Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Shorstkii 2015
Shorstkii 2015
3
Corresponding author. ABSTRACT
TEL: +65-831-261-00,
+7-967-652-5881; The application of pulsed electric field (PEF) as one of the nonthermal intensifica-
FAX: +7-861-275-22-79; tion methods has been proposed to increase oil yield extraction from sunflower
EMAIL: thegector@mail.ru seeds. PEF treatments have been carried out under various electrical parameters
such as electric field, pulsed frequency, pulse width, time of treatment and sample
Received for Publication April 30, 2015
Accepted for Publication August 6, 2015
conductivity. 55 fractional factorial design has been used for the analysis of the
impact of PEF parameters on oil yield, and oil yield square model parameters have
doi:10.1111/jfpe.12281 been investigated. The oil yield was found to increase by 9.1% after treatment of
sunflower seeds by variation of PEF parameters: 30 s under an electric field of
7.0 kV/cm having frequency of 15 Hz, solvent content of 40 wt% and pulse width
of 30 μs.
PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS
Here, we study the application of assisted pulsed electric field for oil extraction
from sunflower seeds and we find the most effective variation of pulsed electric
field parameters for treatment. It is very important in the industrial world as it
deals with the time, quality of production and cost, which are usually carried out
without preliminary treatment.
Journal of Food Process Engineering •• (2015) ••–•• © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. 1
PEF-ASSISTED OIL EXTRACTION FROM SUNFLOWER SEEDS I. SHORSTKII, M.S. MIRSHEKARLOO and E. KOSHEVOI
functional ingredients (Sarkis et al. 2015) has received Sunflower seeds were ground into powder in an agate
increasing interest during the last 10 years. Some reports mortar until particle size was less than 0.5 mm. Conductiv-
have found that PEF pretreatment could increase oil yield of ity of the samples was regulated by adding a liquid solvent,
maize germs (Guderjan et al. 2005) and olives (Kardjilova namely, bio-ethanol (absolute ethanol, 99.8%, Sigma
and Hlavacova 2013) by about 32.4 and 6.5–7.4%, Aldrich), in content ranging from 10 to 50 wt%.
respectively.
PEF treatment can improve oil yield as well as oil quality PEF Treatment
extracting from solid oil contain seeds. Guderjan et al.
(2007) reported that samples preconditioning before treat- Ground sunflower seeds were treated by PEF in a dielectric
ment, like moisture control of seeds, to increase conductiv- chamber, having two titanium top and bottom electrodes
ity during PEF treatment is required. (diameter 40 mm). Electrode gap was set as 5 mm to reach a
Soaking in tap water was used to receive optimal conduc- treatment volume of about 16 cm3, which is enough to
tivity of rapeseeds (Guderjan et al. 2007). However, drying obtain the required amount of samples for extraction
process is required after soaking, resulting in increased process. Square electric pulses were generated by a function
experimental time. Adding the solvent directly into the sam- generator (Agilent 33220A, Agilent Technologies, Loveland,
ple to increase the conductivity parameter of the sample is a Colorado 80537, USA) and amplified by a high-voltage
more efficient method that was used in the current work. amplifier (Trek COR-A-TROL 610D, TREK Inc, Lockport,
In summary, many reports have demonstrated the appli- NY 14094, USA) in range up to 10 kV.
cation of PEF for oil extraction from oilseeds as an intensifi- The chamber was filled with ground samples to form a
cation method, increasing oil yield. Although the effect of sunflower cake, and electrodes were fully covered. Positive
PEF-assisted intensification on oil yield of various oilseeds trains of pulses were applied to samples. The characteristics
has been studied in the literature, however, PEF-assisted of the applied electric pulses such as electric field, frequency
extraction of sunflower seeds with regulating conductivity and pulse width were monitored using a digital oscilloscope
as one of the nonthermal and more effective intensification (Tektronix TDS 220) with PHV 621 oscilloscope probe
methods and its impact on oil yield from sunflower seeds is (400 MHz, ×100). The experimental setup is shown in
yet to be investigated. Fig. 1a.
The aim of this work was to find the effect of different
PEF treatment parameter variations on the oil yield of sun- FFD
flower seeds with preliminary-adjusted conductivity via sol- Different variations of parameters were used in this study
vent adding. In addition, this study aimed to find the effect (Fig. 1b). Electrical parameter ranges were selected from
of each PEF parameter, such as electric field, frequency, sol- works based on PEF treatment of oilseeds, such as olives
vent content, pulse width and time of treatment, on the oil (Kardjilova and Hlavacova 2013), rapeseeds (Guderjan et al.
yield using fractional factorial design (FFD). The results of 2007) and sesame (Sarkis et al. 2015). As summarized in
oil yield were compared with control and treated samples. Table 1, a 55 (five levels and five factors) FFD (Ahnazarova
and Kafarov 1985) was used. A full replication would take
MATERIALS AND METHODS 55 = 525 runs. Hence, this design is a 1/25th rep = 525/
25 = 25 to test several factors with minimum number of
Materials trials. The effect of electric field (1, 3, 5, 6, 7 kV/cm), pulsed
Hulled sunflower seeds grown in 2014 in the U.S.A. were frequency (0.5, 1.5, 5, 10, 15 Hz), solvent content (10, 20, 30,
purchased at a local market (cold storage, Singapore). All 40 and 50 wt%), time of treatment (10, 30, 60, 90, 120 s)
seeds were stored in the dark at 4S until further analysis. and pulse width (10, 20, 30, 40, 50 μs) on oil yield was
Bio-ethanol (absolute ethanol, 99.8%, Sigma Aldrich, investigated.
Saint Louis, MO 63103, USA) was used as a solvent to adjust As a planning matrix, standard Graeco–Latin square was
conductivity of samples during PEF treatment. Hexane used (Ahnazarova and Kafarov 1985) as presented in
(n-Hexane, 99%, tech grade) was used as solvent during oil Table 2. Conductivity of samples was 30, 22.5, 15, 7.5 and
extraction. 3.5 μs/m for solvent content of 10, 20, 30, 40 and 50 wt%,
respectively. The PEF treatment was carried out at room
Moisture Content and Sample Preparation temperature, approximately 20C.
2 Journal of Food Process Engineering •• (2015) ••–•• © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
I. SHORSTKII, M.S. MIRSHEKARLOO and E. KOSHEVOI PEF-ASSISTED OIL EXTRACTION FROM SUNFLOWER SEEDS
FIG. 1. EXPERIMENTAL SETUP FOR PULSED ELECTRIC FIELD (PEF) TREATMENT (A); VARIATION OF PEF TREATMENT PARAMETERS (B): ELECTRIC
FIELD (E), FREQUENCY (F), SOLVENT CONTENT (C), TREATMENT TIME (Τ), PULSE WIDTH (W)
mined according to the method reported in Guderjan et al. Sunflower cake conductivity was measured and plotted
(2007). The PEF-treated sunflower seeds were heated to 40C over frequency. Because the phase angle was low, at least at
for 3 h in an oven to remove the ethanol. Subsequently, 2.3– frequencies above 100 Hz, conductivity can be calculated
2.5 g of samples was placed in a tube and mixed with 40 mL as:
of hexane. The mixtures were shaken in shaker at frequency
of 400 min−1 for 3 h at room temperature to extract the oil.
The extracted oils were filtered using filter paper. Finally, TABLE 2. FRACTIONAL FACTORIAL DESIGN, 55: THE EFFECT OF
DIFFERENT FACTORS ON OIL YIELD FACTORS: ELECTRIC FIELD, E;
hexane was removed by evaporation in a fume hood for
FREQUENCY, F; SOLVENT CONTENT, C; TIME OF TREATMENT, Τ; AND
24 h. PULSE WIDTH, W
Journal of Food Process Engineering •• (2015) ••–•• © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. 3
PEF-ASSISTED OIL EXTRACTION FROM SUNFLOWER SEEDS I. SHORSTKII, M.S. MIRSHEKARLOO and E. KOSHEVOI
σ = G ⋅l A (1)
Disintegration Index
The cell damage induced by electrical treatment can be
indirectly quantified by measuring the electrical conductiv-
ity of the sunflower cake.
This factor allows the determination of the charged par-
ticle concentration (Lebovka et al. 2002; Lebovka et al.
2004). The cell disintegration index, Z, can be determined
by the following equation:
Z = (σ − σ i ) (σ d − σ i ) (2)
FIG. 2. OIL YIELD FOR 25 EXPERIMENTS AFTER PULSED ELECTRIC
In this equation, σ is the electrical conductivity after the FIELD TREATMENT
4 Journal of Food Process Engineering •• (2015) ••–•• © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
I. SHORSTKII, M.S. MIRSHEKARLOO and E. KOSHEVOI PEF-ASSISTED OIL EXTRACTION FROM SUNFLOWER SEEDS
FIG. 3. THE DEPENDENCE OF CONDUCTIVITY, Σ, ON FREQUENCY RECORDED AT DIFFERENT SOLVENT COMPOUNDS (A) AND THE
FREQUENCY-DEPENDENT CONDUCTIVITY, Σ, OF SUNFLOWER CAKE RECORDED FOR SAMPLES WITH DIFFERENT SOLVENT CONTENT (B)
Journal of Food Process Engineering •• (2015) ••–•• © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. 5
PEF-ASSISTED OIL EXTRACTION FROM SUNFLOWER SEEDS I. SHORSTKII, M.S. MIRSHEKARLOO and E. KOSHEVOI
FIG. 4. (A–E) IMPACT OF PULSED ELECTRIC FIELD FACTORS ON THE SQUARE MODEL PARAMETERS (EXPERIMENTS RUN IN TRIPLICATE)
and Boussetta et al. (2015). From our experiments, the 40 wt% with treatment duration of 30 s and pulse width of
optimal value (maximum value at a5 in Fig. 4a) is 7 kV/cm. 30 μs.
• Frequency has also a monotonously growing effect. The results of this study show that treatment with pulsed
However, the impact of frequency is too small to be taken electrical field could be used as an intensification
into account. The maximum value of 15 Hz was obtained at nonthermal method to increase oil yield from sunflower
b5, Fig. 4b. seeds. The obtained results will be used in the future in food
• The effect of solvent content was found to have a processing technologies as a pretreatment method for larger
maximum value at c4, Fig. 4c, for 40 wt% of solvent. scale oil extraction from sunflower seeds.
• Optimal treatment duration is 30 s (at d2, Fig. 4d).
• Maximum effect value of pulse width (30 μs) was
obtained at e3, Fig. 4e.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Additional experiments were carried out in an attempt to The authors would like to thank the President of Russian
determine the oil yield value for PEF parameters after opti- Federation Scholarship for financial support. Thanks to Dr.
mization: E = 7 kV/cm−1, f = 15 Hz, C = 40 wt%, τ = 30 s, Maria Antipina from the Institute of Materials Research and
W = 30 μs. Obtained value of oil yield was 48.24%, which is Engineering (IMRE, A*STAR, Singapore), for providing
0.2% greater than before optimization. research training opportunity in IMRE. This work was sup-
ported by the Federal Target Program “Research and devel-
opment on priority directions of scientific-technological
CONCLUSIONS
complex of Russia in 2014–2020 years” (Unique No.
In this work, the effect of PEF treatment on oil extraction RFMEF157714X0046).
yield from sunflower seeds was investigated. The optimal
variation of PEF parameters was determined, and oil yield
REFERENCES
for those parameters was measured. Maximum disintegra-
tion index and oil yield of 42.3 and 48.2%, respectively, were AHNAZAROVA, S. and KAFAROV, V. 1985. Methods of
achieved for PEF-treated sunflower seeds at electric field of Experimental Optimization in Chemical Technologies (2nd ed.),
7.0 kV/cm having frequency of 15 Hz and solvent content of High School, Moscow.
6 Journal of Food Process Engineering •• (2015) ••–•• © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
I. SHORSTKII, M.S. MIRSHEKARLOO and E. KOSHEVOI PEF-ASSISTED OIL EXTRACTION FROM SUNFLOWER SEEDS
BONOS, E., CHRISTAKI, E. and FLOROU-PANERI, P. 2011. functional food ingredients at the production of rapeseed oil.
The sunflower oil and the sunflower meal in animal nutrition. Innov. Food Sci. Emerg. Technol. 8, 55–62.
J. Hellenic Vet. Med. Soc. 62, 58–70. HEGEL, P.E., CAMY, S., DESTRAC, P. and CONDORET, J.S.
BOUSSETTA, N., GRIMI, N. and VOROBIEV, E. 2015. Pulsed 2011. Influence of pretreatments for extraction of lipids from
electrical technologies assisted polyphenols extraction from yeast by using supercritical carbon dioxide and ethanol as
agricultural plants and bioresources: A review, pp. 1–10. cosolvent. J. Supercr. Fluids 58, 68–78.
BREVEDAN, M.I.V., CARELLI, A.A. and CRAPISTE, G.H. 2000. KARDJILOVA, K. and HLAVACOVA, Z. 2013. Effect of moisture
Changes in composition and quality of sunflower oils during content on the electric properties of spelled grains – T.
extraction and degumming. Grasas Y Aceites. 51, 417–423. Dicoccum. Open Sci. Reposit. Agric. online (open-access),
DEMURIN, Y., ŠKORIĆ, D. and KARLOVIĆ, D. 1996. Genetic e23050420.
variability of tocopherol composition in sunflower seeds as a LEBOVKA, N.I., BAZHAL, M.I. and VOROBIEV, E. 2002.
basis of breeding for improved oil quality. Plant Breed. 115, Estimation of characteristic damage time of food materials in
33–36. pulsed-electric fields. J. Food Eng. 54, 337–346.
DYMEK, K., DEJMEK, P. and GALINDO, F. 2014. Influence of LEBOVKA, N.I., PRAPORSCIC, I. and VOROBIEV, E. 2004.
pulsed electric field protocols on the reversible Effect of moderate thermal and pulsed electric field
permeabilization of rucola leaves. Food and Bioprocess treatments on textural properties of carrots, potatoes and
Technology, 7, 3-761-773. apples. Innov. Food Sci. Emerg. Technol. 5, 9–16.
EVON, P., VANDENBOSSCHE, V., PONTALIER, P.Y. and MORAVEC, C.M., BRADFORD, K.J. and LACA, E.A. 2008.
RIGAL, L. 2007. Direct extraction of oil from sunflower seeds Water relations of drumstick tree seed (Moringa oleifera):
by twin-screw extruder according to an aqueous extraction Imbibition, desiccation, and sorption isotherms. Seed Sci.
process: Feasibility study and influence of operating Tech. 36, 311–324.
conditions. Ind. Crops Prod. 26, 351–359. REGITANO-D’ARCE, M.A., ASSIS, R.P. and LIMA, U.A. 1994.
FINCAN, M. and DEJMEK, P. 2002. In situ visualization of the Functional properties of sunflower seed meal obtained by
effect of a pulsed electric field on plant tissue. J. Food Eng. 55, ethanol extraction. Arch. Latinoam. Nutr. 44, 29–32.
223–230. SARKIS, J.R., BOUSSETTA, N., TESSARO, I.C., MARCZAK,
GUDERJAN, M., TÖPFL, S., ANGERSBACH, A. and KNORR, L.D.F. and VOROBIEV, E. 2015. Application of pulsed electric
D. 2005. Impact of pulsed electric field treatment on the fields and high voltage electrical discharges for oil extraction
recovery and quality of plant oils. J. Food Eng. 67, 281–287. from sesame seeds. J. Food Eng. 153, 20–27.
GUDERJAN, M., ELEZ-MARTÍNEZ, P. and KNORR, D. 2007.
Application of pulsed electric fields at oil yield and content of
Journal of Food Process Engineering •• (2015) ••–•• © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. 7