Primus Kanakapura

Subject : Chiller System Comparison

System Proposal
OPTION III
OPTION I OPTION II
SR. NO DESCRIPTION Variable Refrigerant Flow
Air Cooled Chillers Hybrid Chiller System
system

A Total Building Load

Comfort Load 480 TR
Critical Load 50 TR
Total Building Load 540 TR

B System Water Available is 30.6 KLD

System Air cooled system Hybrid System VRF
270 TR x1 - WC 600 HP + 64 HP
Configuration 270 TR x 3 - AC
270 TR x 2 - AC 664 HP

C Cooling Towers
Induced Draft Counter Flow
Type of Cooling Towers NA
/ Cross Flow

D Condenser Pumps
Type of Pumping NA Constant Flow NA

E Primary Pumps
Type of Pumping Variable Flow Variable Flow NA

F Secondary Pumps
Type of Pumping NA NA NA
 Primus-Kanakapura
Subject : Chiller System Comparison
CAPITAL COST
OPTION III
OPTION I OPTION II
Variable Refrigerant Flow
Air Cooled Chillers Hybrid Chiller System
system
TOTAL LOAD
Total Load 540 TR 540 TR 664 HP
Water Cooled Chillers
Capacity NA 270 TR NA
Capital Cost - 1 No. NA 4860000 NA
Lifting / Shifting of Chillers NA 100000 NA
Total Cost NA 4960000 NA
Nos. of Chillers NA 1 NA
Total Capital Cost 0 4960000 0
Air Cooled Chillers
Capacity 270 TR 270 TR NA
Capital Cost - 1 No. 8100000 8100000 NA
Lifting / Shifting of Chillers 100000 100000 NA
Total Cost 8200000 8200000 NA
Nos. of Chillers 3 2 NA
Total Capital Cost 24600000 16400000 0
Cooling Towers
Capacity NA 338 TR NA
Capital Cost - 1 No. NA 1014000 NA
Lifting / Shifting of Cooling Towers NA 50000 NA
Total Cost NA 1064000 NA
Nos. of Cooling Towers NA 1 NA
Total Capital Cost 0 1064000 0
Condenser Pumps
Capacity NA 810 GPM NA
Capital Cost - 1 No. NA 225000 NA
Lifting / Shifting of Pumps NA 20000 NA
Total Cost NA 245000 NA
Nos. of Condenser Pumps NA 2 NA
Total Capital Cost 0 490000 0
Primary Pumps (Water Cooled)
Capacity 1680 GPM 648 GPM NA
Capital Cost - 1 No. 350000 200000 NA
Lifting / Shifting of Pumps 20000 20000 NA
Total Cost 370000 220000 NA
Nos. of Primary Pumps 3 1 NA
Total Capital Cost 1110000 220000 0
Primary Pumps (Air Cooled)
Capacity 648 GPM NA
Capital Cost - 1 No. 200000 NA
Lifting / Shifting of Pumps 5000 NA
Total Cost 205000 NA
Nos. of Primary Pumps 2 NA
Total Capital Cost 410000 0
Secondary Pumps
Capacity NA NA
Capital Cost - 1 No. NA NA
Lifting / Shifting of Pumps NA NA
Total Cost NA NA
Nos. of Secondary Pumps NA NA
PLC (Including CPM) 1000000 1000000 NA
Total Capital Cost 1000000 1000000 0
Condensed Water Piping & Accessories
Approximate Rmts 75 NA
Capital Cost (Rs. 9000 / Rmt) 0 675000 0
Chilled Water Piping
Approximate Rmts 300 300 NA
Capital Cost (Rs. 20000 / Rmt) 6000000 6000000 0
AHUs and Valve Accessories
AHUs - 15 Nos. 9000000 9000000 Inclusive
VRF System
VRF System 0 0 39840000

Total Chiller Plant Room Cost in Lakhs 417.1 398.09 398.4

 Primus-Kanakapura
Subject : Chiller System Comparison
OPERATIONAL COST
OPTION I OPTION II OPTION III
Air Cooled Hybrid Chiller Variable Refrigerant
Chillers System Flow system
TOTAL LOAD
Total Load 540 TR 540 TR 664 HP
Chillers Power Consumption
Water Cooled Chiller - Kw/ TR 0.00 0.56
Air Cooled Chiller - Kw/ TR 1.20 1.2
Total WC Chiller Power - KW 0 151.2
Total AC Chiller Power - KW 648.00 324
Total Chiller Power Consumption 648 475.2
Cooling Tower Power Consumption
Cooling Tower - Kw/ TR 0.00 0.04
Total CT Power Consumption 0 13.52
Condenser Pumps
Capacity - GPM 0 810
Head in feet 0.00 32.8
Power Consumption 0.00 7.2
No. of Pumps Working 0 1
Total Condenser Pump power consumption 0.00 7.16
Primary Pumps - Water cooled
Capacity - GPM 648
Head in feet 82
Power Consumption 14.3
No. of Pumps Working 1
Total Primary Pump power consumption 14.32
Primary Pumps - Air cooled
Capacity - GPM 648 648
Head in feet 81.25 82
Power Consumption 14.19 14.32
No. of Pumps Working 2 1
Total Primary Pump power consumption 28.37 14.32
Secondary Pumps
Capacity - GPM
Head in feet
Power Consumption
No. of Pumps Working
Total Secondary Pump power consumption
Water Cost
Water Required ( Availabel 30.6 KLD) 6415200
Water - 15 Ps / Litre 962280
AHUs
Fan Power 113.03 113.03
VRF System
Total Power consumption NA NA 664

Total Power consumption per Hour 761.03 637.54 664.00

Hours of usage in a day 12.00 12 12
Annual run Days 264.00 264 264
Unit cost of Electricity 8.50 8.5 8.5
Annual cost for Power 20492906.44 17167631 17880192

System Cost Per 20492906.44 18129911 17880192

Total Annual Running Cost in Lakhs 205 181 179