Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Archneur 23 3 001
Archneur 23 3 001
Original Articles
IN RECENT years levodopa has proved levodopa treatment of these 45 patients will be
to be the most effective agent presently avail- published separately. Here we want to describe
able for the treatment of parkinsonism.1-6u the 16 patients who developed psychic phenom-
Among the side effects of levodopa therapy, ena during the levodopa trial.
psychiatric disturbances have been noted.3-6 Levodopa was administered orally in tablets
of 250 and/or 500 mg. After an initial test done
Levodopa is not only the precursor of of 250 mg, patients received 1,000 mg of levodo-
dopamine hydrochloride but also of norepi- pa daily in four divided doses for three days.
nephrine.7 Although the action of these two The dosage was then increased by no more
catecholamines upon the central nervous than 250 mg every third day until the patient
system is incompletely understood, evidence showed beneficial results, or until he developed
has been accumulated in the last two de- side effects, or a total daily dose of 8 gm was
cades upon their action in behavior.8,9 In this reached.
context we would like to report 16 cases of Prior to treatment, every patient had at least
psychiatric disturbances which occurred two complete physical and neurological exami-
among 45 patients treated with levodopa. nations, and the following laboratory values
were obtained: white blood cell count, hemato-
crit, hemoglobin, urinalysis, blood glucose,
Method blood urea nitrogen, serum glutamic oxaloacetic
transaminase, Coombs' test, protein-bound io-
Levodopa was administered to 45 patients dine, and electrocardiogram. A complete physi-
(31 men and 14 women) with Parkinson's syn- cal and neurological examination and labora-
drome. Forty-one patients had primary par- tory studies were repeated once a week for the
kinsonism or Parkinson's disease, three had first month, then every 15 days in the second
postencephalitic parkinsonism, and one had month, and subsequently once a month. No
arteriosclerotic parkinsonism. Of the patients patient was lost to the follow-up even if the
willing to enter the program, only those with drug was withdrawn. We have personally exam-
decompensated cardiovascular disease, renal ined and followed up every patient reported.
disease, psychosis, and moderate to severe de- The degree of disability of each patient is
mentia were rejected. The detailed results of classified according to the Columbia University
disability scale in five stages.10 Stage 1 indi-
Accepted for publication April 21, 1970. cates unilateral involvement only. Stage 2 indi-
From the Department of Neurology, University of cates bilateral or midline involvement without
Wisconsin Medical Center, and Veterans Adminis- impairment of balance. Stage 3 signifies moder-
tration Hospital, Madison, Wis.
Reprint requests to Department of Neurology, ate involvement with impairment of postural
University of Wisconsin Medical School, Madison, and righting reflexes; however, the patient is
Wis 53706 (Dr. Celesia). still able to lead an independent life. Stage 4
indicates fully developed severely disabling dis- On the contrary, patient 2 carried out whis-
ease, but the patient is still able to walk and pering conversations with an imaginary
stand. Stage 5 indicates confinement to bed or friend sitting at his side without any evi-
wheelchair unless aided. dence of concern. The psychosis cleared in
patient three 48 to 72 hours after withdraw-
Results al of the drug. Patient 2 was controlled by
diminution of medication. Patient 6 was
The psychiatric manifestations which oc- controlled by the addition of pyridoxine,
curred in these 16 patients represent dis- 12.5 mg daily. In this case the levodopa dose
turbing side effects of levodopa and were was left unchanged at 2,500 mg. This pa-
brought to our attention either by the dis- tient has been followed up for six months on
tressed patients themselves or by members this regimen, and she has not experienced
of the family. They all represented intolera- any further difficulty.
ble symptoms which required medical atten- It should be pointed out that five of these
tion. six patients in group A had a mild chronic
The data for each patient are found in organic brain syndrome manifested by for-
Table 1. The psychic disturbances vary con- getfulness, impairment of cognitive func-
siderably in intensity and type. However, tions, and concrete thinking before the onset
they can be grouped into four major catego- of treatment. None of them had experienced
ries as shown in Table 1 and 2. delusional thoughts or hallucinations before
Psychotic Disorders.-Eight of the 45 pa- the administration of levodopa with the ex-
tients or 17.7% developed a frank psychosis ception of No. 4 who had occasional epi-
with delusions, hallucinations, distortion of sodes of nocturnal hallucinations in the last
reality, and various degrees of behavioral six months preceding this therapeutic trial.
disorder. During the psychotic episode, six Only No. 2 had normal mental functioning
patients had an associated confusional state at the beginning of therapy. However, she
with impairment of orientation, judgment, had experienced an episode of toxic delirium
and memory (group A of Table 1). The two years earlier while being treated with a
remaining two subjects had an acute psy- high dose of trihexyphenidyl hydrochloride
chosis with visual and auditory hallucina- (Artane).
tions occurring in an otherwise clear senso- Levodopa was the only drug received by
rium (group B of Table 1). Patient 1, 4, and four patients; two others, No. 5 and 6, were
5 of group A each had several episodes of kept on trihexyphenidyl hydrochloride, 10
aggressive assaultive behavior during which mg and 6 mg daily, respectively, while re-
they appeared grossly confused and halluci- ceiving levodopa.
natory. They were abusive, vociferous, and The two patients of group B who de-
attacked nurses, aides, and family members. veloped acute psychosis with clear con-
They all required physical restraint and se- sciousness suffered from postencephalitic
dation. Withdrawal of dopa was followed in parkinsonism. Patient 8 developed a psy-
48 to 72 hours by disappearance of the chotic disturbance five months after the on-
pvschosis in two of them (patient 1 and 4). set of treatment while receiving 1,875 mg of
The third subject, 5, returned to his normal levodopa daily. This dose had been reached
prepsychotic state after the levodopa was after a higher dose produced severe bucco-
decreased from 2,750 to 2,500 mg and pyri- lingual dyskinesia. She had been on this dose
doxine (12.5 mg daily) was added to the for one month when she began experiencing
regimen. At this reduced dose he was able to nocturnal hallucinations. Four to five days
maintain his motor improvement (from later the hallucinations occurred also in the
stage 3 to stage 2) without any further daytime. They were stereotyped. She be-
psychotic experience. The remaining three lieved that three threatening men were
patients of group A, No. 2, 3, and 6, had trying to attack her by breaking through the
frequent episodes of florid visual and audito- windows. She also had severe constant buc-
ry hallucinations mostly of a persecutory colingual dyskinesia and dystonic move-
nature. Patient 2 and 3 appeared anxious, ments of neck and legs. The possibility of
restless, and frightened by their experience. anticholinergic toxicity was considered in
2 Primary F 56 10 3 2 B - 1 4,000 + -
3 Primary F 58 7 4 3 - - 2 2,500 + -
4 Primary M 68 15 5 5 - - 5 4,000 + -
5 Primary M 69 17 3 2 L + 5 2,750 + -
6 Arterio- M 72 10 5 4 - + 2 3,500 + -
sclerotic
7 Postenceph- F 66 37 5 4 B + 3 2,750 - +
alitic
8 Postenceph- F 61 35 4 3 - + 5 1,875 - +
alitic
9 Primary F 74 14 4 3 B + 2 5,000 - -
11 Primary F 71 4 3 3 - + 3 2,500 - -
12 Postenceph- M 66 49 4 3 - + 2 3,250 - -
alitic
13 Primary M 25 12 3 0 - - 2 5,000 - -
14 Primary M 67 8 3 2 - - 1 4,500 - -
15 Primary F 62 11 3 3 B - 4 7,000 -
16 Primary M 72 9 4 3 - - 1 4,000 -
* B indicates bilateral; L, left; +, present; -, not present; W, withdrawal; P, pyridoxine; D, diminution; AD, anti-
depressant; A, abnormal; N. normal.
of Levodopa Therapy*
Past
History of
Dyskinesia Control of Duration Pretreat- Psychiatric
Worsen- Psychic of ment Disorders
ing Basal Bucco- Disturbances Treatment Mental Other Than
Euphoria Anxiety Depression Status lingual General Achieved by (mo) Status Dementia
- - - + + - W 8 A -
54- - - - - - W 1 N Reactive
depression
- - - + + - P 8 A -
_ _ - + - - W 5 A -
- - - - + + D+P 6 A -
- - - - + - D 2 A -
- - - - + + D 4 N Neurosis
7- - - - + + D+P 6 N -
- + - + + - D 3 N Neurosis
+ + + - + - AD 8 N Reactive
depression
- + - - + + W 3 N -
+ + - - + + D 6 N -
+ - - - - + D 6 N -
+ - - - + + D+P 10 N -
- - + - + - AD 9 N Reactive
depression
- - - + + - D 3 A -
t (3) refers to duration of treatment in months before onset of euphoria, while 4 refers to duration of treatment
before onset of depression.
but its benefits far outweigh its shortcom- may have contributed to the psychiatric dis-
ings. We have chosen to focus our attention turbances.
on the mental disturbances encountered dur- Patients with Parkinson's disease and as-
ing levodopa therapy because together with sociated chronic organic brain syndrome
the dyskinesia they have represented the and patients with postencephalitic parkin-
major limiting factor in this therapy. Psy- sonism appeared prone to develop acute
chiatric disturbances including restlessness, psychosis. Seven of the 45 patients in our
hypersexuality, depression, euphoria, confu- study had a mild dementia, and only one of
sion, and toxic delirium have been reported these seven escaped mental complications
by several authors2-6""',12 (Table 4). during levodopa therapy: five became psy-
In our series psychiatric phenomena oc- chotic, and one had a worsening of his de-
curred in 35.5% of the patients. Psychic side mentia. Each of the three subjects with post-
effects have been reversible in all our cases encephalitic parkinsonism experienced psy-
as well as in all those reported in the litera- chiatric symptoms, and two of them became
ture. The disappearance of the symptoms psychotic. The postencephalitic patients also
was achieved in 12 subjects by readjustment showed a lower tolerance to the drug, de-
of the dose or the use of an antidepressant; veloping side effects at a lower dose than
only in four of our cases was withdrawal of patients with Parkinson's disease (Table 1).
dopa necessary. In nine cases levodopa was This is in agreement with the experience of
the only medication being administered at Calne et al4 who reported psychiatric dis-
the time of the appearance of psychiatric turbances in 55.5% of their patients receiv-
disturbances. Seven patients were simultane- ing levodopa for the management of post-
ously receiving an anticholinergic drug. With encephalitic parkinsonism. These results
regard to these latter cases, the possibility should not be interpreted as advocating the
that anticholinergic agents either contributed exclusion of patients with mild dementia or
to or produced the psychiatric phenomena postencephalitic parkinsonism from levodo-
must be considered. However, these reactions pa therapy. However, such patients should
did not occur until levodopa was added to be treated cautiously. These adverse reac-
the therapeutic regimen. These patients had tions are dose related and therefore can be
received the same amount and type of anti- prevented by careful monitoring of the pa-
cholinergic drugs for six months to seven tients, preferably on an inpatient basis. The
years (mean 31 months) before the onset of occurrence of minor changes in the mental
mental disturbances. Furthermore, in subject status or dyskinetic movements indicates the
8, the psychotic reaction did not disappear necessity for decreasing or even stopping the
when procyclidine alone was discontinued. levodopa.
It was only after the reduction of levodopa An interesting feature of our findings is
that her mental status returned to normal. the association of involuntary dyskinetic
Later, on a lower dose of levodopa, procycli- movements and psychic disturbances. The
dine was reintroduced with no difficulty. In agitated confused patient with vivid visual
every patient the diminution or withdrawal and auditory hallucinations and buccolin-
of levodopa was sufficient to restore normal gual or generalized dyskinesia presents a
mental functioning. Subjects 10 and 14 de- unique clinical picture characteristic of levo-
veloped behavioral changes while receiving dopa toxicity. As far as we are aware, no
levodopa alone; their difficulty was controlled other drug has ever been reported to pro-
by adjustment of levodopa. At a later date duce this psychosis-dyskinesia complex. The
both were started on a trihexyphenidyl regi- levodopa psychosis-dyskinesia complex pre-
men without reappearance of psychiatric sents some fascinating similarities to other
phenomena. clinical entities such as Huntington's chorea,
These data are against the role of anti- Wilson's disease, chronic manganese poison-
cholinergic drugs as the sole cause of behav- ing, and tardive dyskinesia secondary to
ioral changes; they strongly suggest that phenothiazines.13 It also suggests the possi-
levodopa is responsible for these reactions. bility of a role for basal ganglia and cate-
However, in some cases we cannot exclude cholamines in behavior.
the possibility that anticholinergic agents Catecholamines and other brain mono-
amines have been implicated in the etiology among basal ganglia, biogenic amines, motor
of psychotic disorders.7-9 Psychotic symptoms and mental functions, these data do not
have also been induced in rats and mice by suggest a theory invoking a single biochemi-
the intravenous administration of dopa.14,15 cal defect. They suggest, rather, a more
Levodopa administration in animals pro- complex situation and the existence of a
duces an increase in the content of brain delicate balance among different biogenic
norepinephrine.16-18 Reis et al'8 found that amines. Disruption of this equilibrium may
levodopa induces excitement and sham rage lead to a pathological condition which varies
in cats pretreated with monoamine oxidase with the direction of the interference. Bert-
inhibitors. Furthermore, they demonstrated ler and Rosengren2' have shown in hog
that this reponse is due to norepinephrine. brain extracts a competitive inhibition be-
The antipsychotic effects of reserpine and tween dopa and 5-hydroxytryptophan. They
phenothiazine have also been related to also observed that in rabbits injections of
their antagonism of norepinephrine.8,9 How- levodopa lowered the brain 5-hydroxytrypta-
ever, other biogenic amines are also affected mine level to 50% to 60% of normal. The
by these drugs.15 possibility that an excess of levodopa or
Dopamine itself may also be directly in- dopamine may displace other amines from
volved in the generation of abnormal behav- their normal storage sites or interfere with
ior. Ernst'9 has produced bizarre behavior their metabolism has been proposed by Yahr
and a syndrome of gnaw-compulsion in rats et al.3 The undesirable reactions to levodopa
by direct implantation of dopamine into the may then be interpreted as a combination of
dorsal part of the caudate nucleus or into increased dopamine and dysfunction of the
the globus pallidus. It is ineffective when metabolism of norepinephrine, serotonin,
placed in the ventral part of the caudate, and other amines.
subthalamic structures, or substantia nigra. The occurrence of depression in patients
The importance of the caudate nucleus in undergoing levodopa therapy",22 is only ap-
behavior and mental function is also sug- parently contradictory to the concept of
gested by the results of direct stimulation. norepinephrine deficiency in depression. Levo-
Van Buren2O stimulated the head of the dopa increases the tissue content of dopa-
caudate nucleus in man and produced amne- mine and to a lesser extent of norepineph-
sia for the period of stimulation, disturbance rine,16-'8 but it may not raise depressed
of speech, euphoria with smiling, laughter or norepinephrine levels up to normal. The
brightening of mood, and a loss of respon- efficacy of imipramine can be explained by
siveness to visual or auditory cues during a selective increase of norepinephrine to
stimulation. This response was not obtained restore the monoamine balance.23 An interest-
when other basal ganglia or surrounding ing finding has been the pyridoxine antago-
structures were stimulated. nism of levodopa reported initially by Duvoi-
While indicating a close interaction sin et a124 and later confirmed by Cotzias.25