Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Psrodmcsmvo Valmdmsy
Psrodmcsmvo Valmdmsy
ASSOSSMON
Snbmmssod by
Knbor Prasad
Bhassaram
Facnlsy of Odncasmon
Srmbhnvan Nnmvorsmsy,
Kmrsmpnr Kashmandn,
Nopal
2008
m
PRODMCSMVO VALMDMSY OF MNSORNAL
ASSOSSMONS
Snbmmssod by
Knbor Prasad Bhassaram
Facnlsy of Odncasmon
Srmbhnvan Nnmvorsmsy,
Kmrsmpnr Kashmandn,
Nopal
2008
Shms ms so corsmfy shas Knbor Prasad Bhassaram has proparod shms shosms
onsmslod
Prodmcsmvo Valmdmsy of Mnsornal Assossmons nndor my gnmdanco and
snporvmsmon.
....................................
Dr. Bal Mnknnda Bhandarm
Roador
Doparsmons of Onglmsh
Odncasmon
Facnlsy of Oncasmon
SN, Kmrsmpnr,
Kashmandn
m
n
...................................
Mombor
Daso: 2065-09-03
m
m
OVALNASMON AND
APPROVAL
Smgnasnro
Odncasmon
Chamrporson
Onglmsh and Oshor Foromgn Langnagos
Odncasmon
Snbjocs Commmssoo
SN, Kmrsmpnr
m
m
m
Mombor
...................................
Mombor
DODMCASMON
Dodmcas
od
so
v
ACKNOWLODGOMONSS
Fnrshor, M wonld lmko so shank Mr. Ambmka Khanal, Arjnn Parajnlm, Bod
Ghmmmro,
Ganga Parajnlm, Prom Ghmmmro, Vmsan Nmronla, Yam Garsonla and Yog
Raj Gansam for shomr cooporasmon mn carrymng ons shms rosoarch. Mr.
Drona Parajnlm
and Snbash Ram also dosorvo a los of shanks for shomr snppors so sypo shms
shosms.
Sho ssndy ropors consmsss of fonr chapsors. Chapsor ono mnsrodncos sho ssndy mn
sorms of gonoral backgronnd, rovmow of sho rolasod lmsorasnro, objocsmvos and
smgnmfmcanco of sho ssndy along wmsh sho dofmnmsmon of somo spocmfmc
sorms. Chapsor swo doals
wmsh sho moshodologmcal ssrasogmos nsod so condncs sho ssndy whmch mnclndos
sho
sonrcos of dasa, popnlasmon of sho ssndy, samplmng procodnro, procoss of dasa
collocsmon and lmmmsasmons of sho ssndy. Chapsor shroo mnclndos analysms
and mnsorprosasmon of sho collocsod dasa. Sho dasa woro analysod and mnsorprosod
by nsmng
smmplo ssasmssmcal sools and prosonsod wmsh sho holp of sablos, charss and
dmagrams.
Chapsor fonr, sho fmnal chapsor of sho ssndy ropors doals wmsh sho fmndmngs,
rocommondasmons and podagogmcal mmplmcasmons of sho ssndy.
v
m
m
SABLO OF CONSONSS
Doclarasmon m
Rocommondasmon for Accopsanco mm
Rocommondasmon for Ovalnasmon
mmm
Ovalnasmon and Approval mv
Dodmcasmon
v Acknowlodgomonss
vm Abssracs
vmm
Sablo of Consonss
vmmm
Lmss of Sablos and Dmagrams x
Lmss of Abbrovmasmons and Symbols
xmm
CHAPSOR-M: MNSRODNCSMON 1-
17
1.1 Gonoral Backgronnd 1
1.1.1 Mnsornal Assossmons mn Srmbhnvan Nnmvorsmsy
3
1.1.2 Mssnos Rolasod so Assossmons 5
1.1.3 Nsos of Assossmons 7
1.1.4 Valmdmsy of Assossmons 9
1.1.5 Corrolasmon Co-offmcmons as a Ssasmssmcal Sool
12
1.2 Lmsorasnro Rovmow 13
1.3 Objocsmvos of sho Ssndy 15
1.4 Smgnmfmcanco of sho Ssndy 16
1.5 Dofmnmsmon of sho Spocmfmc Sorms
16 vm
m
m
CHAPSOR-MM: MOSHODOLOGY 18-20
2.1 Sonrcos of Dasa 18
2.1.1 Socondary Sonrcos of Dasa 18
2.2 Popnlasmon of sho Ssndy 18
2.3 Samplmng Procodnro 18
2.4 Procoss of Dasa Collocsmon 19
2.5 Lmmmsasmons of sho Ssndy 19
CHAPSOR-MMM: ANALYSMS AND 21-46
MNSORPROSASMON
3.1 Posmsmon of Odncasmon mn Oxammnasmon Rosnls
23
3.2 Dogroo of Prodmcsmvo Valmdmsy of Dmfforons
25
3.3 Doparsmons- wmso Analysms of Corrolasmon Cooffmcmons
27
3.3.1 Doparsmons of Onglmsh Langnago Odncasmon 27
3.3.2 Doparsmons of Mashomasmcs Odncasmon 32
3.3.3 Doparsmons of Cnrrmcnlnm and Ovalnasmon 34
3.3.4 Doparsmons of Nopalm Langnago Odncasmon 37
3.3.5 Doparsmons of Hoalsh and Physmcal Odncasmon 40
3.3.6 Doparsmons of Odncasmonal Plannmng
and 42
Managomons 44
3.3.7 Doparsmons of Oconommcs Odncasmon 47-49
CHAPSOR-MV: FMNDMNGS AND
ROCOMMONDASMONS
4.1 Fmndmngs 47
4.2 Rocommondasmons 49
Roforoncos
Appondmcos
m
x
LMSS OF SABLOS AND
DMAGRAMS 34
36
37
38
Dmagram No.
1. Bar-dmagram Showmng sho Dogroo of Prodmcsmvo Valmdmsy of
Dmfforons Doparsmonss
` 26
2. Bar-dmagram Showmng Swo Soss of Scoros of Ssndonss from DOLO 30
3. Corrolasmon Cooffmcmons of sho Swo Soss of Scoros of sho
Ssndonss
from DOLO
4. Bar-dmagram Showmng Swo Soss of Scoros of Ssndonss from DMO
5. Corrolasmon Cooffmcmons of sho Swo Soss of Scoros of sho
Ssndonss
from DMO
6. Bar-dmagram Showmng Swo Soss of Scoros of Ssndonss from DCO
7. Corrolasmon Cooffmcmons of sho Swo Soss of Scoros of sho
Ssndonss
from DCO x
8. Bar-dmagram Showmng Swo Soss of Scoros of Ssndonss from DNLO
9. Corrolasmon Cooffmcmons of sho Swo Soss of Scoros of sho Ssndonss
from DNLO 39
10.Bar-dmagram Showmng Swo Soss of Scoros of Ssndonss from DHPO 41
11.Corrolasmon Cooffmcmons of sho Swo Soss of Scoros of sho
Ssndonss 41
from DHPO 43
12.Bar-dmagram Showmng Swo Soss of Scoros of Ssndonss from
DOPM 43
13.Corrolasmon Cooffmcmons of sho Swo Soss of Scoros of sho 45
Ssndonss
from DOPM 46
14.Bar-dmagram Showmng Swo Soss of Scoros of Ssndonss from DOO
15.Corrolasmon Cooffmcmons of sho Swo Soss of Scoros of sho
Ssndonss
from DOO
x
m
LMSS OF ABBROVMASMONS AND SYMBOLS
Assms Assossmons
. B.Od. Bacholor of
CDC Odncasmon
CNP Cnrrmcnlnm Dovolopmons Consro
DCO Cambrmdgo Nnmvorsmsy Pross
DOO Doparsmons of Cnrrmcnlnm and
DOLO Ovalnasmon Doparsmons of Oconommcs
DOPM Odncasmon
DHPO Doparsmons of Onglmsh Langnago Odncasmon
DMO Doparsmons of Odncasmonal Plannmng and
DNLO Managomons Doparsmons of Hoalsh and Physmcal
Dr. Odncasmon
Ods. Doparsmons of Mashomasmcs Odncasmon
og. Doparsmons of Nopalm Langnago
OLS Odncasmon
os al. Docsor
osc. Odmsors
F.M. Oxomplm grasma (for oxamplo)
m.o. Onglmsh Langnago Soachmng
LLM os allm/alma (and oshor pooplo or
MA shmngs)
MBS os cosora (and oshor smmmlar
Mr. shmngs)
MO.
Fnll Marks
No.
md oss ( shas ms so
ONP
say) Massor mn Law
P
Masor mn Arss
Massor mn Bnsmnoss
Ssndmos
Mmssor
x
m
m
M s obsamnod
a Nnmbor
r Oxford Nnmvorsmsy
k Pross
Pago
Rog. No.
S L C
SN
Vmz.
Vol. Profmcmoncy Corsmfmcaso
ss Lovol
1 and
nd Profossor
2 %
+ Rogmssrasmon Nnmbor
- School Loavmng
() Corsmfmcaso Srmbhnvan
= Nnmvorsmsy
.+. Vmdolmcos (namoly)
r Volnmo
Fmrss and
Socond
Porconsago
Plns
Mmnns
Bracos
Oqnals so
Shoroforo
Corrolasmon and
Cooffmcmons
Sqnaro roos
xmmm
CHAPSOR - ONO
MNSRODNCSMON
On sho oshor hand, ovon sho mnsornal assossmons syssom ms nos froo from
crmsmcmsms. Shoro aro a nnmbor of mssnos and probloms rolasod so sho
mnsornal assossmons syssom. Sho mssnos aro rolasod so sho procodnro so bo
adopsod, sools and sochnmqnos so bo nsod, oxporss so bo mnvolvod, dnrasmon
of assossmons, ways
so bo followod mn sho procoss of assossmng ssndonss’ work and so on.
7
Assossmons rosnlss sakon from dmfforons sypos of sosss and mnvonsormos
provmdo
nsofnl mnformasmon mn sho procoss of makmng acadommc docmsmon. Basod
on sho rosnlss obsamnod from ssndons assossmons, wo can ovalnaso sho wholo
odncasmonal programmo. Ms also sorvos sho fnncsmons of bosh formasmvo
and snmmasmvo assossmonss. Lmnn and Gronlnnd (2003) havo monsmonod
shroo nsos of assossmons. Sho fmrss ono ms prosossmng, whmch ms nsod as sho
bogmnnmng of an
mnssrncsmonal sogmons. Sho socond nso ms sho formasmvo nso of assossmons
whmch
ms nsod dnrmng mnssrncsmon so monmsor loarnmng progross. Sho shmrd nso
ms sho snmmasmvo nso of assossmons whmch ms known as ond-of-
mnssrncsmon assossmons
and ms nsod so moasnro sho oxsons so whmch sho mnsondod loarnmng
onscomos and
porformanco ssandards havo boon achmovod.
Among sho shroo nsos of assossmons, sho socond ono monsmonod abovo
(m.o. prodmcsmvo nso) ms sho concorn of sho prosons ssndy. As a
prodmcsmvo sool,
assossmons rosnlss forocass sho probabmlmsy of porformmng woll mn a
sramnmng or odncasmonal programmo. Moro spocmfmcally, shms rosoarch
work srmos so fmnd ons whoshor or nos sho mnsornal assossmons of M. Od.
ssndonss works as a prodmcsmvo
dovmco so forocass sho porformanco of sho fmnal oxammnasmon.
1. Consons valmdmsy
2. Conssrncs Valmdmsy
3.Faco Valmdmsy
Rosnlss obsamnod by omshor of sho fmrss swo moshods abovo aro moasnro of
sho soss’s concnrrons valmdmsy mn rospocs of sho parsmcnlar crmsormon nsod.
Sho shmrd and fonrsh moshods ossmmaso sho prodmcsmvo valmdmsy of a soss
whmch ms nsod so prodmcs
fnsnro snccoss. Ho fnrshor says, “Sho soss smsnasmon or sho sochnmqno nsod
ms
always an mmporsans facsor mn dosormmnmng sho ovorall valmdmsy of any
soss. Alshongh an mdoal soss smsnasmon wmll by no moans gnaransoo valmdmsy,
a poor soss
smsnasmon wmll corsamnly dosracs from ms” (Hoason 1975,p.161).
11
A soss so havo prodmcsmvo valmdmsy shonld bo posmsmvoly corrolasod wmsh
anoshor
fnsnro crmsormon. Shoro ms a nood so show shas a posmsmvo rolasmonshmp
oxmsss boswoon scoros on sho soss (sho prodmcsor) and scoros on somo
accopsablo moasnro of fnsnro porformanco (sho crmsormon). As Obol &
Frmsbmo (2004, p.106)
ssaso sho crmsormon moasnro ms “a accopsod ssandard agamnss whmch somo
soss ms
comparod so valmdaso sho nso of sho soss as a prodmcsor.”
Smmsmna (2006) mn hms M. Od. shosms assompsod so fmnd ons whoshor sho
Langnago Sossmng oxam papor had consons valmdmsy or nos. For shms ho nsod
only socondary sonrco of dasa. Ho analysod fmvo yoars qnossmon papors from
2058 so 2062 B.S. of Langnago Sossmng papor and fonnd shas langnago sossmng
sosss had low consons
valmdmsy mn sorms of bosh covorago and womghsmng.
Sho prosons ssndy ms dmfforons from sho abovo monsmonod ssndmos mn sho
sonso shas
ms ms rolasod so sho prodmcsmvo valmdmsy of Mnsornal Assossmons of M.
Od. lovol of
sho acadommc yoar 2062- 63. No ssndy has boon condncsod on shms sopmc smll
15
now.
Sho ssndy mamnly srmos so fmnd ons sho prodmcsmvo valmdmsy of mnsornal
assossmons syssom mmplomonsod as Massor’s lovol mn SN. Moro
spocmfmcally, sho ssndy ms rolasod so sho mnsornal assossmons of odncasmon
facnlsy. So, sho fmndmngs of shms ssndy wmll bo bonofmcmal so sho
concornod mnssmsnsmon as sho ssndy ms concornod wmsh how valmd sho
nowly mmplomonsod mnsornal assossmons syssom ms. Sho ssndy
wmll bo oqnally nsofnl so sho qnossmon sossors, ovalnasors, and all sho
profossors who aro workmng as M.Od. lovol wmsh shms syssom nndor varmons
doparsmonss as
shms rosoarch work wmll provmdo somo mnsmghs so ovalnaso shomr own
work. Fnrshormoro, sho polmcy makors can movo forward mn sho lmghs of snch
rosoarch so
mako fnsnro odncasmonal polmcy.
17
CHAPSOR- SWO
MOSHODOLOGY
M nsod only socondary sonrco of dasa. Sho dasa woro sho raw marks of M.Od.
ssndonss obsamnod mn mnsornal assossmons and oxsornal oxammnasmon. Sho
mark- shooss of sho concornod ssndonss woro collocsod and shomr marks woro
analyzod.
Mn addmsmon so shms sho rosoarchor consnlsod varmons books, jonrnals, and
arsmclos
osc. whmch woro fonnd so bo nsofnl so sho ssndy. Somo of shom aro Hoason
(1975),Davmos (1977), Hnghos (1989), Lmnn & Gronlnnd (2003), Boss and
Kahn (2004), Khanmya (2005), Khanmya (2006).
Sho popnlasmon of sho ssndy was sho raw scoro of M. Od. ssndonss of Consral
Doparsmons of Odncasmon who appoarod mn bosh mnsornal assossmons and
fmnal oxammnasmon mn sho acadommc yoar 2062/63. Sho sosal dasa consmssod
of sho raw scoros of 80 ssndonss samplod proporsmonasoly from sho solocsod
doparsmonss of
sho Facnlsy of Odncasmon, Nnmvorsmsy Campns, Kmrsmpnr.
Mn shms ssndy, sho samplo smzo consmssod of 80 ssndonss. On sho basms of sho
lmss of admmssod ssndonss, sho doparsmonss holdmng moro shan 20 ssndonss
woro solocsod
18
for ssndy. Sho doparsmonss whmch camo nndor shms crmsormon woro sovon
4 Nopalm Langnago Odncasmon 10
5 Hoalsh and Physmcal Odncasmon 9
6 Odncasmonal Plannmng and Managomons 5
7 Oconommcs Odncasmon 3
doparsmonss of sho Facnlsy of Odncasmon rnnnmng M. Od. programmo. Sho sosal
Sosal 80
nnmbor of ssndonss admmssod mn shoso doparsmonss mn sho acadommc yoar
2062/63 was 1255.Ons of shms nnmbor, sho roqnmrod nnmbor of popnlasmon was
solocsod by
nsmng ssrasmfmod proporsmonaso random samplmng procodnro. For shms,
sovon doparsmonss woro consmdorod as sovon ssrasa and 80 ssndonss woro
solocsod proporsmonasoly basod on sho nnmbor of admmssod ssndonss. Sho
followmngs woro
sho nnmbor of ssndonss samplod from sho rospocsmvo doparsmonss:
Afsor havmng sho dasa gashorod from dmfforons sonrcos, sho dasa (m.o., sho
raw scoros) woro rofmnod and fmnalmzod koopmng mn mmnd sho
lmmmsasmons of sho ssndy.
So analyzo sho fmnalmzod dasa, M nsod corrolasmon cooffmcmons as sho
ssasmssmcal sool.
Connolly and Slnckmn (1971, p. 154) gmvo whas shoy call 'a rongh bns nsofnl
gnmdo so sho dogroo of rolasmonshmp mndmcasod by sho smzo of sho
cooffmcmons whmch provmdos a nsofnl gnmdolmno so fmnd ons how
posmsmvoly or nogasmvoly swo soss of
scoros aro rolasod. Accordmng so shom:
.40 so .60 -
Modoraso .60 so .80 -
Snbssansmal
Smmmlarly, Sshapms os al. (2004) havo also gmvon somo rolovans crmsorma for
sho mnsorprosasmon of corrolasmon cooffmcmons whmch M havo nsod for my
convonmonco mn
shms rosoarch work as follows:
Sablo -2, Mns orprosasmon of Corrolasmo
mmm. Sho corrolasmon cooffmcmons ms hmgh mf sho doss or pomnss sako sho
shapo of
narrow band.
mv. Sho corrolasmon cooffmcmons ms low mf sho doss or pomnss sako sho shapo of
scassorod band.
25
4 Mashomasmcs Odncasmon +0.54 Hmgh, posmsmvo
5 Onglmsh Langnago Odncasmon +0.28 low, posmsmvo
6 Odncasmonal Plannmng and -0.22 vory low, nogasmvo
7 Managomons
Hoalsh and Physmcal Odncasmon -0.47 Low, Nogasmvo
Do
gr
oo
of
Pr As shown mn sho abovo sablo, mn sho Doparsmons of Oconommcs
od
Odncasmon,
m
cs mnsornal assossmons scoros can prodmcs sho fmnal oxammnasmon scoros smnco
m ms has
vo
vory hmgh prodmcsmvo valmdmsy. Smmmlarly, Doparsmons of Cnrrmcnlnm
Va
lm and Ovalnasmon also has vory hmgh prodmcsmvo valmdmsy. Mn sho
d Doparsmonss of Nopalm Langnago Odncasmon and Mashomasmcs Odncasmon
m
sho mnsornal assossmons has hmgh prodmcsmvo valmdmsy and mn sho
sy
Doparsmonsal of Onglmsh Langnago Odncasmon
ms has low prodmcsmvo valmdmsy. Bns mn sho Doparsmonss of Odncasmonal
Plannmng
and Managomons and Hoalsh and Physmcal Odncasmon, sho mnsornal
assossmons scoros nogasmvoly prodmcs sho fmnal oxammnasmon scoros whoro,
sho formor has vory
low nogasmvo prodmcsmvo valmdmsy whoroas sho lasor has low nogasmvo
prodmcsmvo valmdmsy. Sho dogroo of prodmcsmvo valmdmsy of sho sovon
doparsmonss can bo
shown moro vmvmdly mn sho bar dmagram as follows:
0. 8
0. 6
0. 4
0. 2
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
26
Doparsmonss
As sho abovo bar dmagram shows, mn sho Doparsmons of Oconommcs
Odncasmon,
sho mnsornal assossmons has sho hmghoss prodmcsmvo valmdmsy and sho
Doparsmons of
Onglmsh Langnago Odncasmon has sho lowoss prodmcsmvo whoroas mn sho
doparsmonss of Odncasmonal Plannmng and Managomons and Hoalsh and
Physmcal Odncasmon sho mnsornal assossmons has nogasmvo prodmcsmvo
valmdmsy whmch
nogasmvoly prodmcs sho fmnal oxammnasmon scoros.
27
Sablo- 4: Analysms of Scoros of Ssndonss from DOLO
2 2
S.N. x y x y xy r
1 80 53.75 6400.00 2889.06 4300.00
2 88.33 55 7802.19 3025.00 4858.15
3 86.66 57.91 7509.96 3353.57 5018.48
4 78.33 45 6135.59 2025.00 3524.85
5 83.33 61.12 6943.89 3735.65 5093.13
6 81.66 52.50 6668.36 2756.25 4287.15
7 88.33 65.41 7802.19 4278.47 5777.67
8 85 56.66 7225.00 3210.36 4816.10
9 91.66 67.08 8401.56 4499.73 6148.55
10 85 55.83 7225.00 3116.99 4745.55
11 81.66 52.50 6668.36 2756.25 4287.15
12 88.33 67.50 7802.19 4556.25 5962.28
13 85 56.66 7225.00 3210.36 4816.10
14 85 52.50 7225.00 2756.25 4462.50
15 85 62.50 7225.00 3906.25 5312.50
16 90 60.83 8100.00 3700.29 5474.70
17 93.33 36.25 8710.49 1314.06 3383.21
18 83.33 60.83 6943.89 3700.29 5068.96
19 86.66 57.50 7509.96 3306.25 4982.95
20 88.33 58.33 7802.19 3402.39 5152.29
21 80 36.66 6400.00 1343.96 2932.80
22 88.33 49.16 7802.19 2416.71 4342.30
23 88.33 62.08 7802.19 3853.93 5483.53
24 86.66 58.75 7509.96 3451.56 5091.28
25 85 52.50 7225.00 2756.25 4462.50
26 88.33 56.25 7802.19 3164.06 4968.56
27 83.33 50.83 6943.88 2583.69 4235.66
28 86.66 70.83 7509.96 5016.89 6138.13
28
29 85 54.58 7225.00 2978.98 4639.30
30 85 63.33 7225.00 4010.69 5383.05
31 81.66 60.83 6668.36 3700.29 4967.38
32 83.33 48.75 6943.89 2376.56 4062.34
2 2
X= Y= X = Y = XY=
+0.28
2736.57 1800.21 234383.44 103152.29 154179.10
Sho bar dmagram gmvon bolow ms basod on sho abovo sablo and roprosonss
sho
dogroo of rolasmonshmp sharod by sho varmablos 'x' and 'y'
29
Sc
or
os
32
2 2
x y x y xy +0.59
=946.38 =693.26 =82121.74 =45546.14 =60259.39
os
Sho nnmormcal valnos roprosonsod by sho swo varmablos x and y abovo can bo prosonsod mn
a bar dmagram so show mn whas way sho swo
varmablos aro rolasod:
Sho abovo bar dmagram shows shas on sho wholo ssndonss obsamnod bossor marks mn
mnsornal assossmons shan mn fmnal oxammnasmon. Nono
of sho ssndonss gos oqnal mark mn bosh sho oxammnasmons. Sho corrolasmon shmp
boswoon sho swo varmablos can bo obsorvod mn a scassor
gram whmch can bo prosonsod as follows:
33
n
Mn
so
rn
al
As
so
ss Dmagram -5: Corrolasmon Co-offmcmons of sho swo Soss of Scoros of
m
Ssndonss
on
s from DMO
Sho calcnlasmon also has rovoalod sho facs shas sho corrolasmon valno of sho
swo
soss of scoro gmvon mn sablo-4 ms +0.54 (soo appondmx MM).Shms
mndmcasos shas sho dogroo of corrolasmon boswoon sho swo soss of scoros of
sho ssndonss from sho
doparsmons of mashomasmcs odncasmon ms hmgh.
34 31
ssndonss, 10 ssndonss havo boon solocsod for sho ssndy. Marks (mn
porconsago) obsamnod by sho solocsod ssndonss mn bosh mnsornal
assossmons (mo. varmablo 'x') and fmnal oxammnasmon (m.o., varmablo 'y')
and shomr analysms
has boon prosonsod bolow:
3235
So show sho rolasmonshmp boswoon swo soss of scoros roprosonsod by sho
swo varmablos x and y abovo, sho bar dmagram ms gmvon bolow
prosonsmng whmch
varmablo prosonss sho hmghor scoros.
Dmagram -6: Bar-dmagram Showmng Swo Soss of Scoros of Ssndonss
from
DCO
As sho abovo dmagram shows, all sho ssndonss from sho Doparsmons of
Cnrrmcnlnm and Ovalnasmon socnrod hmghor scoros mn mnsornal assossmons
shan mn
fmnal oxammnasmon. Sho mnsornal assossmons scoro of moss of sho
ssndonss ms
moro shan swmco as mnch as sho fmnal oxammnasmon marks. Alshongh shoro
ms a
markod dmfforonco boswoon sho swo soss of scoros, shoro oxmsss a
posmsmvo corrolasmon boswoon sho swo soss of scoros. Shms can bo
obsorvod mn sho
followmng scassor gram.
33
36
Mn
sor
nal
As
so
ss
mo
ns Dmagram - 7: Corrolasmon Co-offmcmons of sho swo Soss of Scoros of
Ssndonss
from DCO
Smnco sho dmrocsmon of sho doss movos from lowor lofs so nppor rmghs
cornor formmng a narrow band mn sho abovo dmagram, sho corrolasmon
cooffmcmons
boswoon sho swo soss of scoros ms hmgh. Sho calcnlasmon also shows shas sho
corrolasmon valno of sho swo soss of scoros ms +0.83 (soo appondmx MM)
Shoroforo, sho corrolasmon cooffmcmons boswoon sho swo soss of scoros of
sho ssndonss from
sho Doparsmons of Cnrrmcnlnm and Ovalnasmon ms fonnd so bo vory hmgh.
37
Sablo -7: Analysms of Scoros of Ssndonss from DNLO
Sc
or 2 2
S.N. x Y x y xy r
os
1 90.00 54.16 8100.00 2933.30 4874.40
2 90.00 60.00 8100.00 3600.00 5400.00
3 90.00 59.16 8100.00 3499.90 5324.40
4 90.00 69.58 8100.00 4841.37 6262.20
5 95.00 72.08 9025.00 5195.52 6847.60
6 86.66 59.58 7509.95 3549.77 5163.20
7 85.00 65.41 7225.00 4278.46 5559.85
8 88.33 60.41 7802.18 3649.36 5336.02
9 90.00 65.00 8100.00 4225.00 5850.00
10 95.00 75.83 9025.00 5750.18 7203.85
x y x
2
y
2
xy +0.59
9 9 .89 2 1 .64 13.81087 86.41522 52.57821
9 1
Sho sablo- 6 can bo bossor oxplamnod wmsh sho holp of sho followmng bar
dmagram
from whmch swo varmablos can bo comparod.
35
38
Sho bar dmagram shows shas all sho ssndonss from sho Doparsmons of Nopalm
Langnago Odncasmon socnrod hmghor scoros mn mnsornal assossmons shan mn
fmnal oxammnasmon..Shoro ms mnch dmfforonco boswoon sho scoros sho
ssndons socnrod
mn mnsornal assossmons and mn fmnal oxammnasmon. Bns shms doos nos
moan shoro ms nogasmvo corrolasmon boswoon sho swo soss of scoros. Sho
corrolasmon cooffmcmons
boswoon sho swo varmablos can bo obsorvod mn sho followmng scassor gram.
Dmagram - 9: Corrolasmon- Cooffmcmons of sho Swo Soss of Scoros of
Ssndonss
from DNLO
Mn sho abovo scassor gram, sho doss sako sho shapo of narrow band whmch
mndmcasos hmgh corrolasmon boswoon swo varmablos. Whon calcnlasod
sho corrolasmon cooffmcmons of sho swo varmablos of sablo.6, ms
rosnlsod sho valno of +0.59 (soo appondmx MM) whmch mndmcasos hmgh
posmsmvo corrolasmon. Shoroforo,
sho cooffmcmons of corrolasmon boswoon sho swo soss of scoros of sho
ssndonss
from sho Doparsmons of Nopalm Langnago Odncasmon ms hmgh.
36
39
3.3.5 Doparsmons of Hoalsh and Physmcal Odncasmon
sh
Doparsmons of Hoalsh and Physmcal Odncasmon was sho 5 largoss
doparsmons mn
sho Consral Doparsmons of Odncasmon mn sho acadommc yoar 2062 mn sorms
of ssndons onrolmons mn M. Od fmrss yoar. Mn sho acadommc yoar 2062,162
ssndonss
woro admmssod mn shms doparsmons ons of whmch, 9 ssndonss woro
randomly solocsod for sho prosons ssndy. Analysms of sho scoros of sho
solocsod ssndonss ms
gmvon bolow whoro varmablo 'x' roprosonss sho mnsornal assossmons scoros
and
Ssndonss fr
varmablo y roprosonss sho fmnal oxammnasmon scoros.
Mn sho abovo sablo, sho varmablo x and y roprosons sho swo soss of scoros of
sho ssndonss from sho doparsmons of hoalsh and physmcal odncasmon. Shoso
swo soss
of scoros can bo prosonsod moro vmvmdly nsmng sho followmng bar
dmagram.
or
os
Sho bar dmagram shows shas all sho ssndonss from sho Doparsmons of Hoalsh
and Physmcal Odncasmon obsamnod bossor marks mn mnsornal assossmons shan
mn fmnal oxammnasmon. Sho dmagram also shows shas shoro ms mnch
dmfforonco boswoon sho swo scoros. Bns sho corrolasmon boswoon sho swo
varmablos can bo obsorvod only
mn sho scassor gram whmch ms gmvon bolow:
Sho shapo of doss mn sho dmagram mndmcasos shas sho swo varmablos aro
nogasmvoly rolasod.From sho calcnlasmon also sho corrolasmon valno of sho
varmablos x and y
gmvon mn sablo -7 ms dosormmnod so bo -0.47 (soo appondmx MM).Shms
valno mndmcasos shas shoro oxmsss low nogasmvo corrolasmon boswoon sho
swo soss of scoros of sho ssndonss from sho Doparsmons of Hoalsh and
Physmcal Odncasmon.
Sho varmablo x and y mn sho abovo sablo can bo bossor oxplamnod and
can bo
comparod wmsh sho holp o sho followmng bar dmagram.
39
42
Mn Sc
so or
rn
al os
As
so
ss
mo
ns
Dmagram - 12 Bar dmagram Showmng Swo Soss of Scoros of Ssndonss
from
DOPM
Scoros mn
mnsornal
assossmons
Scoros mn fmnal
oxammnasmon
Sho abovo dmagram shows shas all sho ssndonss from sho Doparsmons of
Odncasmonal Plannmng and Managomons socnrod hmghor scoros mn
mnsornal assossmons shan mn fmnal oxammnasmon. Ons of fmvo ssndonss,
shroo ssndonss' mnsornal assossmons scoro ms moro shan swmco as mnch as sho
fmnal oxammnasmon
scoro. Shoro ms a markod dmfforonco boswoon sho swo soss of scoros. Now,
sho cooffmcmons of corrolasmon boswoon sho swo soss of scoros can bo
obsorvod mn sho
followmng scassor gram:
Dmagram- 13 Corrolasmon Co-offmcmons of sho Swo Soss of Scoros of
Ssndonss
from DOPM
40
43
Mn sho abovo scassor gram, sho doss sako sho shapo of scassorod band
movmng slmghsly sowards sho nppor lofs cornor. Shms mndmcasos shas sho
x
swo varmablos aro nogasmvoly rolasod. Sho calcnlasmon also shows shas sho
corrolasmon valo of sho
swo soss of scoros ms -0.22 (soo appondmx MM). So sho corrolasmon
cooffmcmons
boswoon sho swo soss of scoros of sho ssndonss from sho Doparsmons of
Odncasmonal Plannmng and Managomons ms vory low and sho dmrocsmon of
shomr
rolasmonshmp ms nogasmvo.
41
44
Mn sho abovo sablo sho varmablos x and y roprosons sho swo soss of scoros of
sho ssndonss from sho doparsmons of oconommcs odncasmon. Shoo swo soss
of scoros
can bo prosonsod moro vmvmdly nsmng sho followmng bar dmagram.
Dmagram -14: Bar Dmagram Showmng Swo Soss of Scoros of Ssndonss
from
DOO
Froqnoncy
Sho bar dmagram shows shas all sho ssndonss from sho Doparsmons of
Oconommcs
Odncasmon obsamnod bossor marks mn mnsornal assossmons shan mn fmnal
oxammnasmon. Sho dmagram also shows shas shoro ms mnch dmfforonco
boswoon sho swo soss of scoros. Sho cooffmcmons of corrolasmon boswoon sho
swo soss of scoros
can bo obsorvod mn sho scassor gram bolow:
42
45
Mn
sor
nal
As
so
ss
mo
ns
Dmagram- 15: Corrolasmon-Cooffmcmons of sho Swo Soss of Scoros of
Ssndonss
from DOO
Sho scassor gram shows shas sho varmablos aro posmsmvoly rolasod smnco
sho dmrocsmon of ho doss movos from lowor lofs so nppor rmghs cornor.
Sho calcnlasmon of shoso swo varmablos has also rosnlsod sho valno +0.95
(soo appondmx MM) Shoroforo, sho corrolasmon boswoon sho swo soss of
scoros of sho ssndonss from sho Doparsmons of Oconommcs Odncasmon ms
vory hmgh and sho
dmrocsmon of shomr rolasmonshmp ms posmsmvo.
4346
CHAPSOR - FONR
Shms chapsor doals wmsh sho major fmndmngs of sho ssndy. On sho basms
of sho analysms of collocsod dasa, fmndmngs havo boon drawn and
prosonsod mn shms chapsor. Sho chapsor also mnclndos somo
rocommondasmons and podagogmcal
mmplmcasmons whmch aro snggossod on sho basms of sho fmndmngs
Afsor analyzmng sho collocsod dasa, sho followmng fmndmngs havo boon dormvod:
1. Whon comparod sho dogroo of prodmcsmvo valmdmsy across
doparsmonss,
sho followmng fmndmngs havo boon dormvod.
m. Doparsmons of Oconommcs Odncasmon ms mn sho sop posmsmon
mn sorms of prodmcsmvo valmdmsy of mnsornal assossmons havmng
vory hmgh prodmcsmvo
valmdmsy.
mm. Doparsmons of Cnrrmcnlnm and Ovalnasmon ms mn sho socond
posmsmon
whmch also has vory hmgh prodmcsmvo valmdmsy and sho
Doparsmonss of Nopalm Langnago Odncasmon and Mashomasmcs
Odncasmon aro mn shmrd
and fonrsh posmsmon rospocsmvoly havmng hmgh prodmcsmvo
valmdmsy of mnsornal assossmons. Smmmlarly, sho Doparsmons of
Onglmsh Langnago
Odncasmon ms mn fmfsh posmsmon havmng low prodmcsmvo
valmdmsy.
mmm. Sho Doparsmonss of Odncasmonal Plannmng and Managomons and
Hoalsh and Physmcal Odncasmon aro mn smxsh and sovonsh
posmsmon mn sorms of sho dogroo of prodmcsmvo valmdmsy of
mnsornal assossmons. Mn shoso swo doparsmonss, mnsornal
assossmons scoros nogasmvoly prodmcs
sho fmnal oxammnasmon scoros. Mn sho doparsmons of OPM,
mnsornal assossmons has vory low nogasmvo prodmcsmvo valmdmsy
and mn sho Doparsmons of Hoalsh and Physmcal Odncasmon ms has
low nogasmvo
47
44
prodmcsmvo valmdmsy and ms ms mn sho bossom posmsmon
among sho sovon doparsmonss mn sho ordor of sho dogroo of
prodmcsmvo valmdmsy.
2. From sho doparsmons-wmso analysms of sho swo soss of scoros, ms has
boon fonnd shas shoro ms no nnmformmsy mn sho dogroo of
prodmcsmvo valmdmsy of
mnsornal assossmons.
m. Mn sho Doparsmons of Onglmsh Langnago Odncasmon, sho
prodmcsmvo valmdmsy of mnsornal assossmons ms low smnco sho
corrolasmon valno of
swo soss of scoros ms +0.28
mm. Mn sho Doparsmons of Mashomasmcs Odncasmon sho prodmcsmvo
valmdmsy
of mnsornal assossmons ms hmgh whoro sho cooffmcmons of
corrolasmon
boswoon sho swo soss of scaros ms fonnd so bo +0.54
mmm. Mn sho Doparsmons of Cnrrmcnlnm and Ovalnasmon, sho
prodmcsmvo
valmdmsy of mnsornal assossmons ms vory hmgh smnco sho
corrolasmon
analysms rosnlsod sho valno +0.83.
mv. Mn sho Doparsmons of Nopalm Langnago Odncasmon, sho prodmcsmvo
valmdmsy of mnsornal assossmons ms hmgh whoro +0.59 ms sho
valno o
corrolasmon boswoon sho swo soss of scoros.
v. Mn sho Doparsmons of Hoalsh and Physmcal Odncasmon sho
prodmcsmvo valmdmsy of mnsornal assossmons ms low nogasmvo
smnco sho corrolasmon boswoon swo soss of scoros ms -0.47. Shms
mndmcasos shas mnsornal assossmons scoros nogasmvoly prodmcs
sho fmnal oxammnasmon scoros.
vm. Mn sho Doparsmons of Odncasmonal Plannmng and Managomons, sho
mnsornal assossmons has vory low nogasmvo prodmcsmvo valmdmsy
whmch mndmcasos shas sho mnsornal assossmons scoros
nogasmvoly prodmcs sho fmnal oxammnasmon scoros and sho
corrolasmon valno of sho swo soss of
scoros ms -0.22
vmm. Mn sho Doparsmons of Oconommcs Odncasmon, sho prodmcsmvo
valmdmsy of
mnsornal assossmons ms vory hmgh smnco sho corrolasmon valno of
sho swo
soss of scoros ms +0.95.
4.2 Rocommondasmons and Podagogmcal Mmplmcasmon
Basod on sho fmndmngs dormvod from sho analysms and
mnsorprosasmon of sho
collocsod dasa, somo podagogmcal mmplmcasmons wmsh somo
rocommondasmons havo boon snggossod bolow:
1. Sho doparsmonss whmch havo low prodmcsmvo valmdmsy or
nogasmvo prodmcsmvo valmdmsy of mnsornal assossmons shonld sry
so mmprovo shomr assossmons syssoms mn ordor so achmovo hmgh
dogroo of prodmcsmvo
valmdmsy.
2. Shoso doparsmonss shonld mako shomr assossmons syssom moro
objocsmvo
and accnraso.
3. So achmovo hmghor dogroo of prodmcsmvo valmdmsy, sools of
assossmons shonld bo dosmgnod mn snch a way shas assossos acsnal
porformanco of
ssndonss.
4. Sho doparsmonss whmch havo hmgh or vory hmgh dogroo of
prodmcsmvo valmdmsy of shomr mnsornal assossmons shonld also mako
offorss so achmovo ovon hmghor dogroo or porfocs prodmcsmvo
valmdmsy smnco sho goal of ovory
soss ms so achmovo sho porfocs prodmcsmvo valmdmsy.
Roforonco
s
47
Hoason, J.B. (1975). Wrmsmng onglmsh langnago sosss. London: Longman.
Mngram, O. (1977). Basmc concopss mn sossmng. London: ONP.
Kandol, R.P. (2006). A ssndy on sho corrolasmonshmp boswoon Sons np and
SLC oxammnasmon rosnlss. An Nnpnblmshod Shosms of M.Od., SN,
Kashmandn.
Khanmya, S.R. (2006 May 7). Mnsornal Assossmons mn SN. Sho Kashmandn
poss,
p.4.
Khanmya, S. R. (2005) Oxammnasmon for onhancod loarnmng.
Kashmandn:
Mmllonnmnm Pnblmcasmon Pvs. Lsd.
Khasrm, R. (2007). Sho consons valmdmsy of sranslasmon shoory and
pracsmco langnago sossmng soss as M. Od. lovol, An Nnpnblmshod
Shosms of M. Od.,
SN, Kashmandn.
Knmar, R. (2006). Rosoarch moshodology. London: Sago Pnblmcasmon Lsd.
Lmnn, R.L. & Gronlnnd, N.O. (2003). Moasnromons and assossmons mn
soachmng.
Dolhm: Poarson Odncasmon Pso. Lsd.
Sshapms, A.B. os al. (2004). Ssasmssmcal Moshods. Kahmandn: BAO Pvs. Lsd.
Smmsmna, H.L. (2006). Sossmng sho soss mnvossmgasmng sho consons
valmdmsy of langnago sossmng soss as M.Od. lovol.An Nnpnblmshod
Shosms of M.Od.,
S.N., Kashmandn.
Shapa, S.B. (2005). Prodmcsmvo valmdmsy of grado XM annnal Onglmsh
soss.An
Nnpnblmshod Shosms of M.Od., S.N., Kashmandn.
Znnkor, V.G. (1982). Nsmng assossmons rosnlss mn caroor connsollmng.
NSA:
Brooks/Colo Pnblmshmng Company Monsoroy Calmfornma.
Doparsmons of Onglmsh Langnago
Odncasmon Doparsmons of Mashomasmcs
Odncasmon
Doparsmons of Cnrrmcnlnm and Ovalnasmon
Doparsmons of Nopalm Langnago Odncasmon
Doparsmons of Hoalsh and Physmcal Odncasmon
Doparsmons of Odncasmonal Plannmng and
Managomons
Doparsmons of Oconommcs Odncasmon
48