Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Q2 The Effectiveness of Gadget-Based Interactive Multimedia in Improving Generation Z's Scientific Literacy
Q2 The Effectiveness of Gadget-Based Interactive Multimedia in Improving Generation Z's Scientific Literacy
3
Elementary Education Department, Faculty of Education, Universitas Negeri Surabaya
5
Graduate of the Postgraduate of Science Education,Universitas Negeri Surabaya
6
Student of Department of Education and Human Potentials Development, National Dong Hwa University,
Taiwan
DOI: 10.15294/jpii.v9i2.23208
Accepted: January 25th 2020. Approved: June 25th 2020. Published: June 30th 2020
ABSTRACT
Scientific literacy is very important to generation Z (Gen-Z), while Gen-z’s scientific literacy in Indonesia needs
to be improved. The use of gadgets by Gen-Z almost all the time in their daily lives enables research to improve
scientific literacy by using gadgets. This study aims to determine the effectiveness of gadget-based interactive
multimedia to improve Gen-Z scientific literacy and describe the Gen-Z response to interactive multimedia. This
research was a pre-experiment study with one group pretest and posttest design. Interactive multimedia was de-
signed to be applied on gadget, consists of Socioscientific Issues (SSI) which was relevant to pressure concepts.
This research involved two junior high schools in East Java, Indonesia. Scientific literacy test instrument was
designed based on scientific literacy aspects of PISA 2015. The inferential test results showed that posttest score
was significantly greater than the pretest in the two schools. Results showed that the mean score of students’ sci-
entific literacy at School I increased from 39.6 to 74.0 and N-gain score was 0.57 which was in medium category.
In addition, the average scientific literacy score of students in School II also increased from 31.5 to 59.9 and N-
gain score was 0.41 which was in the medium category. The inferential test results also showed that there were no
significant N-gain differences in the two schools. It can be concluded that interactive multimedia developed ef-
fective to improve students’ scientific literacy. However, Gen-Z students cannot be satisfied with the multimedia.
Students suggest several multimedia enhancements in terms of visual, audio, and music, so that they can enjoy
the multimedia all the time by using the device.
Science education in Indonesia is in prog- learning (Clayton & Murphy, 2016). Gadget be-
ressing. Since 2006 to 2018, scientific literacy comes a tool that makes students productive as
score of Indonesian students was fluctuated from long as directed by proper usage rules (Anshari
time to time (Organisation de coopération et de et al., 2017). This is in accordance with 21st cen-
développement économiques, 2019). However, tury information, media, and technology skills.
it is still below average level. This shows that This skills demand students to be able to access,
scientific literacy of Indonesia students need to understand, and analyze media messages to find
be improved with some efforts during learning information and using technology (Pacific Policy
process in school. Furthermore, this improve- Research Center, 2010).
ment can be achieved by applying creative ways Interactive multimedia is one of media
that attract students’ interest, so students become that can use gadget in the form of digital applica-
interested in reading, thinking, conducting inves- tion. Digital applications contribute significantly
tigations, and making decisions related to the is- to the implementation of didactic principles and
sues given. For example giving an issues related achievement of educational goals (Shi, 2013).
to culture and daily life (Dewi et al., 2019; Ratini, Learning and teaching process supported by mul-
et al., 2018; Alim et al., 2019). timedia attracts students and the creation of cor-
Meanwhile, junior high school students, rect conceptions (Chen, 2012). Multimedia and
known as generation Z (Gen-Z), have a tenden- virtual reality makes the world more visible in
cy cannot be separated from their gadget. An ways that others have never known before (Bilek,
amount of 171.17 million active users utilize 2012; Aberšek, 2013). Students prefer to learn so-
gadget to search for apps, games, and other digi- mething that facilitated by animation than facili-
tal content. More of that, almost every student of tated by other representation (Naqvi et al., 2013).
Primary to Senior High School Student already Theoretically, animation is more effective to port-
have gadget and operates it for daily activities. ray movement or dynamic process. Thus, anima-
The result of survey conducted by Indonesia In- tor becomes attractive option for educators. Rese-
ternet Service Provider Association (2018) sho- arch of Taufiq, et al. (2016), Ismail et al. (2016),
wed that 91% of people aged 15-19 year old use and Moore et al. (2014) confirm these statements.
internet. In addition, the average time they spent Socioscientific Issues (SSI) learning based
to use internet daily via any device is 8 hours 36 on issues in society related to science that stu-
minutes (APJII, 2018). dents will investigate, has been studied can imp-
Those data suggested that junior high rove students’ understanding, argumentation
school students in Indonesia are addicted to skills, empathy, and reasoning effectively about
gadget. Unfortunately, this addiction brings nega- science in various life contexts (Wulandari et al.,
tive impact for students. They will be busy with 2017), decision making (Siribunnam et al., 2014),
their gadget, so they will not study over again or proposed argument (Bilican, 2018), as well as en-
do their assignment. Nonetheless, their addiction vironmental literacy (Kinslow et al., 2019). Ho-
to gadget can give students some advantages if wever, SSI learning to increase scientific literacy
they also use gadget to do something more pro- is still limited.
ductive, such as for learning some skills, for ex- Some research were done in developing
panding the material they have learned at school, science learning media to enhance students’
etc. achievement, most of these studies showed posi-
Based on preliminary research conducted tive outcome (Chee et al., 2017; Wu et al., 2012.
in two junior high schools in East Java by inter- However, research about gadget based interactive
viewing teachers, it showed that they utilize the multimedia on pressure concepts, expecially to in-
internet sometimes to access or look for some in- crease students’ scientific literacy, is still limited.
formation related to learning. Teachers give stu- Even though there are many SSIs are related to
dents assignment or homework and students try the concept of pressure, for example tourists who
to finish their assignment or homework with the died while diving in the Gili Meno Waters of
help of the internet. Teachers never use a certain Lombok, tourists can’t wear high heels at ancient
application or software as a media of learning. sites in Greece, and smoke from Indonesia’s fo-
However, they are interested on using application rest fires to neighboring countries due to wind.
or software to accomplish learning objectives. The SSIs can be used as a context for further in-
These conditions can be utilized and pro- vestigation and decision making by students.
vide a large space for teachers to use gadget as Interactive multimedia can be used as a
a tool to support science learning. Utilization of platform to provide information, direction for in-
devices appropriately tends to generate student vestigations, and challenges for students to make
W. Widodo, E. Sudibyo, Suryanti,
250 D.A.P Sari, Inzanah, B. Setiawan / JPII 9 (2) (2020) 248-256
the Home, Experiments, Exercises, and About tific literacy pages. In addition, it also comes
menu), Home (contains the aims, concept map, with a Home, Returns, and Checks Your Level of
and material menu), and check the level of scien- Scientific Literacy icon.
Gen-z’s Scientific Literacy racy (Gen-Z’s scientific literacy) for each cogniti-
The percentage of students’ scientific lite- ve demand is presented in Table 1.
Table 1. Percentage of Students’ Scientific Literacy for Each Cognitive Demand
The results of the scientific literacy test (posttest). Based on the table, it is known that the
are represented in the form of scoring and leve- scientific literacy of students from 2 pilot schools
ling. The analysis carried out included pretest has increased during learning process in medium
and posttest data analysis which then calculated category.
N-gain scores to determine the increase in scores Students’ scientific literacy of low and me-
between before and after learning activities. Data dium cognitive demand at School I increased and
processed from the pretest and posttest aims to its N-Gain was 0.73 and 0.83 respectively, at high
determine the scientific literacy skills of students category. Scientific literacy on high cognitive de-
before and after learning activities. mand also increased and its N-gain was approxi-
Table 1 provides information regarding the mately 0.20 at low category. Meanwhile, N-gain
percentage of students' scientific literacy from 2 score of students’ scientific literacy of low, me-
pilot schools in solving questions in each cogni- dium, and high cognitive demand were increase
tive scientific literacy requested, which includes by 0.50, 0.40, and 0.44 at School II, at medium
low cognitive demand, namely L1 (pretest) and category.
L2 (posttest), moderate cognitive demand, na- The data on the results of overall students'
mely M1 (pretest) and M2 (posttest), and high scientific literacy tests from the two schools can
cognitive demand, namely H1 (pretest) and H2 be seen in the following tables.
Table 2. Results of the Scientific Literacy Test of Students
Score
No. School Name N-gain Score Criteria
Pre-test Post-test
1 School I 39.6 74.0 0.57 Medium
2 School II 31.5 59.9 0.41 Medium
These results indicate, the learning process science concepts well (Turiman, 2012). The con-
that discusses SSI, investigates, and practices ma- venience is seen from the change from the way of
king decisions, which is driven by gadget-based abstract thinking to the concrete way of thinking.
interactive multimedia can improve students’ So, it can indirectly increase students’ interest in
scientific literacy. With gadget-based interactive learning science process skills and the learning
multimedia, it turns out learning activities tend process becomes more effective.
to be student-centered, students investigate and The learning material prepared in accor-
learn to make decisions using real context. The- dance with the multimedia model supported by
se results are in line with studies of Ardianto & 7E positively influenced academic achievement
Rubini (2016) about using investigating methods and the information learned was more impressive
to improve students’ scientific literacy, Bustami et (Sarac & Tarhan, 2017). On the other hand, the
al. (2018) about the use of context and Cahyarini results of the study show that using the Socio-
(2016) research that SSI allows students to enhan- Scientific Issues approach can improve students’
ced critical thinking skills. ability to improve their decisions on environmen-
To study the consistency of treatment re- tal problems and the results show four patterns of
sults at two schools, and N-gain difference test student decisions (Zo’bi, 2014). Learning in the
was conducted between two schools with the 21st century should be linked to community life so
Mann-Whitney U Test. The result was the value students learn something like in real life. Integra-
of Z = -0,657 (p = 0.511) which showed no signi- ting science subject on technology, such as using
ficant difference in the two schools. gadget, helps students to gain their skills both
The results of the analysis showed the in science and technology (Asrizal et al., 2018).
achievement of N-gain of the students from the Thus, students can be prepared for future life.
two schools were not significantly different. This
shows that the gadget-based interactive multi- Gen-Z’s Response to SSI-Gadget
media developed resulted an increase in scienti- Gen-Z’s response is the student’s opinion
fic literacy that was relatively consistent in both on the quality of gadget-based interactive multi-
schools. These results indicate the power of inte- media, which is viewed from the aspects of ap-
ractive multimedia to improve scientific literacy, pearance, content, material, images/ animation/
in addition to positive responses from students, video, operations, links, audio (narration), scienti-
helped students to make connections between fic literacy tests, and menu instructions contained
content and context (Mylott et al., 2016), critical within gadget-based interactive multimedia. The
thinking disposition (Gunawan et al., 2019), and overall student response can be seen in Table 3.
meaningful understanding and retention of the Based on Table 3 it can be seen that the
conceptual structure of the domain, the concepts, percentage of students’ average responses to
and their relations (Marée al., 2013). the quality of gadget-based interactive multime-
The impact of the interactive multime- dia from the two schools of testing was > 80%,
dia used in learning activities was that students which means that students give positives respond
could explore new concepts that were closer to to learning activities using the developed gadget-
their daily experiences and were able to explain based interactive multimedia.
Table 3. Student Response to Gadget-based Interactive Multimedia Quality
Percentage(%)
No. School Name
1 Meeting
st
2 Meeting
nd
Exercises Response
1 School I 88 88 79 87
2 School II 95 95 88 95
In addition to the questionnaire, an open that teacher’s explanation during the learning
questionnaire also be given to students that ask activity was clear and easy to understand. It was
students’ impressions of learning activities using also not boring.
the developed gadget-based interactive multime- This gadget-based interactive multimedia
dia. The learning activities that have taken place helps students to understand the concept of sub-
were very interesting and exciting (“…The lear- stance pressure and its application in daily life.
ning activity is different than usual because involving This application also helps students to solve the
mobile phone or gadget as a media, so it became more problem while sharpening their scientific litera-
interesting and is not monotonous). They also said cy by providing students with some videos (“…
W. Widodo, E. Sudibyo, Suryanti,
254 D.A.P Sari, Inzanah, B. Setiawan / JPII 9 (2) (2020) 248-256