Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JCDP 23 991 PDF
JCDP 23 991 PDF
JCDP 23 991 PDF
A b s t r ac t
Aim: This study was conducted to comparatively assess the retention and vertical marginal fit of cobalt–chromium copings fabricated by the
conventional casting technique, 3D-printed resin pattern, and with direct metal laser sintering (DMLS) technique.
Materials and methods: Out of the total 60 test samples, 20 copings were obtained from inlay-casting wax and 20 from casting of 3D-printed
resin patterns. In total, 20 copings were obtained from the laser sintering technique.
All 60 test samples were then cemented serially on the prepared maxillary-extracted premolars and were evaluated for vertical marginal gap
in 8 pre-established reference areas. Retention was evaluated using a universal testing machine.
Results: Results obtained for both marginal gap and retention were statistically analyzed, and the values fall within the clinically acceptable
range. The DMLS technique proved precedence over the other two techniques used, as it exhibited maximum retention and marginal accuracy,
which is an area of prime concern.
Conclusion: The results from this study encourage further research with different pattern-forming materials and techniques and the need to
identify the factors that facilitate better marginal fit and retention of cast restorations.
Clinical significance: This study has myriad of applications in clinical dentistry mainly in decision-making for casting procedure to provide better
retention and marginal accuracy for fabrication of Co–Cr crowns. It also aims to aid the clinician to minimize errors by using different techniques
for fabrication of wax pattern as well as the coping, keeping abreast with the recent technology to evaluate the accuracy of 3D-printed resin
pattern over conventional wax pattern.
Keywords: Co–Cr copings, Direct metal laser sintering, Marginal fit, Retention, 3D-printed resin pattern.
The Journal of Contemporary Dental Practice (2022): 10.5005/jp-journals-10024-3399
Introduction 1–5
Department of Prosthodontics and Crown and Bridge, Bharati
The fundamental goal of fixed prosthodontic treatment involves Vidyapeeth Deemed University Dental College and Hospital, Pune,
replacement and restoration of teeth by artificial substitutes Maharashtra, India
ranging from the restoration of a single tooth to the rehabilitation 6
Department of Periodontology, Bharati Vidyapeeth Deemed
of the entire occlusion.1 University Dental College and Hospital, Pune, Maharashtra, India
Based on literature review, the largest prevalent cause of Corresponding Author: Bhagyashree G Kalsekar, Department
failure in crown and fixed partial dentures is the lack of retention, of Prosthodontics and Crown and Bridge, Bharati Vidyapeeth
amounting to 45% of the total failures, which can be attributed Deemed University Dental College and Hospital, Pune, Maharashtra,
to various causes like improper preparation of tooth and lack of India, Phone: +91 9890876681, e-mail: bhagyashree.kalsekar@
resistance form. Another most common cause of failure is poor bharatividyapeeth.edu
marginal adaptation leading to microleakage.2,3 How to cite this article: Kalsekar BG, Gandhi PV, Patil R, et al.
The survival of fixed prosthodontics particularly depends on Comparative Evaluation of Retention and Vertical Marginal Accuracy
the marginal integrity and retention.4 This is principally balanced of Co–Cr Copings Fabricated using Three Different Techniques: An In
by manual and laboratory factors, the latter playing an enormous Vitro Study. J Contemp Dent Pract 2022;23(10):991–997.
role. Manual errors being inaccuracy in impression-making, Source of support: Nil
inappropriate oral environment for impression-making, whereas Conflict of interest: None
laboratory factors comprising of incompatibility of dental materials
such as wax, die stone and casting investments, die spacer, and the
casting techniques. (CAD–CAM) technology has given an opportunity for fabricating
To overcome the manual and laboratory challenges, the metal prosthesis using alternate methods like milling, 3D printing,
advent of recent technologies like digitizing and automation and DMLS.7,8 The intraoral scanner helps in reducing the manual
has gained an important place in fixed prosthodontic treatment errors associated with impression-making, while the CAD–CAM
plan. 5 Several techniques of using Co–Cr for fixed prosthesis are and rapid prototyping techniques help reduce the laboratory
available today after the lost-wax technique that was introduced errors affecting the fit of the restorations.
by William Taggart in 1907. 6 In recent times, introduction of The proponents of these newer methodologies claim
computer-aided design and computer-aided manufacturing superiority over the conventional casting technique, but additional
© The Author(s). 2022 Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (https://creativecommons.
org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and non-commercial reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to
the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain
Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
Comparative Evaluation of Retention and Vertical Marginal Accuracy of Co–Cr Copings
studies to check the fit of these restorations prepared by these new Flowchart 1: Flowchart of the methodology of the study
techniques are required.
Literature states studies conducted on fabrication of Co–Cr
crowns and bridges using different techniques that have been
performed using metal and stone dies.
This study was planned to focus on the effect of conventional
and rapid prototyping techniques (3D printing and direct metal
laser sintering) on the vertical marginal fit and retention of
Co–Cr copings fabricated on extracted teeth which gains utmost
importance for application in clinical dentistry.
M at e r ia l s and Methods
An in vitro study was undertaken at the Department of
Prosthodontics, Bharati Vidyapeeth Deemed University Dental
College and Hospital, Pune, Maharashtra. The measurements were
done at Praj Metallurgical Laboratory, Kothrud, Pune, Maharashtra.
992 The Journal of Contemporary Dental Practice, Volume 23 Issue 10 (October 2022)
Comparative Evaluation of Retention and Vertical Marginal Accuracy of Co–Cr Copings
Figs 1A to D: (A) Surveyor with airotor attachment; (B) Protractor attached to the vertical spindle of the surveyor; (C) Completed tooth preparation
with 6-degree occlusal convergence (proximal view); (D) Occlusal view of completed tooth preparation
Figs 2A to C: (A) Conventional wax patterns for group A; (B) Group B 3D-printed resin patterns; (C) Copings of all the groups ready for cementation
and testing
The Journal of Contemporary Dental Practice, Volume 23 Issue 10 (October 2022) 993
Comparative Evaluation of Retention and Vertical Marginal Accuracy of Co–Cr Copings
mm of thickness. When all the layers had been built up, the solid to the circular ring attached to the cast coping in a universal testing
copings were retrieved from the machine, sandblasted, polished, machine at a cross-head speed of 0.5 mm/minute. The machine’s
inspected, and ultrasonically cleaned. Copings of all the groups software recorded the tensile force values required to separate
(groups A, B, and C) were ready for cementation and testing (Fig. 2C). the copings (N).
Figs 3A to D: (A) Digital stereomicroscope used for testing vertical marginal fit; (B) Testing of vertical marginal gap of each sample using a metallic
jig; (C) Marginal gap measurement for group A Co–Cr copings; (D) Marginal gap measurement for group C Co–Cr copings
994 The Journal of Contemporary Dental Practice, Volume 23 Issue 10 (October 2022)
Comparative Evaluation of Retention and Vertical Marginal Accuracy of Co–Cr Copings
The Journal of Contemporary Dental Practice, Volume 23 Issue 10 (October 2022) 995
Comparative Evaluation of Retention and Vertical Marginal Accuracy of Co–Cr Copings
the clinically acceptable marginal gap value as stated by McLean Future Directions of the Study
et al. and von Fraunher for groups B and C and Moldovan et al. for • Help the clinician decide which casting procedure provides
group A, respectively.13 better retention and marginal accuracy for fabrication of Co–Cr
In the present study, group A demonstrated the highest crowns.
mean marginal discrepancy among all the groups. The precision • Help the clinician get an idea about the errors that can be
of the scanner used to digitize the working models, precision of minimized by using different techniques for fabrication of wax
designing via computer software, and precision of the machine pattern as well as the coping.
used to fabricate the 3D design attributed to this difference in the • Help the clinician evaluate the effect of laser sintering on the
marginal discrepancy. retention and marginal fit of direct metal laser-sintered Co–Cr
The findings of the present study are in consensus with the work crowns.
conducted by Vojdani et al.,14 who observed the lowest marginal • Help the clinician evaluate the accuracy of 3D-printed resin
discrepancy for DMLS copings (group C) and highest discrepancy patterns over conventional wax pattern.
for conventional lost-wax technique.15 The reason for the highest
marginal discrepancy for group A attributes to multiple steps in
the production of copings, which maximizes discrepancies in the
C o n c lu s i o n
definitive product. Wax has a tendency to distort or warp when In this in vitro study, the Co–Cr copings obtained from DMLS
allowed to stand unrestrained. The use of 3D printing software technique show the highest marginal accuracy when compared
in group B compensated for the polymerization shrinkage and with conventionally cast copings obtained from inlay casting wax
increased the precision without any chance of manual errors during and 3D-printed resin pattern. The retention was least for copings
fabrication process, which led to a better marginal fit of group B obtained from the lost-wax technique followed by copings
when compared with group A. fabricated from 3D-printed resin pattern and copings from DMLS
The results of retention parameter in the present study state technique.
that the technique of fabrication does have an effect on the Within the limitations of the study, we can conclude that
retentive properties of the copings, irrespective of the cement the results encourage further research with different pattern-
used. Our findings are in accordance with Suleiman and Vult von forming materials and techniques and the need to identify the
Steyern,16 who concluded there was no significant difference in factors that facilitate better marginal fit and retention of cast
strength between Co and Cr crowns produced using production restorations. Further studies that better simulate oral conditions
technologies: casting, milling, or laser-sintering. In a study are recommended for optimized clinical success.
conducted by Krug et al., there were no statistically significant
differences in the retentive forces between conventionally cast, References
metal-sintered and milled FDPs.17 1. Rosenstiel SF, Land MF, Fujimoto J. Contemporar y Fixed
In the present study, GIC was used to cement milled metal Prosthodontics. 2nd ed. St. Louis, MO: Mosby Year Book; 1995.
and all ceramic copings. Although resin cements have maximum pp. 137–138, 170–173, 184–185, 229.
retention, previous studies assessed that GIC has also got 2. Goodacre CJ, Bernal G, Rungcharassaeng K, et al. Clinical
adequate retention.18 Recently, the study conducted by Choi et al. complications in fixed prosthodontics. J Prosthet Dent 2003;90(1):
evaluated the mechanical properties for Co–Cr alloy fabricated by 31–41. DOI: 10.1016/s0022-3913(03)00214-2.
conventional casting, 3D printing laser-sintered, and CAD-/CAM- 3. Selby A. Fixed prosthodontic failure: A review and discussion of
milled techniques. The results were in congruence with the present important aspects. Aust Dent J 1994;39(3):150–156. DOI: 10.1111/
j.1834-7819.1994.tb03083.x.
study showing that the Co–Cr alloy fabricated by laser sintering had
4. Rai R, Kumar SA, Prabhu R, et al. Evaluation of marginal and
the highest retention.19 internal gaps of metal ceramic crowns obtained from conventional
The significant difference in the retention values between impressions and casting techniques with those obtained from digital
the Co–Cr copings fabricated from lost-wax technique and direct techniques. Indian J Dent Res 2017;28(3):291–297. DOI: 10.4103/ijdr.
metal laser-sintered technique is because of the errors involved IJDR_81_17.
in technique-sensitive conventional casting procedure, precision 5. Abduo J, Lyons K, Bennamoun M. Trends in computer-aided
involved in the addition technique for designing of the DMLS manufacturing in prosthodontics: A review of the available streams.
copings, and manual errors involved in wax pattern fabrication. Int J Dent 2014;2014:783948. DOI: 10.1155/2014/783948.
6. Venkatesh KV, Nandini VV. Direct metal laser sintering: A digitised
However, there are very few studies to evaluate the retention for
metal casting technology. J Indian Prosthodont Soc 2013;13(4):
Co–Cr copings fabricated with different fabrication techniques. 389–392. DOI: 10.1007/s13191-013-0256-8.
Further studies are required for better evaluation and verification 7. Örtorp A, Jönsson D, Mouhsen A, et al. The fit of cobalt-chromium
of the values of retention obtained in the present study. three-unit fixed dental prostheses fabricated with four different
techniques: A comparative in vitro study. Dent Mater 2011;27(4):
Limitations of the Study 356–363. DOI: 10.1016/j.dental.2010.11.015.
• Marginal fit of copings was not determined before cementation. 8. Akova T, Ucar Y, Tukay A, et al. Comparison of the bond strength of
• Cemented copings were not subjected to thermal cycling. laser-sintered and cast base metal dental alloys to porcelain. Dent
Thermal cycling is one of the important factors that affect the Mater 2008;24(10):1400–1404. DOI: 10.1016/j.dental.2008.03.001.
9. Narula S, Punia V, Khandelwal M, et al. Retention in conventional fixed
long-term marginal fit of crown.
partial dentures. J Clin Diagn Res 2011;5(5):1128–1133. DOI: 10.7860/
• All the copings were produced and tested under ideal conditions, JCDR/2011/.1582.
which may not reflect conditions in daily clinical practice. 10. Junner RE, Stevens L. Anisotropic expansion of phosphate-bonded
• Polishing and finishing of the casting were done manually, which investment. Aust Dent J 1986;31:6434–6439. DOI: 10.1111/j.1834-
may also create some discrepancy in the casting. 7819.1986.tb01246.x.
996 The Journal of Contemporary Dental Practice, Volume 23 Issue 10 (October 2022)
Comparative Evaluation of Retention and Vertical Marginal Accuracy of Co–Cr Copings
11. Bezzon OL, Pedrazzi H, Zaniquelli O, et al. Effect of casting 16. Suleiman SH, Vult von Steyern P. Fracture strength of porcelain
technique on surface roughness and consequent mass loss after fused to metal crowns made of cast, milled or laser-sintered
polishing of NiCr and CoCr base metal alloys: A comparative study cobalt-chromium. Acta Odontol Scand 2013;71(5):1280–1289. DOI:
with titanium. J Prosthet Dent 2004;92(3):274–277. DOI: 10.1016/j. 10.3109/00016357.2012.757650.
prosdent.2004.04.021. 17. Krug KP, Knauber AW, Nothdurft FP. Fracture behavior of metal
12. Fransson B, Oilo G, Gjeitanger R. The fit of metal-ceramic crowns, ceramic fixed dental prostheses with frameworks from cast or
a clinical study. Dent Mater 1985;1(5):197–199. DOI: 10.1016/s0109- newly developed sintered cobalt-chromium alloy. Clin Oral Investig
5641(85)80019-1. 2015;19(2):401–411. DOI: 10.1007/s00784-014-1233-2.
13. McLean JW, von Fraunhofer JA. The estimation of cement film 18. Biscaro L, Bonfiglioli R, Soattin M, et al. An in vivo evaluation of
thickness by an in vivo technique. Br Dent J 1971;131(3):107–111. DOI: fit of zirconiumoxide based ceramic single crowns, generated
10.1038/sj.bdj.4802708. with two CAD/CAM systems, in comparison to metal ceramic
14. Vojdani M, Torabi K, Farjood E, et al. Comparison the marginal and single crowns. J Prosthodont 2013;22(1):3641. DOI: 10.1111/j.1532-
internal fit of metal copings cast from wax patterns fabricated by 849X.2012.00907.x.
CAD/CAM and conventional wax up techniques. J Dent (Shiraz) 19. Choi Y-J, Koak J-Y, Heo S-J, et al. Comparison of the mechanical
2013;14(3):118–129. PMID: 24724133. properties and microstructures of fractured surface for Co-Cr alloy
15. Bhaskaran E, Azhagarasan NS, Miglani S, et al. Comparative fabricated by conventional cast, 3-D printing laser-sintered and CAD/
evaluation of marginal and internal gap of Co-Cr copings fabricated CAM milled techniques. J Korean Acad Prosthodont 2014;52(2):67.
from conventional wax pattern, 3D printed resin pattern and DMLS DOI: 10.4047/jkap.2014.52.2.67.
tech: An in vitro study. J Indian Prosthodont Soc 2013;13(3):189–195.
DOI: 10.1007/s13191-013-0283-5.
The Journal of Contemporary Dental Practice, Volume 23 Issue 10 (October 2022) 997