Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Analisis de Principales Metales en Vinos Chilenos
Analisis de Principales Metales en Vinos Chilenos
Analisis de Principales Metales en Vinos Chilenos
2010
www.rcia.uc.cl
research paper
Talca, Chile.
2
Chemistry Institute of Natural Resources, Universidad de Talca. 2 Norte 685, Talca Chile.
3
Instituto de Pesquisas Energéticas e Nucleares, IPEN-CNEN/SP, Universidade de São Paulo. Av. Prof.
Lineu Prestes 2242, Cidade Universitária, 05508-000, São Paulo, Brazil.
Abstract
The most widely used techniques for the deter- et al., 2006). Metals have an important role as
mination of major and trace elements in wine are catalysts in biological systems, they partici-
AAS and inductively coupled plasma mass-spec- pate of important redox processes, and some
trometry (ICP-MS) respectively (Ough and Am- are essential for the metabolism of wine yeast
erine, 1988; Aceto et al., 2002; Thiel et al., 2004; and bacteria (Pereira, 1988; Aceto et al., 2002).
Coetzee et al., 2005). So far, several published Alternatively, the content of metallic elements
studies of mineral identification in wines from has been evaluated with nutritional and toxico-
different world regions have had the purpose of logical purposes (Puig-Deu et al., 1994; Boul-
surveying the content of certain metals and test- ton et al., 1996; Suhaj and Korenovska, 2005;
ing the wines provenance, or region of origin, Ribéreau-Gayon et al., 2006).
including South Africa (Coetzee et al., 2005),
Canada (Taylor et al., 2002; Taylor et al., 2003;
Considering that metal ions have a determin-
Greenough et al., 2005), New Zealand (Angus
ing role in important wine processes, and given
et al., 2006), and Germany (Gomez et al., 2004),
that, to our knowledge, compositional informa-
among others, mostly European areas (Muranyi
tion of this kind for Chilean wines is scarce, is
and Kovacs, 2000; Barbaste et al., 2003; Maren-
that this research was undertaken.
go and Aceto, 2003; Kment et al., 2005; Kore-
novska and Suhaj, 2005; La Pera et al., 2008).
Materials and methods
The normal content of Fe and Zn in the grape
berry is quite low, but their concentration can be
Wine samples
greatly increased by effect of dust, pesticides res-
idues, and other forms of contamination (Ough
and Amerine, 1988). On the contrary, cations
such as K, Ca, Na, and Mg have a much higher Samples of commercial wines were obtained
natural concentrations, especially in the grape directly from wineries located between the
skins (Storey, 1987; Iland and Coombe, 1988; Ca- Elqui and Itata Valleys, or purchased from local
banne and Doneche, 2003). A series of published supermarkets or wine stores. A set of 75 wine
studies have reported concentration ranges for samples elaborated from six grape varieties,
some of the major cations in wine, none of which both reds and whites were used. The white vari-
has included a significant amount of Chilean eties Chardonnay (n = 9) and Sauvignon blanc (n
wine samples (Ough et al., 1982; Ough and Am- = 18), and the red varieties Cabernet Sauvignon
erine, 1988; Lazos and Alexakis, 2007). (n = 19), Carménère (n = 19), Pinot noir (n = 5),
and Syrah (n = 5) were chosen to represent the
The significance of metallic elements deter- following wine producing areas: Elqui, Limarí,
mination in wines has to do mainly with their Casablanca, Maipo, Colchagua, Maule and Itata
influence on wine stability and oxidation re- regions (located approximately between the 29
actions (Boulton et al., 1996; Ribéreau-Gayon and 38° latitude south) (Table 1).
Table 1. Wine samples utilized for the analysis of abundant metallic elements (K, Mg, Ca, Na, Fe and Zn) by Chilean
wine area.
Table 2. Analytical conditions used for the analysis of abundant metallic elements in Chilean wines by flame atomic
absorption spectrometry.
80 ciencia e investigación agraria
nent analysis (PCA) were performed using the L-1 for white samples). The results of Table 3 in-
commercial software package, Statgraphics dicate also that red wines have higher absolute
centurion XV, version 15.01.03 (Statpoint tech- concentrations for most cations analyzed, with
nologies, Warrenton, VA, USA). PCA was used the exception of Na.
as a method of data reduction to allow the con-
struction of new uncorrelated variables known
as principal components (PC) (Kaufmann, The content of metals across wine varieties
1997). Graphical representations of results were
performed using the software package Sigma-
When a comparison of the concentration of
Plot version 11 (Systat software Inc., Chicago,
metals was performed grouping the wines by
IL, USA) and Statgraphics centurion XV for the
grape varieties, a large concentration variation
PCA analysis.
for most of the ion analyzed was observed (Fig-
ure 1). Overlapping concentration ranges were
Results seeing for most of the elements analyzed, except
for K, where white varieties (Sauvignon blanc
and Chardonnay) showed a significantly lower
AAS analysis content than most red varieties (Cabernet Sau-
vignon, Carménère, and Syrah).
Table 3. Summary of the concentration of abundant metallic elements (K, Mg, Ca, Na, Fe and Zn) in Chilean wine samples.
trations of Na, for both reds and white wines, varieties or region of origin were compared.
were encountered in the wines produced in PCA only showed a reasonable degree of dis-
the northern regions (Elqui and Limarí) and crimination when white and red wines were
the lower average contents in the wines pro- compared, influenced mainly by the Na con-
duced in the southern areas analyzed (Maule centration of wine samples. A graphical repre-
and Itata). sentation of the prior is given in Figure 3. From
this plot, it is clear that red and white wines
can be separated in two clusters. The analysis
showed that the distribution of the variability
Principal component analysis
was mainly explained by two principal com-
ponents (which eigenvalues were greater than
or equal to 1) that accounted for approximately
Even though several combinations of the ele-
62.7% of the variability in the original data.
ments under study were tested, poor discrimi-
nation possibilities were found when wine
1600
1600
K
K 1400 Mg
1400 Mg
1200
Concetration (mg L )
1200
-1
Concentration (mg L )
-1
1000
1000
800
800
600
600
400
400
200
200
0
0 140
160
Ca
Ca 120 Na
140 Na
Concentration (mg L )
100
-1
120
Concentration (mg L )
-1
100 80
80 60
60
40
40
20
20
0
0 8
8
Fe
Fe Zn
Zn
6
Concentration (mg L )
-1
6
Concentration (mg L )
-1
4
4
2
2
0
i ri a a e
o Itata
0
e ir Elqu Lima sablanc Maip olchagu Maul
nay anc vignon énér inot no Syra
h
Ca
rdon n bl u Carm
C
Cha auvigno rnet Sa P
S e
Cab Wine producing areas
Wine varieties
Figure 1. Concentration of major metallic elements across Figure 2. Concentration of major metallic elements across
wine varieties in 75 Chilean wines samples (error bars wine producing areas in 75 Chilean wines samples (error
represent the standard deviation of the mean). bars represent the standard deviation of the mean).
82 ciencia e investigación agraria
Figure 3. Score plot of the first two principal components of the atomic absorption spectroscopy
analysis of major metallic elements in 75 Chilean wine samples.
tion of this element (Sierra, 2000; Sierra et al., analyzed could be useful to improve the quality of
2001; Sierra et al., 2007). The high content of the discrimination.
Na in soils from desertic and semidesertic ar-
eas, such as the northern parts of Chile, has
Like in this report, other studies have also been
been explained as a result of cation accumula-
able to discriminate between red and white
tion due to the lack of rainfall (White, 2003).
wines using PCA (Coetzee et al., 2005).
The content of Na observed in wines produced
in the Elqui and Limarí areas could help sup-
port the empirical observation that the Chilean Conclusions
wines produced in these valleys have a distinc-
tive feel, normally described as ‘minerality’;
a term that is vaguely defined, non-objective,
For the first time, the content of six of the most
and not well understood.
abundant metallic elements of a large number
of Chilean wines samples was accurately mea-
In addition, the reasons for the large variation sured. All metal concentrations were within
observed in some of the valleys studied are mul- normal ranges as compared to previously re-
tiple. For instance, large regions such as Maule ported data from other world wine areas. The
valley have several soil types and even weather concentration of Na was higher in the wines
variations that could be broadening the ob- produced in the northern parts of the country,
served variability (Serapinas et al., 2008). a situation that could help to explain part of
the organoleptic peculiarities of these wines,
normally referred to as ‘minerality’. Analysis
of the content of minor elements and further
Principal component analysis studies aimed to elucidate the relationship be-
tween cation concentration, wine oxidation
reactions, and wine sensory perception should
If multivariate analyses are performed with the in- be performed.
tention of determining wine provenance in a high-
er number of geographical regions (e.g. within a
country), the potential for finding unequivocal dis-
crimination are more complicated, and require to Acknowledgments
consider an investigation of the content of other el-
ements, at trace concentrations, and the influences
of production and storage practices (Jakubowski This research was sponsored by CONICYT
et al., 1999; Almeida et al., 2002; Almeida and through FONDECYT grant # 11075084. Sup-
Vasconcelos, 2003; Perez-Magarino et al., 2004). port by Tecnovid and the ‘Ruta del vino Valle
Moreover, an increase in the number of samples del Maule’ are also appreciated.
Resumen
by the use of factor analysis of elemental data. and dry ashing. American Journal of Enology
European Food Research and Technology 221: and Viticulture 45: 25-28.
550-558. Pyrzynska, K. 2004. Analytical methods for the de-
La Pera, L., G. Dugo, R. Rando, G. Di Bella, R. termination of trace metals in wine. Critical Re-
Maisano, and F. Salvo. 2008. Statistical study views in Analytical Chemistry 34: 69-83.
of the influence of fungicide treatments (man- Ribéreau-Gayon, P., Y. Glories, A. Maujean, and D.
cozeb, zoxamide and copper oxychloride) on Dubourdieu. 2006. Handbook of enology, The
heavy metal concentrations in Sicilian red chemistry of wine: Stabilization and treatments.
wine. Food Additives and Contaminants 25: 2nd Edition. Wiley. West Sussex, England. 441
302-313. pp.
Lazos, E. S., and A. Alexakis. 2007. Metal ion con- Serapinas, P., P. R. Venskutonis, V. Aninkevicius, Z.
tent of some Greek wines. International Journal Ezerinskis, A. Galdikas, and V. Juzikiene. 2008.
of Food Science & Technology. 24: 39 – 46. Step by step approach to multi-element data
Lima, J. L. F. C., and A. O. S. S. Rangel. 1990. De- analysis in testing the provenance of wines. Food
termination of metallic cations in wines by flow Chemistry 107: 1652-1660.
injection analysis. American Journal of Enology Sierra, C., R. Césped, and A. Osorio. 2001. Caracter-
and Viticulture 41: 284-288. ización de la salinidad de los suelos y aguas del
Marengo, E., and M. Aceto. 2003. Statistical inves- valle del río Copiapó. Boletín INIA - Instituto de
tigation of the differences in the distribution of Investigaciones Agropecuarias No. 70.
metals in Nebbiolo-based wines. Food Chemis- Sierra, C. 2000. Salinidad de los suelos del norte
try 81: 621-630. chico. Tierra Adentro. May-Jun 2000. 32:35-38.
Mihucz, V. G., C. J. Done, E. Tatar, I. Virag, G. Za- Sierra C., A. Lancelloti, and I. Vidal. 2007. Azufre
ray, and E. G. Baiulescu. 2006. Influence of dif- elemental como corrector del pH y la fertilidad
ferent bentonites on the rare earth element con- de algunos suelos de la tercera y cuarta región de
centrations of clarified Romanian wines. Talanta Chile. Agricultura Técnica 67:173-181.
70: 984-990. Storey, R. 1987. Potassium localization in the grape
Muranyi, Z., and Z. Kovacs. 2000. Statistical evalu- berry pericarp by energy-dispersive X-Ray mi-
tion of aroma and metal content in Tokay wines. croanalysis. American Journal of Enology and
Microchemical Journal 67: 91-96. Viticulture 38: 301-309.
Orescanin, V., A. Katunar, A. Kutle, and V. Valko- Suhaj, M., and M. Korenovska. 2005. Application
vic. 2003. Heavy metals in soil, grape, and wine. of elemental analysis for identification of wine
Journal of Trace and Microprobe Techniques 21: origin - A review. Acta Alimentaria 34: 393-401.
171-180. Taylor, V. F., H. P. Longerich, and J. D. Greenough.
Ough, C. S., E. A. Crowell, and J. Benz. 1982. Metal 2002. Geology and wine 5. - Provenance of
content of California wines. Journal of Food Sci- Okanagan valley wines, British Columbia, using
ence 47:825-828. trace elements: Promise and limitations. Geosci-
Ough, C. S., and M. A. Amerine. 1988. Methods for ence Canada 29: 110-120.
analysis of musts and wines. Wiley-Interscience, Taylor, V. F., H. P. Longerich, and J. D. Greenough.
New York, New York. 377 pp. 2003. Multielement analysis of Canadian wines
Pereira, C. F. 1988. The importance of metallic el- by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrom-
ements in wine - A literature survey. Zeitschrift etry (ICP-MS) and multivariate statistics. Journal
Fur Lebensmittel-Untersuchung Und-Forschung of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 51: 856-860.
186: 295-300. Thiel, G., G. Geisler, I. Blechschmidt, and K. Danzer.
Perez-Magarino, S., M. Ortega-Heras, M. L. Gonza- 2004. Determination of trace elements in wines and
lez-San Jose, and Z. Boger. 2004. Comparative classification according to their provenance. Analyti-
study of artificial neural network and multivari- cal and Bioanalytical Chemistry 378: 1630-1636.
ate methods to classify Spanish DO rose wines. White, R. E. 2003. Soils for Fine Wines. Oxford Uni-
Talanta 62: 983-990. versity Press, USA. 312 pp.
Puig-Deu, M., R. M. Lamuela-Raventos, S. Buxad- Zoecklein, B. W., K. C. Fugelsang, B. H. Gump, and
eras, and C. Torre-Boronat. 1994. Determination F. S. Nury. 1999. Wine analysis and production.
of copper and iron in must: Comparison of wet Aspen, Gaithersburg, Maryland. 621 pp.