Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Comparison of Auditor's Reports
A Comparison of Auditor's Reports
TSMC
INTERNAL AUDIT
TSMC's Internal Audit function is an independent unit that reports directly to the Board of
Directors. Besides informing the Board during its ordinary meetings, it briefs the Chairman,
the Board Audit Committee, and the Operating Committee on a quarterly and on as needed
basis.
The charter of Internal Audit is to review the internal controls in the company's processes and
to report on those controls with respect to the adequacy, effectiveness, and efficiency of their
design as well as their actual functioning on a day-to-day basis. All parts of the company and
its subsidiaries are open for review by Internal Audit.
The key audit matter for the Company's Our audit procedures related to the
consolidated financial statements for the evaluation of when to commence
year ended December 31, 2021, is stated as depreciation of EUI/CIP included the
follows: following, among others:
Property, plant, and equipment (PP&E) - 1. We read the Company's policy and
commencement of depreciation related to understood the criteria used to determine
PP&E classified as equipment under when to commence depreciation.
installation and construction in progress 2. We tested the effectiveness of the controls
(EUI/CIP) over the evaluation of when to commence
Refer to Notes 4, 5, and 14 in the depreciation of EUI/CIP.
consolidated financial statements. 3. We sampled the year-end balance of
The Company's evaluation of when to EUI/CIP and performed the following for
commence depreciation of EUI/CIP each selection:
involves determining when the assets are a. Evaluated whether the selection did not
available for their intended use. The meet the criteria specified by the Company
criteria the Company uses to determine for commencement of depreciation.
whether EUI/CIP is available for their b. Observed the assets and evaluated their
intended use involves subjective judgments status.
and assumptions about the conditions We sampled and evaluated whether the
necessary for the assets to be capable of selection of EUI/CIP met the criteria
operating in an intended manner. Changes specified by the Company for
in these assumptions could significantly commencement of depreciation during the
impact when depreciation is recognized. year.
Given the subjectivity in determining the 5. We sampled and evaluated whether the
date to commence depreciation of EUI/CIP, selection of EUI/CIP met the criteria
performing audit procedures to evaluate the specified by the Company for
reasonableness of the Company's judgments commencement of depreciation after year-
and assumptions required a high degree of end.
auditor judgment. Consequently, a key audit
matter is identified as the validity of
commencement of depreciation related to
PP&E classified as EUI/CIP.
GOBI
INDEPENDENT AUDITOR
The Risk Audit Committee of Gobi JSC determines the independence, qualifications, work
experience, and other criteria for the independent auditor, and evaluates whether the criteria
are met, the rights, duties, and responsibilities of the independent auditor, the number of fees
to be paid to the auditor, and other agreements The board of directors prepares and approves
proposals regarding the conditions. In addition to monitoring the activities of the independent
audit, he also supervises the implementation of the recommendations given to the
management. The financial statements of Gobi JSC as of December 31, 2021, were externally
audited by KPMG Audit LLC. KPMG Audit LLC is one of the 4 largest international audit
companies and was registered by the Financial Regulatory Commission as an Audit Company
providing services to the Securities Market in 2013.
IN CONCLUSION
The TSMC audited the financial accounts of Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing
Company Limited and its subsidiaries (the "Company "consolidated"). The accompanying
consolidated financial statements, in our opinion, depict the Company's consolidated
financial situation fairly in all essential aspects as of December 31, 2021, and 2020. They are
prepared in compliance with the Financial Reporting Regulations for Securities Issuers and
the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFS).
As of GOBI, they present the consolidated financial statements of the main JSC and its
subsidiaries (hereafter referred to as the "Group") as of December 31, 2021, including the
consolidated profit and loss statements and other detailed income statements for the fiscal
year ended, a statement of changes in ownership, cash audited, and a summary of significant
accounting policies. The Group's financial performance and cash flows are provided in line
with International Financial Reporting Standards ("IFRS").