Evaluation Sheet
Key Expert No 1 - Project B.Sc. degree in wastewater/water
Manager supply engineering or related field.
Preferably 10 years’ experience as
project manager or team leader for
similar projects in the field of
modernization of municipal
infrastructure or new construction,
water and wastewater management.
Preferably 3 years of work experience
in the region.
Mandatory knowledge of English.
Knowledge of Russian or Kyrgyz
languages will be an advantage.
Good level of computer literacy,
report writing and communication
skills.
Key Expert No 2 - Design B.Sc. degree in wastewater/water
Engineer supply engineering or related field.
Preferably 10 years of professional
experience in the development of
design documentation in the field of
municipal infrastructure for water
supply, wastewater management and
sanitation.
Preferably 3 years of work experience
in the region.
Fluency in English and
Russian/Kyrgyz.
Good level of computer literacy,
report writing and communication
skills.
Key Experts No 3 Local Higher technical education.
Team Leader Preferably 10 years of professional
experience in modernization or new
construction in the field of municipal
infrastructure for water supply and
sanitation.
Preferably 5 years of work experience
in the region.
Good computer knowledge, report
writing and communication skills.
Fluency in Russian and Kyrgyz.
Knowledge of English will be an
advantage.
Key Expert No 4 - B.Sc. degree in engineering, law or
Procurement and contract similar.
management specialist Preferably 10 years’ experience in
contracting, procurement and contract
management in IFI projects in water
sector.
Preferably 5 years as contracting,
procurement or claims manager for
Name: Dgebuadze Arthur
Experience: 15 Years
Qualification: Diploma
Water Supply and Sewer
Relevant Experience: OK
*Please check if Diploma is
Equivalent to B.Sc. degree
Name: Daniyar Karshalov
Experience: 15 Years
Qualification: Diploma
Water Supply, Sanitation
(2001)
Relevant Experience: Very
less experience of water
supply, wastewater
management and
sanitation (mostly in
Buildings)
Please provide replacement
*Please check if Diploma is
Equivalent to B.Sc. degree
Name: Toltoev Syrgak
Experience: 15 Years plus
Qualification: Documents
for 1995 diploma not
available (Please see if we
can get)
Relevant Experience: OK
*Please check if Diploma is
Equivalent to B.Sc. degree
Name: Mailybayeva
Saltant Kenzhebayevna
Experience: 10 Years
Qualification: Diploma in
Law (2009) available
Relevant Experience: OK
*Please check if Diploma is
Equivalent to B.Sc. degree
 similar projects.
Theoretical and practical knowledge
and experience of IFI (especially
EBRD, WB and/or ADB)
procurement rules.
Theoretical and practical knowledge
and experience of FIDIC conditions
of contract (Yellow/Red books)
and/or World Bank/EBRD Supply
and Installation and Works Contracts.
Preferably 3 years of work experience
in the region.
Fluency in English is mandatory.
Good level of computer literacy,
report writing and communication
skills.
Key Expert No 5 Higher technical education. Name: Grigoryev Igor
Equipment engineer Preferably 10 years of professional Anatolevich
experience in repair equipment, Experience: 10 Years
special equipment such as leak Qualification: Diploma in
detection and etc. in the field of Civil (2008) available
municipal infrastructure for water Relevant Experience: OK
supply and sanitation. *Please check if Diploma is
Preferably 5 years of work experience Equivalent to Higher
in the region. Technical Education
Good level of computer literacy and
good communication skills.
Fluency in English is mandatory.
Knowledge of Russian and Kyrgyz
will be an advantage.
Non-Key Experts Evaluation not required
Environmental and Social Higher specialised education. Name: Kozhoke uulu
Specialist Preferably 10 years’ professional Raikan
(non-key expert) experience in similar projects, Experience: 15 Years
practical knowledge and Qualification: Not Clear
understanding of the environmental Please provide replacement
and social requirements of the EBRD. Relevant Experience: NOT
Preferably 5 years of work experience OK The Project list are not
in the region. available)
Good level of computer literacy and *
good communication skills.
Fluency in English and
Russian/Kyrgyz.
Finance/Disbursement B.Sc. degree in international finance Name: Kuzhebekova
Specialist (or equivalent) Ainash
(non-key expert) Preferably 5 years professional Experience: 10 Years
experience Qualification: Not Clear
Practical knowledge and Relevant Experience: NOT
understanding of IFI disbursement OK The Project list are not
and accounting procedures. available)
* Please provide
replacement
Design engineers for water Higher technical education. 1. Name: Adil Sabitov
supply and sewage Preferably 10 years of professional Experience: 7 Years (Not
systems experience in the development of Ok)
(4 (four) non-key experts) design documentation in the field of Qualification: Not Clear
municipal infrastructure for water Relevant Experience: NOT
supply and sanitation. OK mostly in residential
Preferably 5 years of work experience apartments and schools
in the region. 2. Name: Arman
Good level of computer literacy and Experience: 12 Years
good communication skills. Qualification: Heat Power
Preferably fluency in English and Engineering
Russian/Kyrgyz. Relevant Experience: OK
3. Name:
AfanasyevaMariya
Experience: 10 Years
Qualification: Diploma in
Architectural and
construction, Civil eng
Relevant Experience: OK
4. Name: Valeriya
Ozerova
Experience: 10 Years
Qualification: Diploma in
Water Management
Relevant Experience: Not
OK (Mostly in Dam and
Bridges) Please provide
replacement

Please check if Diploma is

Equivalent to Higher
Technical Education
Automation engineer (non- Higher technical education. Name: Ermekov Nurgisa
key expert) Preferably 10 years of professional Experience: 15 Years
experience in SCADA, water Qualification: Diploma in
modelling, metering devices, etc. in Automation and Control
the field of municipal infrastructure Relevant Experience: Ok
for water supply and sanitation.
Preferably 5 years of work experience
in the region.
Good level of computer literacy and
good communication skills.
Fluency in English and
Russian/Kyrgyz.
Health and Safety Preferably B.Sc. degree (or Name: Sultan Beshli-ogly
Specialist (non-key expert) equivalent qualification) in relevant Experience: 10 Years
sector Qualification: Diploma in
Preferably 10 years’ experience in Automation and Control
similar projects Relevant Experience: Gas
Specific experience in health and Pipeline Please provide
safety of construction for replacement
infrastructural projects.
Practical knowledge and
understanding of EBRD’s
environmental and social
requirements and past experience of
assistance in their successful
 implementation.
Practical knowledge of EU health and
safety requirements particularly with
reference to construction health and
safety.
Technical Supervision and Higher technical education. 1. Name: Arman
Quality Control Engineer Preferably 5 years of professional Umbetov
(4 (four) non-key expert) experience in construction Experience: 10 Years
supervision in the field of municipal Qualification: Industrial and
infrastructure. civil engineering technology)
Preferably 5 years of work experience Relevant Experience: OK
in the region. 2. Name: Kuanysh
Good level of computer literacy and Tankimov
good communication skills. Experience: 15 Years
Preferably fluency in English and Qualification: Diploma in
Russian/Kyrgyz. Civil-Structural
Engineering
Relevant Experience: OK
3. Name: Ruslan
Rustemov
Experience: 11 Years
Qualification: Mechanical
Engineering Technological
Machines
Relevant Experience: Not
OK (Project Details Not
Provided) Please provide
replacement

4. Name: Yuriy
Lazarev
Experience: 10 Years
Qualification: Diploma in
Civil
Relevant Experience: Not
OK (Mostly in Oil and Gas
field) Please provide
replacement

Please check if Diploma is

Equivalent to Higher
Technical Education
Interpreter / translator & Preferably 5 years of experience on No CV Provided
Office Manager the similar role