Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • An Interview On "Indian Art History and Dividing Practices" With Pranab Ranjan Roy

    Uploaded by

    Debaprasad Bandyopadhyay
    522 views10 pages
    2004. On “Indian Art History and dividing practices” with Pranab Ranjan Roy. Published in Ababhas. IV:3 (pp.1-18)

    Original Title

    An Interview on “Indian Art History and dividing practices” With Pranab Ranjan Roy

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    2004. On “Indian Art History and dividing practices” with Pranab Ranjan Roy. Published in Ababhas. IV:3 (pp.1-18)

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Flag for inappropriate content
    522 views10 pages

    An Interview On "Indian Art History and Dividing Practices" With Pranab Ranjan Roy

    Uploaded by

    Debaprasad Bandyopadhyay
    2004. On “Indian Art History and dividing practices” with Pranab Ranjan Roy. Published in Ababhas. IV:3 (pp.1-18)

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 10
    PBSta COMRICOM : Alaa AICHA ACH RANAPAT (ata) ower. Rater RR Be qacw oaleena Ate CTTORT STAC coafce feet —CRETA TC aC AT H, FR ATS TCA TL HT CHAR 6B eal A CATA CIR. CARE HATS ANGUS TTT HATA S(O, CTPA A ONS, HYATA AH ASAI HIF GTN HA HF ACHR!) OCA SAAT aa ees BCH crete, UIs Ban qucw wTy Re atten ACTA — | FSH Cat aca OIA HOS! Fissefteiaia sear oT, Gare Aewca| awd AACA BA COA OE AY ATTICS (AT AT FAAS SPATS LES PLATA |) CPCS cara Benker emo sorReTatT PI fica .crem eee AeA TAR at Boicahis areAiea ofacefecw ‘Indian painting’ AT CATE CoAT aplatta Be ea SAS VH-S GHATS, OF Cl Fine Arts CAF ae at AA HHA FHP : " au “ae Rr a oraea fw’ was (aoe SAS AHS, Rs, Te Vosthea carne 8 aE Ta) AAS FH CaM FING AT TATA? AHS GOA AAU Folk @ Tribe ce 3H SHA GIA aI, WTS Folk art / Song @ Tribal language-3 Cel AFSC SIA TIER ATARI | SICA : Ba: Beara oes wee | Camel Scores AACE | POA by training and by profession ‘al caffter coca Siera wea Rem, fre aad wey FSA ACY SSC ROSH ATS A SAT CAB BET wT Sea CRNA Rd Fea ‘eam UEBefy group formation zafa | aff 8 fica Cat ere fercafena | GLRLA + Orientalism-a9 “fab wea GoAF CATETAIADI Ce em wi AGE A. ICRA ewe, ae FA. RITA aT FPR GR ak TATERA COTA oR EBD HCA aw GHEMAD eS-SCETA binary CoS A at AA ora WA RA eT OA Ie SETH ANS CHIC... 2 se Gal + Bi, closely ze ort aa British Orienlatism... awemns 434 Crete crea... vite SA. cram ems ret BB... BA abies, aati AIRE FRA rR | FE rte TCR ABI AM CORA Sey | OR EA WASH WHS 2008 /y few wisi! British Orientatism-a4 3G GF TW administratorea Orientalism fe aeaeq | Gib] Edward Said-aa wan ACF Co FcR FRG fry fg ons, afer core fei caren face TSA! A GAA coe mlerefereniet OPAC TENS LA “oT” HHS AAS OH AA Ga GA IBA Bate f& psychiatric! tat FSR fice 2 CST cia personal life-+%¢ GG Fics acafi—Sa Wy Dichotomyd! fer at Bea cl PrwaTTE aie waren fort FAR “A traditional wafers Fa arr ol fre tea SUIT As! Westernization, Modernization, Europeanization @2 arf TA CGR CHA ACF GNA GNA ABA Bai all UIE USA DT Weala WA..ST FAMOT UITS WHS A Orientalist AAV a Said aa © eee anfab) cre, qcaibt aa. cause Fae Administrator Orientalist fac AI... Nevertheless ¥Iaf Western Orientalist Geb} GES romantic ideology-3 GIN CAC# Tice! CAB FE RUST ACs OR Ba ww FRAT AH WH eal. SAAT Fea art practice-aa ACH Ya Frente | erartericen art practice At Ca acMeN area 9106 Fre cee ae FITC A Cl FSR Said 43 RFA orientalist FE UA THe GRA Orientalism @ fie a1 ite oS zacw stare AN Sia Hy Romantic im- agination runs high, 41 eHoacva Raa BHA! CO WE AS—ATTA HH STA AA ACHR CATA CRE ARCH | MAAN eter stcetotenTaICs a STATA vice principal #21 & RM acerca Beara aie Hora SMT | 2 CCH GA COCR PL ane AR TITRA Ca RANT CY aCeCRS Rrarai TNOTCER... A RA GbE aca at EP OIE ea Re ace azine Fe. car att TES Ge BE! A GMA CHOKE fine arts JAI BW GING al division ‘al 31 between Indian arts and western arts | 0! irrational oof! CREE... HFM western ATA CRF CO-ATAA CHOC ATS Fal THR ATIC {8 West, by that time reject SAR wf) FAA THA Fe, GE division b1 fe end ef8fw DIAE art college MERE GIA DAE! Gy art school TA FAISH FE COs reject WAR! Ft SKA curriculam~4 @ division-O Fal aR GiB] =A techniques employed... 78 painting Piavai @E sculpture fara... @E print making faa... aamt M. S University «2 division bi Gra Fare (fee raters enBta Brac art Fa foe AI division BIZ GIA Ficwea) aay abia WH CU OTT BORAT GibTe Cra ICR BIS MHRA 2008/4 NPY BEA Aor ety ae MSA WI AAC crAICS BIBT... Wie, abne Ee ebie age Sta Roe BE KAT! IE GH CASH religious architecture 8 listing Fl archive TOA Fat WA CA AIS HCA Ft I AV aBarRI aria rat 08 fan aa ommefiaia ster oF atea cx acme imper- vious to Indian art tradition farm UIA | fe OA approach Bi feet GAIA design oriented | AR + {CSA AR 8. aencabics Pres AI SRA sae? are Fiala sistetcn eas fe ‘ast : et! Administrative ATIC C educational report et Meat WA OLS Cal CT ACSA Fes as AIHA TSH ACATR..Becditert BE FAR... FHS GIFT MG quality NE ele aad! Ga ceahy Sia otstertcat Gra Fea wlaeia asic Ael CRCA HST... Sista FoR fea wats gal GhaA Grea scam Gaal Roa ewe wer ara “ote OI FeTeY-a EAT Fal HS BIG ATTICS BIR | GEA TATA HANTS ICTR ECA OTA | STS CARER FRAN Fl SPAS WET WTR Ie: Ree cH Freier, "wat salar ae “TIAS- sift Seca BA Bey : CUTE BVA BRA AS Baraca zr ACR APG IIE NA BA ATH MCA Mifare Reet acy ena | AHICSETS CRTC CH ART HB CwITAS BIA eT? fe MATES 4 ET BABA ace (ARE Sl WSR SCAT HIS ACA, GNM GAA PA CATTS AAACN GTA GBT STU Te HS | ak Sea aI GA ATH BHT RTE UIT ODI Be we cor ashi aaa vifsra cree ony ~ afew fee af AT ROSH GAARA BAS CIT ad SAS AS aa... ure CAH aA I PAG TAR... TH WG BEHAT MSs AAR! IIA *NSACAA TE WAI... 68 & Firat oR... ABI Bearceis Rete Mat aay OTE CATAT Ta... GTA SCR A FARE GA-ATIM MOAT fsa ae Rove MN ois aE a aAifeaga (Philologist FASay cave Pare yAtfSary ore) Sra TA FAM SAS ee cdarat ofl TA Lae Cdl ficH orientalism WA aati fers vraeT FoR.. FaaSaty aa ABE A a CAI ama amalgamation RR MA AAVAATS Baw WA KF amalgamation-bra afat cre... A481 hybrid space Teh ZR... aF synthetic Miaoeee GTA Indian art aa bien fafa fara ara GE Govt. art school effa CRG? ®t: Exactly CHS fSiribl RHR FA CACH ASS IPs... Government-4 Sal OAC SASHA Q008/~ Indian art [KE F cara? aa non-anatomical drawing 4 fil object 4 living being represented 20% with emphasis on line, Government Art College~4 G#A holistic approach Te ... identfication by trait... Gal FAT trait identify Ware. Fe ve trait of co weet ae CREE SPCR A GATTI, total Te afi follow Fa TH... manuscripts | Oa 2G SRSA aft Healer arena BERT cera RI abr Fe eh SPARGS genealogical fantacy WA WA BAA? 8 OAT sat OR... Indian art-~93 caTq aae particularly Bengal Art~9a CRta? Bal: a fee SORIA BHT Bie fics nf at CRIA mental construc- tion @ post facto mental construction TUS Hal | Bat WATE, week Reece Ur say ar AT UR, a ote manuscript 11—<1 Gam early wont manuscripts 43 3 stylistically CIC At | oT fang WT oT manu- Script 8 FS AA! BISA CAB Re MTC aaa WH Gi territorial Concept of nationality UraM @& period-aa Bet} AHR CF period cay =a ‘SRB territorial concept fA At GH FAR AVIS fluidity tah fee) 2.4 : a Nation States fea at te boundary ¢ 3 fuzy fet) are Serre cot sree bt cata Ficw eR Ice aM en TERR Bom TAT SA A Picea Roxora yater a ca NSTGA BHR AT AA : 4 Be Vy so called Indian art 43 Western art Tid academic syllabi-cS acy Cab) aa administrative continuency-2 GY ace fare larger question 4at Fle address wef, which remains! 42 @ BIS UHRATCTIA 3008/>5 UIC €& identification, FED justified? ef f& HIB aA Indian a Bengal art a ao fargrs ideatify sare HA? a CE diversity 7% UIA AAG? a FF CHA Ground reality wIcRe wIMA Ace Ata nebulous— ORI TAG See Hey BACT ROR W GI TMA GH UNE GA BCH Tih Picea Tr, SISA GAD] etearea awl eal ota Prehistoric 4 Proto historic art Reca weRCeTMICAl-Raatta eH aH FARR BIA CIs aR MATE deal 41 ST... CAA deal Fa Ve ora centemporary tribal art T! Foe Clara COCs CHIBI CaBiICs UIA historical period 24... cubryfe aaa aCe SAA continuous hisory of art He RATA AH GAR Analyticy CRAG WH BA diversity S84 ...regional @ spatiotemporal 2opft... 1 fq SRAS BI BCH —total-Bl CIE VT Gy CTA ACE GRATE UA Saat GRR 686 character TAH GPR! A CATS AA Hera oF STATA Pret ora ae arn Heats 2OR—spread WR—South-Asia Wes, AAD BC UTR WIAs was Fri wad fia cea influences travel --SR GH Indian Art 3a ame acofa Bare at afer FH wea? cas fy Sarat fR—A spread sata Tiottabl caata way | Sawa DI tribal com- munity - Sb! Rt Western India-a, FRIANEA AM CHAT) GA as zat afr Seo tera, ceays, Newt teva went ARfere ef citaws | az ita wR HCG CITE AR eh Ze, ok qeCEA Be Aen A wae TAS Gules GoM WE: metal casting-<4 Tso! se RI-SSa ES spread WAR! WF Generalized term-~4 Corea at BA Uta FS! wistidatat (ara MIGGA Technology) GA GA CTA OF wETEA WE SATS sical | Roemer aro ¢ zap wheres GR Tee TTA GIES sae Hara TS BCR CATIA GATED RITA (AE GI badly written book) Rea— RGAE AewrACHA PCH | Sat BS tribal group 4a—¥fal tribal group a TRA ACH! OTA FS Me aAS? ae a shea Ror ET RFS icon-a4 CRC prescriptions WAR WR CHET CATT | Received concepts Tot SAFE Bt 7I—TAG Internalization BW—I Hea Va Aaa orcas: al : GLUA + Ol AWA Donor-receptor 3 GRUA-GIeAAat WATS a2 awa PAR BY OR AU, LANA SOT MICHA AIHA Tiere Cor emul. SAT: eters corres costar Rion Sree Ber aca CAR Fa Goines at Boreas fica caefet readily available in the locality cama, stB-congran tt BIOPM OIAA-AGOTEA 2008/33 , aif, crea Bf, ara ae seats oem Te sTPrae at VT aE cerca) fare OTT CRRG-Cos Pics sips sift metal <8 TRV BA A Caw HT locally Beents wi abi aaAS nomad-4! Ul rock T&F metal extraction technique GAS, GAS metal casting | : # R78 41 UF, UH traditional History tw we... Gf Period (&# OF Bq TAC A RRNA FAS She walt eat continuous history Teh ERI fee ear South C# sa aah! Rens sees ons saPTafie | wes, South-4 continue #% WAS WPF Indian aa Gar Gab} eae oratcna zeftr Aa areal PRRCHRR RR North Indian AfeaBreme cut veer | rg a FS Dieta GL cae OF Bea ATARI 1g century *€8 iconology 21. iconological thinking 40! Saracnsy role Play Wa WA 4% abl seIIe RAI Art~98 wR ett feet, AA: ah a eet point | Bat iconology @ iconography fii 561 TG, a le Pica weg wares fy a1. gray iconography-4 @ 7eeiaq 3a upords | aa—aern across-religion, across state, ... WISa@a AGHA A851 semi- nal contribution (28 Goa GiNIAS BARR BIR) ATE agai sa Aca... waa GI period-s8 CTS CCF 8S period-aal CHT GAR sculptural centre ROTA at Sea Ges ret! Nersaer ae WIGH, TIM FO! craft centre fe aa Raeaa wiRoKAM SIA patron-cAa TOR UTM se SACRA a COIR SAA GIR Bea HRCI | FC AIA FAAS adi integrated language at style develop @afa | 30a UM FA VC Grew Fy identify saw ana at fee faeiot CUA? Het SPAS A ze sad soul} iconographical postulates UW IHF MEN 3 influence FAR! Ta BY GB Neat pS 6 Tayea Wo gs oa wa a ATi a ONY, cere, afte am fica cera human element Tri aH wa fore wens ASM WA A— sot iconological unity arse Yee 91F—w GIS MAY operative 7A! GNA GN GIT GAOT CAB etm wre Tat TAB sto APO wc CTA a SIE se eM TTS aIpYBOH cea care: fet GR Cra OTIC CHEAT PY, HAT aN icon (identifactio brahmnica) Jaa wal eA A ae fice! COR, wt BH CSI al appropriated acafacrn... Soi BL at qvaa ca Suread fica Cra CREE BIRR] SIS GIHR-ATOTI 2008/s0 SECA Fe Gr aft ae CoTTOUAA SIDE Cowra feet ax 91 SI Ap- Propriated Scary wR fF Ya AP generalize FA WH UWA? BA : BAS 1 FHS GAR HTM TA HAGA | BIA AT level BATA attempt of synthesizing Save abl wErOa aa, OAS ATH imposed | @.%3 : In search of Viswakarma-ce Tal west anes a fevestiona sar RT al South Asia Cy...caIeA fs Goma WA A Al GAD! Gra TOR AR I FAR Roos faentia eI aA AeA TARP Sai: Faris «2 Gree ore feeb yeahh on aa etm fone acai, Craftman #1 ficena identify ® dignity-a Mav (dignity causa) | 431 62 FIC Bel AAAS BE WIE Faterarg aati cell 42 fica “The canons of Orissan Architecture’ | <1 4451 polemic TO BaA—1 GBat Bra Sm ‘Hindu Temple’ Hat acafacen, fey aPicaa conceptual structure-Bt ATT PACK TSA CIE WICH body function WPTN Bret Fa BR wh wr Ap cae era are Hera | Ber- Pea Zonk ’ Pforarg eat eon Sensis aac cx atte Boia wal COI FAL HE... FRO SHAM SICH CICA Cena Peer aT | wrACaT FS Oia orRPTCAR go Rael ACP PACS MCA 2 GA AeA FATS HICH... but, through series of mediations | TAMA DetAVke explain FACT ACH Ka ACA GA! OI LEICA HO WA GT | SA efem wrigens arava Proportions CARH CIC. mediated reaction fra interpret ®41 42 mediation-93 #7 change Feb! 24 CAB rata | CUA + OR ME Schematically Bice SACS fT eat AF Wot do- mains wif We L 1 L-a wale, wate ea Reg CRAAMOTT aa Cee GIA interpretation SPR H-9 FRPICH A GIN MYC ANCH..1 BIT GBT Cot 485) long tradition | 54% AIA Tal BA ABS... FS AB group~4 AN...CAG Caeter DeBIonoTa a co A HTC at UAH ACoA COREA BCATCAA ICR WON TH... GA Tere RerAy SIMO Sei ACow et Teta BATE | CR RRS, Col AACR, OKA. wom FROIN Riese CHEWEA sR CATE aE - ‘HAS ara ona BIR GAH! GEL to Haat hypothesis SA aebt H to L... omen a a1 aa Peed yh ceca’ taal creat APTA ZACNA FISH orcas feoraa 3008/38 SAGO AR GRETA URAL OT ACHTR I aR CRIT O85) CIAReAPTS DENK! 7H fine art @ Indian art~aa a® CINCH ACF BA eT BR Ga fret Gi! BUR folk art 6 classical art | HRS BSAA. ra TITHE OAR AH WAER €Z division of WH Ta oa OB vaK.. cil wee GRITS reflected ROR! a @ folk art, tribal art <8 @ term ev oF TR FAR A OH FTF classical WA ws Ga Fie way a ota BIER FATT WA I? Car Proce SIMCATEICSR wy CISA eB at any Ba ya ber a fenfae aa’ sratesa B11 GR OHS TAP. ys04 aT CaTes Praca sear aac... 2 cReMTETSHTA BaD RS ap oTeT Rea CHE ARR; aa? Bal: Al, ores Roms ceca Fe Ol AN! AOE AR Bers CIR ARIA Aa aia primordial elements surface *27%} fee ad) Bieta saw ah GIRNA...0 CPR Semitic Religion... Gem FaEa a Sra aa, HABE CRAG... Ga Sate Primitive religion C replace WaC&| Gl replace- ment f€% socalled Hinduism-aa ceca wet Grice one at As 2 iS ag wer BP AGT ok yeh CRI Bea Fre SIRT Sf ACS FHA AI BALAN VCS HEA me ear Maca? a eI AGT Be a GAG FAN ag ape EAT AAPA GI er AMIRI, TI He L Wt domain tara wrt Bea Cala OB Fat Bio | CO 4% tribal art...folk art... o% saefa ae 2 orc? : @at : Folk art-classical art division fee orevea RSPCA ATS eT PICHR text Toe) TREC GIs] FAI RUT GA GATT MIAH aT Set Fal FONE, A CHICA FE a Val wes yore vies a, cra Socata Ser... afte Sern Baar FASE classify Faia, categorize or traxonomize Fa “801 tendency fa! ae abs justify 6 776 | fag fog justification TS! SIRI CITA eH, OTaTCRA TTT “ral Fi with all the regional and temporal variations—mainly GI “fy a SERS Wea afte Bie care aoe, afte ee OSA zat wa FACECT aa 2 ROMs BO ws FATA Cl I Ora Fe mf eae cata Si GE) HATE FAR ree era TAS HR CATS-cMeTA wIA TEER @ BTCA Fave SIR! FRE Rote, eMC CR CAE CME afm ignore Fal RRA ar FS oNScws Moras CaGeCT Tet AVE Seah ZOE WISH OBAATOTRA Q008/s¢ Uat : fe watertight a we oF wis clea fei UIaIHa socalled orth Fim =a Ae identify ea AZ was Rows cRTE PARA) IMAI GbE Classic AH, 6 ta-ea “IH aE col fey AT 8) US TH BAA B,... | Classic “BI Co onfig UTA Europe t(&#! T. S. Eliot 4% The Tradi- tional Classic -4 GanA Classic Sef definitions fel 7a BGA aren a II AAR classical ZA Al FSS SET classical Tt al Hellenistic art 7 classic fai! Peartice SR feats ‘afl aaa CO wae aa—aie-anaie— aay ge OO ae SS Ror cH, arate Arata Pia aia cab) ersees Oral aoa Bea CRTATE art history-3 CR BUSS Classic FCS Fe GH TATE CH CFAL..., COAT Ba OTA IAS Fics aed) wereeg Berar ate classic TTS an, GTI ZI ee period HU HAMAS HT A HAA... | CEI classical art BY fF? oma revert back a1 Siow wren @ em PH UIE, GIT AT PS CHS ws eafics sit Sa HAA 2 ah OR Crib BR cor CR SICA CREA OR biway traffic~oa Te wr Ua fe ctr wae aeioea CRMs TCR, CANA Som COMPRA ARETE GUA NR TW GEA WHI sponsorship-4 wel AeeSs TTI AL OTE Worrl hica OAs eee wabicaer | Cre FS ar GOR Uetafee BRE ICR? 4.9 : Tribal art-b) fe orem Tribal art aa language of expression, theme, style of expression ReAcny PAS tribe~aa wet | fee w a FBR A, OS COT cores at wT FRE AT) CHIR, Meat at entaET ste SITS Coa IAA RA At TRS MATA AC CHEMIE otal at aL RA CH eel Tribe C Oro BafRem, AT outside world-24 3 communication wR, GR AT tribe ax wa OrAwAL Ios NEA ABs A... G24 : Speed capitalism~94 FACE ay OA aaa G-TeHte Ga hem aise fe? Qa : 84 Capitalism Ti, Precapitalist situation-9¢ fy 4 rR tribal. community-3 4 penetrate Wat! CHE. contact-4a A IB} STRSTR FCT COI art-8 ABTS OH WA | ACH MAT aD] MIMPAMITA Bel OTA wa FACS fA GAA : (8 Tribe LA GI group identity) RR zaR ae CHB co BAS GCHA-ABOTIA Q008/ su SANA Politico-administrative category | Gna fora a2 aBAea gia mera ares fe . Bal: Bt wage | ee ast interesting 2 $i Gag USwal cas, AHA C21 98% aah RAPBTA: HE 2% ra FABIA AN wrerR Tee fog ae AIM TE UGA SAS SIT I AX Wood curving aa BE Gel WAM HAAG SCAT WHS ies GNA Cel imagistic, TTI design 481 Way alse fer ae RQ at FR CAM FY EA Icon BV follow wate Ficl wis European style-G# OPI WF CRATR | L TAH H-4 mediation-

    You might also like