along the new unit vectors K2 + 1
and α and β the corresponding eigenvalues. This is equivalent The cut of the normal plane and the surface f (ξ , η) is
to a rotation of the tangent plane around the Z-axis with the then
two new unit vectors (1 0)t and (0 1)t in the (ξ η)-plane.
In the (Zξ )-plane (η = 0), the function g(ξ , 0) in Eq. (16) 1 1
will form the parabola f (ξ , η) = αξ 2 + β η 2
2 2
1 1 1
Z = g(ξ , 0) = αξ 2 (17) = αK η + β η 2
2 2
2 2 2
1
2 2
K λ 1
λ2
(23)
Approximating the parabola with a circle of radius Rα , we
= α + β
get 2 K2 + 1 2 K2 + 1
K2
1 1
ξ 2 + (Z − Rα )2 = R2α = α+ 2 β λ2
2 K2 + 1 K +1
ξ 2 + Z 2 − 2ZRα + R2α = R2α (18) ξ
2 2
ξ + Z − 2ZRα = 0 ξ=Kη
and solved with respect to Z,
(ξ,η)
(a,b)
s
l
!
ξ2
q
Z = Rα ± R2α − ξ 2 = Rα 1± 1−
R2α η
ξ2
= Rα 1 ± 1 + 2 − . . .
2Rα
Selecting the minus sign and deleting higher order terms,
we arrive at the simple expression
ξ2
Z≈ (19) Fig. 5. Arbitrary line l through point (a, b) in the tangent plane.
2Rα
Siqveland, L.M. and Skjæveland, S.M. Capillarity, 2021, 2(2): 23-30 29
κ1 + κ2 = α + β (26)
dS = dl1 dl2 , dS0 = dl10 dl20 (31)
The sum of the curvatures of two normal sections in planes
also normal to each other is constant and equal to the sum of
the curvatures of the principal curves. where dl1 , dl2 and dl10 , dl20 are the length elements long the
principal normal sections before and after the displacement,
5. Surface energy and the Young-Laplace respectively. The length elements dl1 and dl10 may be written
equation as
We now consider the surface between two phases to be
infitesimally displaced by δ ζ . The volume element between
the two surfaces is δ ζ · dS where dS is the surface element. dl1 = R1 θ1 dl10 = (R1 + δ ζ )θ1
Let P1 and P2 denote the pressures in the two phases. The
work done by the volume change is where θ1 is the angle shown in Fig. 6. Then
Z
δWp = (−P1 + P2 ) δ ζ dS (27)
dl10 R1 + δ ζ δζ
The total work of the displacement also includes the work = = 1+
dl1 R1 R1
of changing the surface area by δ S and is given by
Similar expressions are valid for dl2 and dl20 . We substitute
δWσ = σ δ S (28)
for dl10 and dl20 in Eq. (31) and get
where σ is the surface tension. And the total work is
Z
δW = (P2 − P1 ) δ ζ dS + σ δ S (29) dS0 = dl10 dl20
δζ δζ
At thermodynamic equilibrium this work is equal to zero. = 1+ dl1 1 + dl2
It remains to express the surface area change δ S, R1 R2
δζ δζ
= dl1 dl2 1 + 1+
δ S = dS0 − dS (30) R1 R2 (32)
δζ2
in terms of the displacement δ ζ and the curvatures of the δζ δζ
= dS 1 + + +
principal normal sections, 1/R1 and 1/R2 . The surface areas R1 R2 R1 R2
before and after the displacement, dS and dS0 , respectively, are
δζ δζ
equal to the product of the length elements along the principal ≈ dS 1 + + , since δ ζ 2 << R1 R2
R1 R2
30 Siqveland, L.M. and Skjæveland, S.M. Capillarity, 2021, 2(2): 23-30
If this expression is substituted into Eq. (30) we get ς = length element along normal, m
ϕ, ψ, χ = function of (u, v)
δ S = dS0 − dS ρ = radius of cap, m
φ = angle, radians
δζ δζ
= dS 1 + + − dS
R1 R2 (33) Subscripts
δζ δζ c = capillary
= dS +
R1 R2 u = partial derivative with respect to u
This expression is inserted for δ S in Eq. (29) to give v = partial derivative with respect to v
α = constant
Z Γ = adsorption (kg surfactant/kg rock)
1 1
Z
δW = (P2 − P1 ) δ ζ dS + σ + δ ζ dS γ = interfacial tension, N/m
R1 R2
Z
1 1
(34) Vectors
= −Pc + σ + δ ζ dS
R1 R2 f = vector function, m
= 0, for all δ ζ r = radius vector, m
t = tangent vector, dimensionless
where Pc = P1 − P2 is the capillary pressure. Then, according i, j, k = unit vectors, dimensionless
to the fundamental lemma of calculus of variations Papatzacos h = principal normal to a curve, dimensionless
(1989), n = surface normal, dimensionless
1 1
−Pc + σ + =0 Acknowledgement
R1 R2
Discussions with Paul Papatzacos and Per Amund Amund-
and rearranged we get
sen are acknowledged.
1 1
Pc = σ + (35) Conflict of interest
R1 R2
The authors declare no competing interest.
which is the Young-Laplace equation.
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms and conditions of
6. Conclusions the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY-NC-ND) license, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the
The classical Young-Laplace equation has been derived by original work is properly cited.
detailing the necessary properties of space curves combined
with force balance and minimization of surface energy. References
Defay, R., Prigogine, I. Surface Tension and Adsorption.
Nomenclature London, UK, Longmans, Green & Co. Ltd., 1966.
[a, b] = interval Howard, A. Elementary Linear Algebra. John Wiley and Sons,
E, F, G, L, M, N = parameters defined by Eq. (5) 1984.
f = area, m2 Landau, L., Lifshitz, E. Fluid Mechanics. Oxford, UK,
K = curvature, m−1 Pergamon Press, 1987.
L = arc length, m Laplace, P. Supplement to the tenth edition. Méchanique
dl1 , dl2 = length elements, m Céleste 10, 1806.
dl10 , dl20 = length elements, m Papatzacos, P. Matematisk modellering. Kompendium ved
p = pressure, Pa Høgskolen i Stavanger, 1989. (in Norwegian)
R = radius of curvature, m Shifrin, T. Differential Geometry: A First Course in Curves
R1 , R2 = principal radii of curvature, m and Surfaces. University of Georgia, 2013.
s = arc length parameter, m Tambs Lyche, R. Matematisk Analyse II. Gyldendal Norsk
t, u, v = parameter, dimensionless Forlag, Oslo, 1962. (in Norwegian)
(x, y, z) = Cartesian coordinates Weatherburn, C.E. Differential Geometry of Three Dimen-
W = work, J sions. Cambridge, UK, Cambridge University Press,
α = angle, radians 2016.
δ = differential operator Young, T. III. An essay on the cohesion of fluids. Philosophical
δ ζ = infinitesimal displacement of surfaces, m Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 1805, 95:
σ = surface tension, N/m 65-87.
θ = angle, radians