DESIGN REVIEW - SUMMARY REPORT

Project Name: Proposed G+3P+16 (JVC16BMHR010) Client Name: Mr.Khalid Abdullah Islam Al Mutawa
Package No: Design Package Date: 30.07.17 Consultant Name: Sigma Art Engineering Consultants (SAE)
Project Status: EHS NOC-BP Submission Preparation

Document Type Review Purpose Code

Drawings B.O.Q 1 Major Technical Remarks
Design Review Report Conditions of Contract 2 Contrary to authorities requirments
Design Calculations Others (Specify) 3 Meet the requirements
Specifications 4 not identical with the approved drawings

S/n Drawing / Document ICA Review Notes Recommended actions CHC response as per received drawings on 30.07.17 Status

1- General
Draft Basis of Dessign report(attached); highlighted parts to be updated as
1.1 Basis of Design Basis of Design to be provided Open
per project design
Draft Thermal comfort design report to be updated as per project design.
1.2 Thermal Comfort Design Report to be updated as per project design Psychometric chart(from Heat load calculation) to be inserted in the Open
report.
2. HVAC

1. It is noted tha the building will be served through District Water Cooling hence
requirement for EER/Cop is not applicable and refrigerant to be used will be water and
is complying with 0 OPD refrigerant. 1. FAHU capacity shall be reconfirmed after considering fresh air
provision for retail areas. Refer to comment 2.4.
2. FAHU capacity is noted to have 10,340 lps. As per fresh air calculation the capacity is FAHU schedule to be updated to include all required specifications.
2.1 AC Equipment Schedule matching. However, the fresh air provision for retail areas to be confirmed. 2. Heat recovery efficiency is note to be 63%. Ok Open
Confirm the provision of fresh air for retail areas.
3. Heat recovery efficiecy to be specified in the FAHU schedule. Minimum 70% to be 3. FAHU schedule to include & specify the use of MERV 13 rated
selected. filters.

4. FAHU schedule to specify the use of MERV 13 rated filter

Building envelope to be designed to have efficient thermal conductivity. In order to

achieve energy savings from building envelope design, below recommended values to
be used:
Provide the Section U-value drawings and Window/Glazing schedule Provide the Section U-value drawings and Window/Glazing schedule
2.2 Section U-value Details External Wall - 0.05 BTU/hr.ft2 Open
showing the designed U-values as recommended. showing the designed U-values as recommended.
Roof - 0.04 BTU/hr.ft2
Floor- 0.07 BTU/hr.ft2
Glass- 0.30 BTU/hr.ft2
SC- 0.24

HAP Calculation No HAP files received. (please provide in pdf format).

HAP calculation files showing the U-values considered (as recommnded above) to be HAP calculation files showing the U-values considered (as recommnded
2.3 Open
provided above) to be provided
Thermal Load Summary Thermal Load summary sheet to be provided.

1. Note that it is required to ensure that all breathble zones in the

1. It is noted that only provision for chilled water will be prodvided for the retail areas.
Fresh air provision for retail area to be confirmed project should have provision for fresh air. Therefore, the provision
Please confirm the Fresh air provision for retail areas- note that minimum outdoor air
for fresh air for retail areas should be confirmed.
should be met as per ASHRAE 62.1-2007.
CO2 sensor to be shown on the gym area
2.4 AC/Ventilation Layout Open
2. Update AC layout to show CO2 sensors in the gym area.
2. CO2 sensor to be provided in the gym area
Inclusion of airflow monitoring device to shown on the roof ventilation
layout 3. Roof ventilation layout to be updated to include air flow
3. Roof ventilation layout to show the inclusion of airflow monitoring device on FAHU
monitoring device in the FAHU supply air side.

Page 1
 S/n Drawing / Document ICA Review Notes Recommended actions CHC response as per received drawings on 30.07.17 Status

BTU meter for the whole building is noted. In addition please show provision of BTU
meters for the retail areas.
Chilled water riser diagram to be updated to show all BTU meters
2.5 Chilled Water Riser Diagram Chilled water riser diagram was not updated. Open
provision including retails and apartment units
Also, confirm if BTU meters will be provided for each unit/flat and show the provision of
BTU meters.
Fresh air calculation is noted. CHC has made some changes on the
people/outdoor air rate used in order to match with the ASHRAE 62.1-
2007 space type as per the project design.
Outdoor air ventilation calculation to be provided to show compliance on fresh air
2.6 Fresh Air Calculations No updated fresh air calculation received. Open
provision for each breathing zone space as per ASHRAE 62.1-2007.
Retail area fresh air calculation to be included on the calculation. If fresh
air provision is not from building FAHU, a note in the calculation can be
added.
3. Electrical / Lighting

Automatic Lighting control system to be incorporated in the design in order to minimize Provide motion/occupancy sensors in all applicable areas such as lobbies,
the use of lighting when the space is not occupied or not in use stairs & corridors (all floors)

External light control (photocell or timer control switch) to be incorporated to Mention a noted in the lighting layout: All external lights to be controlled
3.1 Lighting Layout No updated lighting layout received. Open
automatically switch off the external lights when not lighting is not necessary. by photocell sensor or timer control switch.

Please confirm the lighting layout for podium floor lift lobbies as there are not lighting Update the lighting layout to show the lighting fixtures for podium floor lift
fixtures shown lobbies.

All lights to be installed on site should be high efficient. SAE to update the lighting legend to include wattages of following fixtures:
Lighting legend to be provided showing all the light fixtures to be installed on site with
3.2 Lighting Legend corresponding wattages. Mirror light No updated lighting layout received. Open
decorative light(chandelier)
wall mounted lights.

As per random checking designed LPD values are lesser than ASHRAE 90.1
baseline values apart from the apartment toilets and living room (which
Designed Lighting Power Density (W/m2) should be reduced atleast 20% lesser than the can not be confirmed due to unknown wattage).
3.3 Lighting Power Desity No updated lighting layout received. Open
baseline as per ASHRAE 90.1
Provide wattages for all lighting fixtures and ensure that the LPD acquired
will be 20% less than ASHRAE baseline.

Car charging point to be provided and installed (at least 2 nos.) in any of the LEFE Car charging point to be provided and installed (at least 2 nos.) in any of Provide at least 2 charging points in any of the parking spaces
prefered parking space provided. the LEFE prefered parking space provided. allocated for LEFE vehicles.
3.4 Power Layout Open
Mark the location of charging point in the layout Mark the location of charging point in the layout Charging point should be included in the load schedule

Single line diagram to be provided showing the provision for separate

energy meters for the following:
1. Lighting and small power load (landlord) As per received Single Line Digaram, separate energy meters should
Energy sub-meters to be provided to monitor the lighting and power load separately 2. Separate meter for FAHU be installed for the following:
3.5 Single Line Diagram Open
(for landlord use and retail use). 3. Separate meter for SCWP 1. HRAHU
2. MCC-CHWP
Also, the single line diagram should show the provision for meters
provided in each apartment units and retail areas.

Page 2
 S/n Drawing / Document ICA Review Notes Recommended actions CHC response as per received drawings on 30.07.17 Status

4. Fire Fighting
All fire supressants including foam types to be installed in the project should have 0 ODP Mention a note in the fire fighting layout for the requirement of 0 ODP Mention a note in the fire fighting layout for the requirement of 0
4.1 Fire fighting layouts Open
value value supressants. ODP value supressants.
5. Water Supply
It is noted that the doemstic hot water system in the building will be from electric
heater. Following maximum flow/flush rates to be mentioned in the water
supply layout.
Recommended water sanitary flow/flush rates to be incorporated in the design in order
to reduce water consumption at least 38% from baseline. Wash basin - 5.0 lpm
5.1 Water Supply layout Recommended flow flush rates to be mentioned in the water supply layout Open
Wash basin - 5.0 lpm Public wash basin - 1.5 lpm
Public wash basin - 1.5 lpm Kitchen Sink - 5.5 lpm
Kitchen Sink - 5.5 lpm Shower -6.0 lpm
Shower -6.0 lpm WC - 4/2.5 litres per flush
WC - 4/2.5 litres per flush

Provide irrigation layout showing the compliance for irrigation

Highly efficient irrigation system such as drip should be installed integrated with system.
5.2 Irrigation layout Open
automatic controls system such as timer and moiture sensor control. If irrigation design is not yet available, mention the requirement for
compliance in irrigation system in the Water Supply Setting Out plan.

* Note: All layouts to be sent in CAD format

Page 3