Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Arx 2014
Arx 2014
Typical ophthalmologic complications after intraoral local mydriasis (10 cases) and/or ptosis (9 cases). In 30 out of the
anesthesia include (in alphabetical order): accommodation 43 cases with diplopia, information was available regarding the
disturbance, amaurosis (loss of sight), diplopia (double vision), affected eye muscle. In 26 of these 30 patients (86.7%), a para
enophthalmos (recession of eyeball), miosis (contraction of lysis of the lateral rectus muscle or anesthesia of the abducens
pupil), mydriasis (dilation of pupil), ophthalmoplegia (paraly- nerve, respectively were reported. With the exception of three
sis of all muscles responsible for eye movements), and ptosis cases, the diplopia had disappeared completely within six
(drooping of upper eye lid). Generally, the ophthalmologic hours.
complications in conjunction with intraoral local anesthesia Ptosis was the second most frequent ophthalmologic compli-
have an immediate to short onset, and disappear as the anes- cation with 18 case reports (16.7%). Females again predominat-
thesia subsides. These symptoms are most often attributed ed (72.2%). Regarding the duration, two thirds of the ptosis
to the anesthetic solution reaching the orbit or nearby struc- cases exhibited a complete remission within one hour. As a sin-
tures (Boynes et al. 2010). gle complication, ptosis only occurred in one patient while in
Since the first description of an ophthalmologic complication the other 17 patients ptosis was associated with other complica-
after dental anesthesia by Brain in 1936, several case reports tions, most frequently with diplopia (in 10 patients) and/or
and review articles have been published (Madrid et al. 1990, mydriasis (in 9 patients). In four patients, diplopia was associ-
Peñarrocha & Sanchis 2000, Choi et al. 2009, Aguado et al. 2011, ated with Horner’s syndrome. A mydriasis of the pupil was
Williams et al. 2011, Steenen et al. 2012). reported in 16 patients (14.8%) after intraoral local anesthesia,
The objective of the present article is to analyze in detail case therefore it was the third-most frequently reported complica-
reports about ophthalmologic complications after intraoral local tion. In every third patient with mydriasis, it lasted longer than
anesthesia. five hours. Amaurosis in conjunction with dental anesthesia
was described in 14 patients (13%). In three of those cases,
Material and methods amaurosis did not show remission and remained permanent.
Initially, a PubMed search was performed using English key The other reported complications like accommodation distur-
words (Fig. 1). In addition, the references of selected full text bance, enophthalmos, miosis and ophthalmoplegia were only
articles were screened to identify other articles related to oph- observed in few patients.
thalmologic complications following intraoral local anesthesia. The time period between anesthesia administration and onset
Only articles published in English were accepted for this analy- of the eye complications ranged from immediate to four hours
sis. Any type of article, i.e. case report, case series, clinical (Tab. III). Most frequently, an immediate onset was noted
study, review article, was included provided it yielded infor- (Fig. 3). A wide variation was observed for the duration of the
mation concerning the ophthalmologic complication related different ophthalmologic complications ranging from only five
to intraoral local anesthesia. Articles based on non-human minutes up to four months (Tab. III). However, the majority of
subjects were excluded. Reports about facial palsy and peri complications did not last for longer than five hours (Fig. 4).
orbital blanching were ignored since those complications The most frequent causes of ophthalmologic complications
involve periorbital structures rather than the eye directly. were block anesthesia of the inferior alveolar nerve (45.8%) and
Altogether 44 articles with a total of 65 case reports fulfilled of the posterior superior alveolar nerve (40.3%) (Tab. IV). Data
the inclusion criteria. regarding injection needles was only presented in 31 cases
The following data, if available, were extracted from each case (47.7%). Most commonly 25-gauge injection needles were uti-
report (Tab. I): age and gender of patient; application site of the lized (Tab. V). Lidocaine (45.6%) and articaine (31.6%) were the
intraoral local anesthesia; type, quantity and concentration of most frequently applied local anesthetics (Tab. VI). The vast
the local anesthetic; type and concentration of vasoconstrictor; majority of anesthetics contained epinephrine as the vasocon-
gauge of injection cannula; type, onset and duration of the oph- stricting agent (87.2%), with a concentration of 1: 100,000 as
thalmologic complication. the most frequently administered (50.9%; Tab. VII). Informa-
tion regarding the amount of administered local anesthetic was
Results available in 46 cases. In 35 cases, the amount was ≤ 2 ml, in ten
Out of a total of 65 case reports with ophthalmologic complica- cases the amount ranged from 2.1 to 4 ml, and only in one case
tions following intraoral local anesthesia, 18 affected males the amount exceeded 4 ml.
(27.7%) and 47 females (72.3%). The mean age of the patients
was 33.8 years, the median age was 31 years, and the age range Discussion
was 4 to 73 years. Most patients were in the third or fourth de- The present article analyzed 65 case reports of ophthalmologic
cades of age (Fig. 2). In 37 patients only a single complication complications after intraoral local anesthesia with regard to pa-
occurred, whereas 28 patients experienced multiple symptoms tient factors, type and agents of local anesthesia, and varieties
per manifestation (Tab. II). A total of 108 ophthalmologic com- of ophthalmologic complications. Among the 108 documented
plications were reported in those 65 patients (Tab. III). In 41.5% ophthalmologic complications, diplopia (39.8%) prevailed.
of the cases the left eye was affected while the right eye was Ptosis (16.7%), mydriasis (14.8%) and amaurosis (13.0%) were
affected in 35.4% of the cases (in 23.1% no such information less frequent. Other ophthalmologic complications such as ac-
was available). commodation disturbance, enophthalmos, miosis and ophthal-
Diplopia (43 cases, 39.8%) was the most frequently described moplegia were reported only in very few cases. In 37 patients
ophthalmologic complication after intraoral local anesthesia, (56.9%), only a single complication occurred, with diplopia
with a very high rate of females (81.4%). In 25 patients, diplopia again as the predominating symptom (24 cases).
was the only complication, whereas in the other 18 patients, It was striking that 72.3% of the evaluated patients were
diplopia was associated with one other or multiple ophthalmo- females suggesting the possibility of different anatomic features
logic complications. Most often, diplopia was combined with between genders (Steenen et al. 2012): anatomical variants (see
3 Blaxter & Britten 30 Male Inferior alveolar nerve N/A N/A Diplopia N/A DI 20 minutes
1967 (right)
4 Blaxter & Britten 39 Male Inferior alveolar nerve (left) 3 ml procaine (% N/A) with N/A Amaurosis N/A AM/MY some hours
N/A = not available m. = muscle AC = Accommodation disturbance AM = Amaurosis DI = Diplopia EN = Enophthalmos MI = Miosis MY = Mydriasis OP = Ophthalmoplegia PT = Ptosis
& Sanchis 2000 nerve (N/A) 1 :100,000 epinephrine (lateral rectus m.) 30 minutes
Mydriasis
Ptosis
N/A = not available m. = muscle AC = Accommodation disturbance AM = Amaurosis DI = Diplopia EN = Enophthalmos MI = Miosis MY = Mydriasis OP = Ophthalmoplegia PT = Ptosis
(accommodation disturbance OR
amaurosis OR diplopia OR enophthal-
mos OR miosis OR mydriasis OR
ophthalmoplegia OR ptosis) AND (local
OR intraoral OR dental) anesthesia
n = 670
n = 889
not related to topic (n = 1462)
article repeatedly listed (n = 22)
n = 75
hand search (n = 2)
full-text articles
n = 52
not intraoral local anesthesia (n = 2)
vasospasm of skin (n = 4)
review article without case reports (n = 2)
included articles
n = 44
Fig. 1 Flow chart of literature search
Complication(s) N N
per patient patients complications
1 37 37
2 17 34
3 8 24
4 2 8
5 1 5
Total 65 108
Fig. 2 Patient distribution regarding age decades (n = 65)
Tab. III Overview of gender, age, onset and duration per complication (n = 108)
Gender of patient Age (years) of Onset of complication Duration of complication
patient
Fig. 3 Onset of ophthalmologic complications (n = 63) Fig. 4 Duration of ophthalmologic complications (n = 104)
below) might be more frequent in females than in males, and in Indeed, administration of intraoral local anesthesia to the
females application sites of local anesthesia might be closer to i nferior alveolar nerve (45.8%) or to the posterior superior
the orbit because of smaller body size. It remains unclear why alveolar nerve (40.3%) was the main cause of ophthalmologic
patients aged 21 to 30 were most frequently affected in the ana- complications, i. e. injections given in possible “risk zones”.
lyzed case reports. One may speculate that block anesthesia in Although a positive aspiration test may not be associated nec-
possible “risk areas” of triggering ophthalmologic complica- essarily with an intravascular application, up to 30% of positive
tions are more commonly applied in that age group. aspiration has been reported in anesthesia of the inferior alveo-
lar nerve (Hidding & Khoury 1991, Lustig & Zusman 1999). But
aspiration was also positive in 2.4% of cases with anesthesia of
the posterior superior alveolar nerve (Lustig & Zusman 1999).
Tab. IV Type of anesthesia associated with ophthalmologic
With regard to the thickness of the injection cannula, larger
complication (n = 72*)
cannula (58%) with 24–25 gauge (approximately 0.5 to 0.6 mm
Type of anesthesia N Percentage of external diameter) was more frequently used than smaller
cannula (33%) with 27–28 gauge (approximately 0.4 mm of ex-
Inferior alveolar nerve 33 45.8 ternal d iameter) in the reported cases. Consequently, the gauge
of the cannula might play a role. With regard to the causative
Anterior superior alveolar nerve 1 1.4
anesthetic agent, lidocaine and articaine reflect the anesthetic
Middle superior alveolar nerve 5 6.9 drugs most frequently used in dentistry (Malamed 2006). In
what way the diffusion characteristics of local anesthetics play
Posterior superior alveolar nerve 29 40.3 a role in ophthalmologic complications after intraoral local
* Information about the injection cannula was not available in 34 cases. * In 10 patients no information was available about the type of vasoconstrictor.
Articaine – 14 – 3 1 18 31.6%
Butethamine – – – – 1 1 1.8%
Prilocaine – – 1 – 2 3 5.3%
Procaine – – – – 3 3 5.3%
Total 1 37 5 3 11 57 100.0%
References
Aguado J M, Barona C, Lillo J C, De La Fuente D S, Dogan E A, Dora B: Transient partial ophthalmo- Inchingolo F, Tatullo M, Abenavoli F M, Marelli M,
Martinez J M: Ocular complications following plegia and Horner’s syndrome after intraoral Inchingolo A D, Villabruna B, Inchingolo A M,
dental local anesthesia. Med Oral Patol Oral Cir local anesthesia. J Clin Neurosc 12: 696–697 Diplama G: Severe anisocoria after oral surgery
Bucal 16: e688–693 (2011) (2005) under general anesthesia. Int J Med Sci 7:
314–318 (2010)
Aldrete J A, Narang R, Sada T, Tan Liem S, Dryden J A: An unusual complication resulting
Miller G P: Reverse carotid flow – a possible from a Gow-Gates mandibular block. Compend Kini Y K, Kharkar V R, Kini A Y: Transient diplopia
explanation for some reactions to local anes- Contin Educ Dent 14: 94–100 (1993) with ipsilateral abducens nerve palsy and ptosis
thetic. J Am Dent Assoc 94: 1142–1145 (1977) following a maxillary local anesthetic injection.
Fish L R, McIntire D N, Johnson L: Temporary
Oral Maxillofac Surg 16: 373–375 (2012)
Al-Sandook T, Al-Saraj A: Ocular complications paralysis of cranial nerves III, IV, and VI after
after inferior alveolar nerve block: a case report. a Gow-Gates injection. J Am Dent Assoc 119: Koumoura F, Papageorgiou G: Diplopia as a compli-
J Calif Dent Assoc 38: 57–59 (2010) 127–130 (1989) cation of local anesthesia: a case report. Quin-
tessence Int 32: 232–234 (2001)
Balaji S M: Transient diplopia in dental outpatient Goldenberg A S: Diplopia resulting from a man-
clinic: an uncommon iatrogenic event. Indian dibular injection. J Endod 9: 261–262 (1983) Kronman J H, Kabani S: The neuronal basis for dip-
J Dent Res 21: 132–134 (2010) lopia following local anesthetic injections. Oral
Goldenberg A S: Transient diplopia from a posteri-
Surg 58: 533–534 (1984)
Blanton P L, Jeske A H: The key to profound or alveolar injection. J Endod 16: 550–551 (1990)
local anesthesia. Neuroanatomy. J Am Dent Lacouture C, Blanton P L, Hairston L E: The anato-
Grosskreutz C L, Katowitz W R, Freeman E E,
Assoc 134: 753–760 (2003) my of the maxillary artery in the infratemporal
Dreyer E B: Lidocaine toxicity to rat retinal gan-
fossa in relationship to oral injections. Anat Rec
Blaxter P L, Britten M J: Transient amaurosis after glion cells. Curr Eye Res 18: 363–367 (1999)
205: 104A (1983)
mandibular nerve block. Br Med J 1: 681 (1967)
Hales R H: Ocular injuries sustained in the dental
Lavine M H, Stoopack J C: Postinjection complica-
Boynes S G, Echeverria Z, Abdulwahab M: Ocular office. Am J Ophthalmol 70: 221–223 (1970)
tion to local anesthesia: report of case. J Oral
complications associated with local anesthesia
Hayreh S S, Dass R: The ophthalmic artery: I. Ori- Surg 26: 481–482 (1968)
administration in dentistry. Dent Clin North
gin and intracranial and intra-canalicular
Am 54: 677–686 (2010) Leopard P J: Diplopia following injection of a local
course. Br J Ophthalmol 46: 65–98 (1962)
anaesthetic. Dent Pract Dent Rec 22: 92–94
Brain W R: Third nerve palsy following dental
Heasman P A: Clinical anatomy of the superior (1971)
extraction. Arch Ophthamol 51: 959 (1936)
alveolar nerves. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg 22:
Liu Q, Rhoton A L: Middle meningeal origin of the
Campbell R L, Mercuri L G, van Sickels J: Cervical 439–447 (1984)
ophthalmic artery. Neurosurg 49: 401–407
sympathetic block following intraoral local
Hidding J, Khoury F: General complications in den- (2001)
anesthesia. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 47:
tal local anesthesia (in German: Allgemeine
223–226 (1979) Lustig J P, Zusman S P: Immediate complications of
Komplikationen bei der zahnärztlichen Lokal
local anesthesia administered to 1007 consecu-
Choi E H, Seo J Y, Jung B Y, Park W: Diplopia after anästhesie). Dtsch Zahnärztl Z 46: 834–836
tive patients. J Am Dent Assoc 130: 496–499
inferior alveolar nerve block anesthesia: Report (1991)
(1999)
of 2 cases and literature review. Oral Surg Oral
Horowitz J, Almog Y, Wolf A, Buckman G, Geyer O:
Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod 107: e21-e24 Madrid C, Duran D, Gante P, Reynes P: Ophthalmic
Ophthalmic complications of dental anaesthe-
(2009) accidents during local-regional anesthesia in
sia: three new cases. J Neuroophthalmol 25:
dentistry: clinical aspects, anatomic routes (in
Cooper J C: Deviation of eye and transient blurring 95–100 (2005)
French: Accidents ophthalmiques des anes-
of vision after mandibular nerve anesthesia:
Hyams S W: Oculomotor palsy following dental an- thésies loco-régionales en odontologie. Aspects
report of case. J Oral Surg Anesth Hosp Dent
esthesia. Arch Ophthalmol 94: 1281–1282 (1976) cliniques, voies anatomiques). Actual Odon-
Serv 20: 151–152 (1962)
tostomatol 170: 271–283 (1990)
Magliocca K R, Kessel N C, Cortright G W: Transient Petrelli E A, Steller R E: Medial rectus muscle Spierer A, Spierer S: Transient extraocular muscle
diplopia following maxillary local anesthetic palsy after dental anesthesia. Am J Ophthal- palsy resulting from inferior alveolar nerve block
injection. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral mol 90: 422–424 (1980) in children. J Clin Pediatr Dent 24: 29–30 (1999)
Radiol Endod 101: 730–733 (2006)
Pragasm M, Managutti A: Diplopia with local anes- Surej Kumar L K, Manuel S, Sudhesh A, Thaha K A:
Malamed S F: Handbook of Local Anesthesia. thesia. Natl J Maxillofac Surg 2: 82–85 (2011) Abducens nerve palsy following an inferior alve-
5th edition. Mosby Inc, Maryland Heights/ olar nerve block. J Maxillofac Oral Surg 9: 106
Prakasm M, Managutti A, Dolas R S, Agrawal M G:
Missouri (2004) (2010)
Temporary pupillary dilatation and ptosis: com-
Malamed S F: Local anesthetics: Dentistry’s most plications of PSA nerve block: a case report and Tomazzoli-Gerosa L, Marchini G, Monaco A:
important drugs, clinical update 2006. J Calif review of literature. J Maxillofac Oral Surg 8: Amaurosis and atrophy of the optic nerve: an
Dent Assoc 34: 971–976 (2006) 181–183 (2009) unusual complication of mandibular-nerve
anesthesia. Ann Ophthalmol 20:170–171 (1988)
Marinho R O M: Abducens nerve palsy following Pretterklieber M L, Skopakoff C, Mayr R: The
dental local analgesia. Br Dent J 179: 69–70 human maxillary artery reinvestigated: I. Topo- Uckan S, Cilasun U, Erkman O: Rare ocular and
(1995) graphical relations in the infratemporal fossa. cutaneous complication of inferior alveolar
Acta Anat 142: 281–287 (1991) nerve block. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 64: 719–721
McNicholas S, Torabinejad M: Esotropia following
(2006)
posterior superior alveolar nerve block. J Calif Rishiraj B, Epstein J B, Fine D, Nabi S, Wade N K:
Dent Assoc 20: 33–34 (1992) Permanent vision loss in one eye following van der Bijl P, Lamb T L: Prolonged diplopia follow-
administration of local anesthesia for a dental ing a mandibular block injection. Anesth
Ngeow W C, Shim C K, Chai W L: Transient loss of
extraction. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg 34: Prog 43: 116–117 (1996)
power of accommodation in 1 eye following
220–223 (2005)
inferior alveolar nerve block: report of 2 cases. Verma D K, Rajan R, Prabhu S: Ipsilateral, isolated
J Can Dent Assoc 72: 927–931 (2006) Roda R S, Blanton P L: The anatomy of local anes- amaurosis after inferior alveolar nerve block:
thesia. Quintessence Int 25: 27–28 (1994) report of two rare cases. Oral Maxillofac Surg 17:
Norris L: Eye complications following Gow-Gates
73–75 (2013)
block technique. Dent Anaesth Sedat 11: 59–60 Rood J P: Ocular complication of inferior dental
(1982) nerve block. A case report. Br Dent J 132: 23–24 Walker M, Drangsholt M, Czartoski T J, Long-
(1972) streth W T: Dental diplopia with transient abdu-
O’Connor M, Eustace P: Tonic pupil and lateral
cens palsy. Neurology 63: 2449–2450 (2004)
rectus palsy following dental anaesthesia. Neuro Scott J K, Moxham B J, Downie I P: Upper lip
Ophthalmol 3: 205–208 (1983) blanching and diplopia associated with local Wilkie G J: Temporary uniocular blindness and
anaesthesia of the inferior alveolar nerve. ophthalmoplegia associated with a mandibular
Peñarrocha M, Sanchis J M: Ophthalmologic com-
Br Dent J 202: 32–33 (2007) block injection. A case report. Aust Dent J 45:
plications after intraoral local anesthesia with
131–133 (2000)
articaine. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Singh S, Dass R: The central artery of the retina.
Radiol Endod 90: 21–24 (2000) I. Origin and course. Br J Ophthalmol 44: Williams J V, Williams L R, Colbert S D, Reving-
193–212 (1960) ton P J: Amaurosis, ophthalmoplegia, ptosis,
Perrini P, Cardia A, Fraser K, Lanzino G: A micro-
mydriasis and periorbital blanching following
surgical study of the anatomy and course of the Steenen S A, Dubois L, Saeed P, de Lange J: Oph-
inferior alveolar nerve anaesthesia. Oral Maxil-
ophthalmic artery and its possibly dangerous thalmologic complications after intraoral local
lofac Surg 15: 67–70 (2011)
anastomoses. J Neurosurg 106: 142–150 (2007) anesthesia: case report and review of literature.
Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol 113:
e1–e5 (2012)