Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tewari2000 PDF
Tewari2000 PDF
Objective: To evaluate the efficacy of adjuvant therapy for ferentiated cells, whereas yolk sac tumors show malig-
ovarian germ cell tumors. nant change in a cell line committed to extraembryonic
Methods: We reviewed records of women who had malig- differentiation.1 Immature teratomas are derived from
nant germ cell tumors of the ovary from 1977–1997.
cells predisposed to somatic (embryonic) differentiation
Results: Seventy-two women had surgical resections of
and recapitulate tissue from all three primitive germ
malignant ovarian germ cell tumors and most received
adjuvant therapy. Fifty-six women (78%) presented with
cell layers, ectoderm, endoderm, and mesoderm. When
stage I disease, and 16 (22%) had more advanced disease. considered together, the dysgerminoma, yolk sac tu-
Tumor subtypes included dysgerminoma (n ⴝ 20), yolk sac mor, immature teratoma, and their hybrid—the mixed
tumor (n ⴝ 8), immature teratoma (n ⴝ 29) and mixed germ germ cell tumor— comprise more than 90% of malig-
cell tumor (n ⴝ 15). Surgical management of the 56 with nant germ cell tumors.2 Nongestational choriocarci-
stage I disease consisted of total abdominal hysterectomy, noma, embryonal carcinoma, and polyembryoma man-
bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy, and extensive surgical ifest rarely as pure entities and comprise the remaining
staging in ten women, whereas a conservative surgical 5–10%.
approach, consisting of unilateral adnexectomy with or Although those tumors account for less than 5% of
without comprehensive surgical staging, was adopted in
ovarian cancers, their importance is greater than their
later years (n ⴝ 46). Fifty-six women were treated with
numerical incidence implies because they occur in chil-
postoperative chemotherapy, predominantly platinum-
based regimens. The 5-year actuarial survival rate was 93%.
dren and young women during the prime of life. The
None of the 36 women who presented after 1984 have died of median age at presentation is 18 years, contrasting
disease. dramatically with perimenopausal or postmenopausal
Conclusion: These data confirmed that platinum-based age associated with epithelial ovarian cancer.1–3 Symp-
adjuvant treatments allow most women with ovarian germ toms usually indicate rapidly enlarging abdominopel-
cell malignancies to have conservative surgery without com- vic masses. Approximately one-third of patients have
promising survival. (Obstet Gynecol 2000;95:128 –33. ascites, and 10% present with peritonitis secondary to
© 2000 by The American College of Obstetricians and torsion, infection, or rupture of the ovarian tumor.
Gynecologists.) Prepubertal patients might manifest signs of precocious
puberty, such as breast development or vaginal bleed-
ing, as a result of hormone production by the tumor.
In contrast with more common epithelial ovarian can-
cers that arise from the surface coelomic epithelium,
ovarian germ cell malignancies are believed to originate
from primordial germ cells that migrate into the go- Materials and Methods
nadal ridge at 6 weeks of embryonic life.1 Conse- After institutional review board approval, women were
quently, ovarian germ cell tumors might exhibit a identified by tumor registry abstracts and cross-
spectrum of histologic differentiation that mimics a referencing files from the Gynecologic Oncology Divi-
primitive developing embryo. For example, dysgermi- sion and the Departments of Pathology and Epidemiol-
noma appears to be descended from relatively undif- ogy at the University of California, Irvine—Medical
Center and Long Beach Memorial Medical Center.
Clinical data were abstracted and follow-up informa-
From the Division of Gynecologic Oncology, Department of Obstetrics
& Gynecology, University of California, Irvine—Medical Center, Or- tion obtained on all women up to death or for a
ange, California. minimum of 1 year after diagnosis and initial treatment
VOL. 95, NO. 1, JANUARY 2000 Tewari et al Treatment of Germ Cell Tumors 129
Table 2. Adjuvant Chemotherapy implants free of immature neural elements observed
1977–1980 1981–1986 1987–1997 along the mesentery, pelvic sidewalls, and encasing
VAC VBP BEP Total regions of the liver. Two women had macroscopic
Tumors evidence of residual disease and two others had micro-
Yolk sac tumor 3 3 2 8 scopic evidence of persistent disease. All four received,
Dysgerminoma 4 6 10 at minimum, second-line systemic therapy with a plat-
Mixed tumor 5 5 5 15 inum-based regimen, and three survived.
Immature teratoma 4 9 10 23
After initial treatment (ie, surgery with or without
Total 12 21 23 56
Severe toxicities* postoperative radiotherapy-systemic chemotherapy or
Dehydration 2 6 2 10 reassessment laparotomy), there were four clinical re-
Neutropenic fever 5 3 8 currences, one 10 years after diagnosis of an early-stage,
Sepsis 1 1 grade I immature teratoma. All four women had sec-
Pulmonary injury 1 1
ondary cytoreduction (n ⫽ 2) or second-line systemic
VAC ⫽ vincristine, actinomycin-d, and cyclophosphamide; VBP ⫽ therapy (n ⫽ 4), and three survived.
vincristine, bleomycin, and cisplatin; BEP ⫽ bleomycin, etoposide, and
cisplatin. Five deaths were associated with progressive disease
* Numbers denote total number of affected women requiring hospi- during initial systemic treatment (n ⫽ 2), noncompli-
tal admission. ance (n ⫽ 1), persistent disease at reassessment laparot-
omy (n ⫽ 1), or recurrence (n ⫽ 1). The two women with
disease progression included one with an advanced-
ondary to neutropenic fever, five of whom received stage, mixed germ cell tumor that did not respond to
vinblastine, bleomycin, and cisplatin. Among 22 fourth-line salvage chemotherapy and one with a stage
women treated with vinblastine, bleomycin, and cispla- I yolk sac tumor that did not respond to therapy during
tin, there was one case each of fulminant sepsis and the vincristine, actinomycin-d, and cyclophosphamide
bleomycin-induced pulmonary injury, both of which era. A noncompliant woman with a stage IA, grade II
responded to aggressive medical management in the immature teratoma who initially refused adjunctive
intensive care unit. There were no treatment-induced treatment also died of progressive disease. A woman
deaths among the women given postoperative chemo- with an advanced-stage intraperitoneal dysgerminoma
therapy. who received primary chemotherapy and had a posi-
Six women in the study (8%) were pregnant at tive second-look laparotomy subsequently did not re-
diagnosis. Five had unilateral adnexectomies between spond to salvage therapy and died of disease. One
10 and 26 weeks’ gestation, of whom one also received woman who relapsed after radiotherapy for dysgermi-
three courses of bleomycin, etoposide, and cisplatin noma had an occult focus of radioresistant yolk sac
from 26 –35 weeks’ gestation for metastatic dysgermi- tumor discovered at autopsy.
noma. They each delivered healthy infants beyond 35 Overall, 67 women (93%) are alive without evidence
weeks’ gestation. The sixth woman was diagnosed with of disease at a median (range) follow-up of 10.5 (1–18)
a stage IIIC mixed germ cell tumor and elected preg- years. The 5- and 10-year actuarial survival rates are
nancy termination at 18 weeks to begin adjuvant sys- each 93%, including 50 women (94%) diagnosed with
temic treatment immediately. stage I disease and 11 (85%) with stage III or IV disease.
After completion of postoperative first-line systemic All six women diagnosed during pregnancy are alive
chemotherapy, 50 of 56 women had apparent complete without evidence of disease 1–16 years since diagnosis.
clinical remissions with no measurable disease. Six None of the women who received etoposide as part of
women had disease progression during first-line sys- the bleomycin, etoposide, and cisplatin regimen have
temic treatment, three of whom were rescued with experienced secondary malignancies at 1–10 years of
second-line chemotherapy totaling 53 of 56 who had follow-up.
complete clinical remission after first- or second-line
systemic therapy.
Discussion
From 1977–1992, forty-one reassessment laparoto-
mies were done on women with no clinical evidence of Before 1940, treatment for ovarian germ cell malignan-
disease within 6 weeks after completion of chemother- cies consisted primarily of surgery alone, and survival
apy, predominantly in women with high-risk profile was rare.2 During the 1940s, the use of radioisotopes
malignant teratomas (n ⫽ 23). Second-look laparoto- and postoperative radiation therapy provided a sur-
mies were negative in 37 women, nine of whom showed vival advantage to some women with dysgerminoma.2
evidence of chemotherapeutic retroconversion (or in Unfortunately, the favorable survival with postopera-
situ destruction) of immature teratomas, with benign tive radiation of women with dysgerminoma was not
VOL. 95, NO. 1, JANUARY 2000 Tewari et al Treatment of Germ Cell Tumors 131
Table 3. Sustained Remissions Using Platinum-Based dotally we found that in addition to those with ad-
Chemotherapy vanced disease, women who were noncompliant with
Median therapy or whose tumors had occult mixed elements
Institution Remission follow-up (y) might be at risk of treatment failure and death. Exten-
Stanford University (California)15 9/9 2.5 sive patient education is essential, and detailed patho-
Cross Cancer Institute (Canada)16 13/14 3 logic sampling of the tumor is mandatory and should
Osaka University (Japan)17 4/5 2– 4.5* include at least one slide for every cm of maximum
University of Brescia (Italy)18 9/13 2
tumor diameter.
University Hospital Groningen (The 11/13 5.5
Netherlands)†19 Thorough surgical staging to confirm apparent FIGO
Royal Marsden Hospital (United 14/16 1.5, 2 stage I, grade I, immature teratomas or apparent FIGO
Kingdom)†20 stage I dysgerminomas also is crucial because it might
Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer 21/33 1.5, 3 identify women who can safely avoid postoperative
Center (New York)†21
chemotherapy. Higher-stage– higher-grade immature
University of Barcelona (Spain)22 13/14 4.5
M.D. Anderson Hospital and Tumor 35/41 0.75–7† teratomas, higher-stage dysgerminomas and all women
Institute (Texas)†23 with yolk sac tumors and mixed germ cell tumors need
Istituto Nazionale Tumori (Italy)24 16/24 5.5 postoperative systemic treatment. Women with malig-
Hellenic Cooperative Oncology 44/49 3.25 nant ovarian germ cell tumors in whom first-line adju-
Group (Greece)25
vant therapy fails might still be salvageable. They
University of California, Irvine 40/44 8
Total 229/275 should be referred to facilities where effective second-
and third-line regimens are available.
* Median follow-up not given in manuscript.
†
Denotes institutions that have reported their platinum-based expe- With the evolution of modern platinum-based che-
riences as part of two published manuscripts; the most recent citation motherapy for ovarian germ cell malignancies, most
is listed, and the earlier publication is contained within the cited
women will be able to retain their menstrual and
reference (a complete list of references is available upon request from
the present authors). reproductive potential after treatment. The efficacy of
chemotherapy now allows conservative surgery (ie,
unilateral salpingo-oophorectomy), with potential pres-
phosphamine (Gynecologic Oncology Group Protocol ervation of fertility. Modern treatment emphasizes
90). That observation is noteworthy because some of the shorter courses of chemotherapy and avoidance of
series listed in Table 3 had sustained remissions in prolonged exposure to alkylating agents, which charac-
women who received platinum-based regimens as part terized older treatment regimens and led to substantial
of second-line therapy. Salvage systemic therapy has ovarian toxicity. Women who retain one ovary might
proven to be curative in many women with refractory avoid sterility and premature ovarian failure, and the
ovarian germ cell cancers, including those who were attendant risks of accelerated cardiovascular disease
heavily pretreated, dramatically different from the dis- and osteoporosis.
mal biologic behavior of refractory and recurrent epi-
thelial ovarian cancer.
With an actuarial survival rate of 93% at 5 and 10 References
years, our data confirmed that effective adjuvant treat-
ments now allow most women with ovarian germ cell 1. Talerman A. Germ cell tumors of the ovary. In: Kurman RJ, ed.
malignancies to have conservative surgery without Blaustein’s pathology of the female genital tract. 4th ed. New York:
Springer-Verlag, 1994:849 –914.
compromising survival. The plateau of the survival
2. Williams SD, Gershenson DM, Horowitz CJ, Scully RE. Ovarian
curve beyond 5 years shows a cured population. The germ-cell tumors. In: Hoskins WJ, Perez CA, Young RC, eds.
observation that 11 of 13 women with metastatic stage Principles and practice of gynecologic oncology. 2nd ed. Pennsyl-
III and IV disease have gone into remission further vania: Lippincott-Raven, 1997:987–1002.
attests to the efficacy of combination chemotherapy, 3. Gershenson DM. Management of early ovarian cancer: Germ cell
and sex cord-stromal tumors. Gynecol Oncol 1994;55:S62–72.
particularly platinum-based regimens. None of the 36
4. Serov SF, Scully RE, Sobin LJ. Histological typing of ovarian
women in our series who presented after 1984 are dead tumors. In: World Health Organization. International histological
of disease. We have observed a modern revolution in classification of tumors. Geneva: World Health Organization, 1973.
prognoses rivaled only by the near complete curability 5. Thurlbeck WM, Scully RE. Solid teratoma of the ovary: A clinico-
of gestational trophoblastic disease. pathological analysis of 9 cases. Cancer 1960;13:804 –11.
6. Norris HJ, Zirkin HJ, Benson WL. Immature (malignant) teratoma
Ovarian germ cell malignancies are now highly treat-
of the ovary: A clinical and pathologic study of 58 cases. Cancer
able solid tumors. The nearly complete curability of the 1976;37:2359 –72.
disease makes identifying risk factors that portend poor 7. Staging Anouncement: FIGO Cancer Committee. Gynecol Oncol
outcomes after modern chemotherapy difficult. Anec- 1986;25:383.
VOL. 95, NO. 1, JANUARY 2000 Tewari et al Treatment of Germ Cell Tumors 133