S.No. Document Name Drawing No.

EN001.00

EN002.00

EN003.00

M08013214-I1-GC Energy
1
Objections 4.25.23 (7) _CR NOTES
 M08013214-I1-GC Energy
1
Objections 4.25.23 (7) _CR NOTES
EN004.00

EN005.00

EN106.00

EN303.0
Page 21

EN001.00

M001.00

M099.0

M300
 M08013214-S2-MS Energy
2 Objections 4.26.23 (10)_CR
NOTES

E003.00

E004.00
 E009

E010

E012

M08013214-S3-PL Energy
3 P001
Objections 4.26.23 (1)_CR NOTES
 25 Water Street NYECC Compliance Project
Table Name

Envelope Assembly

Zone Green Complaince

Energy Cost Budget Worksheet

Window Schedule

Envelope Daigrams

-
 -

Energy Modelling

-
 -

Lighting
-

-
 25 Water Street NYECC Compliance Project
NYECC Comment
Not matching A-473
Not matching E-100
Not matching A-470
U-0.30 is connected

Not matching A-473

Exterior Wall Deduction zonning Not matching E-100.

Please use Excel Template available in:
https://www.nyc.gov/assets/buildings/excel/wall_ua_template.xlsx
EN-v.5 Fenestration Assembly
Separate Operable and Fixed Windows.
Separate Windows < 95' and Windows >= 95' above-grade

Submit Reports
NOTE: Review of overall Model Output Reports PENDING provision of complete supporting
documents (A- drawings) that support values/attributes claimed on EN1 form.
EN-a.8 Energy Modeling:
Complete review PENDING submission of complete/correct documents
Above grade wall and fenestration Not matching.
Fenestration Assembly: missing in Plans
EN-a.8 Energy Modeling:
For jobs that chose energy modeling as energy analysis method:
(a) Provide EN1 on EN- labeled sheet -- all values and attributes reported in EN1 must clearly match
drawings, and
(b) Submit model output reports as a separate supporting documentation to validate entries in EN1,
and
(c) Submit a supporting documentation index to tabulate compliance with mandatory provisions.
Energy Related Design Features Incomplete Objection for M08013214-S2-MS.
Incomplete Report floor above garage
Provide a specific drawing number documenting the section details and U-factor values, NOT a range
of drawings.
Supporting Doc location missing
Provide derivations, Not supported by drawings, Not supported by LV-D.LV-D lists U-0.028
Use Space By Space Method. See E-012, Unverifiable provide derivations.
Drawings not found in Plans/Sketch.
Provide complete derivation of all Modeled LPD's Space-by-Space.
Review of mechenical sections pending complete documentation
Not all equipment listed in EN1, e.g., MAU, CT
Provide a drawing number, unless this specific equipment schedule is on multiple drawings.
- typical note

Incorrect VT values
Document in Plans/Sketch under the main application.
Not supporting Section 6b.
Section 6b refers to A-200.
Document Fenestration Schedule in Plans/Sketch under the main application.
Specify "With Thermal Break" or "Without Thermal Break" for all fenestration assemblies that
comprise Spandrel Panels in order to allow use of Table 5.5.3.

Not matching EN-002

Report all below-grade walls that constitute building thermal envelope.
- typical note for ALL building elevations.

EN-a.6 Envelope Diagrams

Provide envelope diagrams in elevation/plan format on EN- labeled sheet to support envelope
components reported in energy analysis. Call out wall/fenestration/roof/floor types and area data (in
sf) on the envelope diagrams, and key them to the envelope energy analysis.
Thermal Boundary incorrect Refer A-101

Provide CLEAR FIELD Thermal Bridges list.

Missing LTBs, e.g., Fenestration Perimters.
Clarify window wall Area how matches section 6A of EN1
u-value walls not supported by drawings

See markup on EN-003 through EN-005 of M08013214-I1.

Further Review of EN1 sections for mechanical systems is PENDING submission of complete/correct
documents

Insulation schedule: Further Review of EN1 sections for mechanical systems is PENDING submission
of complete/correct documents

Specify ventilation controls for enclosed parking garage per 6.4.3.4.5.

Make up air unit schedule: Is Economizer provided?

Specify enthalpy recovery ratio.
Specify performance rating with reference to Table 6.8.1-7.
Missing in EN1
Not matching Model.
SV-A notes 280 kBtu/h

EN-m.8 Hot Water Boiler Controls

Specify hot water boiler controls on drawings as required including:

(a) Modulating burner and/or Minimum turndown ratio

(b) Outdoor temperature setback controls

EN-l.8 (a) Parking Garage Lighting Controls Refer to 9.4.1.2.

EN-l.4 Elevator Cab Specify elevator cab lamp efficacy, ventilation power limit, and controls on fans &
lighting systems to meet requirements.

EN-l.3 Electrical Energy Metering Specify separate electrical meter or sub-meter for each dwelling unit
and/or tenant space for buildings > 25,000 sf with tenant spaces > 5,000 sf.

EN-l.6 Whole-Building Energy & Electrical Monitoring Specify whole-building energy & electrical
monitoring devices in new buildings to individually monitor energy use of each energy type supplied
by utility, energy provider, or plant outside the building.

EN-l.10 Elevators, Escalators, & Moving Walks Specify elevators, escalators, and moving walks with
required efficiency, controls, and regenerative drives.

EN-l.5 (a) Electrical Energy Monitoring Specify electrical energy monitoring devices in new buildings
to separately measure/record total electrical energy, HVAC systems, interior lighting, exterior
lighting, and receptacle circuits.

For Future Fit-out spaces, on EACH floor plan that includes such space, provide the note below
Prior to occupancy/use of the space, the tenant/user/owner shall submit alteration job application to
the nyc dob with documents demonstrating the alteration work is in compliance with the nycecc.
Specifically, all proposed alteration scope of work that may pertain to
- building thermal envelope,
- lighting & electrical power systems, and/or
- mechanical systems (hvac & swh equipment)
Shall comply with the nycecc current at the time of submission, and shall attain approval from the nyc
dob.
Typical note for all future fit-out spaces
For Future Fit-out spaces, on EACH floor plan that includes such space, provide the note below.
Prior to occupancy/use of the space, the tenant/user/owner shall submit alteration job application to
the nyc dob with documents demonstrating the alteration work is in compliance with the nycecc.
Specifically, all proposed alteration scope of work that may pertain to
- building thermal envelope,
- lighting & electrical power systems, and/or
- mechanical systems (hvac & swh equipment)
Shall comply with the nycecc current at the time of submission, and shall attain approval from the nyc
dob.
Typical note for all future fit-out spaces

Document lighting fixture layout completely.The info is required to support derivation of Modeled
LPD

Use Table 9.6.1 for Assumed LPD's.

List all Assumed (Modeled) LPD's in Section 6d.1 'Space-by-Space Method' of EN1 form.
- Typical note for all spaces without lighting design
Cooling Capacity

Indicate the temperature range of the proposed system.

EN-m.6 Piping Insulation and Sealing

Specify piping insulation and sealing requirements for HVAC and service water heating systems on
drawings.
Responsible Party D2O Remark

D2O -

D2O -

D2O -

D2O -
 Need to provide drawings as per NYECC
Matt
comments

Need to provide details as per NYECC

Matt
comments

D2O -

Need to provide details as per NYECC

Matt
comments

Need to provide details as per NYECC

Matt
comments
D2O -

Need to provide drawings as per NYECC

Matt
comments

Need to provide drawings as per NYECC

Matt
comments

Need to provide drawings as per NYECC

Matt
comments

Revert as per the NYECC Comment, D2O

Matt will model accordingly. Also share
required drawings

Need to provide details as per NYECC

Matt
comments

Need to provide details as per NYECC

Matt
comments

Need to provide details as per NYECC

Matt
comments

Need to provide details as per NYECC

Matt
comments
 Need to provide details as per NYECC
Matt
comments

Need to provide details as per NYECC

Matt
comments

Need to provide details as per NYECC

Matt
comments

Need to provide details as per NYECC

Matt
comments

Need to provide details as per NYECC

Matt
comments

Need to provide details as per NYECC

Matt
comments

Need to provide details/ drawings as per

Matt
NYECC comments
 Need to provide details/ drawings as per
Matt
NYECC comments

Need to provide details/ drawings as per

Matt
NYECC comments

Need to provide details/ drawings as per

D2O
NYECC comments

Need to provide details/ drawings as per

Matt
NYECC comments

Need to provide details/ drawings as per

Matt
NYECC comments