Professional Documents
Culture Documents
From Individual Psychiatry To Planetary Health WorldSocPsychiatry
From Individual Psychiatry To Planetary Health WorldSocPsychiatry
From Individual Psychiatry To Planetary Health WorldSocPsychiatry
198]
First‑Person Account/Narrative/Reflections
Brazil. As a result of that, I was able to study and become average increase in the planet is around 1.1°C, which has
a psychiatrist! However, what kind of psychiatrist could I already increased the frequency and intensity of forest fires
become with such a history? Certainly, I had to be very and floods, pushed biodiversity loss, increased heat waves,
creative in trying to integrate many different experiences and caused loss of agriculture output. Beyond direct harms,
brought about by this personal history. unchecked climate change may cause tens of millions
of migrants. Unfortunately, greenhouse gas emissions
I developed the belief that life diversity, in all its forms, and
and climate change are accelerating. Hence, it is widely
freedom are basic to life and that psychopathologies as well
regarded as the greatest health threat to human health in
as social conflicts, are linked to the process of domination
the 21st century.
X submission. In medical training, these beliefs were
reinforced. As I loved both Sciences and Humanist Studies, Networking for Action
I decided on Psychiatry and later Child Psychiatry, already
looking for ways to prevent problems that seemed so hard I am inspired by Fridays for future, the youth movement
to change in grownups. I chose to train in Psychiatry in led by Greta Thunberg, to become more of an activist.
the US, flying a dictatorship that ran Brazil from 1964 to I am trying to find where I can be more efficient. I am
1984. After the basic training in adult Psychiatry, I choose part of a local movement of physicians called Medicine in
to train in Child Psychiatry at University of Pennsylvania Alert,[3] which has been feeding information about human
in a family therapy systems‑oriented school. health problems related to global warming to a large social
I was fortunate to work with different cultures and all movement in our home state. It has been a part of the effort
social classes, starting during my training. Back in Brazil, to stop the building of an open pit coal mine at a distance
which I realized was my home country while living of only 16 km from our city. It would be the largest in
abroad, I became a University Professor. Consequently, South America. Luckily, the social movement won, and it
I was able to develop a flourishing private office too. At was stopped by the Justice system. A victory unheard of
the University Hospital and its outpatient clinic, I worked previously in our state.
at the public Unified Health System of Brazil (SUS) with More recently, I have been close to the Brazilian group,
poor people. In Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, which is led by my son, that works with the Lancet Countdown, a
my subspecialty, it is obligatory, from my point of view, to British‑led international effort to improve the awareness
work with intergenerational families, schools, community of human health consequences of climate change and to
services, and programs, and with the justice system. My propose solutions.[4] It was in the last few years that I fully
academic research, mostly on family development, was understood the breadth of Planetary Health [Appendix 2]
done inside one underprivileged community, interviewing care, which is basically “the insight that we need to care
families at home longitudinally, in close alliance with the for our environment so that the planet cares for us” – as my
local public health service. My approach was always that
son says. Hence, I embarked as a mentor on the Brazilian
of a social psychiatrist systemically oriented. Not by mere
Program of Ambassadors for Planetary Health, in which we
chance, my son Enrique went on to train as a family doctor
mentor university students from all over Brazil to learn and
in this same community.
act on planetary health issues.[5]
I was satisfied with the way I was able to integrate my
The São Paulo Declaration on Planetary Health[6] from
interests and how I developed as a shrink, but with time
October 2021 launched during one of the Planetary Health
and more scientific knowledge, in recent years, I found
Alliance[7] annual meetings is a product of this large group
that I was not systemic enough. I was not considering
along with other similar groups globally. It reads:
the influence of climate change and did not pay enough
attention to how air and water pollution and other “This great transition demands a rapid shift in how we
environmental factors might be related to my patient’s produce and consume food, energy, and manufactured
presenting symptoms. I did not consider how I, my goods; requires rethinking the way we design and live in
patients, and our health system influenced the development the world’s cities; and insists we heal our relationship with
of the Anthropocene epoch [Appendix 1] and vice versa. nature and to each other. Such a paradigm shift requires the
However, the dangerous actions to the environment by the participation of every sector, every community, and every
macrosystem economy already had a lot of my attention. individual.”
I have become curious, I am studying how to include I associate these ideas with our clinical work with families:
climate change in clinical work and I am becoming we do systemic diagnosis and plan necessary systemic
an activist working toward mitigating the causes and involvement to facilitate change, bringing in as many
adaptation to consequences. Yes, adaptation is already here. family members as possible. As our planet is our big house,
Bruno Latour, the French philosopher recently deceased, we all become “family.” Although some “parents” have
suggested that we call it climate mutation because the delusional ideas about moving to other planets, it seems
temperatures have already increased significantly.[2] The certain that as human civilization, we do not have where to
move to. Sometimes, we can diagnose psychosis in a home our civilization is increasing carbon dioxide emissions,
visit to our patient. What can we say about our civilization acidifying the oceans, using excessive amounts of energy,
when the world is so messy? polluting the air, destroying forests, misusing water sources,
poisoning the soil and water with chemical fertilizers and
Building Actions microplastics, causing the 6th mass extinction and digged a
We all know the terrible news about climate change! But hole in the ozone layer. The biosphere integrity is in severe
what can we do? How do we include this knowledge in our danger.[13]
lives and our work? Moreover, it is very important to emphasize that the
Working in Psychiatry, we need to consider the countries that are poorer and have contributed less to
findings published in December 2021 in an article the warming process are those that suffer the larger
about the prevalence of eco‑anxiety in young people consequences. We need equity in mitigation. Equity
worldwide.[8] The authors used the Kantar Platform to is different from equality. Poorer countries need more
send a questionnaire to thousands of youngsters, financed resources to face their problems.[14]
by AVAAZ. Ten thousand people aged 16–25 (including The question for us social psychiatrists is, “how can we
a Brazilian sample) responded. The results are worrisome participate in the effort of mitigation, adaptation, and
but introduce the hope that youngsters may become more resilience?”
creative and resolutive than my generation: 59% were very
or extremely worried and 84% were at least moderately Mental Health and Global Warming
worried. More than 50% reported each of the following What are the known effects of global warming on mental
emotions: Sadness, anxiety, anger, powerlessness, health? The International Review of Psychiatry, in a recent
helplessness, and guilt. Forty‑five percent say that the issue, includes articles that summarize the effects and bring
worries affect their daily functioning, and there is a new hopeful insights into the field.[13]
generalized feeling of betrayal by their governments.
Betrayal by the authorities, their grown‑ups. Around nine million people die every year from direct
consequences of air pollution. If we know as mental
The question arises: If the prevalence of eco‑anxiety is so health workers that one of the major precipitants of
high, should we consider it a disorder? psychopathology is unresolved mourning, what do these
This intergenerational crisis is often something we work death numbers imply? Mental illness prevalence certainly
on with our psychiatric patients, isn’t it? Can we make this is increasing. Pollution is also known to cause dementia,
association? There seems to be a larger intergenerational depression, and anxiety. Heat waves are becoming
crisis: Greta Thunberg put it into words in her UN speech increasingly common and are directly associated with
“How dare you!” in 2019.[9] death, anxiety, depression, and violence. It is important
to remember that psychiatric medication makes body heat
In Brazil, there is a scarcity of research, but it indicates regulation more difficult, so our medicated psychiatric
that around 12% of the young population needs psychiatric patients are more at risk than others. Draughts and floods
treatment.[10] The prevalence is higher in adults: 20%– cause hunger and are responsible for migrations, which
56%.[11] These numbers are from a few years ago. They result in family and community disorganization with
have probably increased now with the COVID pandemic severe consequences to mental health. The increased
and all the associated personal and social traumas of the last temperatures and landscape disruptions increase
few years. COVID‑19 is, unfortunately, one of the many infectious diseases with a negative influence on mental
pandemics we will have to face as the world temperatures health.[13]
increase and the natural environments are affected.
It is becoming evident that air pollution, heat waves, major
Hence, one important question we must answer as climate events, and population dislocation cause important
mental health professionals is, “how should we classify health problems, including mental health problems, which
eco‑anxiety”? Is it a disorder or normal and necessary to may be a direct, immediate, or delayed consequence.
achieve a less dystopian world?[12] Can we be healthy on a Mental health problems are still underestimated in the
sick planet? literature about climate change health impacts.
The Anthropocene There are also many health consequences we do not know
about. For example, we do not know what the impact of
The Anthropocene is a complex Age. No wonder young
plastic garbage on human health is. What we already know
people are perplexed and enraged. Humans have improved
is that microplastic has been found in maternal breast milk.
their/our life on the planet in unprecedented ways with
What consequences may this have?[15]
increased life span, decreased poverty, and decreased
child mortality. In this process, although humans have Breastmilk nursing is at the center of mother‑father‑baby
depleted and poisoned Earth’s resources unprecedentedly, relationship building. A diagram [Figure 1] from my
doctorate thesis studying the duration of breastfeeding Maybe we can be helped to comprehend our difficulties
and mental health 20 years ago illustrates it.[16] The triad and start a new path with the help of the concept of orders
is surrounded by their family and community, including of thinking that comes from cybernetics.
the health‑care team. This is a process formative of the
Cybernetics has described the systemic complexity in
human psyche and human relationships. Starting at the
perceiving and describing the relationship between one
beginning of the 20th century, it was interfered with by
agent (A) over an object (B), as seen by an observer (O).
hyper consumerism when powdered milk was promoted in
In first‑order thinking, A acts over B and receives clear
the occidental world as the “best option for babies.” Now,
feedback from B that O interprets without obvious
we know that there are the traces of plastic also interfering.
problems or distortions. Second‑order thinking recognizes
What can the consequences be?
that A and B interactions are also influenced by the
Mental Illness as Cause of Climate Mutation observer O, which affects the field of action with its own
energy, making interpretation more complex. Third‑order
It is still not sufficiently recognized that climate change thinking recognizes that the 3 (A, B, and O) interact in
causes psychopathology. Beyond this, I have a question: an energy field affected by its own socioenvironmental
Isn’t psychopathology part of the cause of the global organization that makes the relationships more complex,
warming crisis? Who is responsible for these events? To interdependent, and less easily interpretable.[17] We could
a large degree, human greed of the richest people and say, at first glance, that the usual clinical situation of
companies of the world which exploit natural resources medicating a patient could be described with first‑order
beyond capacity. This obviously comes along with the thinking. If one looks closer, it is clearly influenced
exploitation of submissive human beings. The extraordinary by how the relationship created with the patient by the
is that nowadays, in light of basic common sense, those prescribing psychiatrist and the hospital where he works,
are ecocidal and suicidal behaviors because nobody makes these phenomena already second‑order thinking.
can fly away from Earth’s air pollution. Hence, we have Third‑order thinking needs to be introduced, although, to
omnipotence and submission, two primitive behaviors at explain what happens, especially when there is a scarcity
the base of how global warming started and continues to of resources, for example, no medications available, and
increase. the doctor and patient (as well as O) are frustrated by
Third‑order Thinking to Guide Mental the environmental situation, although the person most
clearly affected is the patient. Imagine, now, a situation
Health Work to Safeguard from Climate
associated with the climate change: at the moment of the
Mutation consultation, the room starts to flood and doctor, patient
How can we frame this scenario? What can we do? It is and observer experience that they are equally affected. All
so overwhelming that the tendency is to deny the facts, are in a similar situation of vulnerability. Can the doctor
not even perceive them, and/or, in acknowledging them, act solely as a prescriber? All three are in danger; hence,
find that a helpful response is so out of our reach that we all should act, all are responsible. This enlargement of
give up. third‑order thinking to include planetary factors, beyond
human build socioeconomic structures seems necessary individuals, families, and communities. Networking and
and urgent. support structures can be built in the process, bringing
change. Even happy interactions can be promoted!
When the imminent “existential threat” of climate change
There are interesting reports of resilience building in the
is considered, as stated by the UNs Secretary‑General
Guterres,[18] it becomes evident that health personnel reconstruction work in New Orleans, after the Katrina
must be trained to work with an enlarged third‑order hurricane, for example.[21]
thinking lens. We must embrace third‑order thinking, Another important work is on changing the health system
recently proposed by McDowell et al.,[17] which focuses on itself to make it greener, knowing that if it were a country,
regional interactions of systems and expand to a planetary it would be considered the 5th in the carbon emissions.
health lens, recognizing how human complex interactions There is much to be done, from changing structures to
harm the planet and vice versa. The clinical approach to changing materials and procedures.[22]
planetary health care has to be patient and family‑centered,
developing culturally sensitive community resources, which In clinical work with our patients, we can stimulate specific
simultaneously care for our bigger house [Figure 2].[19] actions. Perhaps, 1 min for the planet in the office would
be sufficient.[19] Encouraging active transportation is already
We, mental health workers, must learn to identify early part of what is done by psychiatrists recommending
psychiatric signs and symptoms associated with the exercise. Presenting the Planetary Health Diet is central,
climate change. For that, we need to become aware of the advising a plant‑based diet with reduced red meat
environmental changes occurring. The goal is to educate consumption, emphasizing choosing the food carefully,
our patients and community about risks. We should also buying fresh from nearby producers, and watching for
pragmatically center on what each one can contribute chemical defensives. The Lancet Countdown 2020 policy
to mitigating problems as soon as possible. To prepare brief for Brazil concentrated on the study of the Brazilian
ourselves to do this, there are the plenty of didactic and diet. The study found that 42,000 deaths yearly were
accessible resources. It is urgent to introduce these issues associated with red meat overconsumption, which in turn
in the training of health professionals. is associated with Amazon forest fires to clean land for
Studies show that our health system provides only 20% cattle while also contributing to air pollution, which is
of health well‑being. Eighty percent of it comes from responsible for 19,000 deaths [Figures 3 and 4].[23]
socioeconomic and environmental determinants.[20] This
The study group found that by operationalizing
is why as social psychiatrists, we aim to influence them.
plant‑based fresh planetary diet food, we can promote
Once we realize the urgency of the facts, we need to start
local biodiversity, better socioeconomic development, and
working at all levels, from the individual patient to our
preserve Brazilian multiple biomes, with special mention to
teaching institutions, the national psychiatric system, and
the Amazon forest. This process in itself promotes health
beyond, to the whole socioeconomic system. What a task!
and community development and happiness.
Do we have the power for that?
Further on, as it is around the table that a family
We have some power for sure, some of us have
mostly relates, we can, as clinicians, go beyond in our
economically and politically influential patients. And all
of us are influential in our communities. This seems a interventions. Working carefully with how food is chosen
tiresome and impossible task. However, it is important to and prepared, how it is shared at the table, and how the
remember that by evaluating risk factors, we simultaneously
uncover resources. This happens during clinical work with
Appendixes
Appendix 1: The Anthropocene epoch is widely accepted as our current geological time. It is marked by the global
increase of human life expectancy, reduction of child mortality and reduction of poverty, along with many other human
marvels of the last two centuries. On the other hand, the great acceleration of population, exploitation of natural resources,
and pollution is overshooting the planetary boundaries to sustain human civilization. Most important is the fact that human
impact has overcome any other geological factor in shaping the biosphere.
Appendix 2: The Lancet‑Rockefeller Planetary Health Commission defined Planetary Health planetary health as “the
achievement of the highest attainable standard of health, wellbeing, and equity worldwide through judicious attention to the
human systems – political, economic, and social – that shape the future of humanity and the Earth’s natural systems that
define the safe environmental limits within which humanity can flourish.”[24]