Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mini Project Report
Mini Project Report
Introduction
Energy conservation requires for reduction in consumption of primary resources,
environment protection and materials and manufacturing input savings. Methods of
improving the thermal and hydrodynamic performance of heat exchange devices are referred
to as heat transfer enhancement, and sometimes as augmentation or intensification (AE, 1998;
RM & AE, 2003). Heat transfer enhancement is one of the main research area in thermal
engineering domain, in which different methods to enhance the heat transfer are studied,
tested, and analyzed. Heat transfer enhancement is one of the challenging task in various
industries containing solar systems, electronic equipment, heat exchangers, and so on. Due to
the development of modern technology, the heat exchangers required in various industries for
high heat-flux cooling to the level of megawatt per meter square. At this level, cooling with
conventional fluids such as water and ethylene glycol are challenging because of their poor
thermal conductivity. Hence, it is necessary to increase the heat transfer performance of
working fluids in the heat transfer devices.
In the heat transfer process, heat exchanger plays an important role. Various heat
transfer enhancement techniques are developed to improve the thermal performance of heat
exchanger systems.
Heat transfer enhancement techniques are classified into three categories: Active
methods, Passive methods, and Compound methods. These techniques are used in various
areas such as thermal power plants, automobiles, refrigerators, heating and cooling in
evaporators etc. Heat transfer techniques can be as simple as change of the fluid velocity
inside the unit or as complex as the design of new surface geometries or the design of inserts
in the case of tubular geometry (Picon-Nunez, Melo-Gonzalez, & Garcia-Castillo, 2018).
Heat transfer enhancement is one of the fastest growing areas in heat transfer. These
heat transfer enhancement techniques include – 1. Active methods – mechanical aids, fluid
vibration, jet impingement, 2. Passive methods – extended surfaces, treated surfaces,
additives for fluids, swirl-flow devices, etc. and 3. Compound methods – rough-surface tube
with a twisted tape insert etc.
The active method involves addition of nanosized, high thermal conductivity, and
metallic powder to the base fluid, to increase the heat transfer rate. Active methods require
external power for instance like fluid vibrations etc. (Picon-Nunez, Melo-Gonzalez, &
For the enhancement of heat transfer, active methods use external power while,
passive methods does not use any of the external power. The passive methods are mostly
preferred as there are simple and can be applied easily in various applications. Heat transfer
enhancement can also be termed as heat transfer augmentation or intensification. Heat
transfer enhancement techniques lead to increase in heat transfer coefficient but at the
expense of increase in pressure drop. So, while designing a heat exchanger using any of these
techniques, analysis of heat transfer rate & pressure drop has to be done (Dhumal, Kerkal, &
Pawale, 2017). Enhancing the performance of a heat transfer device is therefore of great
interest since it can result in energy, material and cost saving.
Heat exchanger is used to transfer heat between two fluids which are at different
temperatures. They are used in many engineering applications such as air-conditioning
systems, refrigeration systems, automobiles, power plants, food processing systems etc. Few
examples of heat exchangers are shell and tube heat exchangers, double pipe heat exchangers,
plate heat exchangers, economizers, evaporators, condensers, and cooling tower in thermal
plants.
In last few decades, the demand for efficient heat transfer in heat exchangers has increased.
Every heat exchanger works in steady state. Irrespective of the design all the heat exchangers
works under the basic fundamental laws – namely the Zeroth, First, and Second laws of
thermodynamics-which describe the transference of heat from one fluid to another fluid. The
most common materials used to construct the heat exchangers are tubes, coils, shells, fins,
plates.
The common metals used for constructing heat exchangers are titanium, copper due to their
high thermal conductivity. Depending on the required application other materials such as
graphite, ceramics, plastics or composites are also used in the construction of heat
exchangers. There are two types of heat transfer mechanisms employed by heat exchangers—
single-phase or two-phase heat transfer (Ronquillo). The required amount of thermal energy
needed for either heating or cooling is provided by the heat exchanger. To select a particular
type of heat exchanger, the rate of heat transfer is taken into consideration.
2. Literature survey
(Ray & Jhinge, 2014) concludes that, wire coiled tube will be having higher pressure drop
when compared to an empty tube. The pressure drop depends on the geometry of the wire and
is always act a significant. Wire coil inserts will do better in turbulent and transition region
flow. Within the transition region, if wire coils are fitted in a smooth tube warmth exchanger,
heat transfer rate is often increased up to 200% keeping pumping power constant. In laminar
flow wire coil insert is not so effective and results shows that wire coils act like as a smooth
tube but accelerate transition to critical Reynolds numbers down to 700. In turbulent flow,
Wire coil leads a high drop increase which depends majorly on pitch to wire diameter ratio.
In the selection of the wire coil inserts, the form of the insert is important. Wire coil provides
better overall performance when the pressure drop penalty is considered.
(Thianpong, Eiamsa-ard, Promvonge, & Eiamsa-ard, 2011) has gone through experimental
investigation on heat transfer and pressure drop nature of turbulent flow in a heating tube
consists of perforated twisted tapes with parallel wings for Reynolds number range in
between 5500 to 20500. he did the design of perforated twisted tape with the following -
The wings consists an extra turbulence near tube wall which leads to disrupt the
thermal boundary layer efficiently.
The pre-existing holes along a core tube decreases the pressure losses in the tube. The
different parameters investigated by him i.e. the hole diameter ratio and wing depth
ratio and also typical twisted tape was also been tested for the assessment. he
compared the results with the plain tube, the result says that the tubes having
perforated twisted tape heat transfer rate increases to 208 % and also with the twisted
tape the heat transfer icreases up to 190%. they check the overall performance during
experimentation under the similar pumping power with that of perforated twisted tape
with ratio of d/W and w/W which are equal to 0.11and 0.33 respectively, provides the
maximum thermal performance factor of 1.32, in the Reynolds number range of 5500.
(Matani & Dahake, 2013) says that, thermal nature in a tube fitted with twisted-tapes in co-
swirl arrangement with wire coil are shown in the present study. Results says that wire coil of
pitch ratio 0.88 is more higher to all twisted tapes. In twisted tape twin twisted tape acts as
counter swirl generator, which shows better performance than single twisted tape alone. The
work was conducted in the turbulent flow regime, Reynolds number from 5000 to 18,000
with air as the test fluid.
1. For the inserted tube, the pressure drop will increase with the rise in mass flow rate where
as the friction factor and performance factor has the opposite trends.
2. The compound enhancement system of the tube and the counter/co-swirl shows a slight
increase of heat transfer rate and thermal performance when compared to the smooth tube
acting alone, depending on twist ratios.
(Richard.T.L & Agilan.H, 2015) says that the experimental analysis in the work the enhancement
of heat transfer of fin for various materials is made and it can be increased. Fin efficiencies of
materials are 68%, 94%, 91% are achieved. And among all these materials from the analysis
says that copper has more thermal conductivity than aluminium and brass.
Various methods or techniques used for enhancing the heat transfer are – active methods,
passive methods, compound methods. Depending on the requirement of heat transfer rate we
use the suitable method. The method which leads to high heat transfer enhancement will be
accepted. Enhancement methods are primarily employed in a heat exchanger to reduce the
thermal resistance by producing higher heat transfer coefficients with or without surface area
increases; the latter is effected by fins or extended surfaces (Manglik, 2018).
These existing methods are broadly classified into two categories. In one category of
methods, the second law of thermodynamics is used and in another category of methods, the
first law of thermodynamics is used. The factors like safety, reliability, and ease of
manufacturing are taken into consideration while evaluating the method. In the present
situation, the need of energy-saving of heat transfer enhancement has acquired more
attention.
The majority of commercially interesting techniques are mainly limited to passive techniques.
However, active techniques such as electro hydrodynamic (EHD) enhancement of boiling and
condensation indicate significant potential (Akira & Hiroshi, 1988). Active methods have
attracted little financially interest because of the costs involved. Active methods need extra
effort towards the development and design of an efficient heat exchanger.
These methods have great potential can control thermally. In scientific fields the use of
active methods is limited because, providing external power input in most of the applications
is not easy. Though active methods have acquired massive attention in research, their
applications have been limited. Let us go through various active methods that are responsible
for enhancing the heat transfer.
Electro hydrodynamic heat transfer enhancement uses interaction of electric field with
magnetic field in a dielectric fluid medium. This interaction, under certain conditions, results
in electrically induced fluid motion and/or interfacial instabilities, which are caused by an
electric body force (Saha, Tiwari, Sundén, & Wu, 2016). A high voltage and current is
applied to the fluid in this method. One of the major aims of this method is to convert
electrical energy into kinetic energy. The electric forces that are responsible for the
displacement of fluid are obtained by:
(1)
Where ,E the electric field strength( v/m), Fe is the electro hydrodynamic force ( N/m2 ), qc
is free electric charge density( C/m3 ), the fluid permittivity( F/m), q the fluid density(
kg/m3 ), and T the temperature in (K) (Jadhav, Awari, Bibe, Bramhane, & Mokashi, 2016).
The three terms in Eq. (1) stand for the electrophoretic, dielectrophoretic, and electrostrictive
components of the electric force (Saha, Tiwari, Sundén, & Wu, 2016).
This force can cause interfacial instabilities that force the liquid with higher permittivity to
move to the regions of higher electric field. This phenomenon is usually called as liquid
extraction phenomenon and is believed to be the primary mechanism responsible for flow
regime transitions which cause heat transfer enhancement (Saha, Tiwari, Sundén, & Wu,
2016). The first term of the equation, electrophoretic force, is the coulomb force. This force
occurs due to presence of net charge in the dielectric fluid medium. In single phase, the heat
transfer enhancement is mainly due to this force. The second term of the equation,
A wide range of applications for EHD method are reported in the literature consisting of:
pumping (Seyed-Yagoobi, 2005), single phase heat transfer (Alamgholilou & Esmaeilzadeh,
2012; Laohalertdecha, Naphon, & Wongwises, 2007), boiling (Cotton, Robinson, Shoukri, &
Chang, 2012; Liu, Li, Wang, & Yu, 2005), condensation (Laohalertdecha & Wongwises,
2006; Sadek, Ching, & Cotton, Characterization of Heat Transfer Modes of Tube Side
Convective Condensation under the Influence of an Applied DC Voltage, 2010), mixing
(Jalaal, Khorshidi, & Esmaeilzadeh, 2013). There are many studies regarding electro
hydrodynamic heat transfer enhancement. Grassi et al. studied heat transfer enhancement in
an annulus flow due to ion injection from sharp electrodes, experimentally (Grassi, Testi, &
Saputelli, Heat Transfer Enhancement in a Vertical Annulus by Electrophoretic Forces
Acting on a Dielectric Liquid, 2005) . N. Kasayapananad and T. Kiatsiriroat studied heat
transfer enhancement in a partially open square cavity with different wire electrode
arrangements (Kasayapanand & Kiatsiriroat, 2009).R. Baghaei Lakeh and M. Molki used a
corona jet to locally enhance natural convection heat transfer in a pipe (Lakeh & Molki,
2012). Sahebi and Alemrajabi studied EHD enhanced natural convection heat transfer of an
inclined heated plate with corona jet, experimentally (Sahebi & Alemrajabi, 2014). These
works proved that heat transfer can be enhanced significantly by EHD method.
The above mentioned papers considered ion-drag pumping, which is an EHD method. This
ion-drag pumping utilizes a wire-plate or needle-plate to generate the corona wind. Ion-drag
pumping deals with injection of ions from a sharp metal electrode into the fluid. This
injection of ions results in the degradation of the working fluid and electrode. A modern
concept, EHD conduction pumping is developed in contrary to the ion-drag pumping method.
It is associated with the nonequilibrium process of dissociation of neutral species and
recombination of generated ions in a finite thickness in the vicinity of electrodes which is
known as hetrocharge layer (Mirzaei & Saffar-Avval, 2018). This EHD conduction pumping
mechanism consumes lower power. Comparatively EHD conduction pumping mechanism is
better than ion-drag pumping mechanism.
Atten and Seyed-Yagoobi presented the first theoretical model of EHD conduction pumping
(Atten & Seyed-Yagoobi, 2003). This model was further developed in other researches. A
number of experimental studies in different electrode configurations are implemented by
different researchers on conduction pumping and the theoretical model is validated against
their results (Pearson & Seyed-Yagoobi, 2009; Siddiqui & Seyed-Yagoobi, 2009; Feng &
Seyed-Yagoobi, 2006). Publications related to EHD conduction pumping are very limited.
(Sadek, Robinson, Cotton, Ching, & Shoukri, 2006) have studied in-tube condensation of R134a
in a horizontal, single-pass, counter-current heat exchanger with a rod electrode placed in the
centre of the tube. In their study they have observed how the various characteristics like
overall heat transfer coefficient, enhancement ratio, over all pressure drop, pressure drop ratio
varies by varying applied voltage.
3.1.2. Jets
Jets are one of the most widely used phenomena because they exhibit free or wall-bounded
shear turbulent flows and large vortex structures which are essential in fluid dynamics and
engineering. Jets are used for various industrial applications such as cleaning, heating,
cutting, cooling, and jet and rocket propulsion. Many studies have been done on jets
phenomena because this method helps in enhancement of the heat transfer. Few literature
surveys on impingement heat transfer of jets are presented by (Viskanta, 1993; Oosthuizen &
Bassey, 1973). (Martin, 1977) examined heat and mass transfer for single round nozzle,
arrays of round and slot nozzles and provided extended reviews of heat transfer data .
A fluid flowing at high speed (jet) breaks the boundary layer and it get mixes near the surface
when projected towards a surface. This causes an increase in convective heat transfer
coefficient. Due to their high efficiency and ability to enhance the heat transfer, impinging
jets are used in variety of heating and cooling process. An effective cooling method for high
temperature surfaces is to use liquid jets impingement on the heated surface (Cardenas &
Narayanan, 2012). A bubble will nucleate on the surface, when liquid jets approach the
superheated surface. Turbulent mixing occurs in the vicinity of the wall. This occurs due to
alternately growing and collapsing of bubbles. The high degree of subcooling of the
surrounding liquid and the impinging flow prevent the bubbles from detaching from the wall,
due to which the entire boiling and condensation process limits to a boundary layer
phenomenon. A single bubble, while growing it is presumed that it will replace a hot fluid
volume near the wall which is consequently shifted into colder regions of the flow.
Momentum and heat exchange of such a deplaced fluid volume with the main flow will result
in a temperature drop in the fluid layer surrounding the bubble, leading to its collapse
immediately after it has reached its maximum radius (Saha, Tiwari, Sundén, & Wu, 2016).
Cold fluid will then be transported back to the heating wall and the process repeats. This
process is clearly shown in Fig. 3. (Timm, Weinzierl, & Leipertz, 2003)
This single steady impingement jet uses only a single jet. It is the simplest method compared
to others. In the following figure we can observe how single jet works for heat transfer.
The flow and heat transfer characteristics of a jet impinging on a surface orthogonal to the
main flow axis are shown in fig. 4. (Léal, et al., 2013). These different zones in the fig. 3. are
explained in (Oyakawa, Umeda, Islam, Saji, & Matsuda, 2009; Jambunathan, Lai, Moss, &
Button, 1992; Weigand & Spring, 2011):
(1) The zone 1 is known as flow development region. This region is made up of free jet
region and core region (Léal, et al., 2013). In the core region the velocity is
approximately equal to the nozzle exit bulk velocity. As the distance from the nozzle
increases, the free jet region gets widen.
(2) The zone 2 is known as fully developed region. It is present at the end of the core. As
the distance from the nozzle increases, the axial jet velocity gets reduced.
(3) The zone 3 is known as deflection region. It is present near the wall. This can be seen
as an increase in static pressure and a sharp decrease in the axial velocity. At the
centre of the deflection region, stagnation point is situated. To plot the Nusselt
number versus the distance from the stagnation point, (Jambunathan, Lai, Moss, &
Button, 1992) used the data from (Gardon & Carbonpue, 1962). When the distance
between the jet nozzle and the impingement plate is very less (H/D < 6), the flow
becomes a laminar flow near the stagnation point inducing a local minimum heat
transfer at the stagnation point. Maximum heat transfer is obtained at the stagnation
point when the impingement plate is situated at the end of the core region (H/D = 6).
When the distance between the jet nozzle and impingement plate increases (H /D > 6),
jet velocity decreases due to which heat transfer reduces at the stagnation point.
Hence heat transfer reduces as the distance from the centre increases.
Hence heat transfer coefficient depends upon various factors such as nozzle-to-plate distance,
nozzle geometry, jet Reynolds number, velocity profiles, turbulence intensity.
The major conclusion that can be drawn from study of single jet impingement is, heat transfer
maximum at the impact zone, but gradually reduces away from it. To overcome this problem,
multiple jets are used which are described below.
The heat transfer of multiple jet is same as that of single jet, when there is no interaction
between the jets. Heat transfer varies, when there is interaction between jets. This variation is
due to two factors – jet-to-jet interaction prior to impingement and head-on collision of
surface flow after impingement. Jet-to-jet interaction occurs due to the expansion of shear
layer. It occurs when the distance between the jets is small and high separation between jet
nozzle and impingement plate. Due to this type of interaction, strength of the jet get weak due
to which overall heat transfer on the impingement plate gets reduced when compared to the
case with no interaction between two jets prior to their impingement (Léal, et al., 2013). The
second factor, head-on collision of surface flow after impingement, also known as secondary
stagnation zone. This interaction causes fountain flow.
The heat transfer coefficient is high near the impingement zone. Hence, heat transfer
coefficient increases as the number of impingement zones increases.
Due to flow instability and higher turbulence, thermal and hydrodynamic boundary layers get
disturbed, due to which heat transfer gets enhanced. Many studies have been done on
unsteady jet to evaluate the performance of heat transfer. (Xu, Yu, Qiu, Poh, & Mujumdar,
2010) recorded significant heat transfer enhancement due to intermittent fluctuation in a
turbulent impinging jet. They also observed that jet-to-plate distance and on-to-off jet time
ratio have significant effect on heat transfer enhancement. They have interpreted the heat
transfer enhancement mechanisms by different mechanisms – larger vortices, higher
turbulence, higher flow entrainment etc.
(Zhou, Wang, Middelberg, & Herwig, 2009) studied heat transfer on smooth and non-smooth
surfaces. Out of the parameters tested, roughness has weak influence on heat transfer for
steady jets but, it has significant effect on heat transfer for unsteady jets. Few authors
acclaimed that, this result cannot be generalized unless and until the study of roughness
parameter on heat transfer on non-smooth plate. Recently one type of unsteady jets are
developed know as “synthetic jets”, in which net mass flux is zero.
This type of vibration enhancement is more experimental type because of mass of mass of
heat exchangers. To excite the fluids is easy than to create vibrations in heat exchangers
themselves. The range of frequency from 1Hz to ultrasound is used in exciting the fluids.
Either at low or high frequency, surface vibration has been firstly used to enhance the single-
phase heat transfer. A piezoelectric device can be used to vibrate a surface.
Mechanical aids involve stirring of the fluid by either mechanical means or by rotating the
surface. They are applied to the liquid in a region close to the heat exchanger wall. Stirrers
are included in it. Mechanical scrapers, which are used for viscous liquids in chemical
industry, can also be applied to duct flow of gases (Bergles, 1988).
3.1.6. Spray
Spray contains the liquid droplets that are generated by air or pressure-assisted atomizer.
When the drops are impinged on the surface, they spread all over the surface, they get
evaporate or a thin film of fluid is formed due to which heat transfer get enhanced (Rini,
Chen, & Chow, 2001).
By evaporation, convection and secondary nucleation, heat transfer is more even at low
temperatures (Horacek, Kiger, & Kim, 2005). The heat transfer behaviour (heat flux versus
wall temperature) using spray cooling, confer the following attributes:
At low wall temperature, the heating plate gets cooled by single-phase regime. As the
flow gets rapidly displaced from the heating surface, the liquid doesn’t get enough
time to warm up in this temperature range
Below the saturation temperature, there might be an increase in curve slope due to the
evaporation thin liquid film formed on the surface (Yang, Chow, & Pais, 1996).
When the liquid near the heating wall gets superheated, heat transfer coefficient gets
enhanced due to due to secondary nucleation and/or boiling (Rini, Chen, & Chow,
2001). Secondary nucleation occurs within the liquid. When the droplets enter the
liquid, nucleation sites will be formed, when adsorbed gas molecules surrounding
them gets dissolved. The number of nucleation sites are proportional to number of
liquid droplets forming the spray (Rini, Chen, & Chow, 2001). As the nucleation sites
increases, the heat transfer gets increased (Yang, Chow, & Pais, 1996). Boiling may
also begin at the wall at this temperature range (superheated liquid). Both secondary
nuclei and boiling can occur concurrently leading to higher heat transfer coefficients.
When the flow increases additionally, the surface start to dry. Spray cooling has
higher heat flux.
3.1.7. Suction
Suction involves either vapour removal through a porous heated surface in nucleate or film
boiling, or fluid withdrawal in single-phase flow through a porous heated surface (Bergles,
1988).
3.1.8. Injection
Injection involves supplying gas to a flowing liquid through a porous heat transfer surface or
injecting similar fluid upstream of or along the heat transfer section. It is mainly applied for
single-phase flow (Bergles, 1988).
3.1.10. Rotation
Rotation is used to improve both heat and mass transfer. When a fluid is allowed to pass
across a rotating disc, improvement in heat transfer coefficients can be observed. In the last
decade, Spinning Disc Reactor (SDR), which utilizes the enhanced heat and mass transfer
was developed. The earliest significant work on rotating discs as heat transfer devices was
done firstly at Newcastle University and then at Protensive Ltd, until recently a PI equipment
manufacturer. For example, it is shown in the following figure. 7. (Reay, Ramshaw, &
Harvey, 2013).
These methods enhance the heat transfer by varying the flow treatment due to which pressure
drop also increases. One of the methods to enhance heat transfer is to increase the surface
area and residence time of the heat transfer fluids in the convective heat transfer. This method
causes the swirl in the bulk of the fluids and displaces the actual boundary layers which
increases the surface area, residence time due to which heat transfer coefficient increases.
Comparatively passive methods are less complex in the context of design and applications
than active methods. Heat transfer is less in passive methods than active methods. Some of
the passive methods are – extended surfaces, rough surfaces, coated surfaces, inserts,
nanofluids, swirl flow devices (turbulators). Out of all passive methods, inserts are popular
devices used for enhancement of heat transfer of heat exchangers used in industries. Many of
the passive methods are used to make shell and tube exchangers more compact.
Reduction of heat exchanger size might be an important objective for vehicular and heat
recovery processes. For these services, heat exchangers generally involve gases that have low
heat transfer coefficients. Extended surfaces, especially those with enhanced configurations,
are used to obtain size, weight, and cost reductions.
a. b
In figure 1a, we can see the offset strip fin that normally exhibits an average heat transfer
coefficient 80 to 100 % higher than that of a plain fin of same area. In figure 1b, we can see
the steel serrated fins used for waste heat recovery boilers (Bergles, 1988).
By using segmented longitudinal fins inside circular tubes, heat transfer can be enhanced by
periodically displacing and restarting the boundary layer on the finned surface and perturbing
the bulk flow field (Prajapati, Mane, Mane, & Gaikwad, 2015). Finned surfaces provide a
large surface area density in plate fin or tube and plate fin type of compact heat exchangers.
Fig. 9. Tubes with circumferential and strip fins on their outer surface
Most of the heat exchangers used in gas streams have fins to enhance the gas-side heat
transfer. Compact units like plate-fin heat exchangers have fins or secondary surfaces
between the pair of plates. In both natural and forced convection, fins are used. To enhance
the performance, plate-fin heat exchanger uses a variety of extended surfaces. Generally
finned heat exchangers are used as the basis of heat exchanger reactors where there is
frequently a need to used enhanced heat transfer control.
Porvair recently introduced a metal foam which can double as an extended surface into the
UK market. Foam can be characterized as an anisotropic three-dimensional extended surface.
One example of its use is in a gas-liquid heat exchanger, the tubes piercing the bulk of the
foam, which replace the conventional extended surfaces. Foam pore size was 0.1-5 mm.
Foam can be kept inside the tubes or between the plates, configuring a gas-gas heat
exchanger. Work is under way at Brunel university (Lu, Zhao, & Tassou, 2006).
Treated surfaces have a comparatively fine scale variation to the surface fins, or have a
coating applied. These changes are naturally used to promote enhancement of boiling or
condensation. Treated surfaces involve usage of pits, cavities or scratches. These are usually
applicable in two phase transfer and they contain a variety of structured surfaces (continuous
or discontinuous integral surface roughness or alterations) and coatings. Though the treatment
provides a roughness to the surface, it is not large enough to effect single phase heat transfer.
There are various types of treated surfaces used –
The principle of providing the treated surfaces for enhancement of boiling is to produce a
large number of vapour traps or nucleation sites on the surface. This is relevant for highly
wetting fluids like refrigerants, organic liquids, cryogens, and alkali metals where the normal
cavities are present on the heated surfaces. (Prajapati, Mane, Mane, & Gaikwad, 2015). For
less wetting or comparatively higher surface tension fluids, coatings of non-wetting material
(ex: Teflon) are given on either side of heated surface to improve stable nucleation. A fine-
scale porous coating may be used to enhance nucleate boiling.
A new process, surfi-sculpt, was developed at TWI, Cambridge, is a new development that
has considerable implications for PI where surface changes can enhance heat and/or mass
transfer.
Surfi -Sculpt gives appreciable feature control by allowing projections to be built and shaped
as separate operations, letting a wide range of features to be formed on flat or curved
surfaces.
The simplest and oldest method, which is widely used in current practice, is the use of surface
roughness inside circular tubes (Webb, Eckert, & Goldstein, 1971). Roughness occurs
naturally in manufactured tubes and is very effective in enhancing turbulent flow convection
by displacing the viscous sub-layer in the near-wall turbulent flow structure to advance
higher momentum and heat transport. However, in laminar flows, small-scale roughness do
not show any significant effect.
For enhanced heat transfer applications, rough surfaces have been employed on both inner
and outer surfaces of tubes in single-phase turbulent flows inside or over tube bundles. The
followings gives sampling of some such tubes that are used in various heat exchangers.
Comparatively heat transfer coefficient can be improved a lot that smooth tube turbulent flow
convection (Ravigururajan & Bergles, 1994; Ravigururajan & Bergles, 1996).
At present many commercial tubes are now produced with structured roughness made up of
ribs or surface indentations that are transversely or helically repeated along the length. Tubes
with ribs and indentations of different cross-sectional geometry, and wire-coil inserts that
provide helical ribs of circular cross section are shown in the following figure. 16
(Ravigururajan & Bergles, 1996). With a tube inside diameter di, the roughness profile
attributes are described by the protuberance height e, repeated-rib pitch p, spiral angle α in
degrees for helical ribs, and contact angle β in degrees of the roughness profile relative to the
flow direction.
Methods for producing swirl flows to enhance heat transfer naturally consist of tube inserts,
axially twisted noncircular ducts, and tangential fluid entry arrangements in ducts (RM &
AE, 2003). Inserts need additional arrangements to make to fluid flow which enhance the
heat transfer. The various types of inserts used are – twisted tape, wire coils, ribs, baffle
plates, conical rings etc. Among these, twisted-tape inserts, are widely used to enhance forced
convection heat transfer inside circular tubes. Their usage in the shell-and-tube heat
exchangers, geometric features and characteristics (Manglik, 2018) are shown in the
following figure –
Fig. 17. Use of twisted-tape inserts in the tubes of a shell-and-tube heat exchanger, and
schematic representation of the geometric features a typical twist tape.
Twisted tapes are the metallic strips twisted using some of the suitable methods as per the
required shape and dimension, which are inserted in the flow to enhance the heat transfer.
The twisted tape inserts are most suitable and widely used in heat exchangers to enhance the
heat transfer.
Even so success has been observed when the twisted tapes are being used in heat exchangers
for heat transfer enhancement, still increased pumping power with the usage of insert devices
remains to be a concern. Investigation has been made to study the possibility of using
perforated helical twisted tape (P-HTTs) with a view to reduce pumping drawback (Saha,
Tiwari, Sundén, & Wu, 2016).
Fig.
20. Geometries V-cut twisted tapes
Fig. 21. Rectangular cut twisted tape inserts (Salam, Biswas, Saha, & Bhuiya, 2013)
Fig. 23. A typical looped wire mesh insert for tubular exchangers and mixers used in the
chemical process industry
Coiled tubes are used in a variety of commercial heat exchangers. They not only increase the
heat transfer surface area per unit volume of the heat exchanger but also significantly enhance
the tube-side flow heat transfer coefficient (Manglik, 2018).
Fig. 24. Schematic representation of curved and coiled tubes and their geometric attributes
A variety of additives can be used to enhance the heat transfer in both single-phase and two-
phase flows. Convective heat transfer in liquids can be improved by the addition of bubbles
or solid particles. Convective heat transfer in gases can be improved by the addition of fine
mists. The use of nano-particles to enhance the heat transfer is a recent development.
3.2.7.1. Nanofluids
Nanotechnology is concerned with the materials and systems whose structures and
components exhibit novel and significantly improved physical, chemical, and biological
properties, phenomena, and processes due to their nanoscale size. In the last two decades, the
application of nanofluids has drastically increased in enhancement of heat transfer.
Nanofluids have captivated the attention of researchers now-a-days.
Nanofluid is a colloidal mixture of nanoparticles in base fluid. They showed better thermal
characteristics than simple fluids. (CG, RA, J, & AJ, 1976) initially discovered ultrafine
particles, whose size is in nanometers. Later on, these ultrafine particles were named as
nanoparticles. Nanofluids are suspensions that can be obtained by dispersing different
nanoparticles in host fluids with the aim of enhanced thermal properties (France, Routbort, &
Choi, 2008). There are so many types of nanofluids used. Some of them are –
Single-step process involves condensing of nanophase powders from the vapor phase directly
into a flowing low vapor-pressure liquid (nanoparticles are made and dispersed in liquid
simultaneously). The nanoparticles are prepared by either using physical vapour deposition
(PVD) technique or liquid chemical method (Y, J, S, E, & S, 2009). The initial PVD method,
known as VEROS (vacuum evaporation onto a running oil substrate), was founded to
produce nanoparticles. As it was difficult to separate the nanoparticles from the liquid, this
method didn’t last long. By applying slight modifications, (JA, US, S, LJ, & S, 1997)
developed a direct evaporation system where Cu vapour is directly condensed into
nanoparticles by contact with a flowing low-vapor-pressure liquid ethylene glycol. This
process does not involve drying, storage, transportation, and dispersion of nanoparticles, thus
during mixing agglomeration is minimized and fluid stability is higher. Only low vapour
fluids can be used in this process. This is the disadvantage of this process. Nanoparticles
shape can be varied from a spherical shape to octahedral shape by altering some synthesis
parameters.
It is well known that combination two or more of the existing techniques can be utilized
simultaneously to develop an enhancement larger than that produced by using single
technique. The pair of different techniques acting simultaneously is known as compound
enhancement. Interactions between different enhancement methods contribute to higher
values of the heat transfer coefficients compared to the sum of the corresponding values for
the individual techniques used alone. Preliminary studies in compound passive enhancement
techniques were encouraging. For example, many previous surveys indicated that the
corrugated tubes are among the most effective and practical methods for enhancing single-
phase heat transfer in tubes. It is reasonable to assume that a mixture of a corrugated tube
with twisted tape would be superior to either passive surface technique acting alone
( IntechOpen, 2018).
In this method heat transfer characteristics of dual twisted tape insert and ribbed tube are
compared to those of the sleek and therefore the ribbed tube acting alone. This pair of the
twisted tapes and modified tubes has been investigated within the prospect of higher heat
transfer enhancement.
The test has been conducted within the flow regime, Re ranging from 6000 to 60,000 with
water as the test fluid (Saha, Tiwari, Sundén, & Wu, 2016). The small print of ribbed tube
and twin twisted tape has been shown (Saha, Tiwari, Sundén, & Wu, 2016) in the following
figure –
It should be noted that the name is tube is named co-swirl when the ribbed tube is arranged in
similar directions of the helical swirl of the twisted tape and thus the helical rib motion.
Effects of the co-swirl motion of the ribbed tube and thus the double twisted tapes with
various twist ratios on heat transfer and friction characteristics were examined.
Nusselt number (Nu) variation with Reynolds number has been displayed Fig . 26(a) as the
heat transfer performance indicator for ribbed tube with twin twisted tape, the performance is
compared with ribbed tube and plain tube and is reflected within the form of Nu/Nu0 ratio
variation against Reynolds number Fig. 9(b). It is observed that Nu increases with the rise in
Re while, the Nu/Nu0 shows an opposite trend for all cases.
On the opposite hand, the combined technique i.e. ribbed tube having twin twisted tape
shows improved heat transfer rate results than the ribbed tube acting alone or the graceful
tube. This improved performance could also be attributed to the simpler stagnant layer
disruption capability of dual twisted tape assisted by the ribbed wall roughness, compared to
those caused by ribbed tube or plain tube individually. Heat transfer augmentation using
combined technique is found to enhance by 4–75 you bored with reference to the ribbed tube.
Of course, this variation is thanks to different combination of Re and twist ratio value. On the
opposite hand, the augmentation has been observed 150–320 yet one more compared to the
plain tube.
3.3.3. Combination of nano fluids and wire coil insert for heat transfer
enhancement
Few researchers combined wire coil inserts with nanofluid to achieve a better heat transfer
rate in thermal devices. (M, S, & AC, 2010) and (M, MA, & M, 2012) investigated
experimentally the laminar heat transfer improvement and pressure loss of nanofluid flow
inside a pipe consists of wire coil inserts. (M, S, & AC, 2010) used Al2O3–water nanofluid,
while (M, MA, & M, 2012) employed CuO-based oil nanofluid. Both the researches
indicated that nanofluid has higher heat transfer efficiency as it flows through the pipes fitted
by wire coil inserts in lieu of flowing through the quality pipe. The higher thermal efficiency
3.3.4. Combination of nanofluids and twisted tape inserts for heat transfer
improvement
Few researchers combined twisted tape inserts and nanofluid to realize a higher heat transfer
rate in thermal systems. Sharma has computed the friction factor and heat transfer coefficient
to a transitional nanofluid flow inside a circular pipe consists of twisted tape inserts. They
increased the heat transfer rate about 23.8 and 43.7% by using the nanofluid and twisted tape
insert, respectively, at Re = 9000.0. Moreover, they also reported that the highest friction
factor by twisted tape at 0.1% nanoparticle volume fraction is 1.20 times greater than the
friction factor obtained by pure water flow through a clear pipe.
(K & S, 2011) improved the heat transfer rate during a pipe by combine in twisted tape with
alternated axis and nanofluid. The twisted tapes with the alternated axis used by (K & S,
2011)are disclosed in figure. The results of earlier researches confirmed that the usage of
twisted tapes along with alternated axis provides higher heat transfer rate and thermal
efficiency. This may be supported by the fact that the alternated axis on twisted tapes changes
the flow pattern. This causes a disordered mixing between the fluid at the centre and the fluid
around the pipe surface.
Accordingly, this leads to a far better interruption of the thermal physical phenomenon in
comparison to the case of normal twisted tape, in which merely rotating flow is created. (K &
S, 2011) and proved that twisted tape with alternated axis has a greater value of heat transfer
(around 90%) as compared to the case of ordinary twisted tape.
(G & P, 2010) investigated numerically the combined effects of nanofluid and helical tape
inserts on the laminar heat transfer during a uniformly heated circular tube. The heat transfer
increment is about 5–30% by combining those two techniques. Note that the enhancement is
the function of the nanoparticle volume fraction and twist ratio.
(S, KP, & P, 2011) compared the thermal behaviours of the steady-state flows of alumina and
copper oxide–water nanofluids in a circular channel consists of helical screw tape inserts
displayed in figure 28. Note that Y represents a twist ratio (ratio of pitch of the helical screw
tape to the insert diameter). Their findings indicated that helical screw tape inserts have
higher thermal efficiency as equipped with copper oxide–water nanofluid.
(LS, NR, MT, & KV, 2012) investigated the combined influences of full-length twisted tape
inserts and magnetic nanofluid on the flow and thermal fields during a pipe. The heat transfer
rate is increases by 30.86% by using this type of nanofluid with a volume fraction of 0.60%
at Re = 22,000 for plain tube. An enhancement of 18.48% is obtained by using full-length
twisted tape inserts in comparison with the plain pipe at Re = 22,000 and u = 0.60%. Under
an equivalent condition, the friction factor is merely 1.122 times higher. (S & K, 2012)used
nanofluids in a microfin pipe equipped with single and dual twisted tapes as shown in figure
29. They reported that micro fin pipe equipped by dual twisted tapes has a significantly
higher thermal efficiency (up to 45.40%) in comparison with the one that equipped by a
single tape.
Other passive method used for heat transfer improvement is to employ baffles to change the
flow path. usually, these devices shifts the flow orientation and can also be employed in
several processes having water cooling, clarifying, clear wells, and reservoirs water treatment
equipment In thermal science, the usage of baffles interrupts both hydraulic and thermal
boundary layers and, accordingly causes improvement of the heat transfer rate indeed, the
flow passing around the baffles effects the duct surface, which can improve the local heat
transfer rate. Few researchers also combined this method with nanofluid to obtain a better
heat transfer rate in thermal devices.
(H, S, & PR, 2016) investigated numerically the combined effects of baffles and nanofluid on
the forced convection in the entry area of a duct. They considered the nanoparticle migration
in their simulation. Figure 31 shows the nanoparticle concentration contours between the
sixth and seventh baffles at Re = 400, dp = 10 nm and u = 4%. As shown in this figure, the
nanoparticle volume fraction reduces near the walls due to the thermophoresis phenomenon.
Note that the nanoparticles migrate from the region with higher temperature to the region
with lower temperature.
(H, J, & M, 2012) studied numerically nanofluid natural convection in a cavity consists of a
conductive baffle. Their results shown that for a higher values of Rayleigh number, because
of the enhancement of convection, the average Nusselt number augments when one increases
the concentration of nanoparticles and other relocates the baffle towards the core of the
cavitation used segmental baffles and nanofluid in a shell and tube heat exchanger. He
investigated the effects of various nanoparticle shapes like cylindrical, bricks, platelets, and
blades and baffle angles on the performance of this system. They mentioned that the cylinder-
shaped nanoparticles have the better efficiency in comparison with all shapes for all baffle
angles.
Moreover, the 20 baffle angle has the best efficiency when compared to other angles.
Mohammed investigated numerically the mixed convection heat transfer of nanofluids on a
backward facing step inside a rectangular channel with a baffle. They came to know that a
(A & A, 2014) checked various multiphase models to simulate and study the effects of
nanoparticles and baffles on the heat transfer increment. He used both single-phase model
and various multiphase models containing mixture, Eulerian, and volume of fluid models to
simulate this problem for Reynolds numbers in between 600 and 3000. He finalised that
multiphase models are more pinpointed for estimating the heat transfer of nanofluids.
Moreover, he showed that the baffle encompasses a larger influence on the heat transfer
improvement when compared to the nanofluid for higher values of the Reynolds number
(e.g., 2100–3000).
(Bahiraei M, 2015) investigated numerically the combined effects of nanofluid and helical
baffles on the energetic performance of a tube heat exchanger. Most of the baffles are
segmental types that the shell-side flow for moving along a zigzag pass to increase the
warmth transfer rate. Equipping this kind of baffles leads to some problems containing
creating dead areas in each portion in between two tandem baffles, and as a result, it
augments the fouling resistance. Another problem is the risk of vibration failure on the tube
surface as a result of intense zigzag flow structure.
Accordingly, helical baffles are introduced as a replacement for segmental type that almost
minimizes the above issues. They recommended that to get best heat transfer rate and a small
pressure loss, it's better to use helical baffles having small helix angle. Moreover, a high solid
volume fraction of nanoparticles can also be used without increasing too much the pressure
drop. (Bahiraei M, 2015) stated that the pressure drop increases about 150% as the volume
fraction increases in the range from 0 to 5%. (M, AR, Y, & R, 2016) used numerically
nanofluid and helical baffles in a twin pipe heat exchanger. A schematic of the twin pipe heat
exchanger with helical baffles simulated by (M, AR, Y, & R, 2016) is shown in figure 32.
The nanoparticle concentration contours between the sixth and seventh baffles at Re = 400,
dp = 10 nm and u = 4%. the nanoparticle volume fraction decreases near the walls due to the
thermophoresis phenomenon. Note that the nanoparticles move from the region with high
temperature to the region with low temperature. Accordingly, a substrate with high values of
nanoparticle volume fraction appears over the baffles. They proved that the effect of the
nanoparticle diameters on PEC depends majorly on the value of the nanoparticle volume
fraction.
4. Conclusion
Energy crisis and environmental issues were the main factors given compulsory drive to
enhance the performance of heat exchangers that are sources for most power consumption
and affecting plant operating cost. In order to answer the performance issues of heat
exchangers, researchers have proposed various active, passive and compound methods.
Among them, active methods has gained huge popularity in the fields like medical
instruments, spacecraft engineering, marine applications and last but not the least all domains
where performance is prior but not cost. Needless to say, apart from the above mentioned
fields, a low cost solution to improve heat exchanger issue is highly desirable. Hence active
approach of enhancing performance is not preferred in industries because of its high
implementation cost and operating cost.
Passive methods where flow is modified either by using insert devices or by altering the
channel geometry offers low cost solution to enhance heat exchange process. Compound
techniques, as discussed, are the most latest techniques of enhancing heat exchange process
and with this approach it would be possible to further decrease the geometry of the heat
exchangers without compromising the thermohydraulic performance. With the assist of
nanotechnology, it's further possible to enhance the performance of heat exchangers,
particularly dealing with low thermal conductivity fluids. Although it has been reported by
researchers that addition of nano particles significantly increases the pressure drop, yet this
new era brings many possibility to contribute.
We are aware that the heat transfer enhancement is possible by using treated surfaces, using
inserts, using extended surfaces which are the most important passive methods to improve
the heat transfer. By using treated surfaces we increase heat transfer rate which is applicable
for both boiling and condensing also. The twisted tape inserts are the most suitable and are
widely used in heat exchanger to increase the heat transfer. Twisted tape inserts generally
improves heat transfer rate with less friction factor. The coiled circular wire should be
applied in place of smooth one to achieve higher heat transfer. The heat transfer can also
done by extended surfaces that conclude that copper has higher thermal conductivity
compared to brass and aluminium.
A better improvement in the heat transfer rate was achieved by using vortex generator in pure
water, while a considerable development was achieved by using the vortex generator and
nanofluids at a time followed with a moderate rise in the friction factor. Usually, vortex
The geometrical properties of coil wires have a considerable effect on the thermal efficiency
of the whole thermal system. The heat transfer rate improves with increasing the coil
diameter. Usually, the secondary vectors have higher strength while using a coiled wire with
a larger diameter and this leads to more increase in the heat transfer rate. The heat transfer
increases as the ratio of wire coil inserts (the ratio of wire coil pitch to the inner diameter of
the pipe) decreases. A wire coil having sharp-edged shoe has higher heat transfer efficiency
when compared with the circular one.
The heat transfer enhancement generated by combining the use of nanofluid and twisted tapes
is greater at the pipe outlet ( when compared to inlet) as a result of the impact of the swirl
flow. The system performance can be increased without even increasing the size of the heat
exchanger. Nanofluid has higher heat transfer efficiency when equipped with r twisted strips.
The use of twisted tapes along with alternated axis improves the thermal efficiency when
compared to the base case with twisted tapes. The micro fin pipe increased by twin twisted
tapes has a considerably better thermal efficiency compared to the case with a single tape
alone. Usually, the twisted tapes are more efficient when compared with the wire coils to
increase heat transfer, while the wire coils lower pressure drop in comparison with twisted
tapes. Helical baffles were introduced as a substitution for segmental types. Even a small
small displacement of the baffle leads to a huge change in the flow and temperature fields. If
one wants to achieve higher heat transfer rates but small pressure drops, it is suggestable to
equip helical baffles with small helix angle.
5. Future scope
Further studies are essential for future to discover and optimizing geometries of different
inserts and vortex generators to enhance the thermal characteristics of heat exchangers.
Additionally, the recent boom in nanotechnology has widened a promising field in heat
transfer investigation. pair of inserts and nanofluids might be a kind of propitious idea to
increase the thermal systems performance which has been rarely reported in the open
literature. Numerous opportunities will be available when authors focus their efforts on
equipping nanofluids combined with various kinds of inserts in large as well as microscale
heat exchangers and heat sinks. The comparison of nanofluids and conventional fluids in
As we know that the Passive heat transfer techniques does not require any external power
input and additional power required to enhance the heat transfer is absorbed from the
available power in the system. In the convective heat transfer one of the methods to enhance
the heat transfer rate is to increase the total effective surface area and residence time of the
heat transfer fluids. Using this technique causes the swirl in the bulk of the fluids and
interrupts the actual boundary layers which increase the total effective surface area, residence
time and along with heat transfer coefficient increases in the system. The primary condition
to improve the heat transfer is to achieve the swirl in the bulk of fluids and this can be done
by the passive heat transfer enhancement techniques. The heat enhancement techniques have
the easy installation and removal at the same time simple manufacturing process with
considerably low cost. We know that the heat transfer enhancement can be done by inserts
like wire coils, twisted tapes which are easily available and it has a simple process. we can
conclude that study on heat transfer enhancement methods offers a wide range of
applications.
6. Bibliography
IntechOpen. (2018, June 27). A review of heat transfer enhancement methods using coiled wire and
twisted tape inserts. Retrieved May 19, 2021, from IntechOpen - Open Science Open Minds |
IntechOpen: A review of heat transfer enhancement methods using coiled wire and twisted tape
inserts
A, H., HA, M., & AN, D. (2014). Mixed convection heat transfer of nanofluids over backward facing
step having a slotted baffle. Applied Mathematics and Computation , 240, 368-386.
A, S., & A, J. (2014, August 25). Application of different CFD multiphase models to investigate effects
of baffles and nanoparticles on heat transfer enhancement. Frontiers of Chemical Science and
Engineering , 320-329.
AE, B. (1998). Techniques to enhance heat transfer. IN: Hand book of heat transfer (3rd ed.). New
York: McGraw-Hill.
Akira, Y., & Hiroshi, M. (1988). Augmentation of convective and boiling heat transfer by applying an
electro-hydrodynamical liquid jet. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer , 31 (2), 407-417.
Alamgholilou, A., & Esmaeilzadeh, E. (2012). Experimental investigation on hydrodynamics and heat
transfer of fluid flow into channel for cooling of rectangular ribs by passive and EHD active
enhancement methods. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science , 38, 61-73.
Albadr, J., SatinderTayal, & Alasadi, M. (2013). Heat transfer through heat exchanger using Al2O3
nanofluid at different. Case Studies in Thermal Engineering , 38-44.
Bahiraei M, H. M. (2015). A novel application for energy efficiency improvement using nanofluid in
shell and tube heat exchanger equipped with helical baffles. Energy , 202 (2), 2229-2240.
Balandin, A., Ghosh, S., Bao, W., Calizo, I., Teweldebrhan, D., Miao, F., et al. (2008, February 20).
Superior Thermal Conductivity of Single-Layer Graphene. Nano letters , 902-907.
Bergles, A. E. (1988). Heat transfer augmentation. Two-Phase Flow Heat Exchangers , 343-373.
Cardenas, R., & Narayanan, V. (2012). Heat transfer characteristics of submerged jet impingement
boiling of saturated FC-72. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer , 55 (15-16), 4217-4231.
CG Thermal. (2020, November 6). SIC Umax Advanced Ceramic Heat Exchangers. Retrieved May 19,
2021, from CG Thermal: https://cgthermal.com/heat-exchangers/sic-ceramic/
CG, G., RA, B., J, W., & AJ, S. (1976). Far-Infrared Absorption in Ultrafine Al Particles. Physical Review
Letters , 37 (10), 625-629.
Cotton, J., Robinson, a. J., Shoukri, M., & Chang, J. (2012). AC Voltage Induced Electrohydrodynamic
Two-Phase Convective Boiling Heat Transfer in Horizontal Annular Channels. Experimental Thermal
and Fluid Science , 41, 31-42.
Dhumal, A. H., Kerkal, G. M., & Pawale, K. (2017). Heat Transfer Enhancement for Tube in Tube Heat
Exchanger Using Twisted Tape Inserts. International Journal of Advanced Engineering Research and
Science , 4 (5), 89-92.
Eiamsa-Ard, S., & Promvonge, P. (2005). Enhancement of heat transfer in a tube with regularly-
spaced helical tape swirl generators. Solar energy , 78 (4), 483-494.
Feng, Y., & Seyed-Yagoobi, J. (2006). Control of Liquid Flow Distribution Utilizing EHD Conduction
Pumping Mechanism. IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications , 42, 269-277.
France, Routbort, J., & Choi, S. (2008). Review and Comparison of Nanofluid Thermal Conductivity
and Heat Transfer Enhancements. Heat Transfer Engineering , 29 (5), 432-460.
G, P., & P, S. (2010, February). Heat transfer behaviour of nanofluids in a uniformly heated circular
tube fitted with helical inserts in laminar flow. Superlattices and Microstructures , 349-360.
Ganić, E. (1991). Report on the Second World Conference on Experimental Heat Transfer, Fluid
Mechanics, and Thermodynamics. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science , 4 (6), 752.
Gardon, R., & Carbonpue, J. (1962). Heat transfer between a flat plate and jets of air impinging on it.
International Developments in Heat Transfer, Second International Heat Transfer Conference , 454-
460.
Grassi, W., Testi, D., & Saputelli, M. (2005, May). EHD Enhanced Heat Transfer in a Vertical Annulus.”
International Communications in Heat and Mass Transfer. International Journal of Heat and Mass
Grassi, W., Testi, D., & Saputelli, M. (2005). Heat Transfer Enhancement in a Vertical Annulus by
Electrophoretic Forces Acting on a Dielectric Liquid. Heat Transfer Enhancement in a Vertical Annulus
by Electrophoretic Forces Acting on a Dielectric Liquid , 44, 1022-1077.
H, F., S, M., & PR, M. (2016). Nanofluid forced convection in entrance region of a baffled channel
considering nanoparticle migration. Applied Thermal Engineering , 106, 293-306.
H, K., J, A., & M, N. (2012). Numerical investigation of Cu-water nanofluid natural convection and
entropy generation within a cavity with an embedded conductive baffle. Scientia Iranica , 19 (6),
1996-2003.
Horacek, B., Kiger, K. T., & Kim, J. (2005). Single nozzle spray cooling heat transfer mechanisms.
International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer , 48 (6), 1425-1438.
JA, E., US, C., S, L., LJ, T., & S, L. (1997). Enhanced thermal conductivity through the development of
nanofluids. Materials Research Society , 457, 3-11.
Jadhav, M., Awari, R., Bibe, D., Bramhane, A., & Mokashi, M. (2016). Review on Enhancement of
Heat Transfer by Active Method. International Journal of Current Engineering and Technology (6),
221-225.
Jalaal, M., Khorshidi, B., & Esmaeilzadeh, E. (2013). Electrohydrodynamic (EHD) Mixing of Two
Miscible Dielectric Liquids. Chemical Engineering Journal , 219, 118-123.
Jambunathan, K., Lai, E., Moss, M., & Button, B. (1992). A review of heat transfer data for single
circular jet impingement. International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow , 13 (2), 106-115.
K, W., & S, E.-A. (2011). Enhancement of heat transfer using CuO/water nanofluid and twisted tape
with alternate axis. International Communications in Heat and Mass Transfer , 38 (6), 742-748.
Kasayapanand, N., & Kiatsiriroat, T. (2009). Enhanced Heat Transfer in Partially Open Square Cavities
with Thin Fin by Using Electric Field. Energy Conversion and Management , 50, 287-296.
Lakeh, R. B., & Molki, M. (2012, February). argeted Heat Transfer Augmentation in Circular Tubes
Using a Corona Jet. Journal of Electrostatics , 31-42.
Laohalertdecha, S., & Wongwises, S. (2006, July). Effects of EHD on Heat Transfer Enhancement and
Pressure Drop during Two-Phase Condensation of Pure R-134a at High Mass Flux in a Horizontal
Micro-Fin Tube. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science , 675-686.
Léal, L., Léal, M., Lavieille, P., Amokrane, M., Pigache, F., Topin, F., et al. (2013). An overview of heat
transfer enhancement methods and new perspectives: Focus on active methods using electroactive
materials. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer , 61, 505-524.
LS, S., NR, K., MT, N., & KV, S. (2012). Effect of full length twisted tape inserts on heat transfer and
friction factor enhancement with Fe3O4 magnetic nanofluid inside a plain tube: an experimental
study. Internal journal of heat and mass transfer , 55 (11-12), 2761-2768.
Lu, W., Zhao, C., & Tassou, S. (2006). Thermal analysis on metal-foam filled heat exchangers. I
nternational Journal of Heat and Mass , 49, 2751-2761.
Lytle, D., & Webb, B. (1994). Air jet impingement heat transfer at low nozzle-plate spacings.
International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer , 37 (12), 1687-1697.
M, C., S, S., & AC, B. (2010). Experimental studies on heat transfer and friction factor characteristics
of Al2O3/water nanofluid in a circular pipe under laminar flow with wire coil inserts. Experimental
Thermal and Fluid Science , 34 (2), 123-130.
M, S., AR, N., Y, A., & R, K. (2016). CFD Investigation and neutral network modeling of heat transfer
and pressure drop of nanofluids in double pipe helically baffled heat exchanger with a 3-D fined
tube. Applied Thermal Engineering , 100, 721-729.
M, S., MA, A.-B., & M, N. (2012). Experimental studies on heat transfer and friction factor
characteristics of Al2O3/water nanofluid in a circular pipe under laminar flow with wire coil inserts.
Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science , 36, 158-168.
Malow, M., Wehrstedt, K., Schuurman, P., & Hoeijmakers, P. M. (2014). Comments on “Thermal
decomposition kinetic evaluation and its thermal hazards prediction of AIBN, by S. Guo, W. Wan, C.
Chen and W. H. Chen” (Journal of thermal analysis and calorimetry (2013) 113:1169–1176, DOI
10.1007/s10973-013-2993-7). Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry , 117 (3), 1015-1016.
Manglik, R. M. (2018). Enhancement of Convective Heat Transfer. Handbook of Thermal Science and
Engineering , 447-477.
Martin, H. (1977). Heat and Mass Transfer between Impinging Gas Jets and Solid Surfaces. Advances
in Heat Transfer Advances in Heat Transfer , 13, 1-60.
Matani, D. A., & Dahake, S. A. (2013). Experimental study on heat transfer enhancement in a tube
using counter/co-swirl generation. International Journal of Application or Innovation in Engineering
& Management .
Mirzaei, M., & Saffar-Avval, M. (2018). Enhancement of Convection Heat Transfer Using EHD
Conduction Method. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science , 93, 108-118.
Mulla, A. M., Jangamashetti, U., Manoj, & K, K. (2014). Experimental study on heat transfer and
friction factor characteristics in laminar flow through tubes of shell and tube heat exchanger fitted
Oosthuizen, P. H., & Bassey, M. (1973). An Experimental Study of Combined Forced- and Free-
Convective Heat Transfer from Flat Plates to Air at Low Reynolds Numbers. Journal of Heat Transfer ,
95, 120-121.
Oyakawa, K., Umeda, A., Islam, M. D., Saji, N., & Matsuda, S. (2009, October 8). Flow structure and
heat transfer of impingement jet. Heat and Mass Transfer , 53-61.
Picon-Nunez, M., Melo-Gonzalez, J. C., & Garcia-Castillo, J. L. (2018, November 05). Use of Heat
Transfer Enhancement Techniques in the Design of Heat Exchangers. Retrieved May 19, 2021, from
Intechopen: https://www.intechopen.com/books/advances-in-heat-exchangers/use-of-heat-
transfer-enhancement-techniques-in-the-design-of-heat-exchangers
Prajapati, R. R., Mane, P. A., Mane, M. S., & Gaikwad, D. (2015). Review of recent techniques of heat
transfer enhancement and validation of heat exchanger. Journal of emerging technologies and
innovative research , 2 (2), 349-.
Ravigururajan, T. S., & Bergles, A. E. (1996). Development and verification of general correlations for
pressure drop and heat transfer in single-phase turbulent flow in enhanced tubes. Experimental
Thermal and Fluid Science , 13 (1), 55-70.
Ravigururajan, T. S., & Bergles, A. E. (1994). Visualization of Flow Phenomena Near Enhanced
Surfaces. Journal of Heat Transfer , 116 (1), 54-57.
Ray, P., & Jhinge, D. P. (2014). A review paper on heat transfer rate enhancement by wire coil inserts
in the tube. International journal of engineering sciences & research technology , 3, 238-243.
Reay, D., Ramshaw, C., & Harvey, A. (2013). The mechanisms involved in process intensification.
Process Intensification , 57-90.
Richard.T.L, A. H., & Agilan.H. (2015). Experimental Analysis of Heat Transfer Enhancement Using
Fins in Pin Fin Apparatus. 2.
Rini, D. P., Chen, R., & Chow, L. C. (2001). Bubble behavior and nucleate boiling heat transfer in
saturated FC-72 spray cooling. Journal of Heat Transfer , 124 (1), 63-72.
RM, M., & AE, B. (2003). Swirl flow heat transfer and pressure drop with twisted tape inserts.
Advances in heat transfer , 183-226.
Ronquillo, R. (n.d.). Process Equipment Articles on Thomasnet. Retrieved May 19, 2021, from
Thomasnet® - Product Sourcing and Supplier Discovery Platform - Find North American
Manufacturers, Suppliers and Industrial Companies: https://www.thomasnet.com/articles/process-
equipment/understanding-heat- exchangers/
S, S., KP, V., & P, S. (2011). Comparative study on thermal performance of helical screw tape inserts
in laminar flow using Al2O3/water and CuO/water nanofluids. Superlattices microstructure , 49 (6),
608-622.
Sadek, H., Ching, C., & Cotton, J. (2010, September). Characterization of Heat Transfer Modes of
Tube Side Convective Condensation under the Influence of an Applied DC Voltage. International
Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer , 4141-4151.
Sadek, H., Robinson, A., Cotton, J., Ching, C., & Shoukri, M. (2006). Electrohydrodynamic
enhancement of in-tube convective condensation heat transfer. International Journal of Heat and
Mass Transfer , 49, 1647-1657.
Saha, S. K., Tiwari, M., Sundén, B., & Wu, Z. (2016). Introduction. Advances in heat transfer
enhancement , 77-80.
Salam, B., Biswas, S., Saha, S., & Bhuiya, M. M. (2013). Heat Transfer Enhancement in a Tube using
Rectangular-cut Twisted Tape Insert. Procedia Engineering , 56, 96-103.
Shrikhande, N. S., & Kriplani, V. M. (2014). Heat Transfer Enhancement in Automobile Radiator using
Nanofluids: A Review. International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology , 3.
Siddiqui, M. A., & Seyed-Yagoobi, J. (2009). Experimental Study of Pumping of Liquid Film With
Electric Conduction Phenomenon. EEE Transactions on Industry Applications , 45, 3-9.
Sonawane, M. T., Patil, M. P., & Chavan, M. A. (2016). A review on heat transfer enhancement by
passive methods. International research journal of Engineering and technology , 3 (9), 1567-1574.
Thianpong, C., Eiamsa-ard, P., Promvonge, P., & Eiamsa-ard, S. (2011). Effect of perforated twisted-
tapes with parallel wings on heat transfer enhancement in a heat exchanger tube. Second
International Conference on Advances in Energy Engineering .
Tijing, L. D., Pak, B. C., Baek, B. J., & Lee, D. H. (2006). A study on heat transfer enhancement using
straight and twisted internal fin inserts. International communications in heat and mass transfer , 33
(6), 719-726.
Timm, W., Weinzierl, K., & Leipertz, A. (2003). Heat transfer in subcooled jet impingement boiling at
high wall temperatures. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer , 46 (8), 1385-1393.
Viskanta, R. (1993). Heat Transfer to Impinging Isothermal Gas and Flame Jets. Experimental Thermal
and Fluid Science , 6, 111-134.
Webb, R. L., Eckert, E. G., & Goldstein, R. J. (1971). Heat Transfer and Friction in Tubes with
Repeated-Rib Roughness. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer , 14 (4), 601-617.
Weigand, B., & Spring, S. (2011). Multiple Jet Impingement - A Review. Heat Transfer Research , 42
(2), 101-142.
Xu, P., Yu, B., Qiu, S., Poh, H. J., & Mujumdar, A. S. (2010). Turbulent impinging jet heat transfer
enhancement due to intermittent pulsation. International Journal of Thermal Sciences , 49 (7), 1247-
1252.
Y, L., J, Z., S, T., E, S., & S, X. (2009). A review on development of nanofluid preparation and
characterization. Powder Technology , 196 (2), 89-101.
Yang, J., Chow, L. C., & Pais, M. R. (1996). Nucleate boiling heat transfer in spray cooling. Journal of
Heat Transfer , 118 (3), 668-671.
Zhou, J., Wang, Y., Middelberg, G., & Herwig, H. (2009). Unsteady jet impingement: Heat transfer on
smooth and non-smooth surfaces. International Communications in Heat and Mass Transfer , 36 (2),
103-110.