Harrie! C. Mills
writer's task is to react and fight back immediately against what is
Tarmful...to resist and attack.” “Works,” he added, “which are
Opiates will perish along with those who administer or take narcotics
‘The essays which live on must be daggers and javelins, which, with
their readers, can hew out a bloodstained path to a new life.” In the
inid.T9a0s, Lu Xun strongly opposed a movement to promote the
"humorous essay’ led by his former friend, Lin Yutang, and his own
brother, Zhou Zuoren, two of China's best-known essayists. Initially,
these two proposed “humorous criticism” of society and public
figures, "Humorous criticism,” Lu Xun charged, was a contradiction it
tems, especially a humor that Lin insisted had to be detached,
Charitable, and not indignant. Lu Xun warned that in China, “humor
rust become satire directed against society or degenerate
Into... common ‘joking’ ”” He was right, Almost immediately, Lin
aarmgunced his retirement from active commentary on the world to let
us mind roam over all things great and small, from fies to the
this was a reprehensible attempt to avoid reality
lity." Their work, he predicted,
rather like party snacks,
universe. To Lu Xun,
and an abdication of social responsi
Would degenerate into literary bric-a-brac,
which, while tasty, do one no good."**
‘During the course of this 1934-1935 exchange between the enter=
taining tsopinoen of Lin Yutang and the militant zazen of Lu Xun, La
Xun predicied that the short satirical zaper, which as yet had no
wXndwledged place in Chinese literature, would soon become a
Fecognized genre. He was right, and he was the one largely responsi
Tie But ironically, it was soon disavowed by the very party thal
symbolized the dreams that had nurtured it E
ne for his own work, Lu Xun said he wrote to expose injustice, tear
dean the maske of righteousness, and vent his indignation." His own
some made him shudder because it was like the “cry of an owl |
‘eporting things of ill omen”; the more correct the report, the m
pektrous for China, It was a losing game. So, like a street peddler
fusty nails and broken crocks,he simply “spread out” his 2:0 hop!
someone would find something useful, They were expendable
His views had grown and shifted through the years, but always
was true to himself. At the end, he sought no accommodation with his
Cnemies- "Let them go on hating me,” Lu Xun wrote. “I have f
Sword,” only a pen that is “not for sale.”
10.
Lu Xun’s “Medicine”
Milena Dolezelova-Velingerova
a subjec ter derived from ;
forceful (but concealed) ideolog de polished wane
ee led) ideological message, and a polished narrative
autobiographical elements and its ic :
linary authenticity. Moreover, the di cae [eerentiae
a prime subject of discussion, summoning dif cent and
Pally epee hea
‘un’s narrative techniques have rarely been studied,* is
Mastery of the written word an¢ rte as eto bee
4 more substantial formulation of its ideological message. Such an
tpproach further justine b
sep Justied by the character of La Xue weg hi
sage is never exit bt i concealed in an inate coe the cvs
be deciphered only if the
bs deciphered only fhe organizing principles of the story's structure
Medicine” is one of those narratives whose autobiographical
Sources are w
| soure ‘ell known. They relate to the bitler experiences of Lut
Xun’ childhood and youth. First there is his father’s death at the handsMilena DoleLefovd-Velingerooi
of “quack” doctors. Forced to commute for years between his home
ghd the local apothecary to fetch “cures” for his father, Lu Xun was
deeply impressed by this family tragedy” The second source, though
hnota personal experience, is still closely related to Lu Xun’s life. The
Formidable woman revolutionary Qiu Jin, an outstanding Chinese
political figure atthe beginning of the century, came from the same
Town. as Lu Xun, Shaohsing, In 1907 she was denounced by close
fronds and publicly executed near her home city Lu Xun, studying in
Japan atthe time of her execution, did not have any direct knowledge
A the event but apparently learned of the incident at second hand
To demonstrate the relationship between these autobiographical
facts and the resulting literary work, a simplified synopsis ofthe story
of “Medicine” is provided here, But instead of the composition of the
Story, the order of events as related in the text, we present the
‘Iovetion ofthe story, the chronological sequence of events, as follows:
Uncle Xia denounces his nephew Xia Yu to the authorities, cause he
fears that his rlative’s political activities may lead tothe extermination
Of the whole family. He is awarded twenty-five taels of silver.
Imprisoned, Xia Yu shows fearless conduct. Instead of breaking down
dhuring the investigation, he incites the jaller to revolt and proclaims
that the great Qing empire belongs to all the Chinese people. Uncle
Kang, who belongs to the town's undeeworld, informs Hua Old Shuan,
the owner of 4 small teahouse, that Xia Yu will be executed, From the
executioner Old Shuan buys a roll of bread, manios, which is dipped in
Sie Yu's blood at the moment ofthe execution. Old Shuan and his wife |
feed the mantou to their fatally ill son, Little Shuan, because they
believe in its healing powers. A half year later, during the Qing Ming
Festival in early spring, Little Shuan’s mother accidentally meets Xia.
Yo's mother in the cemetery. The graves oftheir sons lie side by side,
Seperated only by a path. Xia Yu's mother is puzzled by a circle of
Sewers decorating her son’s grave. In her grief, she turns to 2
superstitious belief and asks a raven perched nearby to fly down and
indicate the presence of her son’s soul. But the raven fails to respond. —
On leaving the cemetery the tio wwomen are startled by the raven's
oud caw as it suddenly takes off toward the horizon.
“The story’s disposition gives us basic information about Lu Xun’
handling of the autobiographical material, To begin with, all
references to the author are removed; there is no father, and there is no
tevolutionary from “our” town, These figures from the author's”
personal experience are transformed into the story's main characters,
‘and their basic qualities, such as age and sex, are determined by =
La Xun’s "Medicine
structural considerations. Second, and
seat | and more importantly, the two
independent personal experiences become two sy line inked
pees ‘er into one coherent plot. Unity is achieved not only ‘because
thereare motif common tbath ines ach ap the nein on
ers, but also because both stc lines have sanizing
mate ory lines have the same organizing
The first of thee prinpe, information manipulation gover ho
and when information about events in the narrative is to be intro-
ued La Xun demote ths prince Medion” by longo
a aired significant pieces of information from the rea der
m tis delayed information release, a well-known mystery story tech-
gue, helps cate users and tension the lot
ips td oaiing pice of "Mic isthe eeaton of
iymamic oppositions in the story structure. This principle br
sian components the sry into muta ppositon and soe
at Importance asthe story progresses
Nae of these principe can be carved inthe soy dapeton,
tates hey appro be oenising prince ofthe try comp
on In other words they ate operons tat raaforn he “tral”
ronolgil sequene of eens (s manfsed tn the depostion
into the “artificial” order of motifs given in the linear
iseties neat development
int
compositional order of motif, the st
ii ifs, the story has two clear
eiferen unis Theis unit consists ofthe ft the scone he
story, tis characterized by unity of time, dynamin ad the
pecans of «native mode cntoned by coin protgonit
Ut of tine achieve in tht the everts narrated ef he
secon ocr win ey shot timespan nly Yew hous
Dynamism resuls rom the mule aton mts lignan
2nd rom th fern ces by ing te aoe of ocground
information, Finally the native mode of the thee con
determined by the point of view of parca characters nsetn
one, the most important events ae Felted 3 the obsertions and
experiences of Od Shuny in section two asthe observations and
elings of Lite Shuan; and in section thre, ab the biased
and beliefs of Uncle Kang. ; ies epions
The second compositional unit of "Medi
sitinal unit of “Medicine” consists of only the
fourth and ast sion, whe n all ts base sucralfate
contrasts with the fist unit, Sigicanty ti separated fom the fst
a considerable temporal gap the fist thrce secon take placeea
act alone indeats
bs he fal, the forth eto nthe sping, Ths a! alone inde
at helas secon Foci san epg tthe try. Rather an 2
throat scenes sn the ft un the eon uni, basal
Ft itic episode permeated by a lyrical and reflective moo ae
a al CParrtie mede ofthe eecond unit not determined by
trove, the narrative mode o
point of view of a character but rather by an “objective,” “hidden’
ay respond to the
F a lines are incorporated into one compositional frame. bea
oe os ob yf information manipulation
ay ves ee story lines. The information about corer oo ng
a important events and circumstances is introduc only
Evotery” oft letely revealee
imagination; all we are allowed to see is a two-re we oat
section are also depi
ee ated yet hopeful sate of rind, which sem
ig 2s and
ee giten ae the sun ml Shans
onl atl peperecony
See ot immedialy ol vu ck
shpat urea tate
See itive. The tr remaining cr :
Se Sn fue ienfve Kron ony by lated sfereces— a
Woe and ouphig Neer chaactertc & hen pari
Fn eat ,tion, the action in section one if
aes ie ecu to comprehend. Presened through
Shuan’s deranged and incoherent perceptions, it reflects his excite
stuns entre obnemes oman stone people 08
merece Along about nests” Te ye tone "shone
IMGsigh es ame ger’ he ht of od
cee abut the xeon gen seed
netic tne eecaonet fat" man cad ete
224
.der’s visual and sensual
omy; only those traits
jcted with maximum economy; 01 te 4
meaningful to the ensuing action are provided. Old Shuan is projected.”
the sky grows light. But Old Shuan’s
acters, Old Shuan’s
Black... his eyes like daggers, making Old Shuan shrink to half his
normal size.” Most importantly, the object that the villager buys from
the executioner is also mysterious. We perceive, at first, only its
outward identity ~ a roll of mantou, Its metaphorical identity is only
suggested to us by the phrase “a crimson substance,” and its healing
power is only vaguely hinted at, again through Old Shuan’s giddy state
of mind. “Whose sickness is this for?” Old Shuan seemed to hear
someone ask; but he made no reply. His whole mind was on the
package, which he carried as carefully a if it were the sole heir to an
ancient house. Nothing else mattered now. He was about to transplant
this new life to his own home, and reap much happiness.”
Section two contains more definite information about the main
characters and a more consistent description of the action. ‘The
fragments of section one gain more coherence, The question “Whose
sickness is this for?,” which seemed only to show Old Shuan’s
hallucinating mind, becomes a logical link between the frst and the
second sections, The gloomy picture of sick Little Shuan gives us an
answer to the question, while the tender attentiveness with which his
Parents give him the mantou reveals tous the connections between the
mantou and the child's coughing. But information about the substance
that had transformed the mantou into a miraculous medicine is still
withheld. ts disclosure is prevented by the particular point of view
from which the action of this section is seen.
The most important stages of the action are related via the
perceptions of Little Shuan, and, secondarily, those of a customer in
the teahouse. Little Shuan is asked to stay away from the kitchen 50
that he cannot see what his parents are preparing. When he i given the
mantou for his breakfast, “he had the oddest feeling, as if he were
holding his whole life in his hands.” And “his father and mother were
standing at each side of him, their eyes apparently pouring something into
him and at the same time extracting something.” (Emphasis added) The
customer, struck by a strange odor permeating the teahouse, sks twice
about the source of the smell but gets no answer. The narrator reveals
that the parents prepared the mantow in the stove, but its
substance” remains a secret,
Only in section three is this secret revealed ~ by Uncle Kang. In fact,
he has so much additional information to provide the other characters
and the reader that Uncle Kang can be rightly called a secondary
“crimson
_Rarrator. He reports his information in response to questions from the
| Occupants of the teahouse (Old Shuan and his wife, anonymous
Customers), who, with the exception of occasional comments on
225—E—————————
Milena Doleielovi-Velingerovd
Kang’s revelations, remain relatively passive fo the situation. To
emphasize Kang’s special narrative role, he is described in greater
Gate! then the other characters. He is “a heavy-jowled man” and “his
“tank coarse cotton shirt was opened in the front, unbuttoned, and
fastened carelessly by a broad dark girdle at his waist.” His predatory
rend is hinted at later when he boasts about his connection with the
jailer
"To heighten the tension of the story, the secret of the mantou is
disclosed during the first part of his narrative in three gradual stages.
srthe first few sentences — shouted to attract the other customers’
sntention __ Kang only alludes to the secret. But these sentences tell ws
hat it was Uncle Kang who informed Old Shuan about the execution,
Inthe second stage of his revelation, Kang indicates the close
CSnnection between the healing power of the mantou and the
fnysterious substance: "This is a guaranteed cure! Not like other
thangs! Just think, brought back warm, and eaten warm!” Finally, the
apNance is directly identified, Significantly it is also in this explicit
eclaration that Little Shuan’s disease is given its real, frightening
secre. “A roll dipped in human blood like this can cure any
consumption!”
Revealing the secret of the mantow marks a turning point in the
development of “Medicine.” The story of Litle Shuan is closed. At the
seme time, the motif of human blood provides a link to the second
Story line the events surrounding Xia Yu's execution
“This second story line, like the first, is subject to the principle of
information manipulation. The execution being concealed in section
ane, itis only in section three that Uncle Kang tells of Xia Yu's fate:
Cantinuing in his narrator's role, Uncle Kang reveals the revolution-
Sis name and the other missing parts of Xia Yu's story — how he was
Jeaounced by his uncle, how he incited the jailer to revolt, and how he
proclaimed that “the great Qing empire belongs to us:” Only now does
Me most important event of this story line, the execution, become
cea the reader can finally reconstruct what actually happened in the
first compositional unit of “Medicine.”
‘One aspect of the disclosure of the revolutionary's story deserves
spual mention. Both Uncle Kang’ remarks and the comments of his =
reccnere are totally negative. The revolutionary is a “young rogue,” 4
veal scoundrel,” a “rotter.” The revolutionary’s tragedy thus deepens,
‘The “people” who were supposed to benefit from his actions have =
turned into his enemies and judges. q
When the first compositional tnit ends at the conclusion of section
Lu Xun's "Medicine
three, all necessary information about the two ston
siven The terion generated by the device of delayed information
Feleas is dissipated. But this is only a momentary respite. The second
uni the epilogue bring an even mere intense and pesstent tension,
Because the information will not be reveled in th tex the reader wi
si intensity ofthe epilogue again, gneated by the pine of
ation manipulation, But here it operates in a fashion opposite t
Bhat fhe i hee etn: deft infra proved, bt i
har concede sym meaning I tet word the pnp of
infomation manipulation i now implemented by mean of symbol
storys overall meaning i deciphered, In the fist compostonal un
the unknown information presented succesivly nthe text but
e epilogue, the unknown meaning has to be provided by the reader’
own interpretaion. The clue to such interpretation is given by the
second organizing principle of "Medicine," namely, dynamic opps
fon, As meine ear ti principe fs manifested inthe forma.
ion of contrasting pais of structural components and in the readjust-
ment of ther relative importance inthe course ofthe narrative
Ron ee er ae ene ae
Linked together by the motif of human blood. But in the epilogue, this
binary characteris demonstrated by other motif: the graves ofthe two
Young men ying sie by side are dvd onl by thin path they ook
lke rls of mantou, the substance that brought thei fates together
The two mothers although unknown to each other, ee united ge
ter Mother Hua crosses the path, they do not part
Tne ationshi ofthe to sary ins i complcted however, by
ine mami great fom the oppeton, Te arrangement of
es a radical reversal in the course ofthe ston
whe pn Inston the when the ere the mania
teva, the story revolves aren Lite Shia, Bu his pivot the
focsafthe wo storylines altered andthe emphasis shi fo ia Yu
This anton is|made dear in the last past of the tahowse
convertion: wl Uncle Kang tl about Xi Yu's exc, Lite
Shut xo of coughing he motes amdous ques
The principle of dynamic opposition governs not on
of evens In “Medicine” but aso Ms inematc stucare, whichis
__ tion. The whole first unit is dominated by the theme of darkness, as,Milena DoleSelovi-Velingerovt
both protagonists are victims of a benighted society. What is more,
darkness obscures the character of the revolutionary’s activity, which
is misrepresented by Uncle Kang’s biased report and by the comments
fof the villagers. It seems, at this point, that darkness has eliminated its
‘opposing theme. But, at its very moment of triumph, its power begins
te wane, First, the hunchback’s comment at the end of section
three — “Crazy” — echoes the other villagers’ opinion about the revo-
lutionary’s “crazy” behavior in jail. But this comment is delayed and
follows Uncle Kang’s final words~“A guaranteed cure!” — with
Which he tries to console the cough-racked Little Shuan. Where the
huunchback’s comment occurs gives the utterance new, unintentional
meaning, for it undermines the theme of superstition. Second, and
more important, an unbiased reader will learn from Uncle Kang about
the revolutionary’s ideals and courage, and the theme of revolution
thereby emerges in a positive light.
‘This latter theme, however, is given mor
the epilogue. There, the reversal in the relative importance of the two
main themes is first indicated by the change of seasons. Autumn, in
the Chinese tradition, is an awesome period of the year, corresponding
to the theme of darkness in the first three sections. In the epilogue, the
coming spring foreshadows the dispersion of darkness and the
emergence of new hope. Accordingly, the theme of revolution
supersedes that of darkness. This is clearly implied when Xia Yu's
mother says, “They all wronged you. .. know, they trapped you." But
a day of reckoning will come, Heaven will see to it. Close your eyes in
peace.” This comment contrasts sharply with those expressed
previously by the villagers. Coming from a grieving mother, it has
Fruch more textural and emotional weight; it transforms the victim of
the darkness into a hero.
“The character of the epilogue is primarily symbolic, and, therefore,
the revaluation of the two themes is also expressed principally in
symbolic form. Understanding these symbols in the epilogue is
Fecessary to determine the final ranking of the themes and to
formulate the story's ideological message. In accordance with out
we find that the various symbols used are actually
yre prominent treatment in
previous discussion,
pairs of opposites,
special importance with respect to the other member. In other words,
the meaning of the symbols is revealed in the opposition of properties
assigned to the particular members of the pair.
The most obvious symbol in the epilogue consists of the £0
mothers, Here, the ranking of themes is shown in the fact that Little
‘arranged so that one member of the pair has @
story's most obscure and, at the s:
ea |, at the same time,
Lu Xun's “Medicine”
Shu mths he a ale suri f ttf th rexhtnays
moter The fore crousthe puh an ter we
ciate The ccle of owes on Regnery eae
th crac questo, "Wht ds meant ahr sheik he
ste he pga mow sant sta, by hr dng te
sve y downto show rss presence Ad last but ee she
re ‘s of her son's fate and “a day of reckoning.” "
“Oi symbole pas are more cbt ost thre, he
But se xpath are two camino apelin: for Cin’ In the
gu the va most dea sybase te Howes he
and the raven, Many critics have already discusse first of these,
apparel cause of Le Xun own Seer
(Alo arm) Bt what has expe steno he fa tha the
{aon Xiu ee pny comet he homeo
taal ong ring oer on ite Sans eng pc te
i of Howes on Xin Yrs pave argc will A Mae
Huaotaere “they hve nore hey eanthne omedre
ae evidence of a pairing of motifs, the flowers on Little Shuan's
sravehavea neural, greenish tin wheres the cieleon Na vann
is composed of red and white blooms. a
Let we cou be ised tsb Xa’ ener ine
= of the wreath as an encouragement to “those fighters naa
falopingon in nls" il ths eneuragerent can havc sor
spr form, n const tothe satay gong er he westh
st hernia aman a though not lear whose the el
foman says only that it could not have been playing children or
Bvingsinvee Pshaps he rove was honed by Ma cond
8 2 ape of the wreath and its red and white colors may refer to
on-Chinese emblematic syst, and, therefore, sg an at of
People who hed adopted on Chins cst sn ens. Tat th
symbol raises these questions and leaves them without a defi 5
answer may be the best interpretation possible. a
‘A similar approach can be laken withthe raven, which, becase it
__ appears at the end of the story, is a highly significant symbol, Just as
the fst unit ofthe st
nit of the sty culminates with the fll revelation
characters action 50 the second it reaches ts Cline ih the
‘nos provocativeMilena Doleielood-Velingerovd
One might point out that the raven is just one bird, nok a PEt of
symbole as we find in the rest of this carefully structured s0ry Buta
ayer inspection reveals a hidden polarity. In fac, the raven appar
cose rrnatng scenes and serves a double symbolic function. 18 We
ee ore the raven is completely passive and is associated with 78
toa cer ors superstitious belief. According to Chinese legend the
wren van be read as a representation of fila piety, because 2 yore
rae feeds its old parents when they are unable to find food. But
ven the raven does not respond to the mother’s call its function 5% 6
Symbol of superstition is negated. Now it can assume a new symbolic
finetion, as shown by its strange behavior in the second cove
Significantly, a pause separates the second scene from the first.
Bolaes the pause, the raven i till seen “on the rigid bough of the 66,
aera econ in, perched immobile as iron.” But afte the pause, the
een suddenly caws loudly, and the women see it “stretch is Wing
cee oelf to take off, then fly like an arrow toward the far
horizon.”
‘Have the reader must ask Mother Xia's question: “What does it
mean?” The general structural principle of dynamic opposition that
Governs the other symbolic pats and the underlying themes leads to
geveTplanation, In the rst scene, the raven symbolizes superstiion
(darkness), whereas in the second scene, it symbolizes the oPPoEE
ceeaeeyt revolution. The second function of the raven, in efecy
the'arces the final dominant position of the theme of revolution vis-3-
vvis the theme of darkness.
“Chacsing the raven to symbolize revolution might seem bold OF
even inappropriate. In both the Chinese and Western traditions the
aoe has mainly represented tragedy, death, fright, and the unknown.
are ie well known that Lu Xun was never one of those waiters whe
wiealized violent change, And in 1919, when “Medicine” was wittety
rains just emerging from a deep depression caused by his diene
ae a ent with the incomplete Revolution of 1911. He might hav
tightly felt that a true revolution is an event that reaches toward far
eo end is, atthe same time, awesome and frightening. TM 7
porzotihen, can be an apt representation of this image of revolutions
Through the story's organizational principle of dynamic opposition,
cre ogeable faced” raven evokes set of dual connotations around 288.7
of its basic themes.
‘Thus, we see that Lu Xun uses the principles of informatil
manipulation and dynamic opposition to express the bizarre junsyes
aeeevof a society in tumult tis through a structural interpretation &
Lu Xun's “Medicine”
‘Med hat ne cn Kent th fain nd therfore
's ideological message. Indee: i
ies fs th nary nature fe ey nto
bai eltoshp bce he themes fdas and re clon
culminates in the negation of the “Garkness and the
cami e powers of darkness. a
th f a frightening, but cathartic symbol of ‘eohtion’ 7