Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Wrong-Side Nerve Blocks and The Use of Checklists - Part 1 - Anesthesiology News 2019
Wrong-Side Nerve Blocks and The Use of Checklists - Part 1 - Anesthesiology News 2019
COM
Co
ht
py
rig ed.
re
©
20
cM
od
uc
ah in w
Pu
hi
ng
le
or
G
ro
in
up
pa
un ou
rt
w
le
ith
ss
ot
he
tp
rw
er
is
m
e
is
no
si
on
te
d.
is
pr
oh
ib
ite
d.
T
he available data suggest that wrong-side
nerve blocks may occur as much as 10 times
more often than wrong-site surgeries.
24 A N E ST H E S I O LO GY N E WS .CO M
Background Wrong-Side Nerve Blocks as Sentinel Events
Checklists have been introduced as a solution for Wrong-side nerve blocks (WSNBs) could be consid-
patient safety and a number of other quality issues ered a prototypical example of a sentinel event, akin
in health care. They are considered to be an inexpen- to WSS. Of note, WSNBs may occur more commonly
sive and simple method to avoid common human than WSS procedures, and may even increase the risk
errors, applicable across a wide range of processes. for surgery on the wrong site, as the surgical team may
The recent rise in their utilization and popularity can be be misled to perform the surgery on the wrong site. As
largely attributed to the recommendations from studies an example, data from 30 hospitals across Massachu-
by Gawande et al1,2 and Pronovost et al.3 Also, a 2009 setts over a 20-year period determined the incidence
nonfiction book by Gawande, “The Checklist Manifesto: of WSS procedures was one in 112,994.2 In contrast, the
How to Get Things Right,” is a fascinating read for any- reported incidence of WSNBs in regional anesthesia
A
Co
py
Although checklists are routinely used in medicine Table 1. Risk Factors Involved in
s
rig ed.
Physician Factors
©
The checklists in health care are intended specifically Other personal time pressures
M
pr
ah in w
accountability
on
hi
The Joint Commission defines wrong-site surgery Failure to check the site
or
wrong part of the body, the wrong side, or in the wrong Poor recording (inappropriate or misinterpreted
up
abbreviations)
pa
Patient Factors
performed both in the OR and in patient care settings
w
le
ss
anesthesia
The National Quality Forum has labeled wrong-side
ot
Language/communication difficulties
er
Procedural Factors
ness or underlying condition.6 Sentinel events require
ib
A N E ST H E S I O LO GY N E WS S P E C I A L E D I T I O N 2 0 1 9 25
ranges from 1.28 to 3.63 per 10,000 procedures (i.e., Risk Factors for Blocks on the Wrong Side
1/2,755-1/7,812).8 Therefore, the available data sug- Factors involved in the occurrence of WSNBs can be
gest that WSNBs may occur as much as 10 times more classified as procedural, physician- and patient-related
often than WSS. Moreover, the real-life incidences of factors (Table 1). Nerve blocks are usually unilateral,
WSS and WSNBs are probably much higher, due to and often require a change of patient position from
underreporting. that in which the checklist was performed. This change
Table 2. Published Case Reports of Wrong-Side Nerve Blocks and the Circumstances
Nixon H, et al15 1 Femoral nerve block Knee surgery Procedural (change in position)
rig
Co
py
Procedural
s
Physician
rig ed.
re
ht
se
cM
od
ah in w
20
Henshaw DS, et al 4 (2) Combined femoral (2) Knee arthroplasty Information not provided
catheter + sciatic nerve block
tio
Pu
Fox M, et al21 4 (2) Brachial plexus block Information not provided Information not provided
is
hi
Stanton MA, et al22 2 (1) Femoral nerve block (1) Total knee arthroplasty Physician
ng
le
Simmons H, et al24 2 (1) Interscalene block (1) Biceps tendon repair Physician
un ou
rt
le
ith
ss
ot
Hudson M, et al25 9 (6) Femoral nerve block Information not provided Physician
he
tp
e
is
Clarke JR, et al26 39 Information not provided Information not provided Information not provided
no
si
LaReau JM, et al27 1 Femoral nerve block Information not provided Information not provided
on
te
Cohen SP, et al28 13 (1) Lumbar sympathetic block Information not provided Physician
d.
is
(2) Intercostal
ib
ite
Yeoh MF, et al29 2 Information not provided Information not provided Information not provided
d.
James M, et al30 2 Information not provided Information not provided Information not provided
31
Seiden SC, et al 3 Information not provided Information not provided Information not provided
Fox M, et al32 4 (2) Brachial plexus blocks Information not provided Information not provided
(2) Local infiltrations
Simon J, et al33 14 Ophthalmic block Information not provided Physician
Patient
Sites B, et al11 7 Information not provided Information not provided Information not provided
26 A N E ST H E S I O LO GY N E WS .CO M
in position for performance of the block may lead to a into the lateral or prone position, possibly resulting in
higher risk for WSNBs. As an example, for a popliteal a confusion in laterality at the point of care. A descrip-
block, the patient’s informed consent and confirma- tion of the circumstances that were determined to
tion on the site of surgery, as per the checklist, are usu- contribute to the occurrences of WSNBs is featured
ally obtained with the patient in the supine position. in Table 2, which lists published case reports of blocks
Subsequently, the patient may then be repositioned placed on the wrong side.
Wrong-side femoral nerve block was performed after patient repositioning (from prone to supine) Yes
rig
Co
py
• No previous time-out
ht
se
• Time-out performed after the block and general anesthesia (preventing only wrong surgical side)
20
• Members of the perioperative team were distracted during the procedure (1) No
19
Re
The routine safety check was not performed before the procedure Yes
uc
ah in w
• Attending anesthesiologist was not present for the time-out Not specified
tio
• The patient for ankle block had wounds on both feet, which potentially contributed to the error
on
Pu
bl
hi
le
• Surgical side was confirmed by the anesthesiologist only with the patient
ith
ss
• Site marking was noticed (correct side) after the block was already performed on wrong side
ot
• The attending physician who performed the block did not participate in the time-out Not specified
he
tp
• The anesthetist did not see the marking on the femoral site after the patient had been repositioned
is
m
e
is
te
• Busy practice
ite
• No site marking indicating the correct eye for operation Not specified
• Patient indicated the wrong side
Information not provided Not specified
A N E ST H E S I O LO GY N E WS S P E C I A L E D I T I O N 2 0 1 9 27
Prevention of WSNBs in industry (e.g., the aviation industry) may not be
Organized societies of anesthesiologists have pro- realistic. An example of a checklist used in the aviation
vided recommendations for the prevention of wrong- industry is shown in Figure 1. One fundamental
side procedures. As an example, the American Society difference between the aviation industry and patient
of Regional Anesthesia and Pain Medicine appointed a care is that the latter requires multiple teams, as
task force to publish recommendations for a prepro- opposed to the checklist used in a cockpit of an
cedural checklist specific to regional anesthesia.9 The aircraft that involves small teams, typically consisting
use of a checklist before surgical procedures has been of just the pilot and co-pilot. Of note, checklists that
demonstrated to positively affect surgical outcomes, rely on teamwork for success may fail despite all the
including mortality,10 but the utility of a preprocedural items being followed, because of the potential lack
checklist in decreasing the risk for WSNBs has not been of team skills.12 Therefore, simply implementing and
A
formally established—although logic should lead one to enforcing checklists, and strict progression through
ll
believe that it should be beneficial.11 the items in them, may not necessarily yield benefits
rig
Co
py
rig ed.
ah in w
on
Pu
hi
ng
le
or
G
ro
in
le
ith
ss
ot
he
tp
rw
er
is
m
e
is
no
si
on
te
d.
is
pr
oh
ib
ite
d.
28 A N E ST H E S I O LO GY N E WS .CO M
One of the difficulties with the use of checklists, access patient management protocols and download
which have been adopted nearly universally in all the latest nerve block techniques and illustrations
aspects of patient care, is that their routine application from NYSORA’s all-new regional anesthesia app
at multiple points in patient pathways has created (Figure 5).
checklist weariness, and potentially decreased their
value in enhancing patient safety. Moreover, while
the use of a checklist is mandated throughout most
surgical facilities in the developed world, the policies
on how they must be implemented and method of
labeling the correct site vary substantially.
In some institutions, the site of the surgery
A
Co
py
rig ed.
ah in w
on
hi
le
ith
ss
A N E ST H E S I O LO GY N E WS S P E C I A L E D I T I O N 2 0 1 9 29
References
1. Gawande AA, Studdert DM, Orav EJ, et al. Risk factors for 18. Edmonds CR, Liguori GA, Stanton MA. Two cases of a wrong-site
retained instruments and sponges after surgery. N Engl J Med. peripheral nerve block and a process to prevent this complication.
2003;348(3):229-235. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2005;30(1):99-103.
2. Kwaan MR, Studdert DM, Zinner MJ, et al. Incidence, patterns, and 19. Barrington MJ, Uda Y. Wrong-side bedside paravertebral block:
prevention of wrong-site surgery. Arch Surg. 2019;141(4):353-357. preventing the preventable. AORN J. 2018;108(4):480-482.
2006;90(7):814-816.
ht
py
6. The Joint Commission. Sentinel events. In: Comprehensive to preanesthetic site verification after 2 cases of wrong site
rig ed.
re
Accreditation Manual for Hospitals. www.jointcommission.org/ peripheral nerve blocks. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2008;33(2):174-177.
ht
se
7. Treadwell JR, Lucas S, Tsou AY. Surgical checklists: a systematic Anesth. 2010;22(1):74-77.
review of impacts and implementation. BMJ Qual Saf.
19
Re
ah in w
Br J Anaesth. 2015;114(5):818-824.
on
Pu
26. Clarke JR, Johnston J, Finley ED. Getting surgery right. Ann Surg.
2007;246(3):395-403.
10. Haynes AB, Weiser TG, Berry WR, et al. A surgical safety checklist
bl
Med. 2009;360:491-499. 27. LaReau JM, Robbins CE, Talmo CT, et al. Complications of femoral
hi
11. Sites B, Barrington M, Davis M. Using an international clinical patient risk. J Arthroplasty. 2012;27(4):564-568.
or
improvement. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2014;39(6):487-495. 28. Cohen SP, Hayek SM, Datta S, et al. Incidence and root cause
ro
in
12. Catchpole K, Russ S. The problem with checklists. BMJ Qual Saf. multicenter study. Anesthesiology. 2010;112(3):711-718.
2015;24(9):545-549.
un ou
rt
29. Yeoh MF, Macfarlane A. Completing the stop before you block
w
le
13. Yalamuri S, Gadsden J. Wrong-sided nerve block—a close prior to performing peripheral nerve blocks in a tertiary hospital.
ith
30. James MA, Seiler JG, Harrast JJ, et al. The occurrence of wrong-
er
in-built action-check to prevent wrong-side anaesthetic nerve site surgery self-reported by candidates for certification by the
blocks. Anaesthesia. 2017;72(2):150-155.
is
m
2012;94(1):1-12.
no
te
iliofascial pour une fracture du col fémoral. Ann Fr Anesth Reanim. 32. Fox MAL, Webb RK, Singleton R, et al. Problems with regional
oh
nerve block at the popliteal fossa. Acta Anaesthesiol Belg. 33. Simon JW, Ngo Y, Khan S, et al. Surgical confusions in
d.
30 A N E ST H E S I O LO GY N E WS .CO M
Additional References
Barrington MJ, Sites BD. Rare event research: is it worth it? Management H, Computing M, Working T. Site marking by
Br J Anaesth. 2015;114(5):726-727. Chikkabbaiah V, French J, Townsley anaesthetists preparing for peripheral nerve blockade. Anaesthesia.
P, et al. Further reducing the risk of wrong site block. Anaesthesia. 2010;65(3):306-315.
2015;70:1453.
Deutsch ES, Yonash RA, Martin DE, et al. Wrong-site nerve blocks: McLellan EJ, Hade AD, Pelecanos A, et al. Introduction of a mandatory
a systematic literature review to guide principles for prevention. pre-block safety checklist into a regional anaesthesia block room
J Clin Anesth. 2018;46:101-111. service: a quality improvement project. Anaesth Intensive Care.
2018;46(5):504-509.
Harris B, Torlot K. Site marking for peripheral nerve blockade
to reduce the incidence of incorrect side regional anaesthesia.
Anaesthesia. 2009;64(9):1022-1036. Rupp SM. Unintentional wrong-sided peripheral nerve block.
A
py
Lie J, Letheren M. “Wrong side” sticker/dressing to help reduce to prevent wrong-sided blocks. Anaesth Intensive Care.
s
2016;44(4):513-516.
re
ht
se
rv
©
20
19
Re
M
pr
cM
od
uc
ah in w
tio
on
n
Pu
bl
is
ho
hi
ng
le
or
G
ro
in
up
pa
un ou
rt
w
le
ith
ss
ot
he
tp
rw
er
is
m
e
is
no
si
on
te
d.
is
pr
oh
ib
ite
d.
Copyright © 2019 McMahon Publishing, 545 West 45th Street, New York, NY 10036. Printed in the USA. All rights reserved, including the right of
reproduction, in whole or in part, in any form.
A N E ST H E S I O LO GY N E WS S P E C I A L E D I T I O N 2 0 1 9 31