Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 13

Cambridge Archaeological Journal 7:1 (1997), 57-69

Archetypal Landscapes and the Interpretation of Meaning

Ronald J. Nash

Carl Jung's analytic ideas on archetypes offer an approach to interpreting ancient mean-
ings in the absence of historic records. The archetypes of the collective unconscious are
said to maintain a uniformitarian consistency over time in form and meaning. Their
recurrent expression in the vernacular arts, dreams, even film of recent times permits
exploration of these same archetypes in ancient contexts. The theory is discussed and
applied to three landscapes, archetypal landscapes of glacial wasteland, primordial sea and
forest labyrinth.

Landscape is a flexible concept and this in part ac- It is argued in this article that psychoanalytic1 theory,
counts for its popularity among cognitive archaeolo- especially Carl Jung's ideas of archetypes, offers a
gists. In a natural sense, it is an evolutionary aggre- possible avenue to ancient minds and meaning which
gate of landforms (Olwig 1993,307). But it has cultural merits exploration by archaeologists. The method
aspects too, ideological in the sense of control and opens up a wealth of transcendental knowledge
ontological as something that is experienced. Tilley which can be extrapolated back through time as far
offers a phenomenological, or subject-centred de- as uniformitarian principles of brain/mind will al-
scription of landscape including the following: 'A low — presumably to the Upper Palaeolithic.
landscape is a series of named locales, a set of rela-
tional places linked by paths, movements and narra- Meaning
tives.' (1994, 34) In recent years, there has been increasing interest in
It is argued here that the archetypal landscape the thoughts and emic views of ancient peoples, an
has an additional dimension of meaning — a surreal interest among archaeologists and the public alike.
or fantastic quality (by scientific standards) which There is, however, considerable debate over the ex-
assumes that there is no isomorphism or concord- tent to which meaning is archaeologically recover-
ance with its natural or social dimensions. This qual- able. Post-processual archaeologists (e.g. Hodder
ity is especially apparent in the case of the glacial 1992; Shanks 1992; Tilley 1994) are more optimistic
wasteland. than processually minded archaeologists.
In this article, case materials are centred on the For the last generation of archaeologists, most
Maritime provinces of Atlantic Canada, which have of whom worked in a positivist and materialist para-
been home to the Algonkian-speaking Mi'kmaq for digm, mind was an epiphenomenon, ultimately the
at least 3000 years. This part of the Northeast was product of infra-structural variables and not of pri-
directly overridden by continental ice-sheets, subject mary explanatory importance. The processual ne-
to extensive post-glacial inundation and then glect of cognition has been helpfully redressed in
forested, developing into the mixed Acadian forest The Ancient Mind: Elements of Cognitive Archaeology
of today. These successive landscapes are 'real' in a (Renfrew & Zubrow 1994). Yet despite the ingenuity
natural sense; but in a cultural sense they have be- of the case studies, there is a recurrent theme of
come surreal, archetypal in their great antiquity and limits. Understanding meaning is said to require writ-
of general interest. ten texts, oral tradition or a rich iconography (e.g.
Are the meanings of these landscapes, anoma- Scarre 1994, 81) and ethnographic analogy is re-
lies and other features unrecoverable in the absence stricted to comparisons that are 'tight' and local (Hill
of written records or symbolic, petroglyphic archives? 1994,88). Of course, all of these studies deal with the

57
Ronald J. Nash

conscious mind and its material signatures, for the and instincts form the collective unconscious, the in-
unconscious mind falls outside the framework of the stincts determining our actions, the archetypes our
empirical method as employed by these authors. Jung mode of apprehension (Hyde & McGuinnes 1992,
always claimed to be working empirically, simply 59). As a crystal can emerge from a liquid, an arche-
using dreams and symbols as data. type too can arise and push into consciousness as an
The conscious mind is presently understood archetypal image. Thus, archetypes are revealed as
not as a location in the brain, but rather as some- images only at the conscious level, whereupon they
thing as insubstantial as a rainbow, an effect pro- acquire meaning. 'The term "image" is intended to
duced by the patterned firing of neurons across express not only the form of the activity taking place,
synapses (Nash et al. 1995). The unconscious mind, but the typical situation in which the activity is re-
although it probably exists, is an even greater un- leased' Qung 1968c, 78). There is of course a personal
known. Nonetheless, we can reasonably assume that unconscious as well, but it is of less interest to this
the psyche (conscious and unconscious mind) of the study, simply because it is personal and particular to
fully modem humans of 40,000 years ago was not individuals.
significantly different to that of people today. The The larger interest lies with the primordial or
images would differ, the functioning would not. This archetypal images of a collective nature arising from
degree of time depth and uniformitarian operation the unconscious and recurring in many times and
is essential to the following Jungian arguments as to places. The unconscious is seen as an active and
archetypes and the collective unconscious. By ad- dynamic force, expressed as a labyrinth of myth,
mitting only the conscious mind as a cultural reposi- symbol, even compulsive behaviours which could
tory, we omit the vast substratum of unconscious unfold over time and be constructed over time, for
meanings of things as they appear in symbolic dis- the collective mind and society are inseparable. The
guise as analogy. We also fail to grasp their histori- images themselves are detectable cross-culturally,
cal antecedents in primordial archetype form. but Jung considered the forms to be inborn rather
than products of cultural diffusion. Like the philoso-
Archetypes and meaning pher Kant, Jung accepted both empirical knowledge
Swiss psychoanalyst Carl Jung, himself interested in derived from experience and transcendental knowl-
anthropology and archaeology, examined a wide va- edge arising from dreams, intuition, synchronicities,
riety of subjects from alchemy to dreams as they visions, active imagination and so on such that real-
pertained to the unconscious mind. Beginning in ity was partly a social construction. Jungian therapy
1902, he published extensively, gaining an increas- can take the form of reconnecting individuals with
ingly wide public audience beyond the field of psy- these hidden or consciously lost archetypal images.
chology. His collected works, and especially volume Jung's archetypes are universal images mani-
9, part 1, The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious fested as the mother earth goddess, the hero, the
(1968c), a series of articles begun in 1933, represent wise old man (e.g. Merlin), the judge, the healer, the
the professional and detailed exposition of these two trickster or, for example, those identified by Moore
concepts which could be useful to cognitive archae- & Gillette (1992) — King, Lover, Warrior, Magician;
ology. Man and His Symbols (1964) is a later series of or by Wolff — Mother, Amazon, the Medial Woman
articles for public consumption. and the Heteira (Moore & Gillett, 216). The Hero With
Jung proposed that archetype (literally, prime a Thousand Faces (1973) is an extended treatment of
imprinter) is a pre-existent form, not an unconscious an archetype by Joseph Campbell; many more are to
idea, which has an a priori existence. They, the arche- be met in mythology and fairy tales. The Shadow,
types, are hereditary, inherent in human nature, and the Anima and Animus are archetypal parts of hu-
comparable to the axial system of a crystal hidden in man nature. There are archetypal events of transfor-
a liquid context (Jung 1968c, 79; Jaffe 1970, 18). 'The mation — initiation, marriage and rebirth and even
more archaic and "deeper", that is the more physi- geometrical forms such as the mandala (magic cir-
ological, the symbol is, the more collective and uni- cle). Animals too are said to be 'symbolic denizens of
versal, the more "material" it is' (1968c, 173). That is, the collective unconscious' (Henderson 1964,153).
the collective archetype is grounded 'in the sub-cor- An archetype is primordial, having existed from
tical centres, the cerebellum and the spinal cord' 'time immemorial' or 'remotest times' (Jung 1968c,
(Jung 1968c, 166) and finally extinguished in the car- 5). Archetypes often appear in dreams, arising from
bon of the body. The archetype per se belongs to the the unconscious, but become modified and more
unconscious and is therefore unknowable. Archetypes indirect as they enter the conscious mind to become

58
Archetypal Landscapes

historically coded in myth and fairy tales (Jung 1968c, the inevitable one-sidedness and extravagances of
5). The archetypes are an expression of Logos, the the conscious mind. (Jung 1968c, 162)
ordering function (Hutchison pers. comm. Jan 13/
96). The archetypes group things and struggle to While meanings may be consistent, the archetype
enter into consciousness, giving rise to an inner con- cannot be fully and rationally explained since the
viction or sense of meaning. But as Jung asks, pure archetype as such exists only in the collective
From what source, in the last analysis, do we de- unconscious. 'The ultimate core of meaning may be
rive meaning? The forms we use for assigning circumscribed, but not described' (Jung 1968c, 156).
meaning are historical categories that reach back This necessary but lengthy exposition can be
into the mists of time — a fact we do not take concluded with a few comments as to the role of
sufficiently into account. Interpretations make use Jungian psychology in anthropology. Jung, more so
of certain linguistic matrices that are themselves than Freud, studied myth, linking it to the psyche
derived from primordial images . . . Ultimately and the collective unconscious. The relationship be-
they are all founded on primordial archetypal forms tween myth and psyche is stated most succinctly by
whose concreteness dates from a time when con- Joseph Campbell, who was greatly influenced by
sciousness did not think, but only perceived. (Jung
1968c, 32, 33). Jung's works: "The symbolic most characteristic of
the psyche is the symbology of mythology' (quoted
Thus, there is not only meaning consciously arising, in Larsen & Larsen 1991, 294). Jung's influence can
but an a priori unconscious meaning in the archetype also be seen in anthropologist Paul Radin's analysis
(cf. Jaffe 1970,152). of the Winnebago hero myth (Radin 1948; Henderson
Jung had many supporters and proponents in- 1964, 103) and I expect, without investigating the
side and outside psychiatry, but his ideas of arche- connection, that French structuralism and particu-
types and a collective unconscious naturally attracted larly Claude Levi-Strauss' 'elementary ideas' are in-
criticism before and after his death in 1961. Arche- debted to Jung. Archaeologists have periodically
types were labelled metaphysical, untestable and the referenced the unconscious mind with respect to
products of experience or diffusion (see Hall & material culture from the time of General Pitt Rivers
Lindzey 1957, 107). Of his critics Jung would ask in the 1880s until today. There has not to my knowl-
why, if these images originate in the conscious mind, edge, however, been any systematic application of
does their sudden appearance so astonish us? And psychoanalytic theory or investigation of recurrent
why do they recur in dreams among people, includ- archetypes — which is the goal of this article.
ing children, who have no connection with one an-
other or experience of the archetype? (Jung 1964,58) Archetypal landscapes
Our interest here is not to decide an unresolved
question in psychology, nor whether archetypes are The idea of an archetype can be helpful not only in
any less real than pottery types, but to investigate archaeomythology, but can usefully be extended to
their utility for the discovery of meaning. landscapes. Jung himself did not do this, although
The critical point for this article is that if land- he singled out an island motif (Jung 1968c, 196). I
scapes, menhirs or other material remains can be would think that a landscape becomes archetypal
construed as potential archetypal images, then their when it is recurrent, recognizable in shape, but also
meanings ought to remain at least consistent to those disturbingly unfamiliar in its dream-like qualities.
open to such deeper perception. Modifications to Such qualities are to be found in surrealist art (Jaffe
meaning will occur in so far as the archetypes move 1964, 294) and in some film genres, particularly the
into conscious thought to become mythic formulas. fantastic, computer-generated landscapes of science
It is the form that is a priori, the content of the arche- fiction. There is a latent power and energy in these
type is filled in upon conscious realization and expe- landscapes, or mindscapes, perhaps because they
rience (Jung 1968c, 79). The strain toward consistency are often sparsely populated, and in a sense, pris-
in meaning ought to continue into the future. Of the tine, newborn.
child archetype, Jung writes: The flexible and dynamic aspects of the land-
The child motif represents not only something that scape, even its subjective aspects, make it a useful
existed in the distant past, but also something that framework for a variety of disciplines including cog-
exists now; that is to say it is not just a vestige but a nitive archaeology (Bender 1993). It is noteworthy
system functioning in the present whose purpose that in this latter volume, Cosgrove (1993, 281) dis-
is to compensate or correct, in a meaningful manner, tinguishes Wilderness, Garden and City as archetypal

59
Ronald J. Nash

landscapes scaled with respect to human impact. drainage patterns, a multitude of smaller lakes and a
The mythologizing of landscape continues in the moss-lichen vegetation suitable for caribou, most of
twentieth century with the American Old West, whom migrate to the forest in the winter. Human
Hollywood and the Smalltown USA of Norman occupation was either seasonal, by the Chipewyan,
Rockwell and Sinclair Lewis. Anthropomorphized and or restricted to a few microbands of Caribou Inuit in
drained of their energy, these and other landscapes historic times. In its simplicity, vastness and empti-
(Fantasyland, Tomorrowland) are repackaged as ness, the barren lands have the power to evoke a
'lands' at the Disney theme parks. While these land- sense of wonder and a feeling that here is the begin-
scapes might be called archetypal in a loose sense, ning of things. It is exotic and dreamlike. There is
they are really conscious constellations of symbols. also a feeling of familiarity, of deja vu that may come
Archetypal landscapes are truly primordial and not from discovery at an impressionable age, but
collective. The landscape per se is not an archetype; it from the resonance of an archetypal motif — the
has no autonomous meaning. It is rather a fruitful glacial wasteland.
source of images/symbols for mythological expres- During the Wisconsin glaciation, ice advanced
sion. These archetypal images and myths carry and into the Maritime provinces of the northeast from
convey powerful meaning at the deepest level for several directions as well as radiating out from local
peoples living in various natural contexts (Hutchison centres. For Nova Scotia, as exemplar, the situation
pers. comm. Jan 13/96). They are not all equally as of 15,000 years ago has been summarized as fol-
derived from 'time immemorial', but have accumu- lows: 'Ice sheet beginning to retreat, 10-15°C below
lated as the psyche has evolved and are, accordingly, present, cold and dry; sea-levels 150 m below present
differentially developed in myths, dreams etc.; they levels; tundra' (The Natural History of Nova Scotia,
are stratified in a sense as an archaeology of the mind. vol. 1, 1984, 80). By 12,500 years ago, only remnant
Two archetypal landscapes are proposed for ice pockets remained and sea-levels were rising. By
the northeast coast of America, developed with data 12,000 years ago, Nova Scotia was ice free and topped
from the Canadian Maritime Provinces. The earliest by ground moraine and a series of glacial features
candidate is the glacial wasteland. This hostile and such as drumlins, eskers, erratics and kames, which
frozen wasteland of barrens and ice mountains pre- were of interest to all later peoples of the area.
cedes even wilderness and is of a time before the Bonnichsen et al. (1991) briefly outline the inter-
earth assumes its more recent form. To this time related events of deglaciation, marine fluctuations
belongs the oldest cycle of myths and tales in which and the timing of subsequent plant, animal and human
are crude animals, often of great size. The next ar- colonization, beginning with the tundra ecosystem:
chetypal landscape is the primordial sea — dark, hid- Tundra which existed between 14,000 and 10,000
den and the domain of monsters such as whales. BP was characterized by sedges, willows, grasses,
This realm, a seascape, finds widespread surface ex- sage and other composites, alders and birch. Over-
pression in such mythological motifs as the primor- all, this tundra was shrubbier than modern tundra
dial sea, the flood and the earth diver. of northern Canada. (Bonnichsen et al. 1991,10)
The landscapes are of course tied to the north- Railton (1975) states that for Nova Scotia, there was
ern latitudes and peoples where glaciation did oc- a 2500-year interval between the last of the remnant
cur, but they should not be considered isomorphic ice and the invasion of spruce (pollen zone A).
and palaeo-ecologically determined landscapes, for In Nova Scotia, the Maritimes generally and
they are cultural, not natural constructs. Moreover, much of New England, this immediate post-glacial
the landscape includes only those flora and fauna of landscape was likely to have been something of a
symbolic interest. Finally, since landscape is a visual wasteland of unconsolidated drift plains, meltwater
product, the use of analogies will include reference lakes, rivers and ponds, disintegration moraine with
to films where appropriate. coastlines retreating in the face of rising seas and
long, bitterly cold winters — a bleak, empty, mo-
The glacial wasteland notonous and ravaged topography.
The cold, dry climate plus the absence of soil
The author, as a young archaeologist, was fortunate and nutrients forestalled forest development, but did
enough to work for seven field seasons in the barren permit colonization by grasses and other tundra veg-
grounds of the Canadian north (Nash 1975). This re- etation. The density and primary productivity of this
cently deglaciated landscape no longer has the large cover is not known, but it was in time sufficient
glacial lakes, but retains long, sandy eskers, immature to support large grazing animals. Horse, muskox,

60
Archetypal Landscapes

mammoth, mastodon and caribou are reported from Lewis Spence recounted a similar story in his
northeastern United States Palaeo-Indian sites and 1914 collection of myths and legends. There are, as
the continental shelf, although only the last two can in the Rand account, two visits of the Winter giant to
be placed in Nova Scotia. The small faunal samples the wigwam, a struggle, a melting. In the Spence
that have been recovered do not indicate substantial version, whose source is unspecified and linked only
populations nor a megafauna comparable in num- to the Algonkians, Summer is represented by the
bers to that of the Eurasian steppes. Rising sea levels 'Elves of Light' and the Indian is Glooscap. 'To them
and the submergence of the continental shelf also [the natives] Winter was a giant, and summer an elf
permitted the expansion of marine mammals (whales, of pigmy proportions' (1994, 149). Spence believed
seals ) into new, shallow water habitats and into the this story was an aetiological nature myth whose
newly formed Champlain Sea. function it was to explain the origin of the seasons.
The Glooscap component may suggest a later
Mythology/legend version than the Rand story. In any event, history
Roger C. Echo-Hawk, in a brief essay entitled 'An- and culture change are not typically functional-eco-
cient Worlds' has tried to compare and integrate logical variables. Spence's model may be accurate to
scientific data and native mythology for western some extent, but it is not a very deep analysis and
North America. He attempts to correlate native oral does not cover or explain related stories also involv-
traditions concerning darkness, the flood, giant ani- ing gigantism. It is not comprehensive enough.
mals and the entry of humans into the Americas The elements of ice and gigantism are also at-
with the evidence of climatology, palaeontology and tributes of the Chenoo3 or ice giants of the north, but
archaeology (1993, 6). This is a laudable effort using these Chenoo, while possessing hearts of ice and
data of comparable age and type to that here. None- subject to melting, have become half human. In the
theless, it should be distinguished from the present story collected by Rand in 1859, the Chenoo has
attempt to analyze mythology on its own terms as even become tamed, humanized and dies a Catholic
containing symbolic meanings of great antiquity. Nor (1894,198) — presumably a codicil to the original.
is the analysis a search for archaic historical survivals Occasionally, stories will involve an Ice Age
in the method and tradition of Sir James Fraser (cf. mammal such as a giant beaver. Among Algonkian
Schama 1995, 208). In this connection, it should be tribes, trickster-transformer figures such as Glooscap
noted that while Algonkian is a language family of are said first to have made the animals very large
great time depth in eastern North America, Mi'kmaq and then reduced them in size for the benefit of
as an ethnic and linguistic group can, at the moment, humans (Hoffman 1955, 393, 401), again, an echo of
be traced back archaeologically only about 3000 years, the first world.
to the Archaic/Woodland interface.
In The Ice Man, the Reverend Silas Rand (1894, Meaning
99) published a story of how, in the spring, an In- These myths, so impenetrable to rationalist, materi-
dian2 struggles and vanquishes a monster 'ice-cake' alist thought, are better understood in a transcen-
(the Ice King) only to have this animate Ice King re- dental paradigm. The myths above are not didactic
enter his wigwam the following winter. With his sup- as Rand or Spence concluded, nor a 12,000 year old
ply of firewood, this time the Indian is able to build oral tradition, but later archetypal expressions of the
up the fire and begin to melt the Ice King who is finally glacial wasteland. In a sense, the early postglacial
forced to depart, taking the cold with him. Rand landscape, a void, has been personified into a gigan-
interprets this story as a moral and didactic fable tic antagonist — the Ice King or Winter Giant. The
reminiscent of Aesop's tale of the grasshopper and ice and cold symbolize death, the hearts of ice a lack
the ant (a version of which exists among the Mi'kmaq). of feeling (heartless) — but not a lifeless landscape.
Surely this is not the reading. The contextual As if to fill up the landscape, animals are inflated,
elements — the wide river, the killing cold, the huge crude, strong and numinous and only recently emer-
size of the ice-being and its animate nature — plus a gent from the unconscious.
theme of struggle and power exchange as the melt- To borrow a symbol from Jung and the Book of
ing proceeds — all deconstruct to an ancient land- Job, these animals are the Behemoth.
scape far removed from the nineteenth-century Whereas Leviathan is a fish-like creature, primi-
clergyman Silas Rand. Only the presence in the tale tive and cold-blooded, dwelling in the depths of
of 'old dry trees' for the fire is at odds with a the ocean, Behemoth is a warm-blooded quadru-
periglacial environment. ped, presumably something like a bull, who roams

61
Ronald J. Nash

the mountains (at least in later tradition). Hence he conscious realization (Jaffe 1970, 24), i.e. from polar-
is related to Leviathan as a higher, superior crea- ity to dualism.
ture to a lower, inferior one, rather like the winged The archetypal glacial wasteland is not a cogni-
and the wingless dragon in alchemy. Qung 1968d, tive mapping of any natural landscape, yet there are
120). enough correspondences to permit processualist-style
Behemoth symbolizes 'the crudest force conceivable testing of cultural constructs which derive from a
in nature' and an undifferentiated collective attitude transcendental paradigm. Hopefully, in the absence
(Jung 1968a; 1968b, 184). Both had power. of a unified field theory, middle-range theory can
At first relatively powerless compared to the bridge the objectivist and idealist traditions and pro-
'Kings' and the animals, the humans seem as part of vide support for the idea of an archeypal landscape.
the landscape — observers and narrators. It is not a At worst, we may have to accept what van der Leeuw
dreamtime landscape; it has not been socialized and termed a 'bee's eye view', a multi-faceted picture
is hardly a phenomenological landscape as defined which can provide some insights if one is prepared
above by Tilley. to accept the fracture lines between the facets and to
To be archetypal, the images must be repeat- make a number of 'leaps of faith across them' (van
able in form, not in specifics of content. The myths der Leeuw 1995, 88).
considered above, even if quite old, would be later The unconscious mind is more of a minefield
expressions of the archetype. In another mythologi- for many individuals, something to be repressed or
cal guise, the wasteland itself reappears as the home otherwise avoided or projected outwards on to the
of the wounded Fisher King in the Arthurian tales of blank slate (tabula rasa) of landscape. For ancient
Dark Age Britain. Today, in an industrial context, peoples, divination, magic and avoidance become
the glacial wasteland becomes the toxic wasteland coping strategies. In the case of the Canadian
for regions such as the Tjlack triangle' in the north- Maritimes, and Nova Scotia in particular, there is
ern part of the Czech Repulic. apparently an interval, perhaps 2500 years (Railton
Modern animals, more conscious and reduced in 1975), prior to the colonization of the spruce forest.
size, can reappear in more archetypal form, as in Case The Clovis-like site at Debert, Nova Scotia, is securely
Y, one of Jung's patients who dreamed of a 'terrible dated to about 10,600 years BP (MacDonald 1968); it
monster, an enormous bear'. Jung comments on this is the earliest site in the whole region, but fairly late
bear and the sky-woman who protected the patient: in terms of the Palaeo-Indian period of the northeast.
Here we have a maternally protective goddess re- Possibly the 'blasted', postglacial landscape was sim-
lated to bears, a kind of Diana or the Gallo-Roman ply empty in Nova Scotia, avoided as a 'no-man's'
Dea Artio. The sky-woman is the positive, the bear land for centuries. Certainly the idea is testable.
the negative aspect of the 'superordinate personal- A second implication derives from the Mi'kmaq
ity', which extends the conscious human being up- myths which portray a power struggle between hu-
wards into the celestial and downwards into the mans and a frozen, antagonistic landscape with co-
animal regions. (1968d, 195). lossal and fantastic animals. The humans are almost
Thus, viewed archetypally, the glacial wasteland with anomalies. They are initially puny but, in a David vs
its god-like 'Kings', its behemoth animals and its Goliath struggle, triumph over the creatures of the
puny humans retains a core of meaning. It is argued unconscious. This struggle could find expression in
that it has a related set of meanings for ancient the cave art of Europe (such evidence being absent
Algonkians, twentieth-century filmmakers4 and as yet in northeastern North America). The power
dreamers. "The shaping of these variants depends differential might be manifested through differences
equally on the unconscious disposition (the organiz- in size, colour or some other attribute which would
ing archetype) the environment, personal experience shift as the human-animal relationship altered, ulti-
and the given culture' (Jaffe 1970,18). The axial core mately terminating in mass extinctions of the
meaning may been a dyad of the form. Pleistocene megaf auna, even as the lithic technology
was homologously shrinking in size.
Nothingness, tabula rasa, death/hypertrophic
growth The primordial sea

The original model of the unconscious archetype The figurative melting of the Ice King and the literal
held that its wholeness is paradoxical or antinomian melting of the continental ice sheets by 10,000 BP
and that the discrimination of opposites occurs upon resulted in a worldwide rise in sea levels of the order

62
Archetypal Landscapes

of 100+ metres. The effects vary from coast to coast what was once Mount Everest (read Mt Ararat) by a
and involve not only marine transgressions but transformed terrestial Adam and Eve.
coastal downwarping, erosion and isostatic rebound. Although set in the future, Waterworld touches
The overall pattern was one of coastal instability. On the deepest levels of the human psyche — which are
the northeast coast of Canada, coastal stabilization archetypal. The imagery can be found even among
was not reached, on average, until 3000-2000 years inland native tribes of the Americas, where floods
BP; on the northwest coast of Canada, near-stabili- can also be river floods. In The Origin of Table Man-
zation was a little earlier, 5000^000 BP (Fladmark ners, Claude Levi-Strauss undertakes a structuralist
1983). The specifics of these events in Canada and analysis of the American examples (1978, part 7).
elsewhere are not of concern. What is of concern is Other examples, such as the flood myths of the an-
that these events did occur, that the world's coast- cient Near East, are interpreted from various per-
lines were dynamic, and that the seas drowned the spectives in an edited collection, The Flood Myth
continental margins, displacing people inland and (Dundes 1988). There have been various types of
providing archetypal images for a flood mythology. models proposed to 'explain' the origin of these
This is not to say that the natural basis for flood myths — historical, structuralist, psychoanalytic and
mythology and an archetypal primordial sea were diffusionist. Some types are incommensurate, others
not laid down during analogous events of the previ- are not sufficiently parsimonious or comprehensive.
ous interstadial or interglacial periods, at least in the In any case, the interest here goes beyond a flood
Old World. episode to a longitudinal study of a dynamic land-
It is significant that similar processes are pres- scape — the primordial sea.
ently in progress — large-scale calving of the Antarctic It is argued here that the sea is best understood
ice cap, threatening the low-lying, heavily-populated as symbolic of the unconscious, which in its collec-
delta areas with submergence, and a general global tive aspect, gives rise to images of recurrent form.
warming powered by the Greenhouse Effect. Ac- 'The sea is the favourite symbol for the unconscious'
cordingly, it is not unexpected to see archetypal ideas (Jung 1968c, 177-8) or 'sea=unconscious' (Jung 1968d,
re-emerging; they typically do so in times of crisis. 106). This symbolism applies to lakes and ponds, of
The reader's attention is directed to the 1995 course, whereas rivers are interpreted as bounda-
film, Waterworld (Universal Pictures) and Collins' ries. Water in general symbolizes the unconscious,
tie-in novel (1995). The plot is not a mere genre for- but any encyclopedia of symbols lists many other
mula, but is overtly symbolic, reworking mythologi- associations (e.g. Cooper 1978).
cal themes and codes of great antiquity. Briefly, As with the glacial wasteland, the primordial
several centuries in the future, in a setting of bleak, sea is not to be identified with a particular natural
endless ocean created by the melting of the polar ice environment, but is a cultural image, giving a gener-
caps, there exists a degenerate culture and society alized meaning to a later sort of landscape or sea-
clinging to boats or constructed 'atolls'. These 'at- scape. Its meaning that is sought either through
olls' are surrealistic, circular, walled settlements, ephemera — dreams, myth, fairy tales, and tradi-
which resemble the self in the unconscious sea (dis- tion, film etc. — or through material remains that are
cussed below). These settlements are trash-heaps of the behavioural results of these emic views. It fol-
bricolage and post-industrial salvage. The particular lows that these remains need not be ancient — as
atoll, called Oasis, has a lagoon inside, and a motley Schiffer (1976) and other archaeologists have noted.
collection of atollans who retain shreds and patches While the glacial wasteland remains a loosely encoded
of the old dryland culture. Outside the atoll are the memory, the sea is still with us, the object of uncon-
hostile and primitive pirates of the dark unconscious, scious perception and conscious symbolic imagery.
warlike nomads reminiscent of the pastoralist 'bar-
Ocean. The primordial waters; chaos; formlessness;
barians' that preyed on the early walled cities of the material existence; endless motion; it is the source
ancient Near East. of all life, containing all potentials; the sum of all
The narrative and conflict deal with the search possibilities in manifestation; the 'unfathomable'
for mythical dryland somewhere beyond the hori- the anima mundi, the Great Mother. The ocean also
zon. There is an earth-diver episode and some arche- symbolizes the sea of life which has to be crossed.
(Cooper 1978,121)
typal characters — a heroic, maritime Adam and Eve,
a wise old man and a foundling child, plus sea mon- The sea contains a bountiful and voracious fauna of
sters — a decaying supertanker above and a 'whalefin' ancient and primitive form, while in the depths of
Leviathan below. Refuge is finally discovered on seas, or even lakes, lurk monsters. In volume 9, part

63
Ronald J. Nash

2 of the collected works — Aion — Jung discusses fish holographic sort of universe requires Power.
symbolism in Christian theology, alchemy and as- The flood story was recorded among the
trology. Fish in general are interpreted as ambivalent Mi'kmaq in 1675-1683 by Chrestian Le Clercq and
symbols, for while fish are frequently venerated as by T.H. Raddell in 1933. This story — "The Big Water
gods, they have also been the object of food taboos, Came and Drowned the Whole World' — features a
as among the Egyptian priesthood Qung 1968d, 121). man called Sebanees, who with a boat of ice, saves
One particular small, round fish (Echeneis the believers among the people, the birds, and other
remora), the remora or sucking-fish, was of special in- animals when water drowned the World. The debris
terest to the medieval alchemists and to Jung. With its from the melting ice boat settled as Prince Edward
sucker, this curious, round fish attaches itself either Island (Whitehead 1991, 5).
to a larger fish or to a ship's hull, thereby travelling The ice boat of gigantic proportions brings to
throughout the oceans. Jung interprets this dweller mind the postglacial epoch, as does the Flood itself,
in the centre of the universal sea as a symbol of the while the whole life-boat (ark) episode has a Biblical
self in its unconscious state (Jung 1968d, 142) — the flavour. Yet Jerry Lonecloud (cited below) is un-
self being a central ordering of the whole personal- doubtedly correct in claiming that this is not a Bibli-
ity, unconscious and conscious. 'Fishing is an intui- cal flood story. The theme of the story is a flood, and
tive attempt to catch unconscious contents (fishes)' a minor point is the gigantic ice-boat which finally
(Jung 1968d, 152). In the eating of fish, there is a melts leaving the rocks and soils to form Prince
connection with the origin (Jung 1968c, 139). Edward Island, presently 110 miles long. The narra-
The unconscious, like the darkness and chaos tive connects the island with ice which is surely
of the ocean depths, can be a dangerous place, the glacial and with the meltwaters which cut off this
realm of monsters. Sometimes the sea-monsters are province from the mainland. Thus the context is more
real, but appear to us as primordial anachronisms. postglacial than Biblical, but it is not a story of the
The Mi'kmaq of Nova Scotia feared killer whales. type to explain why Prince Edward Island is geo-
Elsewhere, sharks or giant eels, or the alligators of graphically unique (analogous to the stories of ani-
tropical zones, have been the feared ones. Some mon- mals and their characteristics). Nor is the story a
sters were quasi-mythological and distinguished by 10,000-year-old survival. The meaning of the flood
gigantism, such as the giant squid, while others were (rather than the fate of the ice-boat) becomes clearer
wholly mythological — horned serpents, the when we examine the Lonecloud version of the myth.
Babylonian Tiamat and the Biblical Leviathan, up Here, as in earlier mythological analyses, we need to
from the unconscious. look at the whole of the myth rather than selected
In psychological terms, the sea is more an alien parts which might lead us to a superficially correct
world, especially in its depths. It is destructive in its functional interpretation.
floods, it continually devours the land and its sea life In the 1920s, the Mi'kmaq elder and medicine
ranges from friendly (dolphins) to fearful (whales). showman Jerry Lonecloud related a very similar story
to Clarisse A. Dennis on several occasions, with vary-
Mythology'/legend ing amounts of detail (Whitehead 1992,15,16,41,61,
Using Mi'kmaq stories, Whitehead (1988) has recon- 66). Here the central figure is Simma'ju, who put the
structed the Mi'kmaq mental landscapes. There were animals on the iceberg, but Lonecloud emphasizes
six worlds — the Ghost World, the World Above the 'We were not in Noah's ark — we had our own ark
Sky, the World Above the Earth, the Earth World, the (Whitehead 1992,41).
World Beneath the Earth and the World Beneath the Lonecloud also discusses the world before the
Water. These worlds were, however, not dramatically flood. The first people in Nova Scotia were the small
different; they looked like the Earth World. 'Sun and people, the Wiklatnmijk, who lived on birds, clams
Earth and Moon are the ancestors of the people' and lobsters, for there were no animals until the
(Whitehead 1988, 8). But these are dynamic worlds in Mi'kmaq. Those Wiglahdmootch (or Wiklatnmijk) drew
which animate beings can transform themselves and pictographs and petroglyphs and lived in caves, but
change shape, in which special features of the land- perished in the flood. So too did the Kukwesk (giant
scape are both animate and powerful. Transformations cannibals) of the forest (Whitehead 1992,45).
can happen on peninsulas; trees and door post-holes
are avenues between worlds, but all is connected as Meaning
though in cyberspace and parts of things retain the Extrapolating from Jung's analysis of rebirth, the
essence of the whole. Navigation and survival in this flood myth could be seen psychologically as a

64
Archetypal Landscapes

'subjective end of the World' wherein 'conscious- such as Mi'kmaq (Goddard 1978, 70-77).
ness sinks back into the darkness from which it origi- Might growth, which turned to hypertrophy in
nally emerged' Qung 1968c, 147), at least among the glacial wasteland, be now manifested as an in-
peoples experiencing floods. Floods are uncontrolla- creasing sea-land polarity? This idea was proposed
ble, but they also bring rebirth as along the Nile as part of a dialectic model for the evolution of
River. To return to Cooper's encyclopedia of symbols, coastal/maritime cultures (Nash 1983, 22f.) There
Flood. The lunar power of the waters; the end of a are several sets of variables which follow from this
cycle and the beginning of a new; causes death but model and could be translated into testable middle-
also regeneration. (Cooper 1978, 70) range theory.
1. Maritime hunter-gatherers will tend to have
Flood myths are images of what Jung terms the ar- qualitatively distinct, binary economic systems
chetype of rebirth, a transformation process Qung exploiting sea and land resources.
1968c, 113f.). 2. In the long run, cultural evolution will involve
The rebirth is apparent in the Lonecloud Flood dialectical shifts in the exploitation of land and/
account in which, before the flood, there were small or sea resources. .
people who lived in caves and ate birds, clams and 3. The social, political and ideological organization
lobsters. As Jung notes in his discussion of rebirth of maritime cultures will be characterized by
symbols, "The cave is the place of rebirth, the secret greater dualism.
cavity in which one is shut up in order to be incu- 4. Dualism in infrastructural and structural organi-
bated and renewed.' (Jung 1968c, 135) These three zation in coastal cultures will increase over time,
food items provide a meagre diet even for small possibly in concert with coastal stablization.
people, but their significance is more likely to be While dualism and food taboos were quite explicit
seen in terms of a symbolic dimensional scaling. The among the historical Inuit and their Thule ancestors
bizarre-looking lobster is a sub-tidal, shallow water of the Arctic coasts (McGhee 1977), they are undocu-
resource that indeed appears as an unconscious crea- mented among the Mi'kmaq (Bock 1978). They may
ture rather than a legitimate animal. Clams are inter- be unrecognized, however, and present in less pro-
tidal resources symbolically at the juncture of the nounced form — more in the nature of polarities
conscious and unconscious worlds. They are femi- than dualities.
nine in nature and carry numerous symbolic mean- The Mi'kmaq settlement patterns of the six-
ings (cf. Eliade 1991, ch. 4). The birds are above the teenth and seventeenth centuries did have some-
water .(unconscious) and are symbols of transcend- thing of a binary character, since people shifted from
ence, messengers of the gods. 'A cage of birds repre- the coast to the interior for hunting during the two
sent the mind, according the Plato' (Cooper 1978, worst months of winter (Hoffman 1955). Moreover, I
21). The flood destroyed much of this, but was fol- would propose that shellfish and sacred 'grand-
lowed by the appearance of the Mi'kmaq and the mother' stones are symbolically linked to women,
'real' animals — a rebirth in a new, post-diluvial water and the coast, whereas land mammals and
more sapient world. cosmic trees are linked to men and the interior.
Over the millennia, as the dynamism of the sea Eliade, cited above, has fully documented the
slowed to move towards coastal stabilization and feminine nature of shellfish which are typically also
the land-sea relationship became predictable, with gathered by women at low tide. There are many
flooding restricted to rivers, the world views may shellheaps on the coast of the Maritimes (e.g. Smith
also have settled into sharper discrimination. A struc- & Wintemberg 1929), but they have an androgynous
turalist duality, of the form introduced in the character with a mixture of shells, bones of land and
Waterworld analysis above, could be one such set, i.e. sea mammals, and fish and bird bone together with
sea-land; unconscious-conscious; dark-light; homog- a well-preserved array of artefacts.
enous-differentiated. While such dualities are not The sacred stones are boulder anomalies or
overt in Mi'kmaq mythology, we can note that the erratics found in a few places on the coast or in a
little people are replaced by Big People (Mi'kmaq) lake or bay. They might resemble a woman in re-
and that the world view is discriminated into six pose; they are called 'grandmother' (Pacifique 1933)
worlds, separated by address more than by contents. and may also have a name linked to the sea. They are
The general differentiation and specialization of sys- animate beings.
tems occurs too in language as proto-Eastern Aside from its economic value, fishing may have
Algonkian (PEA) divides into separate languages afforded a connection to origins and a ready means

65
Ronald J. Nash

of ordering the self. Both women and men could hazardous journey owing to the monsters of the
participate in this critical and satisfying activity with abyss. Jason and the Argonauts undertook this voy-
any polarities perhaps residing in the technology, age, mythologically speaking, as did Jung himself at
i.e. women and wiers; men and harpoons or spears. a time of crisis when he experienced a 'Nekyia' or
Among the Mi'kmaq, land mammals such as moose 'night-sea journey' (Hyde & McGuiness 1992, 48).
were hunted by men and prepared by women The voyage is often symbolized by the rising life of
(Stewart 1986,135). the sun and its subsequent setting death and is ex-
Cosmic trees were used by shamans as ladders pressed in solar boats (Egypt) or the celestial canoe
to travel to worlds above and below the Earth World myths of the Americas. Levi-Strauss also draws at-
(Whitehead 1988, 6 & 7). Archetypally, they are the tention to the motif of 'the susceptible ferryman', a
Tree of Life. The Cosmic Tree, like the Maypole, has character in a middle position who crosses or bridges
phallic and masculine symbolism, although not ex- the water (Levi-Strauss 1978, 457). In the eastern
clusively so. Powerful women also utilized these Algonkian myths, the ferryman is not a person, but a
ladders to move above and below, but not unam- crane or a horned alligator (Levi-Strauss 1978, 445),
biguously — using the door post-hole (rather than i.e. a linear feature.
the post itself) to travel to the World Beneath the Thus the primordial seascape is not a single
Earth, or getting stuck in the few branches at the top archetype, but an image of the unconscious itself.
while descending to the Earth World (Whitehead The unconscious contains a collection of archetypes,
1988, 26, 173). The hole at the bottom represents a the most important of which, in the present context,
more feminine space as does the cluster of branches is that of rebirth, imaged as a flood motif. The sea, in
at the top — the latter being analogous to the feminine its shifting relationship to the land, has at the conscious
discus at the top of the maypole (Cooper 1978,104). level inherent tensions and dualities, which an arche-
While fishing itself is primarily a subsistence typal process, termed the transcendent function by
strategy, it amounts to trolling in the unconscious, Jung, attempts to bridge. Resolution of the tension
so that there are other not insignificant meanings to involves bringing the unconscious contents to the
fishing. At the risk of drowning in deep waters my- surface — which is what fishing does symbolically.
self, I would suggest that fishing symbolizes a voy- These meanings — sea=unconscious; flood=
age into the unconscious in search of origins, inner rebirth; fishing=archetypal process; land/sea tensions
divinity and the wholeness that is the archetype of the etc. — can reasonably be projected into ancient context
self. It also brings the contents (fishes/ideas) up into along uniformitarian lines. Waterworld is not just a twen-
conscious thought. Introspection is often thought to tieth-century story. The Lonecloud tale is not just an-
accompany the modern escape — 'gone fishin" (Fig. 1). other flood myth, but a Mi'kmaq understanding of
The process of individuation towards the goal rebirth. The dualistic or dialectical aspects do seem
of the self involves voyage into the unconscious, a capable of archaeological testing in coastal situations.

The forest labyrinth

CONSCIOUS With respect to the primordial seascape, it was ar-


Bird
gued above that as sea levels dropped and coasts
settled towards stabilization, dualism increased
The Transcendent Fisherman among coastal cultures. Four testable generalizations
0 were proposed with respect to the cognition and
k. /TRV ^A behaviour of maritime peoples, some aspects of
y^—^v which have been identified among the Inuit and
Shellfish ^ UNCONSQOUS
their Thule ancestors (McGhee 1977).
At approximately the same time, several thou-
Lobster
sand years ago, inland peoples living in forested envi-
ronments also evolved a more dualistic conception
of nature and culture, society and environment. In a
related paper (Nash 1996), the evolution of conscious-
ness and dualism and the consequences for the
Bronze Age forests of northwest Europe are dis-
Figure 1. The primordial sea archetype. cussed. The conclusions will not be repeated here,

66
Archetypal Landscapes

but some comments can be made concerning the recognized as such until more recent times. It would
nature and symbolism of the forest and their rel- seem, however, that one can go back beyond recorded
evance for Neolithic archaeology. history, using archetypal images and depth psychol-
For Jung and Jungian analysts of today, the ogy to approach collective meanings. The archetypes,
forest, like the sea, symbolizes the unconscious mind, as recurrent 'inherited pathways' (Progoff 1985, 70)
but more in a sense of the process of living than of connect the twentieth century with the distant past
origins. The forest has a closed, dark, labyrinthine and offer a new method for cognitive archaeology. It
character; it is a fearful place, like the unconscious, seems possible to reconstruct something of what peo-
yet it surrounds and assimilates and thus has a more ple perceived of various ancient landscapes via myth
feminine nature. Jungians and depth psychologists and the contemporary vernacular arts. Crook sug-
such as Newmann (1954), Whitmont (1982) and gests (1980, 275) that we ought to be writing a men-
Jaynes (1976) utilize mythology, ethnography and tal history, documenting the evolution of consciousness
child development studies to argue that there was as part of a psychological archaeology. The initia-
no conceptualized individuality (I-Thou) and only tives to date have all come from psychology.
embryonic ego development before the Late Bronze
Age. As the conscious mind and its ego centre emerge Notes
from the unconscious, and as polarity evolves to
duality, there is the danger of a schism between the 1. Strictly speaking, 'psychoanalytic' is a Freudian
conscious and unconscious parts of the psyche. term and Jung preferred to call his method ana-
It is in this context that we can re-examine the lytical psychology.
henges of the still-forested Neolithic landscape. This 2. I have retained Silas Rand's now dated use of
is increasingly recognized as a ritual landscape (Aston 'Indian' and 'King' in his tale, The Ice Man, both
1985, 150) with the henges having a sacred dimen- for accuracy and out of courtesy to Rand.
sion (Wainwright & Longworth 1971,231). There is a 3. Ruth Holmes Whitehead (pers. comm. May 1995)
deeper psychological dimension, however, and one disagrees with Rand's statement that the Chenoo
without any dichotomy between sacred and secular (or Jenuaq) are not ice giants, but humans who
for those who constructed the henge. have been transformed into cannibals of ordi-
In looking at an aerial photo of the Knowlton nary size, but with hearts of ice.
rings in Dorset for example (Barrett et al. 1991, jacket 4. A humanoid ice giant appears in Conquest of the
illustration), what comes to mind is a floating is- Pole, a very early film by Georges Melies (France
land — a circular motif that Jung would say symbol- 1912) — another appearance of the archetype.
izes the collective self (c/. Jung 1968b, 134). In the
interpretation offered here, the henge is not only an Acknowledgements
expression of collective self worship, but a pivot
unifying the conscious and unconscious, connecting Janet Gaynor, Ian Hodder, Eric Hutchison and Ruth
people and collective archetypes through a process Holmes Whitehead were kind enough to assist me in
Jung called the transcendent-function (Nash 1996, locating source material and/or commenting on ear-
15). The henge is a powerful archetypal image which lier drafts of this article for which they are, of course,
bridges and mediates the tensions accompanying an in no way accountable. The writing of the article was
emerging ego and reflects collective wholeness and greatly facilitated by the staff of the Department of
integration. Going further, we can speculate in the Archaeology at the University of Cambridge. It is
manner of psychoanalyst Jacques Lacan (1901-1981) dedicated to my son Alexander Dennis Nash.
that the henge is narcissistic, a self-image such as
provides identity in what Lacan termed the mirror
phase (Osborne 1993, 162). It seems clear that the
henge is not an object to be contemplated or 'used', but Ronald }. Nash
a centre within the surrounding (unconscious) forest Department of Sociology and Anthropology
landscape as the self is the centre of the psyche. St Francis Xavier University
P.O. Box 5000
Conclusion Antigonish
Nova Scotia
We cannot yet know what was in the minds of indi- Canada
viduals in prehistory — but then, individuals were not B2G 2W5

67
Ronald J. Nash

References Jung. London: Hodder & Stoughton.


Jaynes, J., 1976. The Origin of Consciousness in the Break-
Aston, M., 1985. Interpreting the Landscape: Landscape, Archae- down of the Bicameral Mind. New York (NY):
ology and Local History. London: B.T. Batsford Ltd. Hough ton Miffin.
Barrett, J., R. Bradley & M. Green, 1991. Landscape, Monu- Jung, C.G. (ed.), 1964. Man and His Symbols. New York
ments and Society: the Prehistory of Cranborne Chase. (NY): Dell.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Jung, C.G., 1968a. Symbols of transformation. The Col-
Bender, B. (ed.), 1993. Landscape: Politics and Perspectives. lected Works of C.G. Jung, vol. 5, pt 1. London:
Oxford: Berg. Routledge.
Bock, P., 1978. Micmac, in Trigger (ed.), 109-22. Jung, C.G. 1968b. Psychological types. The Collected Works
Bonnichsen, R., D. Keenlyside & K. Turnmire, 1991. of C.G. Jung, vol. 6. London: Routledge.
Paleoindian patterns in Maine and the Maritimes, in Jung, C.G., 1968c. The archetypes and the collective un-
Prehistoric Archaeology in Maritime Provinces: Past and conscious. The Collected Works of C.G. Jung, vol. 9, pt
Present Research, eds. M. Deal & S. Blair. (Reports in 1. 2nd edition. London: Routledge.
Archaeology 8.) Fredericton: The Council of Mari- Jung, C.G., 1968d. Aion. The Collected Works of C.G. Jung,
time Premiers, 1-36. vol. 9, pt 2. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Collins, M.A., 1995. Waterworld. London: Amour Books. Larsen, S. & R. Larsen, 1991. A Fire in the Mind: the Life of
Cooper, J.C., 1978. An Illustrated Encyclopaedia of Tradi- Joseph Campbell. New York (NY): Anchor Books,
tional Symbols. London: Thames & Hudson. Doubleday.
Cosgrove, D., 1993. Landscapes and myths, gods and hu- Levi-Strauss, C, 1978. The Origin of Table Manners. (Intro-
mans, in Bender (ed.), 281-305. duction to a Science of Mythology 3.) London:
Crook, J., 1980. The Evolution of Human Consciousness. Ox- Jonathan Cape.
ford: Clarendon Press. MacDonald, G.F., 1968. Debert: a Paleo-Indian site in Central
Dundes, A. (ed.), 1988. The Flood Myth. Berkeley (CA): Nova Scotia. (Anthropology Paper 16.) Ottawa: Na-
University of California Press. tional Museum of Canada.
Echo-Hawk, R.C., 1993. Exploring ancient worlds. Society McGhee, R., 1977. Ivory for the sea woman: the symbolic
for American Archaeology Bulletin 11(4), 5-6. attributes of a prehistoric technology. Canadian Jour-
Eliade, M., 1991. Images and Symbols: Studies in Religious nal of Archaeology 1,141-9.
Symbolism. Princeton (NJ): Mythos, Princeton Uni- Maritime Resource Management Service Inc. & Griffiths-
versity Press. Muecke Associates, 1984. Natural History of Nova
Fladmark, K., 1983. A comparison of sea-levels and pre- Scotia, vols. 1 & 2. Halifax: Department of Lands
historic cultural developments on the east and west and Forests and the Nova Scotia Museum.
coasts of Canada, in The Evolution of Maritime Cul- Moore, R. & D. Gillette, 1992. The Warrior Within: Access-
tures on the Northeast and Northwest Coasts of America, ing the Knight in the Male Psyche. New York (NY):
ed. Ronald J Nash. (Publications 11.) Burnaby, BC: William Morrow & Co. Inc..
Department of Archaeology, Simon Fraser Univer- Nash, J.M., A. Park & J. Willwerth, 1995. Glimpses of the
sity, 65-75. mind. Time 146(5), 36-44.
Goddard, I., 1978. Eastern Algonquian languages, in Trig- Nash, R.J., 1975. Archaeological Investigations in the Transi-
ger (ed.), 70-77. tional Forest Zone: Northern Manitoba, Southern
Hall, C. & G. Lindzey, 1957. Theories of Personality. New Keewatin, N.W.T.. Winnipeg: Manitoba Museum of
York (NY): John Wiley & Sons. Man and Nature.
Henderson, J.L., 1964. Ancient myths and modern man, in Nash, R.J., 1980. Research strategies, economic patterns
Jung (ed.), 97-156. and eastern Nova Scotia prehistory, in Proceedings of
Hill, J.N., 1994. Prehistoric cognition and the science of the 1980 Conference on the Future of Archaeology in the
archaeology, in Renfrew & Zubrow (eds.), 83-92. Maritimes, vol. 8, ed. D. Shimabuku. (Occasional Pa-
Hodder, I.R., 1992. Theory and Practice in Archaeology. Lon- pers in Anthropology.) Halifax: Saint Mary's Uni-
don: Routledge. versity, 23-41.
Hodder, I.R., M. Shanks, A. Alexandri, V. Buchli, J. Car- Nash, R.J., 1983. The progress and process of theory build-
man, J. Last & G. Lucas, 1995. Interpreting Archaeol- ing: the northeast and northwest coasts, in The Evo-
ogy: Finding Meaning in the Past. London: Routledge. lution of Maritime Cultures on the Northeast and the
Hoffman, B.G., 1955. Historical Ethnography of the Micmac Northwest Coasts of America, ed. R.J. Nash. (Publica-
of the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries. Unpub- tion 11.) Burnaby, BC: Department of Archaeology,
lished Ph.D. dissertation in Anthropology, University Simon Fraser University, 1-25.
of California, Berkeley. Nash, R.J., 1996. Forest Clearance and the Evolution of
Hyde, M. & M. McGuinness, 1992. Jung For Beginners. Consciousness. Unpublished manuscript.
Cambridge: Icon Books. Newmann, E., 1954. The Origins and History of Conscious-
Jaffe, A., 1964. Symbolism in the visual arts, in Jung (ed.), ness. London: Maresfield Library, Karmac.
pp 255-322. Olwig, K., 1993. Sexual cosmology: nation and landscape
Jaffe, A., 1970. The Myth of Meaning in the Work of C.G. at the conceptual Interstices of nature and culture;

68
Archetypal Landscapes

or What does landscape really mean?, in Bender Nova Scotia. (Anthropological Series 9, Bulletin 47.)
(ed.), 307-43. Ottawa: National Museum of Canada.
Osborne, R., 1993. Freud For Beginners. London: Writers Spence, L., 1994. North American Indians: Myths and Leg-
and Readers Publishing Inc.. ends. London: Senate. (Original publication 1914.)
Pacifique, Le Pere R.P., 1933. Le pays des Micmacs. Bulle- Stewart, F.L., 1989. Faunal Remains from the Delorey Island
tin de la Societe de Geographie de Quebec 27, 51-64. Site (BjCj-9) of Nova Scotia. (Curatorial Report No.
Progoff, I., 1985. Jung's Psychology and its Social Meaning. 57.) Halifax: Nova Scotia Museum.
New York (NY): Dialogue House Library. Tilley, C, 1994. A Phenomenology of Landscape Places, Paths
Radin, P., 1948. Hero Cycles of the Winnebago. Bloomington and Monuments. (Explorations in Anthropology.)
(IN): Indiana University Publications. Oxford & Providence (RI): Berg.
Railton, J.B., 1975. Post-glacial history of Nova Scotia. Pro- Trigger, B. (ed.), 1978. Handbook of North American Indians,
ceedings of the Nova Scotia Institute of Science 27, sup- vol. 15: Northeast. Washington (DC): Smithsonian
plement 3, 37-42. Institution.
Rand, S.T., 1894. Legends of the Micmacs. New York (NY): van der Leeuw, S.E., 1995. A historical perspective on
Longmans, Green & Co.. 'cultural' and 'natural', in Environmental Percep-
Renfrew, C. & E.B.W. Zubrow (eds.), 1994. The Ancient tion and Policy Making. First Report. Unpublished
Mind: Elements of Cognitive Archaeology. (New Direc- manuscript, University of Cambridge.
tions in Archaeology.) Cambridge: Cambridge Uni- Wainwright, G. & I. Longworth, 1971. Durrington Walls: Ex-
versity Press. cavations 1966-1968. London: Society of Antiquaries.
Scarre, C, 1994. The meaning of death: funerary beliefs Whitehead, R.H., 1988. Stories from the Six Worlds: Micmac
and the prehistorian, in Renfrew & Zubrow (eds.), Legends. Halifax: Nimbus Publishing Ltd.
75-82. Whitehead, R.H., 1991. The Old Man Told Us: Excerpts from
Schama, S., 1995. Landscape and Memory. London: Harper Micmac History, 1500-1950. Halifax: Nimbus Pub-
Collins. lishing Ltd.
Schiffer, M.B., 1976. Behavioral Archaeology. New York (NY): Whitehead, R.H., 1992. 'Going Down Into the Water Where
Academic Press. There are no Stars': Mi'kmaq Cosmology Research
Shanks, M., 1992. Experiencing the Past: on the Character of notes. Unpublished manuscript, Halifax, Nova Scotia.
Archaeology. London: Routledge. Whitmont, E., 1982. Return of the Goddess. New York (NY):
Smith, H.I. & W.J. Wintemberg, 1929. Some Shell-Heaps in Crossroad.

69

You might also like