Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Esteban-Febres Et Al. (2019)
Esteban-Febres Et Al. (2019)
Original
ABSTRACT
Objectives: The objective is to know the relationship between age, time of incarceration, juridical situation, activity in pri-
son, penitentiary classification and having or not children under eighteen years old, with the incidence of psychopathological
symptoms of female inmates from a penitentiary in Lima.
Materials and methods: The SCL-90-R was used to determinate the psychopathological symptoms in 388 female inmates.
Correlations and comparisons were made.
Results: Results show low negative correlation between age and depression, anxiety, hostility, psychoticism and PST; time
of incarceration has a low negative correlation with depression, paranoid ideation and GSI. Comparisons show significant
differences according juridical situation in interpersonal sensibility, depression, paranoid ideation, GSI and PSDI. According
activity in prison differences were found in somatization, depression, anxiety, psychoticism, PST and GSI; and, according
penitentiary classification differences were found in somatization, obsession compulsion, interpersonal sensibility, depression,
anxiety, paranoid ideation, psychoticism, PST, GSI and PSDI. There were not differences between inmates with or without
children under eighteen years old.
Discussion: No overcrowding, accessibility of treatment, and cultural differences are related to the low scores obtained. The
low correlations might be related to intermediate variables that were not observed and its recommended to observe in future
research.
Keywords: prisons, women, surveys and questionnaires, psychopathology, mental health, depression, classification, statistics,
nonparametric.
extent of high positive symptoms. Rivera-Ledesma et inmates who require minimal, medium and maximum
al.5 indicate that women generally tend to score more security and who have difficulties in readapting. When
highly on the SCL-90-R than men, while a similar the inmate enters the prison, she is classified once again
pattern is observed when other instruments for meas- by a Technical Classification Committee, where after
uring mental health are used6. considering a series of legal, social and psychological
In the case of female inmates of Peruvian prisons, variables, she is assigned to a regime that may be min-
ignorance about the characteristics of mental health is imum, medium or maximum security. As the Peruvian
greater, due to the fact that they make up only 5.9% prison systems is a progressive one, after a year and a
population of a total of 77,242 inmates, according to half and with positive treatment evaluations, the inmate
the statistics of the National Prisons Institute2. may progress to a lower level of security.
There are gender differences between men and The aim of this study is to determine the relation
women when they enter prison. Herrera et al.7 point between age, period of confinement, the legal situa-
out that women suffer more in prison because their tion of the female inmate, activities taking place in the
confinement directly affects the family nucleus, given prison, the stage of classification of the inmate and
that they are often the affective and economic founda- motherhood of small children, with the incidence of
tion of the family. Such a situation means that a female psychopathological symptoms amongst the female
inmate often experiences symptoms of depression and inmates of the Virgen de Fátima model prison.
anxiety. De Miguel8 comments that the mental health
of women in prisons is more negatively affected than
that of men, since more than half of female inmates METHODS
have reported symptoms of depression, stress and
claustrophobia, and that during their stay, three quar- This study took place in the Virgen de Fátima
ters of female inmates report symptoms of anxiety. model prison, which was opened in December 2008,
Some research work9 indicates that with regard to to house minimum and medium security female
psychopathology, 44% of women in prison meet the inmates. Its population of 371 inmates, and is char-
criteria of a clinical case, in which depression, soma- acterised by not being overpopulated and for being a
tisation, obsessive-compulsive disorder and paranoid prison with the status of school-workshop, where the
ideations predominate. prisoners spend time studying or working, and there
It can be seen therefore that gender inequality has are few inmates who spend time in these activities.
a negative influence on women’s mental health, since This may be due to the fact that there are inmates who
despite their greater participation in the labour mar- think that as they do not have a sentence, they will not
ket, they continue to have more responsibilities in be in prison for long14. Other causes are: withdrawal
terms of caring for and running the family than men10. of workshop activities for disciplinary offences, no
It can be observed that the psychological distress interest in participation or lack of vacant places in
amongst female inmates tends to be experienced with some workshops.
greater intensity when they enter prison and are sep-
arated from their family of origin. This situation can Participants
change as time passes in prison, as Iversen et al propose11,
So as not to affect the results, five female inmates
who found spending more time in prison is a predictor
of the inmates perceiving a good state of health. who presented a diagnosis of psychopathological
The relation between age and the presence of disorder given by the consultant psychiatrist were
psychopathological symptoms has not been covered excluded because of the very high scores they had.
in studies with inmates either. Some investigations Likewise, given that the study was a voluntary one, 28
indicate that young people tend to present a larger inmates refused to participate which left a final sample
number of psychopathological symptoms than older of 338 inmates.
people12, with the exception of older adults13. The participants were assessed in December 2015
The classification and allocation of inmates to a pri- by the psychologists responsible for the modules
son in Peru is regulated by regulations and directives that where they were located, who after explaining the
take into consideration the level of danger of the female purposes of the study and the fact that it was anony-
inmate and if she is pregnant or the mother of small chil- mous, asked for the informed consent of the partici-
dren. For this reason there are prisons that house female pating inmates.
— 12 —
18 Rev Esp Sanid Penit. 2019;21:11-17
Esteban-Febres S, Enoki-Miñano K, Escudero-Moreira T, La Cunza-Peña M, Quispe-Gutiérrez Y.
Factors related to psychopathological symptoms of female inmates of a prison in Lima.
— 13 —
Rev Esp Sanid Penit. 2019;21:11-17 19
Esteban-Febres S, Enoki-Miñano K, Escudero-Moreira T, La Cunza-Peña M, Quispe-Gutiérrez Y.
Factors related to psychopathological symptoms of female inmates of a prison in Lima.
Average rank
Does not work X2 gl Sig. asymp.
Education Work
or study
Age 162.425 170.025 204.449 6.056 2 0.048
Time of confinement in months 163.793 179.096 174.410 1.743 2 0.418
Somatisation 161.593 180.172 182.962 3.264 2 0.195
Obsessive 154.703 179.399 220.256 16.179 2 0.000
Interpersonal sensitivity 155.018 182.247 211.410 13.338 2 0.001
Depression 160.510 182.081 183.667 4.394 2 0.111
Anxiety 164.965 179.657 166.974 1.561 2 0.458
Hostility 166.883 167.439 188.154 1.636 2 0.441
Phobia 163.428 167.732 205.128 6.079 2 0.048
Paranoid 158.435 183.505 190.692 6.435 2 0.040
Psychoticism 158.460 179.657 200.333 7.507 2 0.023
PST 162.100 171.232 203.051 5.778 2 0.056
GSI
PSDI
Note. **Kruskal Wallis test.
GSI: Global Severity Index. PSDI: Positive Symptom Distress Index. PST: Positive Symptom Total.
— 14 —
20 Rev Esp Sanid Penit. 2019;21:11-17
Esteban-Febres S, Enoki-Miñano K, Escudero-Moreira T, La Cunza-Peña M, Quispe-Gutiérrez Y.
Factors related to psychopathological symptoms of female inmates of a prison in Lima.
rage ranks than sentenced inmates, with significant al.18 in 2002, with the exception of the hostility dimen-
differences being found using the Mann-Whitney U sion, where the scores for Spanish women are higher.
test on the scales of interpersonal sensitivity (Z=-2.22, The low scores in hostility for the inmates may be
p<0.026), depression (Z=-3.21, p<0.001), paranoid due to socio-cultural differences between both coun-
ideation (Z=-2.71, p<0.007), GSI (Z=-2.05, p<0.040), tries, especially in aspects of the family and gender
and PSDI (Z=-3.48, p<0.001). roles, where Peruvian society is more traditional19
Table 2 shows that the activities carried out by the
and women tend to adopt feminine attitudes that are
inmates determines statistically significant differences
incompatible with hostility.
in the scores for somatisation, depression, anxiety,
psychoticism, PST and GSI, and it was observed that The high average in the inmates’ somatisation
the lowest average ranks correspond to inmates in and phobic anxiety is repeated when compared with
education and the highest scores matched inmates that the non-clinical sample of Abuín et al.20 Apparently,
did not work or study. the psychosomatic symptoms (which may reflect an
The inmate’s classification also determined diffe- underlying medical pathology) and phobic symptoms
rences in the scores obtained on the scales of the (fear and avoiding activities) receive greater social
SCL-90-R. Table 3 shows that inmates classified for acceptance as a way of expressing distress inside
a medium security module show significantly higher prison and, above all, are functional in interactions
average scores than the ones classified for a minimum between inmates and prison staff.
security module in the scales of somatisation, obses- The correlation of age with symptomatic dimen-
sion-compulsion, interpersonal sensitivity, depres- sions showed that five dimensions (depression, anx-
sion, anxiety, paranoid ideation, psychoticism, PST,
iety, hostility, psychoticism and PST) had a weak
GSI and PSDI.
negative correlation with this variable. This indicates
No significant differences were found when
that the younger inmates present more symptoms in
inmates with under-age children were compared to
those who had none. these dimensions than the older inmates. These find-
ings match those of Casullo et al.12 However, con-
sidering that the relation found is a weak one, the
DISCUSSION presence of other unobserved variables related to age,
such as level of coping skills, may be intuited.
The results obtained with the SCL-90-R help The confinement time in months also showed a
to determine the mental health situation of female weak negative relation with the dimensions of depres-
inmates in a model prison in Lima, where variables sion, paranoid ideation and PSDI, indicating that the
such as overcrowding and lack of access to prison inmates with less time in prison usually experience
treatment (educational workshops, occupational more distress in such dimensions. Evidently, admis-
workshops, psychological, legal and social assistance) sion into a prison, as stated by Bustamante et al.3,
are controlled. We expected to obtain results similar is a traumatic event. Crying and distrust reduce in
to those obtained by Kendal17, who found a deteriora- intensity in line with the time spent by the inmate in
tion in the mental health of female inmates at a wom- prison, as she assimilates the experience and cohabita-
en’s prison in Lima, with a predominance of severe tion with other inmates, which have an influence on
depression; however, the averages extracted in this the reduction of psychopathological distress.
study are lower than the ones obtained in the prison The inmate’s legal situation is a factor related
population by Esteban et al.4, (with the exception of to the presence of psychopathological symptoms,
somatisation and phobic anxiety) and by Villagra et since significant differences were found between the
al.9 This result may be linked to characteristics such inmates that had a final sentence and those that were in
as sufficient space and access to prison treatment and custody (under process of investigation, with custody
their influence on the intensity of the psychopatho- or appeal order). Inmates in custody tend to obtain
logical symptoms. higher scores in the scales of the SCL-90-R, due to the
When comparisons are made of the medians fact that expectations are generated as to the outcome
obtained in this study and those of a normal popula- of the court proceeding, which products hyper-sensi-
tion, what is observed is that the inmates have higher tivity to external opinions, depression, mistrust, and
scores than those obtained by González de Rivera et is reflected in the significantly high scores obtained in
— 15 —
Rev Esp Sanid Penit. 2019;21:11-17 21
Esteban-Febres S, Enoki-Miñano K, Escudero-Moreira T, La Cunza-Peña M, Quispe-Gutiérrez Y.
Factors related to psychopathological symptoms of female inmates of a prison in Lima.
the scales of interpersonal sensitivity, depression, par- that most frequently take on the family roles, espe-
anoid ideation, GSI and PSDI. The type of expecta- cially women with children, as observed by Mignon23
tions regarding their sentence is a variable that should in mothers confined in maximum security prisons.
be studied in detail, given that negative expectations The results obtained do not confirm this hypothesis,
about the result of their trial may come into play. as no significant differences were found in the scores
Participation in activities such as educational and obtained by the inmates with under-age children and
occupational workshops is a factor that contributes those that did not. The influence of this variable may
towards inmates mental health. When the groups be attenuated by other variables, such as time of con-
of inmates who study or work were compared with finement of inmates and participation in educational
those who do not, it was seen that the latter groups and occupational workshops.
tend to obtain high scores in the SCL-90-R. However, Depression is the symptom that most often
when the Kruskal-Wallis test was used to analyse the appears on admission to a prison8, and it is the only
averages in the three groups, the only significant dif- variable that was seen to be present in all the corre-
ferences were found in the dimensions of somatisa- lations and comparisons made, which makes it nec-
tion, depression, anxiety, psychoticism, PST and GSI. essary to carry out more studies that consider the
It may be concluded that the inmates that study pres- incidence and evolution of depression in the female
ent fewer psychopathological symptoms than those prison population.
that work and those that do not participate in any of
the activities, probably because the inmates who study
CORRESPONDENCE
have a less demanding timetable than the ones who
work, which enables them to allocate more of their Silvia Evelyn Esteban Febres
time to leisure activities; while the working inmates Establecimiento Penitenciario Virgen de Fátima.
have to certify eight hours of work, productivity Lima (Perú)
make monthly payments for administrative items in E-mail: estebanfebres19@gmail.com
their workshops. According to Mapelli et al.21, more
female inmates get involved in occupational activities
than men, since they regard studying or working as REFERENCES
a therapeutic activity that helps to keep them occu-
1. Coordinadora Nacional de Derechos Humanos.
pied, forget about their problems and make time pass
Las cárceles en el Perú: manifiesta incompatibi-
quicker, which may explain the fact that the inmates
lidad con los principios constitucionales. [Inter-
who do not work or study obtain high scores in the net]. En: Informe anual 2014-2015. Perú; 2015.
SCL-90-R. p. 108-15. [citado 25 Abr 2016]. Disponible en:
The type of prison regime into which the inmate http://derechoshumanos.pe/informe2014_15/Sis-
is classified also determines differences between tema_Penitenciario_2014_15.pdf
inmates. It was found that minimum security inmates 2. Informe estadístico penitenciario 2016. [Internet].
present significantly lower scores than medium secu- Perú: Instituto Nacional Penitenciario; 2016. [ci-
rity prisoners in seven dimensions of the SCL-90-R: tado 10 May 2016]. Disponible en: https://www.
somatisation, obsession-compulsion, interpersonal inpe.gob.pe/informe-2016.html
sensitivity, depression, anxiety, paranoid ideation, 3. Bustamante R, Paredes-Carbonell JJ, Aviñó D,
psychoticism, and in all the global scores of the scale: González J, Pitarch C, Martínez L, et al. Partici-
PST, GSI and PSDI. These differences, in concord- patory design guide for mental health promotion
ance with the variables that have an influence on the in prisons. Rev Esp Sanid Penit. 2013;15:44-53.
imprisonment process defined by Quintero-Cárdenas 4. Esteban S, Reyes S, Charcape E. Diagnóstico de
et al.22, may be due to the fact that minimum secu- salud mental en internos de establecimientos pe-
rity inmates generally have more confinement time, nitenciarios de Lima. Lima: Instituto Nacional
are serving a sentence, participate in educational or Penitenciario; 2007.
occupational workshops, and are usually older than 5. Rivera-Ledesma A, Caballero N, Pérez I, Monte-
the medium security inmates. ro-López M. SCL-90 R: Psychological Distress,
Herrera et al.7 indicates that imprisonment has a Gender and Risky Behaviors. Univ Psychol. 2013
greater impact on women because they are the ones [citado 11 Abr 2017];12:105-118. Disponible en
— 16 —
22 Rev Esp Sanid Penit. 2019;21:11-17
Esteban-Febres S, Enoki-Miñano K, Escudero-Moreira T, La Cunza-Peña M, Quispe-Gutiérrez Y.
Factors related to psychopathological symptoms of female inmates of a prison in Lima.