Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Philpott 2013 Moving Grief Exploring DanceMovement Therapists
Philpott 2013 Moving Grief Exploring DanceMovement Therapists
DOI 10.1007/s10465-013-9158-x
Ellen Philpott
Introduction
E. Philpott (&)
Dance/Movement Therapy, Somatic Counseling Psychology, Naropa University, Boulder, CO, USA
e-mail: ephilpott@students.naropa.edu
123
Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168 143
123
144 Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168
participants and then developed into conversations that were guided and informed
by the researcher’s proposal to gather an initial understanding about how dance/
movement therapists work with children and grief. Questions delved into areas of
the participants’ experiences and interventions, competencies that they feel may be
unique to working with children and/or grief, and the concept of empathy.
Major themes from the transcribed interviews were extracted through a multi-
step coding process. The results from this study highlight the nascent understanding
of how dance/movement therapists may use their own body-based knowledge and
clinical DMT skills to provide a safe therapeutic environment that may offer
important outlets for expression and possible healing for the grieving child.
Literature Review
The literature for this study is grouped into themes based on contributions from grief
studies, grief counseling, creative arts therapies, and DMT. The first theme explores
universal stages and the individual experiences of grieving populations. Next,
research is grouped based on theories and applications of therapeutic work and
counseling with grieving populations, particularly children. Additionally, further
research findings illustrate how the process of grief may have somatic symptoms.
Finally, the limited amount of DMT research that relates to grief suggests that the
body and its experiences are often overlooked as important sources of knowledge.
This researcher constructs her questions around how the process of children’s
grieving may be further understood and supported by exploring possible DMT
applications.
123
Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168 145
Additionally, Doughty (as cited in Shallcross, 2012) noted that when therapists
incorporated interventions from stage models of grief, clients often fixated on fitting
into a particular experience or tried to find an end point to their grieving; neither
option allowed for their own natural processes. Doughty (2009) conducted research
that evaluated Martin and Doka’s (2000) concept of adaptive grieving styles. Using
the Delphi method, a systematic process that seeks a consensus of opinion from a
panel of experts, Doughty found agreement that supports the use of adaptive
grieving styles. This style affirms:
There are multiple factors that influence the grieving process (i.e., culture,
personality, and gender), that most bereaved individuals use both cognitive
and affective strategies in adapting to bereavement, and that bereaved
individuals experience both internal and external pressures to grieve in
particular ways. (Doughty, 2009, p. 462).
Thus, the newer model of adaptive grieving styles may support Konigsberg’s (2011)
suggestion that humans actually have a need, and are well equipped, to overcome
loss through individual expression. She further notes, ‘‘Humans have an innate
resilience,’’ (Konigsberg, 2011, p. 1) possibly affirming the notion that healing may
come from a deeper, instinctive place.
Bereaved children and adults may go through similar stages of grief, however, it can
be exceptionally challenging for children to find satisfying expressions of their
feelings surrounding the loss of a loved one (Freeman, 2005; Rando, 1988). Hensley
and Clayton (2008) note that, ‘‘A child’s developmental stage plays a major role in
how a child reacts to the loss of a loved one’’ (p. 653). Depending on their age and
development, children may react to grief through new behaviors, including
confusion and defiance, because they may not yet have the cognitive and verbal
skills to process their emotions with another (Freeman, 2005; Sood, Razdan, Weller,
& Weller, 2006).
Additionally, children may grieve intermittently because they ‘‘must be certain
that their physical and emotional needs are going to be met before they can give into
their grief’’ (Rando, 1988, p. 201). Studies show that children need to be given
opportunities for play, where themes of their grieving process can emerge
organically with non-verbal expression and the use of metaphor (Doka & Tucci,
2008; Freeman, 2005; Rando, 1988; Webb, 2003). In their research of healing
among bereaved populations, Bonanno and Mancini (2008) define resilience as the
ability to ‘‘maintain relatively stable, healthy levels of psychological and physical
functioning, as well as the capacity for generative experiences and positive
emotions’’ (p. 371). These two researchers reported a 50 % resiliency rate among
the studied adults who experienced a death loss, and they called attention to the need
to extend and apply resiliency definitions and models to grieving children.
In the Harvard Child Bereavement Study, Worden and Silverman (1996)
conducted longitudinal research with a group of 125 children, ages 6–17, in their
natural course of bereavement at 3, 13, and 25 months after the death loss of a
123
146 Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168
parent. The study measured their ‘‘wellness’’ in comparison with control groups of
non-bereaved children, using extensive diagnostic tests to assess behavioral/
emotional problems, self-efficacy, self-esteem, and their understanding of death at
the various intervals. Based on these quantitative results, the study found that
children who were coping well after 2 years had more cohesive family structure,
could communicate about their dead parent with ease, and ‘‘came from families that
tended to cope actively rather than passively and that could reframe and find
something positive in the difficult situation’’ (Worden, 2008, p. 126). Interestingly,
the study did not define ‘‘active’’ and ‘‘passive’’ coping skills. Instead Worden
(2008) suggested the benefits of active coping because it ‘‘helped the children
experience higher levels of self-efficacy and believe that they could affect what was
happening in their lives’’ (p. 126). Worden (2009) also emphasized ‘‘childhood grief
is best facilitated in the presence of a consistent adult who is able to meet the child’s
needs and help the child express feelings about the loss’’ (p. 233). From the
assertions within Worden’s multiple writings, it might be concluded that ‘‘active’’
coping skills may allow for expression of feelings and the growth of self-efficacy,
with the presence of a consistent adult in support of these needs. In their summary of
research that has offered bereavement counselors suggestions for working with
grieving children, Haine, Ayers, Sandler, and Wolchik (2008) affirmed this
assertion, ‘‘Children’s use of active coping strategies and possession of high levels
of coping efficacy have been associated with positive outcomes following the death
of a parent’’ (p. 147). The researchers name some active coping interventions as
‘‘problem-solving,’’ ‘‘positive reframing,’’ and ‘‘support-seeking’’ (Haine et al.,
2008, p. 147). Thus, it is apparent that many studies highlight the importance of
‘‘active’’ interventions to support grieving children, however, none highlight the use
of movement as a potential outlet of expression for grieving children. Yet, theory
does support the larger umbrella of creative arts therapies as active interventions,
which offer tools for self-expression and self-efficacy among grieving children.
The individual expression that the model of adaptive grieving styles supports, in
addition to providing children opportunities to play, along with offering support for
resiliency through generative experiences and positive emotions, may possibly be
found in the application of creative arts therapies with grieving children. Scientific
studies correlating the possible benefits of creative arts therapies with grieving
children are extremely limited; however, theory and case studies highlight how
these active applications may be supportive.
Fischman (2009) writes about DMT as an ‘‘enactive approach,’’ suggesting,
‘‘individuals know the world through their own actions’’ (p. 35). Additionally, art
therapist Cathy Malchiodi (2008) writes that creative interventions with grieving
children offer many benefits, including ‘‘pleasure in making, doing, and inventing;
play and imagination; and enhancement of self-worth through self-expression’’
(p. 19). Additionally, Malchiodi suggests that creative expression supports
containment and control with traumatic material, through ‘‘active’’ participation
in therapy. Also, in addressing what theorists have written about grieving children
123
Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168 147
needing different outlets for expression of their feelings, rather than just
verbalization, Malchiodi (2008) notes, ‘‘art, play, music, or movement can provide
the necessary means to reenact the feelings and sensations associated with traumatic
experiences’’ (p. 19). In her own case studies and personal experience, Webb (2003)
notes that creative arts therapies have rationale in working with grieving children
because ‘‘feelings are often released more readily in non-verbal form’’ (p. 406).
Additionally, in Peng’s (2010) case study with a child who lost loved ones in an
earthquake, she found that ‘‘through the utilization of expressive materials, children
may reveal their inherent thoughts and feelings, learn to deal with terrible emotions,
find solutions to their concerns, and then activate the healing process’’ (‘‘The
application of expressive art materials,’’ para. 1).
Within active interventions one important concept mentioned earlier is the
inclusion of a consistent adult who can support a grieving child’s self-expression
and needs. Typically, this might include a surviving parent or caregiver, but it is also
important to note how practitioners working with grieving children can offer their
own active interventions through the empathic therapeutic relationship.
123
148 Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168
and psychotic patients at St. Elizabeth’s Hospital beginning in the 1940s. She
introduced the therapeutic concepts of mirroring and movement in a circle, creating
‘‘sensitive awareness of the symbolic movement expressions that were offered and
to which there was validation and response’’ (Chaiklin, 2009, p. 7). Wittig and
Davis (2012) noted, ‘‘One way that we support a deeper entering and greater
intimacy in the group is through the use of Chacian circles,’’ and that the ‘‘use of
mirroring as a way of making relationship in improvisational movement groups
provides opportunities for individual group members to have a sense of belonging to
the group’’ (pp. 169–170).
The concept of kinesthetic empathy has also been discussed as a primary and
active component of DMT. For instance, Levy (2005) defines kinesthetic empathy
as the ‘‘therapists’ awareness of their emotional reactions to a client’’ (p. 182).
Fischman (2009) adds to this idea:
Kinesthetic empathy is a form of knowledge, of contact and shared
construction that may take many forms. It might appear through direct
mirroring and affective attunement in the dance therapist’s movements…. It
might also make use of analogy, metaphor, the telling of…story with the
movement or the patient’s verbalization (p. 48).
A dance/movement therapist’s emotional reactions to a client, as well as the active
tools which promote understanding in the therapeutic environment, can be described
as ‘‘kinesthetic,’’ possibly because they are happening consciously with awareness
of one’s bodily experience. Again Fischman (2009) notes, ‘‘The dance therapist gets
empathically involved in an intersubjective experience that is rooted in the body’’
(p. 34).
In addition, as dance/movement therapists mirror clients’ affects, they also take
active roles as witnesses. In her description of the practice of Authentic Movement,
Janet Adler (2009) suggests, ‘‘The attitude of the witness toward the mover is
nurturing, protective, empathic, and parental at times. The witness honors the
mover’s dependency on her and understands its value…sharing can reduce tension
and expand the understanding of both people’’ (p. 147). Fischman (2009) also
affirms the emotional expression of clients that is supported through this role of
witnessing: ‘‘The dance/movement therapist in the role of an observer who
participates, becomes the necessary relationship within which new emotional
experiences can develop in a safe environment of respect and trust’’ (p. 40). With
the possibility that DMT is an active intervention that may support grieving
children’s needs, it is also valuable to take note of what may be happening on a
bodily level for children who have lost a loved one due to death.
In addition to the studies that point to the need for emotional expression of grief, a
multitude of research also highlights somatic symptoms as a part of the grieving
process. Lieberman and Jacobs (1987) offer that ‘‘normal’’ grief includes somatic
symptoms, while ‘‘pathological’’ grief can involve changes in immune functions as
well as dysfunction within the autonomic nervous system (p. 23). Talbot (2001)
123
Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168 149
123
150 Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168
Research on grief in the field of DMT is limited, and does not directly illuminate the
needs of bereaved children and specific interventions used to support their
processes. However, in their qualitative pilot study dance/movement therapists
Dillenbeck and Hammond-Meiers (2009) found themes relating to the needs,
experiences, and understanding of people who are dying and their caretakers. This
research may provide insight for how dance/movement therapists can work with
grieving children. One key factor in their article explains that while the body is often
a ‘‘focal point’’ in palliative care, ‘‘caretakers commented on how little discussion
takes place pertaining directly to the experience of the body’’ (Dillenbeck &
Hammond-Meiers, 2009, p. 105). Yet, the authors do offer suggestions for
prompting support and expression of the grieving process for both dance/movement
therapists and a grieving client. Interventions used in their study that may also apply
to grieving children included: witnessing the experiences of the clients to help ease
their burdens, using active imagination and fantasy to work with repressed
emotions, educating individuals on acceptance of their bodily experiences, and
using a variety of movement techniques and styles to support ‘‘new ways of being in
the world’’ (Dillenbeck & Hammond-Meiers, 2009, p. 109). The study also notes
how a dance/movement therapist who is ‘‘comfortable with her own expression and
exploration’’ around themes of ‘‘grief, loss, death, and dying is better equipped’’ to
work with clients who are themselves working with these concepts (Dillenbeck &
Hammond-Meiers, 2009, p. 110).
Another study by dance/movement therapist Callahan (2011) focused on parents
who were grieving the death loss of a child. The researcher established a DMT
group with bereaved parents, and then created a performance based on themes that
arose throughout the process. The author noted that some of the interventions within
the group included breathing exercises, writing letters to the person who died, acting
out narratives, enhancing symbolic thinking, as well as drawing, and then walking,
along a grief pathway. Callahan (2011) also recognized the value of group members
witnessing the final performance, as it allowed their internal experiences to be
outwardly expressed. Additionally, the author noted that these interventions allowed
for expression of feelings that are normally repressed on a larger societal scale.
DMT literature does not mention specific applications in working with grieving
children; thus, there is need for this research. The experience of the body and the
awareness one brings to the body may indeed affect one’s ability to express
emotions throughout the grieving process. As the research above suggests, grief has
somatic resonance, and expression of these feelings and sensations may be valuable
for the healing process. However, few studies explore the interventions that have the
potential to support children as they cope with the loss of a loved one. Having a
greater understanding of these factors can be seen as important to the field of DMT
and with grief work as well, as it may support children grieving the death loss of a
123
Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168 151
loved one—and possibly extend to other populations—to trust, and refine, their
innate expression and bodily capacity to heal.
Methods
Participants
Convenience sampling was identified as the most effective tool for recruitment and
choosing of participants, because the researcher found during the process that the
number of dance/movement therapists working with grieving children on a regular
basis is limited. The researcher chose three participants with whom to conduct the
interviews, based on their experience as dance/movement therapists, and the criteria
that they have worked with populations of grieving children. All three participants
identified as female, and range in age from their late 20’s to late 50’s. Two
participants confirmed their racial identity as Caucasian, and one as Hispanic. The
participants have worked with grieving children either individually or in groups at
specialized grief camps, in psychiatric settings, in community health agencies,
through hospice organizations, in private practice, or a combination of the above.
Procedure
Each participant answered a series of questions lasting from 45 to 60 min (see Table 2
in the Appendix for interview questions). After the demographics at the onset of the
interview, questions led the participant toward recalling significant experiences
from her work with grieving children, as well as speaking about clinical
interventions implemented, and how she chose those interventions. Other questions
asked the participant to share skills she thought might be necessary in working
specifically with children, and with grief, as a dance/movement therapist. Each
interview closed by bringing more attention to the nature of the therapeutic
relationship in grief counseling, in addition to what might be most important for
dance/movement therapists and other clinicians to know, as a way to foster greater
understanding and improved clinical skill when working with populations of
grieving children. While each question was set, but there was allowance for natural
conversation and inquiry to arise between the researcher and participants.
123
152 Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168
Each interview took place either over the phone or through Skype, and was audio
and video recorded. All interviews were then transcribed, read exhaustively, and
coded through a multi-layered process that included: brief attribute coding, to gather
demographics; in vivo coding, to organize direct quotes; descriptive coding, to
summarize main themes and ideas from passages within the text; and finally,
affective coding, to allow for investigation of the subjective human experience that
gives direct acknowledgment to the feelings participants may have experienced
(Sadalña, 2009). This researcher also used analytic memo writing to reflect on how
she personally related to the process of interviewing and coding, as a way of
tracking her own biases and subjective experience. Through the process of coding
and memo writing, categories were grouped into major themes that speak to dance/
movement therapists’ experiences and interventions when working with grieving
children. The results from this study attempt to offer plausible models for
supporting grieving children, as well as further developing the fields of DMT and
grief studies.
Results
Through the collection of results from the three participants’ interviews, four major
categories were garnered with eight total themes nested within, creating a nascent
understanding of the proposed research questions:
• What are dance/movement therapists’ experiences in their work with grieving
children?
• How do these experiences inform their clinical interventions with grieving
children?
Figure 1 illustrates how the four categories build upon one another: weaving the
experiences of the (1) Dance/Movement Therapist and the (2) Grieving Child into a
(3) Dynamic of Togetherness, which may further support (4) Moving Grief
Approaches that utilize DMT interventions and are informed by these experiences.
Eight themes most prevalent from all three interviews are highlighted and connected
to the participants’ experiences as dance/movement therapists and the interventions
that they use when working with populations of grieving children. While each
category and theme is interrelated and addresses both research questions, results are
structured to emphasize how categories one and two coincide mostly with the first
research question, while categories three and four brings greater illumination to the
second research question. (See Table 1 for an entire summary of results, grouped by
categories, themes, and sub-themes.)
The first category begins to offer a response to the first research question: What are
dance/movement therapists’ experiences in their work with grieving children? As
the researcher compiled themes from interviews that were most frequently reported,
it became clear that dance/movement therapists’ own experiences in their work with
123
Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168 153
Fig. 1 Four emergent categories and eight nested themes, compiled from interviews with three dance/
movement therapists who work with grieving children
grieving children comprised the first two out of eight total themes. The first theme
included the participants noticing their own emotional and somatic responses to
their work with grieving children. The second theme was generated from how the
participants navigate the countertransference that arises from their emotional and
somatic responses.
The word most often used when participants spoke about their emotional and somatic
response when working with populations of grieving children was heart. The heart
seems to carry the metaphor of an integral informant to this work, not only because of
what the participants feel in the moment through their hearts, but also how they
mention its capacity for transforming the experience of grief within themselves and
their clients. One therapist remarked, ‘‘The whole basis for my work with these kids is
the heart,’’ while another responded, ‘‘What I feel in my heart in that moment is
always informing me.’’ One participant stated that ‘‘To go forward, it’s through the
heart,’’ because it ‘‘connects the past and the future.’’ Two participants also relayed
that working with this population can be heart-breaking and heart-wrenching.
Other responses that the participants spoke about when working with this
population included how they are moved and touched by the children’s stories and
expressions of grief in deep, profound, powerful, and beautiful ways. One participant
discussed and validated her own terror, fear, and stress when walking into unknown
situations in her work, because it possibly mirrors what these children might be
experiencing when they have recently lost a loved one to death. She commented,
‘‘Yes, I’m scared, maybe I don’t know what to say, maybe I don’t know what to do.’’
Two participants also mentioned some of their personal experiences with grief
and relayed that they are actively invested in reflecting on their own emotions
throughout the process, because it informs their work with clients. One participant
123
154 Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168
123
Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168 155
Table 1 continued
commented, ‘‘I think relying on your own personal experience with grief is
invaluable with this population.’’
123
156 Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168
[intervention] is too much, or too soon, or too little, or not enough. And, you
can be better present with the client.
One of the participants also explained that to work with her own countertransference
requires focus, discipline, and experience, ‘‘in a way of being able to leave everything
else at the door and just really be there, with [the grieving children], and embrace that,
accept that, in myself too.’’ The third participant remarked, ‘‘In the moment I really
am routinely checking in with myself and noticing how I’m feeling in response to the
work we’re doing.’’ One participant summarized the value of her own countertrans-
ference awareness well, stating, ‘‘If you don’t tap into what you’re feeling on your
body level, you are missing out on all this information. It is an invaluable way of
gathering information that will ultimately inform what you’re gonna do.’’
All three participants named that their observations of children’s feelings and
expressions, as well as how children reflect on their memories and relationship to
the person who died, are some of the most significant experiences they recall in their
work as dance/movement therapists with grieving children. These responses led to
the grouping of two major themes relevant to the category of the Grieving Child.
When asked what felt significant in their work with this population, two participants
noted the qualities of openness and honesty that grieving children exhibited. Another
participant noted children’s sincerity and risk-taking as well as their availability of
feelings in how they moved and spoke about their experiences. Other words the
therapists used frequently when describing what they witnessed within the children’s
sessions were vulnerability, guilt, sadness, despair, struggle, pain, and anger.
One participant spoke about working with children specifically in the grieving
process: ‘‘This feels different than other kinds of therapy. I think [how children feel]
is right there. Grief is really this propellant…to get the kids to deeper emotional
spaces than they would normally be in.’’ The other participants also felt, through
witnessing children within this process, that the ‘‘experience of grief is held in the
body.’’ With this in mind, each participant spoke about the importance of witnessing
children playing, and that it is often necessary for children to not only ‘‘express the
experience,’’ but also to ‘‘forget about it and play’’ at times. All participants also
commented on being moved by children’s expressions of eagerness, joy, and trust
with the other group members which came out through their resiliency and ability to
‘‘transform the experience.’’
A large part of the dance/movement therapists’ reflections in their work with this
population included how children remember and express their feelings about loved
ones who died. Throughout the participants’ conversations, five sub-themes were
123
Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168 157
gleaned from children’s expressions of relating to their lost loved one: remembering
and honoring; feelings about that person; telling the story of loss; learning about
mortality and limited amount of time; and deepening into resiliency.
Remembering and Honoring All participants reflected on how they create the
opportunity for children to remember and honor their loved one through dancing.
One participant spoke about this experience becoming a ritual with candles. Another
participant explained that she invites children in her group to imagine dancing with
their loved ones, or dancing similar to how their loved ones would have moved, as a
gift to that special person. Another participant asks her group members, ‘‘Who
would you invite to join us in this circle?’’ She commented that many children want
their loved ones who have died to be a part of their circle. This participant relayed
how she supports the children to engage with their memories, by encouraging them
to tell the group what their loved ones would say if they were in the room.
Overall, the participants named that many children had a sense of their loved
ones being with them or a part of them. One dance/movement therapist reflected that
this remembering and honoring serves as a coping skill for children because they
‘‘experience feeling really happy…and having their feelings of love for that
person.’’ This participant also mentioned that the children could relate emotionally
and cognitively to their memories while being witnessed by a group of other peers
who have gone through a similar experience.
Feelings About that Person Each participant also spoke about the significance of
children having the opportunity to share and be heard in expressions around their
relationship to the person who died. Some children shared feelings of love and pride,
while others grieved their disappointment and sadness about never getting to say
goodbye and ‘‘wanting more opportunities to see them and talk with them.’’ One
participant recalled a memory: a teenager took a risk in front of her peers to share what
she wished she could have said to her loved one. Reflecting on the bravery of the
teenager, the participant noted that it gave her the courage to also self-disclose and
model an ability to become vulnerable as a facilitator, sharing some of her own
feelings surrounding losses in her own life. The participant chose this moment with
attention and care, so that it could support more children to witness and respond,
transferring courage and bravery to one another and building upon the group dynamic.
Telling the Story All three participants mentioned the importance of children
telling or sharing their stories about their loved ones through verbal dialogue,
creative writing, or movement. One participant commented on the children’s
willingness to share their stories, while another said that the children have this
‘‘need to tell.’’ One participant explained that:
Children, depending on their age, may or may not have the words to express
themselves, to tell their stories, to talk about their feelings. And so the work
that we do, just provides them with such rich opportunity to do it in a different
way…to tell their story, really, fully in their bodies.
123
158 Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168
Learning About Mortality and Limited Amount of Time Each of the participants
noted that they are highly aware of the length of their own therapeutic timeframe
with children. Whether this followed the course of anticipatory grieving into a loss,
or was constrained to a one-day camp, participants mentioned how the amount of
time they had with grieving children might trigger anxiety surrounding untimely
death. Each participant spoke about how they relate to timeframes by being in the
moment, naming that ‘‘all we have is this moment,’’ or that ‘‘this might be the only
chance’’ to work with these children in this way. One therapist felt inspired because
of the time-sensitive nature of therapy, affirming, ‘‘Let’s make it count…. Let’s
make it really mean something, because…this child and this family has allowed me
into their lives, so I’m going to really just give it everything I have.’’ Another
participant explained that:
There is such a potential for using [grief work] to serve us in such a wonderful
way, to transform that experience into something positive. And I think when
working with children, with people that hopefully have a long life to live, I
would want to give them an opportunity to feel that. And to know that yes, this
is such hard work, and it’s maybe one of the hardest things that I’ll ever go
through in my life, but I’m gonna really make this count! I’m gonna do
something. This is gonna serve me in the long run.
Each participant noted that they wanted to give the children the opportunity to
transform their experiences, supporting them through modeling and teaching how to
take care of themselves—through awareness of their bodies and emotional
responses—in dire life circumstances.
Resiliency All three participants also commented on the resiliency and transfor-
mation that they witness in children through the support of groups, in how
members care for the relationships and experiences with losing a loved one. One
participant spoke about the importance of ‘‘bringing it back to a place that feels
good to you as a facilitator,’’ to model how to move through the group experience.
Another participant mentioned how the children find hope, courage, and bravery
among the group setting with their peers. She specifically supports them to regain
control and strength by asking them, ‘‘What do you do to feel strong?’’ She also
inquires about the strengths that they can rely on, in further support of how they
can ‘‘find those strengths and feelings in themselves.’’ The third participant
mentioned using humor as a way of relating with the children in their grief,
‘‘giving a way to express it that just feels good, and is empowering, and is
creative.’’ Each participant mentioned that giving children the opportunity to play,
to share happiness, to feel joy, and reflect on good memories allows them to
regain confidence in a situation that may have frequently felt out of control.
Additionally, giving children the opportunity to move through these experiences
with a group of peers and a caring adult that also have their own relationship with
grief, cultivates a willingness to being seen, as well as witnessing others, in the
full range of the grieving experience.
123
Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168 159
The third category begins to offer a response to the second research question how do
dance/movement therapists’ experiences with grieving children inform their clinical
interventions? As dance/movement therapists experience and feel resiliency in the
children they work with, witness the remembrance and honoring of loved ones, and
actively work with their own emotional responses, they are also planning and
offering spontaneous interventions. Each participant commented on the dynamic of
togetherness as a valuable intervention: how the co-creation of the therapeutic
relationship and the structuring of physical and emotional containment provides
necessary tools for children to actively process their grief.
Connection One participant commented that in groups she has run, she introduces
an intervention she refers to as shaping, where she will ‘‘mold [my] body at a
comfortable spatial proximity with [the client].’’ She describes that with shaping,
‘‘it’s how you’re positioning yourself that is making the connection and the
intervention…because it’s really supporting [the child’s] feeling experience.’’ This
participant reflected that this interaction aids in ‘‘creating our own dance of
relating.’’ Another participant explained that in her work with children throughout
the grieving process, she has the opportunity to cultivate a whole relationship
because ‘‘there’s that awareness, there’s that connection, there’s that depth of
feeling between the therapist and the child.’’ The third participant described that
paying attention to the children’s developmental needs and her creative muse
supports her to find an appropriate way to help whomever she is with ‘‘make the
connection of what’s the good intervention here.’’
123
160 Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168
Presence Each participant mentioned the concept of presence several times when
speaking about the therapeutic relationships between themselves and grieving
children. One participant described presence as ‘‘really listening with your whole
body.’’ Another relayed that presence comes with tracking her own bodily
countertransference, so that she can discern how her own responses affect what is
happening in the relational dynamic between herself and the child. Two participants
mentioned how the concept of presence reminds them to not always do something
with clients, but rather to be with the variety of emotions that arise. One participant
explained that this required becoming comfortable with silence, while another
explained that incorporating moments of stillness is an important intervention, to
slow down and rest with the process. Finally, each participant mentioned that
presence requires spontaneity, or a ‘‘way of being real in the moment.’’
123
Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168 161
support to other peers in the group. One participant spoke about the camaraderie and
the community among group members, recognizing that children understand, not
just cognitively but through a bodily experience, that they are not alone in the
grieving process. Children have the opportunity to feel understood when their
movements are mirrored or repeated back by other participants, and when they can
see that other members are moving in ways that they can relate to. Another
participant described that within the group setting there are less inhibitions and
children learn how to ask friends in the circle for help through exercises where they
build their own web of support. Additionally, one of the participants commented
that ‘‘sometimes we don’t even talk about [the grief], and we sort of provide these
experiences that, I believe, help to nourish them.’’
Grouped into two sub-themes, participants spoke about specific activities that they
do with children, including the use of props, specialized movement practices, and
additional creative arts therapies, and ways of being with children, regulating their
own bodies as a teaching tool to encourage children’s integration of the techniques.
Activities The activity that all three participants reported including in their
therapeutic work with grieving children is dancing in honor of the loved one.
Additionally, each therapist spoke about how she includes props, such as scarves,
blankets, and parachutes to allow for greater connection and play among the group
members and the therapist. One participant said that she might rock younger
children in blankets and sing to them, to recreate feelings of containment and
nurturing. Each participant encourages storytelling, whether that is through
movement, art, creative writing, or sand tray therapy. One participant also
structures her adolescent groups to both move and witness one another, bringing
their feelings from an internal space into an external dialogue by directing a group
sculpture or moving a partner in a marionette scenario.
When children are deep in their experiences of grief and it is nearing time for the
session to end, participants spoke about how they often change the qualities and
efforts of the movement organically. Participants achieve these changes by working
actively with breath, as well as introducing structured rhythms as a way to organize
and contain thought and expression. One participant also mentioned using guided
123
162 Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168
relaxation and yoga, including the Warrior Pose, to support the children to feel
simultaneously strong and rested.
123
Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168 163
how the pain might have moved. The participant then encouraged the client to
‘‘move that pain out,’’ so the child could feel capable of working with her emotional
experience. Using this practice of self-regulation, children can learn that their
experiences are valid, that they have the ability to move with it and change, and that
grief itself is not always all-encompassing.
Each participant spoke about the current gap in therapeutic practice between dance/
movement therapists and grieving children, with assertions and a variety of reasons
for why DMT might benefit this population.
Observational Skills First, participants noted the level of expertise that dance/
movement therapists cultivate with non-verbal attunement and observation of
movement patterns. One participant commented about her clients, ‘‘Their feelings
are so available even if they don’t have the words for them. You know, we see it in
their bodies, in their openness.’’ Participants noted that they are continually
observing their clients’ bodies for information, as well as their own.
123
164 Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168
where it’s okay to express their grief without fear of isolation, and where they can
allow for all of the different stages and complexities of this emotion to surface.
The scope and nature of this research serves to present preliminary findings on
three dance/movement therapists’ experiences and applications with grieving
children, thus it is not meant to make any universal assumptions or claims about
how or why a dance/movement therapist should work with this population.
Additionally, while this study may present themes that could support the growth
of DMT and its use with grieving children, it is limited in its sample size. While
recruiting for interviews, the researcher found that the number of dance/
movement therapists working on a regular basis with children grieving the death
loss of a loved one is either incredibly small, or challenging to find. Because of
limited time and resources, the researcher used convenience sampling, and also
had to widen the age range of children initially proposed for this research project.
This study includes conversations with dance/movement therapists who worked
with children ranging from very early childhood, through adolescence, and into
young adulthood. However, from participants’ conversations and reviews of grief
literature, it is evident that children process concepts of death in a multitude of
ways based on their age and developmental needs. The research in this study did
not focus on grouping interventions based on different age ranges of grieving
children.
Future research may offer more substantive evidence through conducting more
aggressive recruitment strategies to work with a larger sample size, or to group
findings into what may support children in different stages of development.
Additionally, further research may be able to present DMT interventions that have
been tested and proven in some way to offer benefit to grieving children. The
researcher also recognizes that the three participants in this study identified as
female; it is important to note that the interventions discussed may be related to
the gendered social constructs of each therapist and the clients they worked with.
Further explorations may offer insight into how women, men, and transgender
therapists experience and work through personal death loss, and how this may
123
Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168 165
affect their clinical work with young children. It may also be important to note
how and why therapists are drawn to this work, evaluating whether personal
experience with death loss may be an important competency for working with
populations of grieving children. Finally, researching different cultural values and
implicit coping skills relating to death, and the effects this has on children, may
offer insight into the therapeutic modalities that may be most supportive for
children from a variety of cultural identities.
Implications
Results from this study illuminate that three dance/movement therapists’ emotional
responses, as well as what they witnessed in their work with grieving children,
informed their clinical choices. Interventions were often in support of cultivating
safe physical and emotional environments where normalizing and honoring the full
range of expressions in children throughout their grieving processes could become
possible. It is also evident that body awareness and compassion, including the
physical and emotional responses of the heart, as well as self-regulation techniques
of breathing and moving in relationship with other group members who have been
through a loss, were key components of the techniques that were passed down from
dance/movement therapist to child. It is possible that the knowledge of mortality, as
experienced on a very profound level by both the participants and grieving children,
influences the dynamic of the therapeutic relationship and the potential for
transforming concepts of loss into moments of healing.
Body psychotherapist Susan Aposhyan (2004) writes, ‘‘When we face death, our
bodies respond. We feel it; we grieve; we move, biologically, if only for a moment,
toward death’’ (p. 260). Within the dynamic of DMT, children may have the
possibility to feel their grief, through movement and full expressions of their bodies’
responses toward death. What might it mean for a dance/movement therapist to
honor children’s embodied understandings of death? Perhaps it could mean the
surrender into moving grief: trusting the vitality of the heart’s empathic resonance
while dancing through the complexity and transformative power of emotion.
Acknowledgments The author wishes to thank The Somatic Counseling Psychology department and
her cohort at Naropa University, Dr. Christine Caldwell, Wendy Allen, Himmat Victoria, Leah D’Abate,
Jason Geoffrion, The Denver Hospice Bereavement team and her clients, and her three participants for
their inspiring words and devotion to this project.
Appendix
See Table 2.
123
166 Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168
DEMOGRAPHICS
1. Within these categories, please share the demographics that you identity with:
- Race
- Ethnicity
- Gender
- Preferred pronoun(s)
- Age range: Under 30, 30-40, 41-50, 51-60, 61-70, 70 and above
3. Describe the setting and type of work you do with grieving children.
5. Have these experiences informed the dance/movement therapy interventions or models have you developed in
your work with grieving children? If so, how? If not, what informs your choices to use specific interventions in
specific situations?
7. Are there any competencies unique to working with grief, as opposed to other emotions, that you feel you need
as a therapist? If so, what do you notice?
EMPATHY
[Ask this question only if participants speak about empathy earlier in the interview]
8. According to literature in grief counseling and dance/movement therapy, the empathic therapeutic relationship
serves as an important part of healing within the grieving process. Based on your experiences as a
dance/movement therapist, is there anything you would like to add regarding this concept and/or how it may or
may not relate to your work with grieving children?
CLOSING REMARKS
9. Is there anything else you would like to add to our conversation today?
References
Adler, J. (2009). Who is the witness? A description of authentic movement. In P. Pallaro (Ed.), Authentic
movement: Essays by Mary Starks Whitehouse, Janet Adler, and Joan Chodorow (pp. 141–159).
London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Aldrich, L. (1995). Sudden death: Crisis in the school. Thanatos: A Realistic Journal Concerning Dying,
Death, & Bereavement, 20(3), 10–11.
American Dance Therapy Association. (2009). About dance/movement therapy. Retrieved March 9, 2013
from http://www.adta.org/About_DMT.
Aposhyan, S. (2004). Body-mind psychotherapy: Principles, techniques, and practical applications. New
York: W.W. Norton & Company.
Balk, D. (2011). Adolescent development and bereavement: An introduction. The Prevention Researcher,
18(3), 3–9.
Berrol, C. F. (2006). Neuroscience meets dance/movement therapy: Mirror neurons, the therapeutic
process and empathy. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 33(4), 302–315.
123
Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168 167
Biondi, M., & Picardi, A. (1996). Clinical and biological aspects of bereavement and loss- induced
depression: A reappraisal. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 65(5), 229–245.
Blos, P. A. (1979). The adolescent passage: Development issues. New York: International Universities.
Bonanno, G. A., & Mancini, A. D. (2008). The human capacity to thrive in the face of potential trauma.
Pediatrics, 121(2), 369–375.
Bugge, K. E., Haugstvedt, K. T. S., Røkholt, E. G., Darbyshire, P., & Helseth, S. (2012). Adolescent
bereavement: Embodied responses, coping and perceptions of a body awareness support
programme. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 21, 2160–2169.
Callahan, A. B. (2011). The parent should go first: A dance/movement therapy exploration in child loss.
American Journal of Dance Therapy, 33, 182–195. doi:10.1007/s10465-011-9117-3.
Center for the Advancement of Health. (2004). Report on bereavement and grief research. Death Studies,
28(6), 491–575.
Chaiklin, S. (2009). We dance from the moment our feet touch the earth. In S. Chaiklin & H. Wengrower
(Eds.), The art and science of dance/movement therapy: Life is dance (pp. 3–11). New York:
Routledge.
deVries, B., Davis, C. G., Wortman, C. B., & Lehman, D. R. (1997). Long-term psychological and
somatic consequences of later life parental bereavement. Omega—Journal of Death and Dying,
35(1), 97–117.
Dillenbeck, M., & Hammond-Meiers, J. A. (2009). Death and dying: Implications for dance/movement
therapy. American Journal of Dance Therapy, 31, 95–121.
Doka, K. J., & Tucci, A. S. (Eds.). (2008). Living with grief: Children and adolescents. Washington, DC:
Hospice Foundation of America.
Doughty, E. A. (2009). Investigating adaptive grieving styles: A delphi study. Death Studies, 33(5),
462–480. doi:10.1080/07481180902805715.
Doughty Horn, E. A., Crews, J. A., & Harrawood, L. K. (2013). Grief and loss education:
Recommendations for curricular inclusion. Counselor Education and Supervision, 52(1), 70–80.
Doughty, E. A., & Hoskins, W. J. (2011). Death education: An internationally relevant approach to grief
counseling. Journal for International Counselor Education, 3, 25–38. Retrieved March 30, 2013
from http://digitalcommons.library.unlv.edu/jice.
Fischman, D. (2009). Therapeutic relationships and kinesthetic empathy. In S. Chaiklin & H. Wengrower
(Eds.), The art and science of dance/movement therapy: Life is dance (pp. 33–53). New York:
Routledge.
Fleming, S. J., & Adolph, R. (1986). Helping bereaved adolescents: Needs and responses. In C. A. Corr &
J. N. McNeil (Eds.), Adolescence and death (pp. 97–118). New York: Springer.
Freeman, S. J. (2005). Grief and loss: Understanding the journey. Belmont, CA: Thomson/Brooks Cole.
Glaser, B. G., & Strauss, A. L. (1967). The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative
research. Piscataway, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
Hagan, M. J., Luecken, L. J., Sandler, I. N., & Tein, J. Y. (2010). Prospective effects of post-bereavement
negative events on cortisol activity in parentally bereaved youth. Developmental Psychobiology,
52(4), 394–400.
Haine, R. A., Ayers, T. S., Sandler, I. N., & Wolchik, S. A. (2008). When a parent dies: Helping grieving
children and adolescents. In K. J. Doka & A. S. Tucci (Eds.), Living with grief: Children and
adolescents (pp. 141–157). Washington, DC: Hospice Foundation of America.
Hedman, A. (2012). Faculty’s empathy and academic support for grieving students. Death Studies,
36(10), 914–931. doi:10.1080/07481187.2011.605986.
Hensley, P. L., & Clayton, P. J. (2008). Bereavement: Signs, symptoms, and course. Psychiatric Annals,
38(10), 649–654.
Humphrey, K. M. (2009). Counseling strategies for loss and grief. Alexandria, VA: American Counseling
Association.
Konigsberg, R. D. (2011). The truth about grief: The myth of its five stages and the new science of loss.
New York, NY: Simon & Schuster.
Kübler-Ross, E. (1969). On death and dying. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster.
Levy, F. J. (2005). Dance movement therapy: A healing art. Reston, VA: American Alliance for Health,
Physical Education, Recreation and Dance.
Lieberman, P. B., & Jacobs, S. C. (1987). Bereavement and its complications in medical patients: A guide
for consultation-liaison psychiatrists. International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine, 17(1), 23–39.
Lorenzi, P., Hardoy, M. C., & Cabras, P. L. (2000). Life crisis and the body within. Psychopathology,
33(6), 283–291.
123
168 Am J Dance Ther (2013) 35:142–168
Maciejewski, P. K., Zhang, B., Block, S. D., & Prigerson, H. G. (2007). An empirical examination of the
stage theory of grief. JAMA, 297(7), 716–723.
Malchiodi, C. A. (Ed.). (2008). Creative interventions with traumatized children. London: Guildford
Press.
Martin, T. L., & Doka, K. J. (2000). Men don’t cry…women do: Transcending gender stereotypes of
grief. Philadelphia: Brunner/Mazel.
McGarry, L. M., & Russo, F. A. (2011). Mirroring in dance/movement therapy: Potential mechanisms
behind empathy enhancement. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 38(3), 178–184.
Peng, H. L. (2010). The grief process of a child survivor of the 921 earthquake: A case report. Australian
Journal of Disaster and Trauma Studies, 2010(2). Retrieved April 28, 2013 from
http://trauma.massey.ac.nz/issues/2010-2/hl_peng.htm.
Rando, T. (1988). How to go on living when someone you love dies. New York: Bantam Books.
Sadalña, J. (2009). The coding manual for qualitative researchers. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Scharlach, A. E., & Fredriksen, K. I. (1993). Reactions to the death of a parent during midlife. Omega—
Journal of Death and Dying, 27(4), 307–319.
Schuurman, D. (2008). Grief groups for grieving children and adolescents. In K. J. Doka & A. S. Tucci
(Eds.), Living with grief: Children and adolescents (pp. 255–268). Washington, DC: Hospice
Foundation of America.
Seidman, I. (2006). Interviewing as qualitative research: A guide for researchers in education and the
social sciences. New York: Teachers College Press.
Shallcross, L. (2012). A loss like no other. Counseling Today, 54(12), 26–31.
Sood, A. B., Razdan, A., Weller, E. B., & Weller, R. A. (2006). Children’s reactions to parental and
sibling death. Current Psychiatry Reports, 8(2), 115–120.
Sponagle, M. (2012). Good grief. Chatelaine, 85(3), 141–145.
Talbot, M. (2001, December). The year in ideas: A to z.; Communal bereavement. New York Times
Magazine. p. 62.
Webb, N. B. (2003). Play and expressive therapies to help bereaved children: Individual, family, and
group treatment. Smith College Studies in Social Work, 73(3), 405–422.
Wittig, J., & Davis, J. (2012). Circles outside the circle: Expanding the group frame through dance/
movement therapy and art therapy. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 39(2), 168–172.
Wolfelt, A. (1996). Healing the bereaved child: Grief gardening, growth through grief and other
touchstones for caregivers. Fort Collins, CO: Companion Press.
Wolfelt, A. (2005). Companioning the bereaved: A soulful guide for caregivers. Fort Collins, CO:
Companion Press.
Worden, J. W. (2008). Grieving children and adolescents: Lessons from the Harvard child bereavement
study. In K. J. Doka & A. S. Tucci (Eds.), Living with grief: Children and adolescents (pp.
125–137). Washington, DC: Hospice Foundation of America.
Worden, J. W. (2009). Grief counseling and grief therapy: A handbook for the mental health practitioner.
New York, NY: Springer.
Worden, J. W., & Silverman, P. R. (1996). Parental death and the adjustment of school-age children.
Omega, 35, 95–102.
Author Biography
Ellen Philpott
E. Philpott is a recent graduate of Naropa University’s Somatic Counseling Psychology program, with a
concentration in dance/movement therapy. Ellen pursued her passion for working with dying and grieving
populations in her internship at The Denver Hospice, where she integrated DMT techniques with children,
teenagers, and adults who were anticipating or grieving the death loss of a loved one. Ellen is continually
inspired to create and engage in dance/movement therapy models that further support healing for people
throughout end of life transitions.
123
Copyright of American Journal of Dance Therapy is the property of Springer Science & Business
Media B.V. and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv
without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or
email articles for individual use.