Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ManagementofStiffHand AnOTPerspective
ManagementofStiffHand AnOTPerspective
net/publication/10892490
CITATIONS READS
78 831
1 author:
Josephine Wong
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University
10 PUBLICATIONS 435 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Josephine Wong on 16 December 2022.
Josephine M. W. Wong
Department of Occupational Therapy, Prince of Wales Hospital, Shatin, New Territories, Hong Kong
ABSTRACT
Joint stiffness, resulting from a variety of complications after hand injuries, remains a common problem. Prolonged swelling,
scar formation and shortening of soft tissue after prolonged period of immobilisation are the major causes leading to the loss
of joint range of motion. Treatment used to improve the joint stiffness should be integrative and problem-focused. Pressure
therapy, active and passive mobilisation through remedial activities and corrective splinting should be started as soon as problems
arise. Applying low-load stress through prolonged periods of time onto the shortened tissue at its maximum tolerable range is
the main principle in restoration of passive joint range of motion. The greater the joint limitation becomes, the longer the time
the splint should be applied. Therapists should understand the process of tissue healing and different functions of splints before
a correct and effective splint can be prescribed properly.
Correspondence to: Ms. Josephine M. W. Wong, Occupational Therapist, Department of Occupational Therapy, Prince of Wales Hospital, Shatin, New Territories, Hong Kong,
Tel: (+852) 2632-3236, Fax: (+852) 2648-4132, E-mail: pwhjoe@netvigator.com
261
contiguous tissues may also result in the formation of adhesion MCP Joint Extension Contracture (Fig. 1)
that limits tendon excursion.13 Conditions are much worse when As the collateral ligaments of the MCP joint are eccentrically
the tendon injury is complicated by bone fractures at the same placed, coupled with the configuration of the metacarpal head,
site. Tendons may be adhered to the non-yielding fracture callus, the collateral ligaments are lax with the joint in full extension and
further reducing the amount of possible active motion and tight with the joint in flexion.13 Usually injury or prolonged edema
restricting the passive range of movement. It is not uncommon to around the joint will lead to deposition of the collagen fibres
find that extensor tendon injury at zone IV with proximal phalanx around the ligaments in their slacken positions allowing them to
fracture will result in decreased range of flexion and extension of shorten and contract. The flexion range will be decreased
the proximal interphalangeal (PIP) joint. The repaired tendon progressively. Moreover, direct trauma to the joint or extensor
was adhered to the fractured site. Similar conditions can be seen tendons, joint immobilisation in a more extended position as well
on the palmar side when flexor tendon is adhered and it limits as patients’ not using their hands due to pain can cause thickening
either the active flexion or extension of the finger joint. of the dorsal joint capsules, scar formation of the dorsal skin,
A prolonged period of immobilisation is another contributing and obliteration of the palmar synovial pouch.
factor of joint stiffness. Peacock11 demonstrated on a canine
model that joint stiffness was the by-product of a period of
immobilisation following trauma. He also showed that the primary PIP Joint Flexion Contracture (Fig. 2)
tissue involved in joint stiffness was the periarticular connective It is one of the most common complications of trauma including
tissue — specifically, the ligament and capsule that were placed tendon injuries, fractures, and soft tissue injuries such as post-
in a shortened position during the period of immobilisation. Apart joint dislocation ligamentous lesions. Chronic edema and
from this, any pressure point produced by the dressing or cast immobilisation always put the joint in a flexed position, with
can also lead to edema and swelling of the injured or subsequent contracture of the palmer volar plate of the capsular
postoperative hand.8 Therefore, a properly fitted cotton dressing ligament, and the adherence of the collateral ligaments. Flexor
is preferred. Most of the time, the muscles may become involved tendon adhesions and palmer skin scarring also play important
and the resulting myostatic contraction may occur due to roles in contributing to joint stiffness.8
prolonged immobilisation.13 It happens when the tension within
a skeletal muscle is completely removed for a period of time,
and the muscle belly is shortened at this retracted length. If the PIP Joint Extension Contracture
muscle is kept shortened for a certain period of time, to restore Limitation of flexion of the PIP joint may be due to the impaired
it to its original length may become difficult. Extreme stress may anatomical structures in the finger after dorsal skin laceration or
lead to damage of muscle fibres. direct trauma to the joint. These structures include (1) scarring
To minimise the severity of complications led by tendon of the dorsal skin and joint capsule, (2) adherence of the central
adhesions and to prevent further joint stiffness, efforts including extensor tendon, (3) contracted interosseous muscle or adherent
early joint motion through active and passive mobilisation interosseous tendon, and (4) contracted capsular ligament,
programmes and serial splinting are indispensable. The ultimate particularly the collateral ligament. The consequent immobilisation
goal is to provide beneficial biological effect on adhesion may also contribute to the resulting joint stiffness.8
formation around the healing tissues and their adjacent structures.
“movable” pitting edema (Fig. 4) can be felt to “give way” when to reduce edema. Elevation of the involved limb above the heart
direct pressure is applied by the finger tips over the edematous level can facilitate the flow of the edematous fluid from distal to
area, making the finger and hand “tight and full”. The joint proximal parts of the body.8 Gentle active mobilisation activities
appears inflamed and swollen, and the passive range is limited by should be given to guide patients to flex and extend their involved
the tension created by the edema but creating a soft feel to the limbs within their pain tolerance, thereby gradually pumping away
end range. “Fibrotic” edema is usually a by-product of chronic the “extra fluid” that originally fills up the space. Massage to the
edema. Swelling no longer dominates over the fingers and hand, hand should be used frequently: both distal-to-proximal massage
rather, edema has been replaced by adhesion, and the fibrosis is to reduce edema, and local massage to the deep layers of tissues
limiting the gliding of the tissue. The mobility of the tissue is in the hand to stimulate blood flow and increase mobility of the
hence limited, and the passive motion of the joint becomes tight.5 tissue layers.5 Compression on the edematous site with elastic
Elevation, active mobilisation of involved joints as well as the bandage or pressure garment can effectively reduce edema.
adjacent uninvolved joint, manual massage and compression by Constant pressure has to be ensured at individual wrap during
elastic wraps or pressure garment can effectively reduce the acute the application of elastic bandage to avoid uneven distribution of
pitting edema. Patients should be instructed clearly that the pressure over the involved limb or fingers. Tailor-made pressure
combination of all these methods make up the most efficient way garment can provide gentle and circumferential pressure which
(a) (b)
Fig. 5 Compression techniques through gentle and circumferential pressure can help to reduce edema. (a) Cotton type elastic finger stall over the middle
finger and the elastic self-adhesive bandage over the index finger. (b) Pressure garment over the fingers and hand.
by using total contact plaster casts to hold the partially corrected Static splint is the one molded and applied directly onto the
position for a week or so … I hoped that the improvement gained hand to maintain the tissues in one position. It immobilises one
by moderate correction at the beginning of the week would loosen or more joints; (1) support the healing tissue at the initial stage
up and allow further improvement that would be maintained by after injury or surgery, (2) relieve pain and provide rest to
the next cast …”.4 No joint should be passively flexed without inflamed tissues, and (3) maintain tissue length to prevent
accompanying traction to the joint, allowing room for one joint contractures.10 It may be removed periodically for short periods
surface to glide over the other without friction. One prolonged for specific exercises. It is usually used during the inflammatory
hold will allow the motion to be repeated actively and more stage of tissue healing when the inflamed tissue needs to rest by
effectively than many repeated quick stretches. It is best illustrated immobilisation. Application of stress by splint at this stage should
by the place and hold exercise of the flexor tendon programme. be minimal depending on the specific injury or surgical
Therapists first place the involved finger(s) into maximum flexion, procedure.
usually in touch-palm position, and are followed by patients’ active Serial static splint is similar to the static splint, i.e. it is molded
hold of the fingers in the same place for a prolonged period, in a stationary position. Apart from its function in providing
attempting to restore the maximum gliding of the flexor tendon support to the healing tissue, it can also be applied to correct
to achieve finger flexion at their maximum length. After several contractures and improve the passive range of motion of the joint
attempts, patients will find improvement in finger flexion which is by applying a gentle, prolonged stretch to promote growth of
more effective than quick and forceful stretches. contracted soft tissues.10 With the tissue being stretched at its
maximum tolerable length, the splint has to be worn for longer
periods of time so that the tissue adapts to the new position. After
Splinting the healing tissue adapts the position of the old splint, the old
(1) Types of splints and their application splint is re-molded or a new splint is applied to hold the tissue
in the different phases of tissue healing at its new maximum length. These serial adjustments of the splint
position upgrade the length of the tissue to its maximum length
Before we can decide on the appropriate splint to be applied on
regaining joint motion. Serial static splints can be applied
patients’ hands, different functions of each type of splint should
throughout all stages of tissue healing because of its ability to
be understood. Moreover, in order to facilitate tissue healing and
both rest tissues and gain motion effectively.
preserve motion, splints of different designs can provide different
Dynamic splint applies a passive pulling force to a specific
amount of “stress”, which is needed by the tissues in order to
joint in one direction while permitting active motion in the
induce remodelling of the scar tissue at different stages of wound
opposite direction, using energy-storing materials such as
healing.6 In other words, biological stages of tissue healing help
theraband, rubber band, springs and spring wire10 (Fig. 9). It
define the different types of splint design5 (Fig. 8).
Dynamic Splinting
Static Splinting
Fig. 8 Different types of splints and their combinations are effective in Fig. 9 A dynamic PIP joint extension splint effectively restores the extension
different stages of healing process. of the PIP joint.
in elongation of the elastic elements of various tissues.3 Splints increasing joint torque. Or, to position the joint by “feel”, i.e. to
are applied to provide low-load prolonged stress — a mechanical the position that patients feel slight resistance.12
stimulus that causes the scar to biologically re-model into a form It is important to explain carefully the concept of low-load
conducive to motion.12 As what Arem and Madden1 had stated in prolonged stress to patients in order to avoid overstress to the
1976, living tissue, including scar, will re-organise and change in tissue. They should understand that the use of too much tension
response to stress. The stress stimulus of tension triggers an will not increase passive range of motion faster. Rather, high force
increase in the length of the tissue. Either static or dynamic splints will re-injure the tissue, producing more scars and increasing
are designed to maximise the amount of stress applied to the the time before the joint moves.
offending scar while minimising damage to normal hand tissues.14 As the static progressive splint allows patients to control the
The application of stress to injured hand tissues should be directed tension by themselves, the amount of adjustment and the timing
towards minimising the inflammatory response and maximising of adjusting the inelastic component of the splint should be
the biological re-organisational response. The force applied should explained clearly. It must be pain free and able to maintain the
be small and constant within a given period of time. As what maximum tolerable length of the tissue at the longest period of
Light et al. reported in 1984, low-load prolonged stretch was time in order to improve the passive range of the joint more
more effective than high-load brief stretch in the treatment of stiff quickly. According to Schultz-Johnson’s clinical experience,
knees in human subjects. Based on the data reported from Light patients with contracted joints that have a soft end-feel may wear
et al., together with the results derived from their study in 1994, the splint for three to four hours a day and obtain rapid positive
Flowers and LaStayo found that increase in passive range of motion results. However, patients with well-developed hard end-feel
in stiff joints is directly proportional to the time the joint is held contracture may need to wear the splint for the whole day and
at the end range. This further supports Brand’s concept that the remove it only for hygiene.12
tissue will grow after it is held in a moderately lengthened position
for a significant time.2 Therefore, the key elements in increasing
passive range of motion are high time doses of low-load stress SUMMARY
adequate to position the shortened tissue at or near the end Stiff hand is an unwanted but common consequence of a variety
of its currently available length.12 of complications after injuries. It is evident when the trauma is so
severe that the biological responses of the injured tissue become
difficult to manage. Sometimes, minor trauma to the involved
A Static Progressive Splinting Regime in finger can also result in stiff joints if the patients are extremely
Managing Chronic Stiff Joints withdrawn and cannot manage due to some psychological worries.
To design a splinting regime is a mutual agreement between the Therefore, to manage the stiff finger joints or hand is not only a
therapist and the patient. The therapist should understand clearly matter of “competition between the pace of prioritised treatment
the patient’s conditions, including acuteness of injury, time since and the growth of scar tissues, but it is also a matter of
surgery or trauma, stage of wound healing, pain tolerance, psychological reassurance to the patients, and the close relation-
sensation, general health status, cognitive status as well as ship between the therapist and patient as a whole.”
motivation before the splint is fabricated. The patient should also Intermittent regimes of active and passive mobilisation together
be clear about their conditions and the goal of the splinting with the application of splinting seem to be the vital measures.
programme. Unless the swelling of the hand and fingers are under control,
Initially, the patient may wear the splint for a brief trial period beneficial effects from mobilisation and splinting can hardly be
to decide on the tolerance. In the meantime, the therapist should maximised. In order to watch for joints stiffening, patients’
focus on the patient’s feedback on the fit of splint, line of pull as progress should be well documented and regularly reviewed.
well as amount of tension. The duration of splint compliance may Objective review such as the range of motion and the severity
become progressively extended once the patient can tolerate well. of swelling, especially during the acute phase, provides the
As a general guideline, the splint might position the joint information on how fingers respond to gentle active mobilisation
approximately 5° beyond readily available end range, which means programme and swelling control measures. However, only manual
the range of motion that is easily achieved without dramatically manipulation of the involved joint(s) gives the clearest feedback,
thus indicating the need for passive stretching and splint applica- 4. Brand, PW. Lessons from hot feet: A note on tissue remodeling. J Hand
tion. Choice of splinting should be problem-focused at different Ther 2002; 15(2): 133–135.
5. Colditz, JC. Therapist’s management of the stiff hand. In: Hunter JM,
stages of tissue healing. Alternative day and night splints can
Mackin EJ, Callahan AD. Rehabilitation of the Hand: Surgery and
maximise the work done for the whole integrative mobilisation Therapy, 4th ed. USA: Mosby, 1995.
and splinting programme. The more the joints become stiff, the 6. Fess EE, Philips CA. Hand Splinting — Principles and Methods. USA:
longer the time the tissues should spend at their end ranges C.V. Mosby Company, 1987.
through static progressive splints in order to improve the passive 7. Flowers KR, LaStayo P. Effects of total end-range time on improving
range of joint motion.7 Apart from these, accurate judgments, passive range of motion. J Hand Ther 1994; 7(3): 150–157.
8. Innis PC, Clark GL, Curtis RM. Management of the stiff hand. In: Hunter
flexible attitude as well as prompt actions are needed to tailor
JM, Mackin EJ, Callahan AD. Rehabilitation of the Hand: Surgery and
make the specially designed treatment programme to every Therapy, 4th ed. USA: Mosby, 1995.
individual patient. Moreover, good communication between 9. Light K, Nuzik S, Personius W. Low-load prolonged stretch vs. high-load
therapist and surgeons as well as between therapist and patients brief stretch in treating knee contractures. Phys Ther 1984; 64:
are important to ensure the best efficacy of treatment. It is logical 330–333.
to modify any treatment plan when patients’ conditions are not 10. McKee P, Morgan L. Orthotics in Rehabilitation: Splinting the Hand
and Body. Philadelphia: F.A. Davis Company, 1998.
improving well and contingent actions have to be made in order
11. Peacock EE Jr. Some biomechanical and biophysical aspects of joint
to restore the best results. stiffness. Ann Surg 1966; 164: 1–12.
12. Schultz-Johnson K. Static progressive splinting. J Hand Ther, 2002;
15(2): 163–178.
References 13. Strickland JW. Biologic basis for hand splinting. In: Fess EE, Philips CA.
1. Arem A, Madden J. Effects of stress on healing wounds: Intermittent Hand Splinting — Principles and Methods. USA: C.V. Mosby Company,
noncyclical tension. J Surg Res 1976; 20: 93–102. 1987.
2. Brand PW. Clinical Mechanics of the Hand. St. Louis, MO: Mosby, 1993. 14. Weeks PM, Wray RC. The management of acute hand injuries: A
3. Brand, PW. The forces of dynamic splinting: Ten questions before biological approach. In: Fess EE, Philips CA. Hand Splinting —
applying a dynamic splint to the hand. In: Hunter JM, Mackin EJ, Principles and Methods. USA: C.V. Mosby Company, 1987.
Callahan AD. Rehabilitation of the Hand: Surgery and Therapy,
4th ed. USA: Mosby, 1995.