Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Amare Tsegaye
Amare Tsegaye
Amare Tsegaye
PREPARED
BY:
1, Tesfaye Debele
2, Amare Tsagaye
3, Melkamu Lulie
ADVISOR:
ZERFU LUKU
1
A Senior Essay Submitted to the Department of Civics and Ethical Studies in Partial
Fulfillment of Requirement for the Degree of Art in Civics and Ethical Studies.
JUNE: 2023
WOLKITE, ETHIOPIA
Contents
CHAPTER ONE........................................................................................................................................4
CHAPTER TWO.....................................................................................................................................10
2
2.3.3. Psychological violence..........................................................................................................13
2.5.2. Effects of forced and child marriage violence against women right....................................18
CHAPTER THREE.................................................................................................................................19
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY............................................................................................................19
3
CHAPTER ONE
1 INTRODUCTION
This study will examine the relationship between women and child practices by public
sectors working within Guraghe zone and violation women rights. This research will help
public managers understand the practices of their women protection decisions on the risk
of women right violation that their organization may experience. When public policy
decision makers know the relationship between women and child policy provision and
women right violation, this information can guide their plan for protecting women right
decisions to avoid the risk of experiencing future violation of women right.
Effective women right protection decisions can improve their workers' immediate right
protection situation through empowering women and strengthening community members
leading to a positive social change in workers’ living conditions. This chapter provides
the women right violation that this study will search to address as well as the purpose of
the study. This chapter specifies the research questions, the research objectives, and the
limitation and the scope of the study
Even though UN and national governments agreed to eliminate violence against women’s
right through different conventions and policies, the violation of women rights have
perpetuated in most parts of the world (Dekerssa 2000). The violations of the rights
4
include psychological, physical and sexual harassments. Beyond, traditional practices
such as forced female genital mutilation also harm women (Dekerssa 2000).
In Africa the problem of violence against women right wide spread, but violence against
still largely hidden. Ethiopia is no exception. Women right violation has been aggravated
by the performance of the system of patriarchy that women subordinated and subjugated
to men dominance. Thus, violence against women is generally accepted as the cultural
norms in African societies and not often concerned by community and even sometimes
by the leader (Bergen, 1999).
In Ethiopia, there is high level of prevalence of violence against women (Emebet, 2010).
Both urban and rural women have been exposed to physical beat by their husbands or/and
counter men. However, evidences revealed that the court in Ethiopia does not tend to
consider violence as serious justification for granting a divorce (Bergen, 1999). The
implementation of women policy is critical to the protection of the women rights as it
influences the reduction and elimination of the violation of women right. Equally, the
failure of practices of women policy can lead to the rising of women’s right violation.
Some empirical studies have investigated this relationship between women and child
policy practices and women’s rights protection or violation. Ojulu (2015) found a
significant negative relationship between women and child policy practices and violation
of women right in Gambela town. On the other hand, Melkamu (2010) argued that the
practices of women and child policy in Guraghe zone did not affect violation of women
right.
The studies undertaken on the relationship between women and child policy and violation
of women rights have mostly been broken into two features. The first feature investigates
the effect of gender mainstreaming determinants in determining the women and child
policy practices at play (Ojulu, 2015). The other aspect examines the relationship
between policy elements and their effect on economic and social development is
indeterminate (Melkamu 2010). There is no knowledge of the association between
women and child policy implementation and the women rights violation level of city
administrations such as Wolkite. The trend and pattern between women and child policy
5
implementation, and women rights violation is presently unknown. There has been no
study for public sector organizations operating in Wolkite town to identify such a trend
of policy practices and its effects on women rights’ violation is vital. However, there is
no knowledge of the local-specific factors that might influence the relationship between
policy practice and Women rights violation in wolkite town.
The lack of understanding of this association can lead policy decision makers to make
women rights protection decisions that can place their public sector organization into
violation of women’s rights in their context. That can lead to public organizations
practice unnecessary women’s right violation and face the possibility of social and
economic failures. Thus, this study intends to examine this association between women
and child policy practices and women’s right violation to help decision makers make
improved women’s right protection decisions.
An accepting of the association between the current women and child policy practice and
women’s right violation could assist policy decision makers in escaping their
6
organization falling into women’s right violation through enhanced women’s right
protection decisions.
African union in 2003 adopted the protocol on the rights of women in Africa and set out
right of women in the public and private sphere. Similarily, Ethiopia under take
significant gender sensitive reforms and laws since 1991 ( Fikiremorkos 1999) among
these law are 1995 federal democratic republic of Ethiopia constitution, the 2003 revised
family law and revised criminal code have publicized the need for eliminating women’s
right violation. The codes address violence against women in different forms, by
expanding the exits vague provision, by introducing name offices by redefine the element
of this and by aggregate circumstances of violation ( ibid). According to the criminal
code of 2004 most of violence against women and girls include rape, trafficking women,
prostitutions and physical violence with in marriage (criminal code 2004). The code calls
for protection the aforementioned women’s right violation in Ethiopia. Despite the
prevailing international conventions and national public policy that aim to eliminate
violence against women right why violation of women right have grown? Guraghe Zone
in general and Wolkite town in particular are no exception. However, the root causes for
failures of international conventions and national women policy on preventing women’s
right violation at the grass roots level such as Wolkite town are not clearly identified.
There is a lack of research regarding the relationship that may exist between public policy
practice and violation of women right in Ethiopia particularly in Guragahe zone.
Thus, this study will be conducted to investigate violence against women’s right in
Wolkite town and to address knowledge gap on this aspect. So, this research will fill the
gaps mentioned above and will provide suggestions on how to reduce women’s right
violation in the study area.
7
1.3.2. Specific objectives
Specific Objective of the study will include:
1. To identify the type of violence against women's right in Wolkite town.
4. To analyze the relationship between women and child policy and level of
women’s rights protection in Wolkite town.
2. What are the root causes of women’s right violation in Wolkite town?
4. How does women and child policy practices and level of women’s rights protection
relate in Wolkite town.?
8
because women are most vulnerable social group. Then solving and the un solved
problem desire to understand causal relationship and social thinking and can gain enough
information in the study area.
9
CHAPTER TWO
Globally, the victims of violence are over whelming women and women tend to
experience more sever forms of violence (WHO, 2012). violence occurs when the abider
believes that abuse is acceptable justified or unlikely to be reported (ibid). According to
Sicilian (2002) violence is a conduct which demands and enforced obedience,while
humiliating and degrading the victims using forces or threat to used force(WHO).
Violence can be seen as any how of force or coercion that gravely jeopardizes the life or
freedom of a person anti-family or kinship ( ibid ). Some human right activists prefer
abrade definition of violence against women right includes ‘’structural violence’’ such as
poverty and unequal access to health and education (Graham and Guar 1969). Violence
against women is any act of gender based violence that results in physical, sexual or
psychological harm or suffering at whole ( ibid )
10
Resource Theory is the theory that all social relationships are based on an assumption of
force or a threat of force (Kenny, Fotaki, & Scriver, 2019). It theorizes that the more
resources that are available to an individual ,the greater the threat of force, but the less
likelihood that force/violence will be used in that relationship (Walters, Basile, & Hall,
2013). It does not mean that no threat will be used to maintain control, it means that
physical violence will not be used. Rather the violence that a woman may experience in
this situation is not physical violence but rather emotional violence. However, when
someone has fewer resources, they can only resort to force/violence to maintain control
Social Exchange Theory is the theory that people seek the highest reward while putting in
the least amount of effort while in a social relationship (Kreager, Felson, Warner, &
Wenger, 2013). As it pertains to violence against women, violence is used when the
reward of gaining control is worth the effort and potential legal consequences (Resko,
2010). Although there are laws against abuse, this does not always prevent abuse. This
occurs for a multitude of reasons.
Many women, when reporting abuse, are re-victimized and accused of putting themselves
in that situation (Vidales, 2012). This attempt to justify gender based violence not only
harms the victim further by blaming her for the violent actions of another human being,
but also encourages more violence from the perpetrator because society is essentially
condoning the violence. Without cultural retribution against the violence, the effort of
violence costs nothing but gives the perpetrator control.
11
2.2.Definition of violence against women right
Violence is physical, sexual and psychological violence occurring in the family,
including battering sexual abuse of female in the house hold, dowries related violence,
marital rape, female genital mutilation and other traditional practices harmful to women
(UN, 1993). The world health organization defined violence as ‘’the range of physically,
psychologically and sexually coercive acts used against adult and adolescent women by
current or former male intimate partners (WHO 2003).
Violence can be defined as a pattern of abusive behavior in any relationship that is used
by one partner to gain or maintain power and control over another intimate partner(ibid).
Traditionally, violence was mostly associated with physical violence. violence is no
commonly defined broadly to include all acts. Physical,sexually, psychological or
economic violence (Hanna cheery 2002) .
Violence is the will full intimidation physical assault battery sexually assault and or
other abusive behavior as a part of a systematic pattern of power and control perpetrated
by one intimate partner against another (Caldwell , 2012). Violence against women's
right can be happen to anyone regardless of race, age, sexual orientation, religion or
gender. violence affects people of all–economic back ground and education levels
(WHO) 1997). It varies from community and the pattern of the violence affected by the
different socio –economic and cultural factors ( Ibid). Generally, violence is an act which
results in harasses, harms, injuries or endangers the aggrieved person with view to coerce
her or any other person related to meet any unlawful demand (National Crime statistics,
p.196)
12
2.3.1. Physical violence
The dynamic of physical violence in relationship are of then complex, because of
physical violence can be the culmination of other abusive behavior such as threats,
intimidation and restriction of victim self- determination through isolation and other
limitations of personal freedom (WHO 2023).This form of violence is usual in that many
women are suffering from it. Physics violence is the intentional use of physical force with
the potential of causing injury, harm. Disabilities or death ( D.EWAL, 2002). For
example, Hitting, biting, and kicking by one member of the house holds against other
partner (Ibid). Defying medical care, sleep deprivation and forced drug alcohol use are
forms of physical abuse.It can include inflicting physical injury, onto other targets, such
as children or pets, inorder to cause emotional harm to victims.During pregnancy, a
woman is at higher risk to be abused or long standing abuse may change insecurity,
causing negative health effects to the mother and fetus.Prignancy can also lead to ahiatus
of violence, when the abuser does not want to harm the unborn child.The risks of
violence for women who have been pregnant is greatest immediately after child
birth(Graham, 1999). According to Human Rights Watch,honor killings are generally
performed against sexually assault, seeking a divorce(HRW).
In many cultures, victims of rape are considered to have brought 'dishonour' or 'disgrace'
to their families and face severe familial violence, including honor killings.This is
especially the cause if the victims becomes pregnant.Female genital mutilation is defined
by world health organization as "all procedures that involved partial or total removal of
13
the external female genitalia, or other injury to the female genital organ for non medical
reasons".This procedure has been performed on more than 125 million females alive
today, and it is concentration in 29 countries in African and middle east (Ibid).
Incent, or sexual contact between adult and child is one form of familial sexual violence.
In some cultures, the are ritualized forms of child sexual abuse taking place with the
knowledge and consent of the family, where the child is induced to engage in sexual act
with adults, possibly in exchange for money or goods (Robert 2007).
Among victims who are still living with their perpetrators high amounts of stress, fear,
and anxiety are commonly reported on the violence of against women. Depression is also
common, as are made to feel guilty for 'provoking' the abuse and are frequently subjected
to intense criticism. Victims of violence also commonly experience long term anxiety
and panic disorder .The most commonly referenced psychological effect of violence is
post traumatic stress dis order. Post traumatic stress disorder as experienced by victims is
characterized by flash backs, intrusive images, exaggerated startle response, night mares,
and avoidance of triggers that are associated with abuse(Hanna, 2002).
Studies have indicated that it is important to consider to the effect of violence and psyco-
physiologic sequel on women who are mothers of infants and young children. Several
studies have shown that maternal interpersonal violence related post traumatic stress
14
disorder can despite traumatized mother's best efforts, interfere with their child's response
to the violence and other traumatic events(Robert, 2007).
Economics abuse (or financial abuse) is form of abuse when one intimate partners has
control over the other partner's access to economic resources. Disagreement about money
spent can result in retaliation with additional physical, sexual, emotional abuse. In parts
of the world where women depend on husband's income in order to survive (due to lack
of opportunities for female employment and lack of state welfare) economic abuse can
15
have very severe consequences. Abusive relations have been associated with malnutrition
among both mothers and children(Taylor -Brownie,2001).
The marriage convention addressees the issues of age according to article (2) of the
convention’’ states parties to the present convention shall take legislative action to
specify minimum age for marriage no marriage shall be legally entered to by any person
under this age, except where competent authority has granted dispensation as to age, for
serious reasons, in the interest of the intending spouses (Graham, 1969). Forced and child
marriage mainly affects young women and girls, although there are causes of young men
and boys being forced to marry, especially if there are concerns about his sexual
orientation (WHO, 2011).
16
Cultural factors of violence against women right, women who are most dependent on the
spouse for economic well being (home makers, house wives women with hand caps un
employed) and are the primary care giver to their children fear the increased financial
burden ( UN) 1981).Some people with very traditional beliefs may think they have the
right to control their partner and that women are not equal to men. Others may have
undiagnosed personality disorder or psychological disorder. Still others may have learned
this behavior from growing up in a house hold where violence was accepted as a normal
parts of being raised in their family ( ibid).
A partner’s domination may take the form of emotional, physical or sexual abuse
(Charles 2000). Studies suggest that violent behavior often is caused by an interaction of
situational and individual factors. That means that abusers learn violent behavior from
their family, people in their community and other cultural inferences as they grown up
they many have seen violence often or they may have been victims themselves. Some
abusers acknowledge growing up having been abused as a child ( ibid).
Boys who learn that women are not to be valued or respected and who see violence direct
against women are more likely abuse women when they grow up ( DV ewla, 2008). Girls
who witness violence in their families of origin are more likely to be victimized by their
own husbands. Although women are most gender roles can and are reversed sometimes
(Ibid).
Marriage can also be used to settle a debt, or to streaming then family or caste status
through social alliances. Fears about sexual activity before marriage, or fears about
17
rumors about such activity ruining a daughters opportunity to marry well also fuel early
and forced marriage ( UN1998).
The legal instability to obtain a divorce is also a factor in the proliferation of violence.In
some culture where marriage are arranged between families ,a women who attempts a
separation or divorce with out the consent of her husband and extended family or relative
may risk being subjected to "honor" based violence(Graham,1999).
18
2.5. Effects of violence against women right
The violence against women right has number of terrible or adverse effects on the
victim, women or her children’s and on society at large. The main effect of violence
against women right is the following.
Furthermore violence against women right has different health effects on women
physical health outcomes including injury, unwanted pregnancy, and gemological
problems including HIV/ AIDS, miscarriage and pelvic pain. Mental health problems
including depression, fear, anxiety, low self esteem, sexual dysfunction, easting
problems, obsessive compulsive disorder past basmati stress disorder ( who consultation
1996).
2.5.2. Effects of forced and child marriage violence against women right
Forced and child marriage have severe psychological, emotional, medical, financial, and
legal consequences. Victims tend to be isolated from their peers and friends. They rarely
have access to social services that could assist them ( Girma,1999).
Early marriages often interrupt a victim’s education. This deprives them of their right to
education, as well as limits any possibility of economic independence from an unwanted
marriage. Forced and child marriages are also more likely to became violent, because the
relationship is bases on the power of one spouse over the other (Ibid).
19
2.5.3. Economic cost of violence against women right
violence against women is widely recognized as serious problem of human right against
women that affects millions of world women. In recent year economist, human right
advocates and government have also became aware of severe financial and economic.
Burden that violence impose an victims, households, public sectors, private business and
society as a whole ( WHO consultant 1996). Violence perpetrated by on intimidate
partner is the most common form of violence experienced by women. More over the
spread prevalence of violence is not limited to the particular society or region, but it is
global phenomena (Ibid).
Violence against women and girls bring huge economic costs to any society. The
negative impact on women's participation in education, employment and civic life
undermine poverty reduction .It results in lost employment and productivity,and its drains
resource from social service, the just system, health care agencies and employe (Mergan
R,2008).
20
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Wolkite town is one of the seven towns under Gurage zone in South Nations and
Nationalities of Peoples Regional State. Particularly it is found to the north west of South
Nations and Nationalities of Peoples regional state in Ethiopia. In the north and east it is
bounded by Oromia regional state.
Wolkite town is between Jimma and Addis Ababa. The administrative center of the
gurage zone of the Southern Nation ,Nationalities and People's Region(SNNPR),this
town has a latitude and longitude of 8° 17' N 37°47' E and an elevation between 910 and
935 above sea level. It is surrounding by Kebena woreda and it is a part of former Goro
woreda. Thus, majority of the rural kebeles of Gurage zone are locating far away from
the town. Currently, the total area of the district is 2,203.32 Sq.
According to BOFED (2011), regional statistical data information the total population of
Wolkite district are 79,392 among which male 39,806 and 39,586 are females, from those
urban populations are 10,485 among which male 5,145 and 5,340 are females and, rural
populations were 68,907 among which male 34,661 and 34,246 will be females within
the density of 360 Sq. Km..
The proposal {study} will employs both qualitative and quantitative method. The
qualitative research is typically used to answer questions about the complex nature of
phenomena often with the purpose of describing and understanding the phenomena from
the participant point of view. The reason, is that qualitative method is used to find data,
information and the design also given to the information opportunity to share long time or
relatively experience on the issue or violence against women right and problems related
with it and enabling factors.
21
In addition to this the quantitative methods also employ this research. So using mixed
method can be used full to developed richer pictures of the phenomena under
investigation.
In our research we will be used both primary and secondary data sources. The sources of
secondary data include both published and unpublished materials, news paper, books and
Internet. Source of primary data includes Questionnaire and interview method. The
researcher used questioner and interview methods in order to collect reliable information.
This study will use both interview and questionnaire of data collection. Interview is to get
reliable information to be contacting face to face with respondents. Whereas,
questionnaire used to collect necessarily information by giving prepare questions. It helps
to collect information on, which the respondent does not want to express the truth
information by verbal expression. The main reason for using this method is because of
its being quickly, easily, and the respondent can express freely. {Only Questionnaire?!}
In this research proposal we will use both probability and non probability sampling.
Probability sampling is one of a technique in which each element of the population have
equal chance. Whereas non probability is a type of purposive technique.It is one that was
selected based on the knowledge of the population. {Why you intended to use these
sampling methods?}
22
This formula, n=N/1+N (e) 2,Where, n=Sample size, N=total population, e= significance
point (error tolerance) . Let the confidence interval is 85%, Sample error is 0.15,then
the sample size were determined as follows. Total population =24,214 error is =0.15,
n=N/1+N(e)2. n=N/1+N(e)2=24,214, n=44.44.
The researcher is focused on the formula,and selected 44, respondents from different
sectors and society, that they have enough information about the researcher’s issue. The
researcher selected 15 respondents from different sectors office instance police office,
court office, women and children office, youth office for interview and for
questionnaires 29, respondents in society from the total population 24,214 in Wolkite
town.The questionnaires prepared by closed ended and open ended.The close ended
questionnaires include all possible answers per/written response categories and
respondents are asked to choice them. Where as the open ended questionnaires allow
respondents to answers in their own words. There fore,the researcher to get reliable
information from respondents used both open ended and close ended questionnaires for
'29'selected from society,in total population '24,214' in Wolkite town.
In this paper we {the researchers} will use both descriptive and analytical approaches to
describe and analysis the problem under the study. According, the research employs, the
statically analysis describe` the problem of violence against women right and to
indicate.Its level of severity using analytical approach of the study attempted to examine
the cases and analyze the effect of violence against women right.
After collecting the necessary data, the study will have been analyzed based on
information gathering by questionnaire, interview and the qualitative data was analyzed
by using simple distributive statement like percentage and table. Finally, there searcher
concluded by giving the summary of findings conclusion and recommendation.
23
1. Qualitative
2. Quantitative
3. Mixed
General comments:
1. Your research background is not logically expressed and not well written!
2. More your statement of problem part is copy-paste of your back ground of
your study. Due to this:
a) The problem of the statement is not clearly identified and not well written
b) Research gap is not identified and expressed,…
24