Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Forum

CON SORDINO:
The Art of the
Mute
By Kenneth Sarch, Violin Forum Editor

The string mute is a device placed upon the bridge to soften


and alter the tone color for quiet passages. Nobody has defined
the mute in more artistic terms than Leopold Mozart in his
eighteenth century violin treatise: the mute is “to be put on
the bridge of the violin in order to express better something
quieter and sadder” (Mozart [1756] 1963). According to David
Boyden (1965, 205), the earliest mention of the mute is by the Some examples of the mute for strings.
French theorist Mersenne, who describes the violin mute in
1636. However, we do not find the mute called for in surviving artistic standing only when prescribed by the composer.”
scores until the end of the seventeenth century—for example, Flesch continues to issue a warning about practicing with a
in Lully’s opera Armide (1686) and Purcell’s Fairy Queen mute on (practice mute): “The customary muted practicing
(1692). There is no known use of the mute in the advanced should be repudiated, since the artificial tone production
music of the Italians and Germans before the eighteenth deceives the ear, gives it a false impression, and makes the
century, when it begins to appear in solo pieces (Vivaldi) tone appear more beautiful than it really is.” Except for
having been used prior in ensemble and opera music of the the article you are now reading, you will not find much
seventeenth century (339). information, advice, or recommendation for the artistic use
As early as Leopold Mozart’s time, string players could of mutes!
choose mutes made of various materials. Mozart ([1756]
1963, 322) mentions wood, lead, tin, steel, or brass. Mute Materials
Contemporary string players tend to choose mutes for The material from which the mute is made is of vital
reasons of convenience and expediency (and sometimes importance. The ability to partially dampen the vibrations
price) over artistic reasons—not choosing a mute for its tone produced on a string instrument by clamping the bridge to
quality and dynamic level. Because a mute can change the diminish the tone, while still allowing the rich quality of tone
volume, timbre, and quality of an instrument’s tone, an artist from a fine instrument, depends partly on the material and
performer needs to know how each type and design of mute partly on the design. For example, metal being denser and
will affect the sound of the instrument in different settings— heavier dampens sound more than most woods. Given that
that is, in a large hall with piano or orchestra, or a smaller tone quality and projection is important, then using a mute
venue and in the recording studio. made of the right material is essential. Mutes are made of:
The most notable example of the search for the “right” mute
comes from the great Jascha Heifetz. When Heifetz tried •• Wood: Rosewood, ebony, and boxwood, for example.
available mutes for muted passages in solo works, for example Consider also that ebony is a denser, harder wood than
the Tchaikovsky concerto slow movement, he was frustrated rosewood, so ebony of the same design will dampen the
that available mutes dampened too much for concert halls with tone more.
orchestra and changed his violin tone. He found a craftsman- •• Metal: Tin, steel, brass, aluminum, lead, copper, and
inventor, Henryk Kaston, in Brooklyn, New York, who alloys. Consider, for example, that aluminum is lighter
worked with him to develop a solo mute consisting of a metal than steel and so will allow the bridge to vibrate more
clip overlaid with rubber designed with a single prong that fully than steel. This is why we find an aluminum mute
produced a muted but full and rich tone—what we know today (and not a steel mute) with two or three prongs offered as
as the Heifetz or Solo mute. (More on the Heifetz mute later.) a Solo mute—a mute with a fuller tone that projects more.
Few violin treatises mention the mute; I don’t find any •• Rubber: A number of popular mutes on the market
mention in Galamian or Menuhin, for example. However, today are manufactured from rubber or a chemically
good old detailed and thorough Carl Flesch ([1924] 1939, produced synthetic rubber. Rubber is both firm and
103) has several comments in The Art of Violin Playing: “The flexible and can be formed easily into useful designs.
sordino . . . may be made of wood, bone or metal. Wood, Rubber is also less costly than other materials.
as experience teaches, sounds the best.” “In general, the •• Plastic: Low-cost plastics can also be easily molded into
dampening effect must be accounted one of the cheapest of desired designs and can be lighter in weight than wood
the violinist’s art, and hence it is used by violinists of high or metals.

American String Teacher


Vol. 67, No. 4, November 2017, pp. 24­–29
DOI: 10.1177/0003131317735028
24 | American String Teacher | November 2017 Copyright © 2017, American String Teachers Association
•• Leather: Several mutes have been offered made of in the music to take the mute out of a pocket or other
leather. The leather must be held in shape by a metal clip convenient place and get it fastened on the bridge in time,
or form, and the tone quality is warmer than mutes made or there is not enough time to remove the mute from the
of harder material. bridge and put it away. For these reasons, string players will
•• Bone: We used to find mutes made from ivory. Today, purchase one of several mutes on the market which fasten
this practice is outlawed; therefore, an ivory mute today onto the back of the bridge ready for immediate use. It
is a collector’s item. cannot then be misplaced, lost, or difficult to retrieve when
needed during rehearsal or performance. The quality of tone
that results or the dynamic level of these attachable mutes is
Mute Factors sometimes not considered. Only the ease of use, along with
•• Material the price, often determines their use and popularity.
•• Design—Number of contact points or It is pertinent to note that the design and material of a mute
prongs directly affects the tone and dynamic level of the tone of the
•• Weight or density instrument. Today mutes are manufactured of many more
•• Ease of use and varied materials than in Leopold Mozart’s time, so that
•• Location on bridge many more types and tonal possibilities exist for today’s string
•• Price player. It is important for the string player (as well as the
composer and the conductor) to know that each type of mute
results in a strikingly different tone quality and volume.
The Four Functions of Mutes It is well worth the time and effort to go to the string shop,
or to acquire a collection of various mute types as I have,
1. Solo Mute: For large concert halls and solos with
and try each one on your instrument so that the “right”
orchestra and concert grand pianos. The solo mute muted tone can be achieved for different musical needs and
provides a muted effect, but with a full sound—without requirements and for various concert halls and performance
damping the overtones so that the tone quality of the setups. For example, I wonder how a muted string section
instrument is not changed. would sound if all the players used the same type of
2. Orchestra Mute: Provides damping of volume (less mute! I also feel it would be valuable for the composer
volume than the solo mute) with quality of tone and who is sensitive to a spectrum of tonal qualities related to
clarity. Permanent storage on the instrument for ease his composition to select a mute of a certain design and
of quickly placing mute on and taking it off is often a material, and to recommend this mute for performance in
desired feature. the score to be sure that the special tonal quality which he
3. Sonata, Chamber Music, and Contemporary Music had in mind is achieved. Why should the string player insist
Mute: A mute that provides the desired tone color and on playing on an instrument with fabulous tonal qualities,
volume according to the musical requirements of the and then stick a mute on the bridge that squashes that
composition. Unless there is not enough time to place special tonal quality?
or remove the mute, this mute does not need to be
attached to the instrument. The tone quality of the mute List of Mutes
selected—nasal, mellow, less volume, more volume,
shrill, warm, metallic, clear, foggy—can be different as String mutes are designed to attach to the bridge either by
needed for the particular music. prongs that clip on, or by sliding until contact is made. Nearly
all the mutes on my list are violin mutes, but nearly all (unless
4. Practice Mute: The main purpose of this type of mute otherwise noted) are also available for viola, cello, or bass.
is to dampen the volume to a very, very soft level so Classical string instruments have four strings. This means a
as not to disturb anyone nearby: hotel room, someone mute that is placed between the strings can have one to five
sleeping, apartments, close to a rehearsal going on, and prongs, if not the sliding type. Basically, the more prongs that
so on. clip onto the bridge, the less volume we have. This is why solo
mutes are designed with one or two prongs and why practice
Too often today, I see string players choose mutes for mutes are designed with four or five prongs.
reasons of convenience and price and not for tonal quality or As we search for the right mute, I will list the mutes I have
dynamic level. Following I will list and describe many of the collected—some no longer available—by the number of
available mutes, along with some no longer on the market. I prongs or by a sliding design. I do not intend to recommend
hope to encourage my string colleagues to choose mutes for or to present a rating of any mute. The order of listing
tonal qualities and dynamic level. has no significance; the choice of which mute or mutes
My experience is that most string players today own a player uses must be an individual choice based on the
one or two mutes, chosen usually to avoid two common factors I have listed and the priorities of the player, whether
frustrations: (1) as a mute is a small object, it is frequently artistic or practical. Each individual player must try
lost or misplaced, and (2) there is often not enough time mutes on the instrument and judge the convenience, tone

WWW.ASTASTRINGS.ORG | 25
Forum

Nearly all the mutes on my list are violin mutes, but “


nearly all (unless otherwise noted) are also available
for viola, cello, or bass.


quality, damping effect, and aesthetics based on musical
requirements and artistic taste.

One-Prong Mutes
Heifetz solo mute (Figure 1A).  A one-prong rubber
supported by a metal clip. Inserted onto the bridge between A
and D strings. Creates a slightly muted but full tone without Figure 1. One-prong mutes.
altering tone quality. This mute has much flexibility: pushed
halfway down onto bridge results in only a slight damping; to the tailpiece. The mute is fastened to the middle strings
pushed all the way down creates a fuller muted effect. If through the holes and when slid back off the bridge is secured in
inserted on the right side between the E and A strings, it mutes place with the magnet. Function: solo mute; orchestra mute; or
the upper register more, and if inserted on the left side sonata, chamber music, and contemporary music mute. Price: $5
between the D and G strings, it mutes the lower register more. to $10.
It can be stored behind the bridge by inserting the mute onto
one of the strings. The original Heifetz mute is no longer Sliding Mutes
made; a redesigned (better clip) mute was reintroduced in Alpine Menuhin solo mute (Figure 2A).  Molded plastic with
1989. Original Heifetz mutes are collector items worth around brass insert described as a “shield type,” the mute attaches in
$50, and the actual mute that Heifetz used on his Strad back of the bridge between the middle two strings. The mute
(certified by the Heifetz Estate) is selling for $25,000! slides up to the bridge so that the shield with the brass insert
Function: solo mute. Price: $10 to $15. presses against the back of the bridge to restrict vibrations. It
Tourte one- or two-hole mute (Figures 1B and 1C). A slides back when not in use. The professional model comes in
one-prong or lip, rubber. The one hole attaches to a string or black, with a white alternative which is described as “slightly
two hole attaches to two strings (usually second and third) in brighter sound than the black.” The manufacturer describes
back of the bridge through a slit so that the string passes the mute as producing a “warm tone without changing the
through the hole. The player lifts the mute (the knob on top of instrument colour.” The mute weighs a mere 0.3 ounces.
the one-hole mute is used to lift the mute), and slides it up to There is also an artist model described as the “budget choice.”
the bridge so that the mute lip overlaps the edge of the bridge I found that the Alpine mute reduces volume somewhat,
and then is pushed down to secure it. When not in use, the allowing a bright, vibrant tone to come through. The mute
mute is designed to be pushed down on the string into a does not mellow or sweeten the tone! Function: solo mute. The
narrow slit to prevent rattling. However, if the mute comes professional price: $25+; the artist price: $15–$25.
loose, it will rattle. The lightweight rubber and one-prong Sihon sliding mute (Figure 2B).  Plastic tube metal reinforced
design gives a full tone which is softer and more dampened on a wire frame. The mute permanently attaches to the middle
than the Heifetz mute. Function: solo mute; orchestra mute; or strings and slides up so that the tube rests on top of the bridge
sonata, chamber music, and contemporary music mute. Price: to dampen the sound. The wire frame does scrape the string,
under $5. eventually affecting the wrapping. Muting creates a bright,
The Bech magnetic mute (Figure 1D).  This mute is basically a open solo tone, somewhat mellow. Function: solo mute;
rubber two-hole Tourte style mute with an added magnet to orchestra mute; or sonata, chamber music, and contemporary
secure the mute and prevent rattling when not engaged for music mute. Price: $5 to $10.
muting. A metal insert is placed in back of the mute which Spector sliding mute (Figure 2C).  Made of synthetic rubber
“sticks” to a magnet attached to a small plastic clip that attaches (neoprene—a hard material that maintains flexibility over a

26 | American String Teacher | November 2017


Figure 3. Two-prong mutes.
Leather two-prong solo mute (Figure 3B).  Two sides of
leather held together by metal pins. Mellow, warm, full tone.
Leather mutes are made in Boston by Paul Wiessmeyer and
Figure 2. Sliding mutes. designed with deep grooves on one side and shallow grooves
on the other. The mute stores vertically between the strings
and can slide up on the grooves to the back of the bridge to
wide temperature range)—designed for the Super-Sensitive
obtain a half muted solo tone, or it can be placed on top of the
Company by Fred Spector, former Chicago Symphony
bridge and pushed down with the prongs touching both sides
violinist. Attaches to the middle strings and slides up to bridge
of the bridge for a fully muted tone. The leather allows more of
so that the protruding lip rests on top of the bridge. Slides back
the overtones to sound for a clear tone that is not distorted yet
when not in use. The design is similar to the Finissima mute;
somewhat muted and warm. Function: solo mute; or sonata,
the tone produced, however, is stronger. The “copper”
chamber music, and contemporary music mute. Price: $25+.
description refers only to its color—also available in black.
Function: solo mute; orchestra mute; or sonata, chamber Three-Prong Mutes
music, and contemporary music mute. Price: $5 to $10.
I experimented with three-prong mutes in my collection
Finissima artist mute (Figure 2D).  A plastic sliding mute on my concert violin to make a comparison. All of the three-
that attaches with grooves to the middle strings, so that the prong mutes are designed in a similar way, so the material is
mute slides up to the bridge and the protruding lip moves on the main difference. I tried wood mutes (ebony and rosewood),
top of the bridge. Slides back when not in use. Invented by metal steel mutes, a leather model, and a light clear plastic
violinist Calvin Sieb, an American who lived, taught, and model. The plastic and the leather mutes had the most volume
and fullest tone, the metal mutes had medium volume, and the
performed in Canada and France. The mute dampens tone
wood mutes, especially the ebony, had the least volume. Each
about halfway while still maintaining the instrument’s tone mute must be tried individually on an instrument to assess its
quality. Tone is a bit softer than the Heifetz or Alpine mutes. quality of tone, volume, ease of use, and aesthetic.
The design is similar to the Spector. The Finissima mute is
endorsed and was used by Isaac Stern. The mute is not Wood three-prong mute (Figure 4A).  Ebony muted the tone,
designed for viola or cello. Function: solo mute; orchestra but the result was a pinched, somewhat nasal sound. The
mute; or sonata, chamber music, and contemporary music rosewood mute, being lighter and less dense, had a richer tone
mute. Price: $10 to $15. quality that was full, yet still somewhat muted.

Polly mute (Figure 2E).  A sliding type of mute made of Metal three-prong mute (Figure 4B).  The metal will
polymer synthetic rubber material which is both tough and determine the resulting muted tone. For example, a steel alloy
flexible. Available in red, black, and clear (white). The design is mute will mute softer with instrument tone somewhat altered,
shield shaped like the Alpine mute, but smaller, different whereas an aluminum mute, being lighter and less dense, will
material, and with no metal insert. The Polly mute attaches by have more volume and less damping of the overtones. On my
grooves to the middle strings and slides up to the bridge so the violin, the steel mute seems to allow the lower tones to come
small protruding lip slips on top; it slides back when not in use. through with deeper resonance.
The Polly mute is modeled after the Fawick black rubber mute Leather three-prong mute (Figure 4C).  Leather designed
popular in the 1960s. The mute dampens and gently mellows with three prongs dampens the tone, but the tone is full and
the tone which remains open and full. Price: $10 to $15.

Two-Prong Mutes
Aluminum two-prong solo mute (Figure 3A). Lightweight
metal mute placed on top of the bridge between the strings.
Tone is round, full, smooth, open with muted quality.
Function: solo mute. Price: not currently offered for sale. Figure 4. Three-prong mutes.

WWW.ASTASTRINGS.ORG | 27
Forum

not as nasal as wood. One might say that leather allows a alloy with an electroplated overlay; it weighs 1.1 ounces and
smoother tone quality. claims to mute 90 percent of the sound. Price: $5 to $10.
Plastic three-prong mute (Figure 4D).  As plastic is strong yet Four-prong practice mutes
lightweight, the plastic mute created a tone closer to the Metal four-prong practice mute (Figure 5C).  A heavy mute
original of the instrument—that is, it did not dampen as much that is placed on the bridge to dampen the sound level to
of the overtones, yet still produced less volume. almost nothing. Some musicians worry that the metal can
scrape the string or mar the instrument if accidently dropped.
Practice Mutes Price: $10 to $15.
The sole purpose of a practice mute is to drastically
dampen the sound of the instrument, so the sound does Otto Musica Artino four-prong practice mute (Figure 5D). A
not disturb anyone in a hotel, sleeping, or who might be heavy metal black practice mute with a protective plastic
disturbed nearby. Therefore, practice mutes are designed coating, which dampens the sound way down but protects the
with four or five prongs, and heavy or hard material to instrument. It weighs two ounces. This mute sits high on the
prevent the bridge from fully vibrating. Heavy metal mutes, bridge so that the view of the strings is blocked. The mute is held
because of the rigid metal and the excess weight, produce together with two screws. I found that this mute has the slots
the maximum damping of the sound. Hard rubber mutes made too narrow to go all the way down—the mute stops about
come close, have somewhat better tone quality, and are less halfway. One customer who found that this mute did not go
likely to damage the bridge or the instrument. It is best not down all the way on the bridge took a screwdriver, loosened the
to make a habit of practicing with such a mute because, as screws, and twisted the screwdriver blade between the prongs to
Flesch has pointed out, it stops the normal tone and shuts widen the space so that the mute would go down all the way. This
it down to almost nothing. This can confuse the player who mute produces slightly less damping than a regular metal practice
needs to hear the true result of the physical motions used to mute; the tone becomes somewhat tinny. Price: $10 to $15.
bring out the sound. Five-prong practice mutes
Two-prong practice mutes Five-prong rubber practice mutes (Figure 5E). Rubber
Metal two-prong practice mute (Figure 5A).  It is listed for practice mutes offer somewhat better tone quality than metal.
cello as different brands: String Centre, Meisel, Uxcell, Yibuy, The rubber material offers some protection, and the extreme
and BQLZR metal cello practice mute. The description reads, damping requirement is met by having longer prongs that are
“Heavy metal for maximum damping of sound.” This mute is set further down on the bridge to restrict vibrations. The same
made from either a heavy zinc alloy or chrome plated machine basic five-prong rubber practice mute is sold under different
brass. Although I have not examined this mute, I include it as names and companies: Ultra, Glaesel, Knilling, Senkary, and
an example of a heavy metal two-prong practice mute. Price: eBoot are examples. There are both “heavy” and “lightweight”
$10 to $25. rubber five-prong mutes, and some are offered in different
colors. Price: under $5 to $10.
Three-prong practice mutes
Chrome metal three-prong practice mute (Figure 5B). The Five-prong metal practice mutes (Figure 5F).  The added fifth
Silencer by WOGOD. Red copper color three-prong metal prong along with the heavy metal weight provides the most
mute with added weight and thickness on top designed muting. This design places two prongs on both sides of every
to function as a practice mute. Even with three prongs, it string on the bridge. Metal needs to be used with care around
dampens the sound way down. Also, another three-prong fine instruments made of wood. Price: no longer available.
metal practice mute is manufactured by LANEYLI called “The
Violin Mute Silencer.” This mute is made from polished zinc Homemade Mutes
The clothespin mute (Figure 6A).  The clamping feature of a
wood or plastic clothespin can be used as a mute in a pinch! Even
a paperclip can be attached to the bridge top if a regular mute is
unavailable. The only other advantage I can see, besides saving
the day in an emergency when no mute is present, is that the
clothespin can also be used to prevent music from blowing off
the stand! Function: emergency use only. Price: market value.
The dollar bill mute (Figure 6B).  Invented by my stand
partner at a rehearsal when she left her mute at home! The
dollar bill is folded into a narrow band and woven in and out
of the strings in back of the bridge. This ingenious mute can be
Figure 5. Practice mutes. slid up to the bridge to function as a mute and then slid back

28 | American String Teacher | November 2017


produced that sounds something like an electric Wurlitzer organ
with the vibrato stop out. Function: novelty. Price: priceless.

Conclusion
Now that most available mutes have been listed and described,
I am urging string players to try out as many mutes as practical
and select the mute or mutes that fulfill both artistic tonal ideals
Figure 6. Homemade mutes. and practical ease-of-use requirements. Certainly, the orchestral
musician as well as soloists and chamber musicians need a mute
when not in use. It produces quite a nice, acceptable muted that attaches to the instrument and can be placed on or at the
tone, and the only investment is $1.00, which is retrieved after bridge and removed in very quick time. But when tone quality,
the performance (although it wrinkles the bill terribly)! more or less volume, and aesthetic value are desired, then a
thorough search and trial resulting in a selection of mutes of
The Encore: Novelty Mutes different materials and designs are called for by the artist who
The Baroque Bling violin mute (Figure 7A).  For those must find the “right” sound by just the “right” mute!
inspired by flashy entertainers, this is a two-hole Tourte rubber I have never known a composer or a conductor who
mute decorated on top with Swarovski crystals—golden or requested that the strings all use a specific type or design
black “diamonds.” My guess is that, as the TV cameras pan of mute made of a specific material to achieve a uniform
around the string section of the orchestra, this mute would artistic sound quality and dynamic. I can only imagine how
draw attention in the same way as a diamond ring! Function: wonderful the aggregate tone of a string section or string
ensemble would sound if each player used the same mute to
flashy decoration. Price: $25+.
obtain the same quality and volume of sound! Yet each string
Animal mute (Figure 7B).  Now something for the kiddies— player will choose the mute or mutes that satisfy his or her
the Mouse-Tro plastic orchestral violin/viola mute! This is a own artistic nature. If Flesch swore by wood mutes, Heifetz
novelty item described as “an orchestral violin/viola mute the one-prong metal/rubber solo mute, Menuhin the plastic
captured as a mouse dressed in a tuxedo! Hand painted!” Cute with metal insert shield mute, and Stern found his karma in a
specially designed plastic sliding mute—then your mute that
and silly, but fun for the very young. Unfortunately, this mute
expresses your soul is out there waiting for you to discover it!
is no longer made. Artino makes a three-prong black rubber
practice mute with a rabbit or a whale on top. Price: $5 to $10.
Acknowledgment
Metal mute with tuner (Figure 7C).  This is a metal three- The author thanks Jeffrey Judd of JR Judd Violins in
prong mute. Mounted on top is an A-440 metal tuning pitch Williamsport, Pennsylvania, for reviewing this article and
pipe. This was a three-for-one deal: the player can blow into the making some valuable suggestions.
pitch pipe to secure a tuning A, slide a graduated slit between
the prong upon a string to measure its diameter (thicker- References
thinner), and then have a metal mute handy for musical Boyden, David. 1965. The History of Violin Playing from Its Origins to
purposes. If only the inventor had found a way to attach a small 1761. London: Oxford University Press.
cake of rosin, then all of the string player’s prep needs would Flesch, Carl. (1924) 1939. The Art of Violin Playing: Book One.
have been covered! Function: tuning and calibrating string New York, NY: Carl Fischer.
diameter; orchestra mute; or sonata, chamber music, and Mozart, Leopold. (1756) 1963. A Treatise on the Fundamental
Principles of Violin Playing. Translated by Edith Knocker. London:
contemporary music mute. Price: no longer for sale.
Oxford University Press.
The vibrato mute (Figure 7D).  This mute turned up in an old
violin case. It may be a singular invention by a clever craftsman, Kenneth Sarch enjoys a legacy of international
or it may have once been for sale. The vibrato mute consists of a accomplishments as violinist, conductor,
one-prong metal base that fits on top of the bridge, a thin metal composer, and teacher. He is currently violin
professor at Lycoming College in Pennsylvania.
band protruding upward, on top of which is soldered a metal He previously taught at Mansfield University, New
ball bearing. When the mute is in place and the violin is played, England Conservatory, Shenandoah University
the metal ball shakes and a muted, vibrating, pulsating tone is Conservatory, and eight years as assistant to
Roman Totenberg on the faculty of Boston University. He is a graduate
of The Juilliard School where he studied with Ivan Galamian, Sally
Thomas, and Dorothy DeLay, earning the artist diploma from New
England Conservatory and his doctorate from Boston University. He has
extensive recital appearances throughout the United States, Europe,
Canada, Central and South America, and the Middle East.
Figure 7. Novelty mutes.

WWW.ASTASTRINGS.ORG | 29

You might also like