Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Multiport Power Router and Its Impact On
Multiport Power Router and Its Impact On
Multiport Power Router and Its Impact On
Radio Science
REVIEW ARTICLE Multiport power router and its impact on future
10.1002/2016RS006041
smart grids
Special Section: Yuichi Kado1, Daiki Shichijo1, Keiji Wada2, and Katsumi Iwatsuki3
Special issue of the 2015 URSI-
1
Japan Radio Science Meeting Department of Electronics, Kyoto Institute of Technology, Kyoto, Japan, 2Department of Electrical and Electronic
Engineering, Tokyo Metropolitan University, Hachioji, Japan, 3Research Organization of Electrical Communication, Tohoku
Key Points: University, Sendai, Japan
• We propose a Y configuration power
router as a unit cell to easily construct
a power delivery system Abstract We propose a Y configuration power router as a unit cell to easily construct a power delivery
• A prototype three-way isolated DC/DC system that can meet many types of user requirements. The Y configuration power router controls the
converter as a core unit of the power
router was constructed by using SiC
direction and magnitude of power flows between three ports regardless of DC or AC. We constructed a
power devices prototype three-way isolated DC/DC converter that is the core unit of the Y configuration power router.
• We explored the requirements for The electrical insulation between three ports assures safety and reliability for power network systems. We
communication between energy
routers to achieve dynamic
then tested the operation of power flow control. The experimental results revealed that our methodology
adjustments to energy flows in based on a governing equation was appropriate to control the power flow of the three-way DC/DC
real time converter. In addition, a distribution network composed of power routers had the ability to easily enable
interchanges of electrical power between autonomous microgrid cells. We also explored the requirements
for communication between energy routers to achieve dynamic adjustments of energy flows in a
Correspondence to: coordinated manner and their impact on resilient power grid systems.
Y. Kado,
kado@kit.ac.jp
1. Introduction
Citation:
Kado, Y., D. Shichijo, K. Wada, and There are 450 cities in the world that have populations above one million, and 72% of the world’s population
K. Iwatsuki (2016), Multiport power is expected to be urban residents by 2050 [United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs,
router and its impact on future smart Population Division, 2012]. Also, the headquarters of major corporations are clustered in large cities, and of
grids, Radio Sci., 51, 1234–1246,
doi:10.1002/2016RS006041. the 62 Japanese Fortune Global 500 companies, 45 (about 70%) are located in Tokyo. Accordingly, the
networks that supply electrical power to the major cities and serve as the energy infrastructure that supports
Received 31 MAR 2016 the lives of people and the activities of enterprises in these cities must operate with high levels of reliability
Accepted 14 JUL 2016 and stability and be robust against disasters such as hurricanes or major earthquakes. Increasing the
Accepted article online 18 JUL 2016
Published online 30 JUL 2016 resilience of the power grid and other social infrastructure systems has been a pressing issue in Japan since
the major earthquake that occurred in eastern Japan in 2011.
Another factor is the need for the large-scale introduction of renewable energy sources such as solar power
generation and wind power generation as measures to address global warming and energy self-sufficiency.
Because the output of these energy sources varies greatly with weather conditions, the connection of a
large number of such sources to the existing electric power grid requires solutions to problems such as adjust-
ments to the balance of the power supply and demand and regulation of the power grid voltage. It would also
be advantageous to construct a power grid that facilitates the aggregation of negative watts (surplus power)
that are generated within the distributed power grid by distribution system operators and aggregators and
pooled for use by enterprises and factories that need them in an electrical power interchange market.
To meet the needs for these kinds of power networks described above, changes in the topology of the power
grid from centralized, unidirectional power networks whose nodes are the power generators of local power
companies and that only supply power to users to a distributed, bidirectional power network that is similar to
the Internet have been proposed [Saitoh et al., 1997; Huang et al., 2011; Abe et al., 2011; Xu et al., 2011]. The
Cyber-Physical System [Sztipanovits et al., 2012] is the result of such a tight interworking of power and data
communication networks. The Future Renewable Electric Energy Delivery and Management system [Huang
et al., 2011] has been attracting particular attention as going beyond the proposal of a concept to introduce
solid state transformers [Falcones et al., 2010] as key devices for the interface between power and data net-
works. They can also operate autonomously in isolation from the higher-level grid by using natural renewable
©2016. American Geophysical Union.
energy sources and storage batteries in subordinate grids. Among the proposals for new architectures, con-
All Rights Reserved. trol methods, and operation modes for the next-generation smart grid, the proposals of power electronics
Figure 1. Application of Y configuration power router to autonomous microgrid system utilizing renewable energy resources.
with new functions to serve as the interface between the power network and data network and integration
with the power grid topology will have strong impact.
In response to these issues and requirements, we propose a Y configuration power router that can be used as
a unit cell to enable a power delivery system to be easily constructed to meet many types of user require-
ments and reduce the overall system development costs [Kado et al., 2015] as outlined in Figure 1. The router
is composed of a three-way isolated DC/DC converter [Zhao et al., 2008] and AC/DC converters connected to
the end of each input/output (I/O) port of the three-way converter. The power interchanging function is
performed by the three-way isolated DC/DC converter that is the core unit of the Y configuration power
router. It maintains electrical insulation between the ports and freely controls both the amount of power
and direction of flow. The electrical insulation between three ports assures safety and reliability for the
power network system. The fault currents in the network system consisting of the router will be smaller
due to the use of the Y configuration router that inherently limits these currents. The DC power at any port
can be changed to three-phase AC power by connecting an AC/DC power converter unit to the port, so it
is possible to achieve power interchange among the three ports regardless of whether the power is DC or
AC. Furthermore, many types of loads, energy resources, and energy storage devices can be connected to
the routers simply by rewriting the control software.
The autonomous microgrid system utilizing the renewable energy resources in Figure 1 is only composed of a
single unit (the Y configuration power router), and the unit can be used to construct energy networks with
various topologies. This system can easily accommodate new entries by power suppliers and power consu-
mers and extensions of photovoltaic (PV) cells and battery units at very low engineering costs. Moreover, it
is possible to interchange power with other microgird systems. The three-way isolated DC/DC converter in
the system operates in two power flow patterns of A and B, as outlined in Figure 1, and the transmission
power of each port can be changed in various ways.
We fabricated a prototype three-way isolated DC/DC converter, which was rated at 400 V and 10 kW, which
was the core unit of the Y configuration power router, and tested its operation in power flow control. This
paper describes the validity of the governing equation of power flow control by using the prototype and
clarifies that the router is able to control power flow under open-loop control. Recursive multilevel wide-area
mesh networks composed of autonomous microgrid cells will enhance the resilience of future power grid
systems. We will discuss the requirements for communication between the overall grid control unit and
energy routers to achieve dynamic adjustments to energy flows in a coordinated manner as well as the
impact of the proposed power network on resilient power grid systems.
The rest of this paper is organized as follows. The method of power flow control with the Y configuration
router and the experimental results for the three-way isolated DC/DC converter that is the core unit of the
Y configuration power router are described in section 2. Section 3 explains the application to power grid
systems and discusses the layered control framework. Section 4 concludes the paper.
δ2 ðπ δ2 ÞL3 þ δ3 ðπ δ3 ÞL2 2
P1 ¼ V ; (1)
2π 2 f sw ðL1 L2 þ L2 L3 þ L3 L1 Þ
δ2 ðδ2 π ÞL3 þ ðδ2 δ3 Þðδ2 δ3 π ÞL1 2
P2 ¼ V ; (2)
2π 2 f sw ðL1 L2 þ L2 L3 þ L3 L1 Þ
transmission powers. However, these equations are insufficient to represent all cases of power flows. It is
also necessary to consider the equations for δ3 ≥ δ2 ≥ 0. In addition, equations (1)–(3) have a relation to
equation (4). Power flow control based on the equations is called phase shift modulation (PSM) [Inoue and
Akagi, 2006; Kheraluwala et al., 1992; Liu et al., 2012].
We will next describe a control method for managing power flow under open-loop control. We focused on
the power flow control of P1 and P2. It is necessary to determine δ2 and δ3 that satisfy equations (1) and (2)
to achieve the demanded power P1 and P2. We need to solve a quadratic equation with two variables to
Figure 4. Experimental prototype of three-way isolated DC/DC converter rated at 400 V and 10 kW based on 1.2 kV 120-A SiC-MOSFET.
Table 1. Ratings and Specifications for Experimental Prototype of Three- determine these parameters. The
Way Isolated DC/DC Converter quadratic equation generally has
Specifications Symbols Values four solutions at maximum. However,
DC voltage V 400 V some of these solutions pose large
DC capacitor CDC 9.4 mF resistance losses. Therefore, the
Switching frequency fsw 20 kHz three-way isolated DC/DC converter
Magnetizing inductance Lm 11.7 mH
controls the power flow with the
Leakage inductance Ll1 1.4 μH
Ll2 1.3 μH minimum resistance loss under
Ll3 1.4 μH open-loop control by selecting the
Rated power PR 10 kW numerical solution that is closest to
Number of turns n 20 the origin in the δ2-δ3 plane,
Transformer turn ratio N 1:1:1
Transformer core material Finemet 2.3. Basic Operation of Three-Way
External inductance Le1 40.6 μH
Isolated DC/DC Converter
Le2 36.0 μH
Le3 35.9 μH This section discusses our tests on
the operation of the power flow con-
trol of the three-way converter to
evaluate the validity of its methodology. We fabricated a prototype three-way isolated DC/DC converter
using silicon carbide metal oxide semiconductor field effect transistors (SiC-MOSFETs: 1.2 kV/120-A) by
assuming that it was rated at 20 kHz, 400 V, and 10 kW. There is a photograph of the experimental prototype
in Figure 4. Table 1 lists the ratings and specifications for the prototype.
We demonstrated control of power flow operation by using the prototype. A power source was connected to
each port of the three-way converter during the experiment. The average transmission power of I/O ports of
P1, P2, and P3 was measured using a power analyzer (Yokogawa: WT210 Digital Power Meter), and the wave-
forms for voltages of u1, u2, and u3, and currents of i1, i2, and i3 (Figure 3) were measured using an oscilloscope
(Tektronix: TDS5034B Digital Oscilloscope). The prototype was rated for 10 kW. The phase shift of δ2 was fixed
at 30°, and the phase shift of δ3 was changed by 5° from 0° to 30° to confirm theoretical equations.
Figure 5 shows the measured waveforms for voltages of u1 and u2 and currents of i1 and i2 when V = 400 V,
δ2 = 30°, and δ3 = 20°. Figure 6 plots the experimental and theoretical results for P1, P2, and P3 when δ2 was
fixed at 30° and δ3 was changed by 5° from 0° to 30°. The efficiency of the converter was achieved 96.8%
when P1 = 5.54 kW, P2 = 2.68 kW, and P3 = 2.68 kW. The measuring points of power flow correspond to
these theoretical points, so the experimental results revealed that our methodology based on the governing
equation was appropriate to achieve power flow control.
Figure 6. Experimental and theoretical results for P1, P2, and P3 when δ2 was fixed at 30° and δ3 was changed by 5° from 0°
to 30°.
Table 2. Circuit and Control Parameters Used in Simulation power P3 was determined by giving
Circuit and Control Parameters Symbols Values demanded power P*1 and P*2 from
System voltage Vs 200 V equation (4), as described in
Rated power P 10 kW section 2.2. Tertiary transmission
DC voltage VDC 400 V power P3 changed from 6.0 kW to
Cooperation reactor LS 0.86 mH
10.0 kW when the primary and sec-
Reactor parasitic resistance RS 27 mΩ
Commercial power frequency f 50 Hz ondary demanded powers P*1 and P*2
Switching frequency fsw 20 kHz were changed from P*1 = 10.0 kW and
P*2 = 4.0 kW to P*1 = 6.0 kW
*
and P2 = 4.0 kW.
Figure 9 shows the simulated results obtained form this operation. Before power flows were changed, line-to-
line RMS voltage vu and primary line current iu1 were the same phase, and secondary line current iu2 and ter-
tiary line current iu3 were the reverse phase. After power flows were changed, vu, iu1, and iu2 were the same
phase and iu3 was the reverse phase. The transmission powers P1, P2, and P3 were changed from P1 = 10.1 kW,
P2 = 3.91 kW, and P3 = 5.89 kW to P1 = 6.08 kW, P2 = 3.99 kW, and P3 = 9.73 kW. This result converged on
the demanded values within 2.7%. Then, when the transmission powers were changed, variations in DC link
voltage ΔVDC of 2.9 V (less than 0.7%) were suppressed and the simulated results revealed that this router could
stably control power flows.
Figure 9. Simulated waveforms when δ2 and δ3 were adjusted to control AC power flow pattern from pattern A to B in
100 ms.
It is necessary to measure the current and voltage amplitude at each node and reflect the results in the PSM
control of the energy routers installed at various locations to work cooperatively in the implementation of
flexible power interchange between users in real time. That requires highly accurate time synchronization
of the control modules of the energy routers. The synchronization of a hardware implemented network time
protocol (HwNTP) module for digitized radio over a fiber system was recently reported [Shigeru et al., 2012].
The HwNTP client in the experiments was synchronized with the HwNTP server via an asynchronous packet
network and provided synchronization accuracy of less than 1 μs. The control of an autonomous microgrid
cell consisting of Y configuration power has a software layer, a platform layer, and a physical layer
(Figure 11). The physical layer has wired or wireless communication paths [Iwatsuki and Tsukamoto, 2015],
power lines, and power routers consisting of power devices and current and voltage sensors. The platform
layer serves as interworking between the software layer and the physical layer. It consists of a 32 bit complex
instruction set computing (CISC) processor with an IEEE 1588 industrial Ethernet function control module. The
implementation of a control protocol that can perform real-time control and compress control data is an
important goal. The prediction function for power consumption in the software layer can be trained to make
predictions based on power consumption history and issue control commands according to the predictions.
If an abnormal value appears in the management of a state under control by the power consumption predic-
tion functions, there is a function for processing it in the software layer. Because the router can regulate vol-
tage and phase, it maintains a constant value by making corrections when the system voltage deviates from
the specified value.
Figure 11. Control layers of autonomous microgrid cell consisting of overall grid control unit and Y configuration power
routers.
Figure 12. Control framework in autonomous microgrid cell consisting of overall grid control unit and Y configuration power routers.
Figure 13. Control sequence in autonomous microgrid cell consisting of Y configuration power routers.
Figure 14. Evolution from unit cell to recursive construction of multilevel wide-area grid.
the center. The calculations are performed, and control is executed by incorporating a model in which the entire
system is the target of control, so that the voltage of all nodes in the DC network is kept constant. Also, the bal-
ance between power supply and demand is managed across the entire grid system by distributed cooperative
control of the routers. Another function is the detection of fault locations and isolation of faults. The intelligent
power switches are controlled by intercommunication to isolate the location of short circuits from the network
and minimize damage. The systems that are subordinate to the isolated location are subsequently not sup-
plied with power, but the subordinate systems are put into autonomous operation mode because the router
is connected to renewable energy sources and storage batteries [Huang et al., 2011; Bragard et al., 2010].
The control sequence for the overall grid control unit and the power router control unit in Figure 12 is out-
lined in Figure 13. The amplitude and phase of the voltage and current at routers in different locations are
measured periodically, and the data are stored in the overall grid control unit via a communication channel.
The grid control unit uses the data as the basis for flow optimization calculations and issues the appropriate
control commands to the routers to implement flow control. When a router receives a control command, it
executes flow control. The result is that the power flow changes at various branches, and when a transient
phenomenon has passed and the normal state has returned, the voltage and current are measured and
the measurements are returned to the grid control unit. The control units have clocks that are synchronized
with the highly accurate technique of time synchronization that was described above [Shigeru et al., 2012],
and the control sequence is executed according to these clocks. As we can see from Figure 13, the time
required for one cycle of this control sequence is given by
Time required per one control cycle ¼ ½communication delay time 3 þ ½calculation time
þ ½signal processing time 3 þ ½signal conversion time 3
þ Latency ðe:g:; communication and interrupt latenciesÞ:
When we use an optical fiber network, the latency is compressed by time synchronization with a synchroni-
zation accuracy of less than 1 μs [Shigeru et al., 2012] and the communication delay is less than 1 ms.
Consequently, the time for one cycle is 10 ms or less when the calculation time and signal processing time
are each 1 ms. This synchronization makes real-time power flow control possible. We plan to test this opera-
tion with an actual unit cell in future work.
transformer structure of the router and the calculation of power flow for the entire grid. The cell also serves as
the basis for overall expansion, and even after expansion, we can easily expect to make adjustments to
balance supply and demand on the overall grid. This enables construction of a power network that is robust
against earthquakes and other disasters and that can quickly recover from failures.
4. Conclusions
We proposed a Y configuration power router consisting of a three-way isolated DC/DC converter and AC/DC
converters. It can be used as a basic cell to easily construct various power exchanging systems. A governing
equation for power flow control of the three-way isolated DC/DC converter was developed. We made a pro-
totype of the three-way isolated DC/DC converter, which was rated at 400 V and 10 kW, and demonstrated
the operation of its power flow control. The experimental results revealed that our control method derived
from the equation was appropriate for three-way energy exchanges. We also presented a layered control
framework to ensure the cooperative operation of multiple routers within the autonomous microgrid and
a factor analysis of the time required for the overall system control to ensure cooperative operation of
multiple routers within the system. We consider that real-time power control with a cycle time of 10 ms or less
is possible, and we plan to test operation with actual hardware in future work. Our findings in this study led us
to conclude that a multilevel wide-area mesh network composed of the autonomous microgrid cells has the
potential for enhancing the resilience of future power grid systems.
Acknowledgments References
This work was supported by the project
“Research and Development on Y Abe, R., H. Taoka, and D. McQuilkin (2011), Digital grid: Communicative electrical grids of the future, IEEE Trans. Smart Grid, 2(2), 399–410.
configuration Power Routers as A Unit Bragard, M., N. Soltau, S. Thomas, and R. W. De Doncker (2010), The balance of renewable sources and user demands in grids: Power
Cell Consisting of SiC and GaN Power electronics for modular battery energy storage systems, IEEE Trans. Power Electron., 25(12), 3049–3056.
Devices to Construct Various Power Bruneau, M., S. E. Chang, R. T. Eguchi, G. C. Lee, T. D. O’Rourke, A. M. Reinhorn, M. Shinozuka, K. Tierney, W. A. Wallace, and D. VonWinterfeldt
Delivery Systems” of the New (2003), A framework to quantitatively assess and enhance the seismic resilience of communities, Earthq. Spectra, 19(4), 733–752.
Energy and Industrial Technology Falcones, S., X. Mao, and R. Ayyanar (2010), Topology comparison for solid state transformer implementation, Proc. of the IEEE Power and
Development Organization (NEDO), Energy Society General Meeting, pp. 1–8, doi:10.1109/PES.2010.5590086.
Japan. The authors would like to thank Huang, A., M. Crow, G. Heydt, J. Zheng, and S. Dale (2011), The Future Renewable Electric Energy Delivery and Management (FREEDM)
the anonymous reviewers for their System: The Energy Internet, Proc. IEEE, 99, 134–148.
insightful comments and suggestions Inoue, S., and H. Akagi (2006), A bi-directional isolated DC/DC converter as a core circuit for 3.3-kV/6.6-kV power conversion systems in the
that have contributed to improve this next generation, IEEE Power Electron. Spec. Conf. (PESC), 126(3), 211–217.
paper. The data used are available in the Iwatsuki, K., and K. Tsukamoto (2015), Next generation resilient access networks, Invited paper, SPIE Photonics West 2015, San Francisco,
tables and cited references. vol. 9387, p. 93870J-1.
Kado, Y., D. Shichijo, I. Deguchi, N. Iwama, R. Kasashima, and K. Wada (2015), Power flow control of three-way isolated DC/DC Converter for
Y-Configuration Power Router, Proceedings of 2015 IEEE International Future Energy Electronics Conference, Paper No. 290294,
doi:10.1109/IFEEC.2015.7361500.
Kheraluwala, M. H., R. W. Gascoigne, D. M. Divan, and E. D. Baumann (1992), Performance characterization of a high-power dual active bridge
DC-to-DC converter, IEEE Trans. Indust. Appl., 28(6), 1294–1301.
Liu, C., P. Sun, J.-S. Lai, Y. Ji, M. Wang, C.-L. Chen, and G. Cai (2012), Cascade dual-boost/buck active-front-end converter for intelligent
universal transformer, IEEE Trans. Indust. Electron., 59(12), 4671–4680.
Saitoh, H., S. Miyamori, T. Shimada, and J. Toyoda (1997), A study on autonomous decentralized control mechanism of power flow in open
electric energy network, IEEJ Trans. PE, 117(1), 10–18.
Shigeru, K., Y. Yoshiaki, H. Kenji, and T. Mitsuhiro (2012), Hardware implemented network time protocol (HwNTP) based synchronization for
digitized radio over fiber systems, IEICE Commun. Express, 1(1), 4–9.
Sztipanovits, J., X. Koutsoukos, G. Karsai, N. Kottenstette, P. Antsaklis, V. Gupta, B. Goodwine, J. Baras, and S. Wang (2012), Toward a science of
Cyber-Physical System integration, Proc. IEEE, 100(1), 29–44.
United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division (2012), World urbanization prospects, the 2011 revision:
Highlights, New York.
Xu, Y., J. Zhang, W. Wang, A. Juneja, and S. Bhattacharya (2011), Energy router: Architectures and functionalities toward Energy Internet,
Proceedings of the IEEE Smart Grid Communications Conference, pp. 31–36.
Zhao, C., S. D. Round, and J. W. Kolar (2008), An isolated three-port bidirectional DC-DC converter with decoupled power flow management,
IEEE Trans. Power Electron., 23(5), 2443–2453.