Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DR - Ivy
DR - Ivy
A Term Paper
Presented to
Dr. Urooj S. Malik
Faculty of Graduate Studies
Mindanao State University – Main Campus
Marawi City
In Partial Fulfillment
Of the Requirements for the Course
PA 331 (Seminar on the Administration of Economic Development)
A.Y. 1st semester 2020-2021
NORHAYNAH S. CABILI
July 2020
INTRODUCTION
Islamic City of Marawi is the capital of the province of Lanao del Sur in the
Lanao del Sur’s population was 1, 045, 429 people, of which the Islamic City of Marawi
accounted for 201, 785 people. With 71.9% of the population below the poverty line,
Lanao del Sur is the poorest province in the country. The region’s economic performance
has been poor, with ARMM’s economic growth rate averaging 2.0% annually between
2011 and 2017 compared with the average annual growth rate of 6.2% for the national
economy. Extreme poverty combined with the lack of basic services and poor governance
has exacerbated long-standing conflicts in the region, including the Bangsamoro struggle
for self-determination led by the Moro Islamic Liberation Front and the Moro National
Liberation Front, and the ideological struggle of the Communist Party of the Philippines,
The Autonomous Region of Muslim Mindanao (ARMM), has the highest number
of people displaced by armed conflict, crime and violence in the Philippines. On 23 May
2017, Marawi was occupied by combined terrorist forces of the Maute group, the Abu
Sayyaf group, and foreign jihadists. The ensuing armed conflict between the responding
government security forces and the Maute group continued for five (5) months, with
heavy artillery used on both sides and air bombing by the government forces. On 17
October 2017, the government announced the end of the siege and declared the city
liberated from terrorist forces, although martial law remains in place in Mindanao. For
ten (10) months after the siege ended, intermittent clashes between armed groups and the
modernization works which will be leaded by the national and local government. The
Government of the Philippines led the provision of relief assistance with support also
coming from local, national and international humanitarian agencies. The Philippines
Humanitarian Country Team and its partners guided by the Government’s Task Force
and early recovery needs of vulnerable people severely affected by the conflict. While
most people have now returned home, upwards of 73, 000 may remain in temporary
settlements around Marawi City for some years, according to Government estimates.
displaced by the conflict, and their host communities, is the primary purpose of the
recovery and rehabilitation programme. In 2019, the Humanitarian Country Team will
prioritize assistance to those still displaced in transitional shelters and camps and to
support sustainable early recovery under the overall guidance and leadership of
Accordingly, the Islamic City of Marawi is the capital of the province of Lanao
del Sur, one of five provinces of the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM)
in the Philippines. With a population of around 201, 785 (PSA, 2015), it is the largest
services that attract many to find work and settle in the City.
Thus, this research paper attempted to discuss the problems encountered in the
Rehabilitation of Marawi City Ground Zero. Generally, this research paper was not only
Zero, but most significantly, to provide insights on the Status and Proposed Plans for the
Rehabilitation of Marawi City Ground Zero and Approaches used by the Government for
Since President Duterte declared Marawi liberated on October 17, 2017, the
government rhetoric has been that the people would be able to return to their homes. The
reality is that it is unlikely to happen in the near future, if it will happen at all. For
Marawi’s internally displaced persons (IDP), it has been a struggle complying with the
requirements, mostly in the form of documents, that government has asked of them in
exchange for relief and aid, for livelihood assistance, and for a chance to visit the land
where their homes or shops once stood. In an ordinary place, these requirements would
be standard procedure as a disaster response. But Marawi and the Meranaw who are the
majority here are different, their identities inseparable from a long history of resistance
For Task Force Bangon Malawi (TFBM), the agency on top of the Marawi
rehabilitation, this is all part of a plan for the country’s only Islamic city to start over and
finally enforce laws. “We would like to make things right,” TFBM chair Eduardo Del
Rosario said, referring to the reality that the Meranaw exist outside national laws, among
them land, water, tax and registration laws, as a consequence of which they lack
documents to prove ownership and sometimes even identity. Dr. Jowel Canuday, Ph.D.,
Anthropology and board member of Mindanews, talks to residents of Bito Buadi Itowa
into a modern urban center. Part of the rehabilitation program is making the IDPs
undergo profiling and biometric registration, and for the entire MAA to be surveyed and
tagged, the better to identify who owns what property. “Once they go back, they have the
right titles, and we have established the right ownership,” Del Rosario said. But residents
at the Sagonsongan shelter site just want to go home, even if home is now a mere
memory. Some of them were still seething at the long delays when they spoke to a
research team from the Ateneo de Manila University last March. Some 15, 000 MAA
residents have filed claims for damages totaling more than P90 billion in affidavits
submitted to the Lanao del Sur and Marawi Chapter of the Integrated Bar of the
Philippines. In March 2019, the IBP transmitted the documents to the House Sub-
bill. With the election of new members of Congress this year, a new Marawi Siege
MAA residents will have to wait for the legislative mill to roll.
“The land issue in Marawi is complex,” the assessment noted. “Existing laws
may not suffice (and in fact even serve to escalate issues) and extra-legal options and
solutions must consider the need to correct historical injustices brought about by land
dispossession during the colonial period.” When the American colonial government
ordered the titling of land, not all Muslims were fully informed of the legal significance
of the process, and so not all complied. As a result, Meranaw residents interviewed for
this report said, many of them have no proof of land ownership except for pieces of paper
Marawi’s total land area is around 8, 700 hectares, of which 6, 600 have been
classified military reservation since the early 1900s when the Americans built their first
camp in Lanao. Over the years, at least seven different land proclamations have covered
Marawi. A portion of the military reservation would later be reclassified and set aside to
build what would become the Mindanao State University campus. Muslim leaders
foresaw that land in Marawi would be a post-conflict issue. In September 2017, before
the liberation of Marawi, the late Ghazzali Jaafar, vice chairman of the Moro Islamic
Liberation Front, had appealed to President Duterte to correct the historical injustice by
giving back to the Meranaw the land the Americans took from them.
As important as the land question and the rebuilding of homes is the need for
social healing. The post-conflict needs assessment noted the trauma the Meranaw felt
from the destruction of Marawi, considered the heart and soul of the Lanao provinces,
and the spiritual and business center of Muslim Mindanao. Central to any post-conflict
action, the report said, would be the need to address and overcome “the pain, grief, hurt,
and anger over the destruction of Marawi City, the displacement of the population, the
loss of cherished properties, the prospects of land dispossession, the uncertainty of access
to basic needs, and of their future in general.” Even the Joint Task Force Marawi through
the Philippine Army made a similar assessment. “The Marawi crisis affected the
displaced civilians physically, psychologically, emotionally, and socially. The people of
Marawi City suffered a great loss – death and injury; damage to personal property,
cultural and religious structures; loss of livelihood and income; and a disruption of
business and education. They were also confronted by the appalling living conditions in
evacuation centers. We could not and should not have been indifferent to the plight of
these displaced persons,” wrote the Philippine Army in an article titled “Soft Power
Approach” published by the Joint Task Force Marawi in its website “Marawi and
Beyond.”
The task of psychosocial healing fell on the groups like the International
Committee of the Red Cross because government failed to allocate funds for this need in
its budget. “Social healing was not included because in the initial stage in the drafting
MOA we didn’t really know what we were facing,” Del Rosario said. TFBM ran into
problems with the Commission on Audit for allocating funds for social healing in the
form of trips to Mecca for select IDPs that were not part of the budget allocation. The
“Rebuilding will require not just physical reconstruction of destroyed infrastructure, but
The Asian Development Bank (ADB) worked closely with the Taskforce Bangon
Marawi (TFBM), the Office of Civil Defense, the National Economic and Development
Authority (NEDA), and development partners (DPs) to produce the post-conflict damage
and needs assessment (PCNA), which was completed in December 2017. An inter-
agency task force for the recovery, reconstruction and rehabilitation of Malawi City was
created otherwise known as Task Force Bangon Marawi (TFBM). After five months of
intensified fighting between Armed forces of the Philippines and Isis-Inspired Maute
Group, causing 78, 466 families 0r 359, 680 people were displaced, Malawi City has
been effectively liberated on October 17, 2017, signaling the start of the full-blown
reconstruction period. On October 27, 2017, recognizing the composition of Task Force
Marawi in order to reflect the government’s priority to rebuild and develop the settlement
The Task Force Bangon Marawi (TFBM) sends Post Conflict Needs Assessment
(PCNA) Teams composed of various national and local government agencies in twenty-
four (24) barangays in Marawi City, to conduct Damage and Losses Assessment (DALA)
between August to December 2017. After all the assessments made by PCNA, there is
also a need to evaluate the framework, plans, and programs created by Task Force
Bangon Marawi (TFBM) to expedite the reconstruction and rehabilitation of the City of
Marawi. The Task Force Bangon Marawi (TFBM) is to inform the public of the various
steps, necessary measures and development taken by the said inter-agency in the
recovery, reconstruction and rehabilitation process, with the end goal of providing an
environment conducive to the revival of business and livelihood activities, and restoration
this part of the city, comprising 24 Barangays. Displaced women, children, elderly and
secure and sustainable future. In the coming months,the Government plans to relocate the
occupants of the remaining evacuation centres to transitory sites in Marawi city with
limitedbasic services. While plans to rebuild road and bridge infrastructure, rehabilitate
institutions and economic infrastructure gains momentum, the provision of food, shelter,
health, water and sanitation, education and protection services to meet the immediate
needs of the displaced remains limited. The Department of Social Welfare and
Development estimates 230, 250 people have so far returned to the 72 Barangays in
Marawi City that were partially damaged by the conflict. This community also looks to
the restoration of their businesses and livelihoods to meet their basic needs, including
education and health requirements for their children. Rehabilitation of schools, water
vulnerable segment of the community –children under five, women, girls, and boys–
programmes is essential.
The Humanitarian Country Team works closely with the Government of the
Philippines at the national and Mindanao level to support the priority humanitarian needs
of people displaced and affected by the Marawi conflict. It is also coordinating with
early recovery efforts. As of October 2018, the food security and agriculture sector had
identified a 69 percent food gap impacting the displaced people. Only 6 of the 15
Barangay health stations are functional and lack visiting doctors. Reproductive health and
addressing gender based violence and management remains a challenge. Inadequate clean
water supply and sanitation particularly the desludging of latrines and hygiene promotion
need to be maintained for the displaced people and returnees. Both transitional shelter
and relocation sites require to be maintained, particularly those that are tented. A
protection assessment in August 2018, found that about 18, 000 displaced people do not
Cards. Displaced people are also not receiving adequate information on their status or
when they can return home. Regular and meaningful consultation with displaced
With more than 73, 000 people remaining displaced and unlikely to return home
soon, the Humanitarian Country Team (HCT) will continue to address the priority
residual humanitarian needs of a targeted population of those who remain the most
displacement and their host communities through 2019. It will strengthen coordination
access to information and services. This approach will facilitate the sustainability of the
programmes, once integrated with counterpart institutions. The HCT will enable
partnerships with government, private sector and other stakeholders to support early
recovery and peacebuilding among the targeted group. Sustainable recovery, protection,
gender and adoption of culturally sensitive approaches will be cross-cutting themes for all
clusters. To better facilitate the response, the clusters of the Mindanao humanitarian team
will be further aligned with the sector coordination structure under the Government’s
Task Force Bangon Marawi, which are: food security, agriculture and livelihoods;
protection, including gender- based violence and child protection; shelter and camp
coordination and management; and health including: reproductive health, mental health
and psycho-social services; water, sanitation and hygiene (WaSH); and nutrition.
Barangays most affected by the conflict will not be completed until 2021 brings to the
fore the imperative for a longer- term and more strategic approach to assisting those who
remainin a state of dislocation and displacement. Given the resource and capacity
limitations of humanitarian actors, strong partnership and continued joint planning with
Government agencies will help enable sustainability of the planned interventions and
ensure resource complementation, rather than substitution. With more actors joining the
rehabilitation space in Marawi, UN and NGO partners on the ground are encouraged to
explore linking seamlessly the humanitarian response to the overall recovery, and
peacebuilding efforts of different stakeholders, with the end view that such efforts will
lead to sustainable solutions, encourage social cohesion and build more resilient
communities.
While some 230, 000 people have already returned in Marawi City, more than 73,
000 remain displaced. With the proposed closure of the remaining 21 evacuation centers,
displaced people in these locations will again face uncertainties and the challenges of
resettling in new proposed locations. The registration and profiling of displaced people
has commenced but until its completion, the tracking of their needs and identification of
gaps in assistance remains a challenge. Protection issues on exclusion have been raised,
potentially emanating or associated with registration, which will have a bearing on access
to humanitarian support and basic services. Access to right, timely and relevant
information, and effectiveness of grievance and feedback mechanisms has also been
concern. The food gap remains high at 69 percent as of September 2018, and the safe and
reliable supply of water remains insufficient in evacuation centers and transitory sites.
Vulnerability runs high in Lanao del Sur, being the poorest provincein the country.
Displaced people and host communities alike are challenged to adapt to the demands
brought forth by the economic and social disruption arising from the conflict.
to water, loss of property and livelihoods. Even before the conflict, 5 out 10 children in
Lanao del Sur were categorized as malnourished. Continued support for displaced people
and dislocated communities throughout Lanao del Sur is therefore essential. But the
situation inside Marawi City needs priority and continuous support, both to meet basic
humanitarian needs and address protection concerns. Raising awareness of the dangers of
unexploded ordnance needs to continue, particularly for people planning to return to the
‘most affected areas”. Gaps in needed assistance continue to be reported in key sectors of
protection, food security, agriculture and livelihood, WASH, health, nutrition and
education. Additional financial and material resources are needed in these sectors to
ensure that people who remain displaced do not become critically vulnerable. For 2019,
assistance to people who remain displaced, host families and for the returnee
communities needing food security and agriculture, shelter, WaSH, health, education,
protection and early recovery and livelihood support.
immediate and flexible financing to implement programs, projects, and activities (PPA)
Marawi and its vicinity by rebuilding better public infrastructure, (iii) restoring water
utilities and health infrastructure, and (iv) improving social services for and livelihoods
Marawi City's most devastated area was finally held, after 4 months of delay. The
groundbreaking takes place more than a year after President Rodrigo Duterte declared the
liberation of the city from terrorists on October 17, 2017. The ceremony means they can
now expect construction work inside the Most Affected Area (MAA), the 250-hectare
part of Marawi that sustained the most damage during the 5-month siege by terrorists.
“This will mark the start of the rapid development inside the Most Affected Area. The
The rehabilitation will be done in phases. TFBM has divided the areas for
Incorporated (FIRI) was tapped by the government to do the first phase of debris clearing
in “sector 1.” Their contract for this job is worth P75 million, Del Rosario earlier told
media. The task force wants complete debris management and the construction of some
facilities before allowing the return of people to houses inside the MAA. The
groundbreaking means the government can now begin work on the first 5 components of
the 22 - component rehabilitation plan. The first 5 components are: Debris management;
The armed conflict in Marawi and other parts of Lanao del Sur caused substantial
damage and loss to public and private assets and disrupted businesses and other sources
of employment. As of July 2018, an estimated 73% of the families displaced during the
barangays affected by the hostilities, which the government have cleared and declared
accessible. While displaced, most returned families have depleted their resources and are
struggling to restore their essential livelihood. The entire area, once flourishing trade
region, has lost its previous dynamism. While the local economy is still moving the first
displacement and return dynamics. Through the intervention of the Government and other
agencies, local markets have already started to operate, and commerce has already
emerged in the area. However, there is still a need to accelerate and support the socio-
economic activities. Substantial assistance is needed for the IDPs to have a ready access
to appropriate financial resources to start, improve or recover their businesses and
livelihood activities.
With the aim of complementing the ongoing efforts towards the sustainable
rehabilitation of Marawi City, there is a need to further strengthen the resilience of the
characterize communities in the affected areas, all project activities will be prioritized,
owned and driven by the communities themselves, through inclusive and participatory
decision-making mechanisms. The need to support for micro, small and medium
enterprise for women and men IDPs, as well as to contribute to the creation of alternative
economic opportunities that give people a stake in the local economy, through an
innovative method. Build a sustainable financial system that offers immediate assistance
and most importantly develop the capacity of the IDPs to manage their personal and
properly and needs to further considered M’ranaws culture in the general rehabilitation.
Of the said city. Consequently, there are some ideas that were modified from the research
the rebuilding works in the central district, such works should be non-disruptive or they
road construction and widening, improvement of water system, power, drainage and
sewerage system, garbage management, and zoning policies and standards, and other
(including the central district containing the main battle area) have the graves of the
parents or clan leaders of affected owners. Similarly, the high level of religiosity of the
M’ranaws that entails easy access of family members to mosques, madaris and torils must
be preserved. It should be noted that practically all mosques in Marawi City hold the
mandatory five daily prayers (in jamma or group prayer). Revive community life in
Marawi City, basic local services and community facilities must be restored. Hence,
partially damaged buildings and infrastructures like public markets, mosques, schools,
madaris, torils (live-in Islamic learning centers), health centers, offices, police stations,
sports facilities, multipurpose halls, etc. should be repaired, renovated and reconstructed.
Damaged buildings and facilities must be replaced with new ones either as transition
structures or permanent ones. Provide appropriate amounts of house repair and rebuilding
were partially or wholly damaged during the war. The amount is intended to help the
owners to start with the repair or reconstruction works as early as possible. The owners
should be the ones to undertake the said repair and reconstruction works, subject to
zoning policies and guidelines, engineering standards and other government regulations.
This suggestion will help much in hastening the repair and reconstruction works and the
generating additional funds for the required rehabilitation works involving common-use
program, and adopt a toril program. For example, with the help of DFA (Department of
sponsors/financers for the reconstruction of new big mosques, madrasah schools, or torils
to replace the destroyed ones. Similarly, Christian philanthropists or big businessmen can
be potential funders of new school buildings, hospitals, or health centers. This approach
of buildings or infrastructure. The idea of creating a new Marawi City (i.e., a physically
development of the Bangsamoro and other disadvantaged regions in the country. Big
ticket modernization projects which are crucial to the long-term growth and development
of Marawi City and Lanao del Sur must be prioritized also in the post-siege rehabilitation
plan for Marawi City. This means that the proposed master plan for building a new and
better Marawi has two program clusters. The first cluster embraces the economic
rehabilitation of the affected residents and the rebuilding and reconstruction of the old
Marawi. The second cluster includes program components and development initiatives to
build a modern Marawi. The new Marawi dimensions of the plan shall consist of modern
enclaves which can be located in the existing shorelines of Marawi City (to be proposed
for reclamation) from Barangay Calocan to the old public market, Raya Madaya,
Pumping, Bangon, Bacolod Chico up to Poona Marantao. The other appropriate
expansion areas for the said modern enclaves may be the upper parts of Basak Malutlut
(between the Provincial Capitol and MSU Dairy Farm), and the area near the boundary
Thus, to summing up, based on the whole analysis emerging from the said
pointers, the involvement of the private sector and NGOs in local development work or
Debureaucratization is recognized that the government, on its own, because of its limited
resources and capacities, is unable to perform the gigantic and demanding task of local
development. Hence, the private sector and NGOs are encouraged to do their part and,
where necessary, serve as alternative mechanisms for the delivery of basic services.
explain why the Rehabilitation of Marawi City Ground because Debureaucratization was
perceived to be unpracticed in the case of Marawi City Rehabilitation since some of the
proposed plans and approaches used by the government were contradictory to each other.
To identify an accurate and relevant problem that in need of an urgent solution in the case
of Marawi City, the Government must practice and be engaged in the term
Debureaucratization in order to avert the conflicting of ideas and proposed plans by the
https://www.mindanews.com/mindaviews/2017/11/our-marawi-building-a-better-and
stronger-marawi-city-from-the-ashes-of-war1-2/
https://news.mb.com.ph/2017/11/23/building-a-better-and-stronger-marawi-city-from-
the-ashes-of-war-2/