Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 4

Unveiling the Road Ahead: Modeling Vehicle Ownership Growth in the

Dominican Republic using Gompertz curve

Oliver González-Sánchez∗
May 2023

1. Introduction park experiences an accelerating growth rate. However,


this growth eventually decays as real per capita income
Economic expansion plays a pivotal point in shaping reaches a threshold, approaching a saturation point.
transportation demand and exacerbating traffic con- At this stage, where a significant portion of potential
gestion. As commercial activities flourish, transactions buyers already own a vehicle, further income increments
boost and travels multiply. Simultaneously, rising have a diminishing impact on motorization rates.
incomes afford individuals the means to fulfill their
social aspirations of owning private transportation, Consequently, traditional linear regression approaches
which further amplifies overall traffic volumes. become inadequate for accurately capturing and mod-
eling the vehicle demand function directly. To address
Unfortunately, the continuous increase in demand for this, alternative modeling frameworks, such as the
public road usage, combined with the absence of an effi- Gompertz curve, have been employed to effectively
cient public transportation system and forward-looking capture the non-linear dynamics and provide a more
city planning, leads to adverse consequences. Travel robust representation.
times become longer, fuel consumption escalates, and
productivity suffers due to mobility delays. 2. Model

To accurately evaluate the future of the country’s The Gompertz curve, introduced by the renowned
transportation network and develop effective policies British statistician and mathematician Benjamin
to address this adverse panorama, it is essential that Gompertz in 1825, initially found its applications in
academic researchers, civil engineers and policymakers the fields of actuarial sciences, population growth, and
count on precise forecasts of vehicle ownership dynam- biology (Felis, Moral y Pérez, 2016).
ics. This is particularly important considering the rapid
expansion of the country’s vehicle fleet over the past Over the course of a century, Gompertz curve caught the
two decades, the current levels of traffic congestion1 , attention of economists, with Prescott (1922) being the
and DR’s optimistic medium-term economic outlook. pioneer to utilize it in modeling demand growth. Ex-
panding on Prescott’s work, numerous researches later
Vehicle ownership is a complex phenomenon influenced refined the curve to better capture the motorization be-
by various socioeconomic factors. Among these, per havior of their economies as:
capita income has been widely used to explain motoriza-
−βgt
tion density’s evolution. Extensive empirical evidence Vt = λe−αe (1)
reveals that the positive relationship between these
two variables is non-linear and follows a distinctive Where Vt are the vehicles per 1,000 people, gt is
sigmoidal shape, an “S-shaped curve.” This implies the GDP per capita at constant prices, α and β are
that, initially, as per capita income rises, the vehicle parameters defining the curvature of the function, and
λ describes the saturation condition, taken as the max
∗ oliverantoniogonzalez@gmail.com vehicle ownership a country will reach as income rises.
1 González-Sánchez
and Greneway (2019) found Dominicans lose
14.3 minutes per trip in traffic jams. Equation (1) can be transform by taking the logarithmic
operation on both sides and organizing to obtain: 3. Data
λ The estimation of parameters x and β relies on annual
ln = αe−βgt (2)
Vt vehicle park and GDP per capita at constant 2017
Log-linearizing equation (2) results in: international dollars data, published by Dominican
Republic’s Internal Revenue Agency (DGII) and the
 λ
ln ln = lnα − βgt (3) International Monetary Fund (IMF), respectively, for
Vt
the 1998-2022 period. Additionally, the saturation
  parameter λ was calibrated at 730 vehicles per 1000
Making ln ln Vλt = vt and lnα = x, the equation can
people, in line with the estimates provided by Dargay
be converted to:
(2001) specific to the country. Furthermore, to capture
vt = x − βgt (4)
the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, a dichotomous
Where x and β can be estimated econometrically by an variable was introduced into the econometric estimation
Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) linear regression model. as a control measure, taking the value of 1 in 2020.
Subsequently, the estimated parameters are evaluated
in equation (1) to derive estimates of motorization rates 4. Results
based on expected income behavior.
The econometric estimation of the parameters in the
Differentiating (1) the long-run income elasticity is cal- Gompertz function yields robust results that are statis-
culated as: tically significant and consistent with the expected sign
ηtLR = αβgt eβgt (5) according to the specialized empirical literature. There-
fore, the vehicle fleet growth model based on real per
Following Kresnanto (2019) this elasticity remains
capita income can be described as:
positive across all income levels and it increases until
−1.22x10
−4
reaching a maximum at GDP per capita = −1 β . By
gt
Vt = 730e−4.659e (6)
mathematical construction, the implied long-run elas-
ticity of the vehicle fleet with respect to income is not In-sample estimations using equation (6) demonstrate
isoelastic. that the functional form accurately captures the ob-
served motorization behavior. This not only vali-
The economic rationale for this non-constant elasticity
dates the calibration and estimation exercises but also
is rooted in the premise that as income levels start low,
strengthens the case for utilizing the model in forecast-
the affordability barrier inhibits motorization growth,
ing future motorization trends.
according to Glaeser, Kahn, and Rappaport (2008).
Yet, as incomes rise, individuals can allocate more Figure 1. Comparative examination of the model
resources to purchasing vehicles, sparking a surge in
demand fueled by the desire for mobility and status.
Nevertheless, a saturation point is reached eventually,
as identified by Dargay and Hanly (2004), marked by
limited parking space, increased traffic congestion, and
the availability of alternative transportation options,
causing vehicle ownership to stabilize and become less
responsive to further increases in per capita income.
Instead, vehicle ownership growth aligns more closely
with population growth rather than income growth,
indicating a state of equilibrium in the market.

Source: Own estimations.


According to the computed growth model, for every in- and around 2.0 million more vehicles in the next decade.
come level, motorization in the Dominican Republic is
expected to evolve as depicted by figure 2. Moreover, in light of the current geographical distribu-
tion and composition of the vehicle park, it is expected
Figure 2. Dominican Vehicle Fleet Growth Model that by 2028, an additional 262.4 thousand cargo trucks,
trucks, buses, SUVs, and cars will worsen traffic conges-
tion in Santo Domingo and the Distrito Nacional. Addi-
tionally, an estimated addition of 182.4 thousand motor-
cycles will further contribute to the congestion. This is a
concerning prospect, especially considering the already
slow average speed of transportation, which gravitates
around 9 kilometers per hour in these metropolitan ar-
eas.

Table 1. Vehicle Park Forecast 2024-2034

*Vehicle Park Motorization Rate


(Millions of Vehicles) (Vehicles per 1000 people)
Source: Own estimations. 2024 5.73 531
2025 5.97 549
Based on the modeling exercise, the motorization dy- 2026 6.20 566
namic in the Dominican Republic is unlikely to become 2027 6.42 582
2028 6.64 597
more responsive to increases in per capita income. This
2029 6.85 612
is, the demand for vehicle ownership already surpassed 2030 7.05 626
the stage of maximum elasticity, and motorization rates 2031 7.25 638
are expected to follow a steady growth as income con- 2032 7.43 650
2033 7.60 661
tinues its upward trajectory.
2034 7.76 670
Figure 3. Implied Income Elasticity *Includes motorcycles, cars, jeeps, cargo vehicles, buses, heavy
machinery, dump trucks, and others.
Source: Own estimations.

4. Conclusion

The findings from the developed mathematical model,


which captures the relationship between motorization
rates and income per capita in the DR, emphasize the
importance of addressing the anticipated growth in the
vehicle population.

The fitted Gompertz curve predicts a substantial


Source: Own estimations. increase of 1.2 million vehicles over the next five years
and 2.0 million over the next decade, which will worsen
However, considering DR’s macroeconomic outlook
traffic congestion, particularly in Santo Domingo and
and demographic trends, the mathematical model
the Distrito Nacional, where the slow average speed of
predicts a substantial 21.5% growth in the vehicle park
transportation is already a concern.
over the next five years, reaching approximately 6.6
million vehicles by 2028. These figures emphasize the Efforts to address these worrisome predictions are
forthcoming challenge of accommodating an additional crucial to alleviate the growing traffic burden and en-
1.2 million vehicles on the roads in the near future, sure smoother movement for residents and commuters.
Unveiling the road ahead, authorities must explore
comprehensive supply and demand side measures to
strategically affect the relative prices of transportation.
The cost of inaction far exceeds the budgetary and
political cost of shaping the incentive schemes to tackle
traffic congestion.

5. References

• Dargay, J., & Hanly, M. (2004). Land Use and


Mobility. ESRC Transport Studies Unit Centre for
Transport Studies University College London.

• Glaeser, E. L., Kahn, M. E., & Rappaport, J.


(2008). Why do the poor live in cities? The role
of public transportation. Journal of Urban Eco-
nomics, 63(1), 1-24.

• González-Sánchez, O., & Greneway, I. (2019). Lo


que el tiempo se llevó: Congestionamiento vehicular
en el Distrito Nacional. Investigaciones ganadoras
2do concurso de investigación social de la vicepres-
idencia de la República Dominicana, 29-82.

• Kresnanto, N. C. (2019). Model of relationship be-


tween car ownership growth and economic growth
in Java. IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and
Engineering, 650(1), 012047.

• Moral Carcedo, J., Felis Rota, M., & Pérez Garcı́a,


J. (2016). Dual approach for modelling demand
saturation levels in the automobile market. The
Gompertz curve: Macro versus micro data. Inves-
tigación Económica, LXXV(296).

• Prescott, R. B. (1922). Laws of Growth in Forecast-


ing Demand. Jour. Am. Stat. Assoc., 18, 471-479.

You might also like