Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RESEARCH (Manuscript)
RESEARCH (Manuscript)
CAGAYAN”
By:
Iringan, Richel
Sibayan, Clyvelanda I.
2023
1|Page
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
Table of Contents
Introduction………………………………………………
Conceptual Framework……………………………………
Definition of Terms………………………………………
Research Design…………………………
Research participants/respondents … … … …. … … ..
Research Instrument………………………………………
2|Page
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
Farmers are one of the country's assets which have a crucial role in our society. They
are known as a provider of foods which nourishes human to live. They also have great
contribution to the economy and employment of the country especially to rural areas.
However, countries around the world have suffered from huge economic losses due to
the occurrence of natural disasters, and current agricultural production systems worldwide are
under serious threat (IPCC, 2022). According to the data from the Centre for Research on the
Epidemiology of Disasters, global economic losses caused by natural disasters reached 210.1
billion US dollars in 2017, 49% higher than the historical average (Mohamed et al., 2015;
crops like rice, coconut and sugar which dominate the production of crops and exports.
Moreover, it employs 23% of the Filipino workforce as of 2021, according to the World
Bank.
The Philippines, however, is among the hardest hit in Southeast Asia by natural
disasters such as typhoons, floods, and droughts. On the report of Asian Disaster Reduction
Center (ADRC) it is for the reason that is located along the typhoon belt in the Pacific, the
Philippines is visited by an average of 20 typhoons every year, five of which are destructive.
Being situated in the “Pacific Ring of Fire” makes it vulnerable to frequent earthquakes and
volcanic eruptions. Its geographical location and physical environment also contribute to its
3|Page
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
The frequent occurrence of disasters such as typhoons, floods, and landslides has a
significant impact on the agriculture sector, which employs nearly a third of the country’s
labor force. Small-scale farmers, who make up the majority of the agricultural workforce, are
particularly vulnerable to the effects of disasters due to their limited resources and poor
As of 2010 to 2019, the Philippine Statistics Authority reported that the damages
incurred due to natural extreme events and disasters are amounted to Php. 463 billion.
Agriculture posted the largest share with 62.7 percent or Php. 290 billion followed by
infrastructure, and private/communications with 23.0 percent or Php106 billion and 14.3
percent or Php. 66 billion respectively which implies Philippine agriculture has always been
Hence, Carallangan is not exempted to these catastrophic events particularly due to its
its vulnerability to natural disasters such as floods and typhoons. Apart from that, farming is
the primary source of income for most of the residents of Carallangan as the larger portion of
the land area is used for agricultural production such as crops like palay (oryza sativa) and
corns. As a result, indigent farmers in rural area like Carallangan whose livelihood which
mostly depend agricultural production are more likely experiencing threats as well as the
reductions to agricultural productivity which have significant impacts on their food security,
nutrition, income, and well-being. The impact of disasters on farmers’ subsistence potential
4|Page
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
disaster management policies, and the availability of resources to mitigate the effects of
disasters.
uncertainties, variable weather, and natural hazards but to survive from these disasters are
still a big challenge to indigent farmers due to lack of diverse coping strategies, limited
resources for disaster response and rebuilding, and insufficient hazard and disaster risk data
and information.
Furthermore, disasters are not expected and predicted by all people worldwide, and
natural disasters are frequently beyond human control. Therefore, farmers must learn to
“coexist with disasters” in their relations with nature; developing their resiliency and
strengthening their capabilities in surviving certain phenomena that harshly affect their
livelihood and/is crucial to mitigate and effectively recover from the impact of the disasters.
Thus, this study is of great relevance as it aims to determine the level of subsistence potential
This study aims to ascertain the Level of Subsistence Potential on Disaster among the
5|Page
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
1.1 Age
1.2 Gender
2. What are the impacts of the disaster to the indigent farmers in terms of:
3. Is there a significant relationship on the profile of the respondents and their level of
subsistence potential?
6|Page
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
HYPOTHESIS
There is no significant relationship on the profile of the respondents and their level of
subsistence potential.
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
INDEPENDENT VIRIABLE
1.2 Gender
Attainment
Experience
The researchers use the independent and dependent model to signify the relationship
of variables of this study. The arrow signifies the relationship that the researcher is looking
7|Page
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
forward to, as the arrow’s direction leads toward the dependent variable. Moreover, the
independent variable of this study was the profile of the respondents while the dependent
The general intent of this study is to know the level of subsistence potential on disasters
among indigent farmers of Carallangan, Alcala, Cagayan with a particular emphasis on how
The study’s main objective is to identify the various effects of disasters that have an
impact on indigent farmers’ level of subsistence potential. Additionally, this study seeks to
determine how the researchers help farmers become resilient in recognizing and coping with
This study will be conducted with limited financial resources and time framework.
This study is further expected that this would provide vital information to the
following:
Administration and Management of the Barangay. The research findings and results that
will be reported in this study will provide the management of the barangay with more reliable
and effective ways of motivating and evaluating the level of academic motivation of the
students.
8|Page
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
Alcala Municipal Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Office (MDRRMO). The
results of this study may serve as a basis of information of the MDRRMO as they could
provide support and resources to indigent farmers in Barangay Carallangan to prepare for,
respond to, and reduce the risk of disasters. Their involvement in the study could provide
valuable insights into the disaster management practices in the municipality and how they
Department of Agriculture (DA). The results of this study may serve as a basis of
information for the improvement of policies, recommendations, and supervision that would
improve the subsistence potential level of indigent farmers which would then contribute to
Local Government Unit (LGU) of Alcala. This study can provide LGU’s with important
information that can help them better understand the experiences of indigent farmers during
disasters and develop effective disaster management policies and programs that are tailored to
the specific needs of these populations. This can help improve the resilience of indigent
farmers of barangay Carallangan and ensure that they are better equipped to cope with the
impacts of disasters.
Farmers. This study shall provide the indigent farmers with an opportunity to evaluate
themselves with regards to their level of subsistence potential on disasters, hence, may lead to
Researcher. This study can help the researchers to be aware and could contribute to the
9|Page
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
potential and coping strategies in disaster-prone areas. Hopefully, the researchers will be
Future Researcher. This study can help future researchers in collecting information easier
and faster. The results of this study would serve as a basis for parallel studies to be
conducted.
DEFINITION OF TERMS
Agriculture - The art and science of cultivating the soil, growing crops, and raising
livestock. It includes the preparation of plant and animal products for people to use and their
distribution to markets.
Coping Mechanisms - This refers to the strategies, thoughts, and behaviors people often use
in the face of stress and/or trauma to help manage painful or difficult emotions, internal or
Disaster - It is a phenomenon that causes threat to people such as loss of property, food
scarcity.
Indigent Farmers - This refers to indigent individual whose sole source of income is
agriculture, who cultivate or till of the land whether as owner or lessee of the land or who
engage in crop.
Resilience - The process and outcome of successfully adapting to difficult or challenging life
experiences, especially through mental, emotional, and behavioral flexibility and adjustment
10 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
Rural Area - It refers to the open countryside with population densities less than 500 people
per square mile and places with fewer than 2,500 people.
Chapter II
as these do not only give an idea on the work done in the past and assist in the delineation of
problem area but also provide the bases for interpretation and discussion of findings. An
association with earlier relatable research studies would aid the researcher to build up a better
understanding of the present problem. The following literatures aided the researchers in
realizing the objectives of this study and that is to determine the Level of Subsistence
Philippines ranked third among all the countries with the highest disaster risks
worldwide. Beltrán, A., Maddison, D., and Elliott, R. J. R., (2018) believed that areas with a
high incidence of natural disasters may be more seriously struck by poverty because
impoverished people prefer to settle in these areas, such as low-lying areas of cities with
Bayudan-Dacuycuy and Lim, (2013) studied the influencing factors of short- and
long-term poverty in the Philippines. The study results show that natural disasters directly
lead to or aggravate short-term poverty of households affected by natural disasters, while the
11 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
unemployment and illnesses of family members due to natural disasters result in long-term
household poverty.
The devastated areas and the general populace are adversely affected in terms of the
economy and ecology by these natural disasters. Furthermore, because they are constantly
exposed to natural disasters and their unfavorable effects, the agriculture and natural resource
industries are extremely vulnerable. It is imperative for the Filipinos, especially the
agriculture sector to make interventions to at least minimize the loss as natural disasters
cannot be prevented.
Parallel to this, each year, natural disasters cost Filipino farmers billions of pesos, yet
their courage, optimism, and faith enable them to recover (Shah, S. H., et al. 2017). The
drastic drop in farm income caused by natural disasters forced many farmers to look for
alternative sources of income, such as raising livestock, growing other crops, interplanting
Carter, Little, and Mogues (2005) demonstrated that natural disasters are likely to trap
households into long-term poverty by exploring the influences of drought and hurricanes on
Guo et al. (2014) also found that farmers strongly dependent on natural resources are
very sensitive to natural disasters since natural disasters can cause serious losses of livelihood
Moreover, researchers also found that farmers affected by natural disasters may
increase their food expenditures while lowering their education expenditures, which hinders
the long-term development of human capital. However, some studies have found that natural
12 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
disasters can also positively influence farmers’ incomes (Mottaleb, Mohanty, Hoang, and
Roderick, 2013.)
Turunen, et al. (2022) stated that low-income farmers’ limited coping resources
results to the need of strengthening preventative policies that lessen the likelihood or severity
of damages.
Many farmers lack the financial means to obtain crop insurance, which could affect
resilience. Serio, M. N., et al. (2020), added that strengthening the role of climate-resilient
agricultural techniques can help farmers better manage extreme weather events.
A case study by Heckelman, A., et al. (2018) shown that there are differences between
conventional and organic rice farmers’ levels of climate resilience. Most indicators show that
organic farmers are, on average, more climate resilient than their conventional counterparts.
Furthermore, farmers who have many years of farming experience have interacted
much with the climate in relation to their farming activities and, therefore, have good
2011).
Most individuals have sustained heavy financial losses due to natural disasters. People
involved in agricultural production suffer more losses from natural disasters. Property loss
induces anxiety or other mental health problems in these people. Compared with the
individuals who are not involved in agricultural production, natural disasters can be more
devastating for those who are. Since the damage affects not only financial property, but also
13 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
people’s agricultural livelihoods, the double loss might result in mental health problems
Moreover, previous research has shown that climatic adversity (i.e., drought, severe
weather, extreme climatic variability) detrimentally affects the mental health and wellbeing
of family farmers. Much of the research documenting the impacts of weather and climate on
farmers’ mental health has been produced in Australia, where family farmers have had to
contend with one of the most naturally variable climates on Earth (Hennessy et al., 2008).
feelings of helplessness and powerlessness, Edward et al. (2008) added that it also elevated
rates of psychological distress and depression and, potentially, heightened rates of suicide
Climate change has already exacerbated the natural variability of the Australian
climate (CSIRO & BoM, 2015); and because of their close living and working relationships
with the land, family farmers have been identified as a group whose mental health and
wellbeing may be particularly impacted by climate change (Berry et al., 2011, Morrissey and
Reser, 2007).
Moreover, Zhang et al. (2022) stated that the effect of natural disasters on mental
health might also vary depending on the family’s agricultural production status. They also
suggested that natural disasters have a significant negative effect on middle-aged and older
adults' mental health in the case of rural China. This effect is heterogeneous depending on
14 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
Finally, individuals' happiness and life satisfaction are shown to be the potential
mechanism through which the effect of natural disasters on mental health operates.
(2019) in Bangladesh found that natural disasters such as floods and cyclones had a
significant impact on farmers’ social status. The study revealed that farmers’ social networks
were disrupted, and their social relationships were weakened due to migration and
displacement caused by the disasters. A study by Alam and Siwar (2019) in Malaysia found
making and planning increased their social status and resilience to floods. Natural disasters
can have a significant impact on farmers’ social status and their ability to cope with these
events. Social vulnerability, social capital, community-based approaches, and gender can all
play a critical role in enhancing farmers’ social status and resilience to disasters. These
findings suggest that policymakers should focus on developing policies and support systems
that promote social equity and inclusiveness in disaster management and response.
Furthermore, social networks and social capital play a vital role in disaster resilience.
A study by Adger et al. (2005) in Bangladesh found that social networks were critical in
helping farmers cope with natural disasters. Social networks facilitated information sharing,
resource pooling, and emotional support, which enhanced farmers’ ability to cope with the
effects of disasters. Also, social support from family, friends, and community networks can
(2021) in the Philippines found that social support, particularly from family and community
networks, was essential in helping farmers recover from the impacts of typhoons. These
15 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
(2003) asserts that ‘spirituality is an important force in recovery’, because it helps the
survivors identify inner strengths and find meaning in people’s sufferings and behaviors
(Cannon, 2008).
From the perspective of many faith communities, disaster may be viewed not only as
a loss and target for problem solving, but also as a challenge that can inspire growth and
perceiving oneself as resilient, having more meaningful relationships with others, developing
an increased appreciation for life, and experiencing enhanced spirituality (Tedeschi &
Calhoun, 1996).
Spirituality often guides norms and people’s values. For example, Dove (2008) found
that due to a particular religious belief in Mt Merapi, residents believe that volcano eruption
is a positive change for the area. Certain approaches to explaining suffering have been related
to poorer mental health outcomes; specifically, viewing the disaster as spiritually endowed
punishment or a demonstration of Divine power and anger, attributing the disaster to one’s
sins, perceiving the event as a signal of the Deity’s abandonment of the believer, and
Jang and Wang (2009) stated that participants of their study indicated that with the
support from religious belief, they have found ways to cope with challenges. They affirmed
16 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
that religious belief helped them to be more optimism and see positive side of things. They
also learned not to go to extremes. Likewise, Cadell et al. (2003, p. 280) emphasise that, ‘…
One way individuals who face traumatic events attempt to find meaning is through religion or
spirituality’.
(2021) analyzed the impact of disasters on the economic status of smallholder farmers in
Ethiopia. The study found that disasters have significant negative economic impacts on
poverty. A Literature Review” by Twigg et al. (2015) examined the factors that contribute to
the economic resilience of farmers in the face of disasters. The study found that farmers with
higher levels of economic resources and education are better able to cope with and recover
from disasters.
Moreover, Rashid and Islam (2019) investigated the coping strategies employed by
farmers in Bangladesh after natural disasters. The study found that farmers with higher levels
of economic resources and social capital were better able to cope with the economic impact
of disasters. Also, evidence from Asia and the Pacific” by Zantua et al. (2019) reviewed the
literature on the impacts of disasters on agriculture in Asia and the Pacific. The study found
that disasters have significant economic impacts on agriculture, including crop and livestock
The literature reviewed indicates that the economic status and aspects of farmers play
a crucial role in their ability to cope with disasters. Farmers with higher levels of economic
17 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
resources, education, and social capital are better able to cope with and recover from the
economic impact of disasters. The literature also highlights the significant negative economic
impact of disasters on agriculture, including crop and livestock losses, infrastructure damage,
Chapter III
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
This chapter comprises how the researcher explains the approach taken to address the
research problem or question, as well as the data collection and analysis methods employed
in conducting the research. It clarifies the research design, locale of the study, participants of
the study, research instrument, data gathering Procedure, and statistical analysis of data.
Research Design
disasters among Indigent Farmers of Carallangan Alcala, Cagayan. To achieve this objective,
a mixed-methods research design will be used, combining both quantitative and qualitative
data collection techniques. The study will be conducted through the administration of a
18 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
analyzing both quantitative and qualitative data in a single study. This research design
typically involves using multiple methods for data collection and analysis, such as surveys,
research design that combines quantitative and qualitative data collection, analysis, and
understanding of the research problem by combining the strengths of both quantitative and
qualitative research methods. This research design allows researchers to explore a research
question or problem in more depth and to validate and corroborate findings across different
data sources.
To be more specific, the mixed-method research design in this study would allow for
indigent farmers in Barangay Carallangan. It would provide both quantitative and qualitative
data, which could help identify correlations and patterns, as well as contextualize the research
problem.
This study will be conducted in Barangay Carallangan, Alcala, Cagayan. The area is
predominantly agricultural, with most of the population engaged in farming as their primary
source of livelihood.
19 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
Participants of this study are the indigent farmers of Carallangan, Alcala, Cagayan.
These indigent farmers are registered in the Municipal Agriculture Office (MAO) of the
Local Government Unit of Alcala, Cagayan. The population is composed of 54 rice farmers,
24 corn farmers, and 28 farmers of both crops with a total of one-hundred six (106) indigent
farmers.
Researchers will utilize 24 rice farmers, 24 corn farmers, and 24 farmers of both crops
with a total of 72 participants. The sampling technique will be a stratified random sampling to
ensure that the sample is representative of the population and avoid sampling biases.
The selection process will be done with the assistance of the barangay officials to
identify the eligible respondents. They will be asked to answer a survey questionnaire. The
study will ensure that the respondents’ identities and responses will be kept confidential, and
Research Instrument
the data instrument in the study. The questionnaire intends to gather data about the level of
subsistence potential on disaster among the indigent farmers and also pilot-testing will be
utilizing to test and ensure its clarity, validity, and reliability. On the other hand, interview
will be conducted to supplement and clarify the gathered data through the disseminated
questionnaires.
Survey forms of questionnaires will be used for data collection. Researchers have a
comprehensive set of questions which is composed of two parts. The first part will assess the
20 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
profile of the participants, second will assess the impact of the disaster in terms of human and
Moreover, short questions are given along with the choices given below each
question, and the respondent will indicate his or her response by checking tick marks. The
questionnaire utilized the scale ranging from 5 (always) 4 (very often) 3 (sometimes) 2
(rarely) 1 (never).
In pursuit of the objectives of the study, the researchers will first seek permission
from the barangay captain of Carallangan, Alcala, Cagayan to distribute questionnaires and
gather the needed data for the study, specifically for indigent farmers. Upon approval, an
informed consent will be given to the 106 respondents. The questionnaire will then be
personally administered by the researchers and the respondents will be given ample time to
The questionnaires to be used will be pilot-tested for their reliability and validity
before they are given to the target sample. The researchers will be administering the
questionnaires during the gathering procedure. The researchers will ask politely if they can
help by answering and completing the survey forms. The respondents will be informed about
the nature of the study. To ensure freedom of choice and provide an avenue for the
respondents to voluntarily consent or decline participation in the study, the informed consent
of each respondent will be secured. They will be given enough time to answer the
questionnaire and are allowed to ask questions and seek clarification. After answering, the
21 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
researchers will thank the respondents for their cooperation. Then it will be collected by the
After collecting all the data, the researchers will tally and tabulate the scores for
interpretation and analyzation with the assistance of statistician to generate accurate result.
Dear Respondents,
We, the 3rd Year BS Social Work students under the department of College of Public
research study entitled "Levels of Subsistence Potential on Disasters among Indigent Farmers
questionnaires pertinent to our above-stated study. Your honest responses to the questions
22 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
will surely help us in obtaining the objectives of our study. Rest assured that your responses
will be kept confidential and anonymous. No personal identifying information will be shared
with any third parties. The data collected will only be used for research and academic
purposes only.
Researchers
[ ] College Graduate
23 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
Part II. Impacts of disaster in terms of the human aspects which includes the mental,
Direction: Read the following statements and put check [ / ] mark in the box of column
which you think is the most applicable to your answer. Please be guided to the following
scale:
5 – always
4 – very often
3 – sometimes
2 – rarely
1 – never
Items 5 4 3 2 1
1. I feel stress.
2. I easily get
angry.
24 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
3. I find difficult
to sleep.
4. I get easily
irritated.
5. I feel hopeless.
6. I feel sad.
7. I find difficult
to make
decisions.
8. I loss appetite.
9. I loss interest
on farming.
10. I experienced
mood swings.
Items 5 4 3 2 1
25 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
1. I isolate/distance
myself from
others.
2. I have difficulty
dealing with
others.
3. I lose my
confidence.
4. I experience
discrimination
among my
fellow farmers.
5. I experience
inequality
distribution to
the different
assistance of the
government.
6. I experience
conflict with my
fellow farmers.
blame to my
26 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
partner.
8. I easily get
recover through
the support of
my family.
9. I put all my
anger towards
my children.
Items 5 4 3 2 1
1. I lost my faith
in God.
2. I seek
religious
advice.
3. My faith
become
stronger.
4. I am
encouraged to
27 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
join religious
activities.
5. My spiritual
faith helps me
to recover.
6. My religious
belief helps
me to become
optimistic.
Items 5 4 3 2 1
1. I reduce our
expenses in
non-essential
areas.
2. I get in debt or
increase my
debt.
3. I experienced
difficulty
28 | P a g e
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF PUBLIC ADMINITSRATION
accessing our
basic
necessities,
such as foods.
4. My
agricultural
productivity is
decline.
29 | P a g e