Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hot Wheel Case Analysis - Vikas
Hot Wheel Case Analysis - Vikas
key business problem by introducing a "mixed-play" Hot Wheels experience. This problem was the declining sales of
traditional physical toys, As mentioned in Exhibit 2 which shows the sales have declined from $6484892 to $4514810
between 2013 to 2018, which were losing ground to digital and electronic toys. Mattel wanted to find a way to make
physical toys more appealing to children who were increasingly drawn to digital play experiences, As mentioned in
Exhibit 1,appeal for digital toys increased from 76% to 87% between the age group of 2 and 10 years old children
versus the physical toys that decreased from 80% to 39% between the same age group, and that’s what coddled him to
ponder around creating a new Hot Wheels product that would appeal to modern children's play preferences and offer a
mixed-play experience that combined physical and digital play. To address this challenge, Chris Down and his team
designed a new Hot Wheels product that combined physical and digital play. The product included a physical track and
vehicles that could be customized and enhanced using digital components, such as a digital portal and augmented reality
(AR) technology. The idea was to provide a more immersive and engaging play experience that would capture the
By introducing a mixed-play experience, Mattel should be able to tap into the growing trend of combining physical and
digital play, which would help revitalize the Hot Wheels brand and attract a new generation of customers. Albeit, the
mixed-play features and customizable design are innovative and appear to be aligned with modern children's play
preferences. If the product is successful in resonating with its target audience, it could help Mattel revitalize the Hot
Wheels brand and reverse declining sales. The success of the "mixed-play" concept will ultimately depend on factors
such as the quality of the digital experience, the appeal of the physical toys, and the effectiveness of the marketing
campaign.
Answer 2: Introducing a mixed-play experience to the Hot Wheels brand did carry some risk of damaging the brand's
reputation and alienating existing and older fans and collectors of the traditional physical play experience. However,
Mattel likely felt that it had little choice but to adapt to changes in the way children play today, as digital play
experiences have become increasingly popular and are now a significant competitor to physical toys. Hence, it is also
possible that the new mixed-play experience could attract a new generation of children and families to the brand,
ultimately expanding its reach and revenue potential. So, we can say that by introducing a mixed-play experience,
Mattel could position Hot Wheels as a modern brand that meets the needs of today's children while still retaining the
nostalgia and appeal that older fans and collectors associate with the brand. To mitigate the risk of damaging the brand,
Mattel likely conducted extensive market research including surveys, focus groups, and interviews with parents and
collectors and testing to understand how the new mixed-play experience would be perceived by different groups of
consumers, including existing fans of the traditional Hot Wheels toys, As mentioned in Exhibit 8, 74% respondents said
they loved the product,24% said it’s Okay and the remaining 2% didn’t like it. This research helped the company to
identify key trends and preferences among these groups and to develop a product that met their needs and expectations.
Additionally, Mattel likely focused on emphasizing the benefits of mixed play rather than trying to completely replace
the traditional physical play experience with a digital one. By positioning the new product as a complementary play
experience that enhances creativity and imagination, Mattel may have been able to maintain the loyalty of existing fans
while also attracting new customers who are interested in mixed play. It's also possible that Mattel leveraged the
nostalgia factor associated with the Hot Wheels brand to generate excitement and interest in the new mixed-play
experience among adults who make toy-buying decisions. By tapping into the emotional connection that many adults
have with the brand, Mattel may have been able to position the new product as an evolution of the Hot Wheels
experience that still stays true to its roots. Overall, while there may have been some risk involved in introducing a
mixed-play experience to Hot Wheels, it seems that Mattel approached the introduction of mixed-play to Hot Wheels
thoughtfully and strategically, with a focus on balancing the needs and preferences of different customer groups and
maintaining the integrity of the Hot Wheels brand. Whether the new product will ultimately be successful will depend
on a variety of factors, including the quality of the digital experience, the appeal of the physical toys, and the
Answer 3: Mattel likely hired IDEO to conduct research on the new mixed-play Hot Wheels experience because of
their expertise in human-centered design and innovation. IDEO has a reputation for being able to deeply understand
and empathize with consumers, and for developing creative and effective solutions that meet their needs and desires.
IDEO’s long history of working on projects with designing products and experiences that resonate with people, and
their expertise in this area would be invaluable in helping Mattel to create a successful mixed-play experience for Hot
Wheels
IDEO's design thinking approach and research are also unique and are grounded in empathy for users, meaning that the
firm would have likely spent a significant amount of time observing and interviewing children, parents, and other
potential users of the mixed-play experience. This research would have helped Mattel to gain a deeper understanding
of the needs, desires, and preferences of its target audience, and to design a product that met those needs in a meaningful
way. Additionally, IDEO has experience in designing both physical and digital products and experiences, which would
have been valuable in creating a seamless integration between the physical and digital components of the mixed-play
experience. IDEO's expertise in combining qualitative and quantitative data with observation and analysis to gain a
holistic understanding of the customer experience and designing for both the physical and digital realms may have
given them a unique perspective that industry experts or Mattel's own team may not have had,or we can say that while
Mattel may have had its own internal experts and industry consultants, IDEO likely brought a fresh perspective and
expertise in human-centered design and innovation that complemented Mattel's existing capabilities. In addition,
IDEO's reputation and track record in design and innovation may have helped to lend credibility and legitimacy to the
new mixed-play Hot Wheels experience, particularly among parents and other stakeholders who may have been
Answer 4: Before jumping into one aspect of product design that creates an ‘aha’ moment, let’s first discuss how every
The Cars, being the physical component of the mixed-play experience, are a critical element of the platform's appeal.
By leveraging the nostalgia and brand recognition associated with Hot Wheels, the physical cars provide a tangible
connection to the brand that could attract collectors and older fans while also appealing to younger children who enjoy
playing with physical toys. The Race Portal is another key component that adds value to the platform. By allowing
players to scan their physical cars and unlock digital versions of them in the app, the Race Portal provides seamless
integration between physical and digital play that could increase engagement and encourage players to collect more
physical cars. The Smart Track, which is designed to work with physical cars and provide a range of different track
configurations, adds an element of customization and creativity to the platform. This could appeal to both younger
children who enjoy building and customizing their own tracks, as well as older fans and collectors who enjoy creating
intricate and challenging tracks. Finally, the App provides a digital component to the mixed-play experience that is
critical to attracting younger children and their parents who may be more familiar with digital play. By offering a range
of virtual tracks and other features that complement the physical play experience, the app extends the appeal of the
platform beyond just physical play and could potentially attract a new generation of Hot Wheels fans.
One aspect of the product design that stands out as potentially extending its appeal is the integration of physical and
digital play through the Smart Track and the App. This design decision not only enhances the play experience for kids
by providing interactive features and opportunities for customization, but it also expands the product's appeal to tech-
savvy parents who may be looking for toys that incorporate digital technology. Moreover, the use of augmented reality
(AR) technology in the App component enables users to interact with digital content in a more immersive and engaging
way, which can enhance the play experience and appeal to a broader range of users, including those who are more
digitally savvy. By integrating AR technology into the App component, Mattel may have been able to attract users who
are interested in mixed-play experiences that combine physical and digital elements. Additionally, the decision to make
the Cars compatible with both the Smart Track and traditional Hot Wheels tracks extends the product's appeal to a
larger target market. This means that kids who already have a collection of Hot Wheels tracks can still use the new Cars
with their existing tracks, while also experiencing the mixed-play features of the Smart Track and App. Overall, each
component of the new platform is critical to its success and potential to extend its appeal to a broader target market, the
combination of physical and digital play, and the compatibility with existing Hot Wheels tracks make the new Hot
Wheels platform a more versatile and innovative product than traditional Hot Wheels. This design decision has the
potential to extend the product's appeal to a larger target market and ensure a longer life for the product.
Answer 5: The statement from EVP & CTO, Sven Gerjets, about Mattel's culture of "move on" highlights a potential
challenge that many companies face when it comes to innovation and creativity: the tendency to abandon ideas that
don't immediately show success. This apprises that the company may have a low tolerance for failure and may be less
willing to take risks or experiment with new ideas. While it's important for companies to be efficient and strategic with
their resources, this approach can have a negative impact on innovation and creativity. Innovation often requires a
process of trial and error, where ideas are tested, refined, and improved over time, and taking risks and exploring new
ideas, even if they may not immediately yield positive results. By cutting losses and moving on too quickly, a company
may miss out on opportunities to learn from failure and make necessary adjustments to improve a product or idea. This
"move on" culture can be detrimental to innovation and creativity, as it can discourage risk-taking and experimentation
and can result in a lack of progress and stagnation in the company's growth.
The culture of "move on" can also create a sense of fear or risk-aversion among employees, which can stifle creativity
and discourage them from taking risks or proposing new ideas. In contrast, a culture of experimentation and learning
can create an environment where employees feel empowered to take risks, try new things, and learn from their failures
which will lead to increased creativity, innovation, and ultimately, more successful products and ideas. Hence, when a
company is too focused on immediate success and quick wins, it may limit the company's ability to explore new
opportunities and markets and overlook potentially valuable opportunities that require longer-term investment and
exploration. This will further impede a company's ability to stay ahead of the curve and adapt to changing market
conditions.
The concept of "exploration vs. exploitation" comes into play here. In terms of the exploration-exploitation tradeoff, a
culture of "move on" can create a bias toward exploitation, where a company focuses on optimizing its existing products
and processes rather than exploring new ideas and opportunities. This can limit a company's ability to discover new
markets and technologies, and ultimately hinder its ability to remain competitive over the long term. In contrast, a
company that is also focused on exploration, or experimenting with new ideas and taking risks, may be more likely to
identify and capitalize on emerging trends and opportunities for growth. In summary, while it's important for companies
to be efficient and strategic with their resources, a culture of "move on" can have a negative impact on innovation,
creativity,
Answer 6: The need to appeal to both kids and parents, as well as adult collectors, likely had an impact on the naming
process for the new Hot Wheels product. Mattel would need to choose a name that is not just catchy and memorable
for the kids but also resonates with them. It also must communicate the value proposition of the new mixed-play
One possible name for the new Hot Wheels product could be "Hot Wheels MixTrack". This name combines the classic
"Hot Wheels" brand name with the new concept of a mixed-play experience, as represented by the "MixTrack"
component of the platform. The name also has a modern, tech-savvy feel that may appeal to both kids and adult
collectors. "Rev up your playtime with the ultimate mixed-play experience" can be the tagline to appeal to both kids and
parents. "Hot Wheels Fusion" could also be used as a name, signifying the combination of physical and digital play
experiences. A tagline for this name might be "Race, create, and explore like never before" or "Rev up your playtime
with the ultimate fusion experience" to appeal to both kids and parents. Either of the taglines communicate the key
benefits of the mixed-play or fusion experience - the ability to race cars, create custom tracks, and explore new worlds
through the app. It also emphasizes the idea that this is a new and innovative experience that takes Hot Wheels to the
next level. Ultimately, the most important factor in choosing a name and tagline will be extensive testing with the target
audience to ensure that it resonates and communicates the right message. Mattel could use focus groups, surveys, and
other forms of market research to gather feedback and refine its messaging until they find the perfect combination that
appeals to both kids and adult buyers. In the end, the name and tagline should be memorable, catchy, and clearly
enunciate the mixed-play aspect of the product to both kids and parents.
Answer 7: There are several pricing strategies that Mattel could consider for the launch of the new mixed-play Hot
strategy for Mattel if they want to generate buzz around the new product and encourage trial among consumers. Once
they have established a customer base, they could gradually increase prices. However, this strategy may not be
sustainable in the long run if the costs of producing the product are high. As mentioned in Exhibit 9A,9B, and 9C
respectively, the penetration pricing for the Car, Race Portal, and Smart Track could be $4.99, $39.99, and $159.99 to
Premium Pricing: This involves setting a high price to convey exclusivity and luxury. This could be a good strategy
for Mattel if they want to appeal to adult collectors who are willing to pay a premium for high-quality, unique products.
However, this strategy may not be effective for appealing to families or children who may be more price-sensitive. As
mentioned in Exhibit 9A,9B, and 9C respectively, the premium pricing for the Car, Race Portal, and Smart Track could
Bundle Pricing: This involves offering a discount for purchasing multiple products together. For example, Mattel could
offer a discount for purchasing the Cars, Race Portal, and Smart Track together. This could incentivize consumers to
purchase all the 3 products and increase overall sales. However, this strategy may not be effective if consumers only
want to purchase one of the products. As mentioned in Exhibit 9C,9B, and 9A respectively, the price for the smart track
with the highest likelihood to buy is $159.99, for the race portal is $39.99, and for the car is $4.99.Hence all the 3
products can be offered at a bundled price of $199.99. This will give consumers a feeling that they are getting a deal
with 2 cars for free. Also, different bundled prices can be created if Race Portal and Smart Track are bought together
but no cars.
Value-Based Pricing: This involves setting prices based on the perceived value of the product to the consumer. Mattel
could conduct market research to understand how much consumers are willing to pay for the new mixed-play Hot
Wheels experience and set prices accordingly. This could be an effective strategy for balancing profitability with
consumer demand.
However, when choosing a pricing strategy for the launch of the new Hot Wheels product, there are a few factors to
consider, including the target audience, the competition, and the perceived value of the product, and based on these
factors, I would recommend a skimming pricing strategy. A skimming pricing strategy involves setting a relatively high
price for a new product in order to capture early adopters and maximize profits before competitors enter the market.
This strategy is particularly effective when the product offers a unique value proposition and has a relatively low level
of competition. In the case of the new Hot Wheels product, the mixed-play experience and the integration of physical
and digital components is a unique value proposition that is not currently offered by many other toy products. This
suggests that there may be a high level of demand among innovators, early adopters, and early majority buyers who are
willing to pay a premium price for this experience. Additionally, the Hot Wheels brand has a strong reputation among
collectors and fans, which may further enhance the perceived value of the new product and support a premium price
point. However, it's important to note that a skimming pricing strategy may limit the product's appeal to a narrower,
more affluent audience. Therefore, Mattel could consider introducing lower-priced options, such as a basic version of
the product, in order to appeal to a broader range of customers and increase overall sales. A combination of strategies
could also be used, such as a skimming approach followed by penetration pricing once initial demand has been met.
Overall, a skimming pricing strategy may be a good fit for the launch of the new Hot Wheels product, but it should be
accompanied by a clear marketing strategy that communicates the unique value proposition of the product and justifies
the higher price point. It should be chosen on a variety of factors, including the target market, competition, and the
Answer 8: When considering the retail channels to use for the launch of the new Hot Wheels product, there are a few
factors to consider, including the target audience, the level of competition, and the distribution network of each retailer.
Based on these factors, I would recommend a multi-channel retail strategy that includes both traditional in-store and
online retailers, as well as exclusive deals with select retailers. By partnering with multiple retailers, Mattel can reach
a wider audience and increase the visibility of the new product. It can also help to build brand awareness and generate
buzz around the launch by having the product available in a variety of different locations, thus enhancing market
penetration and proximity with customers. However, Mattel could also consider partnering exclusively with a selected
few retailers who have a strong track record of success with similar products. This strategy could help to build a more
focused and targeted marketing campaign around the product, and may also lead to stronger relationships with key
retailers. One key consideration would be the target market for the product. Since the mixed-play experience is designed
to appeal to both kids and parents, retailers that cater to both demographics would be ideal. This could include major
toy retailers such as Toys "R" Us, Walmart(4000 stores), and Target(1800 stores), as well as online retailers like
Amazon(accounts for 50% of ecommerce sales in the USA). An exclusive deal with a major retailer could also be
effective in generating buzz and initial demand for the product. However, it's important to ensure that the retailer's
values and customer base align with the product and target market. As mentioned in Exhibit 10, 83% of buyers expect
the products to be sold from Walmart, 81% from Amazon, and 78% from Target.
While Apple stores(270 stores) may offer a distribution network(not as strong as other retailers) and a decent level of
visibility, it may not be the best fit for the new Hot Wheels product. Apple stores tend to focus on premium products
and high-end electronics, which may not align with the audience and price point of the new Hot Wheels product.
Traditional toy retailers may be better equipped to showcase the product and provide an engaging in-store experience.
So, the choice of retail channels will depend on factors such as target market, competition, and the perceived value of
the product in each channel which can be achieved through a multi-channel retail strategy that includes both traditional
in-store and online retailers, as well as exclusive deals with selected retailers, and this will prove to be the best fit for
the launch of the new Hot Wheels product. This approach would allow Mattel to reach a wide audience, build strong
relationships with key retailers, and generate excitement around the launch.
Answer 9: It is true that a 30-second TV ad may not be enough time to fully explain the benefits of mixed play and the
new features of the Hot Wheels product. However, it is still possible to convey the message effectively in a short amount
of time by using clear and concise language and focusing on the key benefits that are most important to the target
audience. One effective way to do this is to use storytelling to demonstrate how the new Hot Wheels product can inspire
creativity and imagination beyond traditional play. For example, the ad could feature a child playing with the new Hot
Wheels product, using it to build a custom track that incorporates elements from other toys or household items. As the
child plays, the ad could highlight the various features of the product, such as its ability to connect to other toys, its
customizable design, and its versatility for different types of play. The ad could also emphasize the social and
developmental benefits of mixed play, such as encouraging collaboration, problem-solving, and experimentation. By
showcasing the product's unique features in action and highlighting its potential for mixed play, the ad could capture
the attention of viewers and persuade them to consider the product as more than just a traditional Hot Wheels toy.
Hence, the goal of the ad would be to position the new Hot Wheels product as a fun and innovative way to inspire
As the advertising agency creative director for Mattel, I would focus on highlighting the unique features and benefits
of the new Hot Wheels product in a clear and simple way. Here is an example of a 30-second TV ad message that could
Scene: Children playing with both physical and digital Hot Wheels toys
Voiceover: "Introducing the new Hot Wheels, the ultimate mixed-play experience. With physical cars that you can race
on the track, and a digital world that brings your imagination to life."
Scene: Children using the race portal and smart track
Voiceover: "Unlock endless possibilities with the race portal and smart track, where you can create your own tracks
and race your friends in the real world and the digital world."
Voiceover: "And with the app, you can customize your cars and track performance, making every race an adventure."
Voiceover: "For adult collectors, the new Hot Wheels brings a new level of excitement to your collection, with cars
Voiceover: "Experience the ultimate mixed-play with the new Hot Wheels. Available now."
By focusing on the unique features and benefits of the new Hot Wheels product, this 30-second TV ad could effectively
convey the message to the target audience and generate excitement around the launch.