Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Storage Tank
Storage Tank
H. Ben Bachaa,b*, T. Dammakc, A.A. Ben Abdalaha, A.Y. Maaleja,b, H. Ben Dhiab
a
LASEM (LAboratoire des Systèmes Electro-Mécaniques), bLEEE (Laboratoire Eau, Energie et Environnement),
c
UCA (Unité de Commande Automatique), Department of Mechanical Engineering,
Ecole Nationale d’Ingénieurs de Sfax, B.P. W 3038, Sfax, Tunisia
Tel. +216 (74) 274-088; Fax +216 (74) 275-595; email: Habib.BenBacha@enis.rnu.tn
Abstract
The behaviour of a distillation module of a desalination unit coupled with hot water storage tank heated by a
solar collector field is investigated by a series of simulation, in order to increase productivity of the desalination
unit. Mathematical models are developed to give the ability to estimate the expected performance of the system
under given climatic conditions, allowing the choice of the proper design solutions in relation to the desired usage.
The whole investigation is based mainly on experimental data under real usage conditions.
Keywords: Water desalination; Storage tank; Solar collector; Modeling; Numerical simulation
Presented at EuroMed 2006 conference on Desalination Strategies in South Mediterranean Countries: Cooperation
between Mediterranean Countries of Europe and the Southern Rim of the Mediterranean. Sponsored by the
European Desalination Society and the University of Montpellier II, Montpellier, France, 21–25 May 2006.
and thereby decrease the evaporation rate tion to treat the brackish water. The corresponding
during the day. system scheme presented in Fig. 1 is an illustration
• The storing technique must be simple and of the unit components along with the description
cheap in order to keep the capital cost of the of the different modes (daytime and night time/
system as low as possible. storage mode). The solar unit consists of a:
• flat plate collector field,
This paper deals with the modeling and simula- • conventional insulated heat storage tank,
tion aspects of the main components of a solar • heat exchanger,
hot water system of the desalination unit using • control unit, circulation pump and an electric-
the solar multiple condensation evaporation cycle ally temperature controlled mixing valves
(SMCEC) principle. Mathematical models and (three-way valve).
simulation allow predicting the behavior and ener-
gy balance of a solar collector, testing configu- The desalination module is constituted with
rations of the distillation module together with dif- two chambers: one for evaporation and one for
ferent sizes and types of hot water storage tanks condensation. The evaporation chamber is filled
and the effect of the storage device on the produc- with a packed bed, where the hot brackish water
tion of the unit. is uniformly distributed. The brackish water eva-
porates under ambient pressure, and the saturated
air is transported by free or forced convection to
2. Description of the desalination process
the condenser chamber, where it condenses on the
The desalination plant consists of a solar unit, surface of the plastic heat exchanger. The air cir-
which provides the thermal energy, and a desali- culates in the opposite direction of the water,
nation module that uses multi-effect humidifica- which is thereby preheated in the condenser plates
Fig. 1. Principle scheme of the desalination unit coupled with solar collectors and storage tank.
H. Ben Bacha et al. / Desalination 206 (2007) 341–352 343
by the heat of condensation. The condenser is made among the command signals. The optimum
made of polypropylene bridged double plates, mode of functioning depends on both economic
through which the cold brackish water flows up- and technical factors. It is a compromise between
wards. With the installation of the three-way the highest possible water temperature at the eva-
valve, quasi steady-state conditions for the evapo- poration tower entrance in favour of optimum
ration are guaranteed even during the daytime mass-transfer and heat inside the distillation
mode. If the temperature of the collector outlet module, the limitations of this temperature in fa-
exceeds the temperature adjusted for the mixing vour of gaining acceptable collector efficiency and
valve, cold water from the bottom of the storage to minimize overall thermal losses. The supple-
tank is added. At the same time, the storage tank mentation of the system by a high temperature
is automatically filled from the top with the surplus thermal storage tank makes it possible to keep the
of hot water. The control device of the solar unit temperature range and the volume flow at the eva-
regulates the whole desalination system. When poration chamber entrance over 24 h at a certain
one of the following conditions is satisfied, the level. The fluctuations of the daily temperature
three-way valve switches the system into the stor- are determined by the heat capacity of the storage
age mode automatically (night-time), discharging tank, and the average volume flow depends on
the tank from above: the size of the solar collector field. The ratio of
• the temperature level of the collector outlet is the collector area to the size of the desalination
lower than the minimum temperature for the module is defined by the consideration of the eco-
evaporation, nomic efficiency of the total system. In order to
• the security criterion of the storage tank, for minimize the specific distillate costs, one will
example the maximum temperature at the operate the desalination module at an operating
bottom of the tank, is reached. state (volume flow rate and inlet evaporation
temperature) above the energetic optimum be-
The pump of the solar unit works in the storage
cause it is the most expensive component of the
mode until the minimum temperature for evapora-
system [5,6].
tion is reached. More details concerning the de-
The integration of the thermal storage device
scription and operation principle of the desalina-
can be adopted in different possibilities: the
tion plant are presented in [1–4].
storage tank can contain either brackish or distilled
water, the collector field can be loaded by fresh
3. Process optimisation or brine water and the desalination module can
be connected directly to the storage tank or using
The brackish water debit (L) and the air debit
a heat exchanger. One preferred configuration is
(G) represent the controllable input signals for the
to use a thermal storage tank and a solar collector
desalination module. The water temperature at the
field being loaded by brackish water. This permits
evaporation tower entrance (Tl) is a very influ-
more efficiency due to elimination of heat ex-
ential factor in the unit production. The insolation
changers, but higher demands are to be made on
I(t) represents the important non controllable input
the materials used.
signal to the system and, therefore, can be con-
sidered as perturbations. The condensed water
amount (Wc) is an output signal for the entire sys- 4. Modelling approaches
tem. Based on the optimisation conditions of the
4.1. Flat plate solar collector model
three different modules of the desalination unit
(solar collectors, evaporation tower, condensation The model of the flat plate solar collector, call-
tower), several compromising actions need to be ed two temperatures model, was developed in a
344 H. Ben Bacha et al. / Desalination 206 (2007) 341–352
previous work [7]. It can be written as: 4.2. Hot water storage tanks models
Three different kinds of storage tank models
⎧ ∂T f ∂T f are developed.
⎪⎪ = −v + c1 (Tc − T f )
∂t ∂x (1)
⎨
⎪ dTc = a ( f ( t ) − T ) + b (T − T )
⎪⎩ dt 1 c 1 f c 4.2.1. Storage tank with heat exchangers
Mode 1
with: Fig. 2 represents the model adopted for the hot
mf SU ′ Sh water storage tank with two internal coils heat ex-
v=L , a1 = , b1 = , changers. Tf1 and Tf2 are respectively the inlet and
Mf M c Cc M c Cc
the outlet solar collector temperatures. mf is the
Sh flow rate of the collector. Ts is the temperature of
c1 = BI ( t )
M f C f , f ( t ) = U ′ + Ta ( t ) — the ambient
the water storage tank. A completely mixed stor-
age tank is assumed. Tl2 corresponds to the inlet
condition function. temperature at the top of the evaporation tower.
The obtained mathematical model for the solar Tl1 is the outlet water temperature at the bottom
collector allows the determination, for variable of the evaporation tower. L is the water debit in-
solar intensity levels and ambient temperature, of jected at the top of the evaporation tower.
the fluid instantaneous temperature at any point To establish the model of the energy balance
of the collector as a function of the command, in the storage tank, the following assumptions are
geometrical, and physical parameters (flow rate, taken into account:
collector area, material, and inclination angle of • there is no change in heat storage in the coil,
the collector). It should be noted that the fluid • the coil is in steady state,
temperature and flow rate at the collector outlet • the heat storage tank is entirely insulated.
are the two parameters with the most significant
impact on the unit production as they are the input Eqs. (2), (3) and (4) present the corresponding
parameters of the distillation module. model:
Fig. 2. Hot water storage tank with internal heat exchangers — mode 1.
H. Ben Bacha et al. / Desalination 206 (2007) 341–352 345
Mode 2 (Fig. 3)
dT
MC f s = m f C f (T f 2 − T f 1 ) For the same assumptions used in mode 1, the
dt
(2) following equations present the corresponding
− LC f (Tl 2 − Tl1 ) model:
dTs
m f C f (T f 2 − T f 1 ) = U1 A1
∆T f 2 − ∆T f 1 MC f = m f C f (T f 2 − Ts )
(3) dt
ln ( ∆T f 2 / ∆T f 1 ) (7)
− LC f (Tl 2 − Tl1 )
∆Tl 2 − ∆Tl1
LC f (Tl 2 − Tl1 ) = U 2 A2 ⋅ (4) ∆Tl 2 − ∆Tl1
ln ( ∆Tl 2 / ∆Tl1 ) LC f (Tl 2 − Tl1 ) = U 2 A2 (8)
ln ( ∆Tl 2 / ∆Tl1 )
with ∆Tf2 = Tf2 – Ts and ∆Tf1 = Tf1 – Ts;
with ∆Tl2 = Tl2 – Ts,
∆Tl2 = Tl2 – Ts and ∆Tl1 = Tl1 – Ts
∆Tl1 =Tl1 – Ts
From Eqs. (3) and (4), Tf1 and Tl2 can be de- and
veloped respectively as follows:
1
⎛ uA ⎞
Tl 2 = (Tl1 − Ts ) ⎛U A ⎞
+ Ts (9)
−⎜ 1 1 ⎟ −⎜ 2 2 ⎟
T f 1 = (T f 2 − Ts ) e
⎜ mf Cf ⎟ ⎜ LC f ⎟
⎝ ⎠
+ Ts (5) e ⎝ ⎠
Fig. 3. Hot water storage tank with internal heat exchanger — mode 2.
346 H. Ben Bacha et al. / Desalination 206 (2007) 341–352
exchanger (Fig. 4). This configuration performs 4.3. Model of the desalination module
the heat transfer through a wall surface. Both sides
The model of the distillation module consists
are supposed to be fully mixed. V1 and V2 are the
of the coupling of the individual models of both
volume of storage tank sections and A3 is the sur-
evaporation and condensation towers. The global
face of the heat transfer between the storage tank
mathematical model based on thermal and mass
sections.
balances allows the determination of coupling
The next equations describe the behaviour of
equations between the water and the humid air
the divided hot water storage tank:
temperatures and the water content inside each
tower. The obtained model is a set of equations
dTs1
M 1C f = m f C f (T f 2 − Ts1 ) with partial derivatives with respect to space and
dt (10) time, ordinary differential equations as well as
− U 3 A3 (Ts1 − Ts 2 ) algebraic equations. The model is based on some
previous assumptions [8–12]. More details con-
cerning the established model were presented
dTs 2
M 2C f = LC f (Tl 2 − Tl1 ) earlier [13]. The following equations present the
dt (11) corresponding model:
+ U 3 A3 (Ts1 − Ts 2 )
∂Tl ∂T
εl ρl Cl = LCl l − hl a (Tl − Ti ) (14)
∂t ∂z
∆Tl 2 − ∆Tl1
LC f (Tl 2 − Tl1 ) = U 2 A2 (12)
ln ( ∆Tl 2 / ∆Tl1 ) ∂Tg ∂Tg
ε g ρg Cg = −GC g + hg a (Ti − Tg ) (15)
∂t ∂z
with ∆Tl2 = Tl2 – Ts, ∆Tl1 = Tl1 – Ts
hl (Tl − Ti ) + h g (T g − Ti ) = L v k g ( X i − X g ) (16)
and
1 ∂X g ∂X g
Tl 2 = (Tl1 − TS ) + Ts (13) εg ρg = −G + kg a ( X i − X g ) (17)
⎛U A ⎞
−⎜ 2 2 ⎟ ∂t ∂z
⎜ LC f ⎟
⎝ ⎠
e
Fig. 4. Divided hot water storage tank with internal heat exchanger.
H. Ben Bacha et al. / Desalination 206 (2007) 341–352 347
Table 1
System technical specifications and operation data used for the simulation
temperature profile for configuration 1 — mode 1 The simulation of the global resulting model
(bold line), the temperature profile for configura- allows the prediction of the desalination unit pro-
tion 1 — mode 2 (thin line) and the temperature duction (Fig. 9). Fig. 9 shows the amount of dis-
profile for configuration 2 (dashed). Fig. 8 shows tilled water estimated with the different storage
that storage tank with configuration 2 has large tank configurations: the amount of distilled water
discharging duration than configuration 1 with estimated with configuration 1 — mode 1 (thin
mode 1 and 2. line), the amount of distilled water estimated with
The model of the solar collector and the hot configuration 1 — mode 2 (bold line) and the
water storage tank models were coupled to the amount of distilled water estimated with configu-
models of evaporation and condensation towers. ration 2 (dashed). Such as storage tank configura-
H. Ben Bacha et al. / Desalination 206 (2007) 341–352 349
Fig. 5. Temperature distribution inside the tank with in- Fig. 6. Temperature distribution inside the tank with in-
ternal heat exchangers — mode 1. ternal heat exchanger — mode 2.
Fig. 7. Temperature distribution inside the divided hot Fig. 8. Temperature distribution inside the hot water stor-
water storage tank with internal heat exchanger. age tank: comparison of the three functioning modes (V
= 1 m3).
tion 2 has large discharging duration than configu- operation. This measure prevents thermal losses
ration 1 with mode 1 and 2, so configuration 2 during standstill periods and low efficiency pe-
allows production of distilled water for a long pe- riods restarting the system. Twenty-four hour ope-
riod than the others configurations. ration can be realized by an extended collector
field combined with a hot water storage tank.
In this paper, mathematical models were
6. Conclusion
carried out and used for simulation of three dif-
The main improvement in the solar desalina- ferent configurations solar hot water systems: a
tion unit efficiency can be reached by continuous hot water storage tank with two internal heat
350 H. Ben Bacha et al. / Desalination 206 (2007) 341–352
Greek References
α — Absorbance of the collector absorber [1] I. Ulber, K. Vajen, H. Uchtman, M. Engelhardt, J.
surface Krelle, W. Baier, M. Uecker, R. Orths and H. Ben
Bacha, A new concept for solar thermal desalina-
εl — Water volume fraction in the evapora-
tion: Results of in-situ measurements. EUROSUN
tion tower 98, Portoroz, September 1998.
εg — Air volume fraction in the evaporation [2] H. Ben Bacha, M. Bouzguenda, M.S. Abid and A.Y.
tower Maalej, Modelling and simulation of a water desali-
εc — Cooling water volume fraction in the nation station with solar multiple condensation
condensation tower evaporation cycle technique. Renewable Energy, 18
εG — Air volume fraction in the condensation (1999) 349–365.
tower [3] H. Ben Bacha, M. Bouzguenda, T. Damak, M.S.
Abid and A.Y. Maalej, A study of a water desalina-
εp — Volume fraction of the packed bed in
tion station using the SMCEC technique: produc-
the evaporation tower tion optimization. Renewable Energy, 21 (2000)
εpc — Volume fraction of the condensation 523–536.
plates in the condensation tower [4] H. Ben Bacha, A.Y. Maalej, H. Ben Dhia, I. Ulber,
ρl — Water density in the evaporation tower, H. Uchtmann, M. Engelhardt and J. Krelle, Perspec-
kg/m3 tives of solar powered desalination with “SMCEC”
ρg — Air density in the evaporation tower, technique. Desalination, 122 (1999) 177–183.
kg/m3 [5] H. Ben Bacha, T. Damak, M. Bouzguenda, A.Y.
Maalej and H. Ben Dhia, Study of a water desalina-
ρc — Cooling water density in the condensa-
tion station using the SMCEC technique: dynamic
tion tower, kg/m3 modelling and simulation. Desalination, 137 (2001)
ρG — Air density in the condensation tower, 53–61.
kg/m3 [6] H. Müller-Holst, M. Engelhardt and W. Schölkopf,
τ — Transmittance Small-scale thermal seawater desalination simula-
352 H. Ben Bacha et al. / Desalination 206 (2007) 341–352
tion and optimization of system design. Desalina- [10] S. Kaguel, M. Nishio and N. Wakao, Parameter es-
tion, 122 (1999) 255–262. timation for packed cooling tower operation using
[7] H. Ben Bacha, T. Damak, M. Bouzguenda, A.Y. a heat input-response technique. Intern. J. Heat Mass
Maalej and H. Ben Dhia, A methodology to design Transfer, 31 (1988) 2579–2585.
and predict operation of a solar collector for solar- [11] D. Sonntag, Vapor pressure formulations based on
powered desalination unit using the SMCEC prin- the ITS-90 and psychometer formulate — Impor-
ciple. Desalination, 156 (2003) 305–313. tant new values of the physical constants of 1986.
[8] H. Ben Bacha, M. Bouzguenda, M.S. Abid and A.Y. Z. Meteorologie, 70 (1990) 5/340–5/344.
Maalej, Modelling and simulation of a water desali- [12] A. Wexler, Vapor pressure formulation for water in
nation station with solar multiple condensation range 0 to 100°C. J. Res. National Bureau of Stan-
evaporation cycle technique. Renewable Energy, 18 dards A, Physics and Chemistry, 80 A (1976) 775–
(1999) 349–365. 785.
[9] M.A. Younis, M.A. Fahim and N. Wakao, Heat in- [13] H. Ben Bacha, T. Damak, M. Bouzguenda and A.Y.
put-response in cooling tower-zeroth moments of Maalej, Experimental validation of the distillation
temperature variations. J. Chem. Eng. Japan, 20 module of the desalination station using the SMCEC
(1987) 614–618. principle. Intern. J. Renewable Energy, 28 (2003)
2335–2354.