Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pictures of Virgilian Fama
Pictures of Virgilian Fama
Pictures of Virgilian Fama
An Endless Journey
Pierides
Studies in Greek and Latin Literature
Series Editors:
Philip Hardie and Stratis Kyriakidis
Volume I
Stratis Kyriakidis
Catalogues of Proper Names in Latin Epic Poetry:
Lucretius – Virgil – Ovid
Volume II
Antonis K. Petrides and Sophia Papaioannou (eds),
New Perspectives on Postclassical Comedy
Volume III
Myrto Garani and David Konstan (eds),
The Philosophizing Muse:
The Influence of Greek Philosophy on Roman Poetry
Volume IV
Sophia Papaioannou (ed.)
Terence and Interpretation
Volume V
Stephen Harrison (ed.)
Characterisation in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses
Nine Studies
Pierides
Studies in Greek and Latin Literature
Volume VI
Libera Fama
An Endless Journey
Edited by
Stratis Kyriakidis
Libera Fama: An Endless Journey (Pierides VI)
All rights for this book reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced,
stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means,
electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the
prior permission of the copyright owner.
PREFACE ................................................................................................... x
INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................... 1
Speech, Fame and Glory: Connecting Past and Future
Stratis Kyriakidis
CHAPTER ONE........................................................................................ 28
The Negation of Fame: Epicurus’ meta-fama and Lucretius’ Response
Myrto Garani
period (Le rinascite della tragedia, Rome, 2006 and 2013). His book on
Fama (Word of Mouth) and its personifications from Ancient Rome to the
Middle Ages is forthcoming from Oxford University Press.
GIANNI GUASTELLA
1
In the following pages I discuss several topics that I will develop on in a
forthcoming book entitled Word of Mouth. I wish to thank professor Stratis
Kyriakidis for including my paper in this volume, as well as Grazia Maria Fachechi
for her very valuable suggestions.
2
Quint. IO 9.2.36: Sed formas quoque fingimus saepe, ut Famam Vergilius, ut
Voluptatem ac Virtutem, quem ad modum a Xenophonte traditur, Prodicus, ut
Mortem ac Vitam, quas contendentes in satura tradit, Ennius (We often create
figures, as Virgil does with Fame, as Prodicus – according to Xenophon – does with
Pleasure and Virtue, as Ennius does with Death and Life, when he represents them,
in one of his satires, contending with one another). Cf. Tiberius Claudius Donatus
(Int. verg. 1.377, Georges): veteres omnes multis incorporalibus et nomina dederunt
et formas et nonnulla pro numinibus habuerunt, Victoriam scilicet. Concordiam,
Discordiam, Furorem, Somnum et cetera similia: ita et Famam corporalem esse
voluerunt et deam, ut ipse Vergilius hoc loco ait haec passim dea foeda virum
diffundit in ora. Huic addidit et corpus et corporis incredibilem mobilitatem et
loquacitatem satius effusam nihilque occultantem (All the ancients gave names and
forms to many incorporeal things, and considered some of them as deities, such as
Victory, Concord, Discord, Fury, Sleep and the like. Similarly they transformed
Fame into a goddess, provided with a body, as Virgil himself does here, when he
says ‘The ugly goddess spreads this news in every direction, through men’s
194 Chapter Nine
b. Fama malum
In their study of the illustrated manuscripts of the Aeneid Pierre and
Jeanne Courcelle mention only three examples in which Fama is
represented, all datable to the second half of the fifteenth century. Two of
the three miniatures come from the Aragonese court of Naples. The best
known of these images is found in a manuscript housed in the Escorial
(Real Biblioteca de San Lorenzo, S. II. 19, fol. 98v).5 Fama is depicted in
three different stages of her activity: as she emerges from the ground, as
she swells until her head touches the sky and as she spreads through the
city.6 The winged figure’s two main attributes are, on the one hand, her
mouths’. He also gave her a body capable of an incredible rapidity, as well as an
abundant loquacity, concealing nothing).
3
Hardie (2012) 112.
4
Courcelle and Courcelle (1984) 263-265.
5
See Courcelle and Courcelle (1984) 237 (the miniature is reproduced at fig. 434).
On the manuscript (datable to around 1477) and on its illuminators see De Marinis
(1947-1952) II, 173-174; Courcelle and Courcelle (1984) 231-233 and especially
Toscano (1998) 403-405 and 594-595.
6
Cf. Virg. Aen. 4.173-177: Extemplo Libyae magnas it Fama per urbes, / Fama,
malum qua non aliud velocius ullum: / mobilitate viget virisque adquirit eundo, /
parva metu primo, mox sese attollit in auras / ingrediturque solo et caput inter
nubila condit (At once Fama went through the great cities of Africa, Fama, swifter
than any other evil: she thrives through motion and gains strength as she goes. She
is small and timorous to begin with, but soon she lifts herself into the air, striding on
the ground and her head hidden in the clouds, trnsl. Ph. Hardie).
Pictures of Virgilian Fama 195
long tongue, on the other, her wings and tunic made up of rows of
overlapping tongues resembling feathers, alternating with other rows of
eyes and ears.7 Such an image highlights the disturbing and impressive
character of the personage who is engaged in flooding an entire city with
her voices.
Somewhat later, the same general features were also given to the figure
of Fama by the illustrators of the celebrated 1502 edition of Virgil
published in Strasbourg, the result of a collaboration between Sebastian
Brant and Johann Grüninger. With the famous engraving of the f. 215v
they produced what is perhaps the best known modern image of Virgil’s
Fama.8
Here again, the image directs the viewer’s attention to the monster’s
repulsive features. The body of the winged figure, from its snakelike hair,
to its cloven feet (themselves equipped with wings) is almost entirely
covered with feathers. Flames shoot forth from its hands that will strike
both the houses of the infested city with the effect of the information, and
Iarbas, the final addressee of the rumours about Dido. He is visible in the
lower left, kneeling before the statues of Mercury and Jove to whom he
protests for having been spurned by the queen. Unlike the Aragonese
miniaturist, the engraver here does not reproduce the most curious features
of Virgil’s description, that is, the eyes, the tongues and the ears covering
the body of Fama.9 These features appear in other images which are
intended to give particular emphasis to the malevolent aspects of the
personage depicted.
An example that has recently acquired a certain degree of notoriety10 is
the engraving by an anonymous artist that appears in a sixteenth century
edition of an interlude representing the personage of Calumny (Fig. 1).
7
Cf. Virg., Aen. 4.180-183: pedibus celerem et pernicibus alis, / monstrum
horrendum, ingens, cui quot sunt corpore plumae, / tot vigiles oculi subter (mirabile
dictu), / tot linguae, totidem ora sonant, tot subrigit auris (swift-footed and speedy-
winged, a terrifying, huge monster. She has as many eyes underneath (wondrous to
tell) as she has feathers on her body, and as many tongues and sounding mouths, and
as many are the ears that she pricks up, trnsl. Ph. Hardie).
8
Publii Virgilii Maronis opera cum quinque vulgatis commentariis:
expolitissimisque figuris atque imaginibus nuper per Sebastianum Brant
superadditis, Opera & impensa Iohannis Grieniger: in civitate Argentensi, 1502, f.
215v. The volume’s engravings are the work of various hands. On the importance of
these images see Rabb (1960) 196-198 and especially Schneider (1983).
9
An attempt to represent the multiplication of the monster’s organs of reception can
be seen both in the three ears on the right side of the face and in the two more eyes
added to the waist.
10
Cf. Tupet (1985) and Neubauer (20092) 42.
196 Chapter Nine
The interlude may be dated to 1576 and consists of a monologue that the
Danish bishop Peder Hegelund had inserted into his translation of the
Latin play Susanna by the Swiss Sixt(us) Birck.11 The speech is
pronounced by a repulsive looking woman wearing a motley coloured
garment who in the engraving is seen standing under the legend FAMA
MALVM. This image shows very clearly the multitude of the organs of
communication typical of Virgil’s character: eyes and tongues appear all
over the monster’s garment and wings along with a number of other
threatening attributes. In fact, Hegelund’s Calumny also possesses an
enormous pair of ears and wears winged shoes12 while a forked tongue (or
rather two tongues?) protrudes from her half open mouth: from her robe
hang numerous instruments of witchcraft and in her hand she holds a bow
from which she is about to shoot three arrows.
In an image like this the chthonic character of the personage along with
the monstrous proliferation of organs for receiving and transmitting
information is both used to represent a form of communication that has a
deliberately hostile intent. The Fama-Rumour in the Strasbourg edition
and the Hegelund’s Calumny are caught in the act of setting into
circulation information aimed at doing harm, to Virgil’s Dido in the
former case and to the protagonist of the celebrated episode from the Book
of Daniel in the latter.
c. Other monsters
The second of the manuscripts from the court of Naples mentioned by
Pierre and Jeanne Courcelle ended up, along with a large part of the
remains of the Aragonese book collection, in the Biblioteca Universitaria
de Valencia (Ms.837, olim 748, fol. 111v).13 In one of its splendid
miniatures, datable to the 1470s, we find a representation of our personage
very different from what we have considered thus far.14 In this case, Fama
11
Susanna comicotragœdia […], Prentet i Kiøbenhaffn aff Matz Wingaard (1578)
and Calumnia seu Diabola personata…, by the same publisher (1579). On the
edition and the engraving see Marker and Marker (1996) 24-25.
12
Both this figure and the Fama in the Strasbourg edition have wings sprouting
from their shoulders as well as their ankles.
13
On this manuscript see De Marinis (1947-1952) II, 172 and IV, tables 255-263;
Courcelle and Courcelle (1984) 219-220 and 222-223; Toscano (1998) 364-367 and
526-528; Wlosok (1992) 12-14 and 26-27; id. (1995) 105-106.
14
The image may be seen at the url (visited on 20 May 2015):
http://weblioteca.uv.es/cgi/view.pl?div=226&source=uv_ms_0837&sesion=201312
2110481813963&zoom=0
Pictures of Virgilian Fama 197
looks vaguely like the figure of an ancient siren with extra features that
clearly are derived from the iconography of the dragon of the Book of
Revelation. This peculiar monster with the face of a beautiful woman
stands on a hilltop and appears as if she is on the point of taking flight.
Underneath her is the cave in which Dido and Aeneas are embracing.
Actually, rather than taking off, Fama looks more like she is going to
immerse herself in the surrounding currents of air which also impress a
form on the upper part of her bust. The most disconcerting aspect of the
personage are the six plumed snakes that make up her body. If we are
looking for the multitude of eyes, mouths and ears that characterise
Virgil’s Fama, then we will find them on the heads of these snakes.
The same manuscript perhaps also contains a second representation of
Fama. It is to be found in a miniature illustrating an episode from Book 1,
in particular ll. 494-519 (f. 80v),15 though the scene shown does not
correspond to a precise passage in Virgil’s text. What is being shown here
is the moment immediately preceding the arrival of Aeneas and Achates
before Dido (Aen. 1.516-519).16 The two Trojan heroes, in the lower left,
are still covered by a cloud, and from this cloud Fama appears to emerge
(if it is, in fact, Fama) who directs her gaze to the queen seated on the
throne. This might be a figurative device used to convey the fact that
Aeneas and Achates’ arrival in the queen’s presence has been preceded by
the news of them which is already known in Carthage. As Grazia Fachechi
suggests to me (per litteras), this hypothesis is supported by the fact that
the “maidservants around Dido are clearly speaking amongst themselves
[…]; their chatter seems to arise from the girl on the far left who is the first
to receive the report from Fama”.17
15
The image may be seen at the url (visited on 20 May 2015):
http://weblioteca.uv.es/cgi/view.pl?div=164&source=uv_ms_0837&sesion=201312
2110481813963&zoom=0
16
Dissimulant et nube cava speculantur amicti / quae fortuna viris, classem quo
litore linquant, / quid veniant; cunctis nam lecti navibus ibant / orantes veniam, et
templum clamore petebant (They stay hidden, and enveloped by the hollow cloud
observe what happened to their comrades, on which shore they left their fleet, what
is the reason of their coming; a chosen few, from every ship, came asking for grace,
and headed for the temple with loud cries).
17
It is not clear which of the references to fama that recur in Book 1 are being
alluded to. We can rule out the moment when Aeneas presents himself to Venus,
before she reveals her identity (Sum pius Aeneas, raptos qui ex hoste penatis / classe
veho mecum, fama super aethera notus, I am pious Aeneas, made known by Fame
above the sky, I carry with me in my fleet the Penates snatched from the enemy,
378-379). Just as hard to imagine is that an allusion is being made here to the
passage in which the two heroes, while awaiting the queen, recognise on the friezes
198 Chapter Nine
21
On Barbazza see Liotta (1964).
22
According to a rumour reported among others by Fantuzzi (1781) 346: “si dice,
che Francesco Aretino rispondesse ad alcuni, che esaltavano il merito d’Andrea: che
la di lui fama sarebbe stata un foco di paglia. Ma il fatto ha ben mostrato
differentemente, poiché l’opere sue sono sempre state in molta riputazione” (it is
said that Francesco Aretino [that is, Francesco Accolti] replied to those who praised
the merits of Andrea: that his fame would be a straw fire. But events proved
otherwise, since his works have always enjoyed a high reputation). This is an
interesting and instructive example of how inextricably rumour and reputation are
intertwined, both based on what ‘is told’ about someone.
23
On the creation of this iconographic scheme and the vast bibliography on it see
Guastella 2012.
200 Chapter Nine
24
Just to give one of many possible examples, see the splendid miniature in the ms.
Paris, Bibliothèque nationale, Fr. 594, f. 178v (1503), at the url (visited on 20 May
2015):
http://visualiseur.bnf.fr/Visualiseur?Destination=Daguerre&O=7826130&E=JPEG
&NavigationSimplifiee=ok&typeFonds=noir
25
See e.g. Amsterdam Rijksmuseum, Rijksprentenkabinet inv.nr.: RP-P-OB-10.333.
26
This is a brief cycle of Viri illustres, whose heroic character is intended to extol
the values of courage and self-sacrifice. See Melion (1995) 1090-1095 and 1103-
1105. On the correct identification of the personification of Virtue see in part. 1127,
n. 16.
27
For which see also Neubauer (20092) 85-88.
Pictures of Virgilian Fama 201
‘Virgilian’ features of the eyes and ears seen among the woman’s
feathers.28
Another well known example of this combination of iconographic
models is a woodcut by the Swiss painter and engraver Tobias Stimmer
(1539-1584).29 This is one of the various versions of the printer’s mark
depicting Fama used by the Frankfurt bookseller Sigmund Feyerabend.30
Here again Fama symbolises renown as she blows through the trumpet in
her right hand (another dark coloured trumpet in her left hand is pointed
downward):31 the ‘Virgilian’ feature that has been added are the eyes that
may be seen on the feathers of her wings.32
In examples like this we almost get the impression that the ‘Virgilian’
attribute of the multiplicity of organs for receiving and transmitting
information has been grafted onto the iconographic scheme of Fama-
renown that was developed in the illustrations of Petrarch’s work. What
we see less frequently is the opposite process: attributes from the
‘Petrarchan’ figure grafted onto the personification of Fama-rumour
common in the epic tradition. A famous example is Bolognino Zaltieri’s
engraving which illustrates an episode from Statius’ Thebaid (3.425-431):
Fama preceding Mars’ chariot. From 1571 on this engraving appeared in
the editions of Vicenzo Cartari’s mythological repertory Le imagini de i
dei de gli Antichi.33
The composite symbolic system underlying this representation
ultimately became the standard image of Fama in every one of her
28
The detail is clearly visible in the high resolution image available at the url
(visited on 20 May 2015): http://www.rijksmuseum.nl/collectie/RP-P-OB-
10.333/faam-en-historie
29
The image was discussed by Neubauer (20092) 249 and Hardie (2012) 631-632.
An example may be seen at the url (visited on 20 May 2015):
http://reader.digitale-sammlungen.de/de/fs1/object/display/bsb10146974_00005.html
30
The image quoted at the previous footnote corresponds to n. 135 in Andresen
(1872) 64. To get an idea of the possible variations on the ‘contaminated scheme’
that I am illustrating the reader might look at the many versions of the same figure
produced by the Swiss engraver Jost Amman: see O’Dell (1993) 33 and 257-312.
31
In various depictions similar to this our personage is shown in the act of blowing
into two trumpets at the same time.
32
As Hardie [(2012) 606] has remarked in passing, this trait was also influenced by
another iconographic model, used to represent the cherubim (especially in the
illustrations of the Book of Revelation).
33
See Hardie (2012) 620-621 and fig. 23 (from the Lyon edition “Apresso Stefano
Michele” of 1581, 331, which reproduces Bolognino Zaltieri’s engravings of the
Venetian edition published ten years before); Guastella (2012) 272 and (2013) 122-
123.
202 Chapter Nine
34
See Guastella (2013) 123-128. For the text of this entry see the recent edition by
Maffei (2012) 176-177 (and the notes on p. 686).
ILLUSTRATIONS
1
I take the picture from the copy available at the url:
https://openlibrary.org/books/OL24229759M/Susanna_og_Calumnia
2
I have taken the picture from the digital copy available at the url:
https://openlibrary.org/books/OL24144047M/Iconologia_ouero_Descrittione_di_diu
erse_imagini_cauate_dall%27antichit%C3%A0_di_propria_inuentione
204 Illustrations
Libera Fama: An Endless Journey (Pierides VI) 205
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Claassen, J.-M. (1988) “Ovid’s Poems from Exile. The Creation of a Myth
and the Triumph of Poetry”, A & A 34, 158-169.
—. (1996) “Exile, Death and Immortality: Voices from the Grave”,
Latomus 55, 571-590.
—. (1999) Displaced Persons: the literature of exile: from Cicero to
Boethius, London.
—. (2008) Ovid revisited. The poet in exile, London.
Clausen, W.V. (1992) A. Persi Flacci et D. Iuni Iuvenalis Saturae (rev.
ed.) New York.
Clay, D. (1983) Lucretius and Epicurus, Ithaca.
Clément-Tarantino, S. (2006) Fama ou la renommée du genre. Recherches
sur la représentation de la tradition dans l’Énéide, thèse de doctorat,
Université Lille.
—. (2009) “Phémios dans l’Énéide et les libertés du poète épique”, in B.
Delignon and Y. Roman (eds), 227-242.
—. (2014) “Je et les autres: réflexions sur la voix épique dans l’Énéide”, in
A. Estèves and J. Meyers (eds), 17-28.
Coarelli, F. (1999) “Pons Aemilius”, Lexicon topographicum urbis Romae
4.106-07, Rome.
Coffey, M. (1976) Roman Satire, London.
Coleman, R. (1971) “Structure and Intention in the Metamorphoses”, CQ
21, 461-477.
Colton, R.E. (1970) “Juvenal 6.398-412, 6.419-33, and Martial”, C&M 31,
151-160 [repr. with slight revisions in R. E. Colton (1991)].
—. (1991) Juvenal’s Use of Martial’s Epigrams, Amsterdam.
Connors, C. (2005) “Epic allusion in Roman satire”, in K. Freudenburg
(ed.), 123-145.
Conte, G.-B. (1992) “Proems in the Middle”, in F.M. Dunn, and T. Cole
(eds), 147-159.
Courcelle, P., Courcelle, J. (1984) Lecteurs païens et lecteurs chrétiens de
l’Éneide. II. Les manuscrits illustrés de l’Énéide du Xe au XVe siècle,
Paris.
Courtney, E. (1980) A Commentary on the Satires of Juvenal, London.
—. (2003) The Fragmentary Latin Poets. Paperback edition with Addenda,
Oxford.
Cox Miller, P. (2009) The Corporeal Imagination: Signifying the Holy in
Late Ancient Christianity, Philadelphia.
DeBrohun, J. (2004) “Centaurs in Love and War: Cyllarus and Hylonome
in Ovid Metamorphoses 12.393-428”, AJPh 125, 417-452.
De Decker, J. (1913) Juvenalis declamans: étude sur la rhétorique
declamatoire dans les Satires de Juvénal, Ghent.
212 Bibliography
Zetzel, J.E.G. (1983) “Catullus, Ennius and the Poetics of Allusion”, ICS
8.2, 251-266.
Ziogas, I. (2011) “The Myth is Out There: Reality and Fiction at Tomis
(David Malouf’s An Imaginary Life), in J. Ingleheart (ed.), 289-304.
—. (2013) Ovid and Hesiod. The Metamorphosis of the Catalogue of
Women, Cambridge.
—. (2014) “The Topography of Epic Narrative in Ovid’s
Metamorphoses”, in M. Skempis and I. Ziogas (eds), 325-348.
Zissos, A. (2008) Valerius Flaccus’ Argonautica. Book I, A Commentary,
Oxford.
Zumwalt, N. (1977) “Fama Subversa. Theme and Structure in Ovid,
Metamorphoses 12”, CSCA 10, 209-222.