Professional Documents
Culture Documents
4 5940469709202786551
4 5940469709202786551
4 5940469709202786551
o?,+kr I
t. Ln4r rlrlft? 2
2, tlh?.$ hf4h aloo"l s
u. r"rr ?d?f,{?o h{u n?+r+ {lfT
hoor} hrtc 4
fl, rhrtrh +aq&+ && flh?.r h4u ilr
?q?Qo haz,tfF h71c 6
,{r. nnllofiq Nnt/.f+ hsrnd.-? r}t} r+nr
9
3. fi.Ffi+ ghnAfpq hf,'r+ aoutlfT lr
u, nh4u 4ao7 tl
A, fiou,{,fin* 4sa7 t2
r*r. q$re&;fo lrofrdt$+ 4n? t2
a,a.n?{Lf*{ {laadrfih++ry nmT l4
w. {looc;,|fr6^ (nSC4'-) +2 iltool t7
4. noohh/^e sc'g,q orlbo (+.gc)
4oa? t9
4. frlo f\F ?Linr7'*? @C$ gc,l*t-l sa,{l* 20
5. {lrgd'lf+ d,tn?g.c rflP 22
6. hrfi* ?fufi4r d?dnq+ 22
tt, frua 23
df. n,l+ 2s
rh. tfhd 26
c'o' fr 26
w, rftF 27
7. *Cq? 28
tt. hrfun s9
21. o'tln'fif 78
www.itjsjruth.org www.qf,org
www.iad.org
@+g*
fltu r'h$ grlct ?rrfi4P? +hhnf hn+Pug+T?
d'r+un ?@:: hn hn4t' q#oW qol+ +?6rt 'ftf
af,f f+49 |lczrq hs*c'llP:: 9P6fC0@ 9hr7r
oofr4l^1i oofrl"L$ h"n/|P? h?rli ?o:: h+?qn+P ilLF
oo.ttook qiB? @?'tg 'fif ?G:: Stt.fT?P 9;171
fh"nr\P ooTTg 0*C9? h?y.. t*oarndlq nt{LF oo'Uook
(0.o.(D.)r h?&++'rneo^ d{r+l{l lo:: tl+&o'ltf fin
h"hnr n+f.22d!. ?''L\lv Tf+P;t1 6oooahtr
hlrPhlrh?zz
hrnlFr40 ?qff u",fl h?.T hPn+f ?dltf\@ aaltfuf
*tfTf 9'b7.ft qh9- ;"n4P? 0116 |.g&n f'fiA+ Pntt
fufrrno thf?4dr:: 9,u /-/.f tr"ntP? Jl?tLB no,lgo^
aodrln n4|r+kn ntnra nffn@ lliJlr? 0'tr's?
gao,1.41 hqfi ?o,L.rq {'f1f,lt", f,Lr+rA ,nh? h$fitlA?::
g,v71 r.lFs rtsl@ g/trt'T hr|+ +n4l"+r guT
iur 4ffe.z f,"t+3 nrP?+s d^r rfi&}q+ h'rg+tf1
arqgc'r@ 'fa+ hts+? gdn4fi' n'?.r\ hP?t lo::
4
ultr', d'rkta 9q.Tf\ {|Tf a* lozz frdAfo? ?o'L?/,
o,r7r thgo:t ?p1hl6"j,4P go'Lnc ,f'A ?hfzt
h4u hf7s18+?? htrn^ u9n h?n+ hf? fA?n+
t -\f \f' h1g}'tT f 9.L'r7 {l+f hf4h ?tt}:: hllx) lL,tF?
04.s 24hh,F+ h?n+ hhh bah+ef+s Le+cf+
0en{tlfe f},+1 +?''fivr-+ur 6[brc g&ml h?.&t f
?+&qe vI +ou,qt@'Iq d,'U$f&1 Jn{l+o h?&+g
99e', lc"zt hTEf rt$ ?mft h,eo,e*r hft fd'x,?@*@
ftf? h?8,:: h4U tl?.g h97e7e, l?C n?rrd9. n{'T,4
zailtr tooTll$ttr
hft Aqnn@ hr?Tn@ ll4& hF? f4+ fo:: hF?
,fA ?v"r h7g1 176 au$mc nn xru "o7 nd:LA trl
{ar /tfn?T r'?+r\ af }&:: aJLTt Oflz gl"Lr'@*q
?d,lg,4la+ ne+", t/.:tr ?l^mt \'rc a7 hc$ hs'rzf+
hhA f Nn ?@;: h'o{f6 hr}+T qha'r+', filh2c
fnfio. h?.e h9o4h ootfb| Bf[i/r:: 01[u Vd'0 49'
hn4r h tt t..tlt, h?x. hsrrr 1,"1 a?.ttil h1& hha-{{fF?q
h/ryNnl'r'. ?o'L26 fuf SnbC h?.Rrt/l t'gtTlntrzz
h$/rbah olt't th4u? )gilq FAnlT ?d'1"26 hA '0/F
dTu,07 hhur+T 'hqd.T hf'Ah g.tLma.A,tt "h.tll
m*az,PFr hh'{l tF6l4F+ CIgt'+ ?o'Ltr\e1 f&rtr
{fr} ayol'y" h+4dl+ hr'}+T hhur+ goag\Azt
rn1r+f lo|fr? h"€ fr?e ft4u h}&v &4dr:- nan&i
rq,rr@7 ?Z?o* hrt /h4u/ {ty' ?o::*
h$sd^ a'ilrn* ?d'L+h*f h?.e h4u nf
oro'hhd^?
l0rz: hilq*r f, h?f?h''.,$ au.il\f h.eA gooqlt {lfF
os6l7 qd.e hfdrh ?0:: h7911lu qq'z+ r+{{+ hr}++
0h"n4r fif 94To9-::
fl. rht"rrh +"q&+ &fh /th?s h4u .$r ga'Lrl(b hootf?.
hfic
hhf,r nrc frfro t\F f+4h+ lflf+q au.Ailh+?T
hJlaros+ rln*tr+ gf++ hrAh ?d''L?qc," $Fr fllF?o
h?.e hrlu .{lf aot77 ?o:: h{tl Sfe *+7 ?l"o,en+
q4o'I ht'r.? ,fif h}&'t$.+ ooVb? ?AE.dr:: flL049 r q^n,
ffiG tt.ET $rn"C? hor^'I*l* h?.T t nld 'fif Ag ooltl*
cstlr* ?(tr:: lrn4r hfuft"T hr?+T ?o'Lh,gn+ ?q@
?'r{lr g,v }&:: yTr h?w h{lq?* hr?+T qhr"t
?Lfit h?S t"ttl(, ootl-T llarAh+f hqd,T hfrrh ou^fr
{torolr** ?a& frft
hg,'tTf:: h?tlu hr?+T n+h f"rTo
hh4u nfT )f,A h4;Fo {ln(} ?q?rlf o7 s'te f+
h7&"r* hnnf,'' hd?4F h.ec?o h"r&bC.;Fo gA{lhi-::
'ftr hhf,r F:rf hnh oo-uosk lh.a.al f+4h.+
?&f+ t}rb th+*r++ rA{} AF h4u? ,'fir Fh hpcq fh
h"?4F hT&flaru.ilh \&:: 9v ?nlri lt9ooT ?s'If'h'{1.93
+4Aq hfro AF +Lffh'? q}r.if. 2C ?%$lnl'- h'-l+
?&:: /,u,'r-(lut\ ?o'Lgrnb \hovg?+ 9Ao AF fhf?+ ?,^tt
hqds hrAh h?k hrfih? $9 '''rr^h *fi,r\ {lAo
ffi{fi-:: f.rr?1 hdft }Ln4r nA} f'!o,aldr:: h.finf
nf,*(r\fr rfte Af fhr?+ h?.9 hf4h? '{$
"F flttV?Qfr:: 9"?f
hrar{* of, tld.C hfAh ol,,lt$t*1
h"rw ttLf+ Ioz'ilh{fo hfft-r fiad^ ?a'Lf.l+q r?&,r+
-Ifim?+*,fT'nfi$ il/o+", o3 qd.g hg'd\h ?a,Lnl+ f?n+
{Uf?r ffio f\F h'o?+ qd.g hrtrh ofr'lP oo-il-. 0au.fu
r"?n&** nu-fl+ ?{Lf+ sohhd\ n"?fc rxtl h$*+
?flc:: 0ltrrr rh1f+ ffio A.gT hqd.e hfd\rF *{*o
hl&'Ilb O.f.%fllw hr?+ h?&d,T,frf! rn[fn*r+ ?&f+
0+hf f g, fd\hAtf?dr:'
h4u ffl0 d\F? ?t metu nenfrt. hft? .fiF ?,'lrAh
+&qch? ??fla h?&qao^ h,gcr T&* {lfr/t {lt}rr
.R?f' frgnn fi*ffro su?'tk l}fr il9D+ h?,9 hfirt? ,fir
hf'u'ttlF srrr&11 og rru?q+ h}&f]t?'{lrb f,t+r,fd\::
r"rr hw? &ttl(, nhhrf,h;For n"nn-*q n"fnft+
h'?Tft"+ n4.e aofb7 fld\fiq;frn &fo+f 'fi11 fign6
nun"qfiw g4rb+? ?au&rlnq ?u?.ff, ?'tC ffif, olf hh
,gfil{l4r}::
{lrlcr AF ?f(,h {.,(+ {}n'f npT h?'tq +hhnf
hr4h? ,fir h1&'Il4 q6 ?s'Lfgc? fh.f f f. ?{L.r+{
g'vtrth*trT +d\h?crr: 7?c a7 fffig"nl", r*7* rh?.f+
f"+ 0fg,? pE'L frrr&77 {16'Irnh fqd.r ht'*drh *?qc
+lts+?d\r:
h'lu fAoAF? ?Lnto. hfl.? nf h}&,r{o t0::
nh"n{r +A.* &2F,A CI|. h4u ,9,0t\'r Ao,*e,fi 4:htl
h''fn? 0ttr? hh,lu d).d[b ghT s,l}+&r. 1,rc af,r
t'l"rfiolf Ao a"ltlF ggf o19'|n ?0:: {l/'lh.
?+,ngf.* h4u f,lr qf,1+ hf?'lr hfn&dr?of''z: h4u
gl":4^FZl flrzu'lt' ?o'I.hqq nnd'I.rf!- ??clT r,.ft- g+rnq
do+i ,rr\cr zf lr::
gv ho",tfhr .2c rf hPr\h rlh4u rw
fftm*or* 72C ?hf:z tffg- npT h.!? .{lf oo,Il4.;^ffw
h:i9s'lfn.Rn*t rAE dt:: hfr. fi9"}9- nC 4g, trT ,rr\tf?
t* ?&:: l?C "11 STL*+ 0al.b nr}. tfcr::
ngrtr rr& yq,I\ ^9'f?trT
{r9o+ LFf}. (lh?.T 4f, +dl,0nnd}
hft? ,nf fl?tt+ *zqF ,fud\ ?6Lmhouw \,tC fft'r' r
ll
|tra* gnlhnt*w €fo:: hF" {lnlgp do.a^ttf wt,
?tf\t h4u fif lo ;vou,hh ?01.140::
/l.0au4dh* eIoT
n\lh* fh4u Srrrf,T qfd).:: thtrf' ?,'lC hAnn+
9tr.,\0- h4u or',trilrrtr g&nb#* h'{lcT? dLtf? {c*q
LFAr h4U 9n4+o1 .nr ?qw+ {To::
h4u ?h}ets a1',46h*z nrq +?qc fi+cqT
lfr,?h$fi:: or'htt9" ?1f\ fro. gaortih+ ooq.C h.ffT
F?,8 |&:: necqT h+?io'+ ov46h* aphhdr !L{l.ld\q
d?,hLd\ g,?Tlnfdt:: rlPttrt:- fh4u? lrfrf' nlflftq
Aaudrdh+ryT ?o'lgaft +?qc ?n.fiah ?&::
rh. {lc'a*rh$+ 4oa7
nfio t\F qr\+0211-
a'"frA"fl+ rt?(L,g+ n0./'&,q
oooat,f?+ LFfr ffsrt:: h4u n*CqF ofif tln*d'fo
ft?fttlr+ fffirrr ooftrhs+ ?4m1 ,t!4f hflqr(I)"::
g n?f+r haor;rt4;Fo n&+ thhnT ffh 9h f?n*
S;Fp:: h4u n*C91" frn+rifio. f?fLf+ aoml,f,F>ft-
l. nlr{l lrYr9" fnl&+ o".ltbnfT
2, rlrzo"4 ?$[gd]S hootl1ft nf,+ f?n Ltu hl,+
l+wtr+l
3. n4flr".g ?0L9,0.S haa{lC,$ n&+ r?fi Lft oo',llo*-e
ez+ /n$c/
T2
4. f11{ ?$eg&q harylfie}h n&+ r\na@. o.?ah.
QuTntUq
5. hwUoak ?$egclqhfiill? Lf,{lLT, fl0,ah0+
azdrh ?at\o *C1", ifis:
aofrrtP+ necj.? fir,+ ncgo^ htb", n+nFg
h+qPTt +n"p+ nor,ha.cx* 49, gi-+ ?,,fLf +
aoool,fP+ nnerr,n+ b\f i.g, qfo '{lfltp hg+0rtf::
ho?osr]"Ln ?$ h4u qoego'_ QcqT htg+,rha0"- fip+
q[il'rg, sfltd.rsr,T n,'?dh+ 'fino ncn?f?rr* h?ltu
,fie!,Pry n+rlfg ooT't&T f+h$rl" $f0.:r h?]Luf
(loa(.mdfg fAft- oz.ltilhf+? ovgnuooe of,f f?0t
''.lfrnlfii {lo-[,m(,f,g f,Ho} ?r$etu"t
o-ildn..f.-+1
*crr h}&+nfi il'tkeli h}&th9* fi$re&0t *?*
hTef,f* d,lx|? t,fp:: h?ltu ,fiaqpTq +?nlp+ h?ru
aq+ +hrf.s Ah h?.R hrlu ph +CIfi"R?dr:; nhl'.b, ?l[
h*CqT frry ,Fn.+ a'uifrrhff+ fhiu td\S f^Pry Yd'ft
rfgqn*qtw sfo:: nrlcr ,\F ?hrLq ,na4 r+?d rt{q
oudtbnl' f'jlo^ f,?frt:: alll'ftrtP+ f+.gP PryT oailhd'.re
" frchs+ ?o\.+0rt fLlf?r h+hfg ?qr+q Tlcffisz
?d?haf oo$,tt, ?*I.gf,.Crlq $9. +7 oT'Ik hno/-+
o
ht)-1 nhltT? nd?':'lTft a'ofrrh$ ?+n ofif ffi-+ ?+hfg rnrtt"T
hhrftn oVa nlt nA/!'T nfua.pT ?+x* Tfo:t fi*C17 epltf
?%m+rto mTaA n+tf {ta",O?f Af .L{ (O.fl) 4f, r0.IX$I h?X.
hh"rfun oln nl.t n+Afs g**p+ r+Ifuo"'t h,g.(,flf::
l3
n9-7{f",+ ?4/n{.oD.* +Cq?,rq g?(LB so.llook
+9'ifLc^V hf;,f;,Cf \tu*
so, n?&ftq fl/Ddrdh+f+ 4sa7
t&f+ o",h6h+T+ hh4u a?',hilh+ ++'flfro $f.
u?Q;Fo ?d'I.fn+4A#- 0h4u r't.4rr h'o+ 9T(I}.::
r+4bn+ qtqr ffro trr? h?,e h{u d|.$6l./o,hhn+
+hhnf ?hrr+ teq ila.a.nn: ffro 6\F h4u? hTgi+
oo?ll+ hlehn+ A.t'tft+ilrrcq raog,vl oo77* hnloofih+
?fiC:: rtT.#r ?r[f+q ooitfih+++ hh4u oohtrc..?-
r,hnl? +?rtl+ *$^f ?+p+ hAlnfl9"t: f2f oohtr/^re
)g'd fr!4fio. hP+f ?fi{-:: h?S ou",hlt"f
tt fwdrhTor V\ ag. hrtu @UefrLf h.ec{ rl.ofiefio.
nG6.f hf'A.+,Sn+T:z h"l&t.f g?'P ?Af h"?+q
g'+cf n?f! ntnf\ @g'r h?n' b^+t1 a''rnq-4 hF'+,c\P::
ftnny oo
97" ?d,I.Aft oofn&f Aao.ltA..PT ?o', Qr?q
oo.11oo4t,
n.efl ?o:: hfTe"r& ?&gq gro,ilbh+f h?/glltu 1g,r+
+"lqa.+ t}ft hqd,g hrt\h ?d'L@,f,,fb o?ivbffi
?c'L+'r{1a'ryo. aqnqftr Ao hzu-frfi"fT h?'xd'If-*rnc
hfi+f' Etr:t
aru.il*tf h2n ?$lw h4u nqhr flaz{ haTT* u"0T
{ltF ,tLf+1 hnail,q+ d\b.dr:: aD.frJl"f gtf, fro {l?tLu
nh4u n+4tr.+ ?rL,r+q a,ro.dl.bh+?T LFlb nlooT hnnt"
l4
h7e1e4r ir4u n+C*b rn?0,f?fr:r nnr hfrn+fi-+r
sahhdt:- hgr lnqrli bu lqul z lL{lahr lh{l.etrli
op^tt lou(yl i t{ /}Lffun/ hq ovUsaY tnu-4fio"lf
^F,
s
n+c17 &frf g+fn*.!+ gh4u 4d.ltilh+TT:- h.grt L*^nt ?ui
fir\u i lutt &y-;r: ft"f i lLnd?t fi : lLfi.h+ i g6*'{l : f,f}s i
fl-%F'{l: hF{l 5 au-d i -l+? i l}r\tL$d\ : ,q{D..f T *ll,F"s'l?i }Lfrftl :
?h6i Stsn'. nh{,fi fttf,-t t{q otedioft (nu-r}r} {,€, p{f f,'f0".a*}
f$o,t
r5
Of,f /u,Ttl+ hh-nfif fh0ntd\::6 ao.ftrtll!'T f''r9o hPC
trg,g.z"n+ h?,e &q&7 ,fir h?.&@/lh rnnl} rh4u
?&f+q aroath+T+? tlr! au(rf.g .Brnn+qf"fi::
?ft,f+T d'T.hbh'f.trT l,,.ft. oo',ft flar-fu nh4u fg+ ?n+!
nfb4 h?4ftd au"firtq"T ?06::
tr&.r ?&f+ hh.q,r nrf hnh on $ooft ff!+
nhg','+ ?*tloo4- O7*o1s14+ ?fit:: tF{trtu9m nP+I
h}&@+q h"r&fln+4,r+ n+ifg ?n.e+ h*nfF k"l 2+
2c 0h4r, rl{r}-r ftrfr*r$tr.d^t0- 't'flf (t'l4t}
*or,tthf, f{lC:: tFr}f fn+f,+ f\nl0- ilp+ SrTt'C?
nolg nh hqru *4fo d\di-)gtr d*n11,? {ldTlfrih 'f.g
hT&07 ?0C:: fih.ntlf ?fLS ao.1jooft ?olg'g},*frt fhtlu
or'hdih+fq f?{Lf+ nf,f Xryf $ootf$To hfttl'T
?rL.r+q ao.Abh+FT 'fld\tr} h4for: nlLu ynTg*:-
l) h4u rtAe c\F f@cs rlfids b6g, 1o'h.€')
fic{To ?fL,g,?+ nd'?'{t 9+q /46r+7 lo,h$Tr)
n+Trl ruCrh n+CqT crftT na'tn+oonv$
2\ ?ou,s;Lt[1t ?&gq avf1.bh++ f11F?.+ ou,-1joloft
rlbr *odr,e.+ rth+rtlq r!+?{l++ r"?+r}+
hch fr+ f ht ,h,Bot nn 1oa4 ?ztLq'r+
HrruSTo' {laoflrfryft ?0::
6 h4U nilLg st Uoag (n.0.0) 4f,' f'r?.h+Aft? f *CqT h?+f
trocfi.c\;: "rrf?+ npB-rr* f7? ncfu 1"u7 ffilffi*7 .er??4n* r
f77r 047* fmtF?o? .(77r nC* h"ndarT! *47f -rn*r 247r
ftt?tntt*rr 9,e-?f*7 lt*hhA h**at'i fic*P h*tfgi
(N????)" /*c+r 4r:rn/
l6
hrtu n*cgb *hcfb (h/D.uatr|\ 01fr rw ?,fls aftr
ap.ililh+f h(,n(q9',, {lLfi:: ovttaok f?flf+ ae'gg':gorLf
+{ne f*rn+*f ntlu rnlf+ ]&::7 filr o,rh+
no.h,g ?me&,*q n?rLs w,a+ hq h0+ruc* r+h***
aro,fulr*,g UZp| frrlo tfc fiaa.ft" hnh arl65r|Tl1p,. +7.gefi
hT&flh?b fnO ?**oo+ tfo dtIA+ ?@:: hrp.?+f
ho'14 ilaolfT fio'0'.ttaak ?fl,e,?+ hq nnex4fp oir&
finoo't h?.&u'.r hh4'Fo nd,+ h4u finhfer ?&f+ hf
dn'.fi,6h*FT finfrol hs {tw,^?Tt hr,n1 s&r''q ifil
/rtflcr h4u s4{+ r?n?rf+ hA'lt?r:
arxfii"lPT n$rlr ?&f+ hs or,ilrth'r.FT &Fn,r
f0rirn +qryft? fo'Lh+rt+ hq or'h' firu.r! fq.*?"n'fr+
(oa*(.71w n&bh+T (tmUm*l *fuC+T hq ffiAfg
trgotr ?cr:: hF? r+h{teo^ h4u fin oo.ttou$ n"rdrd:-
"(ao-laoft rfl agnor*r hflr* h.gc?? h?4, hlt4h?uf::" /*cqr
2r:r0//,a4lt::
w. nsc& +T 4aot
rlo 0'.9,1,+ rsc& +7 h?g*Looq hq
'D-ftrLf ?tf"
h4u 0?g'n rnn FNlqh nrq xd'I+77 h?u'q fi('",fin+n
hTg,''Lnnnn? f^h}ery +Cnl{. 4os7 hdfl*:: h4u
mqsnLgr hfln?n+ h?4n'rl} t}# 0.ga,*r nu,f,o*
7
hzar* reorLr# fq,h*ft*r footrrht *an ar*tr fr,nF
au1/oa.taornl*? fq,*bfiF ar*nF ffe $io,em**f%t:-.
frr* ilqT rt:rs rg:rtl flft?rt l:rgar rd:r6 li:rf Ii:26 16:13
16:12-f3::
t7
tfszs:'fw" rllb llhj}. *4 +hhnT sc,e hs?T
tt?s hr+^tt'6\s
+n+fi .snnnnsdr:: hscrh 014 rt rd?.qtr
l'rc {qg nnltg/fP h'rqbh?:: fSC4. eT hf7474- tlo
p.(, hdu i,+ ?q+c{lnt hq hg?s1+ hhpt o
"0ll'{l llltuT
?%mr+0+ +"t ?0.:: 0ltf d',tfi +? hneT#1
wq,o* trh+? ghaTs;fo +r+7 rq"+ ('n+r f'u-l
a.o'ffr) h7\", 4.f,++ *oo?la$& f,+C$f\{A:r nruf +7
oor?fr*q o'rd hil ro?qr\ nc nser hg''rh{tf:: r10{
F6 y"Te$r'h+ iltf? hn#- R'lllo ?nr ?@::
??+ h$ ?{?{t firq{| ?+t n+ figfh fihc?
?o,L,r\ tfrnnf f; /olF $;fOr: tr.b? h,pt hq ?ou'hhf
+?ftc +?&o.? f7& h4'-f, ?tf\s h4u r?+ seP ghc.
rf'4n{'r hF" hn.Rq+s n'rnd?q ntf} 't+ 1lc+ f+tl"rlt
hs hn+ o?Jr+ ?aqll"fun+ ootfb", ?d\E dr:: nr|+
on+4r gn"h1 +Trptili k\ry f'thT 0nf "{lf ou,f&
?r?htu o'r?T$r qf,1+ fflf:: ghrt?}+ 4n&+
gtf'ro. hrtu d!r?q$br qg,1+ "'rc0frf hr?+ \?4P+ i$
n,r''I?d'fi'o n{,g' Srit,ffist tFi- hTXo'Lfg {;f@ 9^
?'fl*fi:: f?+ ,14??{1. fttpT "91t2 f?+ f,IT}Fu}.+ nh{u
h?t?+ hq ngufihf +?q/..Tr,r / h2f+'ro." .3eirt:: nltf
+7 ff.o.h'?.fT +f\+ f,nf r+A#T +d\+ ?tF1d.7 hrtu
A"+ hs'r(.+ on{lgd^to*t ?o:: h?.T fto. aro'|t[,p lff
(hl,b? AhTE h4u hn??f+) hfihA',Io+ gcfi /D.fifuf tff-
ooorh& &g,f oofl. ,nf nfl+ h9f;19(rl9'::
l8
t .tr? hgte h{u ?v}'{l glqo n fn?0-+ h"?Tft+
fifi,g hfip*^ ?lfl {r* hq 6,r+ttl{nfe fio hq k"rzg ?}r'l
h/t+ ooVb? g?frtd\:: 'p{l+ hq 'nC+ ?tfr'. or,^ih+
fiP+1 0.R 'tY.r,fi A"gnr+ ,,htlfr ,Eu f nfrcf\ ,*nflm*nt,
filI6f** ?p , , . ::" /*Cqf $:17/ F4fu::
htru n,fnth+ hr" hrfT hf hs" cu+u {uf?r
hr!? a?o'ttl+ h\r-e\ qf!+ ?il'l.fdceo tq* ?fitd-,
?&:: ^fi
rh'lu 0.qc hf\fl stu r+ar hq ssr !0::
0sc& +7 r,t.flr p$p+ ,Bfcqfli hf're"rf"- ftor
h'th?twi,tb c+?t '{lf\ ,g?fdr:: fh4u h"}+ hdr.fha0+
,r}9- fv/i. audrhr Pd, ftrlT na?+ rnl.fnpT
hf,{r?9-:.:
l. {loz'hhf?6. odh {+g''} *lonl
rh{u ho+* nzn ?6'Ig'"tx{l tlu'av?- fls{ft'(' fi,g
?F'thfr*p? hf7e7&:, ,7C f&fld\:: flttg- -?n+ thl-?Y'
m4* ?tf\w h4u fh*-i hrl? {lruhg,T 4,g' .sf}q 0.g.i,+
fo'L.hfi'F XCZS+ tt lt f&-gil d?tt+ ?G;r fh{u g-ry.tthd.V
ho+* ssr ?ot:: h4u u"bz h"* ha-,tflr qdrc
\'ryrffp hr! h7&1f", 97lo^'r.rc .nf ?0r:
tj-tv? 0*.TT{- pc hr/^?-''- h4u flsrrra-?. 4f, fh's-
d\hAq Sef ?@r hf?ehe, ??Cq hn++ fhf).. S,f.Tq
orrufT qffll': | f,h htu ; 1rtl7i S4t+ hq hp.** &rT
?,''L+A h?,er \,'rc fftf::
l9
4. rft.r trF r&h,'ro."t @c$ ?o'rgra oo{l+
AftO t\f f+ @f,f outfr ?nTIt oo',tp a{t|
hhq.e 2^a"r+ 2c 61rqa4- gLfi4r tl$69 ?&:: h4U
'\3
rlfro d\F llfrrnp nllu t\F oo'{14 rne? d\F hh-llc.fcr;:
ZT
r14 f,',IfiAz: fLf?{l e$ g'tql h{u fi{tt {4fi..r n0t
+'lq*f f7& gh$A?dt:: h4U 0lr?.T fiFt'd\ f+ ,IC
hoot*t"+ nnfnn ,{lf 9-74 fLhSA nrl4 nlt.d\ a7 ootfr
f?qC holp.d"Of ffi0 d,e+'rnc (L+C hf'+nl9.zz
72
oowt++ 4f, ]o$: r 4,tT dG fht]ttt .+2q6+
nh?t|.u
7%/-l+ tn+qnn tuih.r +xct h.Bodr.Rp::
nlLn4t' hF,?+ ?IE oo*afiC fAAfo hg.fi+,
$2Q/',.1:-
u. fr,l&- hhrru 0n++c n ?$+ ?oz1q \f
gurr
oo.Uookf ,/o.itbh,t''Foh qfo|. nr?A+ hg6\+1
drrL2'Iq
11. A4*:- {t+1 hf:n} Zn au,filk
.h. Hh - h++',t* g.n+ ngjaF ?ktfT-l
.tCfi arhLdr
o. f@lfl- fi?ioo* tafr'l OCl oopf ht
p. rhF:- h*ou. hA nu,eol nooT h?.e ?1[
tJd.g. ao\ oo"Ii-ttt ?ljt s,tkta $fo"::
23
t. hh4u {rrt**c qtfgD'lr rhrd\h +"tqc nh?.e h4u
nT oVbT ?s'Lft?'lt ls::8
?d?-lq
2. LaoAh fat,?qtu z.f fnf Ad.g hfd\tr? f9allc
hq ?6'r.fd.cn *A ?0::
3. au-Llao* fh4u aultdh*f {fe ?s'L.htu dn+fo
rhr?+ ho4rr- hsd\ ?so.t ookT ?oog;"tn
a'.e.6h+T?+ gs?..gLrat gA ?&::e
".{lf,l'}'?q
f,ur +crrq +hhnf r?rLB a&n+? auf0d\
f{fdr::
h?.r fio fivqo^t nd\ft hrf fittu h4.o(rht rqd,e
hrd\h +"tftd"+z rft hc?s h,rct $oo*tb aqe Lr-r}.
/rh4u 'nr ?o'L?Qo otfTT hL?7fi '?n+ ?G:: '{lrn
of,r n{,n gr!/ro h{u h?.e rlo nye? htrf}. hrfn+
hrlp fild^s e?yfr] (r1r fuf\ gn{ ftir? h?w,
h79Ar[$ g^ ?"{lfdr:: {l+6sb,",I4r h]Lf nd,+
{twt fo nf +"ttta+ r7& f?fdr::
8
FAf ?o,I.hft hSAn ,h hhrtU nfc ltoohh fq.?q6r r oofthd.q|+
?ry,$ h1uff n/"rta* scr-c? rl.?hqh.0
frloq hr*?t l-Atrlba'l'rr
(.q,?E trf#g) rd?.Td\ s.rhc ?M orni ?o::
o
ht.e fro "luft4r flt}flr ?&f+T g*I.frT htf? h?.9 ncp rlffi*
,b7 fi.nlF rlrl"T ?ftf++1 4,emtfi ?{LF oo-gongT af ?slm*flo
nf?.frtu? 'fldp rl"m,g* ,gT4firt AruU rrrCrfi- +4dr fcn.:: h?,* fro
f?rLF a*goa*1 {fr.o.o; fngf} fr.a0hC h?flg nf,+ afn+*
?fL,f'FT tl.b hol$ alofin* ?&:: Ar4r\:- h?.T fio "hhiu n+C
A/t hg*Ah 9Ar oo-l. (O.fl.) fhrtu oz.ttbh+T t(F" '0rh glff*
rfihf,?+ **1 {LfiT hsa4 n1.{ {lrmrn- ?&f+ 4oo7 hfn&fit&f:z
24
fi. ll'l+? nf? hPn+ xl[ arn?.$
n+? rhrn+ ot* n{'rT? o7,h'rk {thr?q?'e
rl'ftrl.f "tg;f ?0:: h?.9 ao'frrl"f h?lLU fi4+T?
^f'?tt h?.9 h4u? ar holrnflf?+ ?+',rfle
n."I.fl".cfi+
{t+ (hdq) ak%?Tn+ afii oo+.ftlfir{' hfifi}:r f,v t1}
?+'r'rQP nlr."fiAL9" hq nfi$far h"n"?lbf\ ?0::
httu tutr4r r"rr q?,r+ tan rrrh{'
hx./t/to h",^F,
tr,* ,B?{dr:: fttrl+ h+trlqTtt $x hdq
hq.Rc 2h7 -?n+ \bq? hfirvd\hn? -tn+ h,sf.nfr: 9114*
h+rqolL 0.9 hdq h.ect rrufr?,t au"frflllDT pn* i PCq+
hq @f?+ qn(r adrln hrd\hhfiwz h7&+7,{l<-
f ec.zf?drl Ahdqr v\ ho' Tfor srn-c ?il'Ll',l fro
h?,q rqh+ hfrih F,+m/^dr::
nhdq 17qd-- r,Pf! '*fi*d+r hart T ?"l?qd--
*dr+f1T r*nf +&nf+ f4;fog":z
h?ftu rhrn+ o** n{+T h.f? hnh AfL+ qno
tlt ?d'l.h'r+- {Tot: nri+*f fi,e$ P{-tuT 0+.(.,2,2'11.
h}&r"lIq b(v1 ih,lu *drtrt{- hTe"fn?{ rafgc?'+
$tFo:: h}&t)-r fr,:Frq l.nll,", n+T ?qnqT
lqqryry gfor: Art'FT h?f fio nhl'C\h mk h{u hd\f}.
grnl.@nnqToi nh4u rn,?q rd'r-g+c.{lq;Fgr: fhtu
9-uct'f ?al.h9"?qftp'T o.R +1" m?tk h?&avt*tg-t
hn'r+1 h?&A"fie ?%rnF+rlTo fhtlu rzadrhp'
nrn f P+ TTo:: h?k ar,"ftrt f {11}' tdgtd'Id r14+T?
25
fil,tr4''r+ fLn?.g 9T4f,r:: n4+ nf+rh ort'+ (.T d'th+
26
?1oo&7 aC +n n+n U.n"lf ?aoo,y1 o+++ f4C4'|j
Hhd ?u,{l+ d,td,E"f h1gtf, l}ft taog.l r+A.n
",rdn f
'r@:: fotf, n72+ 4f, F,F9'.Cq JLa?l f,mq+*A2t L-L
?lf', h@- fldr'g 4f,mdr* os,(t4li or,m44 hq gaeenp
21'r+ d'lkLI hf,t +gh4rtzto pr &i1 ao4rqrnC hs
f pn +7 ftt*T't tt:z h1A firf+ bb pry n1.1 hgl.Ah
@1, h4U ?ooooh?f aT,Ig .rc"lzt
7. *Cn1
+cqT n7\-04ilrr haaltfil+ fiooolk ?on,*'t7l*
't'fi& hq ooil,lh*T nfh+ oo'UooT (fl.O.@) crtq ?++e0
9lrz.gr*,L?lo. ll.Th? fAnr ?-rt6q hT f+9.4 ifrna+
th4u 9dr lo::
ncht el(LB qdrf,eoT (ddnT) +cj77 nt,zl
fioonC hq 9n h}q+ asL+ hq hu++ nt^T& fioognl
'01F HaoTtT +nae hf n?.e hT&Rctr h.TC?fdr::
r?
f1f6[b&t{,c,r.f,n Joseph Van Ess, "Muharnrnad and the Qur'an: Prophecy
Paths to Dialogue
and Revelation" in Chrisiianiry and the World Religions:
Edited by Hans Kung {Garden ciry, NY:
with lslam, Hinduism and Buddhism.
Double Day and co., l gg6); and Michael sells, Approaching tl. Qur'an: The
g. nhnngp nf i.fi1"7
(tt.g?? fr?n{'*+ h9,2
h4u au"ftfLf+ hCft tlhcfifo h}eg,h+&rt hS.A::
a-4uLf+ fvq,s.lf+ hq fihrr\h +"tq/r+ ,l,g
?dtfqt#.re &m6g+ hq o?0.h4'd.fFT nlLn4r h79-
'flhA+: fru+* hq qi-?'I+ f,&m&tvt (tffr nf\ft:F
fu,So* nCfiT Affi/r fii.g,Inq *hf*-R. ?d'Lh%rh Fno
As ug,fi*l rd'I.hd).flr- i^m&Pry nlr"n4r nhf?
f'{ld'c^.ft})r:
+gr qf}. il'D{* r+h{,e h?e &q41 hoo'ttlF
hllr't+ ga''ratll* +aq/r+ Fh4u? o.?n+ hq d).,*ooF
hnh*n(D. hcr'r*'?d\:: hF" htlT ?lr7.ft hrlu nt(LB
oo.1jooft h.fq a.u,6p,Ln hhq& qg4qft ?+Cq7 h7+fr
rlln4r hr"+1 h1ea3.ur? ?dr&rrtt nhrd\h +"lq/.+
t,g ft?.ht,E *l}+frf n0"T n'r'{l+ f+hnhn oafbT
rrll"ftrl{"T dt'fi n ft.+ ,e,?qdf :: nnq,nft +tr 6q /"C ?tf\U
ffio. C\f ?d'L?RC?o. nttl.it h4u frlhq Sftf h'nct
fffi(*g.w1 rhftdrr{ hrI+ nav#:nn f hr^ +g'e
hf,q|d).f :: lLn4f 4f' ?il!.+?n+ &nap+ LF,t'
+'f+fAtf ar.77k ffiet'h:: ,fT+fpf oa?'tk o"ttF
g*7rlro dflYr,gro F,q1,rd\rr rz-'frrl.1Jo$ f11u qg'\+ Lr;1.t,
34
(rr"6sr/E|n90 V', oo+?n, f'{|qT .gUA fur.f1 h?&? &LO'-=
nfdlf d?n$ fnqfiofr:r{ l"mbry+ n,fd\,f h; h+-
nrr?.+fn + *on.qT h"rg. auf,fif ?Aqe +1q/.+
+kr'ttu ilo?',orn,q h4u rft.h h,ect \ot90 lLfifir
$6[b ?.f\ rt0tr w&fr )r,r,lf+ fu?smc hg2 n"f,+]
.3,Trrrt:: nq.q4 +'tq&+ h+?\n+ t,rft ?n*L't of'r
g)f,',lf+ hq+T? ndtbs? ^,g'
faahfdr has'r*I.f nh"n4r
++(lf,l+ Fflef:r
fh{u ulTl ffhnhfi ?or: hiu
ao*?C n}Ln4rl'
ou,htr+q, oaooifp+1 frt"nofr ?t?,o'lf+ oot,PYt
hozs,dt:: h?tlu oont,rP+1 hd|".(to't ?'{l'he fioF /f#7
hh4u ho'rn+hhd\ radl. hq qh.q hfc\h r-667,c\:: fh
h"q'fl ftcn U? a''-l6.nl+ AfLU h1g.
ar,-19.h7 ?o''l-i"+,g
h?.e rdrl f1.on,e .ST{dr:: th4u uz,z* SSf nAl,Fh
f-?f qf,?+ Tlou,l (Modernization) hfnd.d\,"f tuf :z h4U
ghfr? h9-?+ fia'ohfdr ?m*H?l hfi..sr ?h4ry77 n'T,+
(lrruhfCr fhoofil" aa.lb ?t?+ fiT+tdt:: Jfq9' fhCr!
oondf P+ 4f, &rnt 7 {lrzoffrood an*?C'} hd\d.+.(f\1f 1
rr. Lrrln
LfJln ?h4u \tLf, hS oolrbhf,T ?ftC:: f{'4h@|9-
?h411 h?.g?+ h7&gn+rc ?0C:: ooAb'.q/t+ g?qfrl
'flrt" hAft' h?&zohh mf,+f hgo.*rl h4u riLfrln
htlmo 'flF +h''a.+ azhhfr gA hq+ h.e?"d\ ooaA+.
h74. 7o:: h4u fl+Cgh:- -hnu ilz* ?qi raa hrA h4r ,ttm
,@t hhAC /.mao, hrtff nhch (n@) W hiloi tf?f::" /*Cql
3:59/ {l\ltzz
hilv d,r?+&ap
nc h1R.l.me u.tr Lrftn? &mt:z
vqr th9A.n: fhf.rs f.hp herqmc a9+ gi ?(D:;
h4u Lgfltt? fh hq+i hf.rq h.?7 Ra,Io rn h4+ hT
fn hs+ LrXtr::
39
h"r&n h4u ?ahq,.s Aa \s aur h4u h79
hq+: hq+ af,f AF ?oortnn + 1|aaFT hfi.+ 'ttft"
nlaoT ffio. d\f qV67 lr&nl(, r?{fift l&:tt6 atfrfL{"+
hl&v qg,"+ hrt+ n't'fi+ r'f.hnhn hq +1q+r qd.e
hfd\h otfYl gfqrb;: fifr'-dfi g,f ?&nl6 othf
qu49*f i$rrrC zofirn* hq.T ,$Lf+ ?0:: nh?.T hfih
.fif har?tlt hgr'r+f or.i1^ firu.h 9&7'trn +'lqc 1&::
SarC? 0g Lnltl+ g.Ln hS Fa'IS L7 harlhh+ hLtft.f
fh4u ?ftf+ hT ootl|thtF+ hn*ruc++ 2c gd'Llec
to
lflg .t{ (0.4) 0+6111& lZjff* *n* LQ,f (Nicea) nhlJtrt +Ch
^,9
ofr't hhg+dAr ho,*I hq ho,Ll r6t'{l h,l}rtlq {17ffi s'lg,A a?'f
0rI00 lL.'':[ c++ 4f, hr/ ** co,, @&q h+a.tLf ?f411 flf i.g'
h?.T he?ndr hsn\ot,f ?tt +fi'fln0 ?0C:: 0ll.U n'nflq 4g' l0C
h'|.A.{tdtflp+ h.{t4rq, kr6 tn (o.fu fi?flg}} hq 4.lrilh+T?+ $9
or,trlr+? hr4hl+ hs ?+g.Lt'*:t g4hft d?A-Tri'{l ?tfia0. 14
(g.fi) hhrru 2C h?.R hq hhr\ {fo 'flrt fi\ooT 49 l0:: g'r' 67fi-
yi.{t tLri (o.n) hdtttw hgD+ 0.t.fl+ h}&ntn} flF+ htnzo h?.r
Lnlt7 At ?o,rg hn h{l&Yar'|[ fhf?} ooool,f 2C n+'ff ?d!"2*
lcr:: Lh4f ft.dr (o.fi) ooLrtC gfhfi+{tr i hriu /tdo A.{+ f 4+
hs hT?+ {lrt : h6?$0t d\F hlx-I"gh'tT gqlilo .s?+ $q Aoac?f
h1&gfihp+ 7u{16;1r- qnil1r. o}} \$ '{lf}' th+f&hzz htf f
*?+ $q fL.g,c4+ qo,Ii,r $?k qd\,fefiT u'.\f gtt h?,9'+ lttr?
,gT4du? 'fl4 fiffT:: &'tl6ilf :- h4U t "7 hfro HfqA"' fl"rl
a.DfiA{}:r 0nr drftf .,(r goocq|f ,\E q.fi (0.n) fh4u tr\ +'flA@
9qlfii*:z *h' Vtt ?d'Lhft ?tIF::
40
l&:rt1 h4u hgl}Trolf $ntC ouhf qv4g+ hF" gif
lrt!:: Lfrbn hF? Ct+v fttflo. h4u f'fih afUur th4u
tdt f+fq fll&q oAdhtT lo::
hN, ?alcgr dE (tf\o tl.r$0 h.t4,Aq|!+ hq o.R
hCfr. h?4,trllo. /,l'llttr;: a-hd|"fT flrfftn ooooAh
h?A inl ag^'fl pr\h+ hsc?@ .BrDfi&fdr::
oogfjrtl.d0^
hfftn ag f kc fl'?adfin* ?.ru r?>+ hq
faodtdhfT?* a'ffi hf,f LdDlry:: h4.n 6\g,f gJr
hf,nQf :: f.A,h}f- hftnU Aoo.ttoog n@Lg4p^ ,p1q1-
f,oo/rttzz gho'r++ oot, fioolf}f oot i 4f. ,ll1l. L+Sq
.F4+ f;jr ?aLaru,nt@".T gnill f,mddr::
14. h.ntd??
'h?
rlLn{r 2+ ?\@frru* h+c11q h?fLs oa,uook
v1
(n.0,s) T'lac ('fi&n) ar ?&:: r\h h?.9, *cq", r?fLF
72'lc (rhr'.n) hh{u ?o:; }Lfi{o't%* vz,t* tUrfr"rr
45
r$r,o+ ncc .g,qndd\:: $firlr"t nr"nleffio.q hflft'T
s'te f+ 2c tuf &4s ?r'L'rrtry:sz 171-l+ .g?rrtdr::
h4u nhd?ryT hls1k rDl,PTr h}&w+ ftldr:: nA4
nIl.A g+$fi?. p6pTr hTeg,wt .ghnh4Jr:: ctu?$
tt bT h"{ ?tf'ro- h{u fitF \* hlg? l?c htrhrr qgla
$g,f rzos+.$ f,"Tdt@:r
$qr hn4d?? c'tv/;lefifi hh"ntf \ra hnhA+,268r
lg*dA,n ual gmhA/ tt"l a'rg'",nl+ .3T4fi-:: @f, *z
oa}'ls ?a'L@/r(b ?qh{'l+ ao/,$ hi+{&& ?1f,i1g,. hfiu
hretg +aq/,.*t 1f4d. dF,ffi,t#w h"r&w+ f,"I++d\::
fI0"T? glqD 0+'t,cl' htrhtr 4f.gc,z** h?,&lr*
f,m*d!dt::
h?llu Lr-ft ar+ oh'f ?'{lto rLft{r fl olr'F
9,\+flb:: ll?tlU h.ntd?I? v"l ?&+940-t
fr?aurc ?hfTel&-1 Ao h??n*& 1hg'ft+ ooutt"'rc+
^.9 ft
hs,l"+ .ghd.ut::
r.'lf..f 3. ?+1"+9 5. f+hihn
2.rnl@.gg 4. 9frni
r8
nfl.gc /I,e 41T0"7r fuh FcDfi,e oomT d'tnhd.A o?,r fih/.nl
'r?n,gc nlLfi{r hAhd\ h?.gvl LFfl {loo-foaif pry ?hg,ahk hq
rhcnlq hr?++ r,fhflhfl !fic:: F,tuT h?e ftaahhnfe fimT
rrn+i ?h@-eT hcntffT ?hrl+**t hdrh4 ,fn n,fn
*f,to.,fCr:r nht,FF O*i "?ov'64.f arcTq-' ryryci. nnu fill-df
fh'lu? ua hflqfu &'rfi. ::
47
15.flrfulP rhfirlnn /,'lcq+
h"nqP 0a'?u0l,dfl. ot't or'Ntrg- /,l-9',lqc
h?&n'++ 2(n-$tTl+ oofr. g-lqc ht&+Tn ?fiad\::
f,ut ho-t fld?.eL? gh9D+ hnq0n Fcq+ h}&fao.
a?g|"?1 h79 h?g oo7.l* 9rn+au"{;ld.A:: fun4P
n07&,f arl*P ?19 trnGb+ ?a'L''rq ffio?+ h$r\ hnh
f+ sntfT h7e/10+ n"rrd fn+f,nldr:;
n'nn r06{t ulb+r Pcq+ f ht hfiqnn?
?(''L76rfr rrl ho't*?dr:: f.$f ?a'Lfh++$ h0.1f
us.|+ 7\$7 nft+ gaqo hus.|+ 'trtP n+6rc't4 fiv*1
oofrL',l |0:: h?.9 fio rhnrlnn /*cq+ 'r{.a +'flft"
gs'Lhftfiof f4r77 ?ou'lr,uen 79.fi rl.nft Af t&:: gil+
hq ?@7s hnqnn Pcq+ ?+h?n+ nffo rn2f+
n+d"'nf fficr?+ tCffo auhff+ ?&::
lLh4f nfufr ha}&r rnfl? 9A rhnqnn o'l
hrlo:: a1eng- Af+r /-Cq+ fhd'. d\{ln ar'rfihr
n}}a+ f{tft" h"?nnn hq ?fi* r\F n.fic? a+ hd'r"fhc?*
haq0dT h?&c+ nh"n4f ,-un?d\:: a7* ,\F t-h(Lr
fLf?n hhf'fiC+ hnh ?C\nt f"'LnS? n4 fh d\'fln szfinfi
f,tcfi*Cr:: f,Y rl'f?fro gs'rf,TrlO ?ooo,L\O "tb.tl
lo:: rlf4rt:- hdtbc *9'.nl n{ln h,qqqf, ou,O^4ri
hg,L+gA+T:r r!* d\Fr h&+ nlorq hh,I? nu?|,fl
hry.z/t.t f+q &f?n g16z hq a?,,rt hhfif? go'Lns? A+
9h d\{ln a-odrflft ,srnntrlfdr:: h?&1k t't++ d'ffitt hq
co&+tdf'f *fC oon&"r'i gca|CnlJl.:r fLU t.e?+ hfiqnn
tr{a?cn no0TATq fi&+T aohhdr hnnd.'l? ?+9&\ f*
u'odtt.fi"rq ?a{uneft'fl ??rn*t il+fnc fudr hooh{hdr
?o:: f,ut ghiqnn ;olcq+ oofltlil of'f s?htlC ?Z*7
th4fl h-th'flc ?6'Lth,rnc l&:|
fun4r h+4c nd,+ *r7+0'7g" nfi,+ +n,*fr hq
Aorl{l ?t'L?++ .CC?+ g*|f',dlJt:; }?C A? n*"?t}
.P?AT aohhf\ n.q,+ gd'L+rl+f! hf f10{1"{l go'L'r+4-
+?qa.+ g,na;r,ffh::
h}slk rhr,qftf? rI+ AF s"6? h?r+n$?
rp+g.t'ttu ho?s Ar rn,fT h?x,rflT hrymAh+ ?{}
,srtfh:: f'v hho?.f* ,9C y'?9" aT)'r+ FArlo hrrn
?o:: nlLn4r ?H{l rflndT $r67q h7''rf-7 fi"??fl
r?lal+) fr+ nu'0e+fift" n?.r h'{lc ,gfr''tl.fcr:: / cq+
qAo hnqnflr ?fo?k trF n,T,+ n't/*'Ir"f hoatfT
*,eqiTr: lLn4-?T* rhnqnn FCq+ ?r+h*tr rI+
hu{t/+rlt}- ?rfn+'rA i.& a..?.ilih+ "{rhb?* d\fh.{t+\
f,'Iqill hh rntx,+ s'l/.?r,f *fi h.g,qfl|slf"' gg''L'. ?@::
h"ft{r .rn?.('fl il+q $79 h}&+4+lb! h?'e. fflrle?
n"?,+ hu,o*n+n h?'q.f,hh+q A+ fhiftfin /-cq+
h}&h+ft f?sf.F r,''I.ffrhlrlc Ttc n"flfitb 4f, .fir
?lrrl+C hF,$1 oottlp. s,tt fiettft.? ?d\f4cn rsffbT
fn+fl"C\:: ?&*f hq.f hq T4 ilAA ?o'rf'fa ?@:r
49
JI+? AF no?.e d\f f,nf {lfl" rnaB* c'tt".td,f
nr.el r.? d,lger ntt hq h'}d\tt hg,ghf:: h7wr
nh"ntf f+hnhn h-fi'tlht +?qC ?&: t ?oo.ni.f rI+
?t?+ go,L,trloo n(tr6rq +CL q&tfT Bq$t" hq fio,r?,,*
n+Ah ?&:: r,l.Af &4o.? rit?n.gn+ hol,fithfor.i
n+fffio hq rlortl*u*** h?&au?,* r+,'rL'g.+ grfi/"qb
'clt" il'rT hh"n4r hg,* nqc?+ o,toak ofr't 9b
T:fo::
50
ghh'. t,}.ft+f nhhr\ {lP/,-$b qh9- ?ou,(t''l/.+ oa l+
h4;fo::
n+n.e ooutLfv Vfd,rf*? *fuc++ ooqC
$a\&-f nfiff 4,9 arl.f ]8:: n+6n6'rdf ht}n+f
?*?+ $n'fi", a,r??d\?d\ n+nfF ?hwf+ tlcffT r+hh
qn,f"f P+ n"f+ ,e?Qdr:: nrdA:- Ah+CTI oafobT?
ho'rrrdP+ hs frfrTr qnaa-f,FT*
fi+nrg 4?vn/'.v, rb?+ h{ n&frnr ?Fb
rafihT qf, g"?d+* Frrrrlml* efra.fp+ fin* tlbf
flt\ftn+ t?u0efi,n oil.t rry-f+ ar..ftr1"rT s4t+
hq1l4+ rl"qd\ ?Qfrou^f h'nd+ qnqfio' ?F/r aalrhT
nho+* aott?'l {4* r\v7a;Fp,3T4dr: :
ft+ d\F hnt-?? ho+* h?,s+'tc lhzg*aazl
hq h"n4r?? /:9,-r'.+7 hq .R,roTz {+Tn lto?,qc
*na*.frlT:: fro ?os\C oo,(l*? oa2l^$
^s'ITf
hlr.n4f hn+fuf, .2C ?{-1/'C +"qC ?&:r
o"tk d\F nft+nfl. (fr""n+T nd\,qfr hq hhcf! 2c
nqlf++ rf+ flaue#) f1'tli 6\"nnl oomilf, h{
fauttn#+? oowlf,e s4ifto"l fio'?,ry4+ ?oo?htth'n
at4f hafi*:r ft+ d\F aa+4c 'n+tr}r h?,w 0s4tf
hrrlr? nn++C fft+nt? mwtfq, S4{+T ?q1t4+
'ltlf fnq+9'z: ?{LF ao-$aaft (ft.O.o; "hhq?+ auhhdr
5l
.g0ttlP ho'rT ttfho. ,ld'[n* ?0firn a.ilttP ?Vlo- 'ro.',
'llfl?f,r::
55
rn*Qc ft, h%t$ ha?6fo ftqa6.nrb* /*e*t/r
hqu tt,977 hr4iFo.7 nh&fu oa?Ftl. ttAtu fe
?4a?*t tlf hcntffnrr n-607r flUhnqrb
fhau nr Mqt fol,orlaiFo oahz,qnr nfl,kF
,nci h4ur ,galf*? razltuh? rto nhc?T
,ez4"lt ! hrlu illc* hlftr, ?&f::,, /*c1r? 22:39,fl/
f,vr t?n+ 0*cgh n?Ao h1g+*oT,rn0f- ao"frr\flT
?g'rv q4;F0 ?ru n.\4 fif 4F hrr'^,fio.t nn?+
h}qght& n.gr\ wl.*cnryFo ra4 hrt+ +hdr+
"sq
hfb rp-ftr\lll'T +?a*o h"sq dt+s ?,1 ?6t@"rq+ 1144.
hnq,F{I}::
?h.F+ LFft' Ug6+ lo*htqgo1gm f1 A4 hg'm,l+
+h*f,l h{lcq 1,fir,+ no?.p/r il9.1"+ r^rg,?l} }+n
s;fo:: LFfl.r Ao z*eT ?o?rAh hq ?aolrnoT r&q
?aoh+dr ?r?+ l-t1o. gzQdr::
fhf?+ rnQ{ ?tf'ra- h{u h}&u 'flrb 0?r\f
hn+fCIfdr:: "nzpqf* o!'n?x,t frlf::" /ecq? Z:ZS{
f,uf of, *"u.F h4{t ,p,@n.R€dr:: fr"U.t ?orl.hft ,fd\
+1" tctst- @f?h nf,r re+ o'tgl't a'rrh+ tutf?
s'I}To.If +?qC ho".l"Of ?a'L(.Lt hsff +L*l
f\+fc\:: 4.u,9 n+'I.,f Jnc?+? ro,Lg-,hhF ,fd\
h,gf.n9-t: h?43 nq,+ og,f hop,ttr 'II}qh, bhT
a?+.fif 4.u.9 illf? ,3T{fir: h7&0'.9- f.EC 4,g, q}ui
rp4p$ hhd\?+ h"r&(rs? aru,1?q|Cg', H.u,e..gq4d\::
56
{lhn4rg- 8\ nhcsr} "+rl"n {nc?+ " rqqA mc
ffif;: f,V f+{q fn"US }Cao'f ?p.r: h?n}f npfi
rza-frrt{"T ra4 hr?+ +hc.r+', hn?,ggs rrc'fttl.P
fl',l.f,*,Cln*l f?q6 +&n 1nC?+ '{lrlo f,m+,ff\ $4ft-r:
lfq'. nh"fi4,l' fA4 hf?+ +nd-'fT? hn?.s.e. o*htt"f
qrn d"b,t6 r+hnhn +?qc t&::
nhfi4f &\f ra0*S lLu* ?c'Ltf?n+ o?t
hi:: ??C a7 r7 r7 ^F, l*9ry4 ?o ftLf h19. H"u.r
?s'Lf|mhf0. ?eLhd'^ orrT +f+ ?0:: rnc?+ r&uk
olit'l ?ry"{o&{D. dhqu +'{lft"q h{U {ftfazrno U?q
f,?'{l onwl* (ur? ?e.:: u{l} As'r,lnni hu'lci. tl$?1?
fiilCr Ah,tlcr fi.*?nc '{lrt' sv'P2* n$&9l' hnu.g rtfrnC
h.g+c\p:: nn"u,g (nc?+ nAn + $c?++ 4,s ?6',rf'fK
&nI too&/qmc 't'{l+ .q?il+ hr}}r: fiP+ hh&LFTt
fioT,{l+d\ our?24 hrb.r hn.u,r h,gfmcf.z
h?tLF ov-Uoa? fvB,o* fdn fr.uf h?.9+ gth1.t
hl%hn+ ?u'Lf4r77 'rt +flhf hqrTh?:: ?&B oo-$oaft
?aln\ u?fiT? {lw4n'l?- oa77k $9. }Ln4r ftq+ m7\&
+hftf llnryTrl^ ?flC:i or,'nilf fiorltfqTo. g"hlf+
.{lr ?fL$ hq +h *"Ffs hq,e n*f. .(c{tq,f?rr:: 6li+'{l
f.rfbqr,P^: hulc +{lerPd\ t i +,(,{t.qfl?t\
+'lcl*?d\ T
57
rD'nrL't"T f"v t -ft ohtn hq h*9, h?g,efiq,Fdh
wttry? oT'lk h?pr.h+tt hq h9.,2 hTeg.q,cnqno-
{rh+$1 h}&n{l* hqLg?lllo). h"n{'?t oaso(,f
htd.??flIf:: ?fLg olo^,Uoo* ifO jnf* oul\ arlrf
h"nfif? hn+r?+ 0lrt fiChf ?o?o,tt.,f/te?'n ltqftF hq
ootPT ?tLB? ng{l+ hoo'lf,,dr n''I{tc h*fifB ltrp,+ 2c
ft'?0C nthfrlr f*odtlnl frc 2f-h ftf;ftou: h4u
llrufiflh \,{taa hc'ltrT?+ tt"\ftT lt}llF nd?d@+
fu(rffwl h,rdrn::
furrlTo
qfift0+ &n"+r XLg ao-1)ooft 1d.o.o1
hoa\ o.9, @&q +n.g,sr!:0 freryfir ?{LF? (f1.o,0) hnf?t
a*{+ rr*}a h.rc?oaf?cr:: *1*$r hr*q4fi ve
ru"hrttloF $ft h?&fiq.e ?.T ?s,Ltf?ft+ gzn g/rh:t
?fLF aa-goakT (A.o,o) ^f- n2h
hfg. ood hq ?fl,fi, 0S+CT
nrT,+ g++flrr+ nnfnd,L", nr+tlo"- @&q ofiT ?6,Lq+
u?n+ frt,Ro o,R,?cr! h}&@fn +t, hg.zT4;fo::
(lo&qf Ln4d?3 "d\d
rllrr{ta.t{l +lTfl+
?llg ao-t}ouk
(A,O.o) o,R, lr-n4f ti ?d|kLa wic?t +rrdh.#st
*rnfl'::
?ol\ ,ffc ?g,A h"ft4f' ?Lg orhUook"rq hU$q,
hfi+fpve*-1 nh?f- hq Aaurruen tru nd'tT6+ fCrno.
'o ?fLf, an[aoft (.t.0.0) haah g0g ffi&q f g/'t-* nf,+ Yn& gauqd\
g,c ffirdl:: Ln{"?E ?+T hsrrlrnC (hr1?,g.C) ga''Ln9'aeo"f h''U n*]
?p:; hfu?g{. hHb, pnf ocT fuf++ hf74?e ac ?ryr:rae.
h4.n g,r/* horqTn* 0A* lprt f,rt hsalrnC ,2 fc,e, o*4
h?n6+ tTfv,* rt{l{- hfr?,f,,c ,voefu*f,
2c ?&::
58
l0C:: hoa".ttttot n+'nC hn? gdlnrrn@ hq 0d??q
gilfi.?e @/ft 29A hghlata*e 'tl+ aLA 1}nnfo h^u
frao.fr/U,loT aooqoodf ?l! hdi|fid0?{_ )g,o'rq''+@?
(hrl4,+@1) Aaoh4hdr h44of h'r&ihft &f.R4'Fo:: 'I
6t
f?fLS oo-tltoox (fi.0.o) Qdrgzq? r+hq sad,
r?n6+ ?oo\ootfs tfL+ hfh0hc (L.o,\ hg-qll?
rn.(?n tft reol hn+&fr{, a9 {r&9 fltc f|.t\h ?o?]0.ec r
19. d,g?ftq*hffl"X.
h"ft4f? f\S n \.9,R,C?G {lrt/, h}e, h+hhnf d,g,?n
pC a*.lF flan f! fqln.',r,'7- anlfl. ?{p:: a-.ftf1"pT
ng?{? hrn?fs )g,qf fg hn+ruf+T A";rrm
he+ftr'nAe frqrt::
,F"*tf+ tor,Qg0^ wftsnifq sT,g;beTl hildp
g^r1 h,firtu hfrrT hr4h ?rn:r nnltu h7& pr,*tq*l
hh?e, ft4,9?n)il,t* h&Tc\?p:;
a*frfi"r+ h{u ht"mlfr \.lc rf} +l"t6v
{fi,s?ftt) |t+q il"?Tn+ ,eT4A {lnfi}. fr{lbil
63
lrrl-nr\s'+ +d.f&v, ?"er-T", nd?'nc.&+ n+irc 4.9
hf,Tmimrt9-r,: h?,* ru.ftft f *hf b+ s'lh+ h{U hd.fu
hft+a'ntir.s +&ffh? ut+ d).65L nf? *\f 'tn='+,
h*ho"lo- lll @f\n ha,hm* ftA of,f nfL4
^s'r'r?ti
rh79+ ?s'Le68l#s \1c+ h?,fir?'- frqfr:r 0+srQar
qhf f%nfi+ \,IC+T ns?.{llr{r+ &g,f ?il$T ,\F h?.e
d,e?iq ref, rl,g fhn+1 hrt|Ft?+ hoofr+r"1 |lqd\
+qfbq .''/r,{ll,6f?+ ou*l{l ffiqf ftf'::
hhfl4qq hft+ruf ,9c ?E'L,26f, h1kr d,g,?{q
hw\*f' $\ trrrrnr r$\ fi.g?fr? lkl*4rfi'{t frlfll'u o't?f
ppp d,s?n ?s'Lgcfrqsa} ?T'rT rh{u? sTe f+ hF'fl
.r?+? f*sz ,gnd\,T h?.k"ra& ?0 ?o'I-f 9c?7:t fl][u to
it"n4'- d.s?dg &n&p+ 49, Tq+ h}kqgc"t
"T++1q
?ry}++?q *c??r (fthr 4'g ?d'l-',rT rhqu +916+"1
{s'Itc d"Ftl h?.ctrnt$ h?.eqfi+vFz ?,'''Lf}l?:: nhc?'T.
+ct? n]tu flaT ils'L'IT,* 4g?fr h,er* ?il'Lfihanl
{l+Cfl- sa-fr flaa.r} ?ffi+ hn.g,q* dg?43 oolnP+?
Sg.drtt lr.ntlf ffro d\F f''T++ orrufTZ
htxTm*leafo f"+&Cr:: qfir? A*lnnC\ +?d\
h?,n{*C?'- 7f.+ fgc.zC\:r }Ln4''. f*hfrtqn ornfiTZ
{1fi,2 ,g,fntd\:: *hfft"?LZ fl,T+f* fiovtfrg- C\??n?d\n+
h?T4fi?:: *hffi'R" {l/.r} *&f mfnLg, h,g.RnTzr l"nlt,
fft{nt? do.+t ffi6} CrF? r,Fr} ttf,o+ efnnd\ rl""Td\
??f, d't!Pd\ ff ,4r,1+ ?0r:
hP+ fh"n{f? U?q oooot'| {lttf'di.d^4s
tl+ttoufi* ?n\.oot,!ft ipag {,S,?ni qgrrs .rAg,q
thfrl-H. h'fi{lo ?{lC:: flh"fr4ar lhf 9?n+ f*/'-7
{
fit{'{l? nh"?h+t,i n&nhfi: {luhPqs fi4'e?n: n&ih
Tq'|-: 0u?1 Tn'fi: fi1-'t-trI,}.s3 nhcfi-rxci {ld.it hq \
nAir afrhT n.g rcrc h.gc?(} rlaafih d.r?+ hs*f
hn+VAP hnCh*'Pf,r:: 't{+*Z ha,z,t*n oual,rn{?
hrThi g'tg"t& fig+ H?"l ?ouhn"r tl*ffif-
crrrrfT s;fp;r ,flF orrT$ ouwLfg ^9,1tft+T
h4ftPTt Afr{t'u:-
'ohc\nfih" ?ol,{# *,tc (ht}.? ?r?'tn?d\n+ "h'r2&?fry"
(rtf) *Tc (nt4'ft hrr* hs+f hn+"&? f$eh*)
(lrnhlrAfp tlat? i?n+ hpf fftfT fn+lPcn*+ sa"ftfi"fr.
rtlbT $Tcr:: h"nfi'?q hn+rue rh(}cT rdg?n
h.flr+ h?&f{l'fl{ h}8."ffi?T+ fg.a7eT {,e?{E ?g+-
UA.q &+6hzt
0ru'ft{t"oo' 1^r gqf'?,nq ?^f'7{? orn*T il*'I+
?+'I+dD- htluf hd\f; 4-to frn+o h?:f hsnwefv
flln49' moalfq hg-?+ sTLT?t fi.ff-+ ?&::
69
21, a7efn*hf
h"n4r nnnfw? ?r[ fh h?tl'n ?+oihiq '{11}
nttrnrr ,rA+e+* nfi* l&:t hn4r gwilrr
t ^p+r
Fqtu: Fq:pct rg,+c aoqqd\{ gr$t4 nrt* ?@r:
)
hntr 'fn* Srlt+? rprif iltf\* h{u h{r\C a-firn*
) r?n+ lw:t lLn4r hh{u n+c A{ hr4h fAP:: hf}r
h
70
hrfi+ rhftt\Pq oowt++ r"?h+#+ tf#:-
I. hhttu n+C rI4 hf4h fAf:: ?lLF r*1!aa.*'l'
fhiu o'Arth+f Sfo 'flrt" 0d\'il hff ntdr
ou.alu'tlhC:: a
,r?prrq+
4. {lf,weT {pC mff
5, rrl. fip flh.eo?$. h?f ?rL ,fiF s,rg{a:;
H.u.Tt aul&* f?.9 ?s:r H.ug lr-ftftd't? *At+?q
moatfp+1 frqfl iltf? hsTcrp:r fr.u,T rhAu? wl4f
+{lrt" ?d't g.ea tra ?p.r: hfrrld?+ n}Ln4r
^q'tT+f+o?ll +?flc ?&:: fis&r H.us +'flft" lum*
n"f\s
h,gTdrg':: h/tu {l?f,*rt'+ c?n?n,* ?^r {1f1" hur&dr,,
fflp d\F m,(lf-+q fd^^'tft? fa.rr,g.11^ ?,1?.'q f*hn+
S*cr:: n}unrif fft'FT "?q h$+f ?&:: &.e+f o?,q$
hht\ {lctlf$;Fo f?f[p. h{lg fl"fl.qf6" .rfi&Cr p6.:; htU
llf 4,g 9,3fr1 naU.ro'{+ hfiAr? sFg'q fifio d\,q$
tloqft' osavt,f h.rf,t h?g.oo./,mw il*cgln- lh8.c\:r htu
frls d\,qT firu"rb ftfufi4r 'ficy? *oo'C+T o,g,ct'h /
-t.i
I
7l
22. f0rh&ar. O'rttfloil
hF'fl s?+ ?tf'ro- htru h?rn4 u?n h78nll7
h{s *d}tt 9'U g+tnt'n+? ?rn4 fbdt 4q'71'n+T 1u:P
oft'I' ,e?frt '{lrlo n\'r+7 120 fLfi.F? '1rlhftP+ pC
fin*ftw Frzcuen *r?lrti toumln r*+t+ &ho,ITdr:r
l ?lgqr fiPT? fid?44+ firrohh4fo- hflroTtqli
]
'r.{ri *,o\?+q fnc?+ n ffis? rr}" +??ffc\::
ttcil?qq+ {g ?*nwl,* wtrf} 0f?ne f t+ l"nltF.1
ad?af,,n+ hq il9q71 hmfal fi"?d\ 'r0^ f,v77 rurrhs
ArrufiS f*?dfiti*tt
u,grn* h"tc a7 h$C ?T:: g,t i-,go* +hhnfo
r+&$c?n+ *4s'|17 (h?.t t"rrl/,? *f d?rnh) fiaro/j|.t,t+
h{& ml, ftr}- *f1+? ft6,t;rnn hqh?q+ hAqT ?@:: ,fltl.
h9o+ hft.c rrg,o*Tw"t *4tP u{l+ ,fir nd?hd?fi+
frfqhi+ gn+?frdr:: &ntd filLft4r hc'lrrlr+ hwe*Tzt
,'l{t*g nltneq ilngnF'rv il f,ho. ?r1 ,hf,o f+7
h?.g$ftC"l f,l*fl$dr:: {lSC's. +7 nfi ilft+f+7q nn
hn?fit *Lf h"tmf*h?:? f\ h6'L+cftd\? +f*P+
+.1&$7 auCrfi haofrm* gy'Tql,rpn* cp** hth1 ?fr::
f,v arffrhS 4rl#-+ $r1+ 1nf4 hnd\f qT
tl*amnh* f/trnifio^ *fuC+T? {lou,ou,ch?f ffiSh+
?&:r lmffrh6 fn h4u ht|t+T hcec' h?'e..hr fh
$?'rflffq hu+{ }*{|c fisa hr*fiflr ?flcil fqhr
h?ft hr|I+T u?l'n hr?+ fif'rw? hfic\rq? fio?o'I}n{l
72
f"t'rT zutrrh$ hd'l?ln'fl ?$fTt-T ffi"Tlt h?q&PryTf
hooh?Sftt}:r nnlLn{f +*-mc'tl, ooLE hd.n,lT*
"1f,Af,/,1t.i$lam is.com ?a'Lhfu? *lt&-'rfl+"r7
oz,i'flT+
*TqtTD:: nn U +nlf, t-6+7 4,9, f4T.{f.z ff,+'
hn+fr+ o9,r *Ln h{,9 flf?ngft s.trL?tr {l+firn T : I