Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects
1 Introduction
The format of this report is similar to that of my last contribution. In general,
emphasis is placed on intramolecular photophysical processes. Several aspects of
photochemical excited-state decay processes are covered in later chapters of this
volume.
In the two-year period covered in this report there have been a number of
significant developments, amongst which are the following: (0 the relentless
progress of ab initio methods of calculating excited-state properties as exemplified
by calculations on a model of the active site in the iron-sulphur protein rubredoxin,
(ii) fresh impetus and progress towards methods of calculation which avoid the
Born-Oppenheimer separation, (iii)a major study of cyclic n-electron systems that
uses magnetic circular dichroism, which should advance the wider application of
this technique, (iv) the development of the concept of a proximity effect to interpret
the photophysical properties of N-heterocyclics, (v) the remarkable observations of
mode-to-mode vibrational-energy flow in the first excited singlet states of benzene
and aniline, and (vi) the probing of homogeneous linewidths in fluid solutions in
studies of the anti-Kasha fluorescence of aromatic hydrocarbons.
t
2-N
Z
Figure 1 Regions of validity of k ordering and hydrogenic (H) ordering of the excited-state
levels of neutral atoms and ions with small degree of ionization Z-N ( Z is the atomic number, N
is the number of electrons). The curve separating the two regions is plotted as a graph of Z-N
vs. z
(Reproduced with permission from Phys. Rev. A , 1977, 16, 459)
p
c,
0.7
C
- 0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0
100 105 110 115 120
Wavelength/ nm
Figure 2 Calculated Puorescence for the 22C+ 1 'Z transition (curve a), the Z 2 l I + 1 211
transition (curve b), and the sum of the two (curve c ) rescaled to unity at its maximum
(Reproduced with permission from J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 67, 3122)
' I I I I I 1 I t 1 2
4 5 6 7 8 9 10 II 12 13
R /bohr
Figure 3 Potential-energy curves.for the excited valence states of Mg,. The dashedportions of
the 'nuand 2'Zg+curves indicate regions that have not been investigated directly but are
estimated by joining known short-range and long-range behaviour
(Reproduced with permission from J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 67, 1977)
44
M . Pelissier and J. P. Malrieu, J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 67, 5963
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 9
,,
two lowest states, ,B, and 'A of meth~lene.,~ This value was considerably higher
than the previously accepted, theoretically predicted, and experimentally measured
values, which converged on a value around 0.5 eV or 1 1 kcal mol- '. A recent paper
has presented the results of ab initio calculations, using a multi-reference double-
,,
excitation (MRD) CI technique of the ' A ,B,, and ' B , states of CH, and the ,B1
and , A , states of CH,-, and these have enabled the authors to suggest a re-
interpretation of the results of the photodetachment experiment, which brings them
,
into good agreement with earlier work.46 The 'A + ,B1 To value of 1.05 eV
observed in the photodetachment experiment agreed well with calculated values. A
number of the low-lying excited states of the CH2+ion have been investigated by ab
initio GTOSCF CI method^.^' A laser-induced fluorescence study of CH,
produced in ketene photolysis resulted in a prediction of the ,B, to ' A , energy
',
difference (not To)of 8.1 & 0.8 kcal mol- which is in general agreement with the
above calculation^.^^ A general discussion of the nature of the low-lying excited
states of saturated molecules is included in a study of the ' B , ( l T , ) state of
methane.,' The character of the excited states in such molecules can rapidly change
from Rydberg to valence or vice versa with small changes in geometry. This point is
developed in a discussion of the photodissociation of methane to CH, and H,, in
which a low-lying vertical state of CH,, commonly characterized as a Rydberg
state, correlates with a low-lying valence state in the product, ' B , CH,. The study
has been extended to other features of the photochemistry of C H , using
calculations with an improved basis set.50 The vertical transition energies of the
lower excited singlet states of CH, have been calculated by a bond-orbital
method,51 and the structure and bonding in the excited states of n-alkanes,
,
C,,H2,+ (n = 1-5), have been investigated by use of the semi-empirical INDO
method with CI.', The application of minimal basis-set calculations in the latter
study is supported by previous studies of H ,O and of HCHO and C ,H , in which it
has been possible to compare ab initio calculations and experimental results,
respectively, with the results of semi-empirical calculations.
The effect of improving the valence and Rydberg parts of the basis set on the low-
lying excited states of silane has been investigated. 53 The singlet states were found
to be essentially Rydberg states, whereas the triplet states have significant valence
character. The previously effective use of the one-centre expansion (OCE) SCF MO
and improved virtual orbital (IVO) approximations in calculating the excited states
of H,O and NH,54 has been repeated for the hydrides of some second-row atoms,
H,S, PH,, and SiH,. 5 5 SCF CI and MCSCF CI ab initio calculations of the ground,
-? z
\
w
-6
's +
-5
-4
'D +
-3
3P +
3P +
-2
3P +
-I
Wave method to the theoretical treatment of Rydberg and valence states in small
polyatomic molecules is illustrated by a study of the excited states of H,S.64 It is
suggested that this method is more flexible in such calculations than either the one-
centre expansion methods or the LCAO (multi-centre) methods, and the results, for
H,S at least, indicate that it is sufficientlyaccurate to aid spectroscopic assignments
involving Rydberg states. There is generally good agreement between the results
and those of a recent large-scale ab initio CI study. 6 5 A CNDO CI method has been
used to calculate the electronic spectrum of SO, and thereby aid in the
interpretation of phosphorescence microwave double-resonance and microwave-
induced delayed phosphorescence experiments on this molecule.66
A pseudopotential technique has been used to calculate the vertical transition
energies of the iodine molecule. Strong mixing of the valence configurations of the
same symmetry was found to be important, particularly for the %+, ng,and nu
states. Despite the lack of diffuse orbitals in the basis set and the neglect of
spin-orbit coupling there is quite good agreement with measured transition
energies. A new 'non-Mulliken' state, 3q+, was predicted in the 9eV region, and
"
R. Roberge and D. R. Salahub, J . Chem. Phys., 1979, 70, 1177.
65
S. Shih, S. D. Peyerimhoff, and R. J. Buenker, Chem. Phys., 1976, 17, 391.
'' B. Minaev, T. 0. Tlepbergenov, and Z. M. Muldakhmetov, Opt. Spektrosk., 1978,45, 679.
6'
C. Teichteil and J. P. Malrieu, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977, 49, 152.
12 Photochemistry
the inclusion of diffuse AOs is expected to lower its energy. The excited-state
potential curves of fluorine have been investigated by the asymptotic method. 6 8
A new experimental technique to measure the spectroscopic properties of
excimer molecules has been applied to Hg,.69 A theoretical treatment of diatomic
excimer molecules has been used to interpret the results. 70 The resulting potential-
energy curves and transition rates have been used to discuss the design of a possible
optically pumped 335 nm (1, + )0', mercury laser. Subsequent time-resolved
fluorescence measurements on this system, to avoid a trimer emission 485 nm, have
made it possible to calculate part of the repulsive wall of the 1, state's potential
surface. 7 1 Ab initio MCSCF-CI calculations on Au, have been published. 7 2 The 68
core electrons were replaced by an averaged relativistic effective core potential
(AREP). There is generally good agreement between the calculated and experi-
mental values for a number of Au, properties, e.g. the ground-state dissociation
energy and the energies of the allowed 0', and 0', transitions.
To aid in the interpretation of the luminescence properties of ions such as Ti4+,
V5+,Mo6+,and W6+ in an oxidic lattice, SCF-MO calculations on the W 0 , 6 -
octahedron have been ~ n d e r t a k e n As . ~ ~a result of the study the absorption
spectrum is attributed to excitation into two ' T l ustates and the luminescence to
emission from two 3Tlustates. Ab initio SCF CI calculations have been performed
to describe the ground and excited states of CrCl,(g), CoCl,(g).74 The results
provided a good basis for the interpretation of the spectra of these gaseous
transition-metal dichlorides.
A series of SCF calculations on ethylene have been carried out, in which the basis
set is systematically altered by a change in the number of diffuse orbitals.75As a
result of this the number of members of the Rydberg series [ ( q n n ? ) in the model
used] will change, but there would be little effect on the location and character of
valence-like (n-n?) states, cf. the stabilization method of resonant scattering. Such
a stable state was in fact found, at 10.21eV with a large oscillator strength of 0.46,
and it is believed to be the analogue of the spectroscopic V ( ' B J state found in
Hartree-Fock theory and observed experimentally at 7.66 eV. These 'resonances'
that are spuriously pushed into the continuum in SCF theory may occur in other
systems. CI calculations on all the n = 3 Rydberg states of C,H, derived from the
excitation of the electron have been performed, and with one exception, the 8.26 eV
transition, the results are in agreement with the spectral assignments of Mulliken. 7 6
The recent application of the DODS(different orbitals for different
spins)-NO(natura1 orbital) CI method to the ground state of unstable molecules
such as the trimethylene diradical has led to an investigation of its use for unstable
excited states, using planar and perpendicularly twisted forms of substituted
E/eV + e/tv
-9.910. -9.750.
-9.920. -9.760-
-9.9 3 0 - -9.770-
q
l-
'
n
-1 lnU----F BT &B8 9 9v 9 9T 9s,
3
Figure 5 'Suddenpolarization' ofjirst and second singlet excited states of s-cis-, s-trans-diallyl
with ' S , optimizedgeometry '. The energies of two lowest polarized states S , ( I )and S,(II) and
corresponding deviations from electron neutrality of the trans allylic triad as a function of the
twist angle 034. ( a ) Approach 2 parametrization l(A + B ) corrected for the bond lengths
R j s j + ,j?j,j+l
: = -59.243 exp (-2.206 R j , j + , withj
) = 1, 2, 4, 5 , and j?34 = -59.243
exp( -2.206 R 3 4 ) ~ ~ ~(b) 0 3Approach
4; 4 withparametrization l(A + B + C ) corrected in
the same way
(Reproduced with permission from J. Chem. Phys., 1978, 69, 1168)
results cast doubt on the interpretation of the i.r. spectrum of the matrix-isolated
parent [4]annulene.
Extensive ab initio generalized valence-bond (GVB) and CI calculations on the
valence excited states and positive ion states of trans- 1,4-butadiene and all-trans-
1,3,5-hexatriene have been published. 8 6 The agreement with experimental values is
good. The sudden polarization effect in the excited states of 1,3,5-hexatriene has
been investigated using MO calculations with full orthogonal valence-bond
structures.'' The effect is attributed to an avoided crossing of two excited states. A
study, using ab initio MO theory, of hydrogen bonding in the ground and low-lying
86
M . A. C. Nascimento and W. A. Goddard, tert., Chem. Phys., 1979, 36, 147.
*' C. M . Meerman-van Benthem, H. J. C. Jacobs, J. J . C. Mulder, N o w . J . Chem., 1978, 2, 123.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 15
excited states of the formic acid dimer has been published.88An extension of the
electron-hole potential (EHP) method to a two-configuration wave function was
used, in which form it is the simplest version of the MCSCF method.
Notwithstanding the complication introduced by the resonance interaction of the
two identical dimer subunits the results are of relevance to proton exchange
between base pairs in nucleic acids. No evidence for a lowering of the barrier to a
concerted transfer of the two bridging protons on going from the ground to the
lower excited states was found. It was noted, however, that in the 'A'( II -, li") state
of formic acid an n or 0 -+ a* configuration becomes important as the 0,-H,
distance increases, and this may result in the dimer 'A, or 'B, states (not studied, as
an MCSCF calculation would be required) having a lower barrier than the lower-
lying excited states. The correct order and symmetry of the ground, 'A1, and
',
excited, 3A 2, 'A , 3A states of formaldehyde were obtained in calculations using
'
the semi-empirical CNDO/VN- method,89 and a CND0/2-CI method has been
used to investigate the charge distributions in low-lying exciting states of
diacetamide and N-methyldia~etamide.~' The latter paper follows a study by the
authors of low-lying excited states for different conformations of diformamide and
N-methyldif~rmamide.~' As reported in my chapter in Volume 9 of this title, ab
initio SCF calculations on the interesting glyoxal molecule were not satisfactory. In
particular the 3A, state was predicted to have an adiabatic excitation energy, T,, of
',
36900cm- some 7700cm- ' above the well known experimental value, and an
unusually large splitting of the 1B,( I I - ~ * ) state in trans-glyoxal placed it between the
(n-fl), 3A, and 3B,, states. A new study of trans-glyoxal with ab initio correlated
wavefunctions has given significantly better agreement with experiment. 9 2 The 3A,
',
state is predicted to have a T , of 21 700cm- and the inclusion of electron
correlation is found to reverse the SCF ordering of the 3B, and 'B, states at the
vertical geometry. A similar change in the ordering of these states was also bound in
another study which included CI.93The authors suggest that the two lowest-lying
triplets, 3A, and 3Bu, are close enough to be in thermal equilibrium. SCF-Cl
calculations of the low-lying excited n7ir states of a series of carbonyl compounds 94
and a non-empirical SCF-MO study of the lowest-triplet-state potential-energy
surface of thiocarbonyls 9 5 have been published.
Various discrepancies between theoretical and experimental work on the U.V.
spectroscopy of the HCN molecule have been further investigated by ab initio SCF
and CI methods, which have been successfully applied to a number of small
molecules, to calculate excitation energies and by apriori methods to calculate the
vibrational structure. 9 6 The results confirm a previous reassignment on theoretical
grounds of the upper state in the a t X band system as a 1'A"-'C- species and not
0.40 -
0.35 -
0.32-
0.28 -
0.2L - I
0.20 -
0.16 -
Figure 6 Angular-potential curves for the low-lying states of HCN obtained from the CI
calculations. The calculated vibrational levels are also indicated
(Reproduced with permission from Can. J . Chem., 1977, 55, 3664)
lo' L. Z. Stenkemp and E. R. Davidson, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1977, 44, 405.
'03 E. Oliveros, M . Riviere, C. Teichteil, and J.-P., Malrieu, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 57, 220.
'04 M . Peric, R. J. Buenker, and S. D. Peyerimhoff, Can. J . Chem., 1977, 55, 1533.
'05 M . Peric, R. J. Buenker, and S. D. Peyerimhoff, Mol. Phys., 1978, 35, 1495.
lo' M. J . Robey and E. W. Schlag, J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 67, 2775.
lo' D. Bhaumik and G . S.Kastha, Indian J . Phys., 1977,51B, 195.
Io8 H. H o and Y. J. Ihaya, Bulf. Chem. SOC.Jpn., 1977, 50, 1629.
Io9 J. 0. Noell and M. D. Newton, J . Am. Chem. SOC.,1979, 101, 51.
18 Photochemistry
'
less planarity on going from rigid to fluid solutions. This change can account for
the fluorescence shift, the decrease in the fluorescence lifetime, and the appearance
of several S, t S, transitions observed experimentally. The excited-state equilib-
rium geometries of biphenyl, 1,I '-binaphthyl, and fulvalene have been calculated by
use of a method that combines a PPP n-method with an empirical a-potential,'"
and the bonding between benzene-benzene and anthracene-benzene dimers in
ground and excited electronic states has been calculated from MO theory. ' l 2
It is still not practical, for reasons of time and expense, to apply the most accurate
computational procedures presently available to large molecules, and the search for
approximate methods continues. A study of the low-lying excited electronic states
of pyrazine has explored the use of ab initio CI calculations in which CI expansions
are generated from SCF calculations, using a small set of floating spherical
'
Gaussian orbitals (FSGO). l 3 Pyrazine was chosen for the study because of the
presence of several types of electronic states [ 'l3(n -+ n*), ' * 3 ( n .*)I and the
-+
p 5.0
3.0
-
III
C
e
d
20
0
c
E 10
.-E
L
e
g
w
o
Calculated transition tnergy/cV
Figure 7 A plot of experimental vs. calculated (CI)transition energiesfor singlet states in N-
methylcarbazole
(Reproduced with permission from J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1978, 100, 1371)
'lo R. W. Bigelow and R. W. Anderson, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 58, 114.
''I
J. Suehnel and K. Gustav, Z . Chem., 1977, 17, 417.
I"
V. A. Zubkov, Teor. Eksp. Khim., 1977, 13, 527.
'I3
J. D. Petke, R. E. Christoffersen, G . M. Maggiora, and L. L. Shipman, Znt. J . Quantum Chem.,
Quantum Biol. Symp., 1977, 4, 343.
B. F. Samsonov, A. F. Terpugova, and E. I. Cheglokov, Teor. Eksp. Khim.. 1977, 13, 106.
'I5 D. Murk, L. E. Nitzsche, and R. E. Christoffersen, J . Am. Chem. SOC.,1978, 100, 1371.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 19
relation between calculated and experimental transition energies for the first four
singlets was found, and this is illustrated in Figure 7. It is not expected that this
linear relation will hold for states with substantial Rydberg or ionic character, but it
clearly has some potential for predicting the location of states, particularly in large
molecules. Ab initio SCF MO and n-electron CI calculations of the n-n* excited
states of the pyrrole molecule were found to give results in good agreement with
'
experiment. ' The spatial extension of the wavefunctions indicates that the
ground and lowest 3B2and 3A (an unobserved triplet state 1.10eV above 3B2,the
lowest excited state) states and the first excited 'A state are valence-type and the
first and second 'B2and the second 'A state are Rydberg stages. MO calculations
on fulvene have indicated that electronic excitation both to the first singlet and to
the first triplet states corresponds to a charge transfer from the exocyclic carbon to
the ring. l 7
SCF MO LCAO and INDO calculations on lithium aryls have indicated that
their behaviour may be attributed to an unusually low singlet-triplet energy
separation. ' l 8 The rotational constants of benzaldehyde in its first excited triplet
state have been calculated and compared with experimental values. The '
possibility that the lowest excited singlet state of polyenes is 'A, and not 'B, has
been explored in n-electron PPP calculations on a series of 1-arylbutadienes. 2o The '
results indicate that a weakly allowed 2 'A,-like state lies below the allowed 1 'B,-
like state in 1-arylbutadienes but that in unsubstituted or symmetrical diphenyl-
substituted polyenes it is the 1 'B, state that is lowest. The charge densities in the two
states are quite different, and this should result in significant differences in their
photochemical behaviour. The all-valence electron approximation was used in
calculations of the spectroscopic properties of acene quinones, 2 1 and an HF '
method has been used tacalculate the excitation energies and transition moments of
polyacene radical ions. 122
A useful rule has been identified to account for the effect of the hydroxyl-group
position in various isomeric hydroxycoumarins on their fluorescence properties.
This follows from semi-empirical SCF calculations on the excited states of
'
hydroxycoumarins. 23 To aid the interpretation of electron-spin polarization
measurements in the charge-transfer system phenanthrene-pyromellitic acid
dianhydride (PMDA), ab initio MO SCF calculations on the ground and low-lying
excited states of PMDA have been carried out, the first on this molecule. 124 LCAO
MO calculations have appeared of various properties of the ground and first excited
state of the boron-nitrogen ring compounds which are the analogues of the carbon
compounds biphenyl and biphenylene. 2 s '
'I6
K. Tanaka, T. Nornura, T. Noro, H. Tatewaki, T. Takada, H. Kashiwagi, F. Sasaki, and K. Ohno, J .
Chem. Phys., 1977, 67,5738.
'I7 N . Tyutyulkov, G . Neikov, and I. Kynev, Teor. Eksp. Khim., 1977, 13, 386.
'I8
I. A. Abronin, A. Ya Shteinshneider, G . M. Zhidomirov, and F. M . Stoyanovich, Izv. Akad. Nauk
SSSR. Ser. Khim.. 1979, 307.
'I9
S . N . Thakur, Indian J . Phys., 1977, 51B, 184.
P.J. Baldry and J. A. Barltrop, Chem. Phys. L e f t . , 1977, 46, 430.
G. Olbrich, 0. E. Polansky, and M . Zander, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem., 1977, 81,692.
''' A. V. Luzanov and V. E. Umansku, Zh. Strukt. Khim., 1977, 18,3.
W.Fabian, Z . Naturforsch., Teil, B, 1978, 33B,628.
C.P. Keijzers, P. S. Bagus, and J. P. Worth, J . Chem. Phys., 1978, 69, 4032.
125 E. Y. Bolycheva, V. N . Mochalkin, and A. B. Bolotin, Liet. Fiz. Rinkinys. 1977, 17,41.
20 Photochemistry
The results of CND0/2 MO calculations on the first (n,rl")excited singlet and
triplet states of the pyrimidine bases thymine, uracil, and cytosine have indicated
that the C-5+-5 bond in each of them should be very reactive.'26 Huckel
calculations in the same paper, on the ground- and excited-state energy levels of
non-covalent pyrimidine dimers in sandwich-type structures, indicated that
excimer formation was a possibility for all three bases. PPP MO calculations have
been used to investigate the 7t-electron distribution in the excited state of the
'
fluorescent cytosine derivatives ethenocytosines. *' The n-electron distribution in
the first excited singlet and triplet states of cytosine indicates that electrostatic
bonding may play an important role in the formation of thymine and cytosine
photodimers (see reference 126). This emerges from a CNDO CI study that also
suggests that the possibility of proton tunnelling in the guanine-cytosine base pair
of DNA is reduced if the excitation energy is localized on cytosine. 12' The use of
intermediate excitons in the theoretical description of electronically excited states in
polymers has been illustrated by a study of two simple periodic DNA models,'2g
and the applicability of semi-empirical RPAs has been investigated by calculating
the excited states of DNA bases.'30
Recent work (1972-1976) on quantum-chemical calculations on photoreceptor
''
pigments has been briefly reviewed. One of the disadvantages of using the PPP
method is the difficulty in understanding the wavefunctions that are obtained. A
procedure called configuration analysis (CA) overcomes this difficulty by expres-
sing the SCF molecular orbitals as linear combinations of a set of reference orbitals,
and obvious choice for which would be isoconjugate-hydrocarbon orbitals or
localized orbitals. The CA method has been applied to the photobiological
receptors luciferins, chlorophyll a, and the 11-cis-retinal Schiff bases 1 3 * and to
chlorophylls, phytochrome, and stentorin. 33 The results show, amongst other
things, that in chlorophyll a the peripheral C = C and isocyclic C = O groups are not
locally excited to any significantextent, and this is also true for the 11-C=C bond of
rhodopsin. The simple free-electron molecular-orbital (FEMO) method has been
used to study the electronic structure of chlorophylls. 13'The ab initio methods that
involve the use of a basic set of FSGOs and that were mentioned above in
connection with studies on N-methylcarbazole and pyrazine have been applied to
magnesium porphine and porphine 1 3 5 and to magnesium chlorin and chlorin.
The results reveal a complex pattern of excited states which are used to analyse the
electronic absorption spectra of these molecules. The ground and excited states of
porphyrin, 2,4-divinylporphyrin, and a$, y,Stetraphenylporphyrin have also been
3 Absorption Spectroscopy
General Theory.-There have been some very interesting discussions of the
Born-Oppenheimer (BO) separation in the recent literature. The BO separation is a
cornerstone of theoretical physics and is central to working concepts in spectros-
copy. It is very interesting, however, to return to basics and to see where other
constructions lead and where they can provide new insights into the behaviour of
molecules. For example it has been suggested that the natural co-ordinates for a
separation of the motion in a neutral molecule are those of the collective motion of
neutral subsystems, e.g. bonds, and the individual internal motion in each
subsystem, rather than the nuclear and electronic co-ordinates. 4 1 The physical '
reason for the separation arises from a division of the potential energy into two
parts and has nothing to d o with the smallness of the mass ratio, me,/mnu,as is
commonly believed. The adiabatic approximation, in which nuclei are regarded as
classical point masses following time-dependent paths and the electronic state is
13' S. J . Chantrell, C. A . McAuliffe, R. W. Munn, A . C. Pratt, and R. F. Weave, Bioinorg. Chem., 1977,7,
283.
13' M . Muthukumar and L. J . Weimann, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 53,436.
13' L. J. Dunne, Jerusalem Symp. Quantum Chem. Biochem., 1977, 10, 187.
140 R. A. Bair and W. A. Goddard, tert., J . Am. Chern. SOC.,1978, 100, 5669.
14'
H. Essen, Int. J . Quantum Chem., 1977, 12, 721.
h,
N
h,
w
24 Photochemistry
assumed to adapt itself instantaneously to this motion without any change in the
electronic quantum numbers, is clearly ‘semiclassical’.Other popular concepts such
as potential-energy surfaces, the separation of molecular energies into electronic,
vibrational, and rotational parts, and the symmetry classification of electronic
levels in diatomic molecules all have their origins in the old quantum theory. The
full acceptance of the quantum theory has dramatic consequences even for such a
popular concept as molecular structure. To quote from a recent paper: ‘if we d o not
make molecular structure part of the input of our theory (a full quantum theory) it
will never emerge in the output’. 142 It has been suggested that the retention of the
classical idea of molecular structure is the principal barrier to the development of
‘non-adiabatic’ calculational procedures in which electrons and nuclei are treated
alike.143 (In fact such calculations have recently been carried out on H, and
H2+.144)Whilst the author admits that there are no immediate reasons for
adopting a full quantum theory of molecules, particularly by the experimentalist, it
does appear that some theoreticians are beginning to see a point in the not too
distant future when traditional molecular models will become less and less relevant
to the interpretation of experiments and may even represent a ‘blind alley’.
A theoretical approach to the calculation of molecular spectra which avoids the
BO separation has recently been developed 14” and subsequently applied to
diatomic molecules. 14’’ The theory is the generator co-ordinate method (GCM)
which has its origins in nuclear physics. The theory has no semiclassical features. It
is a non-adiabatic variational method which contains the adiabatic approximation
as a limiting case. It is also possible in the method to separate the total energy into its
electronic, vibrational, and rotational parts, but this is achieved from a purely
quantum-mechanical point of view. The method uses trial functions of the form
given in equation (4),where x represents all particle degrees of freedom and OL a set
W )= Jf(Mx/a)da (4)
of parameters related to the collective motion, which do not appear in the final
result but act as additional co-ordinates to label the basis states and generate the
wavefunctions (hence the GCM). The $ (x) are linear superpositions of continu-
ously labelled basis states x(x/a) with weight functions Aa). The Aa) are deter-
mined from the variational principle and satisfy the secular equation ( 5 ) where
H(a,/?) = ( x ( a ) l H l x ( / ? ) ) and A(.,/?) = (x(a)lx(B)). The eigenvalues of the
c
146
K. Wittel and S. P. McGlynn, Chem. Rev., 1977, 77, 745.
14’
I. Fischer-Hjalmars, A. Henriksson-Enflo, and C. Herrmann, Chem. Phys., 1977, 24, 167.
14’
I. Jano, C. R . Hebd. Seances Acad. Sci., 1965, 261, 103.
149
I . A. Vinokurov, S. Kh. Akopyan, and N. G. Bakhshiev, Vestn. Leningr. Univ.,Fiz.. Khim., 1978,114.
150
I. A. Ar’ev and G . G . Dyadyusha, Teor. Spektrosk., 1977, 25.
”’ A. M. Taleb and H. H. M. Al-Awath, Iraqi J . Sci., 1978, 19, 159.
15’
D. C. Moule, Vib. Spectra Struct., 1977, 6 , 227.
E. A. Gastilovich, K. V. Tskhai, and D. N. Shigorin, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR, 1977, 236, 657.
154 S. 0. Mirumyants and Yu. S. Demchuk, Opt. Spektrosk., 1979, 46, 267.
26 Photochemistry
There have been a number of investigations recently of the effect of high pressures
on the fluorescence properties of molecules (vide infra). A timely paper has re-
examined the theoretical treatment of some earlier published experimental work on
the effect of high pressures (up to 8 GPa) on the absorption, and emission spectra of
anthracene, phenanthrene, and tetracene crystals and various solutions of these
molecules. 5 5 A model, due to Lin, in which the ground- and excited-state
potential functions take the general form given in equation (7), where p is the
I/= E, + : ( f w Z j Q Z j+ c j Q j p ) (7)
A. C. Albrecht in 'Advances in Laser Chemistry', ed. A. Zewail (Springer Series in Chemical Physics),
Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1978, Vol. 3, p. 235.
16'
J . B. Callis, Nat. Bur. Stand. ( U S . ) ,Spec. Publ.. 1977, 466,25.
E. Nodov, Appl. Opt., 1978, 17, 1110.
M. M. Farrow, R. K. Burnham, M. Auzanneau, S. L. Olsen, N . Purdie, and E. M. Eyring, Appl. Opt.,
1978, 17, 1093.
164 C. K. N. Patel and A. C. Tam in 'Laser Spectroscopy IV', ed. H. Walther and K. W. Rother, Springer-
Verlag, Berlin, 1979, p. 646.
165 P. Sladky, R. Danieluis, V. Sirutkaitis, and M. Boudys, Czech. J . Phys., 1977, B27, 1075.
16' F. A. McDonald and G. C. Wetsel, jun., J . Appl. Phys., 1978, 49, 2313.
G. C. Wetsel, jun. and F. A. McDonald, Appl. Phys. Lett., 1977, 30,252.
D. Fournier, A. C. Boccara, and J. Badoz, Appl. Phys. Lett., 1978, 32, 640.
J. Wrobel and M. Vala, Chem. Phys.. 1978, 33, 93.
28 Photochemistry
and non-radiative decay constants. If a separate measurement of the phosphores-
cence quantum yield is available the results taken together will yield a value for the
intersystem-crossing (triplet) quantum yield.
A study of the trace analysis of permanganate ion in aqueous solution has shown
that !aser-induced photoacoustic spectroscopy can detect MnO,- concentrations
as low as 5 x 10- 'moldm- 3, which is a factor of 60 lower than that found by
conventional colorimetric analysis. 7 0 Aspin-flip Raman (SFR) laser was used in a
high-resolution optoacoustic study of the vibrational-rotational transitions in the
2n1,2,2 ~ 3 , 2excited states of NO.i71The study also presented some preliminary
results of optoacoustic Zeeman spectral measurements. Such measurements are
practical because the high sensitivity of the technique makes it possible to use short
(1 cm) path-length cells which can be placed inside the cavity of a superconducting
magnet. The high-resolution spectra of CH,, C2H4, and C,H, have been measured
in the Zeeman displacement region of a He-Ne laser operating at 3.39 pn.1 7 2
In thermal-lensing experiments the heat deposited in the path of a laser beam
passing through an absorbing medium alters the refractive index in such a way as to
produce a divergent lens. The consequent loss of intensity measured by a detector
on the laser-beam axis but downfield from the absorbing medium has proved to be
an extremely sensitive measure of absorption. It has been used to measure ultra-
weak absorptions and as a probe in energy-transfer experiments. In connection
with the latter, recent measurements of the thermal conductivity of C2H4 and
C2H,Cl in an apparatus suitable for energy-transfer measurements gave values
which were in poor agreement with literature values until a relaxation model based
on the laser-beam diameter was introduced.173The discrepancy was traced to
complex Fresnel diffraction patterns produced by the iris in front of the absorption
cell. An example of the use of thermal lensing in energy-transfer studies is in a paper
on the vibrational energy flow in CD3H and its mixtures with SF,, SiF,, and
CF,.174
The important application of the optocoustic method to the measurement of
fluorescence quantum yields will be reported in a later section.
Single-photon Absorption Spectra.-Coverage under this heading is necessarily very
restricted because of the large number of publications that qualify for consider-
ation. Systems of general interest to photochemists have been selected, and, such
that it is, any emphasis is given to excited-state absorption spectra, particularly
triplet-triplet absorption spectra
An interesting review article has considered the impact of dye laser measurement
techniques on the spectroscopy of small molecules. 7 5 The new developments in the
techniques of absorption and emission spectroscopy are discussed and include
those which go beyond the simple measurement of the energies of the eigenstates,
i.e. lifetimes, Lande factors, chemical shifts, collision cross-section, etc. A simple
model for the solvated electron which uses a rectangular potential well with
'lo S. Oda, T. Sawada, and H. Kamada, Bunseki Kuguku, 1978, 27, 269.
C. K. N. Patel, R. J. Kerl, and E. G. Burkhardt, Phys. Rev. Lett., 1977, 38, 1204.
A. B. Antipov and V. A. Sapozhnikova, Zh. Prikl. Spektrosk., 1978, 28, 636.
173
R . T. Bailey, F. R. Cruikshank, D. Pugh, and W. Johnstone, Chem. Phys. Letr., 1978, 59, 324.
174 W. S. Drozdoski, R. D. Bates, jun., and D . R. Siebert, J . Chem. Phys., 1978, 69, 863.
J. C. Lehmann, Rep. Prog. Phys., 1978, 41, 1609.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 29
spherical geometry has been used to interpret its absorption spectrum in a variety of
solvent systems including simple alcohols. 76 Two experimental moments of the
absorption spectrum are used to calculate the two parameters of the model, the well
depth, and its radius, and these in turn are used to calculate a third moment which is
compared with the experimental third moment. The parameters obtained indicated
that for the solvent systems studied the optical transition is bound-free. It was also
shown that the model is compatible with short-range interactions involving only the
first solvation layer. The effect of pressures up to 2.2kbar on the absorption
spectrum of the solvated electron in water and several alcohols has shown that the
relative increase in jmaX with pressure is greater in the alcohols than in water and
that the shifts correlate with increases in the densities of the liquids. 177 The same
authors have also measured the absorption spectra of solvated electrons in water,
several alcohols, and tetrahydrofuran over an extended wavelength range and then
empirically resolved the spectra into two Gaussian bands and a continuum tail. 17*
The alchols, except for t-butyl alcohol, were found to have very similar components
with respect to their half-width and oscillator strengths.
The results of an extensive series of measurements of the charge-transfer-to-
solvent (CTTS) spectrum of the chloride ion in a number of solvents have been
published. 17' The more easily obtained equivalent data for the bromide and iodide
ions were already available in the literature. The chloride-ion spectra are broad and
show none of the doublet splitting which is characteristic for the other halide ions.
For comparison the results for the three ions are summarized in Figure 8, which is a
possible potential-energy diagram for the halide-ion CTTS band spectra. As can be
seen from the figure there are two types of bands present: firstly a low-energy set of
bands, A , B, C , etc., which show the atom doublet 2Pstate splitting to give A ,-A 2,
p 601 E-
D
X
c
g
I
55-
2
Q)
n
5 50.
C
Q,
>
45-
40 -
iodide bromide chloride
Figure 8 Relationship between energy levels for the halides in propionitrile at 298 K
(Reproduced with permission from J . Chem. SOC.,Faraday Trans. I, 1978, 74, 1776)
176
M. De Backer, J.-P. Lelieur, and G. Lepoutre, J . Phys. Chem., 1978,82, 2701.
177
F.-Y. Jou and G. R. Freeman, J . Phys. Chem., 1977, 81, 909.
''13
F.-Y. Jou and G. R . Freeman, Can. J . Chem., 1979, 57, 591.
179
M . F. FOX,B. E. Barker, and E. Hayon, J . Chem. SOC.,Faraday Trans. I , 1978,14, 1776.
30 Photochemistry
B,-B,, etc., and secondly bands D and E which exhibit behaviour that in some
respects is different from that of the first group. The first group has previously been
attributed to s-type electron states, i.e. 1s for the A band, 2s for the B band, etc. The
present authors support the suggestion that the D and E bands correspond to a d-
type solvated electron state. In the theory of CTTS spectra due to Franck and
Platzman (1954) the effect of the solvent on the potential-energy function of the
solvated electron was introduced via the solvent dielectric constant. A new
treatment has been published in which the effect of the solvent dipoles is
included. '8o This results in significantly lower calculated values for the electron-
binding energy. A configuration-mixing model has been very successful in
accounting for the colours and luminescence properties of post-transition-metal
salts in which neither the anion nor the cation is coloured. "' The model uses locally
excited and charge-transfer configurations that, despite building into the model a
number of limitations, d o make it possible to use available experimental data for the
locally excited states of the anion and cation and for the charge-transfer states of the
anion<ation system. The interesting results show that the colour of post-
transition-metal salts, e.g. AgNO,, can be attributed to spin-orbit mixing with, and
intensity borrowing from, charge-transfer transitions of anion-to-metal type. In the
case of light non-transition-metal salts, e.g. NaNO,, the intensity is borrowed from
local excitations. The five generic configuration wave functions are illustrated in
Figure 9, and the transition responsible for the colour is +o + ~ A * .
-
A } +RCT
Reverse
charge transfer
3.
I Locally excited
u }Q
7 locally excited
anion
I
ANION- METAL+
A- M+
Figure 9 An illustration of thefive generic configuration wave functions. The energy scale is
suggestive. The salt is designated A - M for convenience. The upper MO of any pair is the
+
K. Tennakone and R. H . Wijenayake, Natl. Sci. Counc. Sri Lanka, 1977,5, 157.
T. P. Carsey and S. P. McGlynn, J . Am. Chem. Soc., 1979, 101, 1728.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 31
A major investigation of the 'B2" t ' A lg absorption system of benzene vapour
'
has been published. The last major analysis of this band, which is of considerable
theoretical interest as a vibronically induced electric-dipole transition, was that of
Ingold and co-workers in 1946. Since then the work of Callomon, Dunn, and Mills
(1966) on the consequences of vibrational angular momentum and recent single-
vibronic-level (SVL) fluorescence studies have provided the basis for a further
analysis of the spectrum. The present work represents a major advance in the
understanding of the 'BZut ' A lg system, as is evidenced by the fact that over 90%
of the intensity is assigned. To enable them to progress with the analysis the authors
developed a general treatment of vibrational angular momentum in benzene which
makes it possible to predict the rotational-band contour of any vibronic-
component transition and which, they argue, can be applied, after minor
modifications, to determine the extent of vibrational angular momentum effects in
the spectra of other large polyatomic molecules. The vibronically active modes ( v4,
',
v5, v g , v7, vg, vl0, v1 v16, ~ 1 7 and
) the general pattern ofintensities were found to be
similar to those observed in SVL studies. The presence of a number of small and
unidentified perturbations in vibronic levels of 1B2u were seen as variations in the
separation of progression members. The role of the Duschinsky effect, i.e. mode
mixing, on the vibronic intensities in the one- and two-photon spectra of the
' B l u t-' A lg transition in benzene has been considered. 83 The analysis which uses
excited-state normal co-ordinates and not ground-state normal co-ordinates
throughout shows that the Duschinsky effect leads to large asymmetries in the
intensities of coupling modes in the same symmetry species. The vibronic structure
in Jahn-Teller active states of benzene has been analysed. lS4Ithas been attributed
to two Rydberg systems.
The vibronic intensities in the electronic transitions of naphthalene, particularly
for the lowest-energy singlet transition ' B , +- 'Ag,have been calculated using '
a method which has also recently been used for a similar study of benzene. lS6 If
%(g)represents the electronic-transition moment for the nuclei fixed in configur-
ation Q and @ ;) = (i@) IKNQ)), where i@) ) and Ng)) are electronic
I
wavefunctions for the initial and final states and i i s the electric-dipole operator,
then the method involves calculating the l i ( 0 ) ) at a series of selected nuclear
configurations, e.g. along a chosen normal co-ordinate, and using these to calculate
$0) at each of the chosen configurations. The %(Q)results in vibronic intensities
following integration over the vibrational wavefunctions. The success of the
method depends on the quality of the wavefunctions, and in the present study the
CNDO/S CI method was used to calculate them. For one-photon spectra
reasonable agreement was found between experiment and calculation.
A surprising result has been found from a theoretical analysis of bacteriochloro-
phyll a protein's 800nm absorption band and its c.d. spectra.lS7There are pro-
nounced exciton effects in the spectrum of this complex, but its structure is known
G. H. Atkinson and C. S. Parrnenter, J . Mol. Spectrosc., 1978,73,20;ibid., 1978,73,31;ibid; 1978,73,
52.
la'
F. Metz, M . J . Robey, E. W. Schlag, and F. Dorr, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977, 51, 8.
J . Hah, B. Katz, and B. Scharf. Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977, 52, 92.
185
M. J. Robey, I . G. Ross, R. V. Southwood-Jones, and S. J. Strickler, Chem. Phys.. 1977, 23, 207.
L. Ziegler and A. C. Albrecht, J . Chem. Phys., 1974, 60,3558.
IS7
R . M. Pearlstein and R . P. Hemenger, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 1978, 75, 4920.
32 Photochemistry
and calculations of the spectrum based on this structure were found to be
compatible with the usual assignment of the lowest-energy band as Qy (y-
polarized). Good agreement was obtained only if the transition was x-polarized
rather than y-polarized. This may indicate a systematic error in the structural
analysis or a strong environmental perturbation which lowers the energy of an x-
polarized state to below that of Qy.
The cyanocarbene radical HCCN has been produced by photolysis of N,CHCN
'''
in a low-temperature argon matrix. The radical has a linear allenic configuration
in the ground electronic state, where it is a triplet. A structured transition in the U.V.
region has been attributed to a 3Z-3Ctransition involving x-n* excitation because
of its similarities to the corresponding transition in the isoelectronic NCN free
radical. Triplet-triplet (T-T) absorption spectra of simple substituted benzenes in
the gas phase have been measured in the relatively inaccessible region from
'
220-250 nm by modulated absorption spectrophotometry. 89 The first-order non-
radiative and bimolecular quenching rate constants of the triplets were obtained
from studies at different pressures, and an interesting observation was the
remarkable decrease in the non-radiative decay constant upon fluorination and
trifluoromethylation. Related studies of these systems were also undertaken by
laser flash photolysis. 190 A marked broadening of the T-T absorption spectra of a
number of aromatic molecules has been observed in low-temperature matrices
formed by aromatic solvents, e.g. toluene, as compared with those in aliphatic
solvents, e.g. ethanol.19' A strong dependence of the broadening on the triplet
energy of the solute has been interpreted as evidence for a strong resonance
exchange interaction between the triplet states of the solvent and solute.
A very interesting tandem laser pulse absorption experiment on naphthalene in
the vapour phase has clearly shown the time evolution of the 3B,, t 'B,,, triplet
absorption spectrum from a broad, structured, and unrelaxed form to a narrow
featureless band familiar from previous studies of naphthalene. '92 In the experi-
ment a short laser pulse initiates triplet formation and the absorption is probed at
well defined delay times by a second scanning pulsed laser. The T-T absorption
'
spectra of 1,2- and 1,8-dinitronaphthalene, 93 4-nitro-ar-naphthylamine, 194 and 3-
'
nitropyrene 9 5 have been observed in laser flash photolysis experiments. The
electronic transition energies for the T-T absorption and the phosphorescence of
1,l'-binaphthyl calculated by the PPP CI method were in agreement with
'
experimental observations, 96 and the polarizations of the T-T absorption bands
of diphenylacetylene have been determined from measurements in stretched
polymer films at liquid-nitrogen temperatures. 1 9 7 The rates of the internal
conversion and intersystem-crossing decay routes of the first excited singlet of the
fluorescent aza-aromatic acridine have been obtained by measurement of the rate of
la' A. Dendramis and G . E. Leroi, J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 66,4334.
M . E. Sime and D . Phillips, Chem. Phys. Lett.. 1978, 56, 138.
I9O R. Bonneau, M, E. Sime, and D . Phillips, J . Phorochem., 1978, 8, 239.
19' M. F. Alfimov, V. 1. Gerko, L. S. Popov, and V . F. Razumov, Chem. Phys. L e f t . , 1977. 50, 398.
19* H. Schriider, H. J . Neusser, and E. W. Schlag, Chem. Phys. Letr., 1978, 54, 4.
193 C. Capellos and K . Suryanarayanan, i n [ . J . Chem. Kinet., 1977, 9, 399.
194 C. Capellos and F. Lang, Int. J . Chem. Kinet., 1971, 9, 409.
'95 R . Scheerer and A, Henglein, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem., 1977, 81, 1234.
'96 J. Suehnel, K. Gustav, and U . P. Wild, Z . Chem., 1978, 18, 387.
19' T. Hoshi, K. Ota, J . Yoshino, K . Murofushi, and Y . Tanizaki, Chem. Lett., 1977, 357.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 33
T-T absorption growth on a picosecond time-scale. 19' The results were interpreted
to give an n.11C assignment to the first excited singlet state and to indicate the
presence of an important internal conversion process.
Triplet states of N-methyl-2-N-phenylamino-6-naphthalenesulphonate (1 ; N-
methyl ANS) and its C-protonated form, the N-methylbetaine of 6-sulfonato-3/3-
tetralenone N-phenylimine (2), have been produced by laser flash photolysis and
shown not to interconvert either in glycerol or in dioxan-water at 25 "C.199 This
- \ /
fJYJ"0
\
H H
/
yH3
/
03s 03s
(1) (2)
19' V. Sundstrom, P. M . Rentzepis, and E. C. Lim, J . Chem. Phjs., 1977, 66, 4287.
lYy H. Dodnik, E. M . Kosower, M. Ottolenghi, and N. Orbach, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977, 49, 174.
zoo R . Bonneau and P. Fornier de Violet, C. R . Acud. Sci. Ser. C , 1977, 284,631.
2 0 1 V. E. Korobov and A. K . Chibisov, J . Phorochem.. 1978, 9, 411.
'02
B. Veryat, S. G . Davis, M . Yoshida, and K . Weiss, J . Am. Chem. SOC.,1978, 100, 3283.
*03 D . E. Edmondson, F. Riuuto, and G. Tollin, Photochem. Photobiol., 1977, 25, 445.
'04 R. S. Becker, R. V. Bensasson, J. Lafferty, T. G . Truscott, and E. J . Land, J . Chem. SOC.,Furuduy
Trans. 2, 1978, 74, 2246.
34 Photochemistry
Table 2s Triplet-triplet extinction coeficients and quantum eficiencies of
production of the lowest triplet (aT,) for carbonylpolyenes in hexane"
(ieXc = 265nm)
Ex tinction coeflcien t
Carbonylpolyenes A,,,/nm E T,/dm3 mol - cm - @TI
/?-Ionone (C, J 330 85 300 0.10
8-Ionylidene acetaldehyde (C, 5 ) 385 38 500 0.42
trans-Retinal (C20) 445 78 000 0.40
/?-Apo-l4carotenal (C22) 470 127 000 0.41
B-Apo-8'-carotenal (C30) 520 223 000 0.003
Torularhodinaldehyde (C40) 580 363 000 0.001
a ~ T and
, QT, are considered to be correct to f 15%.
(a) (b)
Figure 10 Two-photon processes for an N + 2 level system, showing (a) two-photon
absorption and (b) the Raman process
(Reproduced with permission from Phys. Rep., 1978, 43,455)
205 J. McVie, R. S. Sinclair, and T. G. Truscott, J. Chem. SOC.,Faraday Trans. 2, 1978, 74, 1870.
*06 A Schenzle and R. G. Brewer, Phys. Rep., 1978, 43, 456.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 35
for the related Raman process, Figure lob. The N intermediate transitions are
regarded as far off resonance, and the systems are assumed to be homogeneously
broadened. Although the general problem cannot be solved analytically an effective
Hamiltonian is derived which is equivalent to a two-level quantum problem, and
the application of perturbation theory leads then to a continued fraction expansion,
the leading terms of which agree with earlier treatments. As an example of the
application of new non-perturbative solutions to the problem, which unlike
perturbative solutions can account for intensity-dependent dephasing, the authors
consider the Raman beat effect in which a transient forward scattering is observed
from a system represented by Figure lob, in which 1 and 2 are initially degenerate,
but which is subjected to a Stark pulse that lifts the degeneracy. An important paper
has considered the theory of two-photon absorption by gas-phase molecules. 207 A
new theory is presented which includes the effects of rotation within the rigid rotor
approximation and which leads to general formulae for the transition probabilities,
W , between rovibronic states. The latter contain three terms which, as in Raman
theory, are derived from the isotropic and the antisymmetric and symmetric
anisotropic tensor components. For the case of a symmetric rotor each of these
terms splits into three factors: W = C&&, + C , M , R , + C2M,R2,where the
C j are geometrical factors which reflect the initial polarization of the incoming
photon in relation to the rotating molecules, the M,-are molecular factors arising
from the two-photon absorption tensor, and the R,- are rotational factors which
describe the projection of the tensor on the rotational states. The calculations are
more difficult for the asymmetric rotor case as the projection of the total angular
momentum along the top axis is no longer conserved. Thus the factorization into R,-
and Myis no longer possible, but the resulting expression still contains three terms
each with the same geometrical factor as in the corresponding term in the above
equation. An important feature of the new theory is that it accounts for
experimental observations of different polarization behaviour for different rota-
tional branches within the same vibronic band. This effect does not occur in either
one-photon absorption spectroscopy or in the two-photon spectra of non-rotating
molecules, but the above expression for W shows that it is a quite general
phenomenon requiring only two non-zero terms in the equation. The paper
concludes by presenting model calculations of the band contour of a two-photon
transition in the asymmetric rotor naphthalene, a result of which is shown in Figure
11, and it is emphasized that such calculations are as straightforward as those for
one-photon band contours.
A discussion of two-photon absorption in crystals shows that it is possible, quite
generally, to determine the symmetry properties of the excited states if it is possible
to have one or both of the beams circularly polarized. 2 0 8 The theoretical treatment
factorizes the absorption coefficient into dynamical factors containing matrix
elements of the momentum operator and geometrical factors which depend on the
polarization directions of linearly polarized light and on the propagation vectors of
circularly polarized light. The geometrical factors for several point groups are
presented in Tables la and lb.
207 F. Metz, W. E. Howard, L. Wunsch, H. J. Neusser, and E. W. Schlag, Proc. R . SOC.London, Ser. A ,
1978, 343, 381.
2n8 E. Doni, R . Girlanda, and G. Pastori Parravicini, Phys. Status Solidi B, 1978, 88, 773.
36 Photochemistry
High-resolution two-photon absorption (TPA) spectroscopic studies, usually
under Doppler-free conditions, are carried out by detecting the fluorescence
emitted by the two-photon excited state, the absorption itself usually being too
31
I I I
0 7.5 0 -25 -15.0
Relative excitation energy / c m - l
Figure 11 Computed band contour of an as two-photon transition in naphthalene, h, at 300K
for two linear photons wirh values M,, = 0, M y , = 0.1, and M,, = 0.9
(Reproduced with permission from Proc. R . SOC.London, Ser. A , 1978, 363, 381)
211 S. H. Lin and H. Eyring, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 1977, 74, 3105.
'I2 M. M. T. Loy and D. Grischkowsky, Opt. Commun., 1977, 21;379.
213 V. P. Kaflandjian and L. Klein, Phys. Lett. A , 1977, 62, 317.
J . B. Gruber, E. D. Larson, D. N. Olsen, and T. R. Stoner, Proc. N . D. Acad. Sci., 1978, 31, 218.
215 H. Sekiya, S. Tsunekawa, K. Nishikawa, and A. Sado, Sci. Rep. Kanazawa Univ., 1977, 22, 21.
'I6 M. Kolwas, J . Phys. B, 1977, 10, 583.
217 D. P. Hodgkinson and J. S. Briggs, Opt. Commun., 1977, 22, 45.
38 Photochemistry
approximation shows, amongst other things, conditions where an effective
saturation between the first and third levels may be achieved, with the intermediate
level acting as a virtual state only. The new features of atomic absorption revealed
by the use of coherent light sources have been discussed, and a mechanism for
determining the phase of Doppler-free coherent atomic absorption amplitudes was
identified. ”*
A quantum-mechanical calculation has demonstrated the high probability of
two-photon absorption by light emitted in a two-photon spontaneous decay
process relative to light from ordinary sources, a result which one expects
intuitively. ” A theory of the absorption lineshape on two-photon excitation of a
two-level system has confirmed an experimental observation that negative absorp-
tion, i.e. amplification, without a population inversion can be achieved when the
probability of two-photon excitation is sufficiently high. ’O The observations lead
to a method to generate the third-harmonic frequencies of lasers, and model
calculations are performed for the tripling of the 778.4 nm line of sodium vapour.
The limitations of a perturbation theory approach to the problem of the coherent
propagation of a circularly polarized pulse that is two-photon quasi-resonant with
a medium of multilevel atoms are exposed in a paper which uses multiphoton
coherent excitation theory in the adiabatic following limit ’”
(see reference 212).
The resonance fluorescence excitation spectrum of a two-level atom in a radiation
field whose frequency corresponds to nearly half the level separation has been
shown to consist of four Lorentzian lines: a central line peaked near the two-photon
resonance with a lower- and a higher-frequency sideband and the one-photon
frequency mode. ”’
An interesting paper has examined both experimentally and
theoretically the dependence of the degree of polarization of luminescence on the
frequency difference between the two photons absorbed in the two-photon
excitation process. 2 2 3 The effect arises mainly from the antisymmetric part of the
two-photon transition tensor, and it was demonstrated in glycerin solutions
of 1,3,5-triphenylpyrazoline, 1-phenyl-3-[acenaphthyl( 5)]-5-[fluorenyl(2)-]-A2-
pyrazoline, 4-formylamino-N-methylphthalimide, and 3-aminophthalimide.
A number of general and review articles on two-photon spectroscopy have been
published. A useful general account of the basic physics of two-photon absorption
is contained in an article on two-photon molecular spectroscopy in liquids and
gases. 2 2 4 A full quantum-mechanical treatment for gaseous symmetric-rotor
systems is presented that explicitly contains rotational effects (see reference 207).
Unlike the situation in condensed media it is not possible to predict correctly the
two-photon behaviour of gaseous systems by averaging the single-molecule result
against an orientational distribution function. The theoretical treatment is based on
an irreducible representation of the two-photon transition tensor which may be
utv
:?z
Xu ~ ' = 2 2j'=L9
. ( A1 * I
l +
~ " = 2 , j " = 5 (0X I,)
'. The OH-
*
Figure 12 Level scheme of the Na, two-photon transition at vJc = 16 601.88 cm-
resonance A = 936 ( 25) MHz
(Reproduced with permission from Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977, 50, 41)
24'
M . M. Salour, Ann. Phys. ( N . Y . ) , 1978, 111, 364.
14'
R. Wallenstein and H. Zacharias, Opt. Commun.. 1978, 25, 363.
243
M . Asscher and Y. Hass, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 59, 231.
244 G. F. Nutt, S. C. Haydon, and A. I . McIntosh, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1979, 62,402.
245 Y. Takubo, S. Hasegawa, and M. Shimazu, Jpn. J . Appl. Phys., 1977, 16, 1697.
246
P. A. Freedman, Can J . Phys., 1977, 55, 1387.
247
H. Jones, J . Mol. Spectrosc., 1978, 70, 279.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 41
shown that in the classical limit (J -+ a,a good approximation for J > 10) the
polarization behaviour is independent of the electronic symmetries and can be
different for the cases A % AvD and A x AvD (where A v D is the Doppler width)
owing to velocity tuning. 248 The effect of the near-resonant intermediate level in
Na, on the relative strengths of the Doppler-free and Doppler-broadened two-
photon absorptions has also been investigated.249
An interesting observation of two-photon excited fluorescence from the satu-
rated hydrocarbons cyclohexane, decalin, and n-pentadecane has been made. 250 A
pulsed N, laser was used for excitation, and the fluorescence spectra and lifetimes
found in the study were in good agreement with results from previous one-photon
studies. The authors estimated that 0.1 % of the laser energy was absorbed in 1 cm of
the solvents, and this should clearly be of concern to workers in this area. A recent
paper has suggested that an intense broad feature observed in the two-photon
thermal-lens spectrum of liquid benzene around 200nm does not arise as was
recently suggested from the E , valence state but is a direct two-photon excitation
into the conduction band of the l i q ~ i d . ~A" high-resolution study of the TPA
spectrum of benzene crystals in the 530400 nm region has been published. 2 5 2 The
spectra can be related to benzene molecules of approximately Cul symmetry. The
work has provided values for the two-photon tensors associated with each of the
vibronic transitions. The 1 cm- resolution two-photon excitation spectra of [ 'Ha]-
and [2H8]-toluenevapours in the region of the ' B , t ' A , transition have been
measured. 2 5 3 Ain~previous studies of benzene and its derivatives a large fraction of
the intensity occurs in a subsystem induced by an out-of-phase C-C stretch vI4(b2).
The two-photon excitation spectra of the lowest 'Bzustate of ['Hgl- and ['HJ-
naphthalene at 4.2 K have been analysed, and they show that a b,, vibration is the
most prominent perturbing vibration in the excited state and that it is also
important in the vibronic coupling between the ground and lowest ( 'Bh) excited
state. 2 5 4 The fluorescence spectrum of naphthalene vapour under collision-free
conditions has been measured following excitation into the strongest band of its
two-photon excitation spectrum. 255 The spectrum exhibits vibrational structure
superimposed on a strong non-resolved background, and it is suggested that the
background arises from further excitation of the two-photon excited state by
the strong radiation field. In contrast to naphthalene where the transition to the
lowest electronic state ' B , (Lb)is one-photon allowed but two-photon forbidden,
the transition in phenanthrene to the lowest 'A electronic state is both one- and
two-photon allowed. The one- and two-photon spectra of phenanthrene crystal at
4.2 K have been compared and show the expected one-to-one correspondence for
all the main vibronic bands.256There are, however, differences in the relative
intensities of the vibronic bands in the two spectra.
I .I
0.9
0.7
0.5
0.3
0.50, . ..
34400 36000 3cm 30000 42000 44000
T o t a l Encrgy/crn-l
Figure 13 (a) Upperplots. The dots are data points for the TIPE spectrum of stilbene (linearly
polarized excitation). F = sample fluorescence intensity; I = laser intensity. The ordinate
values have been multiplied by a constant before plotting (left scale). Vertical lines through the
dots indicate a change of dye in the dye laser. The solid line is the one-photon absorption
spectrum of stilbene ( 5 x solution, 1 mmpath) in units of optical density (right scale).
Positions of the A and B bands of the one-photon absorptionspectrum are indicated. (b)Lower
plot. Two-photonpolarization ratio spectrum of stilbene. R is thejuorescence intensity excited
by circularlypolarized light divided by thefluorescence intensity excited by linearlypolarized
light
(Reproduced with permission from J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 66,4540)
257
T. M. Stachelek, T. A. Pazoha, W. M. McClain, and R. P. Drucker, J . Chem. Phys., 1917,66,4540.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 43
diphenylhexatriene (DPH) in an ether-isopentane-ethanol (EPA) glass matrix at
77K has located the origin of the 'A,-'A, two-photon allowed transition at
25 050cm- ', some 990cm- ' below the origin of the lowest one-photon allowed
'B,- 'A, transition. 2 5 8 A study of all-trans 1,3,5,7-octatetraene in n-octane at 4.2 K
has clearly established that the lowest-energy excited singlet state has even parity,
confirming its 'A, assignment, 2 5 9 and measurements of the two-photon excitation
spectrum of all-tram diphenyloctatetraene in EPA glass at 77 K have identified the
origin of the lowest-energy 'A, t 'A, transition at 22 360cm- approximately ',
'
2000cm- below the origin of the one-photon allowed 'B, t ' A , transition.260
The phosphorescence-detected two-photon excitation spectrum of triphenylene in
n-heptane single crystals at 1.6 K has been used to assign 'A'' and ' A ' , symmetry,
respectively, to the S,and S , states, in contradiction with earlier work. 2 6 1 The two-
photon absorption cross-section of the dye 7-hydroxycoumarine (umbelliferone) in
an ethanol solution has been estimated to be (7.9 f 3.9) x 10-50cm4s per
photon molecule at 60814 nm. 2 6 2
An interesting study of two-photon absorption in u.v.-transmitting materials has
been published .263 Absolute TPA coefficients were measured for a number of alkali
halides and a number of widely used harmonic-generating materials at 355 and
266nm. Amongst other things it was noted that for the alkali halides the TPA
coefficients at 355 nm were larger than those at 266 nm.
Multiphoton Absorption Processes.-A number of papers relevant to this heading
are discussed in the section on laser-induced processes. A volume of invited lectures
on multiphoton processes has been published which effectively serves as a review of
the subject. 264 The topics covered include quantum electrodynamics, resonance
fluorescence, atomic and molecular multiphoton processes, coherence and reson-
ance effects, and the relatively new subject of collisions in the presence of intense
fields. A quantum-mechanical formalism for the treatment of temporal atomic and
molecular coherence in multiphoton absorption has been published. 2 6 5
Multiphoton transitions can be conveniently divided into two categories dependent
on whether or not there are 'near resonances' in intermediate states, and the present
paper treats the case where there is no intermediate resonance. The theory provides
a basis for understanding certain features of the effects of high-intensity laser
radiation that are not compatible with kinetic equations and that arise because of a
partial coherence between the laser electric field and the electric dipoles of the
relevant absorber. In such cases it is not possible to average simply over the phases
to compute a transition rate. The treatment in the paper leads to the derivation of
multiphoton Bloch equations. Examples of the coherence effects that have been
observed are line-splitting in resonance fluorescence and ionization, isotopic
selectivity in photodissociation, and the oversaturation effect. The treatment of
258 H. L.-B. Fang, R. J. Thrash, and G. E. Leroi, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 57, 59.
259
M. F. Granville, G . R. Holtom, B. E. Kohler, R. L. Christensen, and K. L. D'Amico, J . Chem. Phys.,
1977, 70, 593.
260 H . L.-B. Fang, R. J. Thrush, and G. E. Leroi, J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 67, 3389.
261
A. M. Merle, A. Campion, and M. A. El-Sayed, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 57, 496.
262
L. Parma and N . Omenetto, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 54, 541.
263 P. Liu, W. L. Smith, H. Lotem, J. H. Bechtel, and N . Bloembergen, Phys. Rev. B, 1978, 17, 4620.
264 'Multiphoton Processes', ed. J. H. Eberley and P. Lambropoulos, Wiley, New York, 1978.
"' P. W. Milonni and J. H. Eberly, J . Chem. Phys., 1978, 68, 1602.
44 Photochemistry
thermal perturbations in multiphoton interactions has been discussed. 2 6 6 The
analogous problems in single-photon spectroscopy are well known, namely
pressure-broadening in gas-phase studies and phonon effects in solid-state studies,
and it is usual to make one of two approximations depending on the relative time-
scales of the optical and thermal processes. If the optical process is much the shorter
of the two the statistical limit is assumed, and if it is much longer than the thermal
process the impact approximation is made. The paper establishes criteria for the
proper application of the impact limit to the calculation of multiphoton transition
rates. Reduced equations of motion have been derived for strongly driven simple
quantum systems which are modulated stochastically by coupling to a bath. 2 6 7 The
equations were applied to two examples: a randomly modulated and driven
harmonic oscillator and a modulated and damped two-level system. The effective
photon concept has been shown to predict qualitatively a number of features of
multiphoton absorption, including isotope selectivity.2 6 8 The distribution of
excited states and the average excitation level of anharmonic molecules in CW laser
beams has been considered. 269 Previous treatments have generally considered the
case of pulsed-laser excitation and V-V, V-R, and V-T energy-transfer processes,
but this present study considers either relaxation effects including diffusion and
convection. The solutions to Schrodinger’s equation for model N-level atoms and
molecules in monochromatic radiation fields have been studied numerically. 270 A
number of regularities and near-regularities were found in the population
dynamics. The following paper considers multiphoton absorption problems which
have exact solutions for the iime-dependent populations, and these are related to
observations in the numerical studies.
Linear Dichroism.-An interesting and timely collection of papers on linear
dichroism spectroscopy, most of which have appeared elsewhere in the literature,
has been published. 2 7 1 There is a continuing growth of interest in the application of
the principles of linear dichroism to studies of molecular dynamics, where the
complementary method of fluorescence emission polarization is already well
established, and in electronic spectroscopy where its use has a long but rather
limited history. In particular in recent years linear dichroism studies, often in
combination with magnetic circular dichroism studies, have made significant
contributions to the understanding of the electronic spectroscopy of a number of
important molecules, particularly aromatic hydrocarbons (vide infra). In part the
growth in interest can be attributed to the availability of new instrumental
techniques, especially those based on the photoelastic modulator, and to a sound
basis for the interpretation of the results, especially for the widely used stretched-
film method, but in general it probably simply reflects a growing recognition of the
266 A Nitzan, S. Mukamel, and A . Ben-Reuven, Chem. Phys., 1977, 24, 37.
267 S. Mukamel, I . Oppenheim, and J. Ross, Phys. Rev. A , 1978, 17, 1988.
N . S. Nogar, Spectrosc. Lett., 1978, 11, 243.
269 B. Steverding, H . P. Dudel, and F. P. Gibson, J . Appl. Phys., 1978, 49, 1260.
270 ( u ) J . H. Eberly, B. W. Shore, Z . Bialynicka-Birula, and I . Bialynicki-Birula, Phys. Rev. A , 1977, 16,
2038; (6) Z. Bialynicka-Birula, I. Bialynicki-Birula, J. H . Eberly, and B. W. Shore, Phys. Rev. A , 1977,
16, 2048.
27’
‘Proceedings of the Nobel Workshop in Lund, October 25-27, 1976, on Molecular Optical Dichroism
and Chemical Applications of Polarized Spectroscopy’, ed. B. Norden, Lund University Press, Lund,
1977. (See also Spectrosc. Lett., 1977, 10)
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 45
value of such studies. The papers in the Workshop Proceedings 271concernboth the
experimental and theoretical aspects of the subject. The applications of linear
dichroism spectroscopy have also been reviewed elsewhere 272 as has the use of
linear and circular dichroism studies in the vacuum ultraviolet region.273The
application of the piezo-optical birefringence modulator to the measurement of
Stokes parameters has been described, and it has been,illustrated by a number of
experiments. 274
An important paper has provided a theoretical basis for some basic well defined
photoselection studies for cases where high-intensity laser excitation is used. 75 For
optically thin samples general expressions are derived for the dichroic ratios of the
probe-beam absorbance for molecules having different transition-moment sym-
metries, i.e. linear, planar, or isotropic, for the cases both of steady state and of
pulsed excitation. For the limit of low excitation levels the familiar limiting values
of the dichroic ratio are recovered; e.g. for the case of the steady-state or 'long-
pulse' bleaching of parallel linear absorbers the dichroic ratio D is given by equation
(8), which for the case of low excitation intensities, a 4 1 (ais a dimensionless
2[a(3a)* - + arctan(3a)bI
(3a*
D =
2a(3a)* + (3a)* + (3a + l)arctan(3a)*
parameter equal to Imopz, where Imisthe mean excitation intensity, opthe molecular
cross-section at the excitation wavelength, and z the electronic relaxation time),
reduces to equation (9), which has the familiar limit of 3. For perpendicular
D =
("7"
+
3 I-- ... , (9)
absorbers the low excitation limit yields the expected value of !4. The variation of D
with a for 'long-pulse' excitation of linear and other symmetries is shown in Figure
14. Perhaps the most interesting result in this paper is a derivation that shows it is
possible to distinguish between transition-moment symmetries in molecules and the
different saturation behaviour of their absorbances when working with optically
thick samples. Ground-state depletion experiments using picosecond laser exci-
tation are described which distinguish the linear absorber, cryptocyanine, from the
planar absorber, gallium phthalocyanine chloride. The time dependence of
photoselection in systems where there is no rotational motion of the excited
chromophores during their lifetimes has been discussed. 276 The changes in the
photoselection due to energy-transfer processes in the limit of weak interactions is
considered, and it is suggested that it may be advantageous to measure time-
dependent photoselection rather than the anisotropy in certain situations. Studies
of laser-induced birefringence in dye solutions 277 and of a new laser method to
measure such effects 278 have been reported. A valuable paper has provided a
272
B. Norden, Appl. Spectrosc. Rev., 1978, 14, 157.
273 A. F. Drake and S. F. Mason, J . Phys. (Paris), Colloq., 1978, 212.
2'4 A. J. Wojtowicz and H. J. Lozykowski, Acta Phys. Poi. A , 1978, 54, 867.
275
B. Magde, J . Chem. Phys., 1978, 68, 3717.
276
F. Tanaka and N . Mataga, Photochem. Photobiol., 1979, 29, 1091.
277
A. M. Borch-Bruevits, T. K. Razumova, and I. 0. Starobogatov, Opt. Spektrosc., 1978, 44, 957.
278 J. J. Song, J. H. Lee, and M. D. Levenson in 'Laser Spectroscopy 111' (Springer Ser. Opt. Sci), Vol. 7,
1977, p. 450.
46 Photochemistry
completely general treatment of the time-dependent relaxation behaviour of a
monodisperse system of arbitrarily shaped rigid bodies, after initial alignment by an
externally applied field e.g. in a Kerr cell. 279 It is shown that the decay of the linear
>I
9.
0.4 - -- ...
.. .
L
0
.-cnc
\
0.2
I 1 1 I I I I
-2 -1 0 1 2 3
l o g a(
Figure 14 The anisotropy A seen by a probe beam S, related to the induced dichroism D by
+
A = ( D - 1)/(D l ) , as a function of excitation level afor long-pulse or continuous-wave
illumination. Four absorber symmetries are distinguished: --- parallel S and P linear
absorbers, -.-- perpendicular linear absorbers, * * coplanar plane absorbers, either
~
absorber isotropic
(Reproduced with permission from J . Chem. Phys., 1978,68, 3717)
that the detected polarization makes with the axis perpendicular to the excitation
beam is 35.25" and where R and D are the average rotational and dipole strengths,
respectively, AA is the difference between left and right circularly polarized
absorbance, and A is the absorbance. The values in the brackets in the expression
can be obtained from separate measurehents of the CD and absorption spectra of
the sample, and therefore as a test of the theory 8," was measured as a function of
both wavelength and the polarizer angle, with good agreement expected when the
latter was 35.25'. The results for solutions of lo-[2H]camphorsulphonic acid in
glycerol are shown in Figure 15, and the agreement between theory and experiment
is seen to be good. An important potential application of the method is in the study
of local conformations in macromolecules, and the paper reports that preliminary
measurements have resulted in a value for 4R/D of the single tryptophan residue in
human-serum albumin accurate to +30%, which is clearly enough at least to
determine its sign. There is, however, apparently a serious artifact problem when
using the technique. An FDCD study of the uranyl ions in Na[UO,(MeCOO),] has
also been published. 300
The application of phase-modulation spectroscopy to the measurement of
circular dichroism in the presence of strong linear dichroism, as is found in
anisotropic single crystals such as the A( + ),-tris(ethylenediamine)cobalt(III)
complex, has been discussed. CD and ORD studies of biological systems in an
293 J. Applequist, K . R . Sundberg, M . L. Olson, and L. C. Weiss, J . Chem. Phys., 1979, 70, 1240.
294 A. Traspaderne and F. Castano, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 56, 318.
295 D. Caldwell, Proc. SOC.Photo.-Opt. Instrum. Eng., 1977, 112, 138.
29b G . Snatzke, Angew. Chem., 1979,91, 380.
29'
D. H. Turner, Methods Enzymol., 1978, 49, 199.
298
E. W. Lobenstine, and D. H . Turner, J . Am. Chem. SOC.,1979, 101, 2205.
299 I. Tinoco, jun.,B. Ehrenberg, and I. Z. Steinberg, J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 66, 916.
300 K. Murata, Y. Yamazaki, and M. Morita, J . Lumin., 1979, 18/19,407.
30r H. P. Jensen, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977, 52, 559.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 49
electric field have been reviewed,302 and a microscopic and macroscopic description
of changes in the polarization state of light on passing through gases and liquids has
been developed which is based on the behaviour of the Stokes parameters. 3 0 3 There
I
i I I 1 I i I
t
z
,
I
0-
ou-
Q)
-
-0.2 -
-
-0.4 -
-
-0.6 -
-0.0 -
I I 1 I I I I I 1
x /nm
Figure 15 Photoselected FDCD spectra of 0.43 M 10-d-camphorsulphonic acid in glycerol:
(-) Q, = O", (---) Q, = 35", (--.--.) Q, = 90", (x) spectrum predicted from c.d. and
adsorption spectra. Base-line solution was 1.O x M DL-tryptophan in water. Filter was
Corning 4-72 and cell path length was 1 m m
(Reproduced with permission from J . Am. Chem. SOC.,1979, 101, 2205)
'I5
J. Michl, J . Am. Chem. Sor., 1978, 100, 6812.
3'h J. Michl, J . Am. Chem. SOL..,1978, loQ, 6819.
317 N. H. Joergensen, P. B. Pedersen, E. W. Thulstrup, and J . Michl, Int. J . Quantum Chem..Symp.. 1978,
12, 419.
31H ( a ) E. W.Thulstrup,J. Mol. Structure. 1978,47,359; ( b )E. W. Thulstrup, f n t .J . Quantum Chem.. 1977,
12 (Supplement I ) , 333.
"' S. T. Lee, Y . H. Loon, H. Eyring, and S. H . Lin, J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 66, 4349.
320 P. N . Schatz, R . L. Mowery, and E. R. Krausz, Mol. Phys., 1978, 35, 1537.
Table 4 Sign of (AHOMO - AL,UMOy for uncharged-perimeter soft chromophores
Subst ituent efec ts
-~
Odd-Soft D - + - t
r,
P2
h
.2
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 53
suitable for MCD and MCPL studies has been described.321The application of
MCD and electrochromism studies to investigations of molecular Rydberg states
has been discussed.322
Stark and Related Effects.-An interesting area of application for studies of the
electric-field-inducedchanges in the absorption and emission spectra of molecules,
i.e. the molecular Stark effect known as electrochromism, is the monitoring of
membrane potential with dye-molecule probes. The studies are complicated by the
possibility of several different mechanisms for changes in the spectral properties of
the optical probes; for example there may be a potential-dependent partition of the
dye between either the cell interior and the external medium or the membrane and
the external medium, there is the possibility of a potential-dependent dimerization
within the membrane, and finally there is the possibility of a direct response to a
local potential which develops subsequent to energization. The above mechanisms
have been variously invoked to account for a wide range of observations with a
variety of probe-membrane systems. There are very few cases, if any at all, where
the electrochromism mechanism has been shown to be dominant. A recent paper
has discussed the desirable features of an electrochromic probe.323 Extended
Hiickel (EH) MO calculations were used to calculate the change in the charge
distribution for the HOMO-LUMO transition in the chromophore which,
following self-consistent charge calculations in which the fixed EH parameters are
re-adjusted, :i used to calculate the electrochromism from the simple equation_
hAv = - qS'.E,where q is charge, 7 the distance it migrates upon excitation, and E
the electric field. The authors have identified a promising charge-shift chromophore
-
for electrochromism studies, namely the 4-@-aminostyryl)pyridinium cation
which, for a typical membrane electric-field strength of lo5Vcm- ',has predicted
Av of 24 cm- '. For the probe (3), 4-(4-dipentylaminostyryl)-l-methylpyridinium
iodide (di-5-ASP), which has a peak absorbance at 500nm, this frequency shift
-
(3)
corresponds to a shift of 0.6 nm or an OD change at 500 nm of 1.3%, both of
which are easily detectable changes. For molecular electronic transitions in which
there is no change in dipole moment on going from the ground to the excited
electronic state electrochromic effects may arise from differences in the ground- and
excited-state polarizabilities, i.e. from induced dipole moments. The discrepancies
between observed and calculated values of these polarizability changes for a
number of aromatic hydrocarbons have been discussed.324Acritical comparison of
sixteen equations in the literature which have been proposed to express the shifts in
the absorption and emission maxima of molecules in solution on changing the
solvent, i.e. solvatochromism, has been published. 3 2 5 In these equations the
321 E. R. Krausz, R. L. Mowery, and P. N. Schatz, Ber. Bunsenges Phys. Chem., 1978, 82, 134.
322 J. D. Scott, W. S. Felps, and S . P. McGlynn, Nucl. Instrum. Methods, 1978, 152, 231.
323 L. M. Loew, G. W. Bonneville, and J. Surow, Biochemistry, 1978, 17,4065.
324 G. Barnett, Int. J. Quantum Chem., 1977, 12, 427.
325 B. Koutek, Collect. Czech. Chem. Commun.. 1978, 43,2368.
54 Photochemistry
solvents are characterized by their dielectric constant and their refractive index. The
experimental data for compounds with a wide range of excited-state dipole
moments, p, were used as a basis for the comparison, and the results were also
compared with values for peobtained from separate electro-optical experiments. A
theory proposed by Bilot, Kawski, and Bakhshiev was found to be the most
satisfactory.
The electronic properties of the 2'A state of methylene (attention is usually
focused on the 3 B , and ' A states - vide supra) have been calculated using MCSCF
and extended CI wavefunctions. 3 2 6 The dipole moments in the two ' A states were
calculated for different non-linear geometries. Calculations of the dipole moment
functions of the a3nand A ' n states 3 2 7 and the d 3 Aand states 3 2 8 of CO have
been published, the latter being in good agreement with available experimental
data. A study of the electrochromism spectrum of the 174.9nm transition in
formaldehyde supports the assignment of the excited state as the 3s(a,) +-- n(b,),
B , +- A molecular Rydberg. 329 The dipole moment in the excited state was found
to be much smaller than in the ground state. An interesting paper has used a visible-
dye laser in a laser-Stark spectroscopy study of the 2 * A 2 - X ' A' transition in
thioformaldehyde. 330 Measurements in the 401vibronic band yielded a value of
0.79 0.04 D for the excited-state dipole moment, which compares with a value of
1.56 f 0.07 D for the corresponding state in H,CO. Strong structural: features
have been observed in the electrochromic spectrum of benzene embedded in
polymer sheets,331and similar dipole-moment changes on excitation to the lowest
' n e and 3n71* excited states of p-methylbenzaldehyde and p-chlorobenzaldehyde
have been found in studies of the Stark splittings in the phosphorescence excitation
and phosphorescence spectra of these compounds in a p-dimethoxybenzene host
crystal.332 The results in the latter, study are contrary to the predictions of
qualitative arguments and may indicate a strong mixing of the 'n7ic and 37r7Pstates.
The effect of vibronic coupling between 3ncP and 3n7P states on the dipole moments
in the triplet states of aromatic aldehydes has been discussed. 3 3 3 The excited-state
dipole moments of various nitrobenzene derivatives have been obtained from MO
calculations and studies of solvatochromic effects.334 The results were used to
compare critically a number of theoretical expressions for solvatochromism (see
reference 325). Dipole moments for a number of exciplexes formed between
heterocyclic compounds and aromatic hydrocarbons and amines have been
obtained from measurements of the solvent shifts of their emission bands,335and
accurate excited-state dipole moments for several exciplexes of 9,l O-di-
cyanoanthracene and NN-dimethylaniline have been obtained from emission
electrochromism studies. 3 3 6 An interesting study of the dipole moments in the
326 C. W. Bauschlicher, jun. and D. R . Yarkony, J . Chem. Phys., 1978.69, 3875.
3'7 J . M . Norbreck, R . R. Merkel, and P. R. Certain, Mol. Phys.. 1977, 34, 589.
328
K . Kirby and B. Liu, J . Chem. Phys., 1978, 69, 200.
320 G. C. Causley and B. R . Russell, J . Chem. Phys., 1978, 68, 3797.
330 R. N. Dixon and C. R . Webster, J . Mol. Spectrosc., 1978, 70, 314.
33' A. Davidsson, Chem. Phys.. 1978, 35, 413.
332 M. Hossain and D. M. Hanson, Chem. Phys., 1978, 30, 155.
333 L. Goodman and I . Ozkan, Chem. Phys. Left.. 1979, 61, 216.
334 S. Millefiori, F. Zuccarello, and G . Buemi, J . Chem. SOC.,Perkin Trans. 2, 1978, 849.
335 R. S. Davidson, A. Lewis, and T. D. Whelan, J . Chem. SOC.,Perkin Trans. 2, 1977, 1280.
33h E. J . J . Groenen and P. N. T. Van Velzen, Mol. Phys., 1978, 35, 19.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 55
ground and 'L, and 'Lbstates of indole and some of its derivatives uses previously
published data on solvent-dependent Stokes shifts and the results of MO SCF PPP
calculations. 3 7 Solvent-dependent Stokes-shift measurements have been used to
calculate the excited-state dipole moments of 1,3-dipheny1-2-pyrazolines in good
agreement with the results of CNDO calculations.338 Detailed studies of the
solvatochromism of merocyanine derivatives 339 and of all-trans-retinal and all-
trans-retinylidene-n-butylamine 340 have also been published.
A new method for the calculation of ground- and excited-state molecular
polarizabilities has been developed and applied to a number of molecules.341It
combines second-order perturbation theory with the CNDO/S CI method and
gives reasonably accurate polarizability tensor components for all the states
included in the CI in one calculation, in strong contrast to an alternative method
which requires at least 21 individual CI calculations for each state. The theory of the
Stark effect for atoms in a constant electric field 342 and the role of resonant Stark
broadening theory in understanding the mechanism of the collision-free dissoci-
ation of molecules in high-intensity laser resonant fields 343 have both been
discussed. The origins of the a.c. Stark effect have been reviewed in a general
discussion of level distortions in atomic systems subjected to strong laser fields. 344
Strong resonance effects are observed in these systems which on the basis of
perturbation theory arise from terms in which the factors w,,, f wp,where wpis the
laser-field frequency and w,,, the resonant frequency for the transition n + rn,
occur in the denominators of expressions for the level shifts.
A theory of electric-field-induced radiationless transitions in isolated molecules
has been published. 345 The perturbation Hamiltonian H,is given by the expression
H , = HNR + i.where ; HNR is the familiar perturbation arising from the nuclear
kinetic-energy operator, the electric field, and the transition dipole-moment
operator. The final expression for the non-radiative transition rate constant, kmg,, of
molecules with a permanent dipole moment in gaseous or liquid systems is given in
equation (1 l), where is the vibrational factor, which is unaffected by the field,
and J, is the electronic factor, which is affected by the field and from which the
squared field-strength term has been extracted. Rough estimates of the ratio r
between the value of kzz.with and without an electric field give values in the range
0.02 < r < 2, which should be readily detectable. Such effects may be partly
responsible for the effects of electric fields on the recombination luminescence of
electron<ation geminate pairs in sensitized low-temperature alkane glasses (see for
example reference 346).The application of a new method for the determination of
337
M. Sun and P. S. Song, Photochem. Phorohiol., 1977, 25, 3 .
338
H. Giistcn, G. Heinrich, and H. Friihbeis, Ber. Bunseng. Phys. Chem., 1977, 81, 810.
J3q A. Le Beuze, A Botrel, A . Samat, P. Appriou, and R. Guglielmetti, J . Chim. Phys., 1978, 75, 255.
340 J . P. Corsetti and B. E. Kohler, J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 67, 5237.
341 F. T. Marchese and H . H. Jaffe, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1977, 45, 241.
342 I . W . Herbst and B. Simon, Phys. Rev. Lett., 1978, 41, 67.
343 E. V. Shuryak, Kvantovaya Elektron. (Moscow), 1978, 5 , 1796.
344 J . S. Bakos, Phys. Rep., 1977, 31, 209.
345 W. Strek, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 57, 121.
346 J . Bullot, P. Cordier, and M. Gauthier, J . Chem. Phys.. 1978, 69, 1374.
56 Photochemistry
dipole moments of molecules in solution by observing the effect of electric fields on
their fluorescence properties has been reported, 347 and the observation of electric-
field quenching of the fluorescence of X-metal-free phthalocyanine indicates that
the first excited singlet is directly involved in carrier photogeneration.348 A Stark
spectroscopy study and a modulated phosphorescence polarization technique have
been used to investigate the interactions between the T , and T , states of
benzaldehydes in the crystalline state. 349 The results indicate that both second-
order vibronic spin orbit and direct environmental mixings occur between the %7r*
and ’n71‘ states.
The optical analogue of the n.m.r. rotary saturation effect, in which an r.f.
standing-wave Stark electric field is tuned in rotary saturation resonance with the
splitting, has been demonstrated and analysed. 350 The production of permanent
giant dipole moments in the photolysis of spiropyran solutions in the presence of
electric fields has been demonstrated 3 5 1 and a model for photo-induced polariz-
ation or depolarization discussed. 352
A number of papers on electric-field effects in systems of biological interest have
been published, of which mention is only made of a valuable review of the role of the
’
electric field in photosynthesis 53 and of interesting observations of electrochromic
effects on bacteriorhodopsin (bR 70) in purple membranes from Halobacterium
hal~bium.~~~
546, 171.
3 s s J. B. Birks in ‘Research in Photobiology’, ed. A. Castellani, Plenum, New York, 1977, p. 15.
3 5 6 R. Van der Werf, D. Zevenhuijzen, and J. Jortner, Chem. Phys., 1978, 27, 319.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 57
behave just as a heat bath, i.e. to be inert, and furthermore the thermal vibrational
relaxation and excitation rates are assumed to be much greater than the relevant
intramolecular decay widths, and the widths of the resonances are assumed to be
considerably smaller than the thermal energy B- 5 kT. The total decay rate, k,,,,of
the IS> + 1T> manifold prepared by a rapid ISC process from the initially
optically excited ( I S > } manifold is given by equation (12), where 2
'f
k,, = ; dEP,bWXP(- BE)Y,(E)
equations derived from the kinetic model but naturally gives a great deal more
insight; in particular it provides explicit expressions for the temperature depen-
dence for the kinetic model rate parameters. This important paper concludes by
applying the theory to recent experimental data for the dicarbonyl molecule
biacetyl, which is an example of a molecule with intermediate level structure. An
equally interesting and related paper has discussed the process of inverse electronic
relaxation (IER), in which the thermal excitation process just discussed is replaced
by a multiphoton excitation of a ground electronic state { 1G > >.3 5 7 The process has
been proposed to explain the recent observation of prompt fluorescence from
CrO,Cl, following N-photon excitation ( N z 16). The theoretical problem is to
account for the apparent reversal of the decay of a 'doorway' state to a dense
manifold of a lower electronic state, a process which exhibits practical irreversibility
in the statistical limit. The difficulty is overcome by considering the scrambled
molecular eigenstates of the isolated polyatomic molecule represented by
>
( ( 1 Ga > + (1S/?> }), which are reached by incoherent multiphoton excitation.
The IER process is then regarded as the one-photon spontaneous decay of these
scrambled states due to their (lS/3>} character. The final decay channel, being a
radiative continuum, ensures the irreversibility of the IER process. The model is
illustrated in Figure 16 along with that for the process of inverse predissociation,
which except for the difference in the initial state is clearly an analogous process.
357
A. Nitzan and J. Jortner, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 60, I .
58 Photochemistry
There are many examples now known of molecules in which the vibrational times
are slow enough to be comparable with radiative decay times, i.e. 10- s and above. '
For large molecules in condensed phases vibrational relaxation times are of the
Inverse Predissociation
Radiative Dissociative
con t inu u m ; : m $
1g> 1-
-
Figure 16 Schematic representation of molecular inverse predissociation and of inverse
electronic relaxation in range ( A ) of polyatomic molecules
(Reproduced with permission from Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 60, 1)
order of 10- l 2 s, and for such cases the large differences in the characteristic times
of the two decay processes permit a decoupled description of the overall decay. In
cases where the times are comparable this is clearly not valid. A unified theory of
relaxation and luminescence has been published which is based on the master
equation (1 3), where P, is the probability of occupation of the mth level, a,,, is the
radiative decay rate of level rn, and ymn is the relaxation decay rate of the transition n
to rn.358 The initial condition P,(O) is established by the method of excitation, and
the o! and y values can be calculated from microscopic parameters. The above
equation can then be solved for P,(t), giving the excitation distribution at any time
t , which may in turn be used to calculate quantities such as the fluorescence
quantum yield (the new theory includes radiationless decay terms), fluorescence
where N is the population, z the path length, and r~ the relevant cross-section.
For C = 10-5Mdm-3 ( N = 6 x l O ” ~ m - ~ )z, = lcm, and (gem- cex)=
2.10- l 6 cm-, the amplification is less than two. A simple model for the interaction
of two laser pulses propagating in a fluorescent dye medium has been successful
in qualitatively accounting for the results of recent experiment^.^^' In essence the
rate-equation analysis shows that the leading pulse is attenuated by absorption
and the second pulse is amplified by spontaneous emission, its amplifi-
cation depending on the delay between the two pulses. A theoretical analysis of the
design of organic compounds to optimize their lasing characteristics has been
published.370
LY-.
rotational matrix elements and selection rules for internal conversion processes
between two singlet states and two triplet states and for intersystem crossing
between a singlet and a triplet state have been The study considers
polyatomic molecules in Hund’s case4 angular momentum coupling scheme in
which N , K , J , and S are the good quantum numbers, and the results indicate that
the selection rules depend on both the angular-momentum coupling and the
interaction operator. It has been demonstrated experimentally that a magnetic field
quenches the fluorescence of I 2, CS,, glyoxal, and NO, molecules in the gas phase.
A general treatment of the effect of magnetic fields on radiationless transitions has
been published. 3 7 6 It identifies three mechanisms as possibly contributing to the
observed quenching: ( i )a direct mechanism, in which an existing zero-field coupling
element between a prepared state and an adjacent quasi-continuum is enhanced by
a Zeeman term and which, since the states must be of favourable symmetry and of
the same spin, applies only to internal conversion, (ii) an indirect mechanism, in
which the Zeeman interaction causes a change in the existing coupling, involving
perhaps an intermediate state, and may affect both intersystem crossing and
internal conversion (unlike the direct mechanism, which increases the rate of the
375 W. E. Howard and E. W. Schlag, J . Chem. Phys., 1978, 68, 2679.
376 P. R . Stannard, J . Chem. Phys., 1978, 68, 3932.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 63
radiationless decay quadratically in the field, the indirect mechanism leads to a
quadratic dependence on the field at low fields, as in the direct mechanism, but to a
constant value at high fields), and (iii) a mechanism arising from a simple level-
shifting effect, which may bring about different resonances but which is only
expected to be noticeable for intermediate case molecules. The paper discusses each
of the specific cases mentioned above. A general model for discussing the
radiationless decay of a polyatomic molecule is of an initially prepared isolated
state strongly coupled to a manifold of intermediate states that in turn are strongly
coupled to a continuum of final states representing dissociation and/or vibrational
relaxation. A paper has discussed the case where there is a random coupling
between the levels that is subject to two weak perturbations, a constant coupling or
a Lorentzian coupling, the latter being appropriate for vibrational relaxation in
The time evolution of the initially excited vibrational mode in the
Lorentzian coupling-random coupling case exhibits two time constants at short
times, one of which corresponds to a redistribution of energy amongst nearly
resonant modes and the other to the relaxation to lower-lying modes.
A discussion by Birks of so-called horizontal radiationless transitions (HRT) in
stilbene and polyene derivatives has resulted in a classification of five types of
behaviour for the S , and S , potentials on rotation about a central double bond. 378
HRTs alter the steric configuration of an electronic state and also its zero-point
energy and sometimes its wavefunction and symmetry. They also change the energy
separation between the state and adjacent states. The discussion is based on a semi-
empirical model of the potential surfaces of the ‘B* and ‘A* excited singlet states
which interact because of asymmetric perturbations, probably torsional vibrations
excited by collisions, distorting the otherwise non-interacting (because they have
different symmetry) surfaces. The five types of potential are illustrated in Figure 18.
A new approach to the calculation of intramolecular radiationless transitions
called the non-integral occupation number (NION) method has been described. 379
The new approach departs from other methods based on the golden-rule expression
of time-dependent perturbation theory by avoiding both the usual generating-
function evaluation of a sum in the vibrational quantum numbers n, in the final
electronic statefand the saddle-point approximation to evaluate the 1’ d t integral
which arises from the &function. The final expression for the radiationless decay
rate from an initial electronic state i with rn quanta in the first vibrational degree of
freedom is given by equation (1 5), where w 2 is the frequency of the best accepting
mode 2, Bvis the electronic factor, and y is a non-integral measure of the number of
available 2-quanta in the final state. The important term is the NION
Franck-Condon factor 1 ( 0 I n, ) In, = y, and this emphasizes the importance of
the accepting mode in this simple method, which is shown to subsume many
previous methods. A series of model calculations of relative rates, R,Xrn, # 0,
m3 # O)/R&rn, = 0 = m3), are presented for the S1 + T , , ISC, and S1--* So,
3’7
M . Muthukurnar and S. A. Rice, J . Chem. Phys., 1978, 69, 1619.
378 J. B. Birks, Chem. Phy.y. Lett., 1978, 54, 430.
379 I. H. Kuehn, D. F. Heller, and W. M. Gelbart, Chem. Phys., 1977, 22, 435.
64 Photochemistry
IC, processes in benzene to investigate the competing effects of anharmonicity,
geometry changes, and frequency shifts in all the relevant vibrations. It is clearly
shown that all of these effects must be considered to obtain a realistic picture of the
iiiil
-
t y x z
C 0 WF I G UR A l l 0 N
p
Figure 18 Schematic diagrams of the angular dependence of the S and S2potentials between t
and p. A = 'A*, B = 'B*
(Reproduced with permission from Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 54, 430)
molecular structure parameters that are important to the decay process. It is argued
that the failure of the model to account for the observed increase in relative rates for
the S , + So process arises from the assumption in the golden-rule expression that
the interaction energy may be written as a product of an electronic factor and a
vibrational overlap integral. This requires modification when potential surfaces
interact, as is the case for 'channel 3' which appears ~ 3 0 0 0 c m - above the origin
of the first excited singlet state.
The effect of introducing unequal quasi-continuum couplings into the well
known Bixon-Jortner model of radiationless processes has been discussed.380 The
paper argues for a new approach in which the lack of quasi-continuum matrix-
380 S. D. Druger, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977, 48, 46.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 65
element correlation is introduced at the outset and which can avoid a number of
qualitative effects implied by the Bixon-Jortner model that are not observed
experimentally. Conditions under which a non-Markovian radiationless decay
process exhibits a rigorous exponential behaviour have been investigated. 381 Such
decays are shown to result from both a finite excitation pulse fall time and a
transverse relaxation process. An expression for the ratio of radiative to non-
radiative decay in electronically excited solid-state materials has been
developed. 3 8 2
The tunnel-effect theory or radiationless transitions described in my previous
contribution to this series (see ‘Photochemistry’, Volume 9) has been extended to
study substituent effects on intra- and inter-molecular H-abstractions of carbonyl
excited electronic states. 3 8 3 The results have revealed that photoabstractions by
n,n* singlet and triplet states and n,n* triplet states are adiabatic processes, whereas
photoabstractions by singlet n,n* levels have an electronic forbidden factor of
< 10- 2. It is shown that these observations are consistent with the state correlation
diagrams of Salem. The possible role of a charge-transfer process in intramolecular
H-abstractions is also discussed in the paper, and such a process is viewed as one
extreme, the other being radical-like abstractions, of a mechanistic continuum for
photoabstraction reactions. The application of the tunnel-effect theory has also
been investigated in a study of hydrogen-abstraction reactions by triplet n7ZC
benzophenone. 3 8 4 The theory was able to predict successfully the quenching rate
constants of NN-dimethylaniline and triethylaniline as substrates, but for the cases
of n-hexylamine and isopropylamine the agreement was not so good. The origins of
the discrepancies are discussed, and in particular the difficulty of obtaining
adequate potential-energy surfaces is pointed out. In its simplest form the theory
uses the harmonic-oscillator approximation to calculate both D,the energy barrier,
and Ax, the barrier width. The nature of the energy barrier in such reactions has also
been the subject of a more recent paper.385
Intersystem Crossing. A Green’s function technique has been used to formulate an
expression for S --* T intersystem crossings (ISCs) in aromatic hydrocarbons.3 8 6
There are a number of outstanding questions concerning the ISC process in such
molecules, including benzene itself, such as the identity of the promoting modes,
which have not been resolved by recent experimental and theoretical work. Using a
pure-spin Born-Oppenheimer basis set, an expression for the ISC rate constant is
derived which involves diagonal terms of both spin-orbit coupling and non-
adiabatically induced spin-orbit coupling and also cross terms between them which
are usually neglected. Such a mechanism leads to a classification of promoting
modes into two groups. The first group is determined by the condition that the
vibronic spin-orbit coupling matrix element must not vanish and the second by a
similar condition for the vibronic coupling matrix elements which involve the
nuclear momentum operator. An approximate calculation of the former for the
38’ P. Grigolini, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 58, 185.
382 A. M . Stoneham and R. H . Bartram, Solid-Slate Elecrron.. 1978, 21, 1325.
383 S. J . Formosinho, J . Chem. Soc.. Faraday Trans. 2 , 1978, 74, 1978.
384 G. D. Abbott and D. Phillips, Mol. Photochem., 1977, 8, 289.
385 H . Cardy, E. Poquet, M . Chaillet, and A. Dargelos, N o w . J . Chim., 1978, 2, 603.
38h Y. Fujimura, N. Simakura, and T. Nakajima, J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 66, 3530.
66 Photochemistry
S, ( ’B,) -+ T1X*Y(3Blu) ISC process in benzene indicates that the dominant
promoting mode is the elg C-H out-of-plane vibration (vl0), and this is true for
both a direct S , - T , and an indirect S , -+ T , T , mechanism. High-resolution
-+
that are in resonance, V,,, the corresponding coupling between the levels, and y the
natural width of the resonance. After appropriate averaging of the ‘collision’
’” W. E. Howard and E. W. Schlag, Chem. Phys., 1976, 17, 123.
’” W . E. Howard and E. W. Schlag, Chem. Phys., 1978, 29, 1.
389 M . K . Bowman and J. R . Norris, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 54, 45.
390
G. L. Bendazzoli, G. Orlandi, and P. Palmieri, J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 67, 1948.
391 R. Naaman, V. Yakhot, and G. Fischer, J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 67, 5472.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 67
trajectories the emission intensity at low pressures, I , is given by the expression
I = I,exp ( - PP)”~, where p is the pressure and /3 a constant derived from the
molecular properties and the temperature. This strong pressure dependence of I at
low pressures predicted by the theory was found to agree quite well with
experimental observations in quinoxaline and benzophenone. At high pressures
other mechanisms, not included in the theory, will contribute to the energy-transfer
behaviour. A comprehensive theory of collision-induced intersystem crossing has
been extended to include the effect of individual collision trajectories on the cross-
section for the process.392The work was prompted by recent experimental work on
inert-gas quenching of CO fluorescence, which indicated that the cross-section, 0,
for the process was not linearly dependent on the average value of the singlet-triplet
mixing coefficient, x2.393 In contrast to the resonant transition model above, the
‘collision’is regarded as a perturbation of an intramolecular radiationless process.
The new model considers both weak long-range attractive and short-range
repulsive interactions, and collisions are divided into two categories. In the first of
these the internal-energy transfer is large compared with the interaction energy, and
this results in the linear dependence of d o n x 2predicted by the earlier theory. In the
second category, called perturbed mixing collisions, where the energy transfer is
comparable to the interaction energy, a non-linear dependence of u on x 2 was
predicted. A model of collision-induced intersystem crossing involving the
formation of a collision complex has been applied to polyatomic molecules such as
glyoxal. 394
Of the numerous experimental investigations of ISC processes only a few
representative examples will be reported here. An extensive review (in Polish) of the
experimental methods for the determination of S , + T , ISC quantum yields has
been published,395and this was followed up by the same authors with a review of
the physicochemical factors which determine these yields. 396 A strong red emission
observed on excitation of Ca atoms in a solid Ar matrix originates from the 4p 3P
state and is evidence for an efficient spin-forbidden non-radiative multiphonon
relaxation process.397This observation is consistent with recent work by the same
author on small molecular guests in rare-gas solids. Detailed studies of the
phosphorescence lifetime and yield of [’ H6]- and [2H6]-benZenein glassy and
crystalline media at low temperatures (2-30K) have revealed that both the
radiative and non-radiative decays originate from the nearly degenerate upper pair
of spin sublevels, E , = D - E and Ex = D + The observed temperature-
dependent behaviour could be explained entirely by the combined effects of a
Boltzmann population term and a spin-lattice relaxation term. The ISC rate
constants of a number of aromatic ketones have been measured directly by
following the build-up of the triplet-state absorption using picosecond-laser
spectroscopy techniques. 399 Similar values were found for benzophenone, an-
392 K. F. Freed and C. Tric, Chem. Phys., 1978, 33, 249.
393 D.Grimbert, M. Lavolee, A. Nitzan, and A. Tramer, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 57, 45.
394 H . L. Selzle, S, H . Lin, and E. W. Schlag, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1979, 62,230.
395 B. Matuszewski and A. Maciejewski, Wiad. Chem., 1977, 31,791.
39b A. Maciejewski and B. Matuszewski, Wiad Chem., 1978, 32, 151.
39’ V. E. Bondybey, J . Chem. Phys., 1978, 68, 1308.
398 N. G. Kilmer and A. H. Kalantar, Chem. Phys., 1978, 27, 3 5 5 .
399 D. E. Damschen, C. D. Merritt, D. L. Perry, G. W. Scott, and L. D. Talley, J . Phys. Chem., 1978,82,
2268.
68 Photochemistry
throne, xanthone, and a number of para-substituted benzophenones. The quantum
yields of T , + S , ISC processes in anthracene and a number of its derivatives have
been measured by a double-excitation method.400 The failure of the simple
logarithmic energy-gap law for k,,, when the energy gap I AE(S,-T2) I is small has
been investigated experimentally and theoretically for a number of 9,lO-substituted
anthracenes. 401 The widely different photophysical properties in these compounds
are attributed to interference effects between the S , + T , and S, + T , ISC
processes. The triplet build-ups observed in a picosecond-laser spectroscopic study
of several carbonyl derivatives of anthracene have been attributed to the
T,, + T I E ,IC process and not to the SIEn. T,,, ISC process which precedes
it.402The latter process was thought to be significantly faster than the former rate-
determining step.
Non-radiative decay processes in the azabenzenes, pyridine, pyrazine, and
pyrimidine have been investigated using an intermolecular triplet-triplet energy
transfer to b i a ~ e t y l . ~The
’ ~ results have revealed a new non-radiative decay channel
in the S,(’nn*) state ofboth [‘H5]- and [2H5]-pyridine,1000cm-’ above the lowest
vibrational level, and similarly for pyrazine and pyrimidine in the 3000cm-
excess-energy region. The influence of the proximity effect between a coupled pair
of nlir and nlir states, which was mentioned earlier in this section, on the T , + S o
ISC process in pyrazine and two of its methyl derivatives has been discussed.404
The electronic-energy gap between the triplet nlir and nlir states is modified by
substitution, and the results show that as this gap decreases the radiationless decay
rate increases. The corresponding increase in the vibronic coupling is evidenced by
the increasing out-of-plane activity in the phosphorescence spectra. ODMR
methods have been used to investigate the S , * T , ISC process in ~yrimidine.~”
An anomalously high z, spin sublevel population rate (x is the out-of-plane axis)
observed in an earlier study of pyrimidine in a benzene matrix was shown to
disappear if a 5-methylpyrimidine matrix was used. The effect can be attributed to a
pseudo-Jahn-Teller distortion of 3A,( ZIP) and/or 3B2(nlir) potential surfaces by a
higher-lying 3A (nlir) state. An energy-level diagram for pyrimidine that shows
this ordering and a number of other features is shown in Figure 19. An experiment
in which the triplet state of [2H12]-tetramethylpyrazine in durene at low temperature
is produced following a short duration laser excitation at 266nm has proved that
the S , + T , ISC process results in a non-stationary superposition of two zero-field
spin states which is coherent throughout the ensemble. 406 The effect manifests itself
as a microwave free-induction-decay signal at the resonant frequency of the ~ ~ - 7 ~
transition. A study of the S , + T I ISC process in acridine in PVA film has
suggested that two processes are involved.407 The first is a temperature-dependent
process which proceeds via T,(n,n*) to T , ( ~ , l i r and ) , the second i s temperature-
G -
Figure 19 The low-lying electronic states of pyrimidine. The spin-orbital symmetries are
indicated in parentheses
(Reproduced with permission from Chem. Phys. Lett., 1279, 62, 250)
Scheme 1
'Iz J. C. Miller, J. S. Meek, and S. J . Strickler, J . Am. Chem. Soc., 1977, 99, 8175.
4'3 H. Saigusa and T. Azumi, J . Lumin., 1979, 18/19, 187.
414 G. Eber, S. Schneider, and F. Eoerr, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977, 52, 59.
415 E. M. Kosower and H. Doduik, J . Phys. Chem., 1978, 82, 2012.
4'6 S. P. Naumov and E. B. Sveshnikova, Opt. Spektrosk., 1978, 45, 903.
417 K. J. Latas and A. M. Nishimura, J . Am. Chem. Soc., 1978, 82, 491.
418 H. Dreeskamp and J. Pabst, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1979, 61, 262.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 71
the luminescence of aza-aromatics and carbazoles 4 1 9 and of barium(r1) on the
fluorescence of naphthalene 4 2 0 have both been investigated.
Internal Conversion. An examination of a number of frequently used approxim-
ations in the calculation of non-radiative matrix elements involving the nuclear
kinetic-energy operator has shown that they can lead to large errors.421Exact
expressions for the matrix element of a simple model involving adiabatic potentials
are derived, and calculated values are compared with those obtained using both an
approximate solution that is equivalent to first-order Tanaka-Fukuda perturb-
ation theory and a solution that uses the spectroscopic Herzberg-Teller procedure
based on the Condon approximation. Except for the use of the latter procedure far
from resonance and for small quantum numbers, both approximations are shown
to be inadequate. The important conclusion reached is that radiationless transitions
do not involve spectroscopic Franck-Condon factors. A new form for the
vibrational integrals is given which results in a generally increased value for
calculated matrix elements compared with Franck-Condon-based formulae,
thereby improving the agreement with experiment. An interesting ab initio CI
calculation of the radiationless decay of the l(nn*)state of formaldehyde has been
An adiabatic Born-Oppenheimer basis set is used in the calculation
of this S , --+ So internal conversion (IC) process, and following an analysis of the
possible couplings between levels in the initial ' A 2 and final ' A , states it is shown
that both H 2 C 0 and D,CO are examples of the so-called resonance case in which
the density of coupling levels is so low that any interaction arises from a fortuitous
position of the interacting levels. The contribution from rotational coupling terms
which can be treated along with vibrational coupling terms in the method used was
shown to be negligible. The results show that contrary to earlier proposals this IC
process is not the rate-determining step in the photodissociation of formaldehyde.
It is also shown that a previous calculation of the rate of this S , + SoIC process
was based on a golden-rule rate expression derived from time-dependent perturb-
ation theory which can be shown to lead to inconsistent results. A discussion of IC
processes in aromatic molecules has included a discussion of the theoretical basis
and range of applicability of Kasha's rule.422 Theoretical calculations of the
S1+ SoIC process in electron donor-acceptor complexes of tetracyanoethylene
with aromatic hydrocarbon donors using a many-promoting-modes model were
found to be in good agreement with experimental values.423
Of the numerous experimental studies of IC processes only a few are mentioned
here. A study of the so-called 'a-substitution effect' has indicated that the ability of
t-butyl groups to facilitate aryl S , --+ So IC processes may be a general pheno-
m e n ~ n . ~An , ~interesting study of the energy andisotope dependence of the
S , + S , and S , + So IC processes in azulene under collision-free conditions has
been The results show that the S , + So IC process is in competition
419 M . Zander, Z . Naturforsch., Teil A , 1978, 33, 998.
'lo A. M. P. C. De Amorim, H. D . Burrows, and S. J. Formosinho, Spectrochim. Actu, Part A , 1977,33,
245.
42' W. Siebrand and M. Z. Zgierski, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 58, 8.
421 V. G. Plotnikov and B. A. Dolgikh, Opt. Spektrosk., 1977, 43, 882.
423 J. Prcchorow, I. Deperasinska, and A. Sobelewski, J . Lumin., 1977, 18/19, 105.
424 W. W. Schloman, jun. and H . Morrison, J . Am. Chem. Soc., 1977, 99, 3342.
425 Y. Hirata and E. C. Lim, J . Chem. Phys., 1978, 69, 3292.
72 Photochemistry
with the S , + So process and may be the dominant decay process even at zero
excess energy. Its rate is every bit as anomalous as the S , -+ So process with respect
to the ‘energy-gap law’ for IC processes in aromatic hydrocarbons in that they are
both several orders of magnitude greater than the predicted value. The results
support the idea that the geometrical structures of the S, and S, electronic states are
similar and that both the IC processes to the ground electronic state involve large
configurational changes. A study of the energy dependence of the luminescence of
quinoline and isoquinoline vapours has been interpreted in terms of the dominance
of an S, -, So IC process from vibrationally excited S,.426This phenomenon is
thought to be general for nitrogen-heterocyclic compounds with closely spaced,
lowest-energy nn* and nn* states. The results indicate that the S2(nn*) + Sl(nn*)
IC process is collisionally induced for low vibrational levels of S2 but that it is an
efficient process, characteristic of the statistical limit, for higher vibrational levels of
S,. The S , -,S , IC process in biacetyl in both the liquid and the vapour phases has
been investigated.427
Vibrational Relaxation. A valuable and interesting review of the theoretical
background and experimental results of studies of the vibrational dynamics of
liquids and solids in their ground electronic states using picosecond-laser pulses has
been The paper discusses the stimulated Raman scattering and
infrared-absorption excitation processes and the coherent and incoherent Raman
scattering and fluorescenceprobing processes used in such studies. The first of these
probing techniques, coherent Raman scattering, has been used in conjunction with
stimulated Raman excitation to give information on the dephasing time T, of
excited modes both in molecules with essentially only one vibrational frequency or
in more complex situations, to observe the collective beating of neighbouring
frequency components, and to measure the lifetime of optical phonons in crystals.
The second two probing techniques have been used to observe directly population
lifetimes, also energy transfer and redistribution processes in the liquid state with
time constants in the range 1-100 ps. A new technique for measuring vibrational
relaxation times, called coherent Raman induced infrared fluorescence (CRIIF),
has been described in the literature and applied in a representative study to the
D,-HCl In the technique a Raman transition with frequency (wL - ws)
is excited by simultaneously exposing the sample to a pumping frequency wL and a
Stokes frequency ws. The transfer of excitation from the totally symmetric states so
produced to dipolar states can be followed by observing the risetime and decay of
the i.r. fluorescence. Another laser-induced fluorescence method is illustrated by a
study of CH3F, in which fluorescence from the overtone 2v3 of the C-F stretch
vibration is measured following excitation at the fundamental frequency v3.430 The
v3 and 2v3 are tightly coupled, and any decay of 2v3 fluorescence is a measure of v3
transfer to other modes. Laser-induced fluorescence techniques have been used to
-7 11'
400
20:l
-285
16'
1
-522
00
Figure 20 A schematic showing every vibrational level up to 1200 cm- above the zero-point
level in S , benzene. The arrows show the vibrational-energyflow monitored in these experiments.
The level 6 , is initiallypumped, and collisional transfer into each of thefour channels A through
D is monitored. Two channels characterize$ow to single levels (ignoring degeneracies). The
other channels involve twofinal levels. The energy separation between 6' and thefinal levels is
given in cm- '. Many levels are instrinsically degenerate; these components have not been
depicted. Heavy lines in the level stack indicate level pairs too close to show individually
(Reproduction with permission from Chem. Phys., 1978, 27, 127)
levels. These four channels account for over 70% of the total energy flow despite the
large number of energy levels in the same energy region, and clearly this indicates
that strong propensity rules are operating. It was found that simple rules previously
derived to described vibrational relaxation in ground electronic states in poly-
atomic molecules can be successfully applied to the S, benzene state. The rules are
based on an expression for the transfer probability which is a product of terms
involving the level degeneracies, the change in the vibrational quantum number,
and the amount of energy exchanged between vibrational and
translational/rotational degrees of freedom. The cross-sections for vibrational-
energy transfer were found to be significantly larger in the excited electronic state
(approaching gas kinetic) compared with those for ground states, in agreement with
432 J . Finzi, F. E. Hovis, V. N . Panfilov, P. Hess, and C. Bradley Moore, J . Chem. Phys., 1977,67,4053.
433 S . A. Edelstein, B. E. Perry, D. J. Eckstrom, and T. F. Gallagher, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977,50, 271.
434 C. S. Parmenter and K . Y. Tang, Chem. Phys., 1978, 27, 127.
74 Photochemistry
previous observations and possibly arising from stronger long-range attractive
forces between excited states and other molecules. The existence of propensity rules
in other systems is supported by a recently published study of vibrational-energy
flow from eight vibronic levels in the ’B2 state of aniline in which argon is the
collision partner.435The study, which differs from that on benzene in that intensity-
versus-time measurements are also used in addition to steady-state measurements to
verify the kinetic model used in the analysis, does, however, indicate that the
propensity rules as presently stated are inadequate. In both the aniline and benzene
studies it was observed that a dominant channel for vibrational-energy transfer was
to a higher-energy vibrational state, and this had led to the suggestion that this
channel involves the formation of a metastable intermediate.
A study of vibrational relaxation in the B,, state Of p-F2C6H4 has shown that
unlike a previous study of p-FC6H4Me the stochastic stepladder model does not
account for the observed fluorescence quantum yield and lifetime results.436In this
simplified model the molecule has only one effective oscillator, and the decay rates
from its levels are a linear function of the level number n. It is further assumed that
collisions only induce transitions from state n + 1 to state n. The authors suggest
that for the model to apply there should be a high density of initially populated
levels. Preliminary results from a study of the fluorescence excitation spectrum of
supercooled naphthalene in a pulsed supersonic molecular beam show a trend of
increased broadening, the higher the vibrational energy.437
The Singlet State.-Resonance Fluorescence. There continues to be a great deal of
interest in the experimental and theoretical aspects of the resonance fluorescence of
atoms and molecules in intense monochromatic or finite bandwidth radiation fields.
The character of the fluorescence emission changes considerably on going from low
to high intensity radiation. The fluorescence spectrum, for example, changes from
purely monochromatic at low intensity to exhibit complex structure at high
intensity. A new approach to the theoretical description of resonance fluorescence
has been published which has a number of advantages over existing treatments.438
In the dressed-atom approach resonance fluorescence is considered as spontaneous
emission from the system comprising the atom and the laser mode, i.e. the atom
dressed by laser photons. A simple procedure, illustrated for the case of a two-level
atom, shows that the components of the resonance fluorescence spectrum are the
allowed Bohr frequencies of the dressed atom. A number of other properties are
also readily obtained, and the authors point out that the approach is well suited to
the treatment of multilevel systems and the effects of collisions and of Doppler
shifts. There has been further discussion of the effect of using finite bandwidth
excitation to excite resonance fluorescence.439A theoretical treatment has shown
that in contrast to truly ‘monochromatic excitation a pronounced asymmetry
appears in the resonance fluorescence when using off-resonance excitation with
Frequency W - ~ I in ) units of 13
~ ~r ) 2 / ( o o 2,u sin$)2 of thefluorescence radiated by a driven
Figure 21 Spectrum CP ( a ) ( 4 l l C2
atom in the steady state,for various values of the excitation bandwidth I , with Rabifrequency
R = log, and detuning 0 = - 3
(Reproduced with permission from Phys. Rev. A , 1977, 15, 689)
440 D. F. Walls, H. J. Carmichael, R. F. Gragg, and W. C. Schieve, Phys. Rev. A , 1978, 18, 1622.
"' H. J. Carmichael, P. Drummond, P. Meystre, and D. F. Walls, J . Phys. A: Math., Nucl. Gen.. 1978,11,
L121.
76 Photochemistry
reviewed.442The properties of resonance fluorescence from a two-level atom in
intense modulated laser fields have been investigated. The cases of phase
modulation,443 phase-frequency modulation,444 and intensity modulation 445
have all been considered. It has been shown that consideration of an intrinsic
linewidth for the driving laser field introduces an additional peak to the fluorescence
power spectrum of a weakly driven two-level atom.446
The statistical properties of three-level atom resonance fluorescence excited by
monochromatic laser radiation have been i n ~ e s t i g a t e d . An
~ ~ ’anti-bunching effect
is predicted, as are differences in the statistical properties of differently polarized
components of the fluorescence. An anisotropically polarized seven-line resonance
fluorescence spectrum has been predicted for a three-level atom having two closely
spaced excited and such a system is one of several treated in calculations
of atomic fluorescence radiance expressions for continuum excitation.449 The
Autler-Townes effect, which is a dynamic Stark splitting of energy levels in a strong
laser field, can be probed by using a second weak optical field to induce transitions
to a third level whose decay may be monitored separately. Numerical calculations
of such experiments have been made for the three-level sodium system 3’St F = 2,
32P,,2 F = 3, and 52S, F = 2 and show that at laser powers greater than that
equivalent to a Rabi frequency of 45 MHz the system behaves like an eight-level
system, i.e. hypefine structure cannot be ignored, a result that is consistent with
experiment.45 O
The effect of recoil is considered in a quantum-statistical theory of resonance
fluorescence valid for all orders of interaction with the laser field,451 and the
Doppler effect has been considered in a quantum-mechanical treatment of the
spectrum of resonance fluorescence from an atom in a perturber gas.452 The
resonance fluorescence from two interacting identical atoms or molecules has been
in~estigated,~’~ and the resonance fluorescence from molecules subject to inelastic
or reactive collisions has been treated theoretically in In the latter study
both classical and quantum-theoretical expressions for the intensity and polark-
ation of the fluorescence were derived for such collisions in which an antisotropic
distribution of rotational angular momentum is typically produced. The experi-
mental requirements to perform such studies are also discussed.
The results of recent detailed experimental work on resonance fluorescence from
two-level systems have been and as examples of recent experiments
442 B. R. Mollow in ‘Coherence and Quantum Optics’, ed. L. Mandel and E. Wolf, Plenum, New York,
1978, Vol. 4, p. 103.
443 P. Zoller and F. Ehlotzky, J . Phys. B. 1977, 10, 3023.
444 P. Zoller and F. Ehlolzky, Z . Phys. A , 1978, 285, 245.
445 P. Zoller, J . Phys. B, 1978, 11, 2825.
446 K. Wodkiewicz, Phys. Lett. A , 1978, 66, 369.
447 B. Sobolewska and R. Sobolewski, Opt. Commun., 1978, 26, 21 1 .
445
R . Kornblith and J. H . Eberly, J . Phys. B, 1978, 11, 1545.
449 G. D. Boutilier, M. B. Blackburn, J . M. Mermet, S. J. Weeks, H. Haraguchi, J. D. Winefordner, and N .
Omenetto, Appl. Opf.,1978, 17, 2291.
450 S. Swain and W. A. McClean in reference 442, p. 127.
45’ G. S. Agarwal and R. Saxena, Opt. Commun., 1978, 26, 202.
452 G. Neinhuis and F. Schuller, Physica B + C (Amsterdam), 1977, 92, 397.
453 C. Mavroyannis, Phys. Rev. A , 1978, 18, 185.
154 D. A. Case, G . M. McClelland, and D. R. Herschbach, Mol. Phys., 1978,35, 541.
455 (a) H. Walther in reference 4386, p. 129; (6) S. Ezekiel and F. Y. Wu in reference 4386, p. 145.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 77
mention is made of the use of Haresonance fluorescence at 656.3 nm to monitor the
plasma conditions in a Tokamak reactor456 and of studies of the resonance
fluorescence of C1, 4 5 7 and Br2.458
Superjluorescence. Although superfluorescence is a property of an ensemble of
inverted atoms or molecules this is an appropriate point in the report to mention a
number of recent papers on this important topic. The general features of the
phenomenon of superradiance are as follows: if a system of atoms or molecules of
density n per unit volume is completely inverted at time t = 0 then the system emits
a short, intense, directional pulse (or pulses) of radiation whose peak intensity is
proportional to n2 at a time zD > 0, where the pulse delay time rD, is proportional
to n- I. This (Dicke) superradiant emission from an inverted population is called
superfluorescence (vide infra) and is to be distinguished from the emission
proportional to n2 that is given by atomic systems subjected to an intitiating
external pulse and referred to as swept-gain superradiance.
There is a considerable debate currently that concerns two different theoretical
approaches to superradiance, one being quantum-mechanical, the other semi-
classical. In the quantum-theoretical approach of Dicke collective energy eigen-
states of two-level atoms are defined and characterized by two quantum numbers,
M the energy quantum number and J the co-operation quantum number. For N
atoms then 0 < J < N / 2 and -J < M < J. Two extreme cases can be identified:
in the first case J z N / 2 and M = 0 and this is called a superradiant state, and in
the second case M = J = N / 2 and this fully excited state has become associated
with the term superfluorescence. The phenomenon may be regarded as collective
spontaneous emission. In the semi-classical approach the radiation field is treated
classically and the spontaneous emission arises from a noise term. Here the
phenomenon is a transient form of stimulated emission from a high-gain medium.
The latter theory has generally been more successful in accounting for experimental
observations. A number of interesting papers on the theory of superfluorescence
have been published (see references 442 and 459), including several on the
phenomenon of bistability in which systems of inverted atoms and molecules
exhibit phase transitions and which, for example, makes a Fabry-Perot filled with
such atoms behave as an optical transistor.
The close correspondence of the quantum and semi-classical theories has been
established in a recent investigation of the fluctuating properties of superradiant
and superfluorescent systems.460The early stages of a superfluorescent pulse have
been described, the pulse being initiated by zero point fluctuations of the atomic
polarization field.461A particular problem to be treated by theories of superradi-
ance is to account for the trains of ringing pulses observed in the superfluorescence
of HF which contrasts with the observation of single pulses from the carefully
4s6
V. S. Burakov, P. Ya. Misakov, P. A. Naumenkov, S. V. Nechaev, G. T. Razdobarin, V. V. Sernenov,
L. V. Sokolova, and I . P. Folomkin, Zh. Prikl. Spektrosk., 1978, 29, 1079.
457
D. Hwang and H. Chang, J . Mol. Spectrosc., 1978, 69, 1 1 .
4s8 H. Chang and D. Hwang, J . Mol. Spectrosc., 1977, 65, 430.
459 ‘Cooperative Effects in Matter and Radiation’, ed. C. M . Bowden, D. W. Howgate, H. R. Robl, and R.
Hermann, Plenum, New York, 1977.
460
A. Zardecki and R. Baribeau, Can. J . Phys., 1977, 55, 984.
461
R. Glauber and F. Haake, Phys. Letr. A , 1978,68, 29.
78 Photochemistry
studied Cs system. Oscillatory effects in superfluorescence have been investigated
by numerically solving both a generalized master equation 462 and a Markovian
master equation,463making it possible to compare the regions of applicability of
the two theories of superradiance. Oscillatory superfluorescence can be described
by the sine-Gordon equation,464and the presence of quantum beats and chirping in
superfluorescence has been discussed.465
There are several reports of experimental work on superfluorescencein references
442 and 459. The 7 P + 7 s transition in Cs at 3pm is ideally suited to studies of
superfluorescence, and this has made it possible to help meet stringent conditions
for the observation of ‘pure’ superfluorescence established theoretically for a
pencil-shaped volume of a pure two-level system.466Under ‘ideal’conditions in Cs
a single pulse was observed.467As the excitation density was increased multiple
pulses were observed which were probably separate pulses originating from
different parts of the sample. A requirement for the semi-classical and quantum
theories to be in agreement that has been established in recent theoretical work 463
is that the semi-classical tipping angle is equal to the square root of the number of
radiating particles. This result has recently been observed experimentally by
injecting a coherent pulse of known area into a completely inverted sample of Cs
atoms and measuring the delay of the output
A wave-front-reversal effect in which the superluminescence of a dye solution
acquires the original coherence of the exciting radiation has been observed,469and
the polarization properties of superluminescence in an anisotropically amplifying
medium have been in~estigated.~~’ The contributions of superluminescence and
stimulated emission to the emission properties of unstable photoisomers of
polymethine dyes have been studied, and this led to conclusions regarding the
influence of photoisomerization on the emission from these systems for different
excitation wavelengths.
Fluorescence. As in my last review only a very limited selection of the large number
of papers on the fluorescence properties of atoms and molecules are reported here.
More extensive coverage of this type can be found in later chapters.
Extensive reviews of the luminescence of inorganic compounds 4 7 2 and of
triboluminescence (mechanically produced electronic excitation as in the crushing
of crystals) 473 have been published. The wide application of laser-induced
fluorescencetechniques in studies of collision dynamics and of energy distributions
462
M. Gronchi, L. A. Lugiato, and P. Butera, Phys. Rev. A , 1978, 18, 689.
463 E. Ressayre and A. Tallet. Phys. Rev. A , 1978, 18, 2196.
464 J . A. Hermann, Phys. Lett. A , 1979, 69, 316.
465 R. Prakash and N. Chandra, Phys. Rev. Lett., 1979,42,443.
466 R. Bonifacio and L. A. Lugiato, Phys. Rev. A , 1975, 12, 587.
467 ( a )Q. H. F. Vrehen, H. M. J . Hikspoors, and H. M. Gibb in reference 442, p. 543; (b) H. M. Gibbs,
Q. H. F. Vrehen, and H. M . J. Hikspoors, Phys. Rev. Lett., 1977, 39, 547.
468 Q. H. F. Vrehen and M. F. H. Schuurmans, Phys. Rev. Lett., 1979,42, 224.
469 V. G . Koptev, A. M . Lazaruk, I . P. Petrovich, and A. S. Rubanov, Pis’ma Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz., 1978,
28,468.
“O
A. I. Odintsov, N. G. Turkin, and V. P. Yakunin, Pis’ma Zh. Tekh. Fiz., 1978, 4, 153.
471
A. M . Bonch-Bruevich, E. N. Kaliteevskaya, and T. K. Razumova, Kvantovuya Electron. (Moscow),
1978, 5 , 1113.
472 D. J . Robbins and A. J . Thompson, Electron. Struct. Magn. Znorg. Compd., 1977, 5, 153.
473
A . J . Walton, Adv. Phys., 1977, 26, 887.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 79
in the fragments of photodissociation processes has been reviewed,474as has the use
of infrared fluorescence studies in vibrational spectroscopy.475There have been
interesting reports of fluorescence-based methods for the measurement of tempera-
tures in particle-laden combustion flows 476 and laser excited low-pressure
gases,477and the saturation of laser-induced fluorescence signals has been used to
measure the concentrations of CH and CN radicals,478and Na atom^,^" in flames.
A number of conclusions are reached in the latter study which restrict the use of
saturated atomic fluorescence intensities in the measurement of the total atomic-
number density in flames.
There are two important laser-based methods for determining homogeneous
linewidths, namely laser-induced fluorescence line-narrowing and hole-burning
(laser saturation of absorption). It is a relatively easy matter to achieve laser
linewidths significantly smaller than the homogeneous linewidth of the transitions
likely to be encountered in electronic spectroscopy, even at very low temperatures,
and such experiments using tunable lasers are finding increasing application.
Recent fluorescenceline-narrowing (FLN) studies of the spectroscopy of rare-earth
ions in glasses have, in the main, used non-resonant excitation which has a number
of important disadvantages. A recent paper has given details of a time-resolved
laser-induced FLN study of the 5D,+ 7F0fluorescence of Eu3+ in which a gated
vidicon detection system made it possible to use resonant excitation.480 The
homogeneous linewidth was found to be determined by the rate of phase-
interrupting, two-phonon Raman scattering processes. A theory of time-dependent
effects in FLN has been published which is based on coupled rate equations and
which is applicable when kTis much greater than the inhomogeneous l i n e ~ i d t h . ~ ~ ’
The FLN of a molecular gas in the resonator of a high-power single-mode laser has
been investigated t h e ~ r e t i c a l l yand
, ~ ~an
~ interesting study of FLN in ruby crystals
has been
The close relation between FLN and hole-burning, particularly as regards the
spectral shapes of the two effects, has been The holes are produced by
the disappearance of resonantly excited molecules and, as in FLN, if the laser
linewidth is sufficiently narrow the width of the hole is related to the homogeneous
linewidth of the transition. The envelope of such a transition can usually be
approximated by a Lorentzian curve. The disappearance can be the result of
photochemical or photophysical processes, for example hole-burning techniques
have been used recently in studies of the reversible photochromism of hydroxy-
quinones arising from both intra- and inter-molecular hydrogen bonds 4 8 5 and of
4’4 J . L. Kinsey, Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem., 1977, 28, 349.
475 G . C. Pimentel in ‘Vibrational Spectroscopy- Modern Trends’, ed. A. J . Barnes and W. J. Orville-
Thomas, Elsevier, Amsterdam, Netherlands, 1977, p. 33.
476 R. M. Kowalik and C. H. Kruger, Combust. Flame, 1979, 34, 135.
477 L. I. Kleinman, R. E. Weston, jun., and G. W. Flynn, J . Appl. Phys., 1978, 49, 4328.
478 P. A. Bonczyk and J. A. Shirley, Combust. Flame, 1979, 34, 253.
479 R. A. Van Calcar, M. J. M. Van de Ven, B. K . Van Uitert, K . J. Biewenga, T. Hollander, and C. T. J.
Alkemade, J . Quant. Spectrosc. Radiat. Transfer, 1979, 21, 1 1 .
480 M. A. El-Sayed, A. Campion, and P. Avouris, J . Mol. Struct., 1978, 46, 355.
481 D. L. Huber, D. S. Hamilton, and B. Barnett, Phys. Rev. B, 1977, 16, 4642.
E. Doepel and D. Kuehlke, Czech. J . Phys., 1978, B28, 141.
*” P. M. Selzcr, D. L. Huber, B. B. Barnett, and W. M. Yen, Phys. Rev. B, 1978, 17, 4979.
484 J. M. Hayes and G . J. Small, Chem. Phys., 1978, 27, 151.
48s F. Graf, H.-K. Hong, A. Nazzal, and D. Haarer, Chem. Phys. Lert., 1978, 59, 217.
80 Photochemistry
aromatic hydrocarbons in low-temperature glasses where there is an excited-state
mediated interconversion of molecules between sites in an asymmetric double-well
An interesting paper has established that sub-nanosecond fluores-
cence lifetimes can be measured using the hole-burning method.487The homoge-
neous linewidth of the zero phonon, electronic origin of the 1B3u+ 'Alg, S , + So
transition of s-tetrazine in benzene crystals at low temperature ( < 1.5 K), was
determined from the measured hole-width of 0.7 f 0.1 GHz to be 350 & 50 MHz.
This corresponds to a fluorescent lifetime of 455 - 5 5 7 5 ps, in excellent agreement
+
between the linewidth and either the excess vibrational energy or the symmetry
species of the vibration. The intriguing question is whether the observed variation
arises from an intramolecular effect, a characteristic of the porphin, or from the
coupling of the guest to the host lattice.
486 J. M. Hayes and G. J . Small, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 54, 435.
487 H. De Vries and D. A. Wiersma, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977, 51, 565.
488 S. Voelker and R. M. Macfarlane, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1979, 61, 421.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 81
A remarkably detailed study of the B'llu-X'Z,+ band system of Na, has been
published.489 The use of laser-induced fluorescence techniques and a 9.3 m
spectrograph led to the observation of over 25 000 lines with absolute frequencies
measured to better than 0.010cm- '. The coefficients in the Dunham expansion of
v(u',u",S,s') in a region of the potential where it is believed to converge
satisfactorily were determined sufficiently accurately to begble to reproduce 12 591
lines in the spectrum with an r.m.s. deviation between observed and calculated
frequencies of 0.01 1 cm- I . The dissociation energies of the X and B states were
found to be 5988 and 3116cm-', respectively. An upper limit of
6.3 O.Skcalmol-' for the CH, (i?'Al-T3Bl) energy separation has been
obtained from a study of the laser-induced fluorescence of the CH, (i?'Al)radical
produced by the nitrogen laser photolysis of ketene CH,C0.490This is a somewhat
lower value than has been obtained by recent ab initio calculations (see Section 2).
Large variations in the fluorescence lifetimes of individual rotational levels in the
(0,O) band of the lowest allowed transition in CO ( A 'n-X'Z+) have been observed
in a study which uses tunable vacuum ultraviolet radiation generated by four-wave
frequency mixing in Mg v a p o ~ r . The ~ ~ 'variations arise from perturbations of the
All7 levels by e3E- and d3Ai states. Resonance fluorescence from a single
rovibronic level of the A ' A , state of formaldehyde excited with 337.5 nm radiation
from a krypton laser was found to comprise vibrational progressions in the ground-
state vibrations v," (carbonyl stretching), v3" (in-plane bending), and even quanta
of vqR (out-of-plane bending), all of which have the_samesymmetry as the level from
which the excitation took place.492Details of the A 2 A l - f 2 B 1emission spectrum of
a NH, radical have been analysed to give the molecular constants of the (010) level
of the f 2 B l ground state,493and the observation of A N = + 2 transitions in the
fluorescence from the A 2 B , state of NO, is evidence of a spin-orbit coupling
effect.494A very large hyperfine splitting, in excess of the Doppler width of the O,,
(O,O,O) 2 level of the PH, radical, has been observed which arises from the Fermi
interaction of 1P,495 and variations in the fluorescence lifetime following pulsed
dye laser excitation of different vibrational levels in the state of this radical have
been reported.496A study of the fluorescence decay of laser excited SO, has shown
that the states responsible for the lpng-lived and short-lived emission components
do not decay independently and support their assignment to the ' B , and ' A , states,
respe~tively.~~' A study of SO, fluorescence and SO,-sensitized biacetyl phos-
phorescence at higher pressures where the short-lived fluorescence component is
strongly quenched have shown that there is a common precursor to both the ' B ,
state and the phosphorescent 3B1state, the latter probably being populated via a
(4)
energy transition was found to be the weak forbidden transition 'Ag* +- 'A,, but in
(5) the excited-state ordering was changed and the lowest-energy transition is the
strongly allowed 'B,* +- lA,. This valuable study shows clearly that geometry can
determine the order of the excited states. Studies of the temperature dependence of
the fluorescence properties of all-trans-diphenylhexatrieneand octatetraene have
provided firm evidence for the S,( 'A,*) and S2('B,*) state assignments proposed
earlier to explain the anomalous photophysical behaviour of these molecules. ''
Anti-Kasha and Anti-Stokes Fluorescence. A number of new research areas have
been explored in a notable series of papers on the low quantum yield (& < 10- 3),
very short-lived (zF < s) emission from the higher excited singlet states of a
number of complex molecules, principally aromatic hydrocarbons. The studies
were initiated by the observation of ultraviolet fluorescence from solutions of the
xanthene dyes Rhodamine 6G and B, following excitation by consecutive two-
photon absorption, a process which when using relatively low-power long-duration
laser-pulse excitation has the important advantage of avoiding the excitation of
impurity fluorescence.5 1 The excitation process is illustrated in Figure 23 where
the first photon, Ao, populates S, and the second photon, Al or A2, populates higher
singlet states by one-photon allowed transitions from S,. This is followed by
S, + So fluorescence emission. As well as establishing that emission did arise from
several excited states above S, these initial studies on the xanthene dyes and rubrene
showed the presence of very strong polarization effects, as expected from short-
lived excited states. In addition it was found that the high frequency limit of the
fluorescence was dependent on the excitation wavelength, an indication that
emission occurred from unrelaxed vibrational levels. The studies were extended to a
number of fluid solutions of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, using the same
technique in which the two photons were of the same frequency, originating from
the same laser, and a series of broad, essentially featureless emission spectra were
observed. 5 2 0 The most remarkable observations were made, however, using a
modified technique in which each photon was obtained from an independently
51' J. R. Andrews and B. S. Hudson, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1979,60, 380.
5'8 J. B. Birks, G. N. R. Tripathi, and M. D. Lumb, Chem. Phys., 1978, 33, 185.
519 H. B. Lin and M. R. Topp, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977, 47, 442.
520 H. B. Lin and M.R. Topp, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978,48, 251.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 85
tunable laser. A study of 3,4,9,10-dibenzpyrene (S, t So 3 430nm) revealed a
strong dependence of the vibrational structure of the fluorescence spectrum on the
energy of the second photon which is illustrated in Figure 24. A progression
I I I m
lnhomogeneout
width
(1460 f 60cm-') was observed in each of the spectra with an origin at the
combined photon energy and a marked trend towards a narrower bandwidth at
lower excitation energies. An additional feature was the appearance of fixed-
position emission bands for excitation R > 590. A subsequent study of 3,4-
benzpyrene showed more clearly the broadening of members of the progression,
whose origin is at the effective excitation energy, towards lower energy.52' The
general picture emerging from these studies is that a process of site selection is
taking place, as illustrated in Figure 23, which is related to the experiments on
fluorescence line-narrowing and hole-burning mentioned in an earlier section. The
very short lifetime of the fluorescence (the measured bandwidth of highest-
'
frequency band of x 300cm- gives a lower limit to the lifetime of 0.02 ps) means
that it is a unique probe of homogeneous linewidths in fluid solutions, it being faster
than the rate of molecular site exchange. The broadening observed in the
progression reflects the competition of fluorescence emission with vibrational
redistribution and internal conversion. Other features of the experiments including
the measurement of the quantum yields of this very weak fluorescence and the
shapes of the Franck-Condon envelopes of the vibrational progressions have been
52'
K . J. Choi, L. A. Halliday, H. B. Lin, and M. R . Topp in 'Picosecond Phenomena', ed. C. V. Shank,
E. P. Ippen, and S. L. Shapiro, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1978, p. 27.
86 Photochemistry
discussed,522and the use of the consecutive two-photon absorption technique to
measure the singlet-state lifetimes of weakly fluorescent molecules such as acridine
in non-polar solutions has been described. 5 2 3
50
I \I \ 550
I \ I\ 580
"/
50
/ \ j- 610
x/n m
Figure 24 Montage of high-frequencyfluorescence spectra obtained by two-laser excitation of
3,4,9,1@dibenzpyrenein hexane at 300 K . Intensities correctedfor the absorption of a single 7-54
filter. Spectra useful down to about 235 nm. Secondary excitation wavelengths are noted on the
spectra: the arrows denote the position of Jeff
(Reproduced with permission from Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977, 50, 412)
-+
demonstrate theoretically significant differences in MLPE spectra arising from
photoselection effects, shown in Figure 25 for a C+ t n transition in linear
OAbsorption
e-7
7 Absorption
,,A?.
r A b sorption
CJ-Absorption
3 -2.5 0 2.5 f
Encrgy/c m - '
Figure 25 Calculated MLPE (AI) and total emission ( I )spectra for the Zg+c ll, transition
with c-polarized molecular absorption and n-polarized molecular absorption. u = 0",
/3 = O", T = 4.2K, B = 2.5T, and A = l.Ocm-'
(Reproduced with ptrmission from J . Chem. Phys., 1978, 68, 4266)
569
M. Daniels and J. P. Morgan, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 58, 283.
570
P. R. Callis, Chem. Phys. Lett.. 1979, 61, 563.
”’ L. A. Bykovskaya, A. T. Gradyushko, R. I. Personov, Yu. V. Romanovsku, K. N. Solov’ev, A. S.
Starukhin, and A. M. Shul’ga, Zh. Prikl. Spektrosk., 1978, 29, 1088.
572
J. T. Merrill and M. K. DeArmond, J . Am. Chem. SOC.,1979, 100, 2045.
573
V. P. Lebedev and A. K. Przhevusku, Fiz. Tverd. Tela (Leningrad), 1977, 19, 2373.
574 For a general review of techniques used in the study of rotational dynamics see G. Williams and
J. Crossley, Annu. Rep. Prog. Chem., Sect. A , 1978, 74, 77.
575 For a brief review of studies of solvation phenomena using fluorescence see T. C. Werner in ‘Modern
Fluorescence Spectroscopy’, ed. E. L. Wehry, Plenum, New York, 1976, Vol. 2, p. 271.
576 K. G . Spears and L. E. Cramer, Chem. Phys., 1978, 30, 1.
577 G. R. Fleming, A. E. W. Knight, J. M. Morris, R. J. Robbins, and G. W. Robinson, Chem. Phys. Lett.,
1977, 51, 399.
”* G. R. Fleming, A. E. W. Knight, J. M. Morris, R. J. Robbins, and G. W. Robinson, Chem. Phys. letf.,
1977, 49, 1.
579
P. Wahl, Chem. Phys., 1977, 22, 245.
U. K. A. Klein and H. P. Haar, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 58, 531.
58’
W. W. Mantulin and G . Weber, J. Chem. Phys., 1977, 66, 4092.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 93
An interesting application of fluorescence polarization has been in the study of
the translational-energy dependence of product rotational energy in chemilumi-
nescent reactions.582The fluorescence polarization of XeBr* (2Z+)produced in the
reaction of Xe ( 3 P 2 )with Br, was found to increase rapidly to a limiting value of + f
as the relative energy of the colliding beams was increased from 0 1 eV. The --+
results showed that the electronic transition involved had AIR = 0 and that the
collisions tend towards spectator stripping dynamics as the energy increases. The
emission anisotropy of the fluorescent molecules 4-amino-4'-nitrosostilbene(ANS)
and 4-dimethylamino-4'-nitrosostilbene (DNS) has been shown to decrease as the
dielectric constant of the solvent increase^.'^' The effect has been interpreted in
terms of the influence of the Onsager reaction field on the volume of the solvent shell.
An apparatus suitable for the measurement of fluorescence polarization at high
pressures has been described and applied to a study of quinine sulphate in
i s o bu tan 0 1 .~~~
Difficult problems arise because of stress effects in the cell windows,
but when overcome this is a valuable method for introducing isothermal viscosity
changes.
Two interesting reviews of circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) measure-
ments in biophysics and biochemistry have appeared and include useful discussions
of the instrumentation involved.585The four parameters A, B, C, and D that
describe the magnetically induced circularly polarized luminescence (MCPL) have
been derived for certain well defined conditions for systems with C , (n > 3 )
symmetry.586 Large errors are introduced if the effects of photoselection and
reorientation are not included in the analysis. A selection rule AM = 0 for elastic
collisions of homonuclear diatomic molecules has been formulated following a
detailed study of the circular polarization ratio of resonance fluorescence doublets
for the v' = 16 level of the 3110u+ electronic state of iodine as a function of
rotational quantum number.587
The Triplet State.-Further developments and applications of a variational-plus-
perturbational method of calculating the triplet states of polyatomic molecules
have been reported.588There are two steps in the method, firstly an SCF calculation
of the triplet state wavefunction in the open-shell one-operator formalism of
Roothaan and secondly a treatment of the electronic correlation of the SCF states
by a second-order perturbation expansion. The method was applied with some
success to calculations of the lower triplet states of a number of aliphatic carbonyl
compounds and six azabenzenes. The method is limited to non-
multiconfigurational triplet states. Other developments in procedures for calculat-
ing triplet-state properties were reported in an earlier section.
582 C. T. Rettner and J. P. Simons, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 59, 178.
583 A. Kawski, J . Kukielski, and J. Kaminski, Z . Naturforsch., Teil A , 1978, 33, 1228.
s84 G . S. Chryssomallis, H. G. Drickamer, and G. Weber, J . Appl. Phys., 1978, 49, 3084.
s85 ( a ) I.Z. Steinberg, Methods Enzymol., 1978,49, 179; ( b ) I. Z . Steinberg, Annu. Rev. Biophys. Bioeng.,
1978, 7, 113.
586 K. W. Hipps, J . Phys. Chem., 1978, 82, 602.
587 S. R.Jeyes, A. J. McCaffery, M. D. Rowe, P. A. Madden, and H. Kato, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977,41,
550.
( a ) J. Leclercq and J. M. Leclercq, Chem. Phys., 1977, 22, 221; (6) J . Leclercq, P. Yvan, and J. M.
Leclercq, Chem. Phys., 1977, 22, 233.
94 Photochemistry
Ab initio CI calculations of the potential-energy surfaces of the 3Z-, 3A2,3A“,
and 3B, states of the nitrenium ion, NH,’, have been carried The results
will be useful in the interpretation of molecular-beam studies of the reaction of the
N + ion with H,. A suggestion that there is a second triplet state of trimethylene-
methane, C(CH,),, that is energetically accessible from, and of lower symmetry
than, the 3 A , state has not been substantiated by SCF calculations.590 An
interesting study of the influence of geometry on the first triplet-state energy
surfaces of linear polyenes, employing a restricted open-shell Nesbet SCF ab initio
minimal basis set, produces results in agreement with experimental cis-trans
isomerization data.’” An unrestricted Hartree-Fock method has been used to
investigate the first triplet state of methylglyoxal.592The ketonic group was found
to acquire a larger amount of unpaired spin than the aldehyde group. The influence
of substituents and of the crystal field on the triplet spin substates of benzene has
been discussed in terms of a model in which there is coupling between the lower 3b1u
and 3Elu state^."^ The structures and properties of the lowest triplet states in p-
b e n z o q ~ i n o n e , ’p-q~inones,’~’
~~ and benzoquinone ’’~5 have been investigated
theoretically, and variations in the zero-field splitting parameters of the strongly
basic lowest 3(71,11*) states of 174-diaza-aromaticshave been interpreted in terms of
proximity effects and hydrogen-bonded c o r n p l e ~ e s . ’The
~ ~ application of the
Siebrand relation between the phosphorescence lifetime and the triplet-state energy
to chlorophyll and pheophytin has been discussed,598and the influence of a trigonal
distortion on a Jahn-Teller effect in a triplet state has been considered.599
There have been several useful discussions of methods for determining triplet
quantum yields.600
Br
suggests that the effect is electronic in origin. The heavy atom introduces a number
of singlet charge-transfer states by electron transfer from the perturber to unfilled
n* orbitals of the chromophore. These states mix with the triplet states of the
chromophore through a second-order mechanism involving one-centre spin-orbit
coupling terms. The results should be compared with those of a study of the internal
heavy-atom effect given in reference 412.
Phosphorescence Polarization. The nature of the lowest triplet states and the
mechanism of phosphorescence in a series of linear polynuclear p-quinones have
been investigated using measurements of the phosphorescence spectrum, lifetime,
and polarization.618 It was found that linear annellation (addition of further
benzene rings) produced either of two regular changes in the nn* and nn* states,
depending on whether or not the addition increased or decreased the difference in
the number of rings on either side of the quinoid ring. The negative polarization of
the phosphorescence from the three isomeric hydroxypyridines and 2-meth-
,oxypyridinein EPA (5 : 5 : 2 ethyl ether, isopentane, ethyl alcohol) supports the idea
that the lowest triplet state is nn*.619 A change in the polarization of 4-
hydroxypyridine on going to alkaline EPA was attributed to the lowering of the ' B ,
state energy to take it below that of the 'A 1, the lowest state in all other cases. There
has been a series of investigations of the polarized phosphorescence spectra of
6's N. J. Turro, K. C. Liu, M. F. Chow, and P. Lee, Photochem. Photobiof., 1978, 27, 1 .
A, K. Chandra, N. J . Turro, A. L. Lyons, jun., and P. Stone, J . Am. Chem. SOC.,
1978, 100,4964.
'I8 M. Nepras and A. Novak, Collect. Czech. Chem. Commun., 1978, 42, 2343.
619
S. Hotchandani and A. C. Testa, J. Chem. Phys., 1977, 67, 5201.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical A spec ts 97
chlorophyll and chlorophyll-like molecules published.620A study of the polarized
phosphorescence of a 4-carboxybenzophenone and of benzophenone-3,3’,4,4‘-
tetracarboxylic acid dianhydride in poly(methy1 methacrylate) glasses at room
temperature has shown clearly that molecular motion is not responsible for the low
value of P observed when the ketone phosphorescence is monitored following
-
excitation of the singlet nn* absorption.621Direct excitation of the strong T , + So
absorption in the second compound gave a P value of 0.5, showing that there is
no significantrotational depolarization during the lifetime of the triplet state (2 ms).
The first measurements, using phosphorescence depolarization, of segmental
relaxation times in bulk polymer systems have been reported in a study of
poly(methy1 acrylate) containing copolymerized acenaphthylene or 1-vinyl-
naphthalene as probe molecules.6 2 2 The activation energies of the observed
relaxation processes were in excellent agreement with published values obtained
using established techniques such as dielectric relaxation.
Optically Detected Magnetic Resonance (0.d.m.r.) and Related Techniques.
Spin-lattice relaxation (SLR) rates of phosphorescent triplet states in zero field
(ZF) can be measured by optically detected magnetic resonance (0.d.m.r.)
techniques. Details of measurements using a more direct, purely optical method
have been given in which the SLR rates of the lowest triplet state of 9,lO-
anthroquinone in Shpolskii matrices were obtained from the phosphorescence
decay profile following pulsed excitation.623Another technique which can give the
magnetic and optical parameters usually obtained from 0.d.m.r. measurements, but
in the absence of perturbing radiofrequency or microwave fields, is illustrated in a
study of the 3(nn*)state of three benzophenones oriented in single crystals of 4,4’-
dibromodiphenyl ether at 1.6K.624The technique involves the measurement of the
signs, magnitudes, field positions, and widths of the changes in the phosphorescence
intensity induced by a magnetic field and which have their origin in level-
anticrossing and cross-relaxation effects. The method can give information on the
fine-structure, g , hyperfine, and quadrupole tensors of emitting paramagnetic
species.
An 0.d.m.r. study of crystalline biacetyl and a microwave-saturation
recovery, microwave-induced delayed phosphorescence (MIDP), and 0.d.m.r.
study of crystalline glyoxal and [2H2]glyoxa1626have shown that the z spin
sublevel, which is along the C-0 bond direction, is the dominant radiative decay
channel in these a-dicarbonyls. A strong temperature dependence of the spin
sublevels’ origin of the phosphorescence of the thioketone xanthione has been
found in an 0.d.m.r. At high temperatures (77K) the T,z(nn*) sublevel is
620 ( a ) S . S. Dvornikov, V. N. Knyukshto, A. N. Sevchenko, K . N. Solov’ev, and M. P. Tsvirko, Dokl.
Akad. Nauk SSSR. 1978, 240, 1457; (b) A. T. Gradyushko, S. S. Dvomikov, K. N. Solov’ev, and
M. P. Tsvirko, Zzv. Akad. Nauk SSSR, Ser. Fiz., 1978,42,511; ( c ) A . T. Gradyushko, K. N. Solov’ev,
and M. P. Tsvirko, Opt. Spektrosk., 1978,44, 1123.
621 R. Loutfy and M. A. Winnik, J . Phys. Chem., 1978, 82, 1304.
622 (a) H. Rutherford and I. Soutar, J . Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed., 1977, 15,2213; ( b ) H. Rutherford
and I. Soutar, J . Polym. Sci., Polym. Lett, Ed., 1978, 16, 131.
623 R. Avarmaa and A. Suisalu, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977, 52, 567.
624 J . A. Mucha and D . W. Pratt, J . Chem. Phys., 1977,66, 5356.
625 I . Y. Chan and S. Hsi, Mol. Phys., 1977, 34, 85.
I . Y. Chan and K. R. Walton, Mol. Phys., 1977, 34, 65.
A. H. Maki, P. Svejda, and J . R. Huber, Chem. Phys., 1978, 32, 369.
98 Photochemistry
the principal source of the short-lived red emission, but at low temperatures the ISC
process preferentially populates the T , x and T,y sublevels, and the phosphores-
cence originates from them instead. A study of the emission wavelength dependence
of the ZF splitting parameters of the triplet state of the amino-acid tryptophan and
several of its derivatives has revealed strong discontinuities, illustrated in Figure 26,
nm
628
A. L. Kwiram, J . B. A. Ross, and D. A. Deranleau, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 54, 506.
629 J. B. A. Alexander, K . W. Rousslang, A. G. Motten, and A. L. Kwiram, Biochemistry, 1979,18,1808.
630 C . Von Borcyzyskowski, M. Plato, K . P. Dinse, and K. Moebius, Chem. Phys., 1978, 35, 355.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 99
reported of the triplet states of chlorophyll b molecules, 6 3 1 of the chlorophyll
protein 668,632of chlorophyll d i m e r ~and ~ ~palladium p ~ r p h i nA. study
, ~ of ~ ~ ~ of
zinc etipporphyrin has illustrated the point that the absolute rate constants for
individual triplet sublevels can be obtained from measurements of the
phosphorescence- and the fluorescence-detected o.d.m.r., an emission intensity,
and the phosphorescence quantum yield.635
The origins of the large variations in the magnetic and dynamic properties of the
3n71* states of aromatic carbonyls have been explored in a combined 0.d.m.r. and
MIDP study of substituted 1-indanones and related molecules.6 3 6 Substantial
differences in the T , properties of the 1-indanones and benzaldehydes were found
which were attributed to lower spin-orbit coupling matrix elements between 3n71*
and 37171* states in the indanones relative to those in benzaldehydes, and to a
reduced direct mixing of 3n7r* and 37r7r* states in the indanones due to their more
rigid planar structure. Zeeman PMDR measurements on duraldehyde have shown
that a consistent model of the results can be achieved by including an S , T , ISC
process, where T , is an HCHO-like n7r* state, in addition to an S , + T , ISC
process.637Estimates of the vibronic mixing coefficients indicate that the T , state
has x 20% m*character. Intramolecular heavy-atom effects in 9,lO-dichlorophen-
anthrene and 1,2,3,4-tetrachloronaphthalenehave been investigated using PMDR
techniques,638 and a MIDP study of p-H,C,(CN), and a number of its charge-
transer complexes has shown that the shortening of the phosphorescent lifetime in
the latter arises from a change in the non-radiative decay constant of the shortest-
lifetime MIDP studies of the triplet states in pyrazine640 and p-
xylene 6 4 1 have also been reported.
Electron Spin Resonance (e.s.r.).The effects which arise in e.s.r. experiments on the
photoexcited triplet states of aromatic molecules because of phase coherence
between individual spin sublevels have been described,642 and a theoretical
treatment of rotary echoes in photoexcited triplet states has been published.643 A
study of the photoexcited triplet states in tetraphenyl chlorin and magnesium
tetraphenyl porphyrin using a light-modulated e.s.r. technique have indicated that
the electron spin polarization signals previously observed from chlorophylls in vitro
arise from the chlorin ring.644 A fast laser-flash e.s.r. technique has been used to
determine the triplet spin sublevel decay rates in Rhodopseudomonas
~ ’ of 6500 s- for k , and k, and 1800 s- fork,, which compare
~ p h a e r o i d e s . ~Values
Relative Experimental
Molecule energy cm - v,, x 104cm-1 pT x 10-3cm N NVsT x lo3 p,(exp)/p;(calc.)
G1yoxal 0 5.1 0.3 0.46 0.23 5.3
926 2.2 2.1 4.4 1.o 15
Methylglyoxal 0 1.6 2.7 3.8 0.62 10
1076 0.64 18.4 27 1.7 12
2084 0.34 70 110 3.7 8.2
Biacetyl 0 0.23 130 175 4.0 12
1011 0.15 300 420 6.3 2.7
Pyrimidine 0 5.8 0.92 5.6 3.2 115
1012 3.1 6.1 73 23 113
2024 1.8 18.4 226 41 55
* The data for glyoxal, methyglyoxal, and biacetyl were obtained from refs. ( a H c ) .The p i is the vibronic density. Values are selected to show the range of parameters for those
states that have larger than gas kinetic self quenching. This is the ‘black hole’ region defined by ref. (c).
(a) R. van der Werf, E. Schutten, and J. Kommandeur, Chem. Phys., 1976, 16, 151. ( b ) R. van der Werf, E. Schutten, and J. Kommandeur, Chem. Phys., 1975,11, 281.
( c ) R. van der Werf and J. Kommandeur, Chem. Phys., 1976, 16, 125.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 103
z x 40 ns) expected for intermediate-case molecules. The observed decreases in the
fluorescence yield of the slow component on methyl substitution and on increasing
the excitation energy are readily understandable in terms of the increasing numbers
of triplet vibronic levels effectively coupled to the fluorescent singlet level. The data
for molecules in which a quantitative analysis of dual fluorescence decays has been
undertaken, i.e. pyrimidine and the dicarbonyls glyoxal, methylglyoxal, and
biacetyl, are collected together in Table 6. The strong pressure dependence of the
lifetime of the slow component has been discussed,661and the SVL fluorescence
lifetimes of several vibronic levels of s-triazine have been measured.662
0
00
0
0
0
0 I I I I I I I
0 50 100
picot cco n d
Figure 27 The risetimes of wavelength-resolved pigment fluorescence in P. cruentum. Each
curve was measured separately with interference filters as wavelength selection filters and
aligned on the time axis. BPE is B-phycoerythrin, RPC is R-phycocyanin, APC is
allophycocyanin, and C H L is chlorophyll a. Fluorescence intensity is on a normalized linear
scale.
(Reproduced with permission from Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 1978, 501, 232)
683
H . C . Brenner, J. C . Brock, and C . B. Harris, Chern. Phys., 1978, 31, 137.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 107
complex.684Energy-transfer quenching processes involving an exchange mechan-
ism have been treated by an extension of the Marcus-Weller theory and applied to
available experimental data on energy transfer from aromatic triplets to biacetyl
and to O - a n i ~ i l . ~ ~ ~
Singlet-state Quenching.-A sequence of papers has considered the problem of
partly diffusion-controlled reactions in which there is a competition between a
chemical or physical process and the physical process of diffusion. In particular the
problem of fluorescence quenching is considered where a particular manifestation
of this competition is known, namely, the consistently lower values of cr', the
reaction distance, calculated from time-resolved quenching experiments compared
with those from steady-state experiments.686This discrepancy is illustrated by the
results in Table 7 for the fluorescence quenching of 1,2-benzanthracene by CBr,. As
Table 7 Values of cr and D which give the bestjts to decay curves vrom Nemzek and
Ware) and to steady-state experiment of I ,2-benzanthracene quenched by
CBr, in propanediol
o'/A D/ 1O6 cm2 s - '
CBr, concentration/moldm- 15 "C 25 "C 35 "C 15°C 25°C 35°C
From decay curves
0.098 9.0 8.5 8.5 0.23 0.50 0.88
0.18 9.0 9.0 8.0 0.24 0.44 0.95
0.29 8.0 7.0 7.0 0.28 0.66 1.1
Steady-state experiments (classical model)
11.2 - - 0.287 - -
a first attempt to account for this discrepancy a simple model was proposed in
which there are two reaction regions surrounding an activated molecule A*:
(i) A region between r = cr, the collision distance of fluorophore and quencher,
and r = d,the reaction distance in which the effective reaction rate constant
is infinite. The concentration of the quencher B in this region is zero and there
is, therefore, no diffusion of B.
(ii) The region r > cr' in which there is no reaction but there is a net diffusion of B
towards the boundary, r = cr'.
It can be seen that on the basis of this model the static effect, in which A*,B pairs
where cr < rB < cr' instantly disappear, will not be observed in time-resolved
experiments but will contribute to steady-state experiments. As shown in Table 7
the inclusion of this static term results in excellent agreement between the cr' values
calculated using the two experimental methods. This simple model was sub-
sequently developed to consider the competition between the true chemical rate of
reaction and the diffusion of the reactants.687The later model assumes that k(r),the
rate constant at r , has a constant value k for cr < r < cr' and is negligible for
600 J. C.Andre, M. Bouchy, and W. R.Ware, Chem. Phys., 1979, 37, 119.
689 K. M. Hong and J. Noolandi, J. Chem. Phys., 1978, 68, 5163.
690 K. M. Hong and J. Noolandi, J. Chem. Phys., 1978,68, 5172.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 109
difficulties which arise in the interpretation of steady-state fluorescence quenching
experiments in micellar systems.691It is shown that the time dependence of the
quencher distribution can significantly alter the value of the detergent-aggregation
number calculated from the quenching results. The cases of ‘mobile’ and ‘immobile’
quencher distribution can significantly alter the value of the detergent-aggregation
not exchange with the surrounding solvent, respectively? on the time-scale of the
quenching process.
Triplet-state quenching.-A continuation of the theme in the previous section
concerning the competition between, for example, a quenching reaction and
diffusion may be found in an interesting paper on the temperature dependence of
the ratio of delayed monomer and delayed excimer fluorescence following
triplet-triplet annihilation in fluid media. 6 9 2 A model which included two
annihilation processes was found to reproduce the experimental temperature
dependence in solutions of pyrene in ethanol with realistic parameters. The first
process was a simple solvent cage encounter to give excited monomer ‘M* or
excimer ‘D* from the reactions 3M* + 3M* + ‘D* and 3M* + 3M* +
‘M + ‘M*, full allowance being made for the possibility of re-encounter in the
second reaction using a Noyes-type treatment to give additional excimer fluores-
cence. As formulated by the authors this process alone was unable to account for
the temperature dependence. The second annihilation process included in the
analysis involved a long-range mechanism whose probability falls off exponentially
with distance and thus can be associated with a Dexter-type exchange interaction.
The success of the model combining these two processes indicates that a long-range
interaction could be taking place, but as the authors point out distance de-
pendencies other than an exponential may possibly be equally successful. The
underlying assumptions in this and earlier treatments of triplet-triplet annihilation
have been discussed. 6 9 3 The author suggests that the contribution of re-encounters
to the intensity of delayed excimer fluorescence could usefully be investigated in
anisotropic media such as a phospholipid bilayer where the solute diffusion is
essentially in a plane. Very large values of the excimer/monomer delayed
fluorescence intensity ratio can be anticipated in such media. The nature of the
interaction which results in delayed fluorescence emission from the encounter
complex formed by two triplet excited species has been discussed. 694 The roles of
charge-transfer and excimer states were both considered.
”’ ( a )J . Michl, A . Castellan, M. A. Souto, and J . Kolc, Jerusalem Symp. Quantum Chem. Biochem., 1977,
10, 361; (b) see for example M. A . Souto, J . Kolc, and J . Michl, J . Am. Chem. Soc., 1978, 100, 6692.
C. Sandorfy, Prog. Theor. Org. Chem., 1977, 2, 384.
’*’
lZ2
L. G. Vanquickenborne and A. Ceulemans, J . A m . Chem. SOC.,1978, 100, 475.
lZ4 H. P. Kelley, J . Phys. (Paris), Cofloq.,1978, 16.
725
F. C. Farnoux, J . Phys. (Paris), Colloq., 1978, 64.
lZ6 NATO Advanced Study Institute Series, ed. F. J. Wuilleumier, Plenum, New York, Vol. B18, 1976.
727 S. Nordholq, J . Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom.. 1979, 15, 109.
P. R . Hilton: S. Nordholm, and N. S. Hugh, J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 67, 5213.
lZ9 D. M. Chipman, Int. J . Quantum Chem., Symp., 1977, 11, 365.
730 P. W . Langhoff, Int. J . Quantum Chem., Symp., 1977, 11, 301.
73’ I . Hubac and V. Kvasnicka, Croat. Chem. Acta, 1977, 49, 677.
732 N. Chandra, J. Phys. B., 1977, 10, L489.
733 E. S. Chang, J. Phys. B, 1978, 11, L293.
734 A. F. Starace, Phys. Rev. A , 1977, 16, 231.
735 A. Goldberg and B. W. Shore, J . Phys. 8, 1978, 11, 3339.
736 J. R. Ackerhalt, Phys. Rev. A , 1978, 17, 293.
737 P. G. Burke in ‘Atomic Processes and Applications’, ed. P. G. Burke and B. L. Moiseiwitsch, North-
Holland, Amsterdam, Netherlands, 1976, p. 199.
738 V. S. Letokhov, V. 1. Mishin, and A. A. Puretskii, Prog. Quantum Electron., 1977, 5, Pt. 3, 139.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical A spec ts 113
An investigation of the resonant ionization of atoms by an intense electromagnetic
wave has resulted in an expression for the resonance width which is valid for light
pulses of arbitrary intensity, duration, and shape.739A paper has considered the
interaction that occurs between the radiative decay of an excited atomic state and a
possible autoionization decay mode of the state.740 The interaction can affect the
excitation profile of the excited state, its fluorescence yield, and the spectra of the
emitted photons and electrons. Significant effects on the alignment of ions in atomic
photoionization have been found when many-electron correlations are included in
calculations,741 and a new model for double photoionization has been proposed
which involves configuration mixing between a double ionization continuum and
an inner-shell excitation ionization channel, thus avoiding the necessity of an
intermediate autoionizing state.7 4 2 The appearance of quantum beats in the
ionization signal from an alkali-metal atom has been treated theoretically by
considering a coherent superposition of the D3/2,5/2fine-structure levels.743In the
treatment the levels are excited by a two-photon resonant pulse and subsequently
photoionized by a delayed probe pulse.
Of the numerous experimental investigations of atomic photoionization mention
is made only of a few studies of photoionization in the presence of an electric field
because of their wider interest in relation to laser-induced selective ionization. Such
studies are exemplified by two recent studies of the photoionization of rubidium
atoms in which narrow field-dependent resonance structures were observed. 745 7449
Attention has been drawn recently to similarities between spectral effects and non-
linearities in the photoionization of atoms in d.c. discharges by low-intensity light
and in the breakdown of gases with high-intensity lasers. 746 Interesting observ-
ations have been made in experiments on Rydberg atoms which are consistent with
there being photoionization of such highly excited atoms by 300K background
blackbody radiation.747
Molecules. A number of modifications to the orthogonalized-plane-wave ap-
proximation used to calculate molecular photoionization cross-sections have been
suggested, 748 and a considerable improvement in the agreement between experi-
mental photoionization cross-sections and those calculated using the plane-wave
method can be brought about by assuming the photoelectron's energy equals that
of the incident photon.749A two-centre treatment has been used to calculate the
photoionization cross-sections for the ui = 0-14 vibrational levels of the X'C,,ui,
state of hydrogen for a range of photon energies,75oand the breakdown of the
73')
M . V. Fedorov, J . Phys. B, 1977, 10, 2573.
740
L. Armstrong, jun., C. E. Theodosiou, and M . J . Wall, Phys. Rev. A , 1978, 18, 2538.
741
E. G. Berezhko, V. K. Ivanov, and N. M . Kabachnik, Phys. Lert. A , 1978, 66, 474.
742
J . P. Connerade, J . Phys. B, 1977, 10, L239.
743 A. T. Georges and P. Lambropoulos, Phys. Rev. A , 1978, 18, 1072.
744 R. R. Freeman, N. P. Economou, G . C. Bjorklund, and K . T. Lu, Phys. Rev. Lert., 1978,41, 1463.
745 S. Feneuille, S. Liberman, J. Pinard, and P. Jacquinot, C. R . Hebd. Seances Acad. Sci., Ser. B, 1977,
284, 291.
746 N. S. Kopeika, G. Eytan, and A. P. Kushelevsky, J . Appl. Phys., 1979, 50, 1 1 .
747
E. J. Beitung, G. F. Hildebrandt, F. G . Kellert, G. W. Foltz, K. A. Smith, F. B. Dunning, and R . F.
Stebbings, J . Chern. Phys., 1979, 70, 3551.
"* T. Fujikawa, T. Ohta, and H. Kuroda, J . Electron Spectrosc. Refat. Phenorn., 1979, 16, 285.
749
M. 3. M. Beerlage and D. Feil, J . Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Plienom.. 1977, 12, 161.
750 H. Tai and M . R . Flannery, Phys. Rev. A , 1977, 16, 1124.
114 Photochemistry
independent particle, MO, picture of ionization has been demonstrated in a study of
the photoionization of the valence electrons of carbon monosulphide, phosphorous
mononitride, and diphosphorus, using a two-particle-hole approximation.7 5
Some very interesting experimental studies of the photoionization of van der
Waals molecules and clusters have been published. Measurements of the photo-
ionization efficiency curves for several heteronuclear rare-gas van der Waals
molecules have amongst other things made it possible to determine the potential
energy of the excited molecular Rydberg state at a distance which corresponds to
the equilibrium interatomic distance of the ground-state van der Waals mole-
c ~ l e . ~The
’ ~ proton affinities of water and hydrogen fluoride have been
determined in a study of the photoionization of the corresponding dimeric
molecules,7s3and the proton affinity of ammonia and the proton solvation energies
by more than one NH, molecule have been measured in similar studies using this
molecular beam-photoionization method. 5 4 An interesting comparison has been
published of the photoionization energies of neutral and ionic species on going from
the gas phase to the liquid phase.755For the change from gas to liquid phase the
values for neutral species exhibit a 1-2eV red shift and for charged species a
2-3 eV blue shift.
Multiphoton Ionization. A number of papers on both the theoretical and experi-
mental aspects of multiphoton ionization have appeared in the published proceed-
ings of an international conference.756A dressed-atom model for the calculation of
multiphoton ionization rates has been extended by the inclusion of continuum as
well as bound atomic states,7s7 and a method for deriving rate equations from
Bloch equations known as the Wilcox-Lamb method has been illustrated by
considering both two- and three-level atom cases.7s8 In the latter study the
differences between the cases of copropagating and counterpropagating laser
excitation beams were discussed. A perturbation theory approach to the calculation
of multiphoton ionization cross-sections of complex atoms has been proposed and
illustrated by calculations on the helium atom. 59 Semiclassical expressions for the
radiative collision-induced two-photon ionization of atoms have been derived. 7 6 0
The results indicate that the process will provide a sensitive method of studying
radiative collisions.
The apparent disagreement between some of the experimental and theoretical
aspects of laser multiphoton ionization and which has raised the possibility that
such processes are sequential multi-step processes has been The
unusual intensity dependences of laser-induced molecular multiphoton ionization
75’ 1. Schirmer, W. Domcke, L. S. Cederbaum, and W. Von Niessen, J . Phys. B, 1978, 11, 1901.
752 C. Y. Ng, P. W. Tiedemann, B. H. Mahan, and Y. T . Lee, J . Chem. Phys., 1977,66, 5737.
753 C. Y. Ng, D. J. Trevor, P. W. Tiedemann, S. T. Ceyer, P. L. Kronebusch, B. H . Mahan, and Y . T. Lee,
J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 67, 4253.
754 S. T. Ceyer, P. W. Tiedemann, B. H. Mahan, and Y . T. Lee, J . Chem. Phvs., 1979, 70, 14.
755 L. Nemec, L. Chia, and P. Delahay, Can. J . Chem., 1977, 55, 1820.
756 ‘Multiphoton Processes’, ed. J . H. Eberly and P. Lambropoulos, Wiley, New York, 1977 (publ. 1978).
757 S. Chu and W. P. Reinhardt, Phys. Rev. Lett., 1977, 39, 1195.
758 J . R. Ackerhalt and B. W. Shore, Phys. Rev. A , 1977, 16, 277.
75y B. Ritchie, Phys. Rev. A , 1977, 16, 2080.
7h0
M. H. Nayfeh and M. G . Payne, Phys. Rev. A , 1978, 17, 1695.
76’ A. P. Kushelevsky and N. S. Kopeika, IEEE J . Quantum Electron., 1977, 13, 737.
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 115
processes have been nicely illustrated in a recent study using a K r F excimer laser
(249 nm) for excitation and a time-of-flight mass spectrometer for detection.762
Photodetachment. Accurate calculations of the photodetachment cross-section of
the hydride ion, H-, that use a perturbation-variation method have been
published.763 A simpler approach to the calculation of this quantity has been
proposed in which a discrete-basis-set expansion is used to represent both the
ground and the continuum states of the system.764An extended asymptotic model
for the calculation of photodetachment cross-sections for alkali anions has been
proposed in which certain assumptions are made regarding the form of the alkali-
anion valence orbital and the alkali-anion 1-wave continuum states.765
Photodetachment energies for the amidogen, NH, - , 7 6 6 and silylene, SiH, - 7 6 7
anions have been calculated using large basis sets, and the photodetachment cross-
section of the fluoride ion, F- ,has been calculated using a Stieltjes imaging method
which involves discrete basis functions only.768It has been pointed out that a beam
of completely polarized electrons can be obtained from an experiment in which the
negative ions of the halogens suffer photodetachment by a beam of circularly
polarized light.769For the photodetachment of I - near threshold the process may
be represented as in equation (19). The first observations of resonances in the
h v + I - ( p 6 lS,) --+ (I+e, lP1) + I(%,Z, 1,2)+e(2s,,2) (19)
photodetachment cross-section of a molecular negative ion at threshold have been
made in a study of the acetophenone enolate anion.770The widths of the resonances
(0.7-0.8nm) gave a lower limit for the lifetime of the autodetaching state of
10- l 3 s. Resonances have also been observed in the photodetachment cross-
sections of the alkali-halide negative ions NaCl - , NaBr - , and NaI - , well above
threshold.771
Electron Transfer.-A recent analysis of experimental values for the rate constants
of excited-state electron-transfer quenching reactions has shown that there are
serious disagreements with the predictions of the well known model due to Marcus
( 1956).772The theory of a new method for investigating reversible excited-state
electron-transfer reactions has been presented.773In the technique simultaneous
measurement is possible of the thermal back-electron-transfer rate constant and the
probability of detectable excited-state electron transfer per quenching encounter.
The possible importance of an abnormal orbital interaction in excited-state
electron-transfer reactions has been and in connection with electron-
transfer processes in biological systems such as occur in photosynthesis and
7h2 S. Rockwood, J. P. Reilly, K. Hohla, and K . L. Kompa, Opt. Commun., 1979, 28, 175.
7h3 A. L. Stewart, J . Phys. B, 1978, 11, 3851.
764 M . A. C. Nascimento and W. A . Goddard, tert., Phys. Rev. A , 1977, 16, 1559.
7 6 5 G. Lamm, A. Szabo, and S. A. Adelman, Phys. Rev. A , 1978, 17, 238.
7 6 h M . M. Heaton, J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 67, 2925.
lb7
M.M . Heaton, J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 67, 5396.
l h A T. N. Resagno, C. F. Bender, and B. V. McKoy, Phys. Rev. A , 1978, 17, 645.
7hy
A. R. P. Rau, Phys. Letr. A , 1978, 64, 367.
7 7 0 A. H. Zimmerman and J. I . Brauman, J . Chem. Phys., 1977, 66,5823.
77’ S. E. Novick, P. L. Jones, T. J . Mulloney, and W. C . Lineberger, J . Chem. Phys., 1979, 70, 2210.
7’2 M . T. lndelli and F. Scandola, J . Am. Chem. Soc., 1978, 100, 7733.
7 7 3 C. A . Wight, tert., T. J. Turley, and J. N. Demas, J . Chem. Phys., 1978, 68, 5486.
There have been further reports of the magnetic quenching of the fluorescence of
molecules in the gas phase. A study of the pressure dependence of the fluorescence
quenching of gaseous glyoxal has revealed two regions of behaviour of the collision-
free lifetime on the magnetic-field strength.832For fields above 5 k G it took a
constant value greater than the no-field value, and for fields below 5 kG it was a
function of the field strength. The results were explained in terms of a direct
mechanism in which the field introduced a Zeeman term to the interaction. A
parallel study of protonated and deuteriated glyoxal by a different research group
reached different conclusions regarding the collision-free lifetimes.8 3 3 They found
them to be unaffected by the presence of the field. There has been a useful discussion
of the magnetic quenching of luminescence in relation to the electronic structure of
E. J . Broomhead and K . A. McLauchlan, J . Chem. Soc.. Faraday Trans. 2, 1978, 74, 775.
N . J . Turro and B. Kraeutler, J . Am. Chem. Soc., 1978, 100, 7432.
N . Hata, Chem. Lett.. 1978, 1359.
0 . G. Kadnikov and V. I . Kobizskoi, Pis’ma Zh. Tekh. Fiz., 1978, 4, 1367.
K . Lendi, Chem. Phys. Lett.. 1977, 50, 485.
”’
82b
R . C. Johnson, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1977, 49, 85.
K . R . Naqvi, H. Van Willigen, and D. A. Capitanio, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 57, 197.
829 H. J . Werner, K . Schulten, and A. Weller, Biochim. Biophys. Acta. 1978, 502, 255.
830 H. G. De Vries and A. J. Hoff, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 55, 395.
83’ V. M. Voznyak, E. I. Elfinov, and I. I . Proskuryakov, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR, 1978, 242, 1200.
A. Matsuzaki and S. Nagakura, Helv. Chim. Acta. 1978, 61, 675.
833 ( a ) H. G . Kuettner, H. L. Selzle, and E. W. Schlag, fsr. J . Chem., 1977,16,264; ( b ) Chem. Phys. Lett.,
1977,48, 207; ( c ) Chem. Phys., 1978, 28, 1 .
Spectroscopic and Theoretical Aspects 121
molecules.834 The effect is expected to be weak for aromatic hydrocarbons but
strong for molecules where the singlet and triplet states have n-n* character and are
mixed by a spin-orbit interaction. Unfortunately lack of space has prevented any
reportage of Zeeman- and Hanle-effect studies.
Chemically Induced Dynamic Magnetic Polarization.-The techniques of chemi-
cally induced dynamic electron (nuclear) polarization, CIDE(N)P, are now well
established, and the papers reported on here have been selected for their general
interest. A perturbational treatment of radical-pair theory has been used as a basis
for the discussion of the field dependence of the CIDNP effect at low fields
( < 1 kG),835and the same author has suggested the use of a new exit-channel
parameter to remove an ambiguity in the interpretation of CIDNP spectra when the
radical pair leads to the triplet state of the reaction
There have been several interesting applications of CIDNP to systems of
biological interest. Recent studies have shown that photo-CIDNP can be of use in
determining structural information in native proteins. A study of porcine
pancreatic phospholipase A, and its precursor found nuclear spin polarization
signals from the tryptophan-3 and tyrosine-69 and -123 residues, the first two of
which are located in the phospholipid binding site.837In a related study the CIDNP
spectra of the simple aromatic amino-acids were first established to help interpret
the results of photo-CIDNP studies on bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor, RNase
A, RNase S, and l y s ~ z y m eA. ~particularly
~~ interesting study of bovine pancreatic
trypsin inhibitor has been published in which a laser was used to excite a dye, 3-N-
carboxymethyl lumiflavin, in a dye-protein solution.839Photo-CIDNP signals were
observed which were attributable to two surface tyrosine residues, -10 and -21.
CIDMP measurements in biological systems have been discussed in a brief
review.840
CIDNP effects have been able to distinguish two mechanisms in the electron-
transfer-photosensitized isomerization of styrene derivatives.841 Donor styrenes
were found to rearrange in the radical cation whereas acceptor styrenes rearrange in
a non-planar triplet state. A CIDNP study has proved valuable in studying the
initial stages of a photoinduced polymerization reaction in which the photoinitiator
was an a l k o x y a ~ e t o p h e n o n eand
, ~ ~an
~ acid-base equilibrium has been observed in
the photo-CIDNP of nitroaromatic compounds.843 The photoreductions of
benzophenone by thio ethers,844uethyl s ~ l p h i d eand , ~ ~secondary
~~ alcohols 845
have all been investigated by CIDNP. A study of the electron-transfer quenching of
photoexcited aryl alkyl ketones has revealed the presence of concentration- and
"""' A. B. Demyashkevich, N. K. Zaitsev, and M. G. Kus'min, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1978, 55, 80.
Kobayashi, J . Phys. Chem., 1978, 82, 2277.
'" T.S. G. Schulman, L. S. Rosenberg, and W. R. Vincent,jun., J . Am. Chem. SOC.,1979, 101, 139.
8b3
H. Shizuka, K. Matsui, Y.Hirata, and I . Tanaka, J . Phys. Chem., 1977, 81, 2243.
864
P. Gangola, N. B. Joshi, and D. D. Pant, Chem. Phys. Lett., 1979, 60,329.
S. E. Morsi and J . 0. Williams, J . Chem. SOC.,Perkin Trans. 2, 1978, 1280.