Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Loan Management Final
Loan Management Final
Loan Management Final
BY
JSFP/SB/20/0009
APRIL, 2022
I Anjeh Emmaculate Amah declare that this research report is sincerely my own effort and
has never been submitted to any institution for any award.
Signature………………….… Date…………………………
CERTIFICATION
This research report submitted by Anjeh Emmaculate Amah on the topic “the impact of
loan management on the financial perfomance of micro finance institutions in Buea,
a case study of P&T credit union, Buea branch was carried out under my supervision
and is now ready for submission to JSF Polytechnic, Department of Banking and Finance
for the award of a HND in Banking and Finance.
Signature………………….… Date…………………………
SUPERVISOR
Signature………………….… Date…………………………
FIELD SUPERVISOR:
Mme KOFFI EDITH
DEDICATION
To my parents Mr and Mrs. Agbor
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
My sincere thanks go to the Almighty God who has guided me throughout this
period and has given me the strength and patient to carry through. And as well
grateful to my supervisor Dr. Njinjong Marcelus and the teaching staffs of JSF
Polytechnic for moulding me up, developing me in professional and
intellectual abilities.
I will specifically thank my family and friends Macmillian, Popina, Rose,
Amana Alibert and the rest who have supported me and given me moral and
CERTIFICATION............................................................................................ii
DEDICATION.................................................................................................iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT...............................................................................iv
ABSTRACT......................................................................................................ix
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction.................................................................................................8
CHAPTER THREE
METHODOLOGY
3.1 Introduction...............................................................................................22
Quantitative data.............................................................................................24
Qualitative data...............................................................................................24
Questionnaires.................................................................................................26
Interview guide................................................................................................26
Validity.............................................................................................................26
Reliability.........................................................................................................27
Data analysis....................................................................................................28
Data presentation............................................................................................28
CHAPTER FOUR
4.1 Introduction...............................................................................................31
5.1 Introduction...............................................................................................51
5.3 Conclusion..................................................................................................55
5.4 Recommendations.....................................................................................55
REFERENCES................................................................................................59
LIST OF ABREVIATION
Three research questions were designed for the study. The instrument used for
data collection was a questionnaire and interview. This research was a
descriptive study in design which used both qualitative and quantitative
approaches of data collection and analysis. Data was collected from 10
respondents who included males and females and their occupations were
classified ranging from farming to business among others and the data was
analyzed using frequency, percentages and an average of the percentage of
results was used to confirm the entire three objectives. As per the findings
from the study, it was reached and concluded that loan management affects the
financial performance of Micro Finance Institutions.
INTRODUCTION
This chapter presents the background to the study, statement of the problem,
objectives and research questions of the study, scope of the study, and
significance of the study.
Loan is one of the many factors that can be used by a firm to influence demand
for its products. According to Horne and Wachowicz (1998), firms can only
benefit from loan if the profitability generated from increased sales exceeds the
added costs of receivables. Myers and Brealey (2003) define loan as a process
whereby possession of goods or services is allowed without spot payment upon
a contractual agreement for later payment.
Loan management is one of the most important activities in any company and
cannot be overlooked by any economic enterprise engaged in loan irrespective
of its business nature. It is the process to ensure that customers will pay for the
products delivered or the services rendered.
1
Receivables.. He explains that the process of loan management begins with
accurately assessing the loan-worthiness of the customer base. This is
particularly important if the company chooses to extend some type of loan line
or revolving loan to certain customers. Proper loan management calls for
setting specific criteria that a customer must meet before receiving this type of
loan arrangement. As part of the evaluation process, loan management also
calls for determining the total loan line that will be extended to a given
customer.
Nelson (2002) views loan management as simply the means by which an entity
manages its loan sales. It is a prerequisite for any entity dealing with loan
transactions since it is impossible to have a zero loan or default risk. The
higher the amount of accounts receivables and their age, the higher the finance
costs incurred to maintain them. If these receivables are not collectible on time
and urgent cash needs arise, a firm may resort to borrowing and the
opportunity cost is the interest expense paid.
2
Nzotta (2004) pointed out that loan management greatly influences the success
or failure of commercial banks and other financial institutions. This is because
the failure of deposit banks is influenced to a large extent by the quality of loan
decisions and thus the quality of the risky assets. He further notes that, loan
management provides a leading indicator of the quality of deposit bank’s loan
portfolio. A key requirement for effective loan management is the ability to
intelligently and efficiently manage customer loan lines. In order to minimize
exposure to bad debt, over-reserving and bankruptcies, companies must have
greater insight into customer financial strength, loan score history and
changing payment patterns.
Hitt, et al (1996) believe that many firms' low performance is the result of
poorly performing assets. MFIs earn financial revenue from loans and other
financial services in the form of interest fees, penalties, and commissions.
Financial revenue also includes income from other financial assets, such as
investment income. MFI‟s financial activities also generate various expenses,
3
from general operating expenses and the cost of borrowing to provisioning for
the potential loss from defaulted loans. Profitable institutions earn a positive
net income (i.e., operating income exceeds total expenses).
4
Bart Baesens and Tony Van Gestel, (2009), argue that poor management of
loans in form of delays in collecting cash from debtors as they fall due has
serious financial problems, increased bad debts and affects customer relations.
It is against this background that the researcher wishes to examine the impact
of loan management on the financial performance of Micro Finance
Institutions in Buea.
5
3. To establish strategies to improve financial performance of Micro
Finance Institutions.
The study was limited to examining the impact of loan management on the
financial performance of MFIs in Cameroon and specifically it was to establish
the policies of loan management, establish the effect of loan management on
the financial performance of Micro Finance institutions and establish strategies
to improve their financial performance.
The research was carried out in of P & T credit union. It’s located in Buea
Municipality, South West Region, Cameroon.
The study was carried out for the period six months between February 2022-
August 2022. The study was based on the performance of P & T credit union
particularly Buea branch for the last four years of operation that is from 2018-
2021 in order to get the recent information about the performance of
Microfinance Institutions and loan management in Cameroon and specifically
P & T credit union.
6
1.7 Significance of the study.
To P & T credit union management, the study was an eye opener to them
because it helped create awareness of the need to ensure proper loan
management so as to foster proper financial performance of P & T credit
union particularly Buea branch.
To future researchers, the research findings form a basis for future research
because it will always serve as a reference.
The researcher also faced delays in giving the required information. The
researcher was therefore required to show high level of patience in data
collection and hence was in position to obtain the required data.
7
Limited finance. The research required a lot of finance to help in transport
while in the field, buy stationary and other necessities which was not be easy
to get however, to solve this the researcher tried to mobilize resources from
friends, parents and well-wishers.
Some respondents did not cooperate thinking that the research was a profitable
venture and needed some financial motivation which was not be available to
overcome this, an explanation was given to make them understand that the
research is for academic purposes.
8
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction.
This chapter looks at loan management and its impact on the financial
performance of MFIs in Cameroon and in Buea in particular. It consists of
existing literature from different writers concerning the factors that influence
MFIs performance and it will consist literature from different scholars,
magazines, text books, journals and newspapers.
Kakuru (2002) asserts that loan policy provides a frame work for the entire
loan management process. Loan policies are set of objectives, standards and
parameters to guide officers of the MFIs who grant loan portfolios. Thus they
are procedures, guidelines and rules designed to minimise costs associated with
loan while maximising the benefits from it (Ahimbisibwe,2002).The main
objective of loan policy is to have an optimal investment and debtors that
minimise costs while maximising profit.
Jhngan (2007) contends that loan depends on a person’s willingness and ability
to pay the borrowed money. In fact, loan of a person depends on his character,
capacity and capital. It is these three Cs on which loan depends. A person who
is honest and fair in his dealings possess the capacity of making his business a
success. Such a person can get loan easily. Financial institutions consider
customer’s character in making a decision on the level of loan worthiness of a
borrower. Most financial institutions value the borrower’s reputation, honesty
and integrity and account history as a sign of willingness to repay the borrowed
9
funds. The financial institution might also consider knowledge and experience
in your area of business, your grasp of financial principles and the soundness
of your plans for the future of your business (Powell and Mylenko, 2004).
According to (Horne 2005), a sound loan policy promotes loan quality. Loan
policy objectives should encompass several elements. That is regulatory
environment, the availability of funds, the selection of risk, loans profitable
balance and term structure and the term structure of liabilities. The essence of
loan policy is to maximize the value of a firm (Puxty and Dood, 2000).
Tight loan standards make a firm lose a big number of customers and when
loan are loose the firm gets an increased number of clients but at a risk of loss
through bad debts. A loose loan policy may not necessarily mean an increase
in profitability because the increased number of customers may lead to
increased costs in terms of loan administration and bad debts recovery.
Character refers to the willingness of a customer to settle his obligations. This
mainly involves assessment of the moral factors. Social collateral group
members can guarantee the loan members known the character of each client;
if they doubt the character then the client is likely to default. Saving habit
involves analyzing how consistent the client is in realizing own funds, saving
promotes loan sustainability of the enterprise once the loan is paid. Other
sources should be identified so as to enable him serve the loan in time. This
helps micro finance institutions not to only limit loans to short term projects.
Such qualities have an impact on the repayment commitment of the borrowers.
It should be noted that there should be a firm evidence of this information that
point to the borrowers character (Vercammen, 1995).
10
Riach (2010), observes that loan terms are normally looked at as the loan
period, terms of discount, the amount of loan and choice of instrument used to
evidence loan. Loan terms may include; Length of time to approve loans, this
is the time taken from applications to the loan disbursement or receipt. It is
evaluated by the position of the client as indicated by the ratio analysis, trends
in cash flow and looking at capital position. Maturity of a loan, this is the time
period it takes loan to mature with the interest there on. Cost of loan, this is
interest charged on loans, different micro finance institutions charge differently
basing on what their competitors are charging (Padilla and Pagano, 2000).
Rajan (2005), asserts that collection policy is a guide that ensures prompt
payment and regular collections. The rationale is that not all clients meet their
obligations, some just take it for granted, others simply forget while others just
don’t have a culture of paying until persuaded to do so. Many micro finance
institutions may send a letter to such individuals (borrowers) when say ten
days elapse or phone calls and if payment is not received with in thirty days, it
may turn over the account to a collection agency. Collection procedure is
required because some clients do not pay the loan in time some are slower
while others never pay (Stiglitz and Weiss, 1981).
11
bad debts. Prompt payments are aimed at increasing turn over while keeping
low and bad debts within limits. However, caution should be taken against
stringent steps especially on permanent clients because harsh measures may
cause them to shift to competitors. States that collection effort are directed at
accelerating recovery from slow payers and decreases bad debts losses (Padilla
and Pagano, 2000).
12
the blue print used by a business in making decisions to extend loan to
customers. Thus, the main goal of a loan policy is to avoid extending loan to
customers who are unable to pay their accounts. Loan policy for some larger
businesses can be quite formal that is involving specific documents, guidelines
loan checks and customer loan applications while the policy for small
businesses tends to be quite informal and lacks items found formal for large
businesses. Many small business owners rely on their instincts as their loan
policy (Blair, 2002). Loan policy has direct effects on the cash flows of any
business. Hence, a loan policy that is too strict will turn away potential
customers, reduces sales and finally lead to a decrease in the amount of cash
paying customers ,increase in the business average collection period for
accounts receivables and eventually lead to cash inflow problems. A good loan
management policy should help management to attract and retain customers
without having negative impact on cash flows.
Loan management likewise alludes to the proficient mix of four note worthy
loan approach parameters to ensure convenient collection of loans conceded to
clients and in the meantime build their trust in and the devotion to the financial
organisations (Van Harne, 2007).The main variable is an evolution of the
nature of the client’s record operations in the establishment. This takes into
13
account the correct examination of the capacity of the clients to meet the
instalment promptly. The second strategy variable is that setting up the right
loan period. In this manner, the organisation should give sufficient time to
permit loyal customers the chance of deriving the full advantage of the loan.
The third parameter is the rebate given to clients as the way of inspiring them
to reimburse their loan facilities on time. Such rebate must sufficiently be
appealing before the goal can be accomplished. The last variable looks at the
level of expenditure that can be permitted in recovering of debts. The inference
here is that the organisation should not give out loan where the cost to be spent
on retrieving the obligation will probably surpass the obligation. To mix these
variables into a proficient workable framework obliges the establishment of a
watchful arrangement, controlling and coordination of all accessible human
and material assets.(Van Horne,2007)
Franklin (2010) contends that loan management policy is the tenets and
systems set up by top administration that oversee the organisation loan division
and investigates execution in the augmentation of loan benefits against set
down procedures. It is essentially a situated composition of rules intended to
14
minimise expenses connected with loan while expanding advantage from it
(Mc Naughton,1996). Loan administration arrangements involve the loan
strategies, loan measures and loan terms. This policy becomes the blueprint
which guides the conduct and expectations of all employees with the
responsibility of granting loan and also acts as a benchmark by which
performance can be measured against set standards.
Chodechai (2004) while investigating factors that affect interest rates, degree
of lending volume and collateral setting in the loan decision of banks, says:
Banks have to be careful with their pricing decisions as regards to lending as
banks cannot charge loan rates that are too low because the revenue from the
interest income will not be enough to cover the cost of deposits, general
expenses and the loss of revenue from some borrowers that do not pay.
Nnanna, (2005), further stressed that “Bank lending decisions generally are
fraught with a great deal of risks, which calls for a great deal of caution and
tact in this aspect of banking operations. The success of every lending activity
to a great extent therefore, hinges on the part of the loan analysts to carry out
good loan analysis, presentation, structuring and reporting.
Mwaura (2005) insists that lack of loan follow up, loan analysis, and hostile
lending of money are some of the factors that have contributed to financial gap
and poor performance. In Kenya, following the liberalization of the financial
sector in the 1990s (Omino, 2003), the back office model of SACCO
operations was found to be inadequate and as a result, many SACCO societies
introduced the front office services activities (FOSA) alternatively known as
the SACCO Savings
15
According to Glen (2006),loan management policy typically take into account
a borrower’s current financial condition and paying capacity, the current value
and reliability of collateral and other borrower and facility specific
characteristics that affect the prospects for collection of principal and interest.
Financial institutions should put in place policies that require that remedial
actions be taken when policy tolerances are exceeded. These institutions
should also document their validation process and results with regular
reporting of the results to the appropriate levels of management. Additionally,
the validation of internal loan risk assessment models should be subject to
periodic review by qualified, independent individuals for example internal and
external auditors (Kagwa, 2003).
According to Pike and Neale (2009), a sound loan policy is the blueprint for
how the company communicates with and treats its most valuable asset, the
customers. Scheufler (2002) proposes that a loan policy creates a common set
of goals for the organization and recognizes the loan and collection department
as an important contributor to the organization’s strategies. If the loan policy is
correctly formulated, carried out and well understood at all levels of the
financial institution, it allows management to maintain proper standards of the
bank loans to avoid unnecessary risks and correctly assess the opportunities for
business development.
16
design, implementation, operation and performance of a loan grading system
(Glen, 1996).
Felix and Claudine (2008) examined the association between the performance
of banks and loan management. As part of their findings, they observed that
return on equity and return on assets both measuring profitability were
inversely related to the ratio of non-performing loan to total loan of financial
institutions thereby leading to an increase in profitability. Also, Hosna, et al.
(2009) in their study opined that loan risk has a significant positive effect on
the profitability of commercial banks in Sweden.
17
Funso and et al (2012) investigated the quantitative effect of proper loan
management on the performance of commercial banks in Nigeria for the period
2000-2010. Findings from their study showed that the effect of loan risk on
bank performance measured by the return on assets of banks is cross sectional
invariant.
18
performance of a SACCO; hence a positive relationship existed between
efficient working capital management and financial performance variable.
Kohansal and Mansoori (2009) were of the view that, lenders devise various
institutional mechanisms aimed at reducing the risk of loan default. These
include pledging of collateral, third-party loan guarantee, use of loan rating and
collection agencies, etc.).
Kay Associates Limited (2005) cited by Aballey (2009) states that bad loans
can be restricted by ensuring that loans are made to only borrowers who are
likely to be able to repay, and who are unlikely to become insolvent. Loan
analysis of potential borrowers should be carried out in order to judge the loan
risk with the borrower and to reach a lending decision.
19
Loan repayments should be monitored and whenever a customer defaults
action should be taken. Thus banks should avoid giving loans to risky
customers, monitor loan repayments and renegotiate loans when customers get
into difficulties (Ameyaw-Amankwah, 2011). MFIs need a monitoring system
that highlights repayment problems clearly and quickly, so that loan officers
and their supervisors can focus on delinquency before it gets out of hand
(Warue, 2012). Sheila, (2011) is of the view that proper and adequate appraisal
is key to controlling or minimizing default. This is the basic stage in the
lending process.
According to Anjichi (1994), the appraisal stage is the heart of a high quality
portfolio. This includes diagnosing of the business as well as the borrower.
Before beginning the process of collecting information on the client for the
purpose of determining loan limits, the loan officer should have specific
information available which will guarantee that the data and figures provided
by the client will have a pro-margin error (Sheila, 2011).
The majority of the information is obtained by the loan officer through direct
interaction with the client in such a way that each loan analysis provides
valuable insights for evaluating the application for the future client. However,
most clients withhold a great deal of information making the evaluation a
difficult and unreliable exercise. Furthermore, the loan officer should visit the
home or the work place of the client with the main objective of determining
whether the client needs the loan programs or not. This information will help
the loan officer to assess the ability to effectively utilise the loan.
Hunte (1996), observed that the time to assess the applicant’s loan worthiness
also matters. This is because he believes that a shorter time is not enough to
fully assess the applicant. This is in agreement with Bigambah (1997) who
20
contends that it is necessary to analyze the client before a loan is issued; the
applicant has to be screened to assess his or her loan worthiness. That is the
ability to repay the loan, the business and the guarantee to secure the
repayment of the loan.
Bigambah (1997) observed that the loan default in Uganda has identified loan
appraisal as the key factor. In a number of cases, the information received is
not verified, in some cases the information received is doctored or falsified. It
must therefore be emphasized that loan risk analysis is another important
element in loan appraisal. When lending out money, the lender should
consider the borrowing proposition and subsequent repayment in isolation
from security. It should be noted that, the borrower should be screened basing
on the future and the past. Lending should be based on capital, character,
capability, purpose, amount, repayment, term and security. Basing on the
knowledge above, the lender should investigate on the customer’s record,
ability and experience. Security tends to come towards the end and is
considered only after the borrowing proposition has met the criteria. This
process of appraising the client will help the officer to assess the ability of the
borrower to utilize the loan effectively. Furthermore; the loan officer will be
able to predict the likely changes or effect on the business for which the money
is being lent out.
21
up spending it unnecessarily. The most affected are those involved in the
agricultural sector because their activities are usually in line with the prevailing
weather conditions. If the people involved in the agricultural sector receive the
loan late, this will delay the planting season hence they end up not making any
profit in time or may yield less as a result they are not able to pay their loans in
time.
Anjichi (1994) lamented that, many of the agonies and frustrations of slow and
distressed loans can be avoided by good loan supervision which helps in
keeping a good loan good. This is done by visiting the borrowers’ premises to
investigate the general state of affairs, checking on the state of borrowers’
morale and physical stock of finished goods.
Anjichi (1994) adds that, the general business policy and advice should be
considered. If the MFI is sensitive to business development, it can revise its
own loan policies and loan procedures as well as advising its customers. It can
also monitor the disbursed loans by the use of loan tracking sheets, checking
the amount deposited and the remaining balance of the borrowers. He further
says that early recognition of the loan default is crucial, and therefore tries to
give guidelines on managing loan losses.
22
CHAPTER THREE
METHODOLOGY
3.1 Introduction.
This section presents and shows the analysis of the research findings in respect
to the impact of loan management on the performance of MFIs in Buea. It
involves the research design, the sample size and selection procedures, the
types of data and collection techniques, the area and population and the mode
of analysis that will be used by the researcher in the study.
A research design provides the glue that holds the research study together. A
design is used to structure the research, to show how all the major parts of the
research study (the samples or groups, measures, treatments or programs, and
methods of assignment) work together to try to address the central research
questions (William, M. 2006). According to Sarantakos (1993), this is the most
significant element of the research process where the whole research is
designed, options considered, decisions made and details of the research.
23
3.3 Data sources and types
Data from secondary sources is got from documents or recordings that relate or
discuss information originally presented elsewhere. They are mainly reports
that use primary data to solve research problems written for professional or
scholarly audience. In this study, secondary data was obtained from published
literatures that are text books, journals, magazines, internet and other related
literature. In this study, this source was adopted because it is easy and cheaper
to collect, it is readily available and less time consuming.
Quantitative data.
24
Quantitative data was collected to formalize the problem concept to be used
and to generate the hypothesis to be tested. It put emphasis on the cause
behaviour with reference to the topic.
Qualitative data.
This study was carried out in the P & T credit Union, which is found in Buea,
the South West Region, Cameroon. Buea (Bakweri: Gbea) is the capital of the
Southwest Region of Cameroon. The town is located on the eastern slopes of
Mount Cameroon and has a population of 300,000 (Helders et al, 2008). The
study population comprised of business community, selected farmers,
households, civil servants who are clients P & T credit union, Buea branch.
25
3.5 Sample size and selection techniques.
Sampling is the process of choosing the units of the target population which
are to be included in the study. (Sarandakos 1998)
Purposive sampling looked at information rich areas especially the staff and
thus was used by the researcher because of the nature of the data required.
These techniques were used because of the specific targeted population and the
nature of the data required.
Questionnaires.
26
increases the chances of getting valid information that is filled at the
respondent’s convenience. This tool was used to collect data from business
community, selected farmers, households, community development officers
and staff of five talents Uganda administered by the researcher.
Interview guide.
In depth interview guide; Here, the researcher sets an in depth interview guide
to collect data from the respondents. In depth interview guide involved face to
face interaction between the researcher and the respondents. This method was
used because it allows probing further for greater depth and explanation. Yes
and No questions or fixed response were used. Interviews allowed participants
to express themselves using their own words.
Validity.
27
Reliability.
The researcher therefore pre-tested the questionnaire and was the most used
instrument on the ten clients, the board committee and board of governance of
P & T credit Union branch.
Data processing.
Data collected was checked for completeness, categorized, coded and entered
into a computer where it will be summarized info frequency tables.
Data analysis.
The data obtained was scientifically analyzed by Statistical Package for Social
Sciences (SPSS).The SPSS package was opted because it handles a large
number of variables. Pearson correlation index was used in order to correlate
loan management on the financial performance of MFIs. This is because the
index measures the degree and direction of the relationship between variables.
Data presentation.
28
answering the research questions through coding of data, identifying categories
and parameters that emerge in the responses to the variable of study.
Qualitative data will be presented by narrative text.
From the beginning of research as well as in the data collection phase a clear
explanation of what the research was about was given. No changes were made
to the original research question after the research had been completed.
The researcher obtained the necessary ethical authorization from JSF
Polytechnic before the research started. Permission to access the data from P &
T credit.
Ethical issues associated with the participants that were addressed in this
research were: “informed consent, right of refusal to take part without penalty,
right to withdraw without penalty, confidentiality and anonymity, deception
and security and safety to prevent any emotional or physical harm” (Plowright,
2011).
When using the secondary data, respondents were numbered and the numbers
were used to identify respondents were assured of confidentiality and
anonymity. In this study the researcher kept identifying information about
respondents separately from their responses.
29
The researcher did not discuss the research with anyone outside the research
milieu and ensured that no individuals could be identified and she was
intellectually honest about the source of her ideas in any discussion about the
research.
The data was kept secure once collected and stored safely to report the results
of the research with integrity and accuracy. No values were excluded from the
analysis. The whole investigation the researcher attempted to maintain
objectivity and integrity and to employ professional judgment.
On the first day of my internship, the intern was taken to the Human Resource
Department and from there, I was given a contract to sign and this contract stated the
law I had to abide as an intern in the Buea P&T credit union. The contract equally
stated duration of the internship and the compensation given at the end of the
internship. Afterwards the intern was taken to her department and was being
introduced to employees in the department and the employees started interacting with
me and making me know some norms to follow in the Buea P&T credit union like
opening time is 8:00 am and closing at 4:00pm and Saturday closing time is at
1:00pm but we are to come thirty minutes in the morning and close all together when
closing this is to witness we all left the office at once. The intern had to come thirty
minutes before time and working days for interns is from Tuesday to Saturday and
Monday to Saturday for the manager, cashier and accountant and when they can’t
make it on Monday, they work hand in hand at home. The intern was made to
understand that the camera in the union are fully working and through this,
everything you do can be seen. Not much was done on the first day because I was
looking at what others did and learning from them and I equally asked questions.
30
CHAPTER FOUR
DATA ANALYSIS, PRESENTATION AND INTERPRETATION
4.1 Introduction
This study was carried out on the impact of Loan management on the financial
performance of Micro Finance Institutions in Buea. This chapter presents the
findings obtained from different respondents, their demographic characteristics,
data analysis in form of charts and tables and their relevant interpretation following
the objectives of this research study.
Male 2 20
Female 8 80
Total 10 100
31
Source: Primary/field data 2022
Female
40%
Male
60%
According to the
table above out the 10 people who participated in the study, most of the
respondents were males who made 60% of the study while 40% were females.
According to the information obtained from the field the males are the ones who
always access loans at P&T credit union Buea due to the fact that they are the ones
who possess collateral and are therefore versed with loan management policies
employed by this institution.
Therefore according to the above table the leading respondents were males 6(60%)
and the least number of the respondents were females 4(40%) in this study having
respondents who are males and females as shown above therefore implies that the
study was gender sensitive and therefore the views of all sexes were captured and
represented in this study.
32
4.3.1 Age distribution of respondents.
The age of respondents was investigated to find out if there was a certain age
bracket that dominated the study. The findings from the respondents were revealed
in table1.
18-27 01 10
28-37 2 20
38-47 3 30
48-57 2 20
58 and above 02 20
Total 10 100
18-27
10%
58 and above
20% 28-37
20%
48-57
20%
38-47
30%
33
As shown in the above table and graph, the age bracket that dominates the
population of study was 38-47 and constitutes 30% of the study followed by those
of the age bracket of 28-37 and 48-57 and 58yrs and above with a similar
percentage of 20%.Also according to the above table, the study constituted 10% of
the respondents whose age bracket was 18-27. This therefore implies that the
information was reliable since it was obtained from mature respondents who were
able to attempt to the questionnaire with ease and were familiar with the how loan
management affects the performance of MFIs since most of them had an
experience with loans from this particular case study. Having a big number of
respondents aged from 38-47 years implies that data was collected from mature
respondents and can thus be relied on in this study.
Single 1 10
Divorced 3 30
Married 4 40
Widowed 3 730
Total 10 100
34
Graph 4.3 showing marital status of respondents.
Single
10%
Widowed
20%
Divorced
30%
Married
40%
From table 3 shown above, out of the 10 respondents, 40% were married and these
through the interview explained that they accessed loans for their families 10%
were single while 30% were divorced and 20% were widowed. This seemed an
important aspect of the study due to the fact they were of sound knowledge and
were therefore able to understand the topic with eases and thus provided reliable
information.
This shows that there was a big number of married respondents comprising of
4(40%) of respondents followed by those who are divorced 3(30%) compared the
other marital statuses which seemed to be an advantage for this study.
35
were educated up to a certain level. This helped the researcher to know whether
they were able to understand what is meant by loan management and financial
performance as regards to Micro Finance Institutions.
Table4.4 showing the level of education of the respondents.
Primary 1 10
Secondary 3 30
Tertiary 2 20
University 4 40
Others 0 00
Total 10 100
4.5
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
Primary Secondary Tertiary University Others
Table 4.4 shows that all respondents were educated at different levels as it
corresponds to their qualifications. According to the above table, many
respondents completed university and these comprised of 40% of the respondents,
36
30% of the respondents completed secondary level of education while 20% had
completed tertiary level of education and 10% of the study respondents had
finished primary level of education.
As shown in the above table, the leading number of the respondents had completed
University level 4(40%) followed by those who completed Secondary level with
3(30%) while the least number of the respondents completed tertiary and primary
levels of education shown by 2(20%) and 10(10%) respectively while none of the
respondents had attended any other of education as shown by 0(0%) of the
respondents.
Farmer 2 20
Business 5 50
Civil servant 3 30
Religious leader 0 00
Others 0 00
37
Total 10 100
0
Farmer Business Civil servant Religious leader Others
According to the table4.5, out of the total number of the respondents, 50% were
engaged in business, 30% were farmers while 20% were civil servants.
As shown in the above table, most of the respondents were from the business
community as shown by 5(50%) followed by farmers 3(30%). In the least
positions, civil servants were represented by 2(20%).
Having a large number of respondents belonging to the business community
implies that the respondents were familiar with loan management practices since
most of them always acquired loans for the expansion of their businesses which
therefore shows that the information obtained from them was viable and reliable
for this study.
38
4.3.6 Duration of the occupation.
The study sought to find out the duration the respondents had been engaged in their
occupation. This aspect was also considered so as to help the researcher identify
the length the respondents have spent in their particular occupations.
<1yr 0 0
1-3 yrs 2 20
4-6yrs 3 30
>7 yrs 5 50
Total 10 100
0
<1yr 1-3 yrs 4-7 yrs >7 yrs
39
Table 4.6 shows the working experience of respondents, where 50% of respondents
have been actively involved in their occupation for a period above 7 years, 30%
have been working for a period of 4-6 years and 30% had worked for a period
between 1-3 years.
The above table clearly shows that 5(50%) of the respondents were leading and
had been employed for a period of 7years and above followed by 3(30%) who had
been employed for a period between 4-6 years and the least number of respondents
had been employed for a period between 1-3 years shown by 2(2%) while none of
the respondents had been employed for less than one year.
From the above findings therefore a big number of the respondents have been
involved in work related activities from where they earn income for survival which
therefore shows that the respondents were well versed with the topic under
consideration.
Yes 9 90
40
No 1 10
Total 70 100
From the findings as shown by table 4.7 above 90% of the respondents indicated
that their institution had adopted loan management practices, whereas 10%
indicated that their institution had not.
This table therefore shows that a leading number of respondents 9(90%) agrees
that their institution has loan management policies while a least number of
respondents 1(10%) disagrees. This therefore implies that the institution surely has
loan management policies.
4.4.1 The nature of loan management policies employed by P&T Credit Union
To probe further whether the respondents who had agreed that their institution had
loan management policies, the researcher asked them to identify these policies and
their findings are illustrated in table 4.8.
Table 4.8 showing the nature of loan management policies employed by P&T
Credit Union
Loan restructuring 1 10
Notice of default 1 1
Credits follow up 00 0
41
Evaluation of customers credit 1 10
worthiness
Others 00 0.00
Total 10 100
From the above table, as part of loan management policies, 30% of the respondents
agreed that the institution liquidates the collateral presented before accessing the
loan, 20% claimed that the institution sends a loan collection agent to collect the
loan and the interest, 10% said that the institution restructures the loan by
extending the loan repayment period, sending, a notice of default through use of
telephones and letters, analyses the credit worthiness of the borrower by checking
their loan experience with the institution and other institutions and taking of legal
action in case of total default while other policies had not been employed by the
institution as shown by the above table.
As shown by the above table, the leading number of respondents 3(0%) agreed that
their institution liquidates the collateral followed by 2(20%) who said that the
institution sends loan collection agency and then loan restructuring 1(10%) as the
most used policies of the institution. While the least used policies of the institution
according to the respondents were sending notice of default 1(10%), evaluation of
42
customers credit worthiness 1(10%) and taking legal action 1(10%).While other
MFIs use policies such as credits follow up, checking credit limit use of maturity
invoice, use of penalty and client appraisal among others, these were not employed
by P &T credit union according to the respondents as shown by 0(0%)
respectively.
Therefore, from the above findings, the institution uses loan management policies
and this has helped to increase its profitability through reducing cases of loan
default by the borrowers which shows that the institutions level of profitability is
maintained.
4.5 The effect of loan management on the performance of P&T Credit Union
The respondents were asked whether loan management policies affect the financial
performance of the institution and their response is displayed in the table below.
Yes 56 80
No 14 20
Don’t know 00 00
Total 70 100
From the findings shown by the above table 80% of the respondents agreed that
loan management affects the financial performance of MFIs and particularly Five
43
Talents Uganda and 20% disagreed with the fact that loan management affects
financial performance.
Thus from the above findings loan management affect financial performance of
MFIs and should therefore be taken as a vital component of Micro Finance
Institutions for their continued performance and profitability.
It increases profitability 8 80 20
44
It makes the institution more 4 40 6 60
competitive
Others 00 00 00 00
According to the above table, out of the 70 respondents who filled the
questionnaire,80%agreed that loan management increases profitability while 20%
disagreed with this view. When asked whether loan management increases
financial performance in terms of increasing working capital, 90% percent of the
respondents supported this view claiming that the institution is left with sufficient
income to run its operations while 10% did not agree with this view.30% of
respondents reported that loan management increases customer base while 70% did
not support this view citing that in cases where the institution takes legal action in
case of default, this scares away customers. 100% of the respondents claimed that
proper loan management increases customer compliance and they are able to clear
their debts especially in situations where the institution sends notices of default to
the would be defaulters. As an effect of loan management on financial
performance, 40% of the respondents in their view agreed that it increases the
institutions competition power relative to other institutions whereas 60% of the 70
respondents did not support this view. As shown by table 11. 60% of the
respondents claimed that proper loan management is an important factor in terms
of financial performance of their institution since it reduces the risks associated
with bad debts while 40% said that this is not always the case. Table 11 also shows
45
that 60% of the respondent agreed that proper loan management reduces bad debts
especially through liquidating the collateral while 40% of the respondent did not
support this idea. When asked to give other effects of loan management, none of
the respondents stated any other effect as shown by the above table.
As shown by the above table, according to the respondents the leading effect of
loan management is that increases compliance by debtors 70(100%) followed by
that it increases working capital 9(90%) and increasing working capital 8(80%).
The least effects of loan management as identified by the respondents were that it
reduces bad debts 6(60%), it reduces risks associated with lending 6(60%), makes
the institution more competitive 4(40%) and that increases customer base
3(30%).When the researcher asked the respondents to give any other effect of the
respondents to give other effects of loan none of the respondents give the effect as
shown by 0(0%).
Yes 10 100
No 00 0.00
Total 10 100
46
From the above all the respondents unanimously agreed that there are strategies to
improve financial performance and this is shown by 100% of the respondents
saying yes while none of the respondents said that there are strategies that can be
employed to improve financial performance. This therefore implies that any
financial institution should put into consideration these policies depending on its
nature of operation.
Therefore from the above table, the leading number of respondents 70(100%)
agreed that there are strategies that can be adopted to improve financial
performance.
For the researcher to validate this fact he asked the respondents to identify some of
these strategies and the findings are discussed in table 4.12
Regular audits 01 10
Compliance reviews 6 60
Proper budgeting 00 0
Follow up evaluation 1 10
Others 00 0
Total 70 100
47
According to the above table, 60% agreed that as a strategy to improve financial
performance, the institution should always examine compliance reviews by
debtors, 10% suggested that the institution should use both addressing non
repayment of debts and conducting follow up evaluation while 10% of the
respondents suggested the need to strengthen human resource and 10% of the
respondents proposed that there is need for the institution to strengthen human
resource as a strategy to improve financial performance.
As explained by the above table, the leading number of the respondents said that
there is need to review compliance reviews as shown by 6(60%) followed by
addressing non repayment of debts and follow up evaluation as shown by 1(10%)
for both least policies suggested were conducting regular audits. other strategies as
proposed by the researcher in the questionnaire were not seen as being effective
according to the respondents such as increased staff supervision and proper
budgeting as shown by 0(0%).
When asked by the respondents to state other strategies that can be employed by
the institution to improve financial performance none of the respondents suggested
this strategy and this is shown by 0(0%) for other strategies.
48
CHAPTER FIVE
5.1 Introduction
The main objective of this study was to establish the impact of loan management
on the financial performance of Microfinance institutions in Buea taking P&T
credit union Buea as a case study. This chapter therefore presents a summary of the
findings, conclusions, recommendations and suggestions for further research.
The study revealed that taking P&T credit union Buea that was taken as a case
study has loan management policies in its operation. This was shown by 90% of
the respondents agreeing to this view which agrees with Rajan (2005), who asserts
that loan management policy is a guide that ensures prompt payment and regular
collections. The rationale is that not all clients meet their obligations, some just
take it for granted, others simply forget while others just don’t have a culture of
paying until persuaded to do so. This implies that all Deposit taking microfinance
institutions should observe clear guidelines on how to approach and manage the
loan risks that they may face from time to time.
This is also supported by Kakuru (2002) who asserts that loan policy provides a
frame work for the entire loan management process. Loan policies are set of
objectives, standards and parameters to guide officers of the MFIs who grant loan
49
portfolios. Thus they are procedures, guidelines and rules designed to minimise
costs associated with loan while maximising the benefits from it
(Ahimbisibwe,2002). The main objective of loan policy is to have an optimal
investment and debtors that minimise costs while maximising profit.
This therefore calls for use of client friendly policies as shown in the study the
most commonly used policy of loan management is liquidating the collateral which
was rated at 35% followed by sending loan collection agency rated at 25% then
followed by sending notice followed as indicated by 7.41% of the respondents.
However there is need to use more friendly policies that do not scare away
potential clients such as undertaking loan reviews and credit follow ups because
they are easy and cheap to implement by the institution and attract clients.
The study also revealed that loan management policies have a great effect on loan
management policies of the institution. This was evidenced by 80% of the
respondents agreeing that loan management affects financial performance of P&T
credit union Buea while 20% disagreed claiming the loan management does not
affect financial performance. When the researcher asked the respondents to state
the extent to which loan management affects financial performance, 60% of the
respondents said that loan management affects financial performance to a greater
extent while 20% of the respondents said that financial performance of the
institution is affected by loan management to a smaller extent. This was confirmed
by 100% of the respondents claiming that it increases compliance by debtors, 90%
agreeing that it increases working capital and 80% stating that it increases
profitability. On the other hand, 60% of the respondents tied on the same
50
percentage saying that loan management reduces the risks associated with lending
and making the institution more competitive as well. This therefore confirms Kargi
(2011) who examined the impact of loan management on the profitability of banks
and revealed that loan management has a significant impact on the profitability of
banks.
This was further supported by Felix and Claudine (2008) who examined the
association between the performance of banks and loan management. As part of
their findings, they observed that return on equity and return on assets both
measuring profitability were inversely related to the ratio of non-performing loan
to total loan of financial institutions thereby leading to an increase in profitability.
Also, Hosna, et al. (2009) in their study opined that loan risk has a significant
positive effect on the profitability of commercial banks in Sweden.
The researcher went ahead to ask the respondents whether there are strategies that
can be adopted to improve financial performance of the institution and all the
respondents all the respondents unanimously agreed that there are strategies to
improve financial performance and this is shown by 100% of the respondents
saying yes. To validate this, the researcher asked them to identify some of these
51
strategies and according to the findings, 70% agreed that as a strategy to improve
financial performance, the institution should always examine compliance reviews
by debtors, 10% suggested that the institution should use both addressing non
repayment of debts and conducting follow up evaluation while 10% of the
respondents suggested the need to strengthen human resource and 10% of the
respondents proposed that there is need for the institution to strengthen human
resource as a strategy to improve financial performance.
This is in line with Ameyaw-Amankwah (2011) who said that loan repayments
should be monitored and whenever a customer defaults action should be taken. He
further stressed that banks should avoid loans to risky customers, monitor loan
repayments and renegotiate loans when customers get into difficulties. This was
further supported by Warue,(2012) who claimed that MFIs need a monitoring
system that highlights repayment problems clearly and quickly, so that loan
officers and their supervisors can focus on delinquency before it gets out of hand.
His view was also supported by Kohansal and Mansoori (2009) who were of the
view that, lenders devise various institutional mechanisms aimed at reducing the
risk of loan default. These include pledging of collateral, third-party loan
guarantee, use of loan rating and collection agencies, etc.). Furthermore, according
Kay Associates Limited (2005) as cited by Aballey (2009) were of the view that
that bad loans can be restricted by ensuring that loans are made to only borrowers
who are likely to be able to repay, and who are unlikely to become insolvent. Loan
analysis of potential borrowers should be carried out in order to judge the loan risk
with the borrower and to reach a lending decision.
52
5.3 Conclusion
This study aimed at examining the impact of loan management on the financial
performance of MFIs in Buea taking P&T credit union Buea Branch as a case
study and 10 respondents from this institution were selected using purposive and
convinient sampling techniques and they received and responded to the self-
administered questionnaires
The study findings reveal that there is a close relationship between loan
management and financial performance. Through the assessment of respondents’
views on this relationship, the researcher found out that the loans were well
managed, because all indicators considered at this level show that the employees
working in loan department have experience.
The study revealed that the use of proper loan management policies lead to
increase in financial performance of MFIs in P&T credit union Buea since it
increases an institutions profitability, increases debtors compliance as well as
reducing risks associated with bad debts among other and therefore there is need to
stream line these policies so as to ensure continued profitability of the institution
5.4 Recommendations
On the basis of the results and conclusions of this study, the following policy
implications are suggested so as to be considered in the future intervention
strategies which are aimed at improving the financial performance of MFIs
particularly P&T credit union Buea.
The loan policies and procedure of the Micro Finance Institutions should
incorporate the ideas of the clients and employees to become more competitive in
53
the finance sector and meet its vision. In other words, it is better for the Bank to
make its credit policy flexible to meet its potential loan clients and thereby putting
a good administrative set up that improves Credit lending and administration.
The periodic repayment schedule of the Micro Finance Institution should be
flexible by considering the operation of the clients’ business as repayment duration
has its impact on the performance of loan collection.
As it is disclosed in the analysis part of the study most of the loan clients and the
institutions have complaints on the loan policies such as taking legal action that
includes taking people to prison and guidelines regarding valuing property offered
for collateral, loan discretion, length of loan processing time, repayment schedule,
and excessive requirements for analysis. These are the major factors impeding
client reputation and retarding to attract potential loan clients. Hence, the
institution should made remarkable changes on its loan policies and procedure
guidelines regarding the above aforesaid drawbacks in order to solve the current
problems and achieve the client reputation.
The current loan processing and approving direction of the institution is moderate
inclined to be conservative especially regarding collateral analysis and its
liquidation. This is highly retarding the loan growth of the institution. Hence, there
is need to follow creative way of loan processing and approving direction that
assists to meet the loan demand of potential loan applicants and the required level
of loan growth as it is the main source of income for the banking industry.
Supply necessary of logistics support for monitoring clients. Sometimes loan
officers need to move long-distance and remote areas for group meeting, visiting
individual clients, collection etc. For doing so, they need some sorts of logistics
support. Managers should provide necessary transportation or allowances.
Managers should not think loans officers as a robot or machine. Redesigning or
54
merging of group or branch offices could play an important role to reduce this type
of hassles.
Effective Implementation of Human Resource Policy and Procedures (HRPP):
Managers should initiate HRPP and stick to that procedural issues for all staff of
the organization. Code of conduct and ethical behavior should be included in the
policies and require time to time monitoring on the implementation. All issues
related to staff, program operation and organizational support should be specified
in an understandable way so that employees can get the exact meaning of the
policies. There could be an internal team to look after implementation of all the
procedural issues and if there is any deviation occurs then the team could treat the
case in a flexible way with logical perspective to adjust with the need of the time,
work place as well as frequency.
Provide need based training on stress management and competency as well as
initiate mentoring program: Managers should fix logical budget for loan officers
training on different issues like developing competency, dealing with delinquent
clients, time management, stress management and other soft skills training. These
sorts of training could help loan officers to prepare themselves to face challenges
in the workplace. Managers can introduce mentoring program for the new and
existing staff so that proper guidance and advice are available to all staff.
55
56
REFERENCES
Binks, M., and Ennew, T. (1996). Financing small firms, small business and
entrepreneur, 2nd edition. Brick., J. R. (2006).Commercial banking,
Addisonwesley publishing company, Newyork-US
Bridget, S. and Cathy, L., (2005). Research Methods in the Social Sciences and
Business borrowers. 2nd Edition, DBA/USA Press.
Brigham, E.F., Gapenski, L.C. and Daves, P.R. (1999). Intermediate Financial
Management. The Dryden press. Florida:
57
Gorter, N. & Bloem ,M. (2002). “The macroeconomic statistical treatment of Non
Performing Loans Publication of the Organization for Economic
corporation & Development , 2nd Edition Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge.
Heath, Gibson. (2006), Doing Business with Banks: A Common Sense Guide for
Small Business borrowers. 3rd Edition DBA/USA Press.
Howard, L. and Thierry B. (2006) Trust in lending: social capital and joint liability
seed loans in Southern Zambia 4thEdtion Lusaka Zambia.
Kenneth D.Bailey, (2008). The art of loan and risk management2nd Edition,
Macmillan Inc.
58
Knox, S. (2004). Credit Analysis Technology in a Changing Business
Environment. 2nd Edition CFO Publishing Corporation Boston
Myers, C.S. and Brealey, R.A. (2003). Principles of Corporate Finance. 2nd Edition
McGraw-Hill publishers, New York.
Morduch J and Argion B.A. (2005) The Economics of Micro Finance Thematic 2 nd
Edition press Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England
Otero, M. and E. Rhyne (1994), The New World of Micro enterprise Finance, 4 th
Edition Hartford, Kumarian Press.
Pande, R. and Burgess, R.,(2005), “Can Rural Banks Reduce Poverty?.”, American
Economic Review. The Indian Social Banking Experiment Factors
Influencing Loan Repayment in Micro-Finance Institutions in Kenya
59
Sagimo, P.O (2002). Towards efficiency, effectiveness &productivity, 1 st Edition
Nairobi East publishers limited.
Yunus, M. (1999). Banker To The Poor: Micro Lending And The Battle Against
World Poverty. 1st Edition, New York USA
Yunus, M. (2003). Halving Poverty By 2015: 6th Edition. New York Press, USA.
60
APPENDIX
APPENDIX 1: QUESTIONNAIRE
In fulfillment for the award of HND in Banking and Finance, option of JSF
Polytechnic, am conducting a research on Loan Management on the financial
performance of Micro Finance Institutions in Buea: a case study of P&T Credit Union. I
will be grateful if you answer the following questions below according to the best of
your understanding. All answers will be used strictly for academic purpose only.
Instruction
6. Duration of the occupation; <1yr [ ] 1-3 yrs [ ] 4-7 yrs [ ] >7 yrs [ ]
SECTION B: SPECIFIC QUESTIONS.
61
8. If yes, what loan management policies does your institution employ?
Loan restructuring/review [ ] Liquidate the collateral [ ] Notice of default [ ]
Others (specify)……………………………………………………………………………………
9. In your view, does loan management affect the financial performance of your
13. In your view, are there strategies to improve financial performance? Yes[ ] No[ ]
Follow up evaluation [ ]
15. What is your general comment on the impact of loan management on the financial
performance of Micro Finance Institutions in Buea?
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………
Thank you
62
APPENDIX 2: INTERVIEW GUIDE
Thank you.
63